Athantopia Awards

The Athantopia Awards is an annual ceremony where players from all Campaigns and One-Shots vote for their favorite accolades. 
== 2017 Season ==
The 2017 season had Twenty categories and covered the events from March 4th, 2017 to March 18th, 2018
It consisted of the first two seasons of S.H.A.D.O.W., the first season of The Numen Swell, and three One-Shots (Synset, The Thunderers, & Last Remnant: Union of the Golden Chalice).
=== Most Likeable Protagonist ===
==== Winner ====
* Sonney Griffin-Thorne (50% of the vote)
==== Runner-Up ====
* Aragi Maxul (20% of the vote)
==== Other Nominees ====
* Alan Caster
* Craton, Son of Kyros of Marathon
* SirQuilion Rasenfar
=== Most Likeable NPC ===
==== Winner ====
* Mal Bloodjaw (38% of the vote) 
==== Runner-Up ====
* Meshi (31% of the vote)
==== Other Nominees ====
* Saint Hylophagous
* Jamven Darksbane
* Mathite'Vomenos
* Psaro'Kokkalo
* Benjamin Tecnic
* Darwin Vulcan
* Ikko "Black Scalp" Wotan
* Lara Youngheart
=== Most Heartbreaking Death (PC) ===
==== Winner ====
* Sera Emberstorm (22% of the vote)
==== Runner-Up ====
* "Bizzy" Cignall (17% of the vote)
==== Other Nominees ====
* Maxxel
* Alan Caster
* Andreios of Argos
* Renbiley
* Balthazar Koegel
* Mentor of Pandosia
* Beatrice, Daughter of Barne of Thebes
* Beni
* Bimbo Biggins
* Cornipharous, Son of Odysseus of Ithica
* Deimos, Son of Ares
* Di-Syl
* Hektor of Cyprus
* Iota, Son of Sokratis of Sklavocampos
* Kasumi, Daughter of Nocturnal of Giza
* Methodios, Son of Nymphodorus of Sounion
* Rhesus of Croton
=== Most Heartbreaking Death (NPC) ===
==== Winner ====
* Meshi (36% of the vote)
==== Runner-Up ====
* Copperbeard (36% of the vote)
==== Other Nominees ====
* Mathite'Vomenos
* Benjamin Tecnic
* Carvorus
* Cronus of Sparta
* Darwin Vulcan
* Jamven Darksbane
* Jorenr of Thebes
* Psaro'Kokkalo
=== Best Version of Gregory ===
==== Winner ====
* Gregorios {The Thunderers} (36% of the vote)
==== Runner-Up ====
* Helmsman Gregory {The Numen Swell} (21% of the vote)
==== Other Nominees ====
* Gregory of STG {S.H.A.D.O.W.}
* Ser Gregory {Last Remnant: Union of the Golden Chalice}
* G, Leader of JOKR {Synset}
=== Biggest Laugh Track ===
==== Winner ====
* "Mimi Hapa Hapa" (25% of the vote)
==== Runner-Up ====
* "You want to fuck on me?" (20% of the vote)
==== Other Nominees ====
* "Blind Getaway"
* "Everything Lais"
* "Fish Moms"
* "Girth"
* "O-DEN"
* "Pickles and Shit" 
* "Playing Cards w/ Copperbeard"
* "Bennsyn 'saves' Tecnic"
* "Deimos, Bartender"
* "Mikey learns to read"
=== Most Likely to Die Next (S.H.A.D.O.W.) ===
==== Winner ====
* Calapharious Ebonscar (38% of the vote)
==== Runner-Up ====
* Aguero Cryhawk (25% of the vote)
==== Other Nominees ====
* Aragi Maxul
* Elatherial Ebonscar
* Phylyco
* Rathisi'Defteros
=== Most Likely to Die Next (The Numen Swell) ===
==== Winner ====
* Bennsyn (58% of the vote)
==== Runner-Up ====
* Mikey (25% of the vote)
==== Other Nominees ====
* Sonney Griffin-Thorne
* Kifo Pomboo
=== Most Believable Performance ===
==== Winner ====
* Matt Christie as Phylyco (46% of the vote)
==== Runner-Up ====
* Kyle Muller as Kifo Pomboo (31% of the vote)
==== Other Nominees ====
* Corey Sexton as Calapharious Ebonscar
* Eric Rios as Aguero Cryhawk
* Richie Maynard as Mikey
* Tim Mayer as Bimbo Biggins
=== Best Newcomer to Roleplaying ===
==== Winner ====
