natgillin/translations-raw huggingface dataset:
Therefore, the aid could be granted up to a maximum rate of 100 % to cover the cost of accurately described activities, in particular training and education.
Mjera je provedena u skladu sa Smjernicama 2000.–2006. kao oblik tehničke pomoći u skladu s točkom 14.1.
The eligible costs could include the actual cost of organising the training programme, travel and subsistence expenses together with the cost of the provision of replacement services during the absence of the farmer or the farm worker.
Svrha je mjere bila poboljšati učinkovitost i stručnost poljoprivrede u Zajednici te time pridonijeti dugoročnoj gospodarskoj održivosti sektora.
This case relates to training for farmers on the abovementioned subjects and thus the requirements laid down in point 14.1 of the 2000-2006 Guidelines were satisfied.
Državna natjecanja u prikupljanju i kvaliteti koja organizira LVMB provedena su u skladu s točkom 14.1. četvrtom alinejom kao „Veranstaltung von Wettbewerben” (organizacija natjecanja).
The requirements laid down in point 14.2 were also satisfied as all natural and legal persons in the area concerned had, in principle, an opportunity to participate in the training, based on objectively defined criteria.
U svojim primjedbama od 27. veljače 2015.
The maximum allowable limit of EUR 100000 was not exceeded as around EUR 125 was paid in aid per beneficiary over three years, in accordance with the criteria laid down in point 14.3.
Njemačka je tvrdila da su se društva iz Brandenburga koja su pobjeđivala u natjecanjima na Međunarodnom zelenom tjednu (IGW) istaknula i time postala poznata većem dijelu javnosti.
Hessen granted financial support for public relations activities aimed at educating consumers on milk and milk products, including their nutritional values and uses.
Za te je potrebe 2006. potrošen iznos od oko 463 EUR osiguran LVMB-u iz pristojbi za mlijeko [16].
The nutrition team of LVMH disseminated scientific knowledge in a generally understandable form, organised information events and campaigns (not directed to specific businesses), and conducted PR activities in the form of flyers, brochures, handouts, recipes or posters related to the production, treatment and processing of milk and dairy products.
LBV je u okviru projekta „Milcherzeugerberatung” (savjetovanje proizvođačâ mlijeka) organizirao savjetodavne usluge putem svojih savjetnika za mlijeko dostupne svim dionicima u mliječnoj industriji.
In its comments dated 20 September 2013 [18], Germany claimed that measure HE 3 did not constitute a State aid because no individual undertakings or branches of production were favoured.
Sredstva su osigurana u obliku sufinanciranja iz pristojbi za mlijeko, kao dio sredstava projekta.
The measure constituted ‘pure consumer education’.
Državna potpora nije bila ograničena na odabrane skupine.
In the alternative, Germany argued that the aid was compatible with the internal market.
Sve zainteresirane osobe u relevantnom sektoru mliječne industrije imale su jednaku priliku sudjelovati u stručnim natjecanjima.
If the measure were classified as State aid, contrary to the view expressed by Germany, it would, in any event, have been in accordance with the decision-making practice prevailing at the time and therefore be regarded as materially legitimate.
Stoga su uvjeti utvrđeni u točki 14.2.
The measure was not limited to a particular group, but supported the entire dairy sector in a general manner.
Smjernica 2000.–2006. ispunjeni.
Thus the conditions indicated in point 14.2 of the 2000-2006 Guidelines were observed.
U okviru te mjere inovacijski tim LVMH-a pripremio je znanstvene informacije u kontekstu specijalističkih članaka i osposobljavanja.
The actual amount of the grants was well below the applicable threshold of EUR 100000 per beneficiary within three years (point 14.3 of the 2000-2006 Guidelines).
Njemačka je tvrdila da su učinci na tržišno natjecanje bili mali [17].
Hessen granted financial assistance to the LVMH for the measure ‘Training of young dairy farmers’.
