natgillin/translations-raw huggingface dataset:
The French authorities have also convincingly demonstrated that strong synergies existed between the reactors business and the back-end fuel cycle — synergies which New Areva and New Areva NP will have little incentive to recreate in the future.
Međutim, zbog razloga opisanih u uvodnim izjavama 356. do 360. čini se da nije opravdano predvidjeti dodatnu mjeru na tom tržištu.
In the medium and long term, New Areva NP's capacity to increase its sales from processing and recycling services for export depends on the existence on the market of a fleet of light-water reactors able to run with MOX fuel assemblies, known as ‘MOX reactors’.
Konačno, logistika i razgradnja tržišta od su razmjerno sekundarne vrijednosti za grupu Areva, na kojima neće imati važan položaj nakon restrukturiranja.
Indeed, MOX fuel is not as such interchangeable with conventional fuel: reactors for which MOX is to be used must have been designed or adapted to accommodate this type of fuel.
Na primjer, u pogledu logistike, grupa Areva 2013. držala je otprilike [0 – 50] % tržišnog udjela u smislu količina za proizvodnju ambalaže potrebne za suho skladištenje i prijevoz iskorištenog goriva („casks”), dok njemački GNS drži [50 – 100] % tog tržišta.
This means that the Areva Group's MOX business depends directly on the fleet of ‘moxed’ reactors worldwide.
Na tržištu razgradnje Nova Areva zadržat će tržišni udio od [0 – 20] % i natjecat će se s brojnim drugim akterima (Onet, Vinci, Bouygues, Westinghouse, Amec, Nukem, Iberdrola itd.).
However, New Areva NP […].
Tijekom ispitivanja tih tržišta, na kojima ne postoji prekapacitiranost, Komisija nije uočila izrazito narušavanje tržišnog natjecanja.
[…] New Areva NP is responsible for selling them.
Prema tome, dodatne mjere specifične za ta tržišta nisu opravdane.
[…] the French authorities explained that the situation was different as long as the Areva Group was integrated, since this meant it had the capacity to make a profit from MOX production, the design and construction of reactors and the selling of fuel assemblies.
S obzirom na prethodno navedeno, Komisija zaključuje da, s obzirom na prodaju Nove Areve NP od strane grupe Areva i obveze koje je preuzela Francuska, na tržištima na kojima će grupe Areva nakon restrukturiranja zadržati važan položaj neće doći do narušavanja tržišnog natjecanja koje bi opravdalo dodatnu mjeru.
In fact, although Areva NP was indeed responsible for selling fuel (as New Areva NP will be in the future), it was under the supervision of Areva SA […].
U zaključku analize mjera kojima se ograničava narušavanje tržišnog natjecanja nastalo potporom Komisija prima na znanje obveze francuskih nadležnih tijela u pogledu poštovanja točke 84. podtočaka (a) i (b) smjernica.
[…], the long-term growth prospects of the MOX segment ([…]) must be downgraded.
U tom pogledu točkom 84. podtočkom (a) smjernica propisano je da su korisnici obvezni suzdržavati se od stjecanja dionica u trgovačkim društvima tijekom restrukturiranja, osim kada je to neophodno kako bi se osigurala dugoročna održivost korisnika.
However, replacing a non-MOX reactor in a call for tenders with a MOX reactor project reduces New Areva NP's captive demand and consequently increases demand for conventional fuel, for which New Areva NP is in competition with other operators, such as Urenco.
Ta se obveza odnosi na stjecanje udjela kojima bi se povećala prisutnost korisnika na tim tržištima ili na nekim drugim tržištima putem vanjskog rasta, a ne na racionalizaciju i upotrebu postojećih proizvodnih sredstava putem unutarnjeg rasta.
In a more general sense, New Areva and New Areva NP will enter into a customer/supplier relationship for an entire range of services that were previously supplied in-house, which will have potentially negative consequences for both New Areva NP and New Areva.
