A high-quality timepiece. It can be an elegant lady's watch or a plain and simple man's watch. Either way, it should be a quality timepiece with a classic design. The face of the watch should be easy to read and the hands should be easy to see and move. If possible, have the watch personalized with the name "Judith" or "Judge Judith" on the dial. This will make it a special and unique gift that will delight her and remind her everyday of your thoughtfulness.