The answer to this question depends on when the axe was made. If we are talking about an axe that was made before 1966, there is no question about the quality. The original Collins company made excellent axes with years of experience. However, these axes have become vintage and are hard to find. The company that bought Collins after 1966 also made great axes. However, they weren't as good as the original ones. Finally, if you are considering the axes that were made after 2004, they are only good enough compared to the ones before. Collins axes are now cheap. But if you use your axe regularly, I recommend investing in something a bit better. And if you can find an original Collins axe, then great.