May 21 , 2009 Superstars results The May 21 , 2009 Edition of Superstars is a Professional wrestling television show of the WWE , it was taped at the Freedom Hall in Louisville , Kentucky on May 18 , 2009 . Summary . Just four days after the gavel dropped for many Superstars at Judgment Day , six men faced off in three , separate grueling bouts - including an ECW Title Match - during " WWE Superstars " Thursday night on WGN America . Don ' t know where to catch " WWE Superstars " ? Find WGN America in your area . Can ' t see " WWE Superstars " on WGN America in your area ? Stay with WWE . com for full results , photos and video clips of all the action . After challenging Tommy Dreamer to face him for his ECW Title , Christian and the ECW Original fought to a No Contest after Jack Swagger interjected himself into the fray . On Sunday , Captain Charisma outsmarted " The All - American American , " and ended up walking out of Judgment Day as champion . This did not please Swagger , who had lost his championship rematch just days prior . And , to add fuel to the two - time All - American ' s fire , Christian challenged Dreamer to a title match Thursday night . As would be expected from the two ring warriors , Christian and Dreamer both fought valiantly against one another with the much coveted ECW Title on the line - that is - until Swagger made himself an unwanted addition . Despite the former champion ' s interference resulting in a quick exit courtesy of the ECW Champion and his challenger , Swagger was the one smiling as he walked to the locker room . What was " The All - American American " smiling about ? Does Swagger have something planned for this Tuesday night following his disruption on " WWE Superstars " ? And , will Tommy Dreamer get another opportunity to go for the Extreme gold before his contract expires next month ? Last week on Raw , Kofi Kingston was on the winning side of tag team action against William Regal & Matt Hardy . This week on " WWE Superstars , " The Jamaican Superstar continued his winning ways as he outshined the Englishman in one - on - one action . Although both have clashing mat styles , Kingston & Regal proved to be fierce competitors as they took each other to their limits . As it appeared that William Regal was closing in on the former Intercontinental Champion , looking to deliver a vicious knee with his exposed knee brace , all he got was a little Trouble in Paradise courtesy of the high - flying Superstar . Even though Regal is an in - ring veteran and a master of his craft , Kingston ' s winning streak continued , and the Englishman was sent to the locker room trying to get his head back on straight . Both Jericho and The Straightedge Superstar were looking to avenge their respective losses from Judgment Day as they met on " WWE Superstars . " Ultimately , it was Mr . Money in the Bank , CM Punk , who proved victorious , but Jericho had the last laugh . This wasn ' t the first time these two have done battle , and much like their past encounters , could be considered a tutorial on the intestinal fortitude it takes to become a top WWE Superstar . All the way to the finish , the two ring titans were evenly matched , with Jericho reversing the Go To Sleep into the Walls of Jericho . But Punk fought back , countering the nefarious Superstar ' s lethal submission maneuver into a roll - up for the win . It was no surprise that the first - ever Undisputed Champion was not pleased with the end - result , and he aired his frustrations by nailing a Codebreaker on the celebrating Mr . Money in the Bank , leaving Punk writhing in pain as " WWE Superstars " went off the air .