It really is a matter of preference, since there are advantages to both. A removable roof rack offers the ability to remove it, obviously, which is a great choice if you know that you’re only going to use it every once in a while. It’s a good choice for families that enjoy the summer vacation getaway, or the retired couple that is planning a second honeymoon adventure.
If however, you know that you’ll be using your roof rack for a wide range of activities and adventures, a more permanent one may be a better choice for you. They are often more secure, offer more versatility, and a greater capacity than temporary choices. If you enjoy weekly jaunts up into the mountains or spend a good amount of time outdoors searching for the next campsite, a roof rack that is a permanent fixture on your car may be a great choice.