You can expect to pay between $70-$165 for a quality gym shoe. Pricier options exist, but they're not necessary unless you're a pro athlete or have an orthopedic issue that requires specialized shoes. Budget-friendlier shoes might be tempting, but they likely won't last as long as pricier options, and they may lose points for fit and comfort. The cheapest gym shoe on our list is often available for less than $70, while our top recommendation, the Nike Metcon 8 was $130 when we published this list.