To make a claim, contact your broker, or in the case of an after-hours claim, contact Economical via the insurance claims line.   Phone number to file a car insurance claim with Economical: 1-800-607-2424   Economical's phone number for insurance claimants in Quebec: 1-888-875-8088   Hours of availability: Call either phone numbers above to reach Economical Insurance's claim against who are available nationally 24-hours a day, seven days a week, year-round.