Program: 52812
Project: 52812
Buggy source:
/** 
 * A lot of this code is based on: git4idea.cherrypick.GitCherryPicker#cherryPick() (which is private)
 */
private static boolean cherryPick(@NotNull GitRepository repository,@NotNull GitCommit commit,@NotNull Git git,@NotNull GitPlatformFacade platformFacade,@NotNull Project project){
  GitSimpleEventDetector conflictDetector=new GitSimpleEventDetector(CHERRY_PICK_CONFLICT);
  GitSimpleEventDetector localChangesOverwrittenDetector=new GitSimpleEventDetector(LOCAL_CHANGES_OVERWRITTEN_BY_CHERRY_PICK);
  GitUntrackedFilesOverwrittenByOperationDetector untrackedFilesDetector=new GitUntrackedFilesOverwrittenByOperationDetector(repository.getRoot());
  GitCommandResult result=git.cherryPick(repository,commit.getHash().asString(),false,conflictDetector,localChangesOverwrittenDetector,untrackedFilesDetector);
  if (result.success()) {
    return true;
  }
 else   if (conflictDetector.hasHappened()) {
    return new CherryPickConflictResolver(project,git,platformFacade,repository.getRoot(),commit.getHash().asString(),commit.getAuthorName(),commit.getSubject()).merge();
  }
 else   if (untrackedFilesDetector.wasMessageDetected()) {
    String description="String_Node_Str" + "String_Node_Str";
    UntrackedFilesNotifier.notifyUntrackedFilesOverwrittenBy(project,platformFacade,untrackedFilesDetector.getFiles(),"String_Node_Str",description);
    return false;
  }
 else   if (localChangesOverwrittenDetector.hasHappened()) {
    GerritUtil.notifyError(project,"String_Node_Str","String_Node_Str");
    return false;
  }
 else {
    GerritUtil.notifyError(project,"String_Node_Str",result.getErrorOutputAsHtmlString());
    return false;
  }
}

Fixed version (ground truth):
/** 
 * A lot of this code is based on: git4idea.cherrypick.GitCherryPicker#cherryPick() (which is private)
 */
private static boolean cherryPick(@NotNull GitRepository repository,@NotNull GitHeavyCommit commit,@NotNull Git git,@NotNull GitPlatformFacade platformFacade,@NotNull Project project){
  GitSimpleEventDetector conflictDetector=new GitSimpleEventDetector(CHERRY_PICK_CONFLICT);
  GitSimpleEventDetector localChangesOverwrittenDetector=new GitSimpleEventDetector(LOCAL_CHANGES_OVERWRITTEN_BY_CHERRY_PICK);
  GitUntrackedFilesOverwrittenByOperationDetector untrackedFilesDetector=new GitUntrackedFilesOverwrittenByOperationDetector(repository.getRoot());
  GitCommandResult result=git.cherryPick(repository,commit.getHash().getValue(),false,conflictDetector,localChangesOverwrittenDetector,untrackedFilesDetector);
  if (result.success()) {
    return true;
  }
 else   if (conflictDetector.hasHappened()) {
    return new CherryPickConflictResolver(project,git,platformFacade,repository.getRoot(),commit.getShortHash().getString(),commit.getAuthor(),commit.getSubject()).merge();
  }
 else   if (untrackedFilesDetector.wasMessageDetected()) {
    String description="String_Node_Str" + "String_Node_Str";
    UntrackedFilesNotifier.notifyUntrackedFilesOverwrittenBy(project,platformFacade,untrackedFilesDetector.getFiles(),"String_Node_Str",description);
    return false;
  }
 else   if (localChangesOverwrittenDetector.hasHappened()) {
    GerritUtil.notifyError(project,"String_Node_Str","String_Node_Str");
    return false;
  }
 else {
    GerritUtil.notifyError(project,"String_Node_Str",result.getErrorOutputAsHtmlString());
    return false;
  }
}