Answer #1 (Stay UMC)
To try to say what the church would look like if the church disaffiliated and left the covenant relationship of the United Methodist Church is purely speculation. What we know is that in our current connection as United Methodists we have a firm grasp on what we believe. We have a strong and positive staff who love one another and who work very well together. You can read more about our beliefs as United Methodist here: https://www.ministrymatters.com/all/entry/7736/united-methodists-and-grace
And here: https://www.umc.org/en/who-we-are/what-we-believe/our-christian-roots
We know our mission, vision, and values as Auburn UMC we feel grateful for the heritage we have as United Methodists. Unfortunately in these divisive times combined with a long term process of disaffiliation everyone feels challenged. We give thanks that over 50 people have joined Auburn UMC already this year and that our Easter attendance was higher than it has been in years. Once this divisive season is behind us it will be important to evaluate and heal as we refocus on the important mission we have to “Love God, love neighbor, and make passionate disciples of Jesus Christ.”
Answer #2 (Pro-Disaffiliation)
If our clergy and staff stay with the UMC and AUMC disaffiliates, the clergy and staff will probably go to a UM church. In a year’s time after we disaffiliate, our membership numbers will be much higher, our financial situation will be much stronger, and the programs that have weakened over the past few years will be thriving again. If the clergy decides to leave, we will hire the most dynamic traditional pastor we can find, someone like Chris Montgomery at Frazer Methodist Church.