Yu - Gi - Oh ! ZEXAL - Episode 077 " Rule Duel " , known as " Disorderly Duels Are Against School Rules ! ? Sally Forth ! Special Disciplinary Commander " in the Japanese version , is the seventy - seventh episode of the " Yu - Gi - Oh ! ZEXAL " anime . It first aired in Japan on October 28 , 2012 and in the United States on September 7 , 2013 . Featured Duel : Yuma Tsukumo vs . Carlyle Chesterton . For this duel , Caswell Francis may return cards to a player ' s hand . Turn 1 : Yuma Yuma draws . He then Normal Summon s " Gagaga Magician " ( 4 / 1500 / 1000 ) in Attack Position . Caswell returns " Gagaga Magician " to Yuma ' s hand as its attire is a violation of the school ' s dress code . Yuma Set s a card . Turn 2 : Carlyle Carlyle draws " Mirror Stage of Discipline " and subsequently activates it . Now the ATK and DEF of all of Carlyle ' s face - up monster s will remain at their original value s . He then Normal Summons " Tamagushi the Righteous " without Tribute via its own effect by reducing its ATK to 0 , however " Mirror Stage of Discipline " prevents the ATK of " Tamagushi " from decreasing ( 6 / 1000 / 2200 ) . As he control s a " Priestess " monster , Carlyle Special Summon s " Sakaki the Honor Student " ( 6 / 1600 / 1200 ) in Attack Position via its own effect , though it may not attack this turn . Carlyle overlays " Tamagushi " and " Sakaki " in order to Xyz Summon " Norito the Moral Leader " ( 6 / 2700 / 2000 , ORU : 2 ) in Attack Position . " Norito the Moral Leader " attacks directly , but Yuma activates his face - down " Impenetrable Attack " to reduce the Battle Damage he would take to 0 . Carlyle then activates the effect of " Norito the Moral Leader " to negate and destroy " Impenetrable Attack " by detach ing an Overlay Unit ( " Norito the Moral Leader " : 2 → 1 ORU ) . The direct attack continues ( Yuma : 4000 → 1300 LP ) . Carlyle Sets a card . Turn 3 : Yuma Yuma draws . He then Sets a monster . Carlyle activates his face - down " Surprise Inspection " to switch Yuma ' s set " Gagaga Girl " ( 3 / 1000 / 800 ) in Attack Position . This would be a violation of the dress code , so Caswell moves to return " Gagaga Girl " to Yuma ' s hand . Yuma activates " Clear Robe " to reduce the ATK and DEF of " Gagaga Girl " to 0 in order to prevent it from leaving the field , but Carlyle activates the effect of " Norito the Moral Leader " to negate and destroy " Clear Robe " ( " Norito the Moral Leader " : 1 → 0 ORU ) . Therefore , Caswell ' s ruling stands and " Gagaga Girl " returns to Yuma ' s hand . As Yuma controls no monsters and the effect of a Spell / Trap Card he used was negated , Yuma activates the effect of " Tatakawa Knight " to inflict 1500 damage to Carlyle by sending " Tatakawa Knight " from his hand to the Graveyard ( Carlyle : 4000 → 2500 LP ) . Yuma activates " Monster Reborn " to revive " Tamagushi " ( 6 / 1000 / 2200 ) in Defense Position and under his control . Yuma Sets a card . Turn 4 : Carlyle At this point , Carlyle tries to get Caswell to negate the effects of " Tatakawa Knight " and " Monster Reborn " due to them being acts of school violence and stealing respectively , however Caswell finds these declarations unreasonable and unjustified . After a conversation with Yuma , Caswell stops the ruling , so the duel will be conducted as a Normal Duel from this point . Carlyle draws " Rank - Up - Magic Barian ' s Force " and subsequently activates it to Rank - Up " Norito the Moral Leader " via Chaos Xyz Evolution in order to Xyz Summon " Chaos Xyz Simon the Great Moral Leader " ( 7 / 3000 / 2500 , ORU : 1 ) in Attack Position . Carlyle activates the effect of " Simon the Great Moral Leader " to detach " Norito the Moral Leader " ( " Simon the Great Moral Leader " : 1 → 0 ORU ) and switch " Tamagushi " to Attack Position . " Simon the Great Moral Leader " attacks " Tamagushi " , but Yuma activates his face - down " Half Unbreak " to prevent the destruction of " Tamagushi " by battle and halve the Battle Damage he takes ( Yuma : 1300 → 300 LP ) . As " Simon the Great Moral Leader " battled and its target was not destroyed by battle , Carlyle activates " Double Check " to destroy " Tamagushi " . Turn 5 : Yuma Yuma draws " Gagagawind " . He then Normal Summons " Gagaga Magician " ( 4 / 1500 / 1000 ) in Attack Position . Yuma then activates " Gagagawind " to Special Summon " Gagaga Girl " ( as it ' s a " Gagaga " monster ) in Attack Position with its Level increased by one ( 3 → 4 / 1000 / 800 ) . Yuma then overlays " Gagaga Magician " and " Gagaga Girl " in order to Xyz Summon " " ( 4 / 2500 / 2000 , ORU : 2 ) in Attack Position . As " Gagaga Girl " was used as an Overlay Unit for an Xyz Summon with another " Gagaga " monster , Yuma activates the effect of " Gagaga Girl " in order to reduce the original ATK of " Simon the Great Moral Leader " to 0 ( " Simon the Great Moral Leader " : 3000 → 0 ATK ) . " Utopia " attacks and destroys " Simon the Great Moral Leader " ( Carlyle : 2500 → 0 LP ) . Featured cards . The following cards appeared in this episode . Cards in italics debuted here .