Lewis is by no means a fan favorite in the Stardew Valley community. Heck, there's a whole hate thread dedicated to him in the r/StardewValley subreddit! While I don't have as much distaste for the mayor as other players, I do think he has the wrong motivations for keeping his relationship with Marnie a secret. I also have to question why the Community Center fell into disrepair under his watch and why Robin was never approached to fix it given that she's an extremely gifted carpenter.