# Induction ofManduca sexta Larvae Caspases Expression in Midgut Cells by Bacillus thuringiensis Cry1Ab Toxin

Authors: Helena Porta; Carlos Muñoz-Minutti; Mario Soberón; Alejandra Bravo
Journal: Psyche
 (2011)

---

## Abstract

Bacillus thuringiensis produces crystal toxins known as Cry that are highly selective against important agricultural and human health-related insect pests. Cry proteins are pore-forming toxins that interact with specific receptors in the midgut cell membrane of susceptible larvae making pores that cause osmotic shock, leading finally to insect death. In the case of pore-forming toxins that are specific to mammalian cells, death responses at low doses may induce apoptosis or pyroptosis, depending on the cell type. The death mechanism induced by Cry toxins in insect midgut cells is poorly understood. Here, we analyze the caspases expression by RT-PCR analysis, showing that the initial response of Manduca sexta midgut cells after low dose of Cry1Ab toxin administration involves a fast and transient accumulation of caspase-1 mRNA, suggesting that pyroptosis was activated by Cry1Ab toxin as an initial response but was repressed later. In contrast, caspase-3 mRNA requires a longer period of time of toxin exposure to be activated but presents a sustained activation,  suggesting that apoptosis may be a cell death mechanism induced also at low dose of toxin.


---

## Body

## 1. Introduction

Bacillus thuringiensis (Bt) are insecticidal Gram-positive bacteria that produce inclusion bodies composed by δ-endotoxin proteins, during sporulation [1]. The main components of these inclusions are the crystal (Cry) toxins, which possess highly selective toxicities against important agricultural and human health-related insect pests but are nontoxic to mammals or other organisms [2]. Cry toxins are classified as pore forming toxins (PFTs) based on its capacity to make pores in the midgut membrane of the larvae causing osmotic shock, rupture of the midgut cells, and finally the insect death [3].In mammalian cells, PFTs are important virulence factors that kill eukaryotic cells by different mechanisms, depending on the dose and the cell type (for review, see [4]). At low doses, cell death occurs through two different mechanisms: (1) apoptosis, characterized by the activation of initiator-caspases (Cas) (Cas-2, -4, -8, -9, -10, and -12) that trigger effector-Cas (Cas-3, -6, and -7) to cleave cellular substrates. Apoptotic cells features include nuclear and cytoplasmic condensation and cellular fragmentation, Cas-3 activation, DNA damage, and formation of apoptotic bodies [5] and (2) pyroptosis characterized by the activation of inflammatory caspases, such as Cas-1, -5 and -11, that mediate cell death and inflammatory responses [6]. Apoptosis and pyroptosis are death processes confined to a discrete cell population that contends the insult and in some cases allows the organism to recover.Some examples of PFT that induce apoptotic death response, when used at low doses are theStaphylococcus aureus Penton-Valentine leukocidin (PVL) that triggers Cas-9 and Cas-3 activity in neutrophils [7] and the Clostridium perfringensenterotoxin (CPE) induces activation of Cas-3 or Cas-7 in Caco-2 cells [8]. In endothelial cells, the Streptococcus pneumoniae pneumolysin (PLY) induces Cas-6, Cas-9, and Cas-3 [9], and in HeLa cells, the Btparasoporin-1, activates Cas-3 [10]. Activation of Cas-1 and pyroptosis has been observed in macrophages treated with the streptolysin O (SLO) toxin from Streptococcus bacteria, the PLY, and the anthrax toxin [11–13]. It was shown that pore formation activity of these PFT is necessary to induce the apoptotic or the pyroptosis responses, since PFT mutants affected in pore formation, toxin-knockout mutants, or organisms in which the expression of PFT has been greatly reduced by antisense RNA were unable to induce these responses [7, 10, 14–16].At high doses of PFT, cells respond starting a more severe cell death processes known as necrosis and oncosis, for example, high doses of CPE provokes oncosis in Caco-2 cells [8]. Oncosis is characterized by cellular and organelle swelling, membrane blebbing, and an increment in membrane permeability. Oncosis leads to depletion of the cellular energy stores and failure of the ionic pumps [17].In the case of Cry toxins, there are no reports studying the induction of apoptosis or pyroptosis cell death processes in vivo in intoxicated Lepidopteran insects. The only report that analyzed the expression ofcas-1 in third instar Aedes caspius larvae, a Dipteran insect, showed activation of cas-1 genes after treatment with two larvicidal bacteria, Btand B. sphaericus [18]. The aim of our work was to explore if pyroptosis and apoptosis cell response processes, are activated in vivo in the midgut cells of Manduca sexta larvae in response to Cry1Ab intoxication. Here, we show that M. sexta larvae intoxicated with Cry1Ab induce a transient expression of cas-1, at low doses (LC25) and short times.  In contrast, the cas-3is induced after longer time of toxin exposure depending also in the toxin dose. Our results suggest that M. sexta midgut cells may induce first pyroptosis as an initial response to low doses of toxin, and then, apoptosis is triggered later with a more sustained pattern also at low toxin dose.


