# A Review on Montmorillonite-Supported Nanoscale Zerovalent Iron for Contaminant Removal from Water and Soil

Authors: Yaru Yin; Wenjuan Zheng; An Yan; Chenxi Zhang; Yuxuan Gou; Chongyang Shen
Journal: Adsorption Science & Technology
 (2021)

---

## Abstract

Nanoscale zerovalent iron (nZVI) has shown great promise for water treatment and soil remediation. However, the rapid aggregation of nZVIs significantly affects their mobility and reactivity, which considerably limits the practical applications. Montmorillonite- (Mt-) supported nZVI (Mt-nZVI) has received increasing attention for the past decade because it can prevent the aggregation of nZVI and incorporate the advantages of both nZVI and Mt in soil and water treatment. This work thus had a comprehensive review on the use of Mt-nZVI for soil and water treatment. We first summarized existing methods used to prepare Mt-nZVI, indicating the advantages of using Mt to support nZVI (e.g., increase of the dispersion and mobility of nZVI, reduction of the size and oxidation tendency of nZVI). We then presented the reaction mechanisms of Mt-nZVI for contaminant removal and evaluated the critical factors that influence the removal (e.g., pH, temperature, and dosage of the adsorbent). We further presented examples of applications of Mt-nZVI for the removal of typical contaminants such as heavy metals and organic compounds in soil and water. We finally discussed the limitations of the use of Mt-nZVI for water treatment and soil remediation and presented future directions for the application of nZVI technology for soil and water treatment.


---

## Body

## 1. Introduction

Water and soil contaminations are becoming more and more severe during the past few decades, which seriously damage the natural ecological balance and threaten human health [1]. Various techniques such as ion exchange, filtration, chemical precipitation, and electrochemical treatment have been employed to address the water and soil contaminations [2–4]. However, these techniques have a series of limitations including high cost, secondary pollution, and complicated operations [5]. Recently, the fabrication of adsorption materials with low cost and high performance for the treatment of soil and water has become a promising way [6]. Particularly, the use of nanoscale zerovalent iron (nZVI) has received focused attention [7].The nZVIs refer to nanoscale iron particles with amorphous structures, which have been widely applied to remove various contaminants because of their large specific surface area (SSA), strong adsorption activity, and reduction ability [8, 9]. However, nZVI tends to agglomerate into larger particles due to van der Waals and magnetic forces, which decreases the SSA and limits its adsorption capacity and mobility [10]. Moreover, nZVI is readily oxidized before reaching the target contaminants during in situ soil remediation, resulting in low longevity [11]. An effective approach to overcome the aforementioned problems is to load nZVI particles onto templates such as biochar [12], zeolite [13], and polymers [14]. Nevertheless, these templates need to be manufactured and/or are relatively expensive, and the fabrications are often complex [15]. Therefore, it is desirable to find low-cost load materials and develop more efficient methods of immobilization of nZVI on templates to take advantage of the real potential of nZVI [16].Montmorillonite (Mt) is a typical 2 : 1 layered silicate clay mineral with low cost, high cation exchange, and adsorption capacity (Figure1) [17]. It is usually composed of an interlayer with a thickness of 0.1-0.8 nm due to the isomorphous substitution within the layers (e.g., Si4+ replaced by Al3+ in the tetrahedral sheet and Al3+ replaced by Mg2+ in the octahedral sheet) (Figure 1). Hence, the Mt layers have permanent negative charges, which can be exchanged by other cations residing at and/or near the Mt surfaces [18]. This structure creates an ideal template to support nZVI particles (Figure 2) [19]. For example, bentonite (Bt) is a kind of natural clay mainly composed of Mt, which has been extensively used as a supporting material for nZVI [20]. Compared to nZVI or Mt, Mt-supported nZVI (Mt-nZVI) had higher removal efficiency for inorganic and organic contaminants [21–23]. This is because Mt can improve the dispersion and mobility of nZVI and reduce the particle size and oxidation tendency of nZVI [24–26]. Therefore, the Mt-nZVI composites have shown great potential for application in water and soil treatment.Figure 1
Structure of Mt. Modified from Reinholdt et al. [110].Figure 2
Schematic representation of the sectional structure of Mt-nZVI. Modified from Wu et al. [43].To date, various papers have made reviews on the synthesis, characteristic, application, or modification of nZVI (Table1) [1, 27, 28]. For instance, Li et al. [8] presented the synthesis, characterization, and applications of nZVI for the treatment of organic and inorganic contaminants. O’Carroll et al. [29] reviewed the application of nZVI and bimetallic particles. Lefevre et al. [30] summarized the impacts of nZVI applications on microbial communities. Ezzatahmadi et al. [31] reported an overview of different types of clay-supported nZVIs (e.g., Mt, kaolinite, zeolite, sepiolite, and palygorskite) for the remediation of contaminated aqueous solutions. However, no review has exclusively addressed the use of Mt-nZVI for soil and water remediation to date.Table 1
Summary of some key review papers on nZVI for water and soil treatments.
Publication dateMaterialFocus areaReference2006nZVISynthesis, characterization, and applications of nZVI for the treatment of organic and inorganic contaminants[8]2012nZVISynthesis and applications of nZVI for water treatment[27]2013nZVI/bimetallic nanometalsApplication of nZVI/bimetallic nanometals for thein situ remediation of chlorinated solvents and heavy metals[29]2013nZVIReactivity, stability, and effects of nZVI amendment on the biogeochemical environment[52]2016nZVIImpacts of nZVI applications on microbial communities[30]2016nZVIThe toxicity of nZVIs prior to the process of remediation and their effect on living organisms after application[28]2016nZVISynthesis, applications, and properties of stabilized nZVI[47]2017Clay-supported nZVIReaction mechanisms and removal efficiencies of clay-supported nZVI for the remediation of contaminated aqueous solutions[31]2019Biochar-supported nZVISynthesis, properties, and applications of biochar-supported nZVI for water and soil treatment[12]2019nZVISynthesis of nZVI-based materials and reaction mechanisms and influential factors between nZVIs and antibiotics[46]This paper provides an overview of the current knowledge of Mt-nZVI composites in water and soil applications. We firstly present the preparation methods of Mt-nZVI and discuss the advantages and disadvantages of the different methods. We highlight the benefits of using Mt as supporting material for nZVI. We then show in detail the reaction mechanisms of Mt-nZVI for contaminant removal and the main influencing factors on the removal using the Mt-nZVI. We further give examples of the applications of Mt-nZVI in soil and water remediation. We finally demonstrate the limitations of Mt-nZVI composites and show future research directions. Our work has important implications to improve the Mt-nZVI composites for application in water treatment and soil remediation.


