natgillin/translations-raw huggingface dataset:
The Commission established that this document is of a very theoretical nature and does not reflect the necessary technical elements allowing for the economic operators to comply with the Comorian law and the Comorian authorities to monitor the activities of the Comorian vessels concerned.
Osim toga, u kontekstu opće ocjene ispunjavanja obveza koje Komori imaju kao država zastave, država luke, obalna država i država trgovine Komisija je, kako je navedeno u uvodnoj izjavi 42.
In light of the situation referred to in recitals 62 to 64 the Commission established that the Comorian authorities have not taken any appropriate precautionary measures in relation to the fishing and fishing-related vessels flying the Comorian flag operating in breach of the Comorian law and requirements.
Odluke od 1. listopada 2015., analizirala i surađuju li Komori s drugim državama u suzbijanju ribolova NNN.
Moreover, it is recalled that, as indicated in recital 46 of the Decision of 1 October 2015, the Comorian authorities were prior to this Decision already aware that vessels flying their flag were, in breach of the Comorian law and requirements, operating outside the Comorian EEZ and had not taken enforcement measures in respect of those vessels.
Kako je istaknuto u uvodnim izjavama 39. do 41., Komisija je utvrdila da ribarska plovila i plovila koja su povezana s ribarstvom koja plove pod zastavom Komorâ djeluju izvan IGP-a Komorâ i izvan područja primjene IOTC-a, posebno u istočnom Atlantiku.
It also contravenes the recommendations to take enforcement measures in respect of IUU fishing activities and to sanction such activities with sufficient severity to effectively prevent, deter and eliminate IUU fishing and to deprive offenders of the benefits accruing from such fishing, as set out in paragraph 8(2)(7) of the FAO Code of Conduct, point 21 of the IPOA IUU and points 31 to 33, 35 and 38 of the FAO Voluntary Guidelines for Flag State Performance.
Komori su objasnili da su poduzete inicijative za stupanje u izravan kontakt s trećim zemljama u kojima djeluju komorska plovila i Komisija je ponudila rješenja za lakše ostvarenje takvih kontakata.
It is noted that the Comorian fisheries legal framework is still based on the Fisheries and Aquaculture Code established by Act No 07-011/AU of 29 August 2007 and the Decree No 15-050/PR of 15 April 2015 in force at the time of Decision of 1 October 2015.
Međutim Komisiji nisu dostavljene nikakve informacije o eventualnim kontaktima.
It is also recalled that recitals 49 and 50 of that Decision established that: (i) the Comorian authorities acknowledged that further implementing texts of the Fisheries and Aquaculture Code needed to be elaborated to ensure consistency between national law and international and regional applicable rules; (ii) the Comorian Fisheries and Aquaculture Code does not include vessels conducting fishing related activities in the definition of fishing vessels; and (iii) while the Comorian legal framework covers serious violations as defined under international law, it does not explicitly define IUU fishing and does not expressly foresee enforcement measures and sanctions for nationals supporting or engaged in IUU fishing as outlined in points 18 and 21 of the IPOA IUU.
Podsjeća se da je u uvodnoj izjavi 34. objašnjeno da su nadležna tijela država članica komorskim tijelima poslala zahtjeve za uzajamnu pomoć u pogledu statusa i aktivnosti komorskih ribarskih plovila i plovila povezanih s ribarstvom.
It is also recalled that recital 50 of the Decision of 1 October 2015 established that, as regards the sanctioning system, fines foreseen in the context of industrial fishing activities are based on the value of the licences fees.
Komisija je obaviještena i o sličnim inicijativama trećih zemalja.
Nevertheless, the categories of fishing licences defined in the Comorian law are limited only to tuna species.
Međutim Komisija je utvrdila da je nedostatna razina suradnje komorskih tijela pri razmjenama informacija s Komisijom utjecala i na navedene zahtjeve za uzajamnu pomoć.
Consequently, in cases of infringements of industrial fleet targeting other species there are no corresponding fines, in view of the lack of corresponding licencing fees.
Zbog tog je stanja ugroženo ostvarenje mjera koje su pokrenula nadležna tijela predmetnih zemalja u pogledu niza komorskih plovila na temelju informacija koje su dostavila komorska tijela.
This situation reduces the level of deterrence of the Comorian sanctioning system and does not allow the Comorian authorities to sanction IUU fishing activities with sufficient severity to effectively prevent, deter and eliminate these activities and to deprive offenders of the benefits accruing from their illegal activities.
