Shakes and asphalt shingles are like apples and oranges; they're very different. Shakes are made from wood and have natural, rustic beauty that appeals to many homeowners. However, they will need regular resealing, or they may develop premature leaks. Asphalt has a more modern appearance and can vary in color to complement the house. Asphalt shingles are durable and easy to maintain. They have a relatively low price; asphalt shingles cost around $150 per square, and last around 20 years. Asphalt shingles vary in price depending on the quality and type.  By contrast, shakes are costlier, $600 per square, and depending on the type of wood used, may last somewhat longer (30 years).