Prihvatljivi bi troškovi mogli uključivati stvarni trošak organizacije programa osposobljavanja, putne troškove i troškove dnevnica, zajedno s troškom pružanja zamjenskih usluga tijekom odsutnosti poljoprivrednika ili radnika na poljoprivrednom gospodarstvu.
The purpose of this measure was to improve the skills of young dairy farmers.
Budući da se ovaj predmet odnosi na osposobljavanje poljoprivrednikâ u pogledu navedenih tema, zahtjevi utvrđeni u točki 14.1.
The eligible costs included the actual cost of organising the training programme, travel and subsistence expenses together with the cost of the provision of a replacement during the absence of the farmer or the farm worker.
Smjernica 2000.–2006. ispunjeni su.
Therefore, such aid could be granted up to a maximum rate of 100 % to cover the cost of accurately described activities, in particular training and education.
Najveći dopušteni iznos od 100000 EUR nije premašen jer je korisniku tijekom tri godine isplaćena potpora u iznosu od oko 125 EUR, u skladu s kriterijima utvrđenima u točki 14.3.
The described measure could be classified under point 14.1 of the 2000-2006 Guidelines, as it ultimately constituted the education and training assistance described therein.
Hessen je dodijelio financijsku potporu za aktivnosti odnosa s javnošću usmjerene na obrazovanje potrošača o mlijeku i mliječnim proizvodima, uključujući njihovu hranjivu vrijednost i načine upotrebe.
The measure included classical training in the dairy sector which was in principle open to all producers, thus satisfying the requirements laid down in point 14.2 of the 2000-2006 Guidelines.
Nutricionistički tim LVMH-a širio je znanstvena saznanja u opće razumljivom obliku, organizirao događaje i kampanje za informiranje (koji nisu bili usmjereni na određena poduzeća) te provodio aktivnosti odnosa s javnošću u obliku letaka, brošura, uručaka, recepata ili plakata o proizvodnji, tretmanu i preradi mlijeka i mliječnih proizvoda.
Aid covering up to 100 % of the costs is therefore permitted in those cases.
U svojim primjedbama od 20. rujna 2013.
The total amount of aid granted in the period 2001-2006 was about EUR 35000, not exceeding the upper threshold of EUR 100000 per beneficiary per three-year period (see point 14.3 of the 2000-2006 Guidelines).
[18] Njemačka je tvrdila da mjera HE 3 ne čini državnu potporu jer se ne daje prednost nijednom pojedinom poduzetniku ili grani proizvodnje.
(LVMN) financial support for participation in fairs and exhibitions and for the preparation of scientific information in a readily comprehensible form.
U slučaju da to nije tako, Njemačka je tvrdila da je potpora spojiva s unutarnjim tržištem.
In this context, subsidised costs included rent and equipment for exhibition premises as well as the cost of publication of factual information (brochures, recipes etc.) on milk and dairy products, including their nutritional values and uses, and on milk production in Lower Saxony.
Da se mjera smatra državnom potporom, suprotno stavu koji je izrazila Njemačka, ona bi, u svakom slučaju, bila u skladu s praksom donošenja odluka koja je prevladavala u to vrijeme te bi je se smatralo materijalno zakonitom.
The measure was coordinated by the LVMN.
Mjera nije bila ograničena na pojedinu skupinu, već se njome općenito podupirao cijeli sektor mlijeka i mliječnih proizvoda.
The technical implementation of the measure was carried out by the association itself or by third parties commissioned by it.
Stoga su uvjeti navedeni u točki 14.2.
In its comments dated 20 September 2013 [20], Germany argued that the measure was governed by the fourth indent (organisation of competitions, exhibitions and fairs) of point 14.1. of the 2000-2006 Guidelines.
Smjernica 2000.–2006. ispunjeni.
The main component of the measure was subsidising the exhibition stand of the LVMN.
U točki 14.3.
In this respect, the aid measure was considered acceptable and compatible with EU law, in Germany's opinion, if it additionally fulfilled the requirements contained in points 14.2 and 14.3.
Smjernica 2000.–2006. navedeno je da državna potpora može pokrivati do 100 % troškova.
