Unfortunately, an insurer only needs to pay for repairing actual damage--not for color matching. The fact that you won't like the color is not a covered loss. Your options are:1) Simply accept the closest color you can find--it's on the back of your house, after all.2) As above, but paint the siding--there are some good products out there, whcih can even cover siding.3) Get the insurer to pay you what they would pay for the repairs; then pay the extra price to replace all siding yourself--i.e. go out of pocket (but for the reimbursement or offset for the actual damage) if the color matching is that important to you.Good luck.