Let's take a look at 25 discontinued McDonald's menu items that could've made it, if we only gave them a chance.. Big N Tasty. Video via YouTube. ... Cheddar Melt. Video via YouTube. ... McDLT. Video via YouTube. ... Arch Deluxe. Video via YouTube. ... Chopped Beefsteak Sandwich. Video via YouTube. ... McStuffins. ... McSpaghetti. ... Chicken Fajitas.