Jennifer buys a piece of costume jewelry for $33 for which she was willing to pay $42. The minimum acceptable price to the seller, Nathan, was $30. Jennifer experiencesa producer surplus of $9 and Nathan experiences a consumer surplus of $3. a consumer surplus of $12 and Nathan experiences a producer surplus of $3. a producer surplus of $9 and Nathan experiences a producer surplus of $12. a consumer surplus of $9 and Nathan experiences a producer surplus of $3.