black surface under layers of cardboard
strewn colored and swirled candles
upside down metal bottle cap
used knife lying on side
icing smeared on blade
curved edge of cardboard
thin layer of hard foam with stains, icing and crumbs
small piece of cake with swirled icing
remaining rectangle of cake with icing, a letter, and orange semicircle
filling of yellow cake, cream and jelly
scattered birthday candles on table
multi colored birthday candles
large knife covered in cake
screw on wine cap
colored sprinkles on cake
white frosting decoration on cake
cake with white filling
orange icing balloon decoration
upside down screw on wine cap
brown handled long knife
Cake on the tray.
Knife on the tray.
White frosting on serving board.
Cap on the tray.
Candles on the table.
White cardboard serving tray.
Orange frosting on the cake.
wine glass on the table.
White flavored cake on the tray.
the candle is blue
the candle is pink
the candle is white
the knife has icing on it
the icing is purple
the icing is red
the lid is upside down
the icing is decorative
the cake has stars on it
knife with black handle
piece of cut cake
candles sitting on table
white cake with white icing
icing left on cake holder
bottle cap sitting on cake holder
white cake holder
wine glass sitting on table
knife coveres in cake
purple letter on white cake

Objects:
cardboard
cap
cake
icing
letter
rectangle
semicircle
candle
candle
candle
candle
candle
table
knife
cake
sprinkles
cake
white frosting
knife
handle
cap
tray
candles
table
frosting
tray
candle
icing
icing
knife
cake
candle
candle
candle
candle
candle
cake
icing
cake holder
cake
glass
cake

Attributes:
name: cardboard
attrs: black
name: cap
attrs: metal
name: cake
attrs: flavored
white
cut
name: icing
attrs: decorative
purple
name: letter
name: rectangle
attrs: remaining
name: semicircle
attrs: orange
name: candle
attrs: birthday
white
scattered
sitting
name: table
name: knife
attrs: handled
brown
large
long
name: sprinkles
attrs: colored
name: white frosting
attrs: white
name: handle
name: tray
name: candles
name: frosting
attrs: orange
name: cake holder
attrs: cake
name: glass
attrs: sitting
wine

Contrastive attributes: