Of the big insurance companies, Farmers and Progressive tend to offer the least compensation for car accident injuries suffered by pedestrians. Windhaven and United Auto also pay low payments. There usually is not enough bodily injury coverage with these companies to pay the full amount of pain and suffering.
Paying a bit more are Allstate, State Farm, and Philadelphia. But they still do not pay much.
Travelers, GEICO, Safeco, CNA, and Liberty Mutual pay above-average settlements.
Better insurance companies are Nationwide, Zurich, and USAA. Hartford also has a good reputation for paying our more in pedestrian car accident claims.