Paniyaram pan is available in Indian stores or on Amazon. Click here to go to amazon: Paniyaram pan. This pan is so useful, you can not only make different variations of appe in this, but can also make any no-fry items like kofta for malai kofta. I even make hush puppies with cinnamon sugar in an appe pan and they turn out incredible. If you are not able to find a decent paniyaram pan, try this Aebleskiver or Takoyaki pan