First and foremost, you should limit your search to Orthopedic Surgeons who specialize in Foot and Ankle Disorders. Orthopedic Surgeons can and often do have more than one speciality so make sure that Foot and Ankle is one of them. If they do not list foot and ankle surgery as one of their specialties it is likely that the Orthopedic Surgeon is a generalist and while they may be able to help you with your problem, they are more likely to be focused on hips, knees, and shoulders. Other factors in choosing the right Orthopedic Surgeon for your needs include getting referrals from other medical professionals you trust, reading patient reviews and knowing what treatment your insurance will cover.