"
the red violin " is a cold , sterile feature that leaves you uninvolved and detached .
it 's a movie that seems almost clinical , as it traces the 300-plus - years history of the legendary musical instrument of the title .
opening in the 17th century , the story shows how violin - maker nicolo bussotti created the instrument as a gift for his unborn son .
but when tragedy strikes , the violin becomes the personification of its maker 's grief .
from there the violin comes into the hands of an orphaned child prodigy at an austrian monastery .
again , tragedy strikes as the child is struck down at the moment of his triumph .
we follow the violin through the centuries as it finds a home in england and in mao 's communist china before being discovered by expert charles morritz ( samuel l . jackson ) , who mounts a painstaking investigation to prove its authenticity .
the violin becomes morritz 's obsession , just as it is for all those who converge on a montreal auction house to bid on it .
morritz , however , is the only one who knows the secret of the instrument and can understand and appreciate its creator 's intention .
"
the red violin " could have been a touching , inspirational story , as soaring as a beethoven symphony .
however director francois girard fails to make any emotional connection with the viewer .
here is a story that could have made use of various camera angles and lighting to heighten its impact .
girard , for some unknown reason , uses mostly master shots , keeping his camera - and thus us - at a distance .
we get no feel for the miracle
that is the violin .
it 's resonance , its purity of sound are not emphasized enough to make an impression .
nor are any of the performances memorable .
it 's as if girard wanted all his actors to play second fiddle to his violin .
"
the red violin " promises much , but delivers little .
it is dull at times , a bit pretentious and a might murky .
the movie 's music soars over its story and performers .
and that is its only saving grace .
we get no feel for the miracle it is dull at times , a bit pretentious and a might murky fails to make any emotional connection delivers little a cold , sterile feature that leaves you uninvolved and detached