* Cory Mazzarelli (31% of the vote)
==== Runner-Up ====
* Richie Maynard (31% of the vote)
==== Other Nominees ====
* Eric Rios
* Matt Finger
* Alex Hanson
* Heather Loguercio
* Rob Christie
* TJ Christie
=== Most Likely to get the Party Killed ===
==== Winner ====
* Eric Rios (54% of the vote)
==== Runner-Up ====
* Matt Finger (31% of the vote)
==== Other Nominees ====
* Rob Christie
* Heather Loguercio
=== Most Reckless Character ===
==== Winner ====
* Bennsyn (29% of the vote)
==== Runner-Up ====
* "Bizzy" Cignall (29% of the vote)
==== Other Nominees ====
* Alan Caster
* Calapharious Ebonscar
* Mordecai Silvergleam
* Beni
* Iota, Son of Sokratis of Sklavocampos
=== Funniest Deformity Made Fun of by Others ===
==== Winner ====
* Aguero Cryhawk is Blind (25% of the vote)
==== Runner-Up ====
* Aragi Maxul is Bald and Gay (20% of the vote)
==== Other Nominees ====
* Mikey is Illiterate
* Balthazar Koegel is Massive
* Maxxel is Old
* Sonney Griffin-Thorne is Half-Monkey
* Kifo Pomboo is Albino
* Lais is a Woman
* Beni is a Midget
=== Most Likely to Kill Each Other ===
==== Winner ====
* Kifo Pomboo & Bennsyn (31% of the vote)
==== Runner-Up ====
* Aragi Maxul & Phylyco (31% of the vote)
==== Other Nominees ====
* Calapharious Ebonscar & The Rest of the Party
* Craton & Skia
* Di-Syl & Mordecai Silvergleam
* Maxxel & Renbiley
* Andreios & Psyche
=== Most Sexual Tension ===
==== Winner ====
* Aragi Maxul & Copperbeard (16% of the vote)
==== Runner-Up ====
* Bennsyn & Daronna (16% of the vote)
==== Other Nominees ====
* Aguero Cryhawk & Mathite'Vomenos
* Alan Caster & Queen Mojcado
* Aragi Maxul & Lara Youngheart
* Kifo Pomboo & Bennsyn
* Phylyco & Elatherial Ebonscar
* SirQuilion Rasenfar & Literally Everyone
* Calapharious Ebonscar & Elatherial Ebonscar
* Elatherial Ebonscar & Mal Bloodjaw
* Skia & Psyche
=== Most Likely to get a Sequel (One-Shot) ===
==== Winner ====
* The Thunderers (50% of the vote)
==== Runner-Up ====
* Last Remnant: Union of the Golden Chalice (42% of the vote)
==== Other Nominees ====
* Synset
=== Most Likely to have a Character Cross-Over into a Main Series ===
==== Winner ====
* The Thunderers (36% of the vote)
==== Runner-Up ====
* Last Remnant: Union of the Golden Chalice (36% of the vote)
==== Other Nominees ====
* Synset
=== One-Shot of the Year ===
==== Winner ====
* The Thunderers (50% of the vote)
==== Runner-Up ====
* Last Remnant: Union of the Golden Chalice (42% of the vote)
==== Other Nominees ====
* Synset
=== Character of the Year ===
==== Winner ====
* Phylyco (36% of the vote)
==== Runner-Up ====
* Kifo Pomboo (29% of the vote)
==== Other Nominees ====
* Pec the Large
* Bimbo Biggins
* Calapharious Ebonscar
* Rhumbus of Thebes
* Deimos, Son of Ares
* Lais, Daughter of Tarchon of Athens
=== Campaign of the Year ===
==== Winner ====
* S.H.A.D.O.W. Season 2 (38% of the vote)
==== Runner-Up ====
* S.H.A.D.O.W. Season 1 (38% of the vote)
==== Other Nominees ====
* The Numen Swell Season 1
== 2018 Season ==
The 2018 season had twenty categories and covered the events from April 22nd, 2018 to March 31st, 2019
It consisted of the third and fourth seasons of S.H.A.D.O.W., the second and third seasons of The Numen Swell, and four One-Shots (Vespertilio Lupus, The Bentley Affair, Oni, & Gregory's Advocates).
Categories marked with an * are brand new this year.
