Mistakes in the Warriors Series/Novellas

===Thunderstar's Echo===
*Slate is said to have only one missing ear tip.
*Riverstar is said to have amber eyes.
*Willow Tail is listed in the allegiances, despite dying in Moth Flight's Vision.
*Thorn is called a tom.
*On the cover of the digital novella collection, at the bottom where it lists the titles, it is mistakenly listed as "Thunder's Echo" instead of "Thunderstar's Echo".:File:NOC-4.jpg This was later fixed in the physical printing.:File:NOC-4-2.png
*Lightning Tail is said to have been part of Wind Runner's group on the moor, but Lightning Tail never lived in Wind Runner's group, instead living in the one led by Tall Shadow, Gray Wing, and Thunder.
===Shadowstar's Life===
*Slate is said to have only one missing ear-tip.
*White Tail, Silver Stripe, Black Ear, Drizzle, and Pine Needle are called kits despite being listed as hunters.
*Willow Tail is listed in the allegiances, despite dying in Moth Flight's Vision.
*Dusk Nose is called a tom.
*Shadowstar refers to SkyClan hunters as warriors, despite the rank not yet existing.
*Though it has been established that early deputies did not take over after a leader's death until much later in Clan history, Shadowstar repeatedly refers to her deputy, which she picks to be Raven Pelt, as definitively the next cat to lead ShadowClan. Shadowstar has no kits or other kin in her Clan, however, so in this case, the deputy may be the obvious choice.
*Skystar is seen reprimanding Quick Water for breaking the warrior code, but the code was not created until later.
*Sparrow Fur is said to have green eyes.
===Cloudstar's Journey===
*Amberclaw and Nettleclaw are both not listed in the allegiances of Cloudstar's Journey, but appear in the book.
*Darkstar is called Duskstar throughout the book.
*In Battles of the Clans, Cloudstorm states that he and Birdflight became warriors at the same time. In Cloudstar's Journey, Cloudstar mentions that Birdflight is several moons older than him, and was already a warrior when he was made an apprentice.
===Mapleshade's Vengeance===
*Mapleshade is called orange-and-white multiple times.
*Larkwing was mistakenly called a tom.
*Frecklewish is called pale ginger or ginger at least three times.
*Oakstar is said to have yellow eyes.
*Darkstar is called a tom.
*Frecklewish is called pale brown.
*Seedpelt is called Seedwhisker.
===Pinestar's Choice===
*Dappletail is listed in the allegiances, despite not even being born yet.
*Flashpaw is called a tom.
*Pearnose is called a tom.
*Moonflower is called blue-gray.
*Sweetpaw is said to have white patches.
*It is said that Lionpaw found out about Pinestar visiting Twolegplace a quarter-moon before Leopardfoot's kits were born, when in reality the kits were born a day before Lionpaw found out.
===Goosefeather's Curse===
*Hawkheart is listed as Chiveclaw's apprentice, with an apprentice name, despite becoming a warrior first.
*Hawkheart is seen as a medicine cat apprentice while Heatherstar is leader, despite having a full medicine cat name during Heatherstar's nine lives ceremony in Tallstar's Revenge.
*Stormtail is called dark gray.
*Goosepaw is mistakenly called Goosefeather before he gets his full name, and is subsequently called Goosepaw after getting his full name.
*Swiftbreeze is mistakenly called by her apprentice name shortly after her warrior ceremony.
===Spottedleaf's Heart===
*Stonepelt is not listed in the allegiances despite being alive at the time.
*Sparrowpelt is called Halftail before he receives that name.
*Even though Poppydawn is said to be in the elders' den, she becomes Willowpaw's mentor.
*Thistleclaw is mistakenly called pale-furred.
*Goosefeather is said to have moved to the elders' den a couple of days after Tigerpaw fights Tiny. However, he does not join the elders until much later, a half-moon before Bluefur's kits are born.
*The beginning of chapter 9 includes several mistakes:
**Tigerclaw and Whitestorm are made warriors at the same time, even though Tigerclaw became a warrior four moons before Whitestorm.
**Bluefur is pregnant when Whitestorm becomes a warrior, despite the fact that she does not even meet with Oakheart until well after he receives his name.
