4th Academy Awards

The 4th Academy Awards were held on November 10, 1931.
The 1931 Oscars will be remembered for the fierce competition and notable achievements that defined the year. Howard Hughes's Hell's Angels won Best Picture, setting a new standard for action cinema with its groundbreaking aerial sequences. Wallace Beery's intense portrayal in The Big House earned him his first Best Actor win, while Ann Harding's performance in Holiday secured her the Best Actress award. The year also saw Jean Cocteau's innovative direction of The Blood of a Poet recognized with a Best Director win. Despite multiple nominations, Irving G. Thalberg went home empty-handed, further cementing his overdue status. Lionel Barrymore made a significant mark by stepping into a directorial role for The Rogue Song. The 1931 Oscars highlighted the evolving landscape of Hollywood, where diverse storytelling and technical brilliance were celebrated.
==Winners and nominees==
===Awards===
Nominees were announced on September 19, 1930. Winners are listed first, in boldface.
Best Picture
*Hell's Angels - Howard Hughes
*All Quiet on the Western Front - Carl Laemmle Jr
*Anna Christie - Clarence Brown, Paul Bern, Irving G. Thalberg
*The Big House - Irving G. Thalberg
*The Rogue Song - Lionel Barrymore & Hal Roach	Best Director
*Jean Cocteau - The Blood of a Poet
*Clarence Brown - Anna Christie
*Rene Clair - Under the Roofs of Paris
*George W. Hill - The Big House
*Howard Hughes - Hell's Angels
Best Actor
*Wallace Beery - The Big House 
*Lew Ayres - All Quiet on the Western Front
*Robert Montgomery - The Big House
*William Powell - Street of Chance
*Lawrence Tibbett - The Rogue Song	Best Actress
*Ann Harding - Holiday
*Louise Brooks - Prix de beaute
*Claudette Colbert - Manslaughter
*Joan Crawford - Paid
*Greta Garbo - Anna Christie
Best Original Screenplay
*The Big House - Frances Marion
*High Society Blues - Howard J. Green & Dana Burnett
*L'Age d'Or - Luis Bunuel & Salvador Dali
*The Blood of a Poet - Jean Cocteau
*The Temporary Widow - Karl Hartl, Walter Reisch, & Benn Levy	Best Adapted Screenplay
*The Blue Angel - Carl Zuckmayer, Karl Vollmoeller, Josef von Sternberg
*All Quiet on the Western Front - Maxwell Anderson, George Abbott, Del Andrews
*Anna Christie - Frances Marion
*Leathernecking - Alfred Jackson & Jane Murfin
*The Cat Creeps - Gladys Lehman
Best Cinematography
*All Quiet on the Western Front - Arthur Edeson
*Anna Christie - William H. Daniels
*Nerone - Carlo Montuori
*The Blue Angel - Gunther Rittau
*The Blood of a Poet - Georges Perinal	Best Production Design
*All Quiet on the Western Front - Charles D. Hall & William R. Schmidt
*Anna Christie - Cedric Gibbons
*The Big House - Cedric Gibbons
*The Blue Angel - Otto Hunte
*The Rogue Song - Cedric Gibbons
==Multiple nominations and awards==
The following films received multiple nominations:
Nominations	Film
6 	Anna Christie
6 	The Big House
5 	All Quiet on the Western Front
3 	The Blue Angel
3 	The Blood of a Poet
3 	The Rogue Song
2 	Hell's Angels
The following films received multiple awards:
Awards	Film
2 	The Big House
2 	All Quiet on the Western Front
==Narrative==
=== 1931 Best Picture Nominees ===
==== Winner: Hell's Angels ====
Produced by Howard Hughes
Hell's Angels is a groundbreaking action drama known for its spectacular aerial combat sequences and ambitious production. Directed and produced by Howard Hughes, the film set new standards in filmmaking with its innovative use of special effects and realistic depiction of World War I dogfights.
* Plot: The story follows two brothers, Roy and Monte Rutledge, who become pilots in the Royal Flying Corps during World War I. Their loyalty and bravery are tested amidst the chaos and carnage of war.
