The Bedwetter has been nominated for several awards. It received a nomination for Outstanding Lyrics at the Drama Desk Awards for Adam Schlesinger. The show was also nominated for Outstanding New Off-Broadway Musical at the Outer Critics Circle Awards. Adam Schlesinger was recognized again with a nomination for Outstanding New Score at the Outer Critics Circle Awards. Additionally, Darren Goldstein received a nomination for Outstanding Featured Performer in a Musical at The Lortels.