Yes, you can try other fillings to switch them up! If you don't like mint, leave out the extract and make white chocolate fudge filling. u003cbr/u003eu003cbr/u003eOr, skip the fudge and fill the chocolate thumbprint cookies with jam, chocolate filling (like chocolate ganache), or frosting.u003cbr/u003e u003cbr/u003eYou can also make chocolate peppermint thumbprints by swapping the mint extract for peppermint extract.