They can be as cheap as $40 and as expensive as $1000 per tire. Just like the new tires, used tires have different properties, are produced by different manufacturers, and, besides that, have indicators of wear — tread left. If you are aiming for tires that will last long, look for the more tread left! For example, here at Utires.com you can get a set of 4 driven only once Michelin Primacy Tour A/S for just for $663,89!