Lucy has dated two Big Time Rush members: Kendall and James (the latter of whom is currently her boyfriend). She claims in Big Time Rocker that she is allergic to flowers and dislikes chocolate. This phrase from James to Lucy, "you shall be mine," has appeared sporadically throughout the series. It first appeared in the episode "Rockstar". In an interview with E! News, James Hetfield said about dating Lucy: "I'm not really into girls. I mean, I went out with one girl for a little while but it didn't work out." He also said that he thinks Lucy is "hot" and that they would make a good couple because they are both "rockers at heart". Kendall also had some comments about Lucy: "She's cool. I like her a lot. And we have the same taste in music so it's pretty much perfect." However, later on in the same interview, when asked if there was any chance of him and Lucy getting back together, he replied, "No way. That ship has sailed." So there you have it - Lucy has dated two BBTR members and both of them are in the band too. However, this doesn't mean that they are all going to get married or anything like that. Just that they have gone out with each other before and maybe will again in the future.