## 2. Materials and Methods

### 2.1. Extraction of  the Crystal-Spore Suspension

Bt strains harboring pHT315-Cry1Ab plasmid [19] were grown at 30°C, in nutrient broth sporulation medium, supplemented with 10 μg ml−1erythromycin until complete sporulation [20]. Crystal inclusions were observed under phase contrast microscopy and purified as previously described [21].


### 2.2.Manduca sexta larvae Intoxication

Cry1Ab was applied onto the diet surface in 24-well plates as described [20]. For clarity, we added thirty-five microliters of Cry1Ab crystal suspensions, containing two different toxin concentrations (1 and 2 ng cm−2), corresponding to the lethal concentrations of LC25, and LC50, respectively, as previously described [20]. Once the surface was completely dry, a neonate first-instar M. sexta larvae was added per well, using 24 larvae per dose and time (from 0 min to 48 h) in order to analyze the initial response of the larvae to the toxin action. Two experiments were done with a total of 48 larvae per treatment. Feeding behavior was synchronized, since first instar larvae were quite voracious and immediately starting feeding when transferred to the artificial diet.


### 2.3. RT-PCR Assays

Total RNA isolated from midgut tissue from controlM. sexta or with intoxicated larvae with LC25 and LC50 concentrations of Cry1Ab toxin at different times from 0 to 48 h was used for cDNA synthesis as previously reported [22]. Control larvae were feed with same diet without toxin addition at the same times. Briefly, 2 μg of total RNA and 500 μg of oligo(dT25)VN was used to synthesize cDNA with 1 μL (200 Units/μL) of Moloney murine leukemia virus Retroranscriptase (MoMLVRT) (Invitrogen, Carlsbad, Calif, USA). A volume of 2 μL of the first strand cDNA reaction was used in a 50-μL PCR reaction. Primers cas-1Forward (5′-CCA  TTT ATT TTC AAT CAT GAA CAT TTT G-3′) and cas-1Reverse (GGT TTA CCA GCA AGT GTG GGA-3′) or cas-3Forward (ACG AAG ATG TCG AAG CTC TGA AT-3′) and cas-3-Reverse (CAT TAA CCA GAT TTC GCG CTT C-3′) were used to amplify the M. sexta cas-1and cas-3 cDNA,  respectively. Taq DNA polymerase was used, and PCR reactions were performed as follows: (1) denaturing step, 1 min at 94°C, (2) extension step, 30 cycles of 30 sec at 94°C, 30 sec at 58°C, and 50 sec at 68°C, and (3) final extension, 5 min at 72°C. An aliquot of 5 μL of PCR product was analyzed by standard agarose gel electrophoresis and observed after ethidium bromide staining. As loading control a 268-bp RT-PCR product of ribosomal protein S3 (rpS3) (Accession number U12708) from M. sexta, was also amplified by using rpS3-Forward, 5′- CCG ATC GGA GAT CAT CAT CAT GGC C-3′ and rpS3-Reverse 5′-GCA ACC GCG CGC TTC AGA CTC C-3′ primers. The mRNA band intensity was quantified using the ImageJ software (http://rsb.info.nih.gov/ij/).  The relative amount of mRNA for cas-1and cas-3 were quantified using as reference the amount of the corresponding loading control (rpS3). The induction folds for cas-1 and cas-3after Cry1Ab toxin administration was calculated in relation to the control larvae that were fed with the same diet and times without toxin addition. All data set were done two times, standard deviation of the data sets were calculated and error bars included in the figures.


### 2.4. Cloning and Sequencing

The PCR products obtained aftercas-1 and cas-3amplification reactions described above were cloned into the EcoRVrestriction site of the pBCSK+ plasmid (Invitrogen, Carlsbad, Calif, USA) and sequenced in the Instituto de Biotecnologia, UNAM facility using Taq FS Dye Terminator Cycle Sequencing Fluorescence-Based Sequencing in a Perkin Elmer/Applied Biosystems Model 3730 sequencer (ABI Prism; AppliedBiosystems, Carlsbad, Calif, USA).


### 2.5. Phylogenetic Analysis

The virtual translations ofcas-1 andcas-3gene sequences from M. sexta were aligned using Muscle 3.7 alignment [23]. The alignment includes Cas-1 and Cas-3 proteins from different Lepidoptera and Dipteran insects as well as some Cas-6, Cas-7, and Cas-8 that were identified in Dipteran insects.  A maximum likelihood tree was constructed and drawn using PhyML version 3.0 [24] with a bootstrap of 500 replicates.


## 2.1. Extraction of  the Crystal-Spore Suspension

Bt strains harboring pHT315-Cry1Ab plasmid [19] were grown at 30°C, in nutrient broth sporulation medium, supplemented with 10 μg ml−1erythromycin until complete sporulation [20]. Crystal inclusions were observed under phase contrast microscopy and purified as previously described [21].