Lower Saxony expressed the view that the relevant requirements were satisfied, since all dairy farms had benefited from the measure (2001-2006 average: around 17500 farms).
Stvaran iznos bespovratnih sredstava bio je znatno manji od primjenjivog praga od 100000 EUR po korisniku u razdoblju od tri godine (točka 14.3.
This was achieved, on the one hand, by ensuring that all dairy farms had access to the measure (point 14.2 of the 2000-2006 Guidelines) and by ensuring that the aid did not exceed EUR 100000 per beneficiary within 3 years (point 14.3 of the 2000-2006 Guidelines).
Smjernica 2000.–2006.).
NI 6 (2001-2003)
U razdoblju 2001.–2006. bilo je oko 6000 aktivnih mljekara u Hessenu, iz čega proizlazi prosječan iznos potpore od oko 170 EUR po korisniku u predmetnom razdoblju.
Lower Saxony also granted financial support for the participation of processing undertakings in fairs.
Hessen je LVMH-u dodijelio financijsku pomoć za mjeru „Osposobljavanje mladih mljekara”.
Germany claimed that the aid granted in the period between 2001-2006 was in accordance with the requirements contained in point 14.1 of the 2000-2006 Guidelines.
Svrha je te mjere bila poboljšati vještine mladih mljekara.
From 26 November 2003, the measure was based on approved State aid No 200/2003, which was in force until 31 December 2008, with a maximum aid intensity of 50 % or a maximum aid amount of EUR 70000 per beneficiary over a three-year period.
Prihvatljivi troškovi uključivali su stvarni trošak organizacije programa osposobljavanja, putne troškove i troškove dnevnica, zajedno s troškom osiguravanja zamjene tijekom odsutnosti poljoprivrednika ili radnika na poljoprivrednom gospodarstvu.
In its comments of 20 September 2013 [21], Germany argued that the measure provided aid only to enterprises active in processing and marketing (dairy plants) for their participation in fairs and exhibitions.
U svojim primjedbama od 20. rujna 2013.
That being the case, the evaluation of this measure was not governed by the fifth indent of point 14.1 (as assumed in the Opening Decision of the Commission), but by the fourth indent of point 14.1.
[19] Njemačka je tvrdila da je utjecaj na tržišno natjecanje malen.
Based on this, aid granted in the period 2001-2003 was regarded as compatible with the internal market.
Stoga se takva potpora mogla odobriti do najviše stope od 100 % kako bi se pokrio trošak točno opisanih aktivnosti, posebno osposobljavanja i obrazovanja.
In their comments dated 27 February 2015, the German authorities warrant that measure NI 6 was open to all companies active in the area of processing and marketing of dairy products in the relevant period (1 January 2002-26 November 2003 [22]) and was awarded according to objective criteria.
Opisana mjera mogla se svrstati pod točku 14.1.
Moreover, the measure was independent from membership in producer or other agricultural organisations.
Smjernica 2000.–2006. jer se, u konačnici, odnosila na pomoć za obrazovanje i osposobljavanje koja je u njoj opisana.
Only one company (Nordmilch eG) received a total amount of aid in excess of EUR 100000 under the measure in the period in question.
Smjernica 2000.–2006.).
According to the German authorities, Nordmilch eG did not fall within the definition of an SME.
U tom kontekstu subvencionirani su troškovi uključivali najam i opremu za izložbeni prostor te troškove objave činjeničnih informacija (brošura, recepata itd.) o mlijeku i mliječnim proizvodima, uključujući njihovu hranjivu vrijednost i načine upotrebe, i o proizvodnji mlijeka u Donjoj Saskoj.
They were therefore looking into recovering this individual aid.
Mjeru je koordinirao LVMN.
Lower Saxony granted financial support for general consumer information campaigns on the use of milk as a foodstuff.
Za tehničku provedbu mjere bilo je zaduženo samo udruženje ili treće osobe koje je udruženje angažiralo.
The beneficiary was the LVMN, on whose behalf the information material was created.
