Don Chandler Donald Gene Chandler ( September 5 , 1934 – August 11 , 2011 ) was an American college and professional football player who was a punter and placekicker in the National Football League ( NFL ) for twelve seasons in the 1950s and 1960s . Chandler played college football for the University of Florida , and thereafter , he played professionally for the New York Giants and the Green Bay Packers of the NFL . Early years . Chandler was born in Council Bluffs , Iowa . He attended Will Rogers High School in Tulsa , Oklahoma , and he played for the Will Rogers Ropers high school football team . College career . After graduating from high school , Chandler first attended Bacone College in Muskogee , Oklahoma , and then transferred to the University of Florida in Gainesville , Florida , where he played halfback , punter and placekicker for coach Bob Woodruff ' s Florida Gators football team in 1954 and 1955 . As a senior in 1955 , Chandler led all major college punters with an average kick of 44 . 3 yards , narrowly beating out Earl Morrall of the Michigan State Spartans . Memorably , Chandler also kicked a 76 - yard punt against the Georgia Tech Yellow Jackets in 1955 , which remains tied for the second longest punt in Gators history . Woodruff ranked him and Bobby Joe Green as the Gators ' best kickers of the 1950s . Chandler graduated from Florida with a bachelor ' s degree in 1956 , and was later inducted into the University of Florida Athletic Hall of Fame as a " Gator Great . " Professional career . After college , he was selected in the fifth round ( fifty - seventh pick overall ) of the 1956 NFL Draft , and played with the New York Giants and Green Bay Packers . He played in the first two overtime games ever in the NFL , in 1958 with the Giants against the Baltimore Colts and again in 1965 when he kicked the winning field goal for the Packers against the same Colts in a Western Conference playoff game at Green Bay . Chandler ' s fourth - quarter field goal that tied the game at 10 – 10 stirred controversy , as many Baltimore players and fans thought he missed the kick to the right . Chandler was named the punter on the NFL 1960s All - Decade Team . He went to the Pro Bowl after the 1967 season . He led the NFL in average yards per punt with 44 . 6 yards in 1957 and led the league with a field goal percentage of 67 . 9 percent on nineteen of twenty - eight attempts in 1962 . Chandler still holds the record for most field goals scored in a Super Bowl with four in the 1968 Super Bowl against the Oakland Raiders , clinching the championship for the Packers . Chandler helped Vince Lombardi ' s Green Bay Packers teams win Super Bowls I and II . Memorably , he kicked a ninety - yard punt against the San Francisco 49ers in 1965 . He was named to the All Pro team in 1967 . In his twelve - season NFL career , Chandler played in 154 regular season games , kicked 660 punts for a total of 28 , 678 yards , 248 extra points on 258 attempts , and ninety - four field goals on 161 attempts . He also rushed for 146 yards on thirteen carries , and completed a perfect three passes on three attempts for a total of sixty - seven yards . Life after football . Chandler was inducted into the Packer Hall of Fame in 1975 , along with tight end Ron Kramer , defensive end Willie Davis , guards Jerry Kramer and Fuzzy Thurston and Vince Lombardi . He was selected as the premier punter for the decade in the 1960s . In 2002 , he was named to the Oklahoma Team of the Century by " The Oklahoman " and in 2003 to the list of Oklahoma ' s Greatest Athletes by the " Tulsa World " . Chandler is also a member of the Oklahoma Sports Hall of Fame and the New York Giants Wall of Fame . Chandler died at his home in Tulsa , Oklahoma on August 11 , 2011 ; he was 76 years old .