## 2.2.Manduca sexta larvae Intoxication

Cry1Ab was applied onto the diet surface in 24-well plates as described [20]. For clarity, we added thirty-five microliters of Cry1Ab crystal suspensions, containing two different toxin concentrations (1 and 2 ng cm−2), corresponding to the lethal concentrations of LC25, and LC50, respectively, as previously described [20]. Once the surface was completely dry, a neonate first-instar M. sexta larvae was added per well, using 24 larvae per dose and time (from 0 min to 48 h) in order to analyze the initial response of the larvae to the toxin action. Two experiments were done with a total of 48 larvae per treatment. Feeding behavior was synchronized, since first instar larvae were quite voracious and immediately starting feeding when transferred to the artificial diet.


## 2.3. RT-PCR Assays

Total RNA isolated from midgut tissue from controlM. sexta or with intoxicated larvae with LC25 and LC50 concentrations of Cry1Ab toxin at different times from 0 to 48 h was used for cDNA synthesis as previously reported [22]. Control larvae were feed with same diet without toxin addition at the same times. Briefly, 2 μg of total RNA and 500 μg of oligo(dT25)VN was used to synthesize cDNA with 1 μL (200 Units/μL) of Moloney murine leukemia virus Retroranscriptase (MoMLVRT) (Invitrogen, Carlsbad, Calif, USA). A volume of 2 μL of the first strand cDNA reaction was used in a 50-μL PCR reaction. Primers cas-1Forward (5′-CCA  TTT ATT TTC AAT CAT GAA CAT TTT G-3′) and cas-1Reverse (GGT TTA CCA GCA AGT GTG GGA-3′) or cas-3Forward (ACG AAG ATG TCG AAG CTC TGA AT-3′) and cas-3-Reverse (CAT TAA CCA GAT TTC GCG CTT C-3′) were used to amplify the M. sexta cas-1and cas-3 cDNA,  respectively. Taq DNA polymerase was used, and PCR reactions were performed as follows: (1) denaturing step, 1 min at 94°C, (2) extension step, 30 cycles of 30 sec at 94°C, 30 sec at 58°C, and 50 sec at 68°C, and (3) final extension, 5 min at 72°C. An aliquot of 5 μL of PCR product was analyzed by standard agarose gel electrophoresis and observed after ethidium bromide staining. As loading control a 268-bp RT-PCR product of ribosomal protein S3 (rpS3) (Accession number U12708) from M. sexta, was also amplified by using rpS3-Forward, 5′- CCG ATC GGA GAT CAT CAT CAT GGC C-3′ and rpS3-Reverse 5′-GCA ACC GCG CGC TTC AGA CTC C-3′ primers. The mRNA band intensity was quantified using the ImageJ software (http://rsb.info.nih.gov/ij/).  The relative amount of mRNA for cas-1and cas-3 were quantified using as reference the amount of the corresponding loading control (rpS3). The induction folds for cas-1 and cas-3after Cry1Ab toxin administration was calculated in relation to the control larvae that were fed with the same diet and times without toxin addition. All data set were done two times, standard deviation of the data sets were calculated and error bars included in the figures.


## 2.4. Cloning and Sequencing

The PCR products obtained aftercas-1 and cas-3amplification reactions described above were cloned into the EcoRVrestriction site of the pBCSK+ plasmid (Invitrogen, Carlsbad, Calif, USA) and sequenced in the Instituto de Biotecnologia, UNAM facility using Taq FS Dye Terminator Cycle Sequencing Fluorescence-Based Sequencing in a Perkin Elmer/Applied Biosystems Model 3730 sequencer (ABI Prism; AppliedBiosystems, Carlsbad, Calif, USA).


## 2.5. Phylogenetic Analysis

The virtual translations ofcas-1 andcas-3gene sequences from M. sexta were aligned using Muscle 3.7 alignment [23]. The alignment includes Cas-1 and Cas-3 proteins from different Lepidoptera and Dipteran insects as well as some Cas-6, Cas-7, and Cas-8 that were identified in Dipteran insects.  A maximum likelihood tree was constructed and drawn using PhyML version 3.0 [24] with a bootstrap of 500 replicates.


## 3. Results and Discussion

### 3.1. Isolation ofM. sexta caspase-1 and caspase-3 Genes

To obtain theM. sexta cas-1 and cas-3gene sequences,theBombix mori gene sequences of these cas genes were used as a template to search for homologues sequences in an EST library from M. sexta deposited in the http://www.agripestbase.org/.Whencas-1 sequence from B. mori(Accession number AF448494) was used as query, a DNA contig containing a complete hypothetical cas-1of M. sexta,with 80% of identity, with B. mori  cas-1 query was obtained (ctg7180001044351). On the other hand, using the B. mori cas-3 sequence as a template (Accession number AAW79564), a DNA contig from M. sexta(ctg7180001055914) with 40% identity to B. mori  cas-3, was identified.The deduced open reading frame fromM. sexta  cas-1 codify for 289 amino acid residues and the partial cas-3gene for 154 residues. Alignment of several Lepidoptera and Diptera Caspase protein-fragments that include the catalytic domain showed that the catalytic dyad, characteristic of the Caspase family, is conserved. In M. sexta Cas-1, the catalytic dyad corresponded to His119 and Cys174 residues. The H and C catalytic residues inM. sextaCas-3 partial protein sequence are also conserved (Figure 1).Multiple sequence alignment of Lepidoptera and Dipterans caspases. The deduced catalytic domain ofM. sexta Cas-1 and Cas-3 is compared with the catalytic domain of caspases from other Lepidoptera and Dipterans family members. The selected sequence fragments include R73  to G173  region based onB. mori Cas-3 sequence (Q2HZ04). Amino acid identities are in gray boxes. *: shows the catalytic dyad.


