The Doctor's trial (The War Games)

In the Doctor's first trial involving the Time Lords, he was charged with breaching the non-interference policy and tried by a court of Time Lords. (TV: The War Games) The Book of the War claimed that the name of Audience of the Ruling Houses applied to "any session in which the ruling Houses passed judgement over those in breach of the Protocols". (PROSE: The Book of the War)
According to one account, the trial was dubbed in the official court records as "Malfeasance Tribunal 309906". (PROSE: A Brief History of Time Lords) According to other accounts, it was its verdict which constituted "Malfeasance Tribunal order 30906", (PROSE: Doctor Who and the Genesis of the Daleks) or indeed "Malfeasance Tribunal order dated 309906", with the number being a date rather than a reference number. (TV: The Deadly Assassin)
== History ==
=== A day to come ===
Not yet realising that he was a future incarnation, the First Doctor reasoned that the Twelfth Doctor was a Time Lord when he observed that he was mid-regeneration, asking if he had come to take "the ship" back, much to the future Doctor's amusement. (TV: Twice Upon a Time)
Acting on behalf of the Celestial Intervention Agency during the First Omega Crisis, Goth masqueraded as the fictional character Lemuel Gulliver in the Land of Fiction to monitor the Second Doctor. When the Doctor recognised him and feared he would be taken to Gallifrey for trial, Goth told the Doctor that "that time is long in your future and long in our past." (PROSE: Future Imperfect)
=== Origins ===
Prior to the trial, the Doctor had been hiding from the Time Lords due to violating their laws. By one account, he was put on trial solely for the charge of breaking the non-interference policy. (TV: The War Games) Other accounts indicated he had two charges, but that the second, stealing a TARDIS, was incredibly minor compared to the first. (PROSE: The Trial of Doctor Who, Doctor Who and the War Games) A third account indicated his charge was breaking the First Law of Time by meeting the Sixth Doctor while on a mission from the Celestial Intervention Agency, and that he'd only been hiding from the Time Lords since then. (PROSE: The Legacy of Gallifrey)
Judging the return of the participants in the War Games too tough a task, the Second Doctor decided to send a hypercube containing all the relevant information to the Time Lords so that they could help with the matter, although the War Chief quite forcibly advised against it. (TV: The War Games) In the timeline as it stood after Rassilon used an amnesiac Eighth Doctor to make "one or two small improvements in the patterns of history", the Second Doctor was aided in this decision by the Eighth Doctor, who suggested a defence speech to his past self which the Second Doctor would recite nearly word-for-word in the trial. (PROSE: The Eight Doctors, World Game) Authorities from Gallifrey were dispatched to the planet, including no lesser Time Lords than the Keeper (PROSE: Doctor Who and the Doomsday Weapon) and three members of the High Council, (PROSE: The Three Doctors, The Legacy of Gallifrey) one of them being Goth, (PROSE: The Legacy of Gallifrey) who was also an agent of the Celestial Intervention Agency, (PROSE: Future Imperfect) yet unknown to the Presidency. (PROSE: The Legacy of Gallifrey)
The Doctor briefly attempted to evade the Time Lords but they took control of the TARDIS and landed it on Gallifrey. The Doctor, Jamie and Zoe witnessed the War Lord being sentenced before Jamie and Zoe were placed in a force field and the Doctor was escorted to his own trial. (TV: The War Games)
=== The recorded trial ===
The court accused the Doctor of breaking their laws of non-interference. The Doctor admitted the crime and reiterated his pride in doing so, rather than merely observing the evil in the universe. He then asked for a Thought Channel to show the evil he fought. He showed the Time Lords the Quarks and the Yeti. When they seemed unimpressed he showed them the Ice Warriors, the Cybermen and the Daleks. He ended by saying that he may be guilty of interference, but they were guilty of passivity against such evil. With the trial over, the Time Lords considered the charges whilst the Doctor played cards.
Allowed to bid farewell to Jamie and Zoe they convince him to try and escape but they are intercepted by a group of Time Lords. The Doctor says goodbye to both of them before they are returned to their own times with their memories wiped of all but their first encounter with the Doctor. The Doctor watched on a screen as Zoe is returned to the Wheel and Jamie fights a Redcoat.