## 2. Fabrication Methods of Mt-nZVI

### 2.1. Methods of Synthesizing Modified Mt

The properties of Mt have a great influence on the application of Mt-nZVI. The pristine Mt is commonly Ca-Mt, which has a permanent negative charge. Positively charged hydrated cations (e.g., K+, Na+, and Ca2+) can be adsorbed in the layers to maintain charge balance [32]. These cations can be exchanged by other organic/inorganic cations, making Mt an efficient adsorbent for cationic contaminants [33].


#### 2.1.1. Inorganic Modified Mt

Na-Mt has better physicochemical properties compared to Ca-Mt, such as strong cation exchangeability, high dispersion in the water medium, large expansion capacity, and great thermal stability [34]. Therefore, Na-Mt is frequently used as the raw material to prepare Mt-nZVI. Alternatively, K-Mt [21] and Al-Mt [33] have also been used to synthesize Mt-nZVI.Due to electrostatic interaction, the negatively charged Na-Mt-supported nZVI normally favors the adsorption of cationic contaminants [33, 35], while the positively charged K-Mt- and Al-Mt-supported nZVIs favor the adsorption of anionic contaminants [21, 33, 36]. For example, Sheng et al. [25] revealed that the removal efficiency of U(VI) (100 mg L-1) by Na-Bt-supported nZVI (0.2 g L-1) reached 99.2% after 90 min, which was higher than that by Al-Bt-supported nZVI (65.6%) (Table 2). Li et al. [35] found that Na-Bt-supported nZVI had higher removal efficiency for Ni(II) (98.5%) compared to Al-Bt-supported nZVI (45.4%) under the same condition (Table 2). However, the removal efficiency of K-Mt-supported nZVI and Al-Mt-supported nZVI for Cr(VI) was higher than that of Na-Mt-supported nZVI [21]. The method of inorganic modification of Mt is relatively simple, which can improve the adsorption of Mt-nZVI to target inorganic contaminants.Table 2
Representative studies dealing with contaminant removal from water by Mt-nZVI.
AdsorbentsParticle size (nm)SSA (m2 g-1)Target contaminantsOperational conditionsAdsorption capacity (mg·g−1)EfficiencyReferenceBt-nZVI—39.94Cr(VI)C0=50mgL−1,C=4gL−1,pH=5—100% in 180 min[81]Mt-nZVI——Cr(VI)C0=20mgL−1,C=2.75gL−1,pH=5.531.6599.75% in 240 min[15]Mt-nZVI——Cr(VI)C0=50mgL−1,C=0.33gL−1,pH=590.9—[43]Hexadecyltrimethylammonium bromide-modified Mt-supported nZVI109.9Bt-nZVI53.2—Cr(VI)C0=50mgL−1,C=1gL−1,pH=9—56.8% in 60 min[95]Bt-supported organosolv lignin-stabilized nZVI20.162.3% in 60 minZeolite-supported nZVI11.729.1Pb(II)C0=200mgL−1,C=2.5gL−1,pH=3‐6115.1±11.099% in 40 