**Whitestorm is made a warrior in leaf-bare when he is actually made a warrior in leaf-fall.
**Spottedpaw is shown to be Featherwhisker's apprentice, despite not gaining that role until a half-moon before Bluefur's kits are born.
*Mumblefoot is shown playing with Bluefur's kits, despite him being dead at this point since he is mentioned to be so before Spottedpaw becomes a medicine cat apprentice.
*Spottedleaf longs to become a warrior, However, it was established in Yellowfang's Secret and Bluestar's Prophecy that she always wanted to become a medicine cat since she was a kitten.
===Redtail's Debt===
*There are several mistakes within the allegiances:
**Stonepelt is not listed despite being alive at the time.
**Mumblefoot and Weedwhisker should also be dead since they are mentioned to be so before Spottedpaw becomes a medicine cat apprentice.
***Fuzzypelt and Windflight should also be elders for the same reason.
**Blackclaw, Sedgecreek, Reedtail, Skyheart, Leopardfur, Petaldust and Loudbelly are listed as apprentices, despite being warriors at the time.
**Softwing should be listed as a queen and not as a warrior.
**Deadfoot is listed as a warrior, while Pigeonpaw and Sorrelpaw are still apprentices, and Palebird is still in the nursery, implying he became a warrior very early. In the allegiances of Leopardstar's Honor, Palebird is a warrior and her kits are apprentices, while Deadpaw and his siblings are also still apprentices.
**Talltail is listed as deputy while Shrewclaw is still alive, despite the fact that the latter died before the former was made deputy.
***Reedfeather is also not listed despite still being alive at this time since Crookedjaw is not leader yet.
*It says that ThunderClan warned RiverClan off of Sunningrocks before Redpaw became an apprentice when it actually was after.
*Fourtrees is called a camp.
*Redtail is mistakenly shown killing Oakheart, when the RiverClan deputy died in a rockfall.
*Despite Stonefur appearing in the battle, Oakheart does not pull Redtail away to protect Stonefur, which later prompts Fireheart's investigation into the mystery of Bluestar's kits.
*Sunstar alludes that Firepaw's apprentice ceremony takes place after Ravenpaw's announcement of Redtail's death, when it takes place prior.
===Tigerclaw's Fury===
*Deerfoot is missing from the allegiances.
*Mistyfoot is called dark gray.
*It is very likely that Applefur is meant to be the same Applefur from Omen of the Stars arc, who shares the same description. However, that Applefur was a kit during the Great Journey and would not have been born for Tigerclaw's Fury. It is possible that the allegiances for Omen of the Stars was consulted while writing this book, as Cedarheart, who would have been an apprentice, is mistakenly shown as an elder and Ratscar, who first appeared in Eclipse, are featured in Tigerclaw's Fury. However, due to timeline inconsistencies, this character is listed as separate from Applefur in Omen of the Stars.
*Clawface is shown alive, despite dying in Fire and Ice.
*Stumpytail is said to have been driven from ShadowClan, but he appears as a ShadowClan warrior in Fire and Ice, Forest of Secrets, and Rising Storm.
*Blackfoot is mistakenly said to have one black paw.
*Brackenpaw is said to be brown.
*Brackenfur is said to be an apprentice, despite having already earned his warrior name.
*Snag is said to be a loner instead of a rogue.
*Cinderfur is said to have brought the infected rat that caused the Carrionplace disease to ShadowClan, but in Rising Storm, Littlecloud says an apprentice brought the infected rat.
*Mowgli is said to be a loner instead of a rogue.
*Stumpytail and Dawncloud are said to have been close friends as apprentices, but Dawncloud was a newborn kit when Stumpytail was a warrior.
*Despite not earning his warrior name until after The Darkest Hour, Cedarheart is shown as an elder in Tigerclaw's Fury, which is set before then.
*Littlecloud is mistakenly referred to as a gray tabby.
*Thornclaw and Mousefur are mistakenly called light brown.
*Despite not earning his warrior name until The Darkest Hour, Thornclaw is shown as a warrior in Tigerclaw's Fury, which is set before then.
*In A Dangerous Path, Littlecloud explains how Whitethroat mysteriously died when he refused to return to ShadowClan's camp after Fireheart made them leave, but in Tigerclaw's Fury, Whitethroat returns to ShadowClan and Tigerclaw explains to ShadowClan how Fireheart killed him on the Thunderpath.
