Warly has no favorite dish, as stated in the Don't Starve: Together Compendium. However, in the lore, many hints suggest Seafood is Warly's favorite type of food. If the player examines a Fishing Rod, Warly will state, "I do prefer the fish market...". Warly was also first introduced into Don't Starve Shipwrecked, where the seafood is bountiful, playing into his love of seafood. The final hint is in the Taste of Home animated short, where Warly cooks his mother, Mussel Bouillabaise, one of Warly's signature dishes he learned to cook from his mother.