Of course you can! Your right to return an item is exactly the same regardless of whether you bought it with a gift card, a payment card, or a combination of the two. If you paid for your whole order with a gift card, then the refund will be credited back to your original gift card. If you paid with a combination of gift card and another payment method, we'll refund the gift card first and then the remaining amount will be refunded back to your other payment method. Please remember: Your replacement gift card will have the same expiry date as your original gift card.