Komisija smatra da se u ovom slučaju osnivanje zajedničkih poduzeća za proizvodnju u cilju racionalizacije proizvodnje putem postojeće imovine, a ne zajedničkog stjecanja i iskorištavanja nove imovine, ne smatra stjecanjem udjela, pod uvjetom da nijedan dioničar zajedničkog poduzeća nema prava vučenja koja premašuju njegov doprinos.
This reasoning applies particularly to logistics operations, which will be more difficult to optimise.
Isto tako, u svrhu primjene točke 84. podtočke (a) smjernica u ovom se slučaju kupnja poduzeća u svrhu razgradnje imovine koju posjeduju ne smatra stjecanjem udjela.
The French authorities have provided the following example.
Na tržištu razgradnje […] vlasnik poduzeća koje posjeduje imovinu namijenjenu razgradnji, na primjer staru nuklearnu elektranu, od pružatelja usluga koji žele preuzeti razgradnju traži da osnuju konzorcij sa svrhom kupnje poduzeća i sredstva za razgradnju koje ono posjeduje te da provedu razgradnju imovine upotrebom tih sredstava.
The natural uranium remains the property of the electricity generator that acquired it, which then entrusts its chosen suppliers with carrying out conversion and enrichment, followed by the manufacturers of fuel assemblies.
Taj slučaj za poduzetnike koji su članovi konzorcija kupaca, a osobito za grupu Areva, predstavlja posebni način za nastavak pružanja usluga koje već pruža, a ne stjecanje udjela koji bi omogućili grupi Areva da poveća svoju prisutnost putem vanjskog rasta.
Either the enrichment company or the designated manufacturer is tasked with delivering the enriched uranium.
S obzirom na navedeno, francuska nadležna tijela obvezuju se da će se grupa Areva (Areva SA i Nova Areva) i poduzetnici pod njezinim nadzorom tijekom razdoblja restrukturiranja suzdržati od izravnog ili neizravnog stjecanja udjela u poduzetnicima koji već nisu pod njezinim nadzorom, osim sljedećih projekata:
Belonging to the same group facilitates discussion and enhances the potential ways of optimising operations, given the lack of opposing interests between the enrichment company and the fuel-assembly manufacturer.
Nadalje, dio tih projekata […] odnosi se na rudarske djelatnosti grupe Areva.
The Areva Group has always benefited from this advantage in relation to its intra-group deliveries.
U tom pogledu grupa Areva morat će se suočiti sa zatvaranjem određenih važnih rudnika, osobito u […].
In recital 189 of the opening decision, the Commission expressed concern about the consequences of the planned strategic partnership between EDF and the Areva Group, especially in terms of the contractual re-creation of the commercial synergies observed in the past.
Svrha rudarskih projekata grupe Areva iz točaka (a) do (d) uvodne izjave 390. ponajprije je zamijeniti izgubljene kapacitete […].
Urenco has shared its concerns with the Commission on this subject.
Osim toga, razvoj djelatnosti grupe Areva […], koja primjenjuje ambicioznu strategiju razvoja nuklearne energije, jednako je tako neophodan kako bi poduzeće ponovno uspostavilo dugoročnu održivost.
The Commission concedes that a contractual partnership based on the concept of ‘best effort’ has little chance of recreating synergies as strong as those that previously existed within a consolidated group.
Predmetni projekti provode se u obliku zajedničkih poduzeća s poduzetnikom […].
However, a partnership that included a kind of favoured commercial cooperation, restricting the ability of New Areva NP's competitors to team up with New Areva NP to develop integrated solutions, would undermine the positive effects for competition of the divestment of New Areva NP.
Nakon što je provela analizu projekata […] navedenih u točkama (a), (d), (e), (g), (h), (j) i (q) uvodne izjave 390., Komisija smatra da su ključni za razvojnu strategiju grupe Areva […], koja je neophodna za ponovnu uspostavu dugoročne održivosti društva.