=== Most Likeable Protagonist ===
==== Winner ====
* Sonney Griffin-Thorne (44% of the vote)
==== Runner-Up ====
* Aragi Maxul (20% of the vote)
==== Other Nominees ====
* Vixaris
* Brie Montgomery
* Rhumbus of Thebes
* Bender Bentley
=== Most Likeable Antagonist* ===
==== Winner ====
* Jack Burrows (48% of the vote)
==== Runner-Up ====
* Shiro Watanabe (20% of the vote)
==== Other Nominees ====
* Saint Opia
* Ravela
* Janus
* Balthazar Koegel
* Thoen Dagarkin
* Charlee Bukett
* Pachosis
* Quincy Mint
* Ulysses Cockrell
=== Most Likeable NPC ===
==== Winner ====
* Mal Bloodjaw (18% of the vote)
==== Runner-Up ====
* Mshi Rika (15% of the vote)
==== Other Nominees ====
* Benjamin Tecnic
* Saint Opia
* Sirobe
* Quincy Mint
* Saint Hylophagous
* Artiss Maxul
* Lara Youngheart
* Ravalyssa Darksbane
* Ravela
* Pachosis
=== Most Heartbreaking Death (PC) ===
==== Winner ====
* Amelia Retter (11% of the vote)
==== Runner-Up ====
* Mwana Pomboo (11% of the vote)
==== Other Nominees ====
* Craton, Son of Kyros of Marathon
* Kifo Pomboo
* Bennsyn
* Caius
* Ciaran Donnelly
* Gray MacBeth
* Hanz Bentley
* Jack Montgomery
* SirQuilion Rasenfar
* Bender Bentley
* Calapharious Ebonscar
* Damian Christian
* J.A.C. Bentley
* Janus
* Shiro Watanabe
* Arek Soir
* Balthazar Koegel
* Elatherial Ebonscar
* Kaspur
* Slevas
=== Most Heartbreaking Death (NPC) ===
==== Winner ====
* Jicho the Owl (16% of the vote)
==== Runner-Up ====
* Mshi Rika (13% of the vote)
==== Other Nominees ====
* Guru Dumu
* Artiss Maxul
* Crufire Fletcher
* Lavarus
* Quincy Mint
* Vida Soulspark
* Ikko "Black Scalp" Wotan
* Alexander "Mad Monty" Montgomery
* Blaine
* Jarrod "Fancy" Anansi
* Hayvard Ximer
* Sirene
* "Ape King" Okubi
* Bentley
* Loyal Tragold
* Saint Opia
=== Best Version of Gregory ===
==== Winner ====
* Helmsman Gregory {The Numen Swell} (44% of the vote)
==== Runner-Up ====
* The Boy {Vespertilio Lupus} (24% of the vote)
==== Other Nominees ====
* Gregory of STG {S.H.A.D.O.W.}
* Officer Gregory {Oni}
* Green Bentley {The Bentley Affair}
=== Most Badass Fight* ===
==== Winner ====
* Sonney VS. "Ape King" (16% of the vote)
==== Runner-Up ====
* Darrow VS. Harvest (15% of the vote)
==== Other Nominees ====
* Phylyco VS. Aragi, Lara, & Darrow
* Kifo VS. Bennsyn & Loyal
* Aguero VS. Mal
* Brie & Frost VS. Shiro
* Darrow VS. Pachosis
* Kifo VS. Balthazar
* Sonney VS. Cockrell
* The Advocates VS. Janus
* Hylophagous VS. Opia
* Vixaris VS. Janus & Shiro
* Ela VS. Rava
* Kifo VS. Kaorti
* Aragi VS. Artiss {Ravela}
=== Most Likely to Die Next (S.H.A.D.O.W.) ===
==== Winner ====
* Grekkus Raisir (29% of the vote)
==== Runner-Up ====
* Darrow Emberstorm (19% of the vote)
==== Other Nominees ====
* Aguero Cryhawk
* Phylyco Brokenwhisper
* Aragi Maxul
* Locus Fochuckl
=== Most Likely to Die Next (The Numen Swell) ===
==== Winner ====
* Jack Burrows (41% of the vote)
==== Runner-Up ====
* Liza Erd (15% of the vote)
==== Other Nominees ====
* Mr. Doda
* Sahge Montgomery
* Mikey Gnash
* Chiens Cascade
* Dex
* Sonney Griffin-Thorne
=== Most Believable Performance ===
==== Winner ====
* Matt Christie as Mello Bentley (17% of the vote)
==== Runner-Up ====