### 3.2. The Cas-1 and Cas-3 Proteins fromM. sexta Larvae belong to Two Independent Phylogenetic Groups Conserved between Lepidotera and Diptera

To obtain a better picture of the relationships between theM. sexta Cas-1 and Cas-3 proteins with those from other organisms, a maximum likelihood phylogenetic tree was constructed. The tree included representative Cas-1 and Cas-3 proteins from different Lepidoptera and Diptera organisms as well as some Cas-6, Cas-7 and Cas-8 archetypes from Dipteran insects (Figure 2). The Cas-1 and Cas-3 sequences are clustered in two independent branches of the phylogenetic tree, indicating that the M. sexta sequences used in this work were correctly identified. Each of the Cas-1 and Cas-3 clades, in turn, are separated in two groups: one containing the Lepidotera proteins and the other those belonging to the Diptera proteins. The Cas-1 group of Lepidopteran proteins contains B. mori (Q8I9V7), Spodoptera frugiperda (P89116), Plutella xylostella (D9IVD4), Trichoplusia ni (B6EEC1), and Helicoverpa armigera (A7L9Z3), and the Dipteran group includes Drosophila melanogaster (O01382), Culex quinquefasciatus (B0W0K2), and Musca domestica (B5AK94) Cas-1 proteins related to activation of cytokines during inflammation. The Cas-3 group of Dipteran sequences includes sequences from Aedes aegypti (Q178B6), C. quinquefasciatus (B0WZJ4), and D. melanogaster (Q7KHK9), while the Lepidopteran group contains two Cas-3 sequences from B. mori (Q2HZ04 and Q2HZ05) that are related to apoptosis [25]. We also add some other caspase proteins to this analysis, such as the Cas-6 from D. melanogaster (Q9NHF9), Cas-7 from Anopheles stephensi(Q86FL0), and two initiator Cas-8 sequences, one from An. gambiae (Q5TMK1) and other from Ae. Aegypti(Q16H55), which are clustered in different branches from Cas-3 and Cas-1 (Figure 2).Figure 2
Phylogenetic tree of Cas-1 and Cas-3 proteins fromM. sexta. A phylogenetic tree was constructed using the following sequences: Cas-1 from Bombyx mori (Q8I9V7), Spodoptera frugiperda (P89116), Plutella xylostella (D9IVD4), Trichoplusia ni (B6EEC1) Helicoverpa armigera (A7L9Z3), Drosophila melanogaster (O01382), Culex quinquefasciatus (B0W0K2), Musca domestica (B5AK94), and Manduca sexta (ctg7180001044351). Cas-3 from Aedes aegypti (Q178B6), C. quinquefasciatus (B0WZJ4), D. melanogaster (Q7KHK9), B. mori (Q2HZ04 and Q2HZ05), and M. sexta (ctg7180001055914). Cas-6 from D. melanogaster (Q9NHF9). Cas-7 from Anopheles stephensi(Q86FL0). Cas-8 from An. gambiae (Q5TMK1) and Ae. Aegypti(Q16H55).