In this context, the Commission notes the commitment by the French authorities to ensure that, during the restructuring period, EDF-controlled New Areva NP and New Areva do not enter into any strategic partnership or other framework agreement for commercial cooperation aimed at favouring New Areva in situations where New Areva NP wishes to provide a customer with an integrated offering alongside a supplier of nuclear material.
Slična se logika primjenjuje na razvojne projekte grupe Areva […].[…].
In the light of this commitment, the Commission believes that New Areva NP will be free to offer its customers the possibility of procuring nuclear material from operators other than New Areva.
Ti projekti […] navedeni su u točkama (o) i (p) uvodne izjave 390.
When New Areva needs to renew its order book, it will not be able to count on the structural synergies which the Areva Group benefited from in the past.
Druga skupina projekata […] odnosi se na […] koja su dinamična tržišta u kojima grupa Areva mora ostati prisutna kako bi zajamčila uspjeh svojeg plana restrukturiranja.
The Commission's doubts on this point can therefore be dispelled.
Ti su projekti navedeni u točkama (i) do (n) uvodne izjave 390.
Before going into detail with respect to each market, the Commission would first of all point out that it has made sure that the aid to the Areva Group is not so large that it would place the restructured group (i.e. New Areva) in an unusually good financial position in relation to its competitors.
Komisija će moći odobriti sve druge udjele koji se pokažu neophodnima za osiguranje dugoročne održivosti grupe Areva te koji neće predstavljati povredu obveze ograničenja prisutnosti grupe Areva na postojećim tržištima.
The aid has been calculated to allow the company to restore its long-term viability, which means helping it regain an ‘investment-grade’ rating.
Namjera provedbe takvog stjecanja i elementi koji omogućuju Komisiji da provjeri jesu li ti uvjeti ispunjeni te, ako je to primjenjivo, da odobri stjecanje ili mu se ne suprotstavi, moraju biti prijavljeni Komisiji u razumnom roku, u okviru nastavka plana restrukturiranja.
However, New Areva will still have sizeable debts […].
Drugo, u skladu s točkom 84. podtočkom (b) smjernica, francuska nadležna tijela obvezuju se da grupa Areva (Areva SA i Nova Areva) neće predstavljati potporu koju prima kao konkurentsku prednost pri stavljanju na tržište proizvoda i usluga.
It is expected that, after restructuring, New Areva will benefit from a […] financial rating, which is no better than the rating of competitors like Urenco [56].
Transparentnost potpore
Consequently, New Areva will not enjoy markedly greater financial agility than its competitors after restructuring.
U skladu s točkom 38. (g) smjernica države članice, Komisija, gospodarski subjekti i javnost moraju imati jednostavan pristup svim relevantnim aktima i važnim informacijama o dodijeljenim potporama.
There are four major global players in the mining market.
To znači da moraju biti ispunjene odredbe o transparentnosti iz točke 96. smjernica.
The main operator is KAP, which holds [0-50 %] of the market, followed by Cameco, with [0-50 %] of global production.
Komisija utvrđuje da su francuska nadležna tijela dostavila jamstvo da su kriteriji transparentnosti iz točke 96. smjernica ispunjeni.
The Areva Group and Rosatom, via its subsidiary AtomEnergoProm, hold [0-30] % and [0-30] % of global production respectively [57].
Konkretnije, francuska nadležna tijela obvezuju se da će objaviti informacije predviđene komunikacijom [61] o transparentnosti kako bi bile dostupne javnosti.
KAP and Cameco have regularly increased their production in recent years and are expected to maintain or continue to increase it further in the near future.
Te će informacije biti dostupne na internetskoj stranici https://www.legifrance.gouv.fr ili na internetskoj stranici http://www.economie.gouv.fr/agence-participations-etat.
On the mining market, if New Areva were to obtain additional concessions (for example in the form of divestments), this would risk giving an advantage to operators who already hold significant positions in this concentrated market, with a risk for both the market structure and for the EU's security of uranium supply.