* Kyle Muller as Kifo Pomboo (14% of the vote)
==== Other Nominees ====
* Graeme McEneany as Jack Burrows
* Matt Christie as Phylyco Brokenwhisper
* Richie Maynard as Mikey Gnash
* Alec Tiano as Troy Ross
* Eric Rios as Aguero Cryhawk
* Eric Rios as Darrow Emberstorm
* Kyle Muller as Peter Scanlan
* Darryl Walaszek as Gray MacBeth
* Juliana Giannasca as Chiens Cascade
=== Best Newcomer to Roleplaying ===
==== Winner ====
* Graeme McEneany (50% of the vote)
==== Runner-Up ====
* Corey Macleod (25% of the vote)
==== Other Nominees ====
* Dani Morrison
* Javier Jimenez
=== Most Likely to Break the Narrative* ===
==== Winner ====
* Eric Rios (34% of the vote)
==== Runner-Up ====
* Dani Morrison (24% of the vote)
==== Other Nominees ====
* Alec Tiano
* Kyle Muller
* Matt Finger
* Corey Sexton
* Javier Jimenez
=== Most Likely to get the Party Killed ===
==== Winner ====
* Eric Rios (54% of the vote)
==== Runner-Up ====
* Kyle Muller (29% of the vote)
==== Other Nominees ====
* Matt Finger
* Richie Maynard
=== Most Likely to Kill an Ally* ===
==== Winner ====
* Rob Christie (21% of the vote)
==== Runner-Up ====
* Graeme McEneany (18% of the vote)
==== Other Nominees ====
* Matt Christie
* Kyle Muller
* Dani Morrison 
* Antoine SinClaire
* Corey Sexton
* Richie Maynard
=== Poorest Time Management* ===
==== Winner ====
* Matt Finger (46% of the vote)
==== Runner-Up ====
* Eric Rios (29% of the vote)
==== Other Nominees ====
* Matt Christie
* Richie Maynard
=== Most Sexual Tension ===
==== Winner ====
* Darrow Emberstorm & Amelia Retter (26% of the vote)
==== Runner-Up ====
* Mwana Pomboo & Sahge Montgomery (17% of the vote)
==== Other Nominees ====
* Aragi Maxul & Lara Youngheart
* Slevas & The Boy
* Dex & Thomas Dawkins
* Liza Erd & Chiens Cascade
* Troy Ross & Shiro Watanabe
* Amelia Retter & Artiss Maxul
* Ravalyssa Darksbane & Rathisi'Defteros
=== Most Likely to get a Sequel (One-Shot) ===
==== Winner ====
* Gregory's Advocates (67% of the vote)
==== Runner-Up ====
* Oni (19% of the vote)
==== Other Nominees ====
* The Bentley Affair
* Vespertilio Lupus
=== One-Shot of the Year ===
==== Winner ====
* Gregory's Advocates (48% of the vote)
==== Runner-Up ====
* The Bentley Affair (24% of the vote)
==== Other Nominees ====
* Oni
* Vespertilio Lupus
=== Character of the Year ===
==== Winner ====
* Phylyco Brokenwhisper (18% of the vote)
==== Runner-Up ====
* Jack Burrows (18 % of the vote)
==== Other Nominees ====
* Kifo Pomboo
* Mello Bentley
* Darrow Emberstorm
* Troy Ross
* Aragi Maxul
* Gray MacBeth
* J.A.C. Bentley
* Kaspur
=== Campaign of the Year ===
==== Winner ====
* S.H.A.D.O.W. Season 3 (36% of the vote)
==== Runner-Up ====
* The Numen Swell Season 3 (32% of the vote)
==== Other Nominees ====
* S.H.A.D.O.W. Season 4
* The Numen Swell Season 2
== 2019 Season ==
The 2019 season had twenty categories and covered the events from April 7th, 2019 to March 29th, 2020
It consisted of the fifth and sixth seasons of S.H.A.D.O.W., the fourth (and final) season of The Numen Swell, the first season of Blood in the North, and four One-Shots (Primal Legacy, The Braun, Borderlands: The Other One, & Monstrous).
Categories marked with an * are brand new this year.
