The main difference between the Sorel Tofino and the Joan Of Arctic boots is that the Tofino boots are made for everyday wear, while the Joan Of Arctic boots are designed for more extreme weather conditions. Both boots are waterproof and offer great insulation, but the Tofino boots have a more stylish look to them, while the Joan Of Arctic boots are more rugged. If you're looking for a boot to wear in the snow, then the Joan Of Arctic would be a better choice, but if you're just looking for a nice boot to wear around town, then the Sorel Tofino would be a better choice.