You can analyze gloves for durability based on the way the gloves are stitched and the quality of the materials used in the gloves. Typically, gloves with Gore-Tex fabrics in them are stronger, since Gore-Tex is not only waterproof and windproof but also abrasion resistant. It is suggested that you read through reviews when choosing your gloves based on durability.
However, if you opt for something on this list, you will most certainly get a glove that is both waterproof and durable. Not to mention, Carhartt tends to make work quality gear, so their gloves are tried and true when it comes to durability.