U tom se pogledu, prema mišljenju Njemačke, mjera potpore smatrala prihvatljivom i spojivom s pravom EU-a ako je dodatno ispunila zahtjeve iz točki 14.2. i 14.3.
In its comments dated 20 September 2013 [23], Germany claimed that the measure ‘general public relations activities’ did not constitute a State aid because no individual undertakings or branches of production were favoured.
Donja Saska izrazila je stav da su ispunjeni odgovarajući uvjeti jer su sva mljekarska gospodarstva imala koristi od mjere (prosjek za razdoblje 2001.–2006.: oko 17500 gospodarstava).
Germany argued [24] that the measure materially complied with the requirements of the Guidelines applicable at the time and could essentially be considered as provision of technical assistance in accordance with point 14.1 of the 2000-2006 Guidelines, as its purpose was the general dissemination of scientific knowledge and information about the properties of milk and dairy products.
To je s jedne strane ostvareno osiguranjem pristupa mjeri svim mljekarskim gospodarstvima (točka 14.2.
Considering an average of about 17500 milk producers in Lower Saxony in the period indicated above and a total amount of approximately EUR 6,9 million earmarked for measure NI 7 in the entire period, around EUR 395 of aid was paid per beneficiary.
Donja Saska dodijelila je financijsku potporu i za sudjelovanje prerađivačkih poduzeća u sajmovima.
NW 4 and NW 5
U svojim primjedbama od 20. rujna 2013.
North Rhine-Westphalia granted financial support for informative events and measures to raise general awareness amongst consumers and measures regarding the use of milk and dairy products and their general characteristics (sub-measure NW 4).
[21] Njemačka je tvrdila da se mjerom pružala potpora samo poduzećima koja se bave preradom i stavljanjem proizvoda na tržište (mljekarama) za sudjelovanje u sajmovima i izložbama.
The grant recipients were Landesvereinigung der Milchwirtschaft Nordrhein-Westfalen e.V.
Zbog toga ocjena ove mjere nije uređena točkom 14.1. petom alinejom (kako se pretpostavlja u Komisijinoj Odluci o pokretanju postupka), nego točkom 14.1. četvrtom alinejom.
(LVMNRW) and Landwirtschaftsverbände Rheinland und Westfalen-Lippe.
Na temelju toga potpora dodijeljena u razdoblju 2001.–2003. smatrala se spojivom s unutarnjim tržištem.
The costs of event organisation and management, consultation, education and training related to issues of the dairy industry were subsidised.
[22]) te je dodijeljena u skladu s objektivnim kriterijima.
Aid intensity amounted to up to 30 %.
Osim toga, mjera nije ovisila o članstvu u organizaciji proizvođača ili drugoj poljoprivrednoj organizaciji.
In its comments dated 20 September 2013 [25], Germany argued that no favouring of individual companies or sectors occurred under measures NW 4 and NW 5 since they were aimed at the general public.
U skladu s istim primjedbama najveći intenzitet potpore za tu mjeru bio je 48 %.
As a consequence, these measures cannot be considered as a form of technical assistance.
Samo je jedan poduzetnik (Nordmilch eG) u okviru mjere u predmetnom razdoblju primio ukupan iznos potpore koji premašuje 100000 EUR.
With some 10000 businesses holding dairy cattle over the same period, an annual amount between EUR 33,52 and EUR 49,78 was earmarked per beneficiary.
Donja Saska dodijelila je financijsku potporu za kampanje za opće informiranje potrošača o upotrebi mlijeka kao prehrambenog proizvoda.
Under measure NW 5, annual expenditure of EUR 14000 works out at around EUR 1,40 per beneficiary per year.
Korisnik je bio LVMN, u čije su ime izrađeni informativni materijali.
North Rhine-Westphalia granted financial support for the collection of relevant data that contributed to market transparency.
U svojim primjedbama od 20. rujna 2013.
Costs incurred by the Vereinigung der Milchindustrie LVMNRW during the collection, analysis and publication of relevant data related to the dairy market were eligible for funding.
