There may be little you can do. Given the length of time that has passed, it is probably too long to dispute the charge with your credit card provider (though you should still try to do so). If you ordered through some larger site, like eBay or Amazon, you could also contact the main website to see if they will take action. You have the legal right to sue, but doing so could cost you more than you could recover, especially if they are not a local company. You could  try contacting the attorney general's office in their state and reporting them as probably fraud, but given how many internet-based fraud's there are (and that $67.93, while a lot to you, is not a large amount in absolute terms), it may be very unlikely that the authorities will actually take an action.