I personally use a combination of Olay Makeup Removing Wipes and Pond’s Cold Cream Cleanser. Both can take off waterproof mascara. As long as your makeup remover can remove waterproof mascara, you can use it to remove Sky High mascara. Just be sure not to use handwashing soap. This soap will dry out your lashes and it may not be safe for the eye area. In addition, many makeup removers come with skincare benefits. For example, Pond’s Cold Cream Cleanser also moisturizes the skin, which is why I’ve been swearing by this makeup remover for years.