Carthage, Texas, has had mixed reactions to Bernie Tiede's story. While some residents were appalled by the murder and Bernie's actions, others remembered him fondly for his contributions to the community and his caring nature. The town found itself divided, with some advocating for Bernie's release or a reduced sentence, while others believed justice was served with his conviction. The story has left an indelible mark on Carthage, sparking debates about justice, forgiveness, and the complexity of human relationships.