These are seven of the scariest episodes from American Horror Story so far. 2 Neighbors From Hell (Cult, Episode 3) 3 Piggy Piggy (Murder House, Episode 6) ... 4 Chapter 5 (Roanoke, Episode 5) ... 5 Checking In (Hotel, Episode 1) ... 6 Monsters Among Us (Freak Show, Episode 1) ... 7 Camp Redwood (1984, Episode 1) ... More items... Nov 16, 2022