* Critics Say: Critics praise Hell's Angels for its technical brilliance and thrilling action scenes. Hughes's commitment to authenticity and his daring vision have made the film a cinematic landmark.
* Impact: Winning Best Picture cements Hell's Angels as a significant achievement in film history, showcasing Hughes’s talent and ambition. The film's success highlights the potential of action cinema to combine spectacle with emotional storytelling.
==== All Quiet on the Western Front ====
Produced by Carl Laemmle Jr.
All Quiet on the Western Front is a poignant anti-war drama based on Erich Maria Remarque’s novel. Directed by Lewis Milestone, the film offers a harrowing depiction of World War I from the perspective of young German soldiers.
* Plot: The film follows Paul Bäumer, a young German soldier who experiences the brutal realities of trench warfare. The story explores themes of camaraderie, disillusionment, and the devastating impact of war on a generation.
* Critics Say: All Quiet on the Western Front is acclaimed for its unflinching portrayal of war’s horrors and its humanizing depiction of soldiers on the front lines. Critics commend Milestone’s direction and the film’s powerful narrative.
* Impact: This nomination highlights the film’s significance in the anti-war genre. Its emotional depth and realistic portrayal of war continue to resonate with audiences, solidifying its place as a classic in cinematic history.
==== Anna Christie ====
Produced by Clarence Brown, Paul Bern, and Irving Thalberg
Anna Christie is a dramatic adaptation of Eugene O’Neill’s play, directed by Clarence Brown and produced by Paul Bern and Irving Thalberg. The film stars Greta Garbo in a performance that earned her a Best Actress nomination.
* Plot: The story centers on Anna Christie, a woman with a troubled past who seeks reconciliation with her estranged father. As she struggles with her inner demons and societal judgments, Anna’s journey becomes one of redemption and self-discovery.
* Critics Say: Critics praise Anna Christie for its compelling narrative and Garbo’s standout performance. The film’s emotional intensity and strong character development are highlighted as key strengths.
* Impact: This nomination underscores the film’s impact as a powerful drama. The collaboration between Brown, Bern, and Thalberg, along with Garbo’s performance, contributes to its critical success. This marks one of Thalberg's multiple nominations this year, emphasizing his influence and significance in Hollywood, despite not securing a win.
==== The Big House ====
Produced by Irving G. Thalberg
The Big House is a gripping prison drama directed by George W. Hill, showcasing the harsh realities of life behind bars. Produced by the prolific Irving G. Thalberg, the film is notable for its realistic depiction of the prison system and its complex characters.
* Plot: The story follows three inmates, each with distinct personalities and motivations, as they navigate the brutal and dehumanizing environment of a maximum-security prison. Their lives intersect in a dramatic and violent climax.
* Critics Say: The Big House is praised for its intense narrative and strong performances, particularly by Wallace Beery. Critics highlight Hill’s direction and the film’s unflinching look at prison life.
* Impact: This nomination further establishes Thalberg’s reputation as a producer of significant and influential films. Despite his multiple nominations this year, Thalberg goes home empty-handed, creating a sense of anticipation and acknowledgment that he is long overdue for an Oscar win. His continued work showcases his dedication to bringing powerful stories to the screen.
==== The Rogue Song ====
Produced by Lionel Barrymore and Hal Roach
The Rogue Song is a musical adventure directed by Lionel Barrymore and produced by Hal Roach. The film features Lawrence Tibbett in a role that combines his operatic talents with dramatic acting.
* Plot: The story revolves around Yegor, a bandit leader who falls in love with a noblewoman. Their romance is set against the backdrop of dramatic and musical sequences, highlighting themes of love, revenge, and redemption.
* Critics Say: The Rogue Song is praised for its musical numbers and Tibbett’s powerful performance. Critics appreciate the film’s blend of drama and music, creating an engaging and entertaining experience.
