There are a few ways to make your eyes look tired with makeup. One way is to use a dark eyeshadow shade in the crease of your eye and blend it out. This will create a shadow effect that can make your eyes look droopy and tired. Another way is to use a white or light-colored eyeliner on the lower lash line. This will make the whites of your eyes look more prominent and can give the illusion of fatigue. Finally, you can smudge some dark pencil liner on the outer corner of your eye and blend it outward to create a cat-eye effect. This will make your eyes appear narrower and more fatigued.