Fortunately, there are many dog-safe brands of peanut butter that do not have xylitol in them. For starters, we recommend sticking with human-grade, FDA-tested brands of peanut butter, as animal-grade may not go through the same quality control for mycotoxins that could remain after processing. This will be any peanut putters that you find in your grocery store vs. your pet store.
Our personal favorite peanut butter brands are the ones that only have two ingredients: peanuts and salt. We personally shop at Costco, and love their Kirkland Organic Creamy Peanut Butter for both us and our dogs.