* Impact: This nomination highlights the film’s unique contribution to the musical genre. Lionel Barrymore, known primarily as an actor, stepping into the role of director, brings a fresh perspective and is well-received by audiences and critics alike. Barrymore’s involvement adds a notable dimension to the film's production, marking a significant crossover in his career.
=== Summary ===
The 1931 Best Picture category at the Oscars showcases a competitive and diverse range of films. Hell's Angels’ win underscores its technical brilliance and Howard Hughes’s ambitious vision, setting a new standard in action cinema. All Quiet on the Western Front offers a powerful anti-war narrative, while Anna Christie and The Big House highlight Irving G. Thalberg's influential production skills, despite his multiple nominations leading to no wins this year, leaving him overdue for recognition. The Rogue Song stands out for its musical and dramatic blend, with Lionel Barrymore’s direction bringing an additional layer of interest. This year’s nominees reflect Hollywood’s evolving landscape, where innovative storytelling and production excellence are celebrated
=== 1931 Best Director Nominees ===
==== Winner: Jean Cocteau - The Blood of a Poet ====
Jean Cocteau (born July 5, 1889) is a French filmmaker, poet, and artist known for his avant-garde style and innovative approach to storytelling. At 42, Cocteau's direction of The Blood of a Poet has earned him the Best Director award, alongside a nomination for Best Original Screenplay.
* Film: The Blood of a Poet
* Directorial Style: Cocteau's film is a surreal exploration of the artistic process, blending reality and imagination in a series of dreamlike sequences. His innovative use of visual effects and non-linear narrative structure is groundbreaking.
* Critics Say: Critics praise Cocteau for his visionary approach and the film's poetic imagery. The Blood of a Poet is celebrated for pushing the boundaries of cinema and offering a unique, thought-provoking experience.
* Personal Life: Cocteau is a multi-talented artist with a significant influence in various artistic circles. His personal life, marked by close relationships with other prominent artists and a bohemian lifestyle, adds to his enigmatic persona.
* Implications of Winning: This win solidifies Cocteau's reputation as a trailblazer in cinema. His innovative techniques and artistic vision are likely to inspire future filmmakers, making him a key figure in the evolution of film as an art form.
==== Clarence Brown - Anna Christie ====
Clarence Brown (born May 10, 1890) is a seasoned director known for his ability to bring out powerful performances from his actors. At 41, Brown's direction of Anna Christie showcases his skill in adapting complex literary works to the screen.
* Film: Anna Christie
* Directorial Style: Brown’s direction is characterized by its emotional depth and strong character development. He effectively captures the gritty realism and psychological complexity of the story.
* Critics Say: Anna Christie is praised for its compelling narrative and Greta Garbo's standout performance. Critics highlight Brown’s ability to translate the raw emotion of the play into a visually engaging film.
* Personal Life: Brown's career has been marked by a series of successful collaborations with top actors. His professional relationships and keen directorial insight have established him as a respected figure in Hollywood.
* Future Prospects: This nomination reinforces Brown's status as a skilled director of dramatic adaptations. He is expected to continue delivering films that explore deep emotional and psychological themes, solidifying his legacy in the industry.
==== René Clair - Under the Roofs of Paris ====
René Clair (born November 11, 1898) is a French director known for his whimsical and innovative approach to filmmaking. At 32, Clair’s direction of Under the Roofs of Paris showcases his unique blend of romance and comedy.
* Film: Under the Roofs of Paris
* Directorial Style: Clair’s film is noted for its use of sound and music to enhance the narrative, a pioneering technique in early sound cinema. His charming and light-hearted storytelling style is both engaging and entertaining.
* Critics Say: Critics commend Under the Roofs of Paris for its lyrical quality and inventive use of sound. Clair’s direction is celebrated for creating a vibrant and enchanting portrayal of Parisian life.
* Personal Life: Clair's background in journalism and his early career in silent films have influenced his distinctive style. He remains a prominent figure in the French film industry, known for his creativity and innovation.
* Future Prospects: This nomination highlights Clair’s potential to further innovate in sound cinema. His ability to combine humor with technical ingenuity positions him as a leading figure in the evolving landscape of film.
