Please don't hesitate to contact our Support Team so we can learn more about your comparison product. We're available at 800.476.0016 or https://globalhealing.com/pages/contact. While we can't say why other formulas contain a milky white substance, we can offer more details on the properties and benefits of our products. Additionally, our formula uses organic vegetable glycerin as a base to encapsulate the ingredients better. It's also thought to be more gentle on your digestive system vs. alcohol-based liquid extracts. Our organic vegetable glycerin is derived from organic mustard seeds, and it is considered low glycemic but has a sweet taste. If you need further information, please let us know.