Hero : Scarlett or Baroness 3. Buffy the Vampire Slayer : Kristy Swanson or Sarah Michelle Gellar 2. Shannen Dohrety replacement : Tiffany Thiessen (“ 90210 “) or Rose McGowan (“ Charmed “) 1. Bikini goddess : Phoebe Cates (“ Fast Times At Ridgemont High “) or Carrie Fisher (“ Return