Despite his stellar career, Randy Orton has not been as powerful in the ring as Roman Reigns. Orton now has 1216 wins, 1028 losses, and 69 draws, which is pretty impressive, but let's look at Reigns' records. Roman Reigns has a staggering record of 894 wins, 292 losses, and 31 ties. This shows that even though Orton has more victories than Reigns, they are over different opponents. If you asked me to choose between these two stars, I would have to say that Roman Reigns is the clear winner.