Mariners Cove at Paynesville Motel & Apartments, rated with a score of 8.8 from 127 reviewers, is one of the most popular hotels in Paynesville. Other top stays include The Abbey Raymond Island, with an average rating of 7.5 from 91 reviewers, and Lilys by the Lake - Raymond Island Accommodation, with a score of 9.6 from 12 reviewers.