91 Best Songs About Unrequited Love 1. " You Belong With Me," by Taylor Swift. 2. " If," by Janet Jackson. 3. " Stephen," by Kesha. 4. " Little Bit (Remix)," by Drake ft. ... 5. " Memphis," by Justin Bieber. 6. " I Can't Make You Love Me," by Bonnie Raitt. 7. " It Takes A Muscle," by M.I.A. 8. " Heartless," by Kanye West. More items... Mar 19, 2020