min[77]Mt-nZVI9.320.9105.5±9.0Bt-nZVI20-5024.3-46.5Pb(II)C0=200mgL−1,C=1gL−1,pH=7—95% in 240 min[50]Na-Mt-supported nZVI31.8U(VI)C0=100mgL−1,C=0.2gL−1, initial pH99.2% in 90 min[25]Al-Mt-supported nZVI46.965.6% in 90 minMt-nZVI—91.42U(VI)C0=0.1mgL−1,C=0.1gL−1,pH=3—97.8% in 3 min[32]Mt-nZVI40.1Zn(II)C0=50mgL−1,C=5gL−1,pH=510.33—[34]Bt-nZVI—42.88Cu(II)C0=100mgL−1,C=1gL−1,pH=5±0.373.3771% in 16 h[88]Bt- and graphene oxide-supported nZVIs42.3547.3283.8982% in 16 hNa-Mt-supported nZVI—46.9Ni(II)C0=200mgL−1,C=0.25gL−1,pH=6—98.5% in 120 min[35]Al-Mt-supported nZVI31.845.4% in 120 minBt-nZVI30-7029.8NO3-C0=50mgL−1,C=0.5gL−1,pH=7—100% in 120 min[86]Mt-nZVI—11.78NO3-C0=60mgL−1,C=0.67gL−1,pH=7.0±0.3—32.6±1.9% in 24 h[99]Mt-nZVI30-170—Se(VI)C0=200mgL−1,C=2.5gL−1,pH=734.2142.76% in 24 h[76]As(V)54.7568.43% in 24 hMt-nZVI—36.97As(III)C0=5mgL−1,C=1gL−1,pH=759.9—[82]As(V)45.5Bt-nZVI10-6066.5Co(II)C0=100mgL−1,C=1.25gL−1, initial pH—90.0% in 120 min[49]N,N,N-trimethyl-1-dodecanaminium salt-modified Mt-supported nZVI<5—2,4-DichlorophenolC0=20mgL−1,C=15mgL−1, initial pH—>99% in 10 h[19]Mt-nZVI——TrichloroethyleneC0=250mgL−1,C=4gL−1, initial pH—78.7% in 12 h[102]Mt-nZVI56.1% in 12 hCetyltrimethylammonium bromide- (CTMAB-) modified Mt-supported nZVI30–9036.431Decabromodiphenyl etherC0=2mgL−1,C=0.6gL−1,pH=5.5—98.02% in 24 h[73]Tetramethylammonium-modified Mt-supported nZVI0.5—Decabromodiphenyl etherC0=2.5mgL−1,C=4gL−1,pH=9.6—>80% in 90 min[42]Cetyltrimethylammonium bromide- (CTMAB-) modified Mt-supported nZVI—29.5PentachlorophenolC0=53mgL−1,C=0.6gL−1,pH=6—96.2% in 120 min[40]Mt-nZVI—47.4—49.6% in 120 minMt-nZVI84—Bisphenol AC0=25mgL−1,C=0.4gL−1,pH=3—99.3% in 30 min[64]CTMAB-modified Mt-supported nZVI—36.4Tetrabromobisphenol AC0=10mgL−1,C=0.1gL−1,pH=7—98.6% in 60 min[26]Bisphenol A94.7% in 60 minBt-nZVI—39.94Acid violet red BC0=800mgL−1,C=2.8gL−1, initial pH—95.6% in 9 min[74]Bt-nZVI—39.94Methyl orangeC0=100mgL−1,C=1gL−1,pH=5.699.80% in 40 min[24]Mt-nZVI——Rhodamine 6GC0=5000mgL−1,C=10gL−1, initial pH500100% in 15 min[78]Bt-nZVI40–12047.4NitrobenzeneC0=200mgL−1,C=0.3gL−1,pH=6—87.2% in 90 min[41]Cetyltrimethylammonium-modified Bt-supported nZVI40-9031.498.2% in 60 minCTMAB-modified Mt-supported nZVI——SulfamethazineC0=20mgL−1,C=1.5mM,pH=6.8—92% in 5 min[44]Mt-nZVI76% in 5 minMt-nZVI——OxytetracyclineC0=100mgL−1,C=0.6gL−1,pH=5—99% in 20 min[75]Bt-nZVI——AmoxicillinC0=20mgL−1,C=4gL−1, initial pH5.593.5% in 40 min[91]SSA denotes the specific surface area;C0 and C denote the concentration of contaminants and adsorbents, respectively.