Stanje opisano u uvodnim izjavama 54. do 56. upućuje na to da Komori nisu ostvarili učinkovitu suradnju i koordinaciju aktivnosti s državama u kojima djeluju komorska plovila u pogledu sprečavanja nezakonitog, neprijavljenog i nereguliranog ribolova, odvraćanja od njega i njegova zaustavljanja u skladu s točkom 28.
It is noted that the Comorian authorities in charge of fisheries presented to the Commission draft amendments to the provisions of the Fisheries and Aquaculture Code established by Act No 07-011/AU of 29 August 2007 and of the Decree No 15-050/PR of 15 April 2015.
Međunarodnog plana djelovanja protiv ribolova NNN.
During its visit in August 2016, the Commission however established the revision process is affected by the inadequate administrative environment.
Konkretno, kako je utvrđeno u točki 31.
The Commission also found part of the Comorian administration considered the revision process as an opportunity to bolster the flag of convenience policy of the Comoros.
Međunarodnog plana djelovanja protiv ribolova NNN, Komori bi, kao država zastave, trebali sklapati sporazume ili dogovore s drugim državama te na druge načine surađivati u cilju provedbe primjenjivih propisa i mjera za očuvanje i upravljanje ili odredaba donesenih na nacionalnoj, regionalnoj ili međunarodnoj razini.
Therefore, the Commission finds that the legal framework is still inadequate in terms of compliance with international and regional applicable rules.
Kako je objašnjeno u uvodnoj izjavi 44.
On the basis of the information gathered from the Comorian authorities as well as during its visit in August 2016, the Commission found that many obligations foreseen under Comorian law are still not implemented and enforced by the Comoros (e.g. obligation to transmit vessel monitoring system information and report catch data, restrictions on the area of operation of Comorian vessels, etc.).
Odluke od 1. listopada 2015., Komisija je analizirala i to jesu li Komori poduzeli učinkovite izvršne mjere u pogledu subjekata odgovornih za ribolov NNN i jesu li primijenjene dovoljno oštre sankcije kako bi se počiniteljima uskratile koristi koje proizlaze iz njihovih ribolovnih aktivnosti NNN.
As stated in recital 47 of the Decision of 1 October 2015, this situation highlights the authorities' inability to monitor the operations of Comorian vessels and undermines the authorities' ability to effectively enforce rules applicable to the different areas concerned.
Dostupni dokazi potvrđuju da Komori nisu ispunili svoje obveze u skladu s međunarodnim pravom u pogledu učinkovitih izršnih mjera.
Furthermore, no progress has been made as regards the facts described in recital 51 of the Decision of 1 October 2015, concerning the lack of a national inspection plan to ensure a coherent policy on control of the Comorian fleet operations, and the insufficient number of observers.
Napominje se i da su u tijeku razmjena informacija ostvarenih u kontekstu zahtjeva za pomoć koji su se odnosili na 12 komorskih plovila koja su sudjelovala u aktivnostima prekrcaja na moru i zajedničkim operacijama komorska tijela Komisiji i državama članicama dostavila pisane izjave kojima se potvrđuje da komorska tijela zabranjuju prekrcaje na moru te da su stoga ta plovila provodila ribolovne aktivnosti NNN.
During its visit in August 2016, the Commission found that, notwithstanding an admission from the Comorian authorities regarding their lack of capacity to monitor and control the fishing and fishing-related activities of the Comorian fleet wherever it operates and the foreign fleet operating within the Comorian EEZ, there was still an intention to pursue an expansion of the fleet strategy.
Međutim Komisija je utvrdila da nakon Odluke od 1. listopada 2015. komorska tijela nisu izvijestila o poduzimanju ikakvih izvršnih mjera protiv plovila koja djeluju izvan IGP-Komorâ bez odobrenja komorskih tijela te izvan područja primjene IOTC-a.
As highlighted in recitals 67 to 72 of the Decision of 1 October 2015, the level of development of Comoros cannot be considered as a factor undermining the capacity of the competent authorities to cooperate with other countries and pursue enforcement actions.
Nadalje, kako je opisano u uvodnoj izjavi 32., napominje se da je ribarskim plovilima i plovilima povezanima s ribarstvom koja plove pod zastavom Komorâ kršeći komorske zakone i propise stvarno dodijeljeno šestomjesečno razdoblje odgode s početkom od kolovoza 2016.
The evaluation of the specific constraints emanating from the Comorian level of development is further described in recitals 88 to 93 of the present Decision.
Ta je odluka, uz stanje opisano u uvodnoj izjavi 56., ugrozila mjere koje su pokrenula nadležna tijela država članica u pogledu niza komorskih plovila na temelju informacija koje su dostavila komorska tijela.
