black handle on a silver knife
silver metal blade of a knife
half of a small chocolate cake
cake and knife on a white plate
white candle in a metal holder
gold metal candle holder
black plastic pepper shaker
glass container next to cake plate
half of a cake next to a knife
small shadow cast by knife handle
a plate on the table
the plate is white
the plate is square
the cake is cut in half
the cake is brown
the cake is chocolate
the knife handle is black
the ball is gold
the candle is white
a shadow on the table
silver end of knife
black handle on knife
silver and black knife
small piece of cake
piece of cake on plate
piece of bread on plate
brown cake on plate
crumbs from cake on plate
black top to bottle
small golden candle holder
piece of cake or steak
steak knife sitting on plate
candle on counter top
steak knife and cake
cut piece of cake
granite table counter top
brown piece of cake
chocolate cake and knife
plate under knife and cake
candle sticking into onion
tip of black handle knife
middle of black handle knife
end of black handle knife
top of black table
middle of chocolate cake
left end of chocolate cake
right end of chocolate cake
cake crumbs on sheet paper
brown board cake is on
half eaten chocolate cake

Objects:
knife
handle
knife
cake
plate
plate
bread
cake
plate
crumb
crumb
crumb
crumb
crumb
cake
bottle top
candle holder
cake piece
candle
counter
knife
cake
table
knife
plate
candle
onion
handle
table
cake
cake crumbs
sheet paper
board
cake

Attributes:
name: knife
attrs: end
handle
silver
black
middle
steak
name: handle
attrs: black
name: cake
attrs: cut
chocolate
piece
half eaten
brown
name: plate
name: bread
attrs: piece
name: crumb
name: bottle top
attrs: top
black
name: candle holder
attrs: candle
small
golden
name: cake piece
attrs: piece
name: candle
name: counter
attrs: top
name: table
attrs: top
granite
black
name: onion
name: cake crumbs
name: sheet paper
name: board
attrs: brown

Contrastive attributes:
attr1: black
attr2: silver
nouns: knife