Top 10 Safest CarsMercedes-Benz CLA-Class. Average safety rating: 88% (5-stars) ... Mazda CX-30. Average safety rating: 86% (5-stars) ... Mazda3. Average safety rating: 86% (5-stars) ... Subaru Forester. Average safety rating: 85% (5-stars) ... Toyota Yaris. Average safety rating: 84% (5-stars) ... Nissan Juke. ... Ford Puma. ... Isuzu D-MAX.More items...