Ultimately, this is up to you and what you're comfortable with; we just want you to be happy with your shopping experience. As a preface, over 95% of our customers shop on our website opposed to Etsy. Here are the main differences:
Our Website
 We have a potato points loyalty program that you can sign-up for on the bottom right corner of your screen! Receive points for signing-up, birthdays, and every dollar spent in our shop. Accumulated points can be redeemed for various levels of shop credit.
 Products are cheaper on our website. For example, our standard sticker sheets that are 3.00USD on the website is 3.25USD on Etsy.
 The website gets first priority for special events. Sometimes we list specialty products on Etsy, however in most cases, we only host washi tape sales, vellum sales, product bundles, etc. on our website.
 As a small business, we are charged less seller fees on our website than on Etsy.
Etsy
 All of your purchases across different stores are consolidated in one place for you to keep track!
 You may feel safer purchasing through a marketplace than on a standalone website (I hope you don't hesitate to contact me if you ever have any questions or concerns!)