Municipal Beautification Commission — Charleston, WV
Date: 2025-10-07
Time: 13:00

City of Charleston, West Virginia
 Municipal Beautification Commission/Tree Board
 City Services Center Conference Room - 915 Quarrier Street
 Tuesday, October 7, 2025
 1:00 PM

 AGENDA
Call to Order

 • Approval of the September 2, 2025, General Meeting Minutes
 • Treasurer’s Report (September 2025)

MBC General Matters

 • Nominating Committee Report – Barbara Rose, Susan Shumate, John Casto
 • Ruffner Park – Anna Forbes, Marlene Dial, Lois Crichton, Susan Shumate, Barbara Rose
 • The Appalachian Spring Project (Cherry/Flowering Tree Initiative) – Anna Forbes, Jason
 Testman, Brenda Craig Ellis, Lisa Dobbins, Donna Graham
 • Greenbrier Street Garden—Barbara Rose, Marlene Dial, Jason Testman
 • City Gardens Committee Update—Lois Crichton, Donna Graham, Barbara Rose
 • BID Update—Lois Crichton
 • MBC Gold Leaf Award (Mid Atlantic Chapter of the International Society of
 Arboriculture (MAC-ISA))

Tree Board Matters:

 • Tree Inventory Update—Brenda Craig Ellis & Anna Forbes

Public Grounds Report—Brent Webster

Additional Business

Adjournment

MUNICIPAL BEAUTIFICATION COMMISSION/TREE BOARD
 October 7, 2025, Meeting Minutes


Time: Tuesday, October 7, 2025, 1:00 PM

Place: Charleston Municipal Parking Building #1

Commissioners: L. Anna Forbes, Chair
 Lois Crichton, Vice Chair
 Lisa Dobbins, Treasurer
 Susan Shumate, Secretary
 John Casto (absent)
 Marlene Dial
 Mimi Dinsmore
 Brenda Craig Ellis (absent)
 Donna Graham (absent)
 Jane Powell
 Barbara Rose
 Jason Testman


Call to Order: Anna Forbes called the meeting to order at 1:00 PM.

Approval of Minutes: The minutes of the September 2, 2025, MBC meeting were circulated prior to
the meeting. A motion to approve the minutes was made and seconded and the Commission
unanimously approved the minutes.

Treasurer’s Report: The MBC currently holds $292,200.05, which includes $20,000 of a $40,000
grant from the Jacobson Foundation and accrued interest, with a usable balance of $125,162.04 after
earmarked commitments for Ruffner Park, The Appalachian Spring Project, Davis Park planters, and
Lee Street Triangle planters.

The Greater Kanawha Valley Foundation holds an additional $22,628.35 for city beautification and
Ruffner Park.

Nominating Committee: The commission voted unanimously to approve the nominating committee’s
slate of officers, reappointing Anna Forbes as Chair, and appointing Lois Crichton as Vice Chair, Lisa
Dobbins as Treasurer, and Susan Shumate as Secretary.

Ruffner Park: Safety railings will be installed on the steps on each end of the park. The park is weeded
and well maintained. Terra Care is contracted to provide quarterly maintenance to the park. There are
suckers on the large trees that need to be trimmed, and tree health needs to be evaluated.
The Appalachian Spring Flowering Tree Project (TASP): A ceremonial tree planting is scheduled
for Monday, October 20th at 11:30 AM in front of city hall with Mayor Goodwin and city council
members present. We will be planting two spring snow crab apple trees symbolizing the project’s
broader scope beyond cherry trees. This will kick off the planting plan which includes 30 trees
distributed across key locations including six cherry trees at Ruffner Park, five cherries at the base of
Airport Road/Greenbrier Street, and the upper sections of Magic Island and along the Boulevard.

The TASP subcommittee, including Anna, Jason, Brenda, Lisa, and Donna decided to scale back the
initial spring planting to approximately 50-100 trees to pilot the process and contractor relationship
before a larger 2026 fall planting. Advice from Mark Buscaino (Casey Trees) led to shifting the planting
plan from spring 2026 to late fall 2025 and early 2026 to optimize tree survival and reduce watering
needs.

Risk mitigation for the trees will include protective cages against deer and beaver damage, as needed.

The Appalachian Spring Fund at The Greater Kanawha Valley Foundation is accepting private sector
donations. The primary purpose of the fund is to support The Appalachian Spring Project and its related
activities. If this fund were to grow substantially and beyond the needs of TASP, a secondary purpose of
the fund is to support other beautification projects in southern West Virginia.

Greenbrier Street Garden: The knotweed has been terminated. The garden is ready for five trees from
The Appalachian Spring Project.

City Gardens Updates: Davis Park has been identified as a priority for future revitalization due to its
poor condition.

Maintenance workflows for flower beds have been clarified. Planning includes managing infrastructure
changes, such as relocating the urn on Virginia Street near Summers Street. Watering strategies are
being optimized by coordinating plantings of annuals and perennials.

MBC Gold Leaf Award: Brenda Craig Ellis accepted a Gold Leaf award from the Mid-Atlantic
Chapter of the International Society of Arboriculture on behalf of MBC in Maryland. The award was
given in recognition of MBC’s Arbor Day activities.

Tree Board Business: The upcoming tree inventory is about to start. Mapping will begin in Kanawha
City and continue into other areas of the city. Flowering and other trees will be added to the tree
inventory as they are planted.

Public Grounds Report: The tulips have been planted. Donna will oversee where the alliums will be
planted. The living wall parts have been ordered. The building in City Center with plumbing will need to
have limited access to avert a repeat of the incident last winter when the water for the living wall was
inadvertently turned on. The large tree at the base of Edgewood Drive is being taken down due to
disease.

Adjournment: Anna called for adjournment at 1:51 pm.