[23] Njemačka je tvrdila da mjera „aktivnosti odnosa s javnošću” ne čini državnu potporu jer se ne daje prednost nijednom pojedinom poduzetniku ili grani proizvodnje.
The results were made public in the form of notices and market reports and were available free of charge to everyone.
Njemačka je tvrdila [24] da je mjera u biti usklađena sa zahtjevima iz Smjernica koje su bile primjenjive u to vrijeme te bi je se u biti moglo smatrati pružanjem tehničke pomoći u skladu s točkom 14.1.
They contributed to the transparency of the market and promoted the sharing of factual and scientific information and knowledge between different businesses in the dairy sector.
Smjernica 2000.–2006. jer je bila namijenjena općem širenju znanstvenih saznanja i informacija o svojstvima mlijeka i mliječnih proizvoda.
In its comments of 20 September 2013 [26], Germany claimed that the measure was not substantively or geographically selective.
Njemačka smatra da mjera nije bila ograničena na pojedinu skupinu, već se njome općenito podupirao cijeli sektor mlijeka i mliječnih proizvoda.
In the alternative, Germany argued that the compatibility requirements of the Guidelines had been met.
Stoga su uvjeti utvrđeni u točki 14.2.
The beneficiaries were farmers, producer groups and all stakeholders in the dairy sector [27].
Smjernica 2000.–2006. ispunjeni.
In its comments of 27 February 2015, Germany estimates the range of total annual expenditure under measure NW 6 in the period 2001-2006 to be between EUR 139400 and EUR 155900.
Njemačka tvrdi da je iznos dodijeljene potpore bio znatno manji od gornjeg praga od 100000 EUR po korisniku u razdoblju od tri godine utvrđenog u točki 14.3.
With some 10000 businesses holding dairy cattle over the same period, an annual amount between EUR 13,94 and 15,59 was earmarked per beneficiary.
Uzmu li se u obzir prosjek od oko 17500 proizvođača mlijeka u Donjoj Saskoj u prethodno navedenom razdoblju i ukupan iznos od približno 6,9 milijuna EUR namijenjen za mjeru NI 7 u cijelom tom razdoblju, po korisniku je isplaćen iznos od oko 395 EUR.
Rhineland-Palatinate and Saarland granted financial support for the dissemination of consumer information, including scientific knowledge in a generally understandable form, generic factual information on products, their nutritional benefits and suggested uses.
Sjeverna Rajna-Vestfalija dodijelila je financijsku potporu za informativna događanja i mjere za podizanje opće svijesti među potrošačima te za mjere u pogledu upotrebe mlijeka i mliječnih proizvoda te njihovih općih svojstava (podmjera NW 4).
Costs of participation in fairs and exhibitions, travel expenses, publication costs, rent paid for exhibition spaces, symbolic prizes worth up to EUR 250 per prize and winner were eligible for funding.
Sjeverna Rajna-Vestfalija dodijelila je dodatnu financijsku potporu za događanja povezana s razmjenom znanja o pitanjima mljekarske industrije među proizvođačima mlijeka (podmjera NW 5).
Promotional activities [28] or measures aimed at the products of particular companies were excluded from funding.
Subvencionirani su troškovi organizacije događanja te upravljanja, savjetovanja, obrazovanja i osposobljavanja u pogledu pitanja mljekarske industrije.
The coordination and technical implementation of the measure was carried out by Milchwirtschaftliche Arbeitsgemeinschaft Rheinland-Pfalz e.V.
Intenzitet potpore iznosio je do 30 %.
(MILAG) and the Landesvereinigung der Milchwirtschaft des Saarlandes e.V.
U svojim primjedbama od 20. rujna 2013.
(LVMS).
[25] Njemačka je tvrdila da u okviru mjera NW 4 i NW 5 pojedinačna društva ili sektori nisu stavljeni u povoljniji položaj jer su mjere bile usmjerene na opću javnost.
(88) In its comments dated 20 September 2013 [29], Germany claimed that these measures did not constitute State aid because no individual undertakings or branches of production were favoured.