OBVEZE KOJE JE PREUZELA FRANCUSKA
Moreover, the mining business is a […] contributor to restoring the viability of the Areva Group, since it accounts for […] of New Areva's EBITDA up to 2020.
Komisija podsjeća na obveze koje je preuzela Francuska u okviru ovog postupka.
Weakening this activity would endanger the Group's ability to restore viability, with no obvious benefit to competition.
Francuska nadležna tijela obvezala su se na sljedeće:
In the light of these factors, the Commission does not believe compensatory measures, in addition to the divestment of New Areva NP and the commitments given by France, to be justified in the mining segment.
grupa Areva u potpunosti će napustiti djelatnost povezanu s reaktorima, što znači da Areva SA i Nova Areva nakon provedbe prijavljenog plana restrukturiranja više neće imati nikakvu kapitalnu vezu s Novom Arevom NP.
The conversion sector has four main operators by market share: Rosatom/TVEL ([0-50] %), Cameco ([0-50] %), Conver Dyn ([0-50] %) and the Areva Group ([0-50] %) [58].
tijekom razdoblja restrukturiranja grupa Areva neće povećati kapacitete tvornice Georges Besse II, osim nabave i instalacije centrifuga predviđenih postojećim ugovorima […];
The Chinese company CNNC is also present, but currently only supplies to the Chinese market.
Areva SA neće obavljati druge djelatnosti osim onih izričito predviđenih planom za restrukturiranje prijavljenim Komisiji;
The Areva Group is now Europe's sole conversion company following the closure of the SFL plant in the United Kingdom.
tijekom razdoblja restrukturiranja Nova Areva NP pod nadzorom EDF-a i Nova Areva neće sklapati nikakva strateška partnerstva ili okvirne sporazume o poslovnoj suradnji na temelju kojih bi Nova Areva imala prednost u situaciji kad Nova Areva NP želi klijentu predložiti zajedničku ponudu s dobavljačem nuklearnog materijala, na tržištima definiranim u uvodnim izjavama 344. i 347. – opskrba gorivnim sklopovima i izgradnja novih reaktora.
The conversion activity is part of the […] business.
Ta obveza ne sprječava Novu Arevu i Novu Arevu NP da podnose zajedničke ponude pod uvjetom da bi Nova Areva bila odabrana na temelju komercijalnih i tehničkih kriterija.
Any additional measure that weakens New Areva NP in this business could strengthen the market's existing oligopolistic structure and threaten the viability of this essential link in the fuel cycle, in which New Areva will be the only European operator.
tijekom razdoblja restrukturiranja grupa Areva (Areva SA i Nova Areva) i poduzetnici pod njezinim nadzorom suzdržat će se od izravnog ili neizravnog stjecanja udjela u poduzetnicima koji već nisu pod njezinim nadzorom, osim projekata navedenih u uvodnoj izjavi 390.
Consequently, the Commission does not believe compensatory measures, in addition to the divestment of New Areva NP and the commitments given by France, to be justified in the conversion segment.
Ta se obveza ne primjenjuje na stjecanja udjela koja ostvaruju Nova Areva i poduzetnici koji su izravno ili neizravno pod njezinim nadzorom u svrhu financijskog upravljanja i. sredstvima za razgradnju kojima grupa Areva mora upravljati u skladu sa zakonskom ili regulatornom obvezom; ii. mirovinskim fondovima osoblja grupe Areva i iii. novčanim ulaganjima.
On the enrichment market, in 2014 the Areva Group held a global market share of approximately [0-30 %], while its two main competitors, Rosatom/Tenex and Urenco, each held more than [0-50] % [59].
grupa Areva (Areva SA i Nova Areva) neće predstavljati potporu koju prima kao konkurentsku prednost prilikom stavljanja proizvoda i usluga na tržište.
Urenco has informed the Commission of its concerns regarding the distortions of competition on the enrichment market created by the restructuring aid.
