In theory, this is possible, if the photo is well exposed and the white balance is perfect. In reality, a preset is usually used as a base. Every photo has different lighting and colors. So the presets will have a different effect on each photo. None of the presets include white balance, and photos shot during sunset or sunrise, or in shadows, are often 'bluer'/cooler than what we like, so we adjust the white balance. Some photos are heavy on the highlights and shadows or whites and blacks, so often you need to work on 'lighting' to expose your photo properly. We have a Lightroom tutorial blog post in which we explain how to work with presets and how to edit!