Posljedica je da se te mjere ne mogu smatrati oblikom tehničke pomoći.
According to the German position, these measures constitute ‘pure consumer education’.
Osim toga, potencijalne koristi obiju mjera nisu podrazumijevale materijalnu i zemljopisnu selektivnost.
The decision-making practice of the Commission in the period 2000-2006 across several product areas and Member States indicated that the introduction of measures which were comparable with the measures at issue here was considered to be materially legal and approvable by the Commission in the abovementioned period.
Budući da je u istom razdoblju oko 10000 poduzeća držalo muzne krave, svakom je korisniku bio namijenjen godišnji iznos od 33,52 EUR do 49,78 EUR.
Germany added that even if they were classified as State aid contrary to the opinion of Germany, measures RP 1 and SL 2 were at least in accordance with the former decision-making practice and could therefore be regarded as materially legitimate.
U okviru mjere NW 5 godišnji izdatci u iznosu od 14000 EUR podrazumijevaju oko 1,4 EUR godišnje po korisniku.
According to Germany, the ‘general public relations activities’ measures were not limited to a particular group, but supported the entire dairy sector in a general manner.
NW 6
In accordance with point 14.3, the subsidies could cover up to 100 % of the costs.
Rezultati su objavljeni u obliku priopćenja i tržišnih izvješća te su bili dostupni svima bez naknade.
In its communication of 27 February 2015, Germany argued that State aid granted over a period of three years under the ceiling of EUR 100000 per beneficiary amounted to a sum between EUR 46 and EUR 73 per year per beneficiary [30].
Pridonijeli su transparentnosti tržišta i promicali dijeljenje činjeničnih i znanstvenih informacija i znanja među različitim poduzećima u sektoru mlijeka i mliječnih proizvoda.
RP 5 and SL 5
U svojim primjedbama od 20. rujna 2013.
Rhineland-Palatinate and Saarland granted financial support for consulting and training programmes for milk producers to improve the hygiene of milking equipment and the quality of the delivered milk (sub-measures RP 5 and SL 5).
[26] Njemačka je tvrdila da mjera nije materijalno ili zemljopisno selektivna.
Proven consultancy costs were subsidised up to a maximum of EUR 75000 per year in Rhineland-Palatinate and up to EUR 15000 per year in the Saarland.
U slučaju da to nije tako, Njemačka je tvrdila da su ispunjeni uvjeti spojivosti iz Smjernica.
Ongoing advisory services were excluded from the subsidy.
Korisnici su bili poljoprivrednici, skupine proizvođača i svi dionici u sektoru mlijeka i mliječnih proizvoda [27].
The coordination and the technical implementation of these measures was carried out by the Landeskontrollverband Rheinland-Pfalz e.V.
RP 1 i SL 2
(LKVRP) and the LVMS.
Porajnje-Falačka i Saarland dodijelili su financijsku potporu za širenje informacija za potrošače, uključujući znanstvena saznanja u opće razumljivom obliku, opće činjenične informacije o proizvodima, njihove prehrambene vrijednosti i predložene načine upotrebe.
In its comments of 20 September 2013 [31], Germany claimed that the special consultancy on milking technology and the measures for the improvement of the quality of raw milk in Rhineland-Palatinate and Saarland were compatible with the internal market in the period of 2001-2006.
Troškovi sudjelovanja u sajmovima i izložbama, putni troškovi, troškovi objave, najam za izložbene prostore i simbolične nagrade do iznosa od 250 EUR po nagradi i dobitniku bili su prihvatljivi za financiranje.
The aim of the measures was to offer specialist consulting in the field of milk technology and provide related advice and training for milk producers chosen on an ad hoc basis after problems (such as increased somatic cells) have been identified in the context of quality inspections of the delivered milk, with the involvement of veterinarians to improve udder health and thus the quality of raw milk.
Promotivne aktivnosti [28] ili mjere usmjerene na proizvode pojedinih društava isključene su iz financiranja.
Membership in LKVRP or LVMS was not necessary.
U točki 8.