Report 98

Report #98
Skillset: Acrobatics Skill: Springup
 Org: Serenguard Status: Completed Dec 2008
Furies' Decision:
Approved.
Problem: Springup is currently doable with a broken and mangled leg (doesn't
work with amputate/tendon, though). You can't stand normally with these
afflictions, and there's no reason that springup ought to be any different from
stand aside from the fact that you can do it offbalance
[A: 0 R: 0] Solution #1: Make springup unable to be done with a broken/mangled
 leg
[A: 0 R: 0] Solution #2: :(
Player Comments:
---[Charune on 12/19 @ 00:43 writes]:
98 Solution 2 is overpowered.
---[Shuyin on 12/19 @ 03:21 writes]:
Solution 2 appended to be more balanced
---[Shuyin on 12/19 @ 03:21 writes]:
...which is what I would say if I were allowed to edit it after finalizing, but
I can't, so damn.
---[Lanfayr on 12/19 @ 11:38 writes]:
I'm fine with springup not working with a mangled leg. It works with a broken
leg because you use your arms to spring up or something, and it hasn't been a
problem afaik so I don't see a need to change that.
---[Shuyin on 12/20 @ 23:26 writes]:
That's shoddy logic at best. As said, there's no reason why springup should be
better than stand aside from the fact that you can do it offbalance.
---[Xiel on 12/23 @ 08:48 writes]:
I've no qualms with SpringUp being tweaked to actually do what it's supposed to
be only doing, not more.
---[Ceren on 12/25 @ 04:31 writes]:
Yep, should only be offbalance stand limited by all the afflictions that stand
is limited by. Solution 1 should include hemiplegy, shattered ankles, pierced
legs (on a % chance like stand), and anything else I'm forgetting too
---[Shuyin on 12/25 @ 09:19 writes]:
Hm, I didn't think to check those affs, if it's true that you -can- springup
from those, please make you unable to springup with those affs as well, Furies
---[Xenthos on 12/25 @ 21:36 writes]:
Standing off-balance is a pretty good advantage all by itself.
---[Sadhyra on 12/26 @ 16:04 writes]:
This suggestion seems perfectly fair
---[Steingrim on 12/31 @ 15:58 writes]:
I don't think you should be able to :( no matter what balance you have. Solution
one seems more reasonable.