There are a number of insurance companies in the United States and our experts have reviewed their performance for New York homeowners. We have compared the insurers based on their overall rating, J.D. Power score and AM Best rating. Our top 3 performing homeowners insurance companies in New York are USAA, State Farm and Erie Insurance. Below are the top reviewed insurance carriers for New York residents.
Best home insurance companiesOverall RatingJ.D. Power scoreAM Best rating USAA4882A++ State Farm4835A++ Erie Insurance4835A+ AIG (American International Group)4830- Allstate4829A+ Progressive3821A+ Farmers3813A Nationwide4812A+ Safeco4810A Liberty Mutual4806A Chubb4801A++ Travelers4800A++ Hartford3798A+