Jurisprudence: on the usage of dubious research for research and development

== Parties ==
The following is a suit of the city of Seiz against PICS Inc. (Putzer Industrial Chemical Solutions)
 
== Case ==
The city of Seyiz refutes PICS Inc.’s usage of the Unscented Perfumers research into olfactory technologies and techniques. 
They were illegally obtained without the consent or knowledge of the city’s officials
Unlawful usage of dubious research
Breach of several case documents relative to the case of the Unscented Perfumer
 
== Facts ==
PICS Inc., by using city documents classified by the officials have illegally accessed confidential data. As proof of claims, the city of Seyiz has shown the reports of PICS Inc. Staff breaking into city records and pillaging all documentation relative to the Unscented Perfumer case. 
PICS Inc. had for several years petitioned for further access into the case but was repeatedly refused on the grounds that the files were nonexistent, and that the cases were a fabrication, more akin to local folklore and exaggeration. 
 
== Arguments ==
- Assault
The city of Seyiz defends the position that pICS Inc. deliberately organized a raid on city records in order for PICS Inc. Staff to access documents not available for public view. 
- Defense
PICS Inc. denies the assault ever took place, or the presence of Staff during the raid on city records.
- Assault
The city of Seyiz defends the position that over a hundred of the perfumes recently developed by PICS Inc. were directly issued from the case files of the Unscented Perfumer
- Defense
PICS Inc defends the position that the research behind the development of these perfumes were from research and development into Unscented individuals, but was unwilling to show proof of claims.
- Assault
The city of Seyiz defends the position that PICS Inc.’s denial is proof of unlawful usage of dubious research. 
 
== Legal elements ==
=== Definition of illegal obtention of scientific documentation ===
Illegal obtention of scientific documentation is defined by a party gaining access to scientific or research productions from a laboratory or associated source without consent or knowledge of its proprietor.
=== Definition of unlawful usage of dubious research ===
Unlawful usage of dubious research is defined by the usage of production documents without reviewing the research through the proper peer reviewing channels. As such any and all research is considered dubious until peer reviewed by a scientific committee.
=== Definition of breach of legal cases or investigations ===
Breach of legal cases or investigations is defined by a party gaining access to legal cases or investigations through illegal means.
=== Relation of breach of legal cases or investigations with illegal obtention of scientific documentation ===
Since the assault of PICS Inc. in the city of Seyiz’s city records can be proved to be the source of the scientific documentation, the illegality can be ascertained, however, since the city was not the proprietor of the documents, and these were not directly linked to the case, in this case the Unscented Perfumers case, the qualification of illegal obtention of scientific documentation has been revoked. 
However, the qualification of the crime as breach of legal cases or investigations has been noted and maintained. 
=== Relation of illegal obtention of scientific documentation with unlawful usage of dubious research ===
Since the 112 formulas of perfume developed and launched by PICS Inc. can be traced to research documents found in the files of the Unscented Perfumer case following an investigation into PICS Inc. production sites, the qualification of unlawful usage of dubious research is approved. 
 
== Solution ==
Based on these elements, unlawful usage of dubious research is proven according to criteria mentioned above and is to be set in practise for cases concerning research and development. 
 
== Answer ==
All PICS Inc. research and development following on the advancements made by scientific documentation found in the Unscented Perfumer case files must go through scientific clearance and made public once clearance has been reached. 
 
== Similar Cases ==
None
 
== Legal sources ==
 
=== Codes ===
Code of commerce
Code of scientific inventions, research and development
Imperial code of redistribution
 
=== Jurisprudence ===
On the qualification of scientific research
 
=== Subsequent Cases ===
On the hiding of the Unscented Perfumer case by the city of Seyiz
 
== Annexes ==
 
=== Annex 1: The Unscented Perfumer Case ===
A pattern of murders whose killers are attracted to the scent of cut open bodies. 
Murders occur wildly in the city of Seiz, in the Elected KIngdom of Grom purportedly on those without a scent, a psychosis around using perfume as protection arises.
A suspect of the murders is apprehended. The suspect is apparently released due to “an entrancing perfume”.
The town briefly falls under the control of the perfume maker, where orgies and bouts of cannibalism take place. 
Eventually the source of the scent is eaten alive, the perfumer works on the aspect of smell are developed into several useful techniques.
Evidence of the Unscented Perfumers works on olfactory technologies are found in his previous lodgings as well as in a cave where he operated seemingly for years on the surface. 
 
=== Annex 2: Developments subsequent to the discovery of the unscented and its research ===
The term unscented is coined, which refers to beings lacking a smell, usually with an affinity for certain scents. 
The twelve scent harmony theorem is proved, the theory of the thirteenth scent begins
Hundreds of perfume formulas enter the market
The practice of distilling bodies for the open body scent is discovered. The practice of hot and cold enfleurage is later discovered for the same purpose.
A method of recognizing bad vegetables by smell is developed 
A method of recognizing people and other living beings over long distances is developed
A method of navigating through smell of nearby objects is developed
== Notes ==
The case was previously known as the Unscented murders case until being unscented was recognized as a condition, where it was reclassified as the perfumer cases, but after backlash from perfumers was left as the current title.
Category:Jurisprudence
Category:Research