In view of recitals 37 to 54 of the Decision of 1 October 2015 and the developments after 1 October 2015, the Commission takes the view, pursuant to Article 31(3) and Article 31(5)(a), (b), (c) and (d) of the IUU Regulation, that the Comoros has failed to discharge the duties incumbent upon it under international law as a flag, coastal, port and market State in respect of cooperation and enforcement efforts.
Komorska tijela obavijestila su Komisiju o mogućem brisanju iz registra komorskih plovila koja do isteka šestomjesečnog razdoblja odgode ne reguliraju svoj status.
Failure to implement international rules (Article 31(6) of the IUU Regulation).
Međutim napominje se da brisanje plovila iz registra nije jamstvo da će se počinitelji kršenja primjereno oštro kazniti i da će im se uskratiti koristi koje proizlaze iz njihovih nezakonitih aktivnosti.
As described in the recitals 57 to 60 of the Decision of 1 October 2015, the Commission analysed information deemed relevant from available data published by Regional Fisheries Management Organizations (RFMOs), in particular the IOTC and the Southwest Indian Ocean Fisheries Commission (SWIOFC).
Nadalje, Komisija je tijekom posjeta u kolovozu 2016. utvrdila i da nadležna tijela nisu donijela konkretnu odluku o brisanju iz registra.
In addition, the Commission carried out an analysis on the information deemed relevant with respect to the status of the Comoros as contracting party to the IOTC and the SWIOFC following the Decision of 1 October 2015.
U svakom slučaju takvo teoretsko brisanje iz registra ne bi nužno uključivala provedbu istraga ribolovnih aktivnosti NNN koja provode plovila ili uvođenje sankcija za utvrđeno kršenje.
It is recalled that recitals 57 and 58 of the Decision of 1 October 2015 described the repeated and non-repeated compliance issues of the Comoros with IOTC Resolutions identified for 2014 in the IOTC Compliance Report for the Comoros produced on 25 March 2015 [4].
Na temelju informacija koje je prikupila tijekom posjeta u kolovozu 2016.
According to information derived from the IOTC Compliance Report for the Comoros produced on 16 April 2016 [5], several repeated compliance issues were identified in 2015.
Komisija je utvrdila da su komorska tijela nadležna za ribolov izradila kontrolni popis uvjeta za izdavanje odobrenja za ribolov u cilju poticanja regularizacije tijekom šestomjesečnog razdoblja odgode iz uvodne izjave 62.
In particular, the Comoros only partially complied with the requirements to: (i) provide aggregated statistics on nominal catch for sharks, as required by Resolution 05/05; (ii) provide aggregated statistics on catch and effort for sharks, as required by Resolution 05/05; and (iii) provide aggregated statistics on size frequency for sharks, as required by Resolution 05/05.
Taj je dokument proslijeđen komorskim tijelima nadležnima za registraciju plovila.
The Comoros has also not provided any information on coverage by gear for artisanal landings, as required by Resolution 11/04.
Svrha je bila dostaviti dokument privatnim pravnim osobama smještenima izvan Komorâ kojima je djelomično delegirano upravljanje registrom komorske flote ribarskih plovila i plovila povezanih s ribarstvom.
Non-repeated compliance issues were also identified in the same report.
Tim privatnim pravnim osobama povjereno je slanje navedenog dokumenta gospodarskim subjektima.
The Comoros has not provided any information on the ban on oceanic whitetip sharks, as required by Resolution 13/06 and has not provided any information on the implementation of FAO guidelines on marine turtles, as required by Resolution 12/04.
Komisija je utvrdila da je riječ o dokumentu iznimno teorijske prirode, koji ne uključuje nužne tehničke elemente s pomoću kojih bi se gospodarskim subjektima omogućilo da ispune zahtjeve propisane komorskim pravom, a komorskim tijelima da prate aktivnosti predmetnih komorskih plovila.
The compliance issues of the Comoros with IOTC Resolutions demonstrates the failure of the Comoros to fulfil its obligations as flag State laid down in Article 94 of Unclos.
S obzirom na stanje iz uvodnih izjava 62. do 64.
They also show that the Comoros is not following the recommendations of points 31 to 33, 35 and 38 of FAO Voluntary Guidelines for Flag States Performance and of point 24 of the IPOA IUU.
Komisija je utvrdila da komorska tijela nisu poduzela odgovarajuće mjere predostrožnosti u pogledu ribarskih plovila i plovila povezanih s ribarstvom koja plove pod zastavom Komorâ kršeći komorske zakone i propise.
With the exception of IOTC and SWIOFC, the Comoros is not a contracting party to other RFMOs.