#### 2.1.2. Organic Modified Mt

While Mt is hydrophilic and negatively charged, organic contaminants are usually hydrophobic [37]. Consequently, some nonionic or anionic organic compounds have poor adsorption affinity with Mt-nZVI [38]. To overcome the limitations, cationic surfactants have been used as modifiers of Mt [39]. Quaternary ammonium salt cations are common cationic surfactants such as cetyltrimethylammonium (CTMA) [40, 41], cetyltrimethylammonium bromide (CTMAB) [26, 42], and hexadecyltrimethylammonium bromide (HDTMA) [43].The advantages of using organic modified Mt-supported nZVI to remove organic compounds have been reported. Substituting the inorganic cations (e.g., Na+) with organic ammonium cations (e.g., DTA+) in the Mt interlayer can further increase the layer spacing and enhance the adsorption capacity of organic contaminants on Mt by changing the surface of Mt from hydrophilic to hydrophobic [19, 42, 44]. For example, Li et al. [40] reported that the efficiency of pentachlorophenol (53 mg L-1) removed by CTMA-modified Bt-supported nZVI (0.6 g L-1) reached 96.2% within 120 min at pH 6, which was higher than that by Bt-nZVI (49.6%). Moreover, the degradation efficiency of decabromodiphenyl ether (DBDE) by tetramethylammonium- (TMA-) modified smectite-supported nZVI was 10 times greater than that by nZVI. Note that the organic modified Mt can also inhibit the rapid consumption of nZVI by forming a hydrophobic environment in the clay interlayer. For example, Jia and Wang [19] used N,N,N-trimethyl-1-dodecanaminium salt- (DTA+-) modified smectite-supported nZVI to remove 2,4-dichlorophenol (2,4-DCP) and found that almost 100% of 2,4-DCP could be dechlorinated even after five cycles on organo-smectite-supported nZVI, but smectite-supported nZVI only dechlorinated twice.