### 3.3. Cry1Ab Intoxication Inducescas-1 and cas-3 Expression in M. sexta Larvae Midgut

To get new insights into the responses ofM. sexta midgut cells to Cry1Ab intoxication, we analyzed the expression pattern of cas-1 and cas-3 as characteristic features of pyroptosis and apoptosis, respectively. M. sexta larvae were treated with two different doses of Cry1Ab toxin. The 25% lethal concentration and the medium lethal concentration were calculated in first instar M. sexta larvae feed 7 days with different concentrations of toxin by Probit statistical analysis. We then used a low dose, 1 ng cm−2 (corresponding to LC25) and medium dose, 2 ng cm−2 (corresponding to LC50) to study the initial response of M sextamidgut cells after ingestion of the toxin. M. sexta larvae feed with the same diet without contamination with Cry1Ab toxin, were used as control in each time analyzed.  A RT-PCR approach was used to monitor cas-1 and cas-3 gene expression and the internal loading control rpS3 was also analyzed. The predicted cas-1 and cas-3 cDNA sizes were 440 nt and 243 nt, respectively. The cDNA products obtained by RT-PCR, were cloned, and sequenced to corroborate their identity. Figure 3 shows representative RT-PCR electrophoretic patterns of cas-1 and cas-3 obtained in the control larvae and after treatment with the different toxin dose. This figure also shows the rpS3loading control. The numbers on the agarose gel represent the number of pixels observed in each mRNA band as determine by scanning optical density of the bands.Figure 3
Representative electrophoretic patterns of RT-PCR amplifications ofcas-1, cas-3, and rpS3 genes from M. sexta larvae. RT-PCR analysis of the expression of cas-1, cas-3, and rpS3genes at different times were performed with control larvae or with Cry1Ab intoxicated M. sexta larvae with two different concentrations of Cry1Ab toxin. The numbers on the agarose gel represent the number of pixels observed in each mRNA band as determine by scanning optical density of the bands.RT-PCR was used to analyze the expression ofcas-1 and cas-3 in response to Cry1Ab intoxication. In panel A of Figure 4, we show the relative expression levels of cas-1 and cas-3 in control and toxin intoxicated larvae at the different times by analyzing the band intensity of cas-1 or cas-3 RT-PCR data over the band intensity of the constitutive rpS3 control at the corresponding time and toxin dose.  RT-PCR expression analysis showed that both cas-1 and cas-3 expression was slightly induced in the control larvae during the time frame of the analysis, where both cas-1 and cas-3 showed a twofold induction after 48 h of feeding in normal diet (Figure 4(a)).Accumulation ofcas-1mRNA in response to LC25 and LC50 doses of Cry1Ab in M. sexta midgets. (a) shows analysis the relative expression of cas-1or cas-3overrsp3constitutive gene induced in control larvae (black bars) or after larvae intoxication with LC25  toxin dose (gray bars) or LC50 toxin dose (white bars). (b) shows the changes in fold expression of cas-1or cas-3after Cry1Ab intoxication compared to their expression in control larvae, fed with normal diet. Gray bars, LC25   toxin dose and white bars, LC50   toxin dose.
(a)(b)In relation to the Cry1Ab intoxicated larvae, the results showed thatcas-1 was only induced after low dose of Cry1Ab administration, showing higher levels of cas-1 mRNA than the control feed larvae after 30 min and 2 h of feedingM. sexta with a LC25 Cry1Ab surface contaminated diet (Figure 4(a), upper panel). The cas-1 mRNA expression was then repressed at longer times of incubation at this toxin dose and at all times after intoxication with higher toxin dose, LC50 (Figure 4(a) upper panel). It is noticeable that larvae looked healthy during the course of the experiment. In relation to the cas-3 mRNA expression, we found that this mRNA was also induced at low dose of toxin ingestion but requires longer times of toxin administration to be fully activated (Figure 4(a), lower panel). In LC50 toxin dose, the cas-3 mRNA was only induced at 2 h after feeding with the toxin. It is interesting that this gene did not show a clear repression at longer times of intoxication with both toxin doses even at 48 h. The induction of cas-3 mRNA was dependent on toxin dose, being higher with a LC25 than with a LC50 toxin dose (Figure 4(a), lower panel). Larvae looked paler than control larvae at 48 h feeding with LC50 toxin dose, but no death larvae were observed as expected, since LC50 value corresponds to the dose that kills 50% of the larvae after 7 days of intoxication.In Panel B of Figure4, we show the analysis of the changes in fold expression of cas-1 and cas-3 mRNA after Cry1Ab ingestion relative to control larvae fed with a noncontaminated diet. In this figure, it is clear that the highest expression of cas-1 in response to Cry1Ab intoxication was observed after 30 min intoxication with a LC25 showing 1.5 fold induction,  and then, the expression of this cas-1 gene was repressed after 24 h of toxin ingestion as well as with higher LC50 dose of toxin administration, where it was repressed at all tested times, when compared with the control larvae fed with a normal diet (Figure 4(b), upper Panel). In contrast, the expression of cas-3 mRNA showed an induction of 2.3 fold over the control larvae at 2 h after intoxication with LC25 toxin dose (Figure 4(b), lower Panel) and one fold induction after 2 h intoxication with LC50 toxin dose. The expression of cas-3 mRNA did not show a clear repression when compared with the control larvae, during the time frame of this study (Figure 4(b), lower Panel).In conclusion, two different toxin doses of Cry1Ab, LC25 and LC50, were used in this study to analyze the initial response of M. sexta larvae to toxin intoxication. In this work, we identify the putative cas-1 and cas-3 genes of M. sexta larvae and analyzed their expression in vivo in the midgut tissue of the insect during intoxication with Cry1Ab toxin. As mentioned above, the inflammatory Cas-1 and the effector Cas-3 have been implicated in activation of different programmed cell death responses, named pyroptosis or apoptosis, respectively. In mosquito larvae, it has been described that Cas-3 protease is activated after invasion of midgut cells with the malaria parasites Plasmodium gallinaceum and P. berghei,suggesting that midgut cell death during penetration of the malaria ookinete is related to an apoptotic process [26]. In other reports, it was shown that the modulation of Cas-1 and Cas3 in midgut tissue of Heliothis virescens and in Periplaneta americana are implicated in the activation of programmed cell death during metamorphosis or during starvation, respectively [27, 28].Our results suggest thatM. sexta larvae trigger pyroptosis as an initial response to intoxication with a low dose of Cry1Ab, suggesting that this process may participate as a defense mechanism under this condition, and this response is inhibited at longer periods of toxin ingestion or at higher dose of toxin (Figure 4). In the case of other pore forming toxins, such as PLY, SLO, and lethal toxin from B. anthracis, it was shown that these toxins activate Cas-1 in macrophages promoting cell death though pyroptosis [11–13]. Cas-1-deficient macrophages were more resistant to cell-death induced by the SLO toxin [12]. In contrast, the expression of cas-3 in M. sexta intoxicated larvae suggests that apoptosis may play a role latter, after longer times of Cry1Ab toxin administration and may be present at higher toxin doses showing a more sustained activation than Cas-1. These results are similar to the PVL toxin or the α-hemolysin produced by Escherichia coli that activate Cas-3 expression, inducing apoptosis in neutrophils, monocyes and macrophages when used at sublytic concentrations [7, 15], or to CPE from C. perfringens that also induces typical apoptotic cell death at low dose in mammalian Caco-2 cells by activating Cas-3 [15].Regarding to higher doses of Cry1Ab intoxication, it was reported that cell death was produced by oncosis inTrichoplusia niH5 ovarian cell line expressing the M. sexta Cry1Ab cadherin receptor. These authors showed that the broad-spectrum Cas inhibitor z-VAD-fmk did not suppress cell death in these cells, suggesting that Cas dependent responses such as pyroptosis or apoptosis were not activated with high doses Cry1Ab toxin in this cell line [29].Further research is needed to analyze the role of Cas-1 activity in activating immune responses to low-dose administration of Cry1Ab toxin inM. sexta larvae. Similarly, the role of Cas-3 in activating apoptotic responses at low doses remains to be analyzed. Also, it will be desirable to analyze the effect of specific caspase inhibitors on the toxicity of Cry1Ab to determine the potential role of these programmed cell death responses on survival to Cry toxin intoxication.


