The choice for an alcoholic after shave splash or an after shave balm is of course personal. It depends on what you like or what is good for your skin.
In case of sensitive or dry skin, it is wise to use a nourishing, soothing, alcohol-free and neutral (unscented) product after wet shaving, such as an after shave balm.
After shaving, the skin pores are open. After shave with alcohol closes the pores and disinfects the skin. But it stings for a few seconds and it can (slightly) dry out or irritate the skin. Instead of after shave, it is better to use after shave balm or gel . These products have a caring and soothing effect.
In case of oily skin, an after shave balm can leave a slightly greasy film on the skin.
In the case of normal or oily skin, an aftershave with alcohol can be used. After shave with alcohol closes the pores and disinfects the skin. As the alcohol evaporates, it gives a pleasant cooling effect. The skin gets a fresh, healthy appearance.