The garter toss tradition can be controversial due to various reasons. Some perceive it as tacky or embarrassing, while others believe it singles out single individuals or pressures them to participate. Critics argue that the tradition is sexist and objectifies women, perpetuating gender roles and treating women as objects to be won. The historical roots of the tradition of sexual conquest and objectification can be offensive to some. Brides may choose not to wear a garter or participate due to personal discomfort or conflicting values. Ultimately, the controversy arises from differing perspectives and beliefs.