This is highly subjective. We have worked with both methods and in our opinion, there's no rule regarding which is best. It's argued Goodyear Welted is a more labour intensive process, hence it results in universally superior products. While in theory this is true, in reality, what determines quality goes well beyond this point. From our experience, a shoe should be judged by so much more than its construction method alone. Consider the quality of the leather, components, processes, finishings and fit just as important, if not more.It really is a matter of personal preference. Our customers have responded more positively to the Blake method as compared to our previous Goodyear Welted line. It creates a lighter and more comfortable shoe. Also Blake-stitching allows for a sleeker profile with a nicer taper around the waist which looks beautiful and increases arch support.For additional information, we recommend this article from Permanent Style.