If you’re looking for the feel of a down pillow, without the price tag attached, you’re looking for a fiber pillow. Fiber pillows offer synthetic alternatives to down. They provide a more affordable hypoallergenic option, while still providing the cushiness, loftiness and softness. Cotton pillows start out fluffy, but over time, flatten out a bit and become somewhat hard. They are not as puffy or plush as down or polyester pillows.