Case: case_481

Atomic Facts:
[{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicant was born in 1951.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicant lives in Vienna.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "On 30 October 1998, the applicant notified the Salzburg Federal Police Authority (Bundespolizeidirektion) under section 2 of the Assembly Act (Versammlungsgesetz) of a planned meeting.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicant is a member of parliament for the Green Party.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The applicant notified the Salzburg Federal Police Authority that on All Saints' Day, 1 November 1998, from 9 a.m. until 1 p.m., he would be holding a meeting at the Salzburg municipal cemetery in front of the war memorial.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The applicant noted that the planned meeting would coincide with the gathering of Comradeship IV (Kameradschaft IV).", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The applicant considered the gathering of Comradeship IV (Kameradschaft IV) to be unlawful.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The purpose of the applicant's planned meeting was to commemorate the Salzburg Jews killed by the SS during the Second World War.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The applicant expected about six participants at the planned meeting.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The participants of the applicant's planned meeting would carry commemorative messages in their hands and attached to their clothes.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The applicant stated that no other means of expression, such as chanting or banners, which might offend piety or undermine public order would be used at the planned meeting.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "On 31 October 1998, the Salzburg Federal Police Authority prohibited the applicant's planned meeting.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The Salzburg Federal Police Authority relied on section 6 of the Assembly Act (Versammlungsgesetz) when prohibiting the applicant's planned meeting.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "The Salzburg Federal Police Authority relied on Article 11 of the Convention when prohibiting the applicant's planned meeting.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "The Salzburg Federal Police Authority prohibited the applicant's planned meeting on the ground that it would endanger public order and security.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "F.E. is also a member of parliament for the Green Party.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "F.E. had informed the Salzburg Federal Police Authority of the allegedly illegal assembly of Comradeship IV (Kameradschaft IV) in memory of the SS soldiers killed in the Second World War.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "The assembly of Comradeship IV (Kameradschaft IV) was to be held at the same time and place as the applicant's planned meeting, namely on 1 November 1998 at the Salzburg municipal cemetery in front of the war memorial.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "F.E. refused to give an undertaking that the proposed meeting in memory of the murdered Salzburg Jews would not disrupt the Comradeship IV (Kameradschaft IV) gathering.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "The Salzburg Federal Police Authority noted that Comradeship IV (Kameradschaft IV) was a registered association.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "Comradeship IV (Kameradschaft IV), like a number of other organisations, traditionally held a commemoration ceremony at the Salzburg municipal cemetery on All Saints' Day.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "The Salzburg Federal Police Authority noted that such commemorations by Comradeship IV (Kameradschaft IV) qualified as popular ceremonies within the meaning of section 5 of the Assembly Act (Versammlungsgesetz) and thus did not require authorisation.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "The Salzburg Federal Police Authority found that disruption of the Comradeship IV (Kameradschaft IV) commemoration ceremony and other commemoration ceremonies was likely to offend the religious feelings of members of the public visiting the cemetery.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "The Salzburg Federal Police Authority found that disruption of the commemoration ceremonies would indisputably be regarded as disrespectful towards the dead soldiers of both world wars and thus as an unbearable provocation.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "The Salzburg Federal Police Authority found that there was a risk of protests by visitors to the cemetery which could degenerate into open conflict between them and those participating in the applicant's planned assembly.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "The Salzburg Federal Police Authority ordered that any remedies used against its decision to prohibit the applicant's planned meeting should not have suspensive effect.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "As a result of the Salzburg Federal Police Authority's order that remedies should not have suspensive effect, the applicant's planned demonstration could not take place.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "On 17 August 1999, the Salzburg Public Security Authority (Sicherheitsdirektion) dismissed an appeal by the applicant against the prohibition of his planned meeting.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "The Salzburg Public Security Authority (Sicherheitsdirektion) noted that Comradeship IV (Kameradschaft IV) was a registered association whose members were mainly former members of the SS.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "For more than forty years, members of Comradeship IV (Kameradschaft IV) had commemorated SS soldiers killed in the Second World War by gathering on All Saints' Day and laying a wreath in front of the war memorial at the Salzburg municipal cemetery.", "source_paragraph": 15,

Fact Mapping:
{"list1": {"scope": ["F003", "F005", "F008", "F006", "F018", "F029", "F004", "F010", "F011", "F031", "F032", "F033", "F009"], "interference": ["F012", "F026", "F027"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F013", "F060"], "legitimate_aim": ["F015", "F023", "F025", "F021", "F050", "F046", "F047", "F048"], "necessity": ["F004", "F006", "F008", "F018", "F029", "F005", "F010", "F011", "F009", "F031", "F032", "F033", "F012", "F027", "F015", "F035", "F036", "F043", "F026"], "positive_obligation": ["F045", "F049", "F050", "F051", "F052", "F053", "F031", "F032", "F033", "F012"]}, "list2": {"scope": ["F003", "F005", "F008", "F009", "F010", "F011", "F029"], "interference": ["F012", "F026", "F027"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F013", "F060"], "legitimate_aim": ["F015", "F023", "F050"], "necessity": ["F004", "F008", "F009", "F010", "F011", "F018", "F029", "F031", "F032", "F033", "F035", "F036", "F043"], "positive_obligation": ["F050", "F051", "F052", "F053", "F031", "F032", "F033"]}, "list3": ["F004", "F008", "F009", "F010", "F011", "F012", "F027", "F029", "F032", "F033", "F043"]}

Conclusion:
{"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit", "aims": ["prevention_of_disorder", "rights_of_others"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}}}