*In one scene, the cats are training at "a sandy space among the pines not far from the lake". This refers to the new territories, despite the fact that the Clans had not traveled to the lake territories yet.
*Frostfur is mistakenly called a tom.
*Tawnykit is mistakenly called pale brown.
*Cinderpelt is mistakenly called pale gray.
===Blackfoot's Reckoning===
*There are several mistakes within the allegiances:
**Despite dying before the book takes place, Whitestorm, Darkstripe, Tigerstar, Gorsepaw, and Stonefur are all listed.
**Fernpaw is listed as Darkstripe's apprentice, even though Longtail was her mentor by that time.
**Thornclaw is listed as an apprentice, despite already receiving his warrior name.
**Tawnypaw is listed in ThunderClan, despite have left to join ShadowClan by that point.
**Brightheart is listed as Lostface, even though she had already had her name changed.
**Jaggedtooth is listed in ShadowClan, even though he had joined BloodClan by that time.
**Gorsepaw is described as a very pale gray-and-white she-cat with blue eyes.
*Darkstripe is called a black-and-silver striped gray tabby.
*Sagewhisker is called a tom.
*Fernpaw is called a tom.
*During a fight with WindClan, it is initially said that the battle is occurring within WindClan camp, but then it is said that the WindClan cats are a patrol.
*WindClan is referred to as ShadowClan.
*Mintkit and Marigoldkit are described as Yellowfang's half-siblings.
*Right after his exile, Tigerclaw informs Blackfoot of Brokentail's death even though there is no way for Tigerclaw to know this yet as Brokentail is killed shortly after he leaves ThunderClan's camp.
*Cinderfur is called a she-cat.
*Shadowstar gives Blackstar a life at his ceremony, despite it being established in River of Fire that the two have never met each other.
===Mothwing's Secret===
*Shadepelt claims she is the same age as Mudfur; however, he is several years older than her.
*Hawkfrost is mistakenly called Hawkwing twice on the same page.
*Darktail is said to have been in the Dark Forest with Tigerstar and the others, when he was actually alive and had not even met most of the cats by the lake at the time.
*Troutstream is mistakenly called Troutpaw, despite the fact that the Great Battle takes place after she receives her warrior name.
===Leafpool's Wish===
*Spiderleg is mistakenly said to be the father of Hazelkit, Mousekit, and Berrykit.
*Squirrelflight is mistakenly described with amber eyes.
*Yellowfang is described with yellow eyes.
*Smokepaw is listed in the allegiances, despite dying in Dawn.
*Leafpool mistakenly describes Feathertail as Crowfeather's first mate when they were never mates to begin with.
*Daisy is mistakenly said to be the one who will nurse Jaykit, Hollykit, and Lionkit. In The Sight, Ferncloud was the cat who nursed them.
===Hollyleaf's Story===
*In the allegiances, Honeyfern is listed despite dying in Sunrise, which took place before.
*Heavystep is also listed despite dying in Sunset.
*Fallen Leaves is said to have blue eyes.
*Hollyleaf is shown discovering the fallen tree in the hollow, but in The Forgotten Warrior, she is surprised to learn that a tree fell in the hollow.
*Hollyleaf leads Ivypool and Blossomfall to a tunnel entrance within ThunderClan territory; however, in Sign of the Moon, this entrance is beyond ThunderClan's borders.
*Hollyleaf discovers Sol's plot the same night she meets Dovewing and Ivypool, but in The Forgotten Warrior, Hollyleaf tells Dovewing and Ivypool that she has been eavesdropping on Sol plotting with WindClan in the tunnels for the past half-moon.
===Mistystar's Omen===
*In the allegiances, Bumblestripe, Blossomfall, and Briarlight are listed as warriors despite being apprentices at the time.
**In addition, Bumblestripe is listed as Bumbleflight.
*Leopardstar is said to have blue eyes.
*Tigerstar is mistakenly said to have died in the battle with BloodClan, despite dying days before.
*It is said that Bluestar revealed to Mistyfoot and Stonefur that she was their mother just before she died, when it was actually Fireheart who revealed the secret to them some time earlier, in a battle for Sunningrocks.
