While I love using Peeps for this recipe because they are colorful and fun for Easter, you can easily swap them for any holiday, like Christmas Trees, Ghosts or any other Peeps shape that you prefer. You can buy Peeps at a huge discount after most holidays and stock them to make these delicious S’mores any time. Peeps work just like marshmallows in this recipe so if you can’t find Peeps or don’t have any left after the holidays, feel free to substitute regular marshmallows or even mix it up and use a jumbo marshmallow or some mini-marshmallows to make a quick and easy s’more.