There are numerous claims from individuals, a university, and companies that say they invented this ice cream. An ice cream consultant, Malcolm Stogo, reported that he invented Oreo ice cream in 1976, 77, or 78. Then South Dakota State claims their dairy department invented it in 1979. Blue Bell started producing cookies and cream in 1980, though Edy's/Dreyers contradicts them saying they were the first to produce it in 1982.