That "overly-lifted" look comes from a brow that has been raised too much, and it can be avoided simply by being more conservative with the lift. In general, a natural-looking result can be achieved by maintaining an attractive shape of the brow in conjunction with the orbital rim rather than simply lifting the whole brow as much as possible. For optimal results, be sure to consult with an experienced facial plastic surgery specialist who is skilled in the artistry of brow lifting.