==== George W. Hill - The Big House ====
George W. Hill (born April 25, 1894) is an American director known for his dynamic and hard-hitting films. At 36, Hill’s direction of The Big House has earned him critical acclaim and recognition.
* Film: The Big House
* Directorial Style: Hill’s direction is characterized by its realism and intensity. He effectively captures the harsh realities of prison life, using innovative camera techniques and strong character development.
* Critics Say: The Big House is praised for its gripping narrative and powerful performances. Critics highlight Hill’s ability to create a tense and immersive atmosphere, making the film a standout in the crime drama genre.
* Personal Life: Hill’s career in Hollywood has been marked by a series of successful and influential films. His dedication to portraying realistic and gritty stories has earned him a reputation as a master of the crime drama.
* Future Prospects: This nomination underscores Hill’s talent for directing intense and realistic dramas. His continued focus on hard-hitting narratives is likely to bring more critical success and solidify his standing in Hollywood.
==== Howard Hughes - Hell's Angels ====
Howard Hughes (born December 24, 1905) is a maverick filmmaker and businessman known for his ambitious and larger-than-life projects. At 25, Hughes’s direction of Hell's Angels marks a significant achievement in his burgeoning career.
* Film: Hell's Angels
* Directorial Style: Hughes’s film is noted for its spectacular aerial sequences and impressive special effects. His commitment to authenticity and scale in depicting World War I dogfights sets a new standard for action filmmaking.
* Critics Say: Hell's Angels is celebrated for its technical prowess and thrilling action scenes. Critics commend Hughes for his daring vision and the film’s groundbreaking aerial cinematography.
* Personal Life: Hughes is known for his flamboyant lifestyle and numerous business ventures. His passion for aviation and filmmaking has made him a prominent and sometimes controversial figure in Hollywood.
* Future Prospects: This nomination highlights Hughes’s potential to revolutionize the action genre. His willingness to take risks and push the boundaries of filmmaking suggests a future filled with ambitious and high-profile projects.
=== 1931 Best Actor Nominees ===
==== Winner: Wallace Beery - The Big House ====
Wallace Beery (born April 1, 1885) is an established actor known for his versatility and commanding screen presence. At 46, Beery's performance in The Big House has earned him his first Oscar win after a previous nomination in 1929.
* Role: Butch
* Character: Butch is a hardened and charismatic inmate who becomes a central figure in a prison uprising. His complex personality and moral code make him a captivating character.
* Performance: Critics praise Beery for his intense and layered portrayal of Butch. His ability to combine menace with a surprising depth of character makes his performance stand out.
* Personal Life: Beery has had a colorful personal life, including a well-publicized divorce from actress Gloria Swanson. Despite personal controversies, his professional career remains strong, and he continues to be a favorite among audiences.
* Implications of Winning: This win solidifies Beery’s status as one of Hollywood’s leading actors, likely leading to more significant and challenging roles in the future. His ability to bring depth to complex characters will continue to make him a sought-after talent in the industry.
==== Lew Ayres - All Quiet on the Western Front ====
Lew Ayres (born December 28, 1908) is a young and rising star in Hollywood, known for his naturalistic acting style. At 22, Ayres’s performance in All Quiet on the Western Front has garnered critical acclaim and a nomination for Best Actor.
* Role: Paul Bäumer
* Character: Paul Bäumer is a young German soldier whose idealistic views of war are shattered by the brutal realities of battle. His journey from naive enthusiasm to disillusionment is the emotional core of the film.
* Performance: Ayres’s portrayal of Paul is praised for its authenticity and emotional depth. Critics highlight his ability to convey the harrowing experiences of a soldier with sensitivity and realism.
* Personal Life: As one of Hollywood’s promising young actors, Ayres’s career is on an upward trajectory. His dedication to his craft and his impactful performances have made him a rising star.
* Future Prospects: This nomination positions Ayres as a significant talent in Hollywood. His ability to handle emotionally complex roles suggests a bright future with potential for more critical acclaim and prominent roles.