*Icewing is said to be the RiverClan cat, along with Rippletail, to travel to find the beavers and bring back the water instead of Petalfur.
*Pouncetail is said to have known Stonefur and to miss the forest, despite being introduced as an apprentice in The Sight.
*Graypool is mistakenly described as a pale gray cat.
*Feathertail is mistakenly described as a gray tabby.
*Silverstream is mistakenly described with delicate silver markings.
*Oakheart is mistakenly called a dark brown tabby.
*Bluestar is described as a dark gray she-cat.
*Mistystar is mistakenly said to have known Graystripe since he was an apprentice, despite him not meeting her until he was a warrior.
*Willowshine is said to have blue eyes.
*Mothwing is described with blue eyes multiple times.
*Mintfur is supposed to have gone on the patrol upstream alongside Mistystar, Icewing and Grasspelt, but he is not mentioned again for the rest of the chapter.
*It is mentioned that Mudfur stayed behind in the old forest because he had grown too old to travel. However, Mudfur died before the journey to the lake even began.
*Mistystar mentions that she did not know Oakheart to be her father until after Bluestar's death. However, in Forest of Secrets, long before Bluestar's death, Mistyfoot tells Fireheart that Oakheart is her father.
===Ravenpaw's Farewell===
*Rileypaw is mistakenly said to be almost the same color as Graystripe.
*Duskpaw is mistakenly called Dustpaw.
===Dovewing's Silence===
*Brambleclaw is listed as Bramblestar along with Squirrelflight being his deputy despite not going to the Moonpool yet.
*Brightheart is described with white patches.
*Purdy is called black.
*Ivypool is called gray-and-white.
*Purdy talks about the greencough outbreak from Long Shadows like he had been there, despite not arriving in ThunderClan until Sunrise.
*Seedkit is listed as both an apprentice and a kit, despite being a kit during the whole story. This is in the original digital-only copy and is fixed in the physical reprints.
*Dewkit, Snowkit, and Amberkit are not listed in the allegiances, despite being members of ThunderClan.
**Additionally, Brightheart is not listed as a queen.
*Beetlewhisker is said to have died in the Great Battle, when he actually died beforehand.
===Tree's Roots===
*Chestnut is not listed in the allegiances, despite appearing in the book.
*Mud and Sparrow are listed in the allegiances, despite not appearing in the book.
*It is said that Root has a squirrel dangling from his jaws, but in the next paragraph it says he drops a rabbit.
===Pebbleshine's Kits===
*Pebbleshine is mistakenly called Puddleshine.
===Tawnypelt's Clan===
*There are a few mistakes in the allegiances:
**Beetlewhisker is listed, and has an apprentice, despite dying in The Last Hope.
**Harrybrook's name is not in bold print or capitalized.
**Heronwing is listed despite dying in Shattered Sky.
*The word "winter" is used twice, despite Clan cats referring to it as "leaf-bare".
*Bramblestar is mistakenly called Brambleclaw twice.
*Rowanclaw is mistakenly called Rowanstar.
*It is mistakenly said that Tawnypelt had not visited the Tribe since leaving the old territories, when she visited them in Outcast.
===Spotfur's Rebellion===
*Briarlight is shown in the allegiances, despite dying before the book takes place.
*According to the allegiances, the book starts before The Raging Storm, but in chapter one of the novella, it is mentioned that ShadowClan and SkyClan had trouble over territory, which happened in The Raging Storm.
*Spotfur is mistakenly referred to by her warrior name before actually receiving it.
*Rowanclaw is mistakenly called Rowanstar.
*It is said that Rosepetal dragged Twigbranch out of sight, but it was actually Bristlefrost whom she dragged.
*Finleap is described with brown paws.
*Finleap is said to be in ThunderClan, but by that point he had already left with Twigbranch and Alderheart.
===Daisy's Kin===
*The book is said to take place between books three and four of The Broken Code, but it actually takes place between books four and six.
*Smoky says to Coriander that "Greenleaf is coming", although they are already in greenleaf.
==Notes==
==References==
de:Fehler in den Warrior Cats-Büchern/Short Adventure
Category:Reference
Category:Novellas