The "I Don't Get What People Saw In This Movie" Award

The "I Don't Get What People Saw In This Movie" Award is a Sinkie Award presented annually by the Everything But the Kitchen Sink podcast since the awards debuted in 2018. The award typically honors the most polarizing films of the year within the voting body, and as such there is often crossover between nominees here and in the Best Picture race. Seven films are nominated every year for this award. There have been 49 films nominated for this award and seven winners.
In the first three years of the awards, there were often repeat nominees in this category and Worst Movie. Beginning with the 2021 Sinkies Awards, no film could be nominated for both categories, with the seven nominees for Worst Movie becoming off-limits for a nomination here. There was one exception with the 2024 nominees, where the film Saltburn received such an abundance of votes in each category that it felt appropriate for it to land in both, particularly given the film's polarizing nature.
== Correlation with Best Picture ==
Of the 49 films nominated over the years for this award, seven were also nominated for the Sinkie for Best Picture: Bohemian Rhapsody (2018), Vice (2018), Dune (2021), The Power of the Dog (2021), Nope (2022), Barbie (2023), and Poor Things (2023). Nope, The Power of the Dog, and Poor Things are all films that won this award and were nominated for the Sinkie Award For Best Picture.
==Winners and nominees==
In the list below, winners are listed first, bolded with asterisks around them, followed by the other nominees. The year shown is the one in which the film premiered - the year of release. This is also the year before the ceremony at which the award is given; for example, a film exhibited thetrically during 2021 was eligible for consideration for the 2021 honor, awarded in 2022. The number of the ceremony (1st, 2nd, etc.) appears in parentheses after the awards year, linked to the article on that ceremony.
Year of Film Release	Film
2017
(1st) 	*I, Tonya*
2017
(1st) 	Home Again
2017
(1st) 	It Comes at Night
2017
(1st) 	Mother!
2017
(1st) 	Mudbound
2017
(1st) 	Star Wars: The Last Jedi
2017
(1st) 	Thor: Ragnarok
2018
(2nd) 	*Jurassic World: Fallen Kingdom*
2018
(2nd) 	Avengers: Infinity War
2018
(2nd) 	Bohemian Rhapsody
2018
(2nd) 	Fantastic Beasts: The Crimes of Grindelwald
2018
(2nd) 	The Favourite
2018
(2nd) 	Hereditary
2018
(2nd) 	Vice
2019
(3rd) 	*Joker*
2019
(3rd) 	Aladdin
2019
(3rd) 	Captain Marvel
2019
(3rd) 	Ford v Ferrari
2019
(3rd) 	A Hidden Life
2019
(3rd) 	Honey Boy
2019
(3rd) 	The Peanut Butter Falcon
2020
(4th) 	*I Care a Lot*
2020
(4th) 	An American Pickle
2020
(4th) 	Birds of Prey (and the Fantabulous Emancipation of One Harley Quinn)
2020
(4th) 	News of the World
2020
(4th) 	Palm Springs
2020
(4th) 	The Trial of the Chicago 7
2020
(4th) 	The Way Back
2021
(5th) 	*The Power of the Dog*
2021
(5th) 	Belfast
2021
(5th) 	Dune
2021
(5th) 	Eternals
2021
(5th) 	The French Dispatch
2021
(5th) 	House of Gucci
2021
(5th) 	Zola
2022
(6th) 	*Nope*
2022
(6th) 	The Batman
2022
(6th) 	Black Panther: Wakanda Forever
2022
(6th) 	Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness
2022
(6th) 	Elvis
2022
(6th) 	Nope
2022
(6th) 	Thor: Love and Thunder
2022
(6th) 	Triangle of Sadness
2023
(7th) 	*Poor Things*
2023
(7th) 	Barbie
2023
(7th) 	Ferrari
2023
(7th) 	Maestro
2023
(7th) 	Napoleon
2023
(7th) 	Saltburn
2023
(7th) 	Theater Camp
== Jimmy & Kyle's Votes ==
Each year, hosts Jimmy Nicholas and Kyle Wilson announce their vote before they announce the winner. In this category, Jimmy's pick has won twice and Kyle's pick has won once. Jimmy and Kyle have never agreed on this category, and at the 7th Annual Sinkies, Jimmy was so frustrated with the lineup that he abstained from voting.
Year of Film Release	Jimmy 	Kyle 	Winner
2017 (1st) 	It Comes at Night 	Mother! 	I, Tonya
2018 (2nd) 	Jurassic World: Fallen Kingdom 	Bohemian Rhapsody 	Jurassic World: Fallen Kingdom
2019 (3rd) 	Captain Marvel 	Joker 	Joker
2020 (4th) 	Birds of Prey (and the Fantabulous Emancipation of One Harley Quinn)	The Trial of the Chicago 7	I Care a Lot
2021 (5th) 	The Power of the Dog 	Belfast 	The Power of the Dog
2022 (6th) 	Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness 	Triangle of Sadness 	Nope
2023 (7th) 	Abstain 	Barbie 	Poor Things