The answer is usually yes. It takes an experienced tinter, and is not an exact science, but can generally be done. It also works much better if you have a sample of the same wood it will be used on. This is one area we have an advantage compared to other paint stores. To match a paint, a machine does most of the work, but to match a stain takes a person and a keen eye to how wood and stain combine, and the effect of weathering on a finish.