You should always trust your instinct if something feels weird about a law firm. Yet, some specific red flags to look for when searching for a new lawyer include: Poor reviews. It’s normal to see a few negative reviews in a sea of positive ones. However, if most of the reviews seem troubling, you should continue your search. An outdated website. A lawyer’s website should have routine updates. A website that offers outdated information or otherwise seems unattended could reflect poorly on a potential law firm.