May 4 , 2010 NXT results The May 4 , 2010 Edition of NXT is a Professional wrestling television show of the WWE , which took place at the North Charleston Coliseum in North Charleston , South Carolina . Summary . The remaining winless NXT Rookies , Daniel Bryan and Michael Tarver , met for the first time in singles action Tuesday , deciding who ’ d enter the second Pros ’ Poll without a victory . Tarver finally earned his first victory over Bryan , who was noticeably ailing from the beating he took by Batista the previous night on Raw . Bryan suffered through three monstrous Batista Bombs when his WWE Pro , The Miz , cited medical reasons for being unable to compete , sending his NXT Rookie in his place to fight The Animal . Bryan ’ s loss was capped off by a backstabber by Tarver ’ s WWE Pro , Carlito , as The Miz looked on approvingly . Tarver ’ s win upped his record to 1 - 7 , while Bryan ’ s fell to 0 - 10 . Considering Tarver has refused to compete in the Rookie Challenges , was his victory too little too late or was it enough to impress the WWE Pros just one week before the second Pros ’ Poll ? Will Bryan continue to hold the No . 1 spot with the WWE Pros with such a dismal record ? During last week ’ s Seal the Deal Challenge , NXT Rookie Darren Young tried to convince the WWE Universe to purchase WWE merchandise so he ’ d be able to face his own WWE Pro , CM Punk . But Young ’ s bold words weren ’ t what Punk and the Straight Edge Society wanted to hear . NXT Rookie David “ A - List ” Otunga ’ s wish was granted after winning last week ’ s Seal the Deal Challenge . He earned the opportunity to face the WWE Pro of his choice , and picked his own mentor – R - Truth . While these two have clashed throughout the last 10 weeks of competition , their rivalry climaxed with R - Truth ’ s victory over Otunga on Tuesday ’ s WWE NXT . R - Truth defeated his NXT Rookie with a corkscrew back elbow , but Otunga had to compete mere minutes after running the grueling Obstacle Course Challenge . Otunga ’ s record fell to 4 - 4 . Is this the end of the contention between “ A - List ” and his WWE Pro ? Will Otunga ’ s choice of opponent affect his standing in next week ’ s crucial Pros ’ Poll ? One part of being a WWE Superstar is overcoming obstacles , and NXT Rookie Justin Gabriel did just that Tuesday . He completed the Obstacle Course Challenge in the fastest time – 1 minute , 29 seconds – earning the best prize yet – an Immunity Pass . That means next week when the second Pros ’ Poll is revealed , Gabriel cannot be eliminated , no matter the circumstances ! When Gabriel learned he was the winner , he called out fellow NXT Rookie , David Otunga , telling him that his ego outweighs his talent ! The NXT Rookies have competed against each other in matches , and have had their minds and bodies tested through special challenges . Next week on WWE NXT , the second Pros ’ Poll will be revealed , and the NXT Rookie ranked in eighth place – in last – will be eliminated from the competition ! The NXT Rookies have worked hard to not only survive the intensifying pressure , but also thrive on it to become WWE ’ s newest breakout Superstar . The winner will earn a title match against the champion of his choice , live on pay - per - view . But next week , one NXT Rookie ’ s dream will be over . Who will be the first eliminated ? Hoping to leave a lasting impression on the WWE Pros and the WWE Universe , the NXT Rookies had 30 seconds each to express why he should survive next week ’ s elimination after the second Pros ’ Poll . While most of the NXT Rookies defended themselves , Daniel Bryan pointed out he ’ s winless and said he should leave . Michael Tarver did the same , but told his fellow competitors , “ I ’ m the most dangerous Rookie on NXT , ” as the WWE Universe booed . Many of the NXT Rookies agreed it should be Tarver who leaves , but Darren Young called out each of his opponents and singled out Wade Barrett , ending WWE NXT with a brawl . Which NXT Rookie has impressed you most ? Who do you want to stay in the competition ? Vote now in WWE . com ’ s WWE NXT poll and learn the results next week when the Pros ’ Poll reveals the Rookie Rankings . With next week ’ s critical Pros ’ Poll just days away , the NXT Rookies gave it their all to impress the WWE Pros and the WWE Universe . While one NXT Rookie finally earned himself a victory , another remained winless , and a third shockingly earned immunity !