natgillin/translations-raw huggingface dataset:
The attractiveness of the Union market was demonstrated by the fact that despite the anti-dumping and countervailing duties in force, Indian GES continued to enter the Union market.
Veel väitis HEG, et GILil on pikaajaline strateegiline leping kuumtöödeldud roheliste elektroodide (pooltoode) müümiseks GIL Cova grafiidistamistehasele.
During the period considered, India continued to be the second largest exporting country to the Union after the People's Republic of China (‘China’).
Samuti väitis HEG, et GILi strateegilise investeeringu tõttu oli komisjoni järeldus, et India eksport liitu suureneb, väär ning järeldus, et mõlemal India tootjal on ekspordi jaoks vaba tootmisvõimsust, põhineb pelgalt oletustel.
Despite a decrease between 2012 and the RIP, India maintained its exports to the Union in significant volumes and market shares as explained in recital 179 below.
Tuginedes Indiast liitu suunatud ekspordi (sh HEGi ekspordi) vähenemisele läbivaatamisega seotud uurimisperioodile järgnenud ajavahemikul, väitis HEG ka seda, et meetmete aegumisega ei suurene liitu suunatud ekspordi maht.
The possible development of export sales to the Union should measures be allowed to lapse has to be seen against the background of the overall decrease in consumption of GES in India and worldwide in combination with the spare capacity in India.
Seoses põhjendustes 149 ja 150 kirjeldatud komisjoni hinnavõrdlusega, mis hõlmab eksporti muude kolmandate riikide turgudele, esitas HEG analüüsi, milles on võrreldud HEGi keskmisi CIF-/CFR-hindu eksportimisel nelja muusse kolmandasse riiki HEGi keskmise CIF-hinnaga eksportimisel liitu, mille põhjal HEG järeldas, et tema hinnad eksportimisel nelja muusse kolmandasse riiki olid keskmiselt kõrgemad kui tema hinnad eksportimisel liitu.
This will in all likelihood increase the pressure on the Indian exporting producers to explore further export markets, in particular when considering their export oriented business model.
Seepärast väitis HEG, et liidu turg, kus hinnatase on madalam, on selles võrdluses vähem atraktiivne.
Therefore, should measures in the Union be repealed and the access to the Union market be free of either anti-dumping or countervailing duties it is indeed likely that a large part of the available spare capacity will be used for export to the Union market.
Mis puudutab HEGi väidet GILi investeeringu kohta GIL Covasse vaatlusalusel perioodil, siis GIL eksportis liidu turule väga väikese koguse.
In particular since the investigation showed that while in some exporting markets (such as Saudi Arabia, United Arab Emirates, USA) Indian exports increased in 2015, overall exports from India to other third country markets followed a decreasing trend.
Samas leitakse, et selle põhjus ei olnud üksnes GILi kõnealune investeering, vaid peamiselt suured dumpinguvastased ja tasakaalustavad tollimaksud, mida kohaldatakse GILi liitu suunatud ekspordi suhtes (kokku 15,7 %).
This indicates that on certain third countries there appears to be a limited capacity to absorb additional exports quantities.
Seepärast on dumpinguvastaste ja/või tasakaalustavate meetmete kehtetuks tunnistamise korral tõenäoline, et GIL jätkab hoolimata oma investeeringust GIL Covasse eksportimist liitu, muu hulgas võttes arvesse GILi vaba tootmisvõimsust ja liidu turu atraktiivsust, mida on kirjeldatud eespool põhjendustes 152–155.
In addition, as mentioned in recital 146, Russia has imposed anti-dumping duties on imports of GES from India.
Seoses HEGi väitega ekspordi vähenemise kohta pärast läbivaatamisega seotud uurimisperioodi tuleb rõhutada, et see eksport toimus ajal, mil dumpinguvastased ja tasakaalustavad meetmed kehtisid.
Indian exporting producers thus have limited access to this market and cannot increase or re-direct their export volumes to Russia, as showed by the drop in exports to this destination as of 2012.