==== Robert Montgomery - The Big House ====
Robert Montgomery (born May 21, 1904) is a versatile actor known for his charm and on-screen charisma. At 27, Montgomery’s role in The Big House has earned him critical recognition.
* Role: Kent
* Character: Kent is a privileged young man who finds himself incarcerated and must navigate the harsh realities of prison life. His character’s growth and adaptation are central to the film’s narrative.
* Performance: Montgomery’s portrayal of Kent is noted for its emotional range and depth. Critics commend his ability to depict the character’s transformation from naivety to resilience.
* Personal Life: Montgomery’s career is marked by a series of successful roles, and he continues to build a reputation as a talented and reliable actor. His personal life remains relatively private, focusing on his professional endeavors.
* Future Prospects: This nomination highlights Montgomery’s growing prominence in Hollywood. His ability to portray diverse characters will likely lead to more significant roles and continued success.
==== William Powell - Street of Chance ====
William Powell (born July 29, 1892) is an experienced actor known for his sophisticated and debonair screen presence. At 39, Powell’s performance in Street of Chance showcases his versatility.
* Role: John Marsden
* Character: John Marsden is a man who becomes entangled in a web of deceit and danger, struggling to clear his name and protect his loved ones.
* Performance: Powell’s portrayal of Marsden is praised for its suave charm and intensity. Critics highlight his ability to bring a sense of elegance and tension to the role.
* Personal Life: Powell’s career has been marked by a steady rise to fame, with his performances consistently earning acclaim. His personal life, including a high-profile marriage to Carole Lombard, keeps him in the public eye.
* Future Prospects: This nomination reinforces Powell’s status as a leading man in Hollywood. His skill in handling complex and varied roles suggests continued success and critical recognition in his future projects.
==== Lawrence Tibbett - The Rogue Song ====
Lawrence Tibbett (born November 16, 1896) is an acclaimed opera singer and actor known for his powerful voice and strong screen presence. At 34, Tibbett’s performance in The Rogue Song marks his transition from stage to screen.
* Role: Yegor
* Character: Yegor is a bandit leader whose life is marked by passion, revenge, and redemption. His journey is both dramatic and poignant, set against a vibrant musical backdrop.
* Performance: Tibbett’s portrayal of Yegor is noted for its vocal prowess and emotional intensity. Critics commend his ability to seamlessly blend his operatic talents with his acting, creating a compelling character.
* Personal Life: Tibbett’s career in opera has been illustrious, and his transition to film has been well-received. His dedication to his craft and his ability to captivate audiences remain his defining characteristics.
* Future Prospects: This nomination highlights Tibbett’s versatility and potential in Hollywood. His success in The Rogue Song suggests a promising future in film, with opportunities to further showcase his unique talents.
=== 1931 Best Actress Nominees ===
==== Winner: Ann Harding - Holiday ====
Ann Harding (born August 7, 1901) is a talented actress known for her elegance and emotional depth. At 29, her performance in Holiday has earned her the Best Actress award, marking a significant milestone in her career.
* Role: Linda Seton
* Character: Linda Seton is a free-spirited woman who falls in love with a man engaged to her sister, challenging societal norms and familial expectations.
* Performance: Harding’s portrayal of Linda is praised for its warmth, intelligence, and emotional complexity. Critics highlight her ability to convey Linda’s inner conflicts and passions with grace and nuance.
* Personal Life: Harding has built a reputation for her dedication to her craft and her ability to bring depth to her characters. Her win is a testament to her hard work and talent.
* Implications of Winning: This victory solidifies Harding’s status as one of Hollywood’s leading actresses, likely leading to more prominent and challenging roles in the future.
==== Louise Brooks - Prix de beauté ====
Louise Brooks (born November 14, 1906) is known for her distinctive bob haircut and magnetic screen presence. At 24, Brooks receives her second nomination, building on her previous recognition for Beggars of Life.
* Role: Lucienne Garnier
* Character: Lucienne is a typist who enters a beauty contest, leading to fame and complicated personal choices.
