A paddle air fryer is better than a basket air fryer for X and Y foods. A basket air fryer is better than a paddle air fryer for A and B foods. Neither air fryer is outright better for frying in general although paddle-type air fryers do have some advantages.
First off, because paddle-type air fryers employ a solid base, they can be used for heating dishes like risotto and some thick stews – something basket-style air fryers are not equipped to perform.
Paddle-type air fryers come with a large handle that makes them easier to move especially when it comes to flipping and removing cooked food.
Bucket-type air fryers work better for battered foods like onion rings and breaded chicken.