Due to their organic nature our Stone and Wood products tend to vary from plug to plug in color, consistency, and even shape/fit. We do our best to match pairs as best we can, but since every pair is unique there is no way to match them perfectly to the photos on our site. Please keep in mind this doesn’t mean we are sending something other than what you ordered; it just means that what you ordered is unique! If you prefer something that will be exactly the same every time you buy it, we recommend you check out our wide selection of Steel, Silicone, and Acrylic plugs!