Seepärast – isegi kui HEGi ekspordi maht pärast läbivaatamisega seotud uurimisperioodi vähenes – on tõenäoline, et HEGi eksport liitu dumpinguvastaste ja/või tasakaalustavate meetmed kehtetuks tunnistamise korral suureneb, võttes arvesse seda, et hoolimata kehtinud meetmetest jätkas HEG eksportimist liidu turule märkimisväärsete dumpingu- ja subsideeritud hindadega, samuti pidades silmas tema ekspordisuunitlusega ärimudelit ja vaba tootmisvõimsust, mis võib tulevikus veelgi suureneda, kui nõudlus tema toodete järele kasvab, nagu on kirjeldatud eespool põhjendustes 139–155.
Indeed, this is likely for the cooperating exporting producer that will have an incentive to further increase its already significant presence in the Union market, and even more for the non-cooperating exporting producer, which duty levels are higher as compared to the cooperating exporting producer and which almost stopped exporting to the Union market.
Muu hulgas tutvustati selles äriühingu plaani suurendada tulevikus oma tootmisvõimsust.
Conclusion on the likelihood of continuation of subsidisation
Lisaks selgitasid äriühingu esindajad kohapealse kontrolli käigus, et see plaan oli pandud ootele, võttes arvesse asjaolu, et äriühing ei kasutanud täielikult oma võimsust, ja üleilmse nõudluse vähenemist.
The foregoing analysis shows that (i) subsidised Indian imports continued to enter the Union market in significant quantities during the RIP; (ii) subsidy schemes will continue to be available in the foreseeable future; (iii) both Indian producers are export oriented and have spare capacity which could be used to increase export volumes to the Union; (iv) consumption worldwide is following a decreasing trend, thus reducing the export possibilities to certain other third markets; (v) the existence of anti-dumping measures in Russia against Indian GES further restricts export possibilities to the Indian exporting producers.
Seepärast on dumpinguvastaste ja/või tasakaalustavate meetmete kehtetuks tunnistamise korral tõenäoline, et nõudlus India grafiitelektroodisüsteemide järele liidu turul suureneb ja nii saab HEG stiimuli suurendada nõudluse rahuldamiseks oma tootmisvõimsust.
It is therefore likely that Indian GES would continue to enter the Union market in significant volumes and at subsidised prices should the measures be lifted.
Seoses HEGi väitega, milles viidatakse liidu turu ja kolmandate riikide turgude hinnaerinevusele, tuleb rõhutada, et komisjon võrdleb põhjendustes 149 ja 150 hinnavõrdluse tegemisel India eksportivate tootjate keskmisi hindu muudel kolmandatel turgudel ja liidu, mitte India tootjate hindu liidu turul.
In view of the above, in accordance with Article 18(3) of the basic Regulation, the Commission it was concluded that there is a likelihood of continuation of subsidisation should the measures in force be allowed to lapse.
Tuletagem meelde, et HEGi keskmine hind liidu turul on märkimisväärse dumpinguhinna tasemel ja lööb alla liidu tootjate keskmise hinna, mistõttu see kõnealuse võrdluse jaoks ei sobi.
After disclosure, the sole cooperating Indian exporting producer, HEG, claimed that the Commission has not considered the facts pertaining to the period after the RIP in its assessment of likelihood of continuation of subsidisation.
Eespool öeldut arvesse võttes lükatakse HEGi väited tagasi.
In this regard, the cooperating Indian exporting producer claimed that when applying Article 28 of the basic Regulation, the Commission has not taken into account the fact that GIL, the other Indian producer of GES, has made an investment in a manufacturing facility in the Union, that is Graphite Cova GmbH (‘GIL Cova’).
Seepärast kinnitatakse komisjoni järeldust, et kui meetmed tunnistatakse kehtetuks, on tõenäoline subsideerimise jätkumine.
HEG further argued that GIL has a strategic long term contract to sell baked green electrodes (which is a semi-finished product) to its graphitization facility of GIL Cova.