Nadalje, podsjeća se da su, kako je navedeno u uvodnoj izjavi 46.
Considering the structure of the Comorian fleet, which operates not only in the Indian Ocean region, this finding undermines the Comorian efforts to fulfil obligations under Unclos, in particular Articles 117 and 118 thereof.
Odluke od 1. listopada 2015., komorska tijela i prije donošenja te odluke bila upoznata s time da su plovila koja plove pod njihovom zastavom, kršeći komorske zakone i propise, djelovala izvan IGP-a Komorâ te nisu poduzela izvršne mjere u pogledu tih plovila.
Moreover, with the exception of Unclos, the Comoros has not ratified other international legal instruments related to fisheries management.
Stanje koje se navodi u uvodnim izjavama 58. do 66. nije u skladu s člankom 94.
Considering the importance of straddling and highly migratory fish stocks for the Comoros, this finding undermines the Comorian efforts to fulfil its duties as flag, coastal, port and market State under Unclos, in particular Articles 63 and 64 thereof.
Konvencije Ujedinjenih naroda o pravu mora (UNCLOS) o obvezama države zastave da djelotvorno vrši svoju jurisdikciju i nadzor nad brodovima koji plove pod njezinom zastavom i njihovim zapovjednicima, časnicima i posadama.
The performance of the Comoros in implementing international instruments is also not in accordance with the recommendations of point 11 of the IPOA IUU which encourages States, as a matter of priority, to ratify, accept or accede to the United Nations Agreement for the Implementation of the Provisions of Unclos relating to the Conservation and Management of Straddling Fish Stocks and Highly Migratory Fish Stocks (UNFSA) and the FAO Compliance Agreement.
Nije u skladu ni s preporukama za poduzimanje izvršnih mjera u pogledu ribolovnih aktivnosti NNN i za sankcioniranje takvih aktivnosti dovoljno teškim kaznama radi djelotvornog sprečavanja ribolova NNN, odvraćanja od njega i njegova zaustavljanja i lišavanja počinitelja koristi od takvog ribolova, kako je utvrđeno člankom 8. stavkom 2. točkom 7.
It also fails to follow point 14 that provides that States should fully and effectively implement the Code of Conduct and its associated International Plans of Action.
Kodeksa FAO-a, točkom 21.
The Comoros also has not ratified the 2009 FAO Port State Measures Agreement.
Međunarodnog plana djelovanja protiv ribolova NNN i točkama 31. do 33., 35. i 38. neobvezujućih smjernica FAO-a za postupanje države zastave.
Contrary to the recommendations of points 25 to 27 of the IPOA IUU, the Comoros has, to date, not developed a national plan of action against IUU fishing.
Podsjeća se i da se u uvodnoj izjavi 50.
From the information gathered from the Comorian authorities, the Commission found that the management of the register of the Comorian fishing and fishing-related fleet remains partly delegated to private legal persons located outside the Comoros.
Odluke od 1. listopada 2015. utvrđuje da se u pogledu programa sankcija novčane kazne predviđene u kontekstu aktivnosti industrijskog ribolova temelje na vrijednosti pristojbi za povlastice za ribolov.
Based on the information gathered by the Commission as well as statements made by the Comoros, it was established that the Comoros failed to ensure that vessels flying its flag have a genuine link with the country.
Međutim, kategorije povlastica za ribolov definirane pravom Komorâ ograničene su samo na vrste tuna.
This contravenes Article 91 of Unclos which provides that a genuine link must exist between the flag State and its ships.
Kao posljedica toga, za slučajeve kršenja koje počini industrijska flota usmjerena na druge vrste ne postoje odgovarajuće novčane kazne zbog nepostojanja pristojbi za odgovarajuće ribolovne povlastice.
In view of the recitals 55 to 65 of the Decision of 1 October 2015 and the developments after 1 October 2015, the Commission takes the view, pursuant to Article 31(3) and (6) of the IUU Regulation, that the Comoros has failed to discharge the duties incumbent upon it under international law with respect to international rules, regulations as well as conservation and management measures.
Zbog tog je stanja smanjena razina učinka odvraćanja komorskog sustava sankcija te komorska tijela nisu u mogućnosti da ribolovne aktivnosti NNN sankcioniraju dovoljno teškim kaznama za djelotvorno sprečavanje tih aktivnosti, odvraćanje od njih i njihovo zaustavljanje i da počinitelje liše koristi od takvih nezakonitih aktivnosti.
Specific constraints of developing countries (Article 31(7) of the IUU Regulation)
Osim toga, Komisija je utvrdila da dio komorske uprave smatra da je postupak revizije prilika za učvršćivanje politike „zastave pogodnosti” Komorâ.
