Sonny compelled Carly to marry him after she witnessed him shoot Lorenzo in order to avoid having to testify in court. Sonny expressed his love for her after surviving a hostage situation, and they made love, but she divorced him in order to marry Jax. They were married from May 2004 to October 2005. After divorcing Jax, she married Carlito Ballerina in November 2007. The marriage only lasted a few months before she began dating James Stemler. In April 2009, it was reported that Carly had ended her relationship with Stemler. In August 2010, it was revealed that Carly was pregnant with Stemler's child. However, she had the baby prematurely and lost the baby shortly after giving birth. In March 2011, it was reported that she had begun dating Ryan O'Reilly. The two broke up in June 2012, but got back together in February 2013. They broke up for good in September 2014. Carly Foshay is currently dating Marcus Walton. They met on the set of her new show in Los Angeles where he works as a production assistant.