Yes, you can easily substitute the alcohol in this recipe with a non-alcoholic alternative such as sparkling soda water, ginger beer or even cranberry juice! Non-alcoholic versions of any cocktail can be created by brewing non-alcoholic beer or substituting water for spirits and juices. If a sweeter taste is desired, the simple syrup can also be mixed in. Other options may include adding drops of flavored extracts, such as vanilla or almond extract, to help further flavor the non-alcoholic beverage. Just make sure not to wet Santa's pants too much!