No. Anyone can visit Chub Cay without renting or purchasing an Idol. However, those guests will not have access to the resort amenities such as the Clubhouse Restaurant and Bar, Pool Deck, Spa, Tiki Bar, surrounding areas, and will miss out on major discounts. The discounts, in most cases, cover the costs of the membership rental. Without an Idol you can ONLY access the Nauti Rooster, Fuel Dock, Posh Peacock/ Marlin Market, Marina Wash house, and Fish Cleaning House.