* Performance: Brooks captivates with a performance that balances vulnerability and strength. Critics praise her naturalistic style and the emotional depth she brings to the character.
* Personal Life: Brooks continues to be an icon of 1920s liberation, known for her independent spirit and defiance of societal norms. Her career is on a steady rise, and this second nomination enhances her standing in Hollywood.
* Future Prospects: With two nominations, Brooks is positioning herself as a leading actress of her generation. Her unique screen presence and acting skills suggest a bright future with more significant roles and potential wins ahead.
==== Claudette Colbert - Manslaughter ====
Claudette Colbert (born September 13, 1903) is an emerging talent known for her versatility and charm. At 28, her performance in Manslaughter has earned her critical acclaim.
* Role: Lydia Thorne
* Character: Lydia Thorne is a wealthy socialite whose reckless behavior leads to tragic consequences, forcing her to confront her own moral failings.
* Performance: Colbert’s portrayal is lauded for its emotional intensity and complexity. Critics commend her ability to navigate the character’s transformation from frivolity to self-awareness.
* Personal Life: Colbert’s career is gaining momentum, with her talent for both dramatic and comedic roles becoming increasingly recognized.
* Future Prospects: This nomination positions Colbert as a versatile actress capable of handling a wide range of characters. Her future in Hollywood looks promising, with opportunities for both critical and commercial success.
==== Joan Crawford - Paid ====
Joan Crawford (born March 23, 1904) is a popular actress known for her dynamic performances and strong screen presence. At 27, Crawford’s role in Paid adds another notable performance to her growing list of achievements.
* Role: Mary Turner
* Character: Mary Turner is a wronged woman who seeks revenge against those who falsely imprisoned her, navigating a path of justice and redemption.
* Performance: Crawford’s portrayal is powerful and compelling, with critics highlighting her ability to convey Mary’s determination and vulnerability.
* Personal Life: Crawford’s rise to fame has been marked by hard work and a series of successful roles. She remains a prominent figure in Hollywood, known for her tenacity and dedication to her craft.
* Future Prospects: This nomination solidifies Crawford’s status as a leading actress. Her ability to take on complex roles suggests a continued trajectory of success and critical recognition.
==== Greta Garbo - Anna Christie ====
Greta Garbo (born September 18, 1905) receives her second nomination, continuing to captivate audiences with her enigmatic presence and remarkable talent. At 26, her performance in Anna Christie further establishes her as a leading actress.
* Role: Anna Christie
* Character: Anna Christie is a woman with a troubled past who seeks reconciliation with her estranged father while grappling with her own inner demons.
* Performance: Garbo’s portrayal is both powerful and subtle, capturing the character’s struggles and resilience. Critics highlight her ability to convey deep emotions with minimal dialogue, relying on her expressive face and presence.
* Personal Life: Known for her reclusive nature, Garbo maintains an air of mystery that only adds to her allure. Her focus on her craft and avoidance of Hollywood’s social scene make her a unique and respected figure.
* Future Prospects: This second nomination reinforces Garbo’s status as one of Hollywood’s most talented actresses. Building a case for a future win, she continues to choose diverse and challenging roles, keeping audiences and directors intrigued by her next moves.
==== Notable Snub ====
While Ann Harding's win for Holiday is well-deserved, some critics and fans feel that Greta Garbo's performance in Anna Christie was equally deserving of the Best Actress award. Garbo's ability to convey deep emotions with such subtlety and minimal dialogue has left a lasting impression, and many believe she is building a strong case for a future Oscar win.
==Gallery==
File:M01179-Photograph-of-Jean-Cocteau.jpg|Jean Cocteau, Best Director winner
File:Screen Shot 2014-01-09 at 8.07.32 PM.jpg|Wallace Beery, Best Actor winner
File:MV5BZTMwZTUyNjQtZTkyZS00YjI4LWI2ZmMtZWQzNTM2NDVkMmY2XkEyXkFqcGdeQXVyMTcyODY2NDQ@. V1 .jpg|Ann Harding, Best Actress winner
**