Technically, asphalt or metal roofing systems will both hold up to frigid temperatures, even here in Indiana. However, choosing between the two depends on factors like your budget and the longevity you're looking for. Metal roofing systems are better equipped for winter-weather performance - if it's in your budget. However, our asphalt roofing systems are sturdy; they're just not going to last as long because shingles can't sustain long-term like metal.