It's hard to give a solid yes or no answer here as penis pumping is a very personal thing - with some people preferring certain products or sensations over others. That said, Bathmate pumps are often highly praised by people who have used both water pump and air pump products. Often-mentioned preferences for Bathmate products include: The uniform pressure and results that come from a water pump, The increased safety of a water pump, Increased comfort over air pumps, Improved relaxation and blood flow