### 2.2. Methods of Synthesizing Mt-nZVI

#### 2.2.1. Liquid-Phase Reduction

Wang and Zhang [45] were the first to develop a liquid-phase reduction method to prepare nZVI. This technique has then become the most widely used method to prepare nZVI in laboratories [46]. In this approach, nZVI is synthesized by reduction of Fe3+ or Fe2+ in aqueous solutions using NaBH4 under N2 atmosphere (Equations (1) and (2)) [31, 47]:
(1)4Fe3++3BH4−+9H2O⟶4Fe0+3BO3−+12H++6H2(2)2Fe2++BH4−+3H2O⟶2Fe0+BO3−+4H++3H2The Mt-nZVI is synthesized by a slightly modified liquid-phase reduction method with Mt as support [21]. Briefly, Mt-nZVI is typically prepared under N2 atmosphere by using NaBH4 to reduce Fe3+ or Fe2+ to Fe0 in the presence of Mt as the supporting material (Figure 3(a)). The Mt is used as a layered template to limit the size of the nZVI formed at the nanoscale (60-80 nm) and direct the distribution of nZVI clusters [19, 48–50]. The scanning electron microscope (SEM) images of Bt-supported nZVI (Bt-nZVI) (Figure 4(a)) synthesized by the aforementioned method showed that the aggregation of nZVI particles was decreased due to Bt [51]. Various organic or inorganic modifiers can be used to modify Mt before the preparation of Mt-nZVI to improve its adsorption performance and dispersibility in organic media [33], which are detailed later in the paper.Figure 3
Illustration of the synthesis process of Mt-nZVI by different methods: (a) liquid-phase reduction; (b) heteroaggregates of Mt with nZVIs; (c) green synthesis method; (d) thermal reduction method.
(a)(b)(c)(d)Figure 4
SEM images of (a) Bt-nZVI [51] synthesized by liquid-phase reduction and (b) heteroaggregates of Mt with nZVIs [15]. TEM images of (c) Bt and (d) Bt-supported “green” nZVI synthesized by green synthesis [60]. SEM images of (e) Fe-Mt and (f) Fe-Mt-H2 synthesized by thermal reduction method [64].
(a)(b)(c)(d)(e)(f)There exist several drawbacks to the liquid-phase reduction method. First, it is relatively expensive due to the high cost of NaBH4 [52]. Second, NaBH4 may destroy some chemical bonds in Mt or Bt, resulting in a change of the proportion of Mt or Bt [50]. Third, the nZVI is hard to be evenly distributed on the template surfaces. For example, Wang et al. [53] prepared Mt-nZVI and observed that more nZVI particles were dispersed at the edge of the Mt, and few particles were distributed in the middle part of Mt. This ununiform distribution of nZVI on template surfaces could affect the mobility of the composite in the environment because the distribution morphology of nZVI on the template surfaces influences the interaction energy between the composite and the collector surfaces and accordingly the attachment.


#### 2.2.2. Heteroaggregates of Mt with nZVIs

Yin et al. [15] presented a novel technique to prepare Mt-nZVI based on the liquid-phase reduction method. Specifically, nZVI colloidal suspension was first synthesized by the liquid-phase reduction reaction [54], and the nZVIs were allowed to attach to surfaces of Mt in solutions in a monolayer (Figure 3(b)). The Mt solution was prepared by sedimentation siphon separation [55]. The SEM images of Mt-nZVI synthesized by this method showed that the nZVI particles were evenly distributed on the Mt surfaces in a monolayer (Figure 4(b)) [15].In this approach, the sizes of nZVI particles could be changed via the liquid-phase reduction method and the concentration of the attached nZVI particles on Mt could be controlled by varying experimental conditions (e.g., the ratio of concentrations of Mt and nZVI in suspension) [15]. The fabricated heteroaggregates of nZVIs with Mt had a unique micro/nanostructure. This structure favors the heteroaggregates to attach to collector surfaces and then detach even with a minor change of system conditions [56, 57]. Therefore, the Mt-nZVI has great mobility in the subsurface environments through continuous capture and release, showing the promise for the in situ treatment of contaminants in soil [15]. Note that the previous method can also change the sizes of nZVI particles by changing experimental conditions.


#### 2.2.3. Green Synthesis

The chemical synthesis methods of Mt-nZVI may lead to toxic chemicals (e.g., borohydride) absorbed on their surfaces [58]. Alternatively, the green synthesis method used plant extracts containing naturally derived polyphenolic compounds (instead of NaBH4) as reducing agents to synthesize Mt-nZVI [59]. For example, Soliemanzadeh and Fekri [60] used green tea extracts to prepare Bt-loaded “green” nZVI. The green tea extract solution was prepared by heating the plant extracts to a temperature close to the boiling point, and then it was mixed with the Bt and Fe2+ solution (Figure 3(c)). The transmission electron microscope (TEM) images (Figures 4(e) and 4(f)) indicated that nZVIs were successfully supported on the Bt surface. Moreover, the composite material prepared by this method was found to be effective for the adsorption of Cr(VI) in contaminated soil and aqueous environments.The green synthesis method has the following advantages. First, plant extracts can better stabilize the reaction surface of nanoparticles than NaBH4 and decrease their biotoxicity [52]. Second, excess polyphenols in solution during preparation could encapsulate the synthesized Mt-nZVI and prevent its further oxidation [58]. Third, the use of natural active biological components can reduce the total cost of the synthesis process [61]. However, it should be noted that plant extracts may not completely reduce iron to nZVI, resulting in other forms of iron on template surfaces. Moreover, the preparation method of “green” extracts is relatively complicated, and the disposal of residues after extraction needs to be addressed [62]. These limitations decrease the application of green synthesis [28].


