Monkeys on typewriters

https://groups.google.com/forum/?fromgroups=#!topic/talk.origins/CxB8SB_Rutw
The issue with the works of Shakespear that it assumes the composite 
integrity of grammar, syntax, semantics and pragmatics. Even if the 
works of Shakespear were to by typed out by a monkey it still wouldn't 
actually mean anything because for this a mind is needed. Meaning is 
always inferred as a composite functionality of base concepts or 
elements. 
Marcel Schützenberger in the French interview after Wistar described how we 
only derive meaning as functionality: the function of a car, function 
of a battery. 
http://www.arn.org/docs/odesign/od172/schutz172.htm . He echoed D'Arcy 
Thompson's description of composite integrity with functional 
integrity, revived by Behe under the rubric of IC.
:.... The laboratory biologists' normal and unforced vernacular is 
almost always couched in functional terms: the function of an eye, the 
function of an enzyme, or a ribosome, or the fruit fly's antennae -- 
their function; the concept by which such language is animated is one 
perfectly adapted to reality...... 
Without a mind the monkey typing would be no different than a random 
string of letters. Hence *mind first* is implicitly assumed 
commensurate with our everyday experience: designed objects always 
existed in a mind before being expressed physically. For the sonnets 
of Shakespear to be classified as designed, the very concept of
*design* must exist a-priori before any expression in a physical
dimension(cars, letters) of such mind. With such design deriving its 
meaning as the opposite of random,chance. If there are more infinite 
options, then we would have to wait an infinite time to explore them 
all, off into the abyss of infinite regress. The best explanation for 
design is that it is the opposite of chance, therefore the explanation 
doesn't need an explanation or the explanation itself would need one, 
ad-infinitum .
Category:Dawkins
Category:Marcel Schützenberger
Category:Irreducible functionality