## 3.1. Isolation ofM. sexta caspase-1 and caspase-3 Genes

To obtain theM. sexta cas-1 and cas-3gene sequences,theBombix mori gene sequences of these cas genes were used as a template to search for homologues sequences in an EST library from M. sexta deposited in the http://www.agripestbase.org/.Whencas-1 sequence from B. mori(Accession number AF448494) was used as query, a DNA contig containing a complete hypothetical cas-1of M. sexta,with 80% of identity, with B. mori  cas-1 query was obtained (ctg7180001044351). On the other hand, using the B. mori cas-3 sequence as a template (Accession number AAW79564), a DNA contig from M. sexta(ctg7180001055914) with 40% identity to B. mori  cas-3, was identified.The deduced open reading frame fromM. sexta  cas-1 codify for 289 amino acid residues and the partial cas-3gene for 154 residues. Alignment of several Lepidoptera and Diptera Caspase protein-fragments that include the catalytic domain showed that the catalytic dyad, characteristic of the Caspase family, is conserved. In M. sexta Cas-1, the catalytic dyad corresponded to His119 and Cys174 residues. The H and C catalytic residues inM. sextaCas-3 partial protein sequence are also conserved (Figure 1).Multiple sequence alignment of Lepidoptera and Dipterans caspases. The deduced catalytic domain ofM. sexta Cas-1 and Cas-3 is compared with the catalytic domain of caspases from other Lepidoptera and Dipterans family members. The selected sequence fragments include R73  to G173  region based onB. mori Cas-3 sequence (Q2HZ04). Amino acid identities are in gray boxes. *: shows the catalytic dyad.


## 3.2. The Cas-1 and Cas-3 Proteins fromM. sexta Larvae belong to Two Independent Phylogenetic Groups Conserved between Lepidotera and Diptera

