I am looking to get a wheelbarrow and I have narrowed it down to either a poly or steel wheelbarrow. The wheelbarrows seem to vary in price between $200 - $400. I have heard that poly wheelbarrows are much more durable than steel. However, steel wheelbarrows are better for heavy loads and the poly wheelbarrows are better for light loads. A few things to keep in mind as you make your decision: Poly wheelbarrows are more expensive and harder to repair than steel. If you can buy a new steel wheelbarrow, do it.