D. KAHJU JÄTKUMISE VÕI KORDUMISE TÕENÄOSUS
HEG also claimed that because of the strategic investment of GIL, the Commission's conclusion that exports from India to the Union will increase is incorrect and that the finding that both Indian producers have spare capacity available for exports is based on mere assumptions.
Liidu tootmisharu ja liidu toodangu määratlus
HEG also argued that the expiry of measures is not going to increase the volume of imports to the Union based on the decreasing trend of exports from India to the Union (including HEG's export to the Union) post RIP.
Läbivaatamisega seotud uurimisperioodil tootis samasugust toodet kaheksa tootjat (kaks eraldiseisvat äriühingut ja kaks kontserni).
In addition, HEG claimed that HEG's plans to increase production capacity was only the vision of its Chairman considering the favourable economic scenario of 2010.
Nemad moodustavad liidu tootmisharu alusmääruse artikli 9 lõike 1 tähenduses.
Thus, in the annual report of HEG for the year ended March 31, 2016 there are no new proposals being discussed by the board of directors for expansion of capacities anymore.
Sissejuhatavad märkused
In relation to the comparison of prices carried out by the Commission in recitals 149 and (150) with regard to exports to other third country markets, HEG submitted an analysis of its average CIF/CFR prices to four other third countries as compared to its average CIF prices to the Union and concluded that, in general, its average prices to the four other third countries were higher than its prices to the Union.
Nagu on märgitud põhjenduses 141, on grafiitelektroodisüsteemide tootmine tihedalt seotud elektrotehnilise terase tootmisega, kus grafiitelektroodisüsteeme kasutatakse elektriahjudes terasejäätmete sulatamiseks.
Therefore, HEG claimed that the Union market with lower price levels would be in comparison less attractive.
Vaatlusalusel perioodil valitsesid elektrotehnilise terase tootmise sektoris negatiivsed turutingimused – tarbimine vähenes ja see kajastus ka grafiitelektroodisüsteemide tarbimises.
As regards HEG's claim concerning the investment of GIL in GIL Cova during the period considered GIL exported a very small volume to the Union market.
Kuna Indias on vaid kaks vaatlusalust toodet eksportivat tootjat, ei ole grafiitelektroodisüsteemide Indiast ja muudest kolmandatest riikidest Euroopa Liitu importimise kohta esitatud täpseid arvandmeid, et säilitada konfidentsiaalsus vastavalt alusmääruse artiklile 29.
It is however considered that this is not only due to GIL's investment in GIL Cova, but mainly to the high anti-dumping and countervailing duties that apply to the exports of GIL India to Union (15,7 % in total).
Liidu tarbimine
In the scenario that the anti-dumping and/or countervailing measures are repealed, it is therefore likely that GIL will resume its exports to the Union, despite its investment in GIL Cova, also taking into account its available spare capacity and the attractiveness of the Union market as described in recitals 152 to 155 above.
Komisjon tegi kindlaks liidu tarbimise, liites
As concerns HEG's claim regarding the trend of exports after the RIP, it is highlighted that these exports were made while the anti-dumping and countervailing measures were in force.
valimisse kaasatud liidu tootjate müügi, võttes aluseks küsimustikule antud vastustes esitatud andmed;
Therefore, even if the volume of exports of HEG's after the RIP showed a decreasing trend, it is likely that HEG's exports to Union will increase if the anti-dumping and/or countervailing measures are repealed taking into account that despite the measures in place, HEG continued to export to the Union market at significantly dumped and subsidised prices, its export oriented business model and its spare capacity which is not excluded to increase in the future if the demand for its products increases, as described in recitals 139 to 155 above.
valimisse kaasamata koostööd teinud liidu tootjate müügi, võttes aluseks läbivaatamistaotluses esitatud andmed;
Furthermore, regarding HEG's intention to increase capacity, it is highlighted that during the on-spot verification visit in 2016, HEG showed to the case team a short movie providing an overview of HEG's group.
valimisse kaasamata koostööst hoidunud liidu tootja müügi, võttes aluseks asjaomase tootja aastaaruannetes esitatud andmed;
One of the elements presented in this movie were the future plans of the company to increase its production capacity.
impordi Indiast, võttes aluseks artikli 14 lõike 6 kohase andmebaasi andmed, ning
Moreover, the company's representatives explained during the on-spot verification that such plans were currently on hold taking into account that the company was not fully using its capacity and the decrease in the global demand.
impordi kõikidest muudest kolmandatest riikidest, võttes aluseks Eurostati andmed (TARICi koodide tasandil).
