Paula Deen Ain't Got Nothing On Me

A local Creator is brewing up something strong, but to finish his project he needs a list of rare materials acquired for him. To quicken his plans he seeks out the help of the player's Squad whom he hopes will track down these important items. 
The items should be decently hard to get. For extra flavor you could make them supernatural and fantastic in nature: vampire blood, bark of a red oak, rooster's teeth, mermaid scales, black oil, the antlers of a jackalope, etc.