Mara Blumenfeld has been nominated for several awards for her outstanding costume designs in various productions. Some of her notable nominations include:
- Outstanding Costume Design, Resident Production (Helen Hayes Awards) for Candide
- Outstanding Costume Design (The Lortels) for The Glorious Ones
- Outstanding Costume Design (Drama Desk Awards) for The Glorious Ones
- Outstanding Costume Design (Drama Desk Awards) for Lookingglass Alice
- Outstanding Costume Design, Resident Production (Helen Hayes Awards) for Pericles
- Best Costume Design (Olivier Awards) for Pacific Overtures
- Outstanding Costume Design (The Lortels) for Metamorphoses.