There are soooooo many different types of cheese you can go with when making this. Here are a few of my favorites: American Cheese Swiss Sharp Cheddar Muenster Provolone Pepper Jack And don’t sleep on Bleu, Feta, Havarti and Goat cheese. These types of cheeses might not scream “Grilled Cheese” but trust me they’ll elevate your classic childhood dish to suit your adult tastes.