Renault Mograine Scarlet Commander Renault Mograine was the young commander of the military forces of the Scarlet Crusade at Scarlet Monastery . He was a level 40 elite paladin boss located in the Crusader ' s Chapel of the Cathedral in the Scarlet Monastery . Biography . The Ashbringer . Renault Mograine was the older son of Highlord Alexandros Mograine — also known as the Ashbringer because of the sword he wielded against the undead . When the first hint of the plague of undeath started to spread around Lordaeron , he lived in a farmhouse in Brill with his father and brother ( his mother , Elena died due to post - partum complications when his younger brother , Darion , was born ) . He joined the Silver Hand at a relatively young age ( believed to be about fifteen ) soon after the end of the Third War . The Grand Crusader Saidan Dathrohan ( the mortal form of the Dreadlord Balnazzar ) had struck a deal with Kel ' Thuzad ( the lich who served as the Scourge overlord in the Plaguelands ) to kill Alexandros ; Dathrohan / Balnazzar would be in a position to take over the Crusade and Kel ' Thuzad would be rid of a great threat to his hold in Lordaeron . To that end , Dathrohan recruited young Renault by promising him great power and prestige in his Crusade if he could kill his father . Under the pretext that Darion had been kidnapped by the undead , Renault sent Mograine and his adviser Fairbanks to near the ruined city of Stratholme — the primary fortress of the Scourge in Lordaeron — where they were to be ambushed . Fairbanks fell relatively early on , but Mograine was able to destroy wave after wave of the Scourge attackers . Mograine weakened during the long battle , however , and dropped his sword to the ground ; this was the opportunity Renault had waited for . Coming from behind his father , the boy picked up Ashbringer and ran it through Mograine ' s heart , killing the Highlord and fouling the blade . . . thus dooming both to the service of Kel ' Thuzad . As promised , Renault was promoted to Scarlet Commander and sent to the Monastery in Tirisfal as commander of operations . His treachery would not be forgotten , though , by the now - death knight Highlord Mograine . His brother Darion and a small contingent from the Argent Dawn entered into the necropolis Naxxramas and destroyed the corrupted Highlord , unaware that the elder Mograine ' s spirit still resided in his weapon . Darion took the fouled blade and traveled to the Scarlet Monastery to see Renault . Renault flew into a rage upon seeing the blade in his brother ' s hands and began beating Darion . However , Highlord Mograine was to have his revenge . . . Chained to the blade , Alexandros ' s corrupted spirit appeared in the chapel and confronted his horrified son with his treachery . Alexandros then lashed out , killing the Scarlet Commander instantly . Thus , as had happened in the reverse five years earlier , Renault Mograine was killed by his own father , an act of revenge that would not be forgotten by any who witnessed it that day . In World of Warcraft . in the Hillsbrad Foothills instructed Alliance players to kill Mograine as part of , while in the Undercity instructed Horde players to kill him to fulfill . However , these attempts to end the Commander ' s life seem to have failed , as he is in the end slain by his own father ' s spirit as part of the event . Mograine and Whitemane were part of a scripted two - part boss fight . After clearing the Crusader ' s Chapel of the other Crusaders ( every nook and cranny in the Chapel MUST be cleared , to avoid being attacked by the trash during the battle with Mograine ) you could safely aggro the Scarlet Commander . Only the patrolling trash will respawn , so you could take as long as you like on the stationary mobs in the cathedral . He used Hammer of Justice ( 3 sec stun ) , Crusader Strike ( increases holy damage on target ) , Retribution Aura , and Divine Shield ( invulnerable for 10 seconds ) . He hit hard and could take a lot of pain — but he did not heal . After he died , High Inquisitor Whitemane came out and attacked ; once she reached about 40 - 50 % , she sleeped the entire group ( even any high level help you might have ) and resurrects Mograine . According to popular belief , it is thought that you need to kill Whitemane first or she will resurrect Mograine again ; she does not , but it is good to kill Whitemane first because she would heal herself and Mograine occasionally . If Whitemane was killed before she resurrected Mograine , he became unlootable ( this broke the event scripting and was a common problem in similar pre - Burning Crusade events being done by high - level and well - geared characters ) . If you kill Whitemane but died while fighting Mograine , then when you went back into the instance you would not be able to find him . You would have to go out and reset the instance . To get credit for clearing the Scarlet Monastery ( for the achievement ) you MUST have killed Morgaine and have Whitemane resurrect him otherwise he became unlootable and you didn ' t get credit for the kill ( even if you one - shotted him before Whitemane comes out ) . In Burning Crusade . Renault Mograine appears as a child in Southshore of the past via the Caverns of Time instance , Old Hillsbrad Foothills , along with Sally Whitemane ( also as a child ) , where they pre - enact how they behave in the Scarlet Monastery as adults . In Mists of Pandaria . Renault was removed with the update to Scarlet Monastery . Quotes . Old Hillsbrad Foothills quotes . In Old Hillsbrad Foothills , you are able to see younger versions of Sally Whitemane , Renault Mograine , and Little Jimmy Vishas playing around and capturing a critter next to them ( a frog ) . Sally Whitemane says : My champion , destroy this monster ! Renault Mograine says : The infidel shall be purified , milady ! Renault Mograine says : ARGH ! It has struck a fatal blow ! I have failed you . . . " ( Renault Mograine staggers about as if he were mortally wounded . ) " Sally Whitemane says : Mograine has fallen ! You shall pay for this treachery ! Arise , my champion ! Arise ! " ( Sally Whitemane pretends to cast a healing spell on Renault . ) " Renault Mograine says : At your side , milady ! Sally Whitemane says : We will attack as one ! Sally Whitemane says : We are victorious ! Old Scarlet Monastery . Aggro : " " Infidels . They must be purified ! " " Resurrected : " " At your side , milady . " " Killing A Player : " " Unworthy . " "