Ryan Ashley is married to Arlo DiCristina. The couple married in a private ceremony in Colorado in the fall of 2019, according to an announcement posted on her Instagram account. Malarkey said that DiCristina proposed with a "solid marble ring that he hand carved from a block of marble from the earth where he proposed."
Instead of having a long engagement, the couple decided to get married—discreetly, just the two of them. She changed her name to Ryan Ashley DiCristina.