=== Most Likeable Protagonist ===
==== Winner ====
* Sonney Griffin-Thorne (22% of the vote)
==== Runner-Up ====
* Mikey Gnash (17% of the vote)
==== Other Nominees ====
* August Fallon-Nox
* Aragi Maxul
* Arthur Ried
* Sparra the Siren
* Violet a Chuul
* Foar
=== Most Likeable Antagonist ===
==== Winner ====
* Vargas de Orion Highstar (22% of the vote)
==== Runner-Up ====
* Gramma (17% of the vote)
==== Other Nominees ====
* Saint Hylophagous
* Jack Burrows
* The Demon Sachayoj
* Booker Dread
* Jikan
* Ravela
* Jean de Orion Highstar
=== Most Likeable NPC ===
==== Winner ====
* Mal Bloodjaw (17% of the vote)
==== Runner-Up ====
* Saint Hylophagous (17% of the vote)
==== Other Nominees ====
* Thomas Dawkins
* Sabra "Scarab" Nazari
* Aethin an Owlbear
* Benjamin Tecnic
* Bhalgus Tornhammer
* Robin Santos
* Sirobe
* Booker Dread
* Connor Mills
* Jean de Orion Highstar
* Lara Youngheart
* Lyssaria
* Rachel Bailey
* Ravela
* The Thorns
=== Most Heartbreaking Death (PC) ===
==== Winner ====
* Lucila "Lulu" O'Neil (14% of the vote)
==== Runner-Up ====
* Sonney Griffin-Thorne (14% of the vote)
==== Other Nominees ====
* Rebecca Bailey
* Aguero Cryhawk
* Chiens Cascade
* Orville
* Violet a Chuul
* Mordecai Silvergleam
* Sahge Montgomery
* Shyt
* Spjurmph
* Jack Burrows
* Liza Erd
* Mr. Doda
=== Most Heartbreaking Death (NPC) ===
==== Winner ====
* Echo (18% of the vote)
==== Runner-Up ====
* Mal Bloodjaw (14% of the vote)
==== Other Nominees ====
* Onion Kid
* Aethin an Owlbear
* Benjamin Tecnic
* Cain Emberstorm
* Connor Mills
* Lyssaria
* Mort Soulspark
* Saint Hylophagous
* Booker Dread
* Arcos Emberstorm
* Ardyn
* Jean de Orion Highstar
* Kurudi Amenkufa
* Ravela
* The Demon Sachayoj
=== Best Version of Gregory ===
==== Winner ====
* Helmsman Gregory {The Numen Swell} (38% of the vote)
==== Runner-Up ====
* The Obligatory Cameo {Borderlands: The Other One} (15% of the vote)
==== Other Nominees ====
* Sgt. Gregory {Blood in the North}
* Y'rogerg {Monstrous}
* Guregu {The Braun}
* Gregory of STG {S.H.A.D.O.W.}
* Greg {Primal Legacy}
=== Fan Favorite Character (The Numen Swell)* ===
==== Winner ====
* Dex (19% of the vote)
==== Runner-Up ====
* Kifo Pomboo (17% of the vote)
==== Other Nominees ====
* Sonney Griffin-Thorne
* Jack Burrows
* Mikey Gnash
* Orville
* Mwana Pomboo
* Quincy Mint
* Liza Erd
* Benjamin Tecnic
* Chiens Cascade
* Bennsyn
* Tamaa Nyeusi
* Balthazar Koegel
* Booker Dread
* Darwin Vulcan
* Mr. Doda
* Sahge Montgomery
=== Most Likely to Die Next (S.H.A.D.O.W.) ===
==== Winner ====
* Vargas de Orion Highstar (44% of the vote)
==== Runner-Up ====
* Phylyco (25% of the vote)
==== Other Nominees ====
* Darrow Emberstorm
* Aragi Maxul
=== Most Likely to Die Next (Blood in the North)* ===
==== Winner ====
* Ellie Eastwood (31% of the vote)
==== Runner-Up ====
* Roger (23% of the vote)
==== Other Nominees ====
* August Fallon-Nox
* Hiro Orias
* Lily
=== Most Believable Performance ===
==== Winner ====
* Anthony Hotchkiss as "K" the Badass (21% of the vote)
==== Runner-Up ====
* Matt Christie as Phylyco (17% of the vote)
==== Other Nominees ====
* Eric Rios as Aguero Cryhawk
* Eric Rios as Darrow Emberstorm
* Kyle Muller as Orville
* Anthony Hotchkiss as Roger
* Frankie Ramos as Lucila "Lulu" O'Neil
* Matt Christie as Dex
* Antoine SinClaire as Tsunni Dai
* Richie Maynard as Mikey Gnash
=== Best Newcomer to Athantopia* ===
==== Winner ====
* Anthony Hotchkiss (54% of the vote)
==== Runner-Up ====
* Aaron Hamilton (23% of the vote)
==== Other Nominees ====
* Frankie Ramos
* Jordan Scocozza
=== Most Likely to Break the Narrative ===
==== Winner ====
* Rob Christie (29% of the vote)
==== Runner-Up ====
* Dani Morrison (29% of the vote)
==== Other Nominees ====
* Eric Rios
* Kyle Muller
* Antoine SinClaire
=== Most Likely to Get the Party Killed ===
==== Winner ====
* Richie Maynard (47% of the vote)
==== Runner-Up ====
* Dani Morrison (24% of the vote)
==== Other Nominees ====
* Eric Rios
* Rob Christie
=== Most Likely to Kill an Ally ===
==== Winner ====
* Kyle Muller (24% of the vote)