ZAKLJUČCI
In summary, these concerns relate to (i) New Areva's alleged financial agility compared to its unaided competitors; (ii) the risk that EDF, which is one of Urenco's key customers, will favour New Areva for its enriched uranium requirements; (iii) the increased excess capacity on the European enrichment market, especially if New Areva were to decide to increase the capacity of its Georges Besse II plant or to expand in SWU trading; (iv) the continuation or even strengthening of the MOX fuel business, which competes with Urenco's conventional fuel even though Urenco believes it to be less competitive.
Upis povećanja kapitala Areve SA i Nove Areve od strane francuske države predstavlja državnu potporu za restrukturiranje u iznosu od 4,5 milijardi EUR.
The Commission has already demonstrated, in recital 368, that New Areva will not be in a better financial position than Urenco after the restructuring.
Ta će potpora biti u skladu s kriterijima navedenima u smjernicama, a time i spojiva s unutarnjim tržištem, kada će se moći utvrditi postojanje stvarnog i konkretnog vlastitog doprinosa većeg ili jednakog polovini troškova restrukturiranja, odnosno nakon uklanjanja suspenzivnih uvjeta utvrđenih u uvodnoj izjavi 318. i navedenih u članku 2. ove odluke.
This concern is therefore unfounded.
Prema tome, provedba potpore može započeti tek nakon ispunjavanja tih dvaju uvjeta,
Moreover, the French authorities have indicated that the Areva Group's enrichment business, housed in the subsidiary SET, already had positive net cash flow in 2016, and this trend is set to continue in the period from 2017 to 2030.
DONIJELA JE OVU ODLUKU:
In this regard, SET will contribute more to restoring the viability of the rest of the Areva Group through the scheduled payment of dividends than it will benefit from the effects of the aid.
Članak 1.
Nor does the Commission see any risk that EDF would favour New Areva NP to the detriment of Urenco for its supply of enriched material.
Državna potpora koju Francuska namjerava provesti u korist grupe Areva u iznosu od 4,5 milijardi EUR spojiva je s unutarnjim tržištem u skladu s člankom 107. stavkom 3.
Firstly, there will be no capital link between EDF-controlled New Areva NP and New Areva which would justify EDF favouring the latter over its competitors.
Ugovora o funkcioniranju Europske unije i uvjetima predviđenima člankom 2. ove Odluke.
The Commission notes in this regard that EDF does not appear to have favoured the Areva Group in the past, since Urenco currently satisfies a significant portion of EDF's enriched uranium requirements.
Članak 2.
Secondly and in turn, the absence of a capital link eliminates any incentive for New Areva to offer more advantageous conditions to New Areva NP than to another customer, because it will no longer be able to partially recoup the benefits as a shareholder that it would grant as a supplier.
Provedba potpore iz članka 1. ove Odluke podliježe ispunjavanju sljedećih uvjeta:
With regard to the increase in excess capacity on the European enrichment market, the Commission notes that the French authorities have undertaken to ensure that, during the restructuring period, the Areva Group does not increase the capacity of its Georges Besse II plant, with the exception of the acquisition and installation of centrifuges planned in its existing agreements […].
ASN mora donijeti mišljenje o rezultatima programa jamstava u pogledu problematike odvajanja ugljika otkrivenog u dijelovima reaktorske posude EPR-a u projektu Flamanville 3, pri čemu to odvajanje ne dovodi u pitanje prikladnost dijelova reaktorske posude za rad ili, umjesto toga, EDF mora donijeti odluku, koju mora dostaviti grupi Areva s obzirom na prodaju Nove Areve NP, o uklanjanju suspenzivne klauzule koja se odnosi na reaktor EPR projekta Flamanville 3 u pogledu odvajanja ugljika otkrivenog u dijelovima posude tog reaktora;
Furthermore, the Areva Group has not expanded this activity in the past decade […].
Plan za restrukturiranje grupe Areva, kako ga je predložila Francuska, u potpunosti je proveden.
