There haven’t been many sports families in the world who were more successful than the Mannings. Archie Manning and 2 of his sons were all quite famous in the NFL. Overall, Peyton has better stats than his brother, leading to him stealing the spotlight away from Eli. While Eli can be clearly stated to be the NFL’s highest-paid player, Peyton still beats out his little brother on net worth. Eli closed his career with a $150 million net worth, while Peyton holds an estimated $250 million.