==== Runner-Up ====
* Dani Morrison (24% of the vote)
==== Other Nominees ====
* Rob Christie
* Frankie Ramos
* Matt Christie
* Richie Maynard
* TJ Christie
=== Most Memorable Scene* ===
==== Winner ====
* "The Vale" {S.H.A.D.O.W.} (13% of the vote)
==== Runner-Up ====
* "Black Harbor" {S.H.A.D.O.W.} (10% of the vote)
==== Other Nominees ====
* "Aguero's Goodbye" {S.H.A.D.O.W.}
* "Everyting Orville" {The Numen Swell}
* "The First Bite" {Blood in the North}
* "Vargas' State of the Union" {S.H.A.D.O.W.}
* "Aethin's Sacrifice" {Monstrous}
* "Darrow v. Mordecai" {S.H.A.D.O.W.}
* "Finding Rebecca" {Blood in the North}
* "Losing Sonney" {The Numen Swell}
* "Tripping on Shrooms" {Primal Legacy}
* "K'eyush" {The Braun}
* "The Saint's Martyrdom" {S.H.A.D.O.W.}
=== Most Sexual Tension ===
==== Winner ====
* Darrow & Lara (29% of the vote)
==== Runner-Up ====
* Scarab & Roger (21% of the vote)
==== Other Nominees ====
* August & Rachel
* Orville & Sonney
* Phylyco & Elbije
=== Most Likely to Get a Sequel (One-Shot) ===
==== Winner ====
* The Braun (42% of the vote)
==== Runner-Up ====
* Borderlands: The Other One (33% of the vote)
==== Other Nominees ====
* Monstrous
* Primal Legacy
=== One-Shot of the Year ===
==== Winner ====
* Borderlands: The Other One (46% of the vote)
==== Runner-Up ====
* The Braun (38% of the vote)
==== Other Nominees ====
* Primal Legacy
* Monstrous
=== Character of the Year ===
==== Winner ====
* Phylyco (23% of the vote)
==== Runner-Up ====
* "K" the Badass (23% of the vote)
==== Other Nominees ====
* Aguero Cryhawk
* Orville
* Dex
* Roger
* Lucila "Lulu" O'Neil
* Shyt
* Tsunni Dai
=== Campaign of the Year ===
==== Winner ====
* S.H.A.D.O.W. Season 5 (43% of the vote)
==== Runner-Up ====
* The Numen Swell Season 4 (21% of the vote)
==== Other Nominees ====
* Blood in the North Season 1
* S.H.A.D.O.W. Season 6
== 2020 Season ==
The 2020 season had twenty categories and covered the events from April 5th, 2020 to March 28th, 2021
It consisted of the seventh and eighth seasons of S.H.A.D.O.W., the second and third seasons of Blood in the North, and four One-Shots (Advocates 2, Tales of Eris: Saints, Blood in the North: Rise of the Zeds, & Swell of Shadows)
Categories marked with an * are brand new this year.
=== Most Likeable Protagonist ===
==== Winner ====
* Aragi Maxul (40% of the vote)
==== Runner-Up ====
* Hiro Orias (20% of the vote)
==== Other Nominees ====
* August Fallon-Nox
* Saint Hylophagous
* Vixaris
=== Most Likeable Antagonist ===
==== Winner ====
* William "Wild Bill" Imes (33% of the vote)
==== Runner-Up ====
* Phylyco Brokenwhisper (24% of the vote)
==== Other Nominees ====
* Hezekiah Silvergleam
* Amarel Jenella
* Desmond
* Pragaras
* Saint Wroth
* Sparra the Siren
* Tsunni Dai
* Arvatio Mordus
* Br-KN
* Corrine Levalle
* Deacon Vincent
* Dhaxx
* Harvest
* Meekknuckle
* Mr. Crenshaw
* Qing Shu
* Samuel Locke
=== Most Likeable NPC ===
==== Winner ====
* Sabra "Scarab" Nazari (16% of the vote)
==== Runner-Up ====
* Sirobe (3% of the vote)
==== Other Nominees ====
* Bhalgus Tornhammer
* Zinonna Murium
* Aurora Lightblade
* Desmond
* Julius Nox
* Saint Hylophagous
* Tadal
* Elizabeth Archer
* Lara Youngheart
* Lexi Watson
* Reggie Greyleather
* Sparra the Siren
* Amarel Jenella
* Arvatio Mordus
* Br-KN
* Corrine Levalle
* Deacon Vincent
* Franklin Bailey
* Gabrielle Mendez
* Meekknuckle
* Mello Bentley
* Onyx Winter
* Rhumbus
* Robin Santos
* Saint Ibis
* Saint Opia
* Saint Wroth
* Sarya Nameless
=== Most Heartbreaking Death (PC) ===
==== Winner ====
* Ellie Eastwood (28% of the vote)
==== Runner-Up ====
* Phylyco Brokenwhisper (17% of the vote)
==== Other Nominees ====
* Conrad Willabee
* Jocelyn Knapp
* Rathisi'Defteros
* Tsunni Dai
* Hezekiah Silvergleam
* Lily
* Darrow Emberstorm
* David Stone
* Pragaras
=== Most Heartbreaking Death (NPC) ===
==== Winner ====
* Lara Youngheart (19% of the vote)
==== Runner-Up ====
* Lexi Watson (14% of the vote)
==== Other Nominees ====
* Delsin Emberstorm
* Devin Daniels
* Rhumbus
* Alidiana Pegason