Therefore, in the event that the anti-dumping and/or the countervailing measures are repealed, it is likely that the demand for Indian GES in the Union market will increase and that HEG therefore, will have an incentive to increase its capacity to meet the demand.
Nende andmete põhjal muutus liidu tarbimine järgmiselt.
As concerns HEG's claim referring to the price differences between the Union market and other third country markets, it is highlighted that the comparison carried out by the Commission in recitals 149 and 150 is made between average prices of the Indian exporting producers on other third markets and average prices of Union producers in the Union market and not the average prices of the Indian producers in the Union market.
Tabel 2
It is recalled that the HEG's average price in the Union market is at a significantly dumped level that undercuts the Union producers' average price and is therefore not suitable for the comparison in question.
Allikas: valimisse kaasatud liidu tootjatelt küsimustikule saadud vastused, koostööst hoidunud liidu tootja aastaaruanded, läbivaatamistaotlus, Eurostat (TARICi koodide tasandil), artikli 14 lõike 6 kohane andmebaas.
In view of the above, HEG's claims are rejected.
Läbivaatamisega seotud uurimisperiood
The Commission's conclusion that there is a likelihood of continuation of subsidisation should the measures be repealed is therefore confirmed.
Liidu tarbimine (tonnides)
D. LIKELIHOOD OF A CONTINUATION OR RECURRENCE OF INJURY
Indeks (2012 = 100)
Definition of the Union industry and Union production
Liidu tarbimine vähenes vaatlusalusel perioodil 8 %.
During the review investigation period, the like product was manufactured by eight producers (two individual companies and two groups).
Täpsemalt vähenes liidu tarbimine 2013. aastal 7 %, suurenes 2013.–2014. aastal 4 % ja siis vähenes alates 2014. aastast kuni läbivaatamisega seotud uurimisperioodini uuesti 5 %.
They constitute the ‘Union industry’ within the meaning of Article 9(1) of the basic Regulation.
Nagu on märgitud põhjendustes 141 ja 168, tulenes üldine nõudluse vähenemine elektrotehnilise terase tootmise sektoris valitsenud negatiivsetest turutingimustest, sest grafiitelektroodide müügimahud sõltuvad elektriahjudes toimuva terasetootmise mahu arengust.
Preliminary remarks
Pärast avalikustamist väitis koostööd teinud India eksportiv tootja, et turuosa ja tarbimise analüüsimisel tuleks arvesse võtta liidu tootjate importi nende USAs, Mehhikos, Jaapanis ja Malaisias asuvatelt seotud äriühingutelt, mis on viimasel kolmel aastal oluliselt kasvanud.
As mentioned in recital 141 the situation of the GES industry is closely linked to that of the electrical steel industry where GES are used in the electric steel furnaces to melt steel scrap.
Liidu tarbimise arvutamisel võeti arvesse importi kõikidest muudest kolmandatest riikidest, nagu on selgitatud eespool põhjenduses 170, ja seepärast kajastub see nõuetekohaselt kogutarbimises.
In this context, during the period considered negative market conditions prevailed within the electrical steel industry, with a decrease in consumption which is also reflected in the consumption of GES.
Seepärast lükati väide tagasi.
Given that there are only two exporting producer of the product concerned in India, data relating to imports of GES from India and other third countries into the European Union are not presented in precise figures in order to preserve confidentiality pursuant to Article 29 of the basic Regulation.
