How to Resend Your Gift Cards Redeemed from a Toasty Choice Card: Access your Toasty Choice Card from the reward email. Click on 'Redeem your Toasty Choice Card.' Click the 'Order History' icon in the top-right corner next to the cart. Find the gift card that you wish to resend, and click 'Resend.' Check your inbox! Your gift card should arrive within a few minutes.