Who Killed Lividmanda? Part Four

Over a year ago, a very special 4(?) hour Survivor Roleplay occurred in the IRC. Ovivor: All-Stars, hosted by OHF, took 14 of the most memorable characters to grace the first four seasons of the Ovivor franchise.
The cast along with the users who played them and their placement in All-Stars is posted below.
But, if you look beyond the users, a huge controversy erupted after the live reunion show and has just now surfaced.
And beneath the cast is the continuation of a gripping saga that will have you asking Who Killed Lividmanda? 
==The Cast of Ovivor: All-Stars==
Contestant 	Original Tribe	Merged Tribe	Finish
Gandhi HitlerThebiggestdtifan 	Estrela 	 	1st Voted OutDay 3
Topaz BradyReddude 	Vinganca 	 	2nd Voted OutDay 6
Milk DairyEnTrey 	Vinganca 	 	3rd Voted OutDay 9
Nissim OurfaliToadgamer80 	Estrela 	 	4th Voted OutDay 12
Soo HokBrunoSomebody 	Vinganca 	 	QuitDay 15
Isabel De SouzaManatee12 	Estrela 	Eviloneklop 	5th Voted Out1st Jury MemberDay 18
CaptainFreedomAvery FireFlame 	Estrela 	Eviloneklop 	6th Voted Out2nd Jury MemberDay 21
Morpheus David1dra7 	Vinganca 	Eviloneklop 	7th Voted Out3rd Jury MemberDay 24
Jack FoireThat Epic 	Estrela 	Eviloneklop 	8th Voted Out4th Jury MemberDay 27
Lividmanda KimmelThe real toad's sister	Estrela 	Eviloneklop 	9th Voted Out5th Jury MemberDay 30
Tanner SmithJake R 	Vinganca 	Eviloneklop 	10th Voted Out6th Jury MemberDay 33
Ishiguro KyotoJaxswim 	Estrela 	Eviloneklop 	11th Voted Out7th Jury MemberDay 36
Eliza NewOrlinsToadgamer80 	Vinganca 	Eviloneklop 	Runner-UpDay 39
Judd SergeantCOKEMAN11 	Vinganca 	Eviloneklop 	Sole SurvivorDay 39
==Day Four of the Investigation==
===New Findings===
*The safe is still locked.
*The Smith-De Souza household is being searched for a possible wedding ring to validate Isabel's claim. 
*The fingerprints on the fake idol are revealed to be Captain Freedom's.
*Analysis shows that Captain Freedom and Lividmanda were hurt with the same knife.
===Suspect Interrogation===
*Isabel de Souza - Due to too few leads, Isabel was not questioned and will not be questioned until her house is searched for the wedding ring.
*Tanner Smith - Mr. Smith is asked why he attempted to contact Ishiguro. Mr. Smith claims that it was because Mr. Kyoto owed him twenty dollars after buying him lunch. The investigation team is suspicious of Mr. Smith for now, but asked no further questions today.
*Captain Freedom - After being asked why he was in the room with Lividmanda, Captain Freedom answered that he was delivering Topaz's fake idol to Lividmanda, who planned to sell it for money. After the scar on Mr. Freedom's shoulder was identified as the same type of wound that Lividmanda sustained, Mr. Freedom is no longer a suspect. However, he is guilty by association for helping Lividmanda steal Ms. Brady's idol and will face minor charges.
===Day 4 Interviews===
*Eliza NewOrlins - Eliza returned to the police station once again after remembering more about the fateful night. She said that she briefly talked to Tanner at the reunion, but during that conversation, he received a call from Ishiguro.
*Topaz Brady - Ms. Brady came back to the police station after hearing that they found out who took her idol. After learning that it was Captain Freedom who possessed it, Ms. Brady claims that she never did like Mr. Freedom very much, though she never showed any animosity towards him.
*Ishiguro Kyoto - After the Eliza interview, Mr. Kyoto was asked what he and Tanner talked about. Mr. Kyoto denies having called or received any calls from Tanner that night; after reviewing his phone records, the investigation did see that there were five calls from Mr. Smith, but only one was picked up. Mr. Kyoto did not appear drunk during the reunion show, either; Ishiguro is now a primary suspect.
==Questions==
i'll write these later