Understand the difference between your dog being excited about a toy and simply obsessing over it. If your dog shows signs that it's obsessively fixated on a toy, you may want to take steps to ween your dog from it. These signs include the following: Aggression toward other dogs or humans over a toy. Constantly guarding the toy. Inability or refusal to be distracted from the toy. Trances over the toy for abnormal periods of time when it is out of reach. If your dog shows signs of this type of intense fixation, consider leaving the toy out of the rotation for a while. Check out pet toys and pet supplies that suppliers near you offer through Instacart. With Instacart, you can make small work of your shopping trips. Download the app or visit the Instacart website, fill your virtual cart with the pet toys your pet friend loves, and wait for an Instacart shopper to collect these items for you. Whether you order your items for pickup or delivery, shopping for pet toys — and plenty else — just got easier.