The Mystery of Edwin Drood has been nominated for several Tony Awards. These include Best Direction of a Musical for Scott Ellis, Best Revival of a Musical for The Mystery of Edwin Drood, Best Revival of a Musical for Roundabout Theatre Company, Best Revival of a Musical for Todd Haimes, Best Revival of a Musical for Harold Wolpert, Best Revival of a Musical for Julia C. Levy, and Best Scenic Design of a Musical for Anna Louizos.