On the issue of MOX, the Commission demonstrated in recitals 356 to 360 that the divestment of New Areva NP would have adverse effects on that segment's long-term growth, thereby increasing the size of the market accessible to producers of conventional fuels, such as Urenco.
Francuska Komisiji dostavlja polugodišnja izvješća o ispravnoj provedbi plana za restrukturiranje, položaju grupe Areva na tržištima na kojima djeluje te o ispunjavanju obveza koje je preuzela Francuska u okviru ove Odluke.
There is therefore no justification for obtaining additional measures in this market segment.
Ta se izvješća moraju dostavljati tijekom čitavog razdoblja restrukturiranja od datuma obavijesti o ovoj Odluci.
In a general sense, the Commission emphasises that the loss of synergies arising from the divestment of New Areva NP will generate opportunities for New Areva NP's competitors in the enrichment segment, especially in the specific circumstances described in recitals 353 and 360.
Komisija mora primiti prvo izvješće u roku od šest mjeseci od datuma obavijesti o ovoj Odluci.
In the light of these factors, the Commission does not believe compensatory measures, in addition to the divestment of New Areva NP and the commitments given by France, to be justified in the enrichment segment.
Francuska obavještava Komisiju o nastanku jednog od dvaju događaja iz članka 2. točke (a) ove Odluke.
With regard to back-end fuel-cycle operations (nuclear waste reprocessing and MOX production), the Areva Group holds a market share of around [50-100] % [60] on the reprocessing market and is currently the only company handling all spent-fuel reprocessing and recycling and MOX production operations.
Članak 4.
The restructuring aid does not create any obvious distortion of competition insofar as the Areva Group is the only operator in this segment.
Ova je Odluka upućena Francuskoj Republici.
The Commission concedes that MOX is a competitor of conventional fuel, for which New Areva will have competition from other suppliers.
Sastavljeno u Bruxellesu 10. siječnja 2017.
However, for the reasons described in recitals 356 to 360, additional measures are not justified in this market.
Za Komisiju
Finally, logistics and decommissioning are relatively minor markets for the Areva Group, in which it will not hold a particularly significant position after the restructuring.
Članica Komisije
As regards logistics, for example, in 2013 the Areva Group held a market share in terms of volume of around [0-50] % for the production of packaging needed for the dry storage and transportation of spent fuel (‘casks’), with the German company GNS holding [50-100] % of this market.
SL C 301 od 19.8.2016., str. 2.
On the decommissioning market, New Areva will have a market share of approximately [0-20] % and will be in competition with a large number of other companies (Onet, Vinci, Bouygues, Westinghouse, Amec, Nukem, Iberdrola, etc.).
Upućivanje na bilješku br. 1.
No especially obvious distortion of competition has been brought to the attention of the Commission during the investigation into these markets, on which there is no excess capacity.
Taj je subjekt opisan u uvodnoj izjavi 33. ove odluke.
Specific additional measures for these markets are not, therefore, justified.
Iskorišteno gorivo uklonjeno iz nuklearnog reaktora sadržava 94 – 95 % uranija (osiromašenog) i 1 % plutonija; a obje se tvari mogu reciklirati u „novo” gorivo za nuklearne elektrane u obliku goriva MOX (engl. „Mixed Oxyde Fuels”).
In light of the above, the Commission concludes that, following the divestment of New Areva NP by the Areva Group and the commitments given by France, no distortion of competition justifying an additional measure will exist on the markets on which the Areva Group will hold a significant position after the restructuring.
Ako nije navedeno drugačije, u nastavku odluke izraz „djelatnost povezana s reaktorima” obuhvaća i gorivne sklopove.
Concluding its analysis of the measures taken to limit the distortions of competition created by the aid, the Commission notes the commitments given by the French authorities to comply with point 84(a) and (b) of the Guidelines.
Uzimajući u obzir njihovo kratkoročno ustupanje, djelatnosti Areve NP, Areve TA i Canberre nisu uključene u konsolidirani promet grupe Areva za 2015.