#### 2.2.4. Thermal Reduction Method

Mt-nZVI can also be obtained through the thermal reduction of iron compounds [28]. In this method, the thermal energy and gaseous reducing agents were adopted to drive the reduction of iron oxide or hydrous Fe2+ at elevated temperatures in the presence of Mt [63]. For instance, Yang et al. [64] added an aqueous dispersion of Mt to the mixture of ferric nitrate and sodium carbonate to synthesize iron-pillared Mt (Fe-Mt) [65] and obtained Fe0-Mt composites (Fe-Mt-H2) through thermal reduction under mixed H2 and N2 atmosphere (Figure 3(d)). The SEM images of Fe-Mt showed that small needle-like Fe particles attached to the surface of Mt (Figure 4(e)). With high-temperature pyrolysis, small needle-like protrusions distributed on the Mt surfaces partially turned into large cube-like particles (Figure 4(f)). Compared with Mt-nZVI prepared by the aforementioned liquid-phase reduction, Fe-Mt-H2 embedded more Fe0 in Mt with larger sizes, which might be more difficult to be oxidized.The thermal reduction method is cheaper and energy-saving because it does not require NaBH4 for Fe ion reduction compared to the liquid-phase reduction method. The production of toxic chemicals is also avoided [12]. The method is also environmentally friendly because only gaseous products are generated [28]. However, this method requires high-temperature conditions, which is energy-consuming and may bring potential risks during the preparation [31].Although the cost of producing Mt-nZVI has been reduced, large-scale preparation and application are still expensive. Further improvement is thus necessary to produce high-quality, low-cost, and environmentally friendly Mt-nZVI. For example, it is vital to develop some cheap and environmentally friendly reducing agents to replace NaBH4. Additionally, different modifying agents can be used to introduce various functional groups into the Mt interlayer to increase Mt-nZVI’s adsorption activity to target contaminants [66].


### 2.3. Advantages of Using Mt to Support nZVI

The clay minerals are nontoxic, low cost, and environmentally friendly. Moreover, they have a high surface area and adsorption ability [67, 68]. A number of studies demonstrated that the adsorption capacity of Mt was stronger than that of other clay minerals [69–71]. Furthermore, the combination of Mt and nZVI can result in a synergetic effect between adsorption by the Mt and removal by nZVI particles [31]. There are several advantages of using Mt to support nZVI, such as improvement of the dispersion and mobility and reduction of the particle size and oxidation tendency [21, 26]. These advantages will be elaborated on in detail in the following.


#### 2.3.1. Increased Dispersion

Typically, the bare nZVI particles were spherical and formed prominent chainlike aggregates; adding Mt into nZVI can improve the dispersibility of nZVI [19]. Several possible reasons have been used to explain the increased dispersion of nZVI in Mt. First, during the preparation of the Mt-nZVI, Fe3+(or Fe2+) is uniformly absorbed into the interlayer of Mt through ion exchange [19]. This can control the nucleation of nZVI clusters produced by the reduction of Fe3+(or Fe2+) and limit the growth of particles, thereby preventing the aggregation of nZVI clusters [72]. Second, the interlaminar distance (between clay sheets) of Mt clay is between 0.1 and 0.8 nm, which creates an ideal template to carry nZVI clusters (Figure 2) [18]. Adding nZVI into Mt can increase its interlayer spacing. The basal spacing of Mt-nZVI calculated by Pang et al. [73] was 2.450 nm, which was 0.571 nm larger than that of Mt. This phenomenon might be explained by the fact that the hydration radius of Fe3+ was much larger than that of Na+, and when Na+ was replaced by Fe3+, the interlayer spacing of Mt was increased. In short, the nZVI clusters have intercalated the interlayers of Mt and acted as pillars, thus expanding the interlayer distance. In addition, the surface area of Mt is much larger than that of nZVI, which can significantly increase the surface dispersion of nZVI [21]. Third, as a 2 : 1 layer silicate due to the swelling of the interlayer, the layers in Mt are separated into discrete single-layer units, which make Mt highly accessible in the suspension to some extent, thereby enhancing the reactivity of Mt-nZVI [72, 74]. Notably, the nZVI aggregation decreased as Mt loadings increased [22, 68, 75].


