Spice Up Your Espresso With These 12 Toppings! Cinnamon. If you're in the mood to literally add some spice to your black coffee, a dash of cinnamon is a great idea. ... Honey. ... Butter. ... Cardamom. ... Chocolate Syrup. ... Vanilla Extract. ... Ginger Powder. ... Coconut Milk. More items... Jan 25, 2021