Asjaomasest riigist pärit import
Union consumption
Asjaomasest riigist pärit impordi maht ja turuosa
The Commission established the Union consumption by adding:
Tabel 3
the sales of the sampled Union producers, obtained after verification of the questionnaire replies,
Impordimaht ja turuosa
the sales of non-sampled cooperating Union producers, obtained from the review request,
Allikas: artikli 14 lõike 6 kohane andmebaas.
the sales of non-sampled non-cooperating Union producer, obtained from its' annual reports,
Riik
the imports from India, based on 14(6) data base and
Impordi maht (tonnides)
the imports from all other third countries, based on Eurostat (TARIC level).
9000 – 10000
On this basis, Union consumption developed as follows:
5000 – 6000
Table 2
7000 – 8000
Source: questionnaire replies of sampled Union producers, annual reports of non-cooperating Union producer, review request, Eurostat (TARIC level), 14(6) data base.
6500 – 7500
Review investigation period
Indekseeritud impordimaht (2012 = 100)
Union consumption (tonnes)
Turuosa (%)
Index (2012 = 100)
6–7
More specifically, the Union consumption decreased by 7 % in 2013, it recovered by 4 % between 2013 and 2014, and then decreased again by 5 % from 2014 to the review investigation period.
5–6
As mentioned in recitals 141 and 168, the overall decrease in demand was a result of the negative market conditions prevailing within the electric steel sector, since the sales volumes of graphite electrodes follow the development of the volume of steel production in electric furnaces.
4–5
After disclosure, the cooperating exporting producer from India claimed that the market share and consumption analysis should take into consideration the imports made by the Union producers from their related companies in the USA, Mexico, Japan and Malaysia which would have increased significantly during the past three years.
Indekseeritud turuosa
Imports from all other third countries were duly taken into account when calculating the Union consumption, as explained above in the recital 170 and are therefore duly reflected in the total consumption.
Impordi maht vaatlusalusel perioodil vähenes.
The argument was therefore rejected.
See kahanes märkimisväärselt 2013. aastal (43 %), kasvas 2014. aastal ja kahanes uuesti läbivaatamisega seotud uurimisperioodil.
Imports from the country concerned
Kokkuvõttes vähenes impordi maht vaatlusalusel perioodil 26 %.
Volume and market share of imports from the country concerned
Komisjon tegi impordi turuosa kindlaks põhjenduses 170 kirjeldatud liidu tarbimise alusel.
Table 3
Turuosa arenes sarnaselt impordimahuga, st kahanes 2012.–2013. aastal ja kasvas 2013.–2014. aastal ning kahanes taas 2014. aasta ja läbivaatamisega seotud uurimisperioodi seisuga.
Import volume and market share
Kokkuvõttes vähenes turuosa läbivaatamisega seotud uurimisperioodil võrreldes 2012. aastaga 1,2 % võrra.
Source: 14(6) data base.
Indiast pärit impordi turuosa jäi vaatlusaluse perioodi alguses vahemikku 6–7 %.
Country
Läbivaatamisega seotud uurimisperioodi lõpuks vähenes see vahemikku 4–5 %.
India
Asjaomasest riigist pärit impordi hind
Import volume (tonnes)
Komisjon tegi Indiast pärit impordi hinnasuundumuse kindlaks artikli 14 lõike 6 kohases andmebaasis salvestatud andmete põhjal.
9000-10000
See oli laias laastus kooskõlas koostööd teinud eksportiva tootja teatatud hindadega.
5000-6000
Asjaomasest riigist liitu saabuva impordi keskmine hind muutus järgmiselt.
7000-8000
Tabel 4
6500-7500
Impordihind [25]Allikas: artikli 14 lõike 6 kohane andmebaas.
Indexed import volume (2012 = 100)
Impordihind (eurot tonni kohta)
Market share (%)
2500 – 3500
6-7
3000 – 4000
3-4
2200 – 3200
5-6
Kokkuvõttes langes keskmine impordihind vaatlusalusel perioodil 14 %.
4-5
See tõusis 2012.–2013. aastal 5 % ning langes 2014. aastal 16 % ja läbivaatamisega seotud uurimisperioodil veel 3 %.
Market share indexed
Hinna allalöömine
Import volumes were decreasing during the period considered.