To obtain a better picture of the relationships between theM. sexta Cas-1 and Cas-3 proteins with those from other organisms, a maximum likelihood phylogenetic tree was constructed. The tree included representative Cas-1 and Cas-3 proteins from different Lepidoptera and Diptera organisms as well as some Cas-6, Cas-7 and Cas-8 archetypes from Dipteran insects (Figure 2). The Cas-1 and Cas-3 sequences are clustered in two independent branches of the phylogenetic tree, indicating that the M. sexta sequences used in this work were correctly identified. Each of the Cas-1 and Cas-3 clades, in turn, are separated in two groups: one containing the Lepidotera proteins and the other those belonging to the Diptera proteins. The Cas-1 group of Lepidopteran proteins contains B. mori (Q8I9V7), Spodoptera frugiperda (P89116), Plutella xylostella (D9IVD4), Trichoplusia ni (B6EEC1), and Helicoverpa armigera (A7L9Z3), and the Dipteran group includes Drosophila melanogaster (O01382), Culex quinquefasciatus (B0W0K2), and Musca domestica (B5AK94) Cas-1 proteins related to activation of cytokines during inflammation. The Cas-3 group of Dipteran sequences includes sequences from Aedes aegypti (Q178B6), C. quinquefasciatus (B0WZJ4), and D. melanogaster (Q7KHK9), while the Lepidopteran group contains two Cas-3 sequences from B. mori (Q2HZ04 and Q2HZ05) that are related to apoptosis [25]. We also add some other caspase proteins to this analysis, such as the Cas-6 from D. melanogaster (Q9NHF9), Cas-7 from Anopheles stephensi(Q86FL0), and two initiator Cas-8 sequences, one from An. gambiae (Q5TMK1) and other from Ae. Aegypti(Q16H55), which are clustered in different branches from Cas-3 and Cas-1 (Figure 2).Figure 2
Phylogenetic tree of Cas-1 and Cas-3 proteins fromM. sexta. A phylogenetic tree was constructed using the following sequences: Cas-1 from Bombyx mori (Q8I9V7), Spodoptera frugiperda (P89116), Plutella xylostella (D9IVD4), Trichoplusia ni (B6EEC1) Helicoverpa armigera (A7L9Z3), Drosophila melanogaster (O01382), Culex quinquefasciatus (B0W0K2), Musca domestica (B5AK94), and Manduca sexta (ctg7180001044351). Cas-3 from Aedes aegypti (Q178B6), C. quinquefasciatus (B0WZJ4), D. melanogaster (Q7KHK9), B. mori (Q2HZ04 and Q2HZ05), and M. sexta (ctg7180001055914). Cas-6 from D. melanogaster (Q9NHF9). Cas-7 from Anopheles stephensi(Q86FL0). Cas-8 from An. gambiae (Q5TMK1) and Ae. Aegypti(Q16H55).


