Shakes and shingles are both made from cedar but differ in thickness and size. Shakes are usually thicker and have a more rustic appearance, while shingles are thinner and have a more polished look. Many homeowners prefer shakes for their roofs because they provide more insulation and are more durable. However, shingles are easier to install and usually cost less. Ultimately, the decision between shakes and shingles comes down to personal preference.