Case: case_691

Atomic Facts:
[{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The case concerns police ill-treatment of the applicants during a political rally on 6 May 2012 at Bolotnaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants were neither convicted of mass disorder nor accused of any other offence in connection with the relevant events at Bolotnaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The first applicant (Mr Zakharov) was born in 1966.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The second applicant (Ms Varzhabetyan) was born in 1945.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The first applicant (Mr Zakharov) lives in Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The second applicant (Ms Varzhabetyan) lives in Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The first applicant (Mr Zakharov) was represented by Mr S.A. Minenkov, a lawyer practising in Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The second applicant (Ms Varzhabetyan) was represented by Mr A.N. Laptev, a lawyer practising in Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The Government were initially represented by Mr G. Matyushkin, the Representative of the Russian Federation to the European Court of Human Rights.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The Government were subsequently represented by Mr M. Galperin, the successor to Mr G. Matyushkin as Representative of the Russian Federation to the European Court of Human Rights.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The background facts relating to the planning, conduct and dispersal of the assembly at Bolotnaya Square are set out in more detail in the judgment of Frumkin v. Russia (no. 74568/12, §§ 7-65, 5 January 2016).", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE PUBLIC ASSEMBLY ON 6 MAY 2012 AND THE APPLICANTS' ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "Both applicants participated in the political rally on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE PUBLIC ASSEMBLY ON 6 MAY 2012 AND THE APPLICANTS' ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The first applicant (Mr Zakharov) was one of the organisers of the political rally on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE PUBLIC ASSEMBLY ON 6 MAY 2012 AND THE APPLICANTS' ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "According to the applicants, they neither violated public order nor resisted the police who were present at the assembly on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE PUBLIC ASSEMBLY ON 6 MAY 2012 AND THE APPLICANTS' ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "During the dispersal of the meeting on 6 May 2012, the police allegedly hit the first applicant (Mr Zakharov) on the head with a rubber truncheon.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE PUBLIC ASSEMBLY ON 6 MAY 2012 AND THE APPLICANTS' ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "During the dispersal of the meeting on 6 May 2012, the police allegedly hit the second applicant (Ms Varzhabetyan) on the head with a rubber truncheon.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE PUBLIC ASSEMBLY ON 6 MAY 2012 AND THE APPLICANTS' ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "The first applicant (Mr Zakharov) submitted photographs in support of his account of events at Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE PUBLIC ASSEMBLY ON 6 MAY 2012 AND THE APPLICANTS' ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "One of the photographs submitted by the first applicant (Mr Zakharov) shows some police officers aiming blows at the crowd with their rubber truncheons.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE PUBLIC ASSEMBLY ON 6 MAY 2012 AND THE APPLICANTS' ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "The first applicant (Mr Zakharov) can be seen in the crowd in the photograph showing police officers aiming blows with rubber truncheons.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE PUBLIC ASSEMBLY ON 6 MAY 2012 AND THE APPLICANTS' ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "Another photograph submitted by the first applicant (Mr Zakharov) shows him being pulled by two police officers.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE PUBLIC ASSEMBLY ON 6 MAY 2012 AND THE APPLICANTS' ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "The photographs submitted by the first applicant (Mr Zakharov) do not show the actual moment when he was allegedly attacked with a rubber truncheon.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE PUBLIC ASSEMBLY ON 6 MAY 2012 AND THE APPLICANTS' ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "Two photographs submitted by the first applicant (Mr Zakharov) show him at the site of the events at Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012 with his face bleeding.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE PUBLIC ASSEMBLY ON 6 MAY 2012 AND THE APPLICANTS' ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "According to the first applicant (Mr Zakharov), having received a blow to the head, he lost consciousness.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE PUBLIC ASSEMBLY ON 6 MAY 2012 AND THE APPLICANTS' ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "Other participants in the rally helped the first applicant (Mr Zakharov) obtain first aid treatment after he received a blow to the head.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE PUBLIC ASSEMBLY ON 6 MAY 2012 AND THE APPLICANTS' ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "The first applicant (Mr Zakharov) was taken to a hospital following the events at Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE PUBLIC ASSEMBLY ON 6 MAY 2012 AND THE APPLICANTS' ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "The first applicant (Mr Zakharov) was discharged from hospital on 6 May 2012, the same day he was admitted.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE PUBLIC ASSEMBLY ON 6 MAY 2012 AND THE APPLICANTS' ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "The first applicant (Mr Zakharov) submitted a medical certificate dated 6 May 2012 stating that he had been diagnosed with a contused wound of the frontal lobe.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE PUBLIC ASSEMBLY ON 6 MAY 2012 AND THE APPLICANTS' ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "The second applicant (Ms Varzhabetyan) provided links to YouTube videos showing the clashes between the police and the protesters at Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE PUBLIC ASSEMBLY ON 6 MAY 2012 AND THE APPLICANTS' ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "The YouTube videos provided by the second applicant (Ms Varzhabetyan) indicate that she was surrounded by police officers when she fell and started screaming.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE PUBLIC ASSEMBLY ON 6 MAY 2012 AND THE APPLICANTS' ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "The YouTube videos provided by the second applicant (Ms Varzhabetyan) show other participants in the assembly carrying her and shouting at the police officers, accusing them of hitting an elderly woman, referring to the second applicant (Ms Varzhabetyan).", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE PUBLIC ASSEMBLY ON 6 MAY 2012 AND THE APPLICANTS' ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "The second applicant (Ms Varzhabetyan) submitted a medical certificate s

Fact Mapping:
{"list1": {"scope": ["F001", "F011", "F012", "F002", "F014", "F037", "F038", "F053", "F054"], "interference": ["F015", "F016", "F022", "F027", "F029", "F031", "F032", "F033", "F037"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F104", "F105", "F106", "F107", "F108", "F109", "F110"], "legitimate_aim": ["F104", "F105", "F106", "F107", "F109", "F110"], "necessity": ["F037", "F038", "F002", "F053", "F054", "F015", "F016", "F027", "F032", "F033", "F111", "F112"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F001", "F012", "F002", "F037", "F053", "F054"], "interference": ["F015", "F016", "F027", "F032"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F104", "F106", "F109"], "legitimate_aim": ["F104", "F110"], "necessity": ["F037", "F002", "F053", "F054", "F111", "F015", "F016"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F012", "F002", "F037", "F015", "F016", "F111", "F053", "F054"]}

Conclusion:
{"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit", "aims": ["prevention_of_disorder", "prevention_of_crime"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}