* Bjorn Urregard
* Tyson Greenwell
* Villberg
* Deacon Vincent
* Harvest
* Julius Nox
* Moh Gragogva
* Onyx Winter
* Robin Santos
* Shredder
* Sparra the Siren
=== Best Version of Gregory ===
==== Winner ====
* Prisoner Gregory (57% of the vote)
==== Runner-Up ====
* Sgt. Gregory (29% of the vote)
==== Other Nominees ====
* Gregory of STG
=== Most Committed Player* ===
==== Winner ====
* Kyle Muller (40% of the vote)
==== Runner-Up ====
* Corey Sexton (27% of the vote)
==== Other Nominees ====
* Anthony Hotchkiss
* Matt Christie
* Richie Maynard
=== Most Likely to Die Next (S.H.A.D.O.W.) ===
==== Winner ====
* Aragi Maxul (36% of the vote)
==== Runner-Up ====
* Vargas de Orion Highstar (21% of the vote)
==== Other Nominees ====
* Banshee Black
* Grekkus Raisir
* Mayon of the North
=== Most Likely to Die Next (Blood in the North) ===
==== Winner ====
* August Fallon-Nox (29% of the vote)
==== Runner-Up ====
* William "Wild Bill" Imes (21% of the vote)
==== Other Nominees ====
* Roger
* Frank Schmidt
* Hiro Orias
* Oliver Larson
* Zestari Delorio
=== Most Believable Performance ===
==== Winner ====
* Kyle Muller as William "Wild Bill" Imes (23% of the vote)
==== Runner-Up ====
* Matt Christie as Phylyco Brokenwhisper (19% of the vote)
==== Other Nominees ====
* Anthony Hotchkiss as Roger
* Eric Rios as Vargas de Orion Highstar
* Monti as Frank Schmidt
* Eric Rios as Arthur Ried
* Cory Mazzarelli as Pec the Large
* Vin Craig as Oliver Larson
=== Best Newcomer to an Athantopia Campaign ===
==== Winner ====
* Monti (47% of the vote)
==== Runner-Up ====
* Darryl Walaszek (33% of the vote)
==== Other Nominees ====
* Joanna Battersby
* Vin Craig
=== Most Likely to Break the Narrative ===
==== Winner ====
* Rob Christie (26% of the vote)
==== Runner-Up ====
* Eric Rios (26% of the vote)
==== Other Nominees ====
* Dani Morrison
* Kyle Muller
* Antoine SinClaire
=== Most Likely to Get the Party Killed ===
==== Winner ====
* Dani Morrison (30% of the vote)
==== Runner-Up ====
* Eric Rios (20% of the vote)
==== Other Nominees ====
* Kyle Muller
* Richie Maynard
* Rob Christie
=== Most Likely to Kill an Ally ===
==== Winner ====
* Kyle Muller (30% of the vote)
==== Runner-Up ====
* Dani Morrison (22% of the vote)
==== Other Nominees ====
* Antoine SinClaire
* Richie Maynard
* Rob Christie
* Matt Christie
=== Most WTF Moment* ===
==== Winner ====
* "Wild Bill Eliminates Gregory" (32% of the vote)
==== Runner-Up ====
* "Fort Tidus" (23% of the vote)
==== Other Nominees ====
* "Aguero's Sacrifice"
* "Gregory is Not Alone"
* "Br-KN"
* "Paramedics"
* "Snowfall"
* "Solair: Corrupted"
* "Vargas in the Dragon Tomb"
* "Ameliore"
* "Project: Daybreak"
=== Most Sexual Tension ===
==== Winner ====
* Lexi & Everyone (36% of the vote)
==== Runner-Up ====
* Aragi & Aurora (21% of the vote)
==== Other Nominees ====
==== Winner ====
* Hezekiah & Jenella
* Hylophagous & Belxori
* Pec & Robin
* Uwibami & Mendez
* Wild Bill & Karen
* Zestari & Oli
=== Most Likely to Get a Sequel (One-Shot) ===
==== Winner ====
* Advocates 2 (75% of the vote)
==== Runner-Up ====
* Blood in the North: Rise of the Zeds (8% of the vote)
==== Other Nominees ====
* Swell of Shadows
* Tales of Eris: Saints
=== One-Shot of the Year ===
==== Winner ====
* Advocates 2 (42% of the vote)
==== Runner-Up ====
* Blood in the North: Rise of the Zeds (33% of the vote)
==== Other Nominees ====
* Swell of Shadows
* Tales of Eris: Saints
=== Character of the Year ===
==== Winner ====
* William"Wild Bill" Imes (50% of the vote)
==== Runner-Up ====
* Phylyco Brokenwhisper (29% of the vote)
==== Other Nominees ====
* Banshee Black
* Frank Schmidt
* Pec the Large
* Hiro Orias
* Oliver Larson
* Vargas de Orion Highstar
=== Campaign of the Year ===
==== Winner ====
* S.H.A.D.O.W. Season 7 (42% of the vote)
==== Runner-Up ====
* Blood in the North Season 3 (25% of the vote)
==== Other Nominees ====
* Blood in the North Season 2
* S.H.A.D.O.W. Season 8
== Trivia ==
=== 2017 Season ===
* S.H.A.D.O.W. took the most awards home for a campaign with 9 wins.
