I have leather, performance fabric, as well as the more affordable twill fabric all from Pottery Barn. I have had zero issues with all 3. And I like all 3 for different reasons. The twill is on a slipcover, so it is easy to throw in the washing machine. The performance fabric is super easy to clean. And the leather has been super low maintenance for us. So, long story short, it really is up to you and how you live in your home. I will say if you have a cat, read this blog post before going with a performance boucle: Our Living Room Sectional (Pottery Barn Pearce Sectional)