It is recalled that the Comoros has a low human development index and was ranked 159 out of 188 countries in 2014 [6] according to the United Nations Human Development Index (UNHDI).
Stoga Komisija smatra da je pravni okvir još uvijek neprikladan u smislu usklađenosti s međunarodnim i regionalnim primjenjivim pravilima.
It is also recalled that Regulation (EC) No 1905/2006 of the European Parliament and of the Council [7] listed the Comoros in the category of least developed countries [8].
Na temelju informacija koje je prikupila od komorskih tijela te tijekom svojega posjeta u kolovozu 2016.
No corroborating evidence has been found to suggest that the failure of the Comoros to discharge its duties under international law is the result of development constraints.
Komisija je utvrdila da Komori još uvijek ne provode ni izvršavaju mnoge obveze predviđene komorskim zakonima (npr. obveza dostave informacija dobivenih preko sustava za praćenje plovila i izvješćivanja o podatcima o ulovu, ograničenja područja djelovanja komorskih plovila itd.).
Although specific capacity constraints may exist in general with respect to monitoring, control and surveillance, the specific constraints of the Comoros derived from its level of development cannot justify the deficiencies identified in the previous sections.
Kako je navedeno u uvodnoj izjavi 47.
This concerns especially the status of the Comorian register and the total absence of control of a part of the Comorian fleet.
Odluke od 1. listopada 2015., to stanje naglašava nemogućnost nadležnih tijela da prate aktivnosti komorskih plovila i narušava sposobnost tih nadležnih tijela da djelotvorno provode pravila primjenjiva na različita predmetna područja.
As stated in recital 69 of the Decision of 1 October 2015, it appears that the shortcomings identified result primarily from the inadequate administrative environment and lack of cooperation and information sharing within the Comorian administration to ensure the efficient and effective performance of the Comorian duties as flag, coastal, port and market State.
Nadalje, nije ostvaren napredak u pogledu činjenica opisanih u uvodnoj izjavi 51.
This situation is aggravated by the imbalanced size of the Comorian fishing and fishing-related fleet and its area of operation.
Odluke od 1. listopada 2015. koje se odnose na nepostojanje nacionalnog programa inspekcija kojim bi se osigurala jedinstvena politika kontrole djelovanja komorske flote te u pogledu nedovoljnog broja promatrača.
It is also recalled that the European Union and the Comoros have signed a Fisheries Partnership Agreement [9].
Tijekom posjeta u kolovozu 2016.
The last protocol [10] of this agreement included sectoral financial support in the financial contribution paid to the Comoros.
Komisija je utvrdila da, bez obzira na to što su komorska tijela priznala da nisu sposobna pratiti i kontrolirati ribolovne aktivnosti i aktivnosti povezane s ribolovom komorske flote u svim područjima u kojima ona djeluje i aktivnosti strane flote koja djeluje unutar IGP-a Komorâ, i dalje postoji namjera provedbe strategije proširenja flote.
The sectoral financial support aimed to promote sustainable fisheries development by strengthening administrative and scientific capacity through a focus on sustainable fisheries management, monitoring, control and surveillance.
Kako je istaknuto u uvodnim izjavama 67. do 72.
This should have contributed to helping the Comoros to meet its duties under international law as flag, port, coastal and market State and to fight IUU fishing.
Odluke od 1. listopada 2015., razina razvoja Komorâ ne može se smatrati čimbenikom koji narušava mogućnosti nadležnih tijela da surađuju s ostalim zemljama i provode izvršne mjere.
Moreover, the Comoros also gets support from regional initiatives such as the project SmartFish which is funded by the European Union and which is implemented by the Indian Ocean Commission (IOC) and aims, inter alia, to fight IUU fishing through shared resources; information exchange; training and the development of operational schemes for monitoring, control and surveillance; and the First South West Indian Ocean Fisheries Governance and Shared Growth Project of the World Bank which aims to improve the management effectiveness of selected priority fisheries at the regional, national and community level.
Ocjenjivanje posebnih ograničenja koja proizlaze iz razine razvoja Komorâ dodatno je opisano u uvodnim izjavama (88). do (93). ove Odluke.
In view of the considerations presented in this Section made on the basis of all factual elements gathered by the Commission as well as the information submitted by the Comoros, the Commission has established that, pursuant to Article 31(7) of the IUU Regulation, it appears appropriate to take into account the specific constraints of the Comoros in view of its development status, which may impair the Comoros' overall performance in fisheries management.
S obzirom na uvodne izjave 37. do 54.