* Matt Christie took the most awards home for an individual with 3 personal wins and 5 group wins for a total of 8 wins.
* There were 7 ties for first place but the awards went to whichever held he lead longer during the voting process.
* Bennsyn received the most votes in one category for Most Likely to Die Next (The Numen Swell) with an impressive 58% of the vote.
=== 2018 Season ===
* S.H.A.D.O.W. took the most awards home for a campaign with 9 wins. (Second Year in a Row)
* Matt Christie took the most awards home for an individual with 3 personal wins and 4 group wins for a total of 7 wins. (Second Year in a Row)
* There were 2 ties for first place but the award went to whichever held the lead longer during the voting process.
* Gregory's Advocates received the most votes in one category for Most Likely to get a Sequel (One-Shot) with an impressive 67% of the vote.
* 5 categories from 2017 did not return for 2018. (Biggest Laugh Track, Most Reckless Character, Funniest Deformity Made Fun of By Others, Most Likely to Kill Each Other, & Most Likely to Have a Character Cross-Over into a Main Series)
* 5 categories are brand new to 2018. (Most Likeable Antagonist, Most Badass Fight, Most Likely to Break the Narrative, Most Likely to Kill an Ally, & Poorest Time Management)
* 3 Nominees succeeded in winning their category for the second consecutive year in a row. (Sonney Griffin-Thorne for "Most Likeable Protagonist", Mal Bloodjaw for "Most Likeable NPC", & Phylyco Brokenwhisper for "Character of the Year")
=== 2019 Season ===
* S.H.A.D.O.W. took the most awards home for a campaign with 10 wins. (Third Year in a Row)
* Matt Christie and Eric Rios took the most awards home for an individual with a total of 6 wins each. (Christie's Third Year in a Row)
* Anthony Hotchkiss received the most votes in one category for Best Newcomer to Athantopia with an impressive 54% of the vote.
* There were 5 ties for first place but the award went to whichever held the lead longer during the voting process.
* 4 categories from 2018 did not return for 2019. (Most Badass Fight, Most Likely to Die Next {The Numen Swell}, Best Newcomer to Roleplaying, & Poorest Time Management)
* 4 categories are brand new to 2019. (Fan Favorite Character {The Numen Swell}, Most Likely to Die Next {Blood in the North}, Best Newcomer to Athantopia, & Most Memorable Scene)
* 3 Nominees succeeded in winner their category for the third consecutive year in a row (Sonney Griffin-Thorne for "Most Likeable Protagonist", Mal Bloodjaw for "Most Likeable NPC", & Phylyco Brokenwhisper for "Character of the Year") and 1 Nominee for the second consecutive year in a row (Helmsman Gregory for "Best Version of Gregory")
=== 2020 Season ===
* Blood in the North took the most awards home for a campaign with 12 wins.
* Kyle Muller took the most awards home for an individual with 5 personal wins and 3 group wins for a total of 8 wins.
* There was 1 tie for first place but the award went to whichever held the lead longer during the voting process.
* Advocates 2 received the most votes in one category for Most Likely to Get a Sequel (One-Shot) with an impressive 75% of the vote.
* 2 categories from 2019 did not return for 2020. (Fan Favorite Character {The Numen Swell} & Most Memorable Scene)
* 2 categories are brand new to 2020. (Most Committed Player & Most WTF Moment)
* The category "Best Newcomer..." was altered to "Best Newcomer to an Athantopia Campaign" due to there only being two new players in 2020.