Whether or not Peloton is better than Tonal depends on your fitness goals. If you're looking for cardio equipment, then yes, Peloton is likely the better choice. But if you're more interested in resistance training, then Tonal is the smarter option. Both companies provide a quality product with a fee-based monthly subscription to access classes and other programming. However, we feel the Peloton All Access Membership offers more variety and class choices than the Tonal app. Plus, the Peloton App does not require Peloton equipment.