You apparently knew he had HPV since you signed a settlement regarding his HPV 3 years ago. If you then had relations with him after that, he is NOT liable for your disease. A person is liable for giving someone a disease if they intentionally hid or lied about the disease, thereby infecting an unsuspecting person. But if you have sex with someone knowing they are infected, they are not liable--they did not and could not hide anything, since you knew of the disease, and you made the knowing and voluntary choice to be intimate. Therefore, since you had intimate relations with someone whom you already knew had been infected, he is not liable and you are not entitled to compensation for your voluntary act of having sex with this person.