Komisjon tegi kindlaks hinna allalöömise läbivaatamisega seotud uurimisperioodil, võrreldes i) valimisse kaasatud liidu tootjate tehasehindade tasemele kohandatud kaalutud keskmisi hindu tooteliigi kohta liidu turul sõltumatute klientide jaoks ning ii) vastavaid kaalutud keskmisi hindu imporditud tooteliigi kohta, millega India koostööd teinud tootja toodet müüdi esimesele sõltumatule kliendile liidu turul ning mis tehti kindlaks CIF-hinna alusel ja mida kohandati asjakohaselt dumpinguvastase/tasakaalustava tollimaksu ja impordijärgsete kulude järgi.
They dropped significantly in 2013 (by 43 %), picked-up in 2014 and decreased again in the review investigation period.
Hindu võrreldi tooteliikide kaupa samal kaubandustasandil toimunud tehingutes, tehes vajaduse korral nõuetekohased kohandused ning arvates maha tagasimaksed ja hinnaalandused.
Overall there was a decrease of 26 % during the period considered.
Võrdluse tulemus on väljendatud protsendina valimisse kaasatud liidu tootjate käibest läbivaatamisega seotud uurimisperioodil.
The Commission established the market share of the imports on the basis of the Union consumption as set out in recital 170 above.
Võrdlusest on näha, et koostööd teinud eksportiva tootja kaalutud keskmine hinna allalöömise marginaal liidu turul oli läbivaatamisega seotud uurimisperioodil 3 %.
Market share showed similar trends as import volumes, i.e. a decrease between 2012 and 2013, an increase between 2013 and 2014 and then a decrease again between 2014 and the review investigation period.
Kui aga maha arvata dumpinguvastane ja tasakaalustav tollimaks, oleks hindade allalöömise marginaal 9 %.
Overall market share decreased by 1,2 percentage points in the review investigation period as compared to 2012.
Koostööst hoidunud eksportiv tootja importis läbivaatamisega seotud uurimisperioodil vaid väga väikseid koguseid.
The market share of Indian imports at the start of the period considered was in the range of 6 % to 7 %.
Sellegipoolest hindas komisjon hinna allalöömist.
It dropped to the range of 4 % to 5 % by the end of the review investigation period.
Komisjon tegi kindlaks, et hinna allalöömise marginaal oli 12 %, lahutades arvutustest kehtestatud dumpinguvastased ja tasakaalustavad tollimaksud.
Prices of imports from the country concerned
Samas põhineb see hinnang väga väikesel impordimahul ja koostöö puudumise tõttu ei ole selles arvesse võetud tooteliike.
The Commission established the trend of the prices of Indian imports on the basis of data recorded in the 14(6) data base.
Seepärast on selle hinnangu usaldusväärsus piiratud.
They were broadly in line with the prices reported by the cooperating exporting producer.
Import muudest kolmandatest riikidest
The average price of imports into the Union from the country concerned developed as follows:
Tabel 5
Table 4
Allikas: Eurostat (TARICi koodide tasandil).
Import price [25]Source: 14(6) data base.
Muud kolmandad riigid kokku
Import prices (EUR/tonne)
Import (tonnides)
2500-3500
33000 – 35000
3000-4000
30000 – 32000
2200-3200
34000 – 36000
Overall, average import prices decreased by 14 % over the period considered.
Indeks
Import prices increased by 5 % between 2012 and 2013, decreased by 16 % in 2014 and decreased further by 3 % in the RIP.
22–23
Price undercutting
24–25
The Commission determined the price undercutting during the review investigation period by comparing (i) the weighted average sales prices per product type of the sampled Union producers charged to unrelated customers in the Union market, adjusted to an ex-works level; and (ii) the corresponding weighted average prices per product type of the imports from the cooperating Indian producer to the first independent customer in the Union market, established on a cost, insurance, freight (CIF) basis, with appropriate adjustments for anti-dumping/countervailing duty and post-importation costs.
Hind (eurot tonni kohta)
The price comparison was made on a type-by-type basis for transactions at the same level of trade, duly adjusted where necessary, and after deduction of rebates and discounts.
2400 – 3400