## 3.3. Cry1Ab Intoxication Inducescas-1 and cas-3 Expression in M. sexta Larvae Midgut

To get new insights into the responses ofM. sexta midgut cells to Cry1Ab intoxication, we analyzed the expression pattern of cas-1 and cas-3 as characteristic features of pyroptosis and apoptosis, respectively. M. sexta larvae were treated with two different doses of Cry1Ab toxin. The 25% lethal concentration and the medium lethal concentration were calculated in first instar M. sexta larvae feed 7 days with different concentrations of toxin by Probit statistical analysis. We then used a low dose, 1 ng cm−2 (corresponding to LC25) and medium dose, 2 ng cm−2 (corresponding to LC50) to study the initial response of M sextamidgut cells after ingestion of the toxin. M. sexta larvae feed with the same diet without contamination with Cry1Ab toxin, were used as control in each time analyzed.  A RT-PCR approach was used to monitor cas-1 and cas-3 gene expression and the internal loading control rpS3 was also analyzed. The predicted cas-1 and cas-3 cDNA sizes were 440 nt and 243 nt, respectively. The cDNA products obtained by RT-PCR, were cloned, and sequenced to corroborate their identity. Figure 3 shows representative RT-PCR electrophoretic patterns of cas-1 and cas-3 obtained in the control larvae and after treatment with the different toxin dose. This figure also shows the rpS3loading control. The numbers on the agarose gel represent the number of pixels observed in each mRNA band as determine by scanning optical density of the bands.Figure 3
Representative electrophoretic patterns of RT-PCR amplifications ofcas-1, cas-3, and rpS3 genes from M. sexta larvae. RT-PCR analysis of the expression of cas-1, cas-3, and rpS3genes at different times were performed with control larvae or with Cry1Ab intoxicated M. sexta larvae with two different concentrations of Cry1Ab toxin. The numbers on the agarose gel represent the number of pixels observed in each mRNA band as determine by scanning optical density of the bands.RT-PCR was used to analyze the expression ofcas-1 and cas-3 in response to Cry1Ab intoxication. In panel A of Figure 4, we show the relative expression levels of cas-1 and cas-3 in control and toxin intoxicated larvae at the different times by analyzing the band intensity of cas-1 or cas-3 RT-PCR data over the band intensity of the constitutive rpS3 control at the corresponding time and toxin dose.  RT-PCR expression analysis showed that both cas-1 and cas-3 expression was slightly induced in the control larvae during the time frame of the analysis, where both cas-1 and cas-3 showed a twofold induction after 48 h of feeding in normal diet (Figure 4(a)).Accumulation ofcas-1mRNA in response to LC25 and LC50 doses of Cry1Ab in M. sexta midgets. (a) shows analysis the relative expression of cas-1or cas-3overrsp3constitutive gene induced in control larvae (black bars) or after larvae intoxication with LC25  toxin dose (gray bars) or LC50 toxin dose (white bars). (b) shows the changes in fold expression of cas-1or cas-3after Cry1Ab intoxication compared to their expression in control larvae, fed with normal diet. Gray bars, LC25   toxin dose and white bars, LC50   toxin dose.
(a)(b)In relation to the Cry1Ab intoxicated larvae, the results showed thatcas-1 was only induced after low dose of Cry1Ab administration, showing higher levels of cas-1 mRNA than the control feed larvae after 30 min and 2 h of feedingM. sexta with a LC25 Cry1Ab surface contaminated diet (Figure 4(a), upper panel). The cas-1 mRNA expression was then repressed at longer times of incubation at this toxin dose and at all times after intoxication with higher toxin dose, LC50 (Figure 4(a) upper panel). It is noticeable that larvae looked healthy during the course of the experiment. In relation to the cas-3 mRNA expression, we found that this mRNA was also induced at low dose of toxin ingestion but requires longer times of toxin administration to be fully activated (Figure 4(a), lower panel). In LC50 toxin dose, the cas-3 mRNA was only induced at 2 h after feeding with the toxin. It is interesting that this gene did not show a clear repression at longer times of intoxication with both toxin doses even at 48 h. The induction of cas-3 mRNA was dependent on toxin dose, being higher with a LC25 than with a LC50 toxin dose (Figure 4(a), lower panel). Larvae looked paler than control larvae at 48 h feeding with LC50 toxin dose, but no death larvae were observed as expected, since LC50 value corresponds to the dose that kills 50% of the larvae after 7 days of intoxication.In Panel B of Figure4, we show the analysis of the changes in fold expression of cas-1 and cas-3 mRNA after Cry1Ab ingestion relative to control larvae fed with a noncontaminated diet. In this figure, it is clear that the highest expression of cas-1 in response to Cry1Ab intoxication was observed after 30 min intoxication with a LC25 showing 1.5 fold induction,  and then, the expression of this cas-1 gene was repressed after 24 h of toxin ingestion as well as with higher LC50 dose of toxin administration, where it was repressed at all tested times, when compared with the control larvae fed with a normal diet (Figure 4(b), upper Panel). In contrast, the expression of cas-3 mRNA showed an induction of 2.3 fold over the control larvae at 2 h after intoxication with LC25 toxin dose (Figure 4(b), lower Panel) and one fold induction after 2 h intoxication with LC50 toxin dose. The expression of cas-3 mRNA did not show a clear repression when compared with the control larvae, during the time frame of this study (Figure 4(b), lower Panel).In conclusion, two different toxin doses of Cry1Ab, LC25 and LC50, were used in this study to analyze the initial response of M. sexta larvae to toxin intoxication. In this work, we identify the putative cas-1 and cas-3 genes of M. sexta larvae and analyzed their expression in vivo in the midgut tissue of the insect during intoxication with Cry1Ab toxin. As mentioned above, the inflammatory Cas-1 and the effector Cas-3 have been implicated in activation of different programmed cell death responses, named pyroptosis or apoptosis, respectively. In mosquito larvae, it has been described that Cas-3 protease is activated after invasion of midgut cells with the malaria parasites Plasmodium gallinaceum and P. berghei,suggesting that midgut cell death during penetration of the malaria ookinete is related to an apoptotic process [26]. In other reports, it was shown that the modulation of Cas-1 and Cas3 in midgut tissue of Heliothis virescens and in Periplaneta americana are implicated in the activation of programmed cell death during metamorphosis or during starvation, respectively [27, 28].Our results suggest thatM. sexta larvae trigger pyroptosis as an initial response to intoxication with a low dose of Cry1Ab, suggesting that this process may participate as a defense mechanism under this condition, and this response is inhibited at longer periods of toxin ingestion or at higher dose of toxin (Figure 4). In the case of other pore forming toxins, such as PLY, SLO, and lethal toxin from B. anthracis, it was shown that these toxins activate Cas-1 in macrophages promoting cell death though pyroptosis [11–13]. Cas-1-deficient macrophages were more resistant to cell-death induced by the SLO toxin [12]. In contrast, the expression of cas-3 in M. sexta intoxicated larvae suggests that apoptosis may play a role latter, after longer times of Cry1Ab toxin administration and may be present at higher toxin doses showing a more sustained activation than Cas-1. These results are similar to the PVL toxin or the α-hemolysin produced by Escherichia coli that activate Cas-3 expression, inducing apoptosis in neutrophils, monocyes and macrophages when used at sublytic concentrations [7, 15], or to CPE from C. perfringens that also induces typical apoptotic cell death at low dose in mammalian Caco-2 cells by activating Cas-3 [15].Regarding to higher doses of Cry1Ab intoxication, it was reported that cell death was produced by oncosis inTrichoplusia niH5 ovarian cell line expressing the M. sexta Cry1Ab cadherin receptor. These authors showed that the broad-spectrum Cas inhibitor z-VAD-fmk did not suppress cell death in these cells, suggesting that Cas dependent responses such as pyroptosis or apoptosis were not activated with high doses Cry1Ab toxin in this cell line [29].Further research is needed to analyze the role of Cas-1 activity in activating immune responses to low-dose administration of Cry1Ab toxin inM. sexta larvae. Similarly, the role of Cas-3 in activating apoptotic responses at low doses remains to be analyzed. Also, it will be desirable to analyze the effect of specific caspase inhibitors on the toxicity of Cry1Ab to determine the potential role of these programmed cell death responses on survival to Cry toxin intoxication.



---

*Source: 938249-2011-08-11.xml*