Here we’ve compiled a few things you can look for in a replenishing lip balm. Shea butter. Antioxidant and anti-inflammatory properties that can help your lips bounce back.  Fragrance-free. Added fragrances may irritate your skin, so it’s best to skip the extra scents in your products. Our unflavored lip balm is a great option! No parabens. Parabens may irritate sensitive skin and may make your lips feel worse. Zinc or titanium oxide. Help shield your lips from UV rays. Petroleum, jelly-based lip treatments. Keep your lips hydrated and prevent future chapping. Jojoba oil. This natural oil can help repair your skin barrier and facilitate wound healing.