Belgian, cookie butter, speculoos, or a variety of similarly-named flavored syrups are actually more similar in taste to the pumpkin spice syrup than to this sugar cookie syrup. That's because all of those syrups include spices. Cinnamon, ginger, and nutmeg are common in those syrups, while in this sugar cookie syrup, the butter, sugar, and slight hint of frosting flavors win the day.