claim: Offers of appointment to the Supreme Court of the United States were declined by William Howard Taft.
evidence: Rudi M. Brewster -LRB- May 8 , 1932 - September 7 , 2012 -RRB- was a United States Federal Judge , best known for 2006 ruling in a patent infringements suit against Microsoft tied to the licensing of the MP3 format .. United States. United States. Federal Judge. Federal Judge. Microsoft. Microsoft. MP3. MP3. Born in Sioux Falls , South Dakota , Brewster received a B.A. from Princeton University in 1954 and was in Navy ROTC there .. Princeton University. Princeton University. Navy ROTC. Navy ROTC. He was in the United States Navy as an aviator from 1954 to 1957 , and thereafter attended Stanford Law School while in the U.S. Naval Reserve .. United States. United States. United States Navy. United States Navy. Stanford Law School. Stanford Law School. U.S. Naval Reserve. U.S. Naval Reserve. He earned a J.D. from Stanford in 1960 , and went into private practice in San Diego , California , at the law firm of Gray , Cary , Ames & Frye .. He left the Naval Reserve in 1981 .. On May 24 , 1984 , President Ronald Reagan nominated Brewster to the United States District Court for the Southern District of California , to a seat vacated by Howard B. Turrentine .. United States. United States. Ronald Reagan. Ronald Reagan. United States District Court for the Southern District of California. United States District Court for the Southern District of California. Howard B. Turrentine. Howard B. Turrentine. He was confirmed by the United States Senate on June 15 and received commission the same day .. United States. United States. United States Senate. United States Senate. While on that court he tossed out February , 2006 ruling against Microsoft for patent infringements tied to the licensing of the MP3 format , worth $ 1.5 billion .. Microsoft. Microsoft. MP3. MP3. He also ruled in United States v. Bauer .. United States. United States. United States v. Bauer. United States v. Bauer. He assumed senior status on July 1 , 1998 .. senior status. senior status. He died on September 7 , 2012 .. Brewster held a fellowship with the American College of Trial Lawyers , was an associate of the American Board of Trial Advocates and served as President and chancellor  : Louis M. Welsh Inn of Court .. American College of Trial Lawyers. American College of Trial Lawyers. American Board of Trial Advocates. American Board of Trial Advocates. Louis M. Welsh Inn of Court. Louis M. Welsh Inn of Court. He was also a member of the J. Clifford Wallace Inn of Court .. J. Clifford Wallace Inn of Court. J. Clifford Wallace Inn of Court