Here's a list of the top 10 most valuable pennies for 2023: 1) 1944 Steel Wheat Penny - $408,000. 2) 1943 Copper Wheat Penny - $250,000. 3) 1856 Flying Eagle Penny - $25,000. 4) 1873 Indian Head Penny - $10,000. 5) 1858 Flying Eagle Penny - $10,000. 6) 1857 Flying Eagle Penny - $7,000. 7) 1914 D Wheat Penny - $5,500. More items... Mar 1, 2023