The Time Lords then delivered their verdict; they accepted that there was evil in the universe that must be fought and the Doctor had a part to play. They noted his affinity to Earth and told him he would be exiled there as well as forced to regenerate. The Time Lords gave the Doctor several choices for his new body but he declined all of them. He then lost his speech and began to swirl into nothingness. (TV: The War Games)
=== The trial's secret facets ===
Another matter raised during the Doctor's trial was the 1986 Cyberman invasion of Earth. It was a temporal anomaly, not part of the orthodox Time Lord vision of Earth's history — and the Doctor's presence on Earth at the time, in his previous incarnation, led to the speculation that he had somehow bent the planet's time-stream out of shape himself, permitting the invasion. Less harshly, it was suggested by the prosecution that the Doctor may have accidentally "ripped" the Earth's time stream in the 20th century by operating his TARDIS there too often. The Doctor convinced the prosecution that this line of argument was misguided by pointing out that if excessive TARDIS activity really had deleterious effects on a nexus world's time-field, Gallifrey itself would long have been "a smoking hole in space". (PROSE: The Cyber Files) Elsewhere, however, the Accord were aware that Earth's timeline was damaged by the TARDIS as a result of its unique faults. (PROSE: The Enfolded Time)
Before the Doctor's sentence could be carried out, the Celestial Intervention Agency intervened and turned him into their "hired gun". (PROSE: World Game) He worked in this capacity for some time, (TV: The Two Doctors et al.) although he was unaware of the true extent of this. Knowing the Doctor was liable to becoming impatient and feeling exploited, the Time Lords took to wiping his memory after each mission. The result was that the Doctor believed every mission to be his first and readily accepted them, led as he was to believe each time that success would grant him his release. (PROSE: Save Yourself) However, when the CIA needed to cover up his visit to Space Station Camera, it was decided that his exile should be enforced. (PROSE: A Brief History of Time Lords) Before he could be forced to regenerate, the Doctor finally succeeded in escaping. He settled down on Earth in hiding, though lived there in luxury for some time, before falling into a trap and finally regenerating into his third incarnation. (COMIC: The Night Walkers)
=== Legacy ===
Because the Time Lords knew little about the human mind, both Jamie (COMIC: The World Shapers) and Zoe were able to regain some of their memories of travelling with the Doctor. (AUDIO: Echoes of Grey) Additionally, after the Doctor had saved the Time Lords from certain doom they lifted his exile and restored his knowledge of the TARDIS. (TV: The Three Doctors) On the day of Pandad IV's assassination, Spandrell and Engin consulted the Doctor's entry in the APC Net, learning of this trial. (TV: The Deadly Assassin) This trial was referenced during the Sixth Doctor's trial for meddling, in which the sentence was deemed by the prosecutor to be too lenient. (TV: The Mysterious Planet)
It was during the trial that the Doctor first directed the Time Lords' attention towards the Daleks. (TV: The War Games) The Time Lords monitored the Daleks' continued activities and partially came around to the Doctor's way of thinking, viewing them as a potentially serious threat. (AUDIO: The Dalek Conquests) Eventually, they summoned the Fourth Doctor to Skaro to avert the creation of the Daleks. (TV: Genesis of the Daleks) The failure of this mission eventually prompted the Daleks to retaliate, resulting in mounting aggression which led, in the longer term, to the Last Great Time War. (PROSE: A Brief History of Time Lords, The Slyther of Shoreditch, Engines of War, et al.)
The trial was mentioned by the Fifteenth Doctor as one many memories which weighed on the Fourteenth Doctor when convincing him to go into rehabilitation on Earth. (TV: The Giggle)
== Other realities ==
In a parallel universe, the Second Doctor chose one of the faces offered to him and became a brutal dictator on Earth. (PROSE: Timewyrm: Revelation)
In one universe, the Second Doctor succeeded in escaping from the trial, regenerating into a female incarnation to hide on Earth. When the Doctor was eventually found, the Time Lords skipped the trial and proceeded straight to the sentencing. (AUDIO: Exile)
In the Unbound Universe, the Second Doctor was put on trail for violating the non-interference policy, being made to regenerate into a new body as punishment and was exiled to Earth. Though the Doctor, as in N-Space, was meant to arrive in 1970s England, he instead arrived in Hong Kong in the year 1997. (AUDIO: Sympathy for the Devil)
== Behind the scenes ==
The concept of a Season 6B set between The War Games and Spearhead from Space was a long held fan theory and established as narrative fact by TV Comic.
The four faces proposed to the Doctor for his change of appearance were drawn by the story's designer Roger Cheveley. The script of the episode confirms, as the episode's dialogue indicates, that five faces are proposed to him. The one deemed "too young" by the Doctor is not shown. None of the faces shown resemble the actual Third Doctor, as Jon Pertwee was not cast in the role until production of this serial had concluded.
A Kroton was originally going to be one of the foes the Doctor brought up on the projection screen in the courtroom, and a copyright payment made to Robert Holmes. However, neither of the two Kroton costumes was in usable condition, according to the DVD Production Information subtitles.
In the fan film, Devious, the Doctor was extracted by the CIA halfway through his regeneration creating the "Second-and-a-Halfth Doctor" played by Tony Garner. He went on several adventures before completing his regeneration.
Category:Trials in which the Doctor was the defendant
Category:Time Lord history
Category:Events involving the Second Doctor