#### 2.3.2. Small nZVI Size

The presence of templates such as Mt or Bt can reduce particle sizes of nZVI [76]. For example, Arancibia-Miranda et al. [77] found that the average diameter of Mt-nZVI was 9.3 nm, which was smaller than that of nZVI (16.9 nm). The X-ray diffraction (XRD) patterns from Peng et al. [26] have shown that the peak value of the organo-Mt- (OMt-) supported nZVI (OMt-nZVI) was weaker and broader at 44.78° compared with that of bare nZVI (Figure 5(a)), indicating the smaller crystallite size of nZVI within OMt-nZVI. The sizes of nZVI can be further decreased with the increase of the mass ratios of Mt/iron [68, 75, 76].Figure 5
XRD patterns of (a) (A) OMt, (B) OMt-nZVI, and (C) nZVI [26] and (b) (A) nZVI, (B) Mt-nZVI, (C) K-Mt-supported nZVI (K-Mt-nZVI), and (D) starch-stabilized K-Mt-nZVI [21].
(a)(b)Smaller size of nZVI means larger SSA and stronger adsorption capacity [34]. Compared with Mt, the SSA of Mt-nZVI is increased as a result of massive nZVI particles supported on the surface or interlayers of Mt [24, 36]. Although the SSA of Mt-nZVI is lower than that of nZVI, the stability and reactivity of nZVI are stronger after being monodispersed on Mt [68].


#### 2.3.3. Improved nZVI’s Stability against Oxidization

The nZVI is easily oxidized when exposed to the air, which greatly affects its reducibility [72]. Mt can reduce the surface corrosion of nZVI and improve its stability [12]. According to the XRD results of Mt-nZVI by Zhang et al. [21] (Figure 5(b)), the characteristic peaks of iron oxide were not observed, indicating that the nZVI particles were not oxidized or only a small part of them was oxidized to form amorphous iron oxide. Rao et al. [78] investigated the antioxidant abilities of Mt-nZVI and nZVI by observing their color changes in the air at different time slots. The black nZVI solution totally turned yellow at 72 h, while only a small part of the Mt-nZVI solution turned yellow, revealing that nZVI loaded on Mt was more difficult to be oxidized compared to pristine nZVI. This phenomenon can be explained by the fact that Mt has a layered structure, and when the nZVIs are inserted in the interlayer of Mt, they were not readily available for oxidization [25].Li et al. [79] found that fewer oxides were formed on Bt-nZVI compared to nZVI. The removal efficiency of Se(VI) by Bt-nZVI only decreased 3.7% after four cycle experiments. The results indicated that Bt-nZVI displayed much higher stability and reusability than nZVI, which was partly due to the fact that Bt inhibited the oxidation of nZVI. Another possible reason was the buffering effect of some particular functional groups of Bt [79]. Moreover, when Fe2O3 was formed and precipitated on the surfaces of nZVI during the reaction of Bt-nZVI with contaminants, Bt could help to transfer some precipitates from nZVI surfaces and prolong the reactivity of nZVI [65].


#### 2.3.4. Other Advantages

Tomasevic et al. [67] and Kerkez et al. [69] demonstrated that the total pore volume of the Mt-nZVI was larger than that of Mt and nZVI. This is because of the formation of more mesoporous structures by the intercalated nZVI, which enhanced the diffusion and adsorption of contaminants [26]. In addition, the introduction of Mt may improve the sustainability of nZVI, inhibit the rapid consumption of nZVI, and ultimately enhance the service life of composite materials [19]. Finally, Bt-nZVI has higher stability (lower sedimentation) and greater mobility in porous media than nZVI [80]. For example, Shi et al. [68] conducted column experiments and revealed that the sedimentation rate of Mt-nZVI was greatly decreased and its mobility was significantly increased compared with that of bare nZVI. This is because the zeta potentials of nZVI particles changed from positive to negative after the addition of Mt, which led to the repulsive interaction between Bt-nZVI and quartz sand [80].


## 2.1. Methods of Synthesizing Modified Mt

The properties of Mt have a great influence on the application of Mt-nZVI. The pristine Mt is commonly Ca-Mt, which has a permanent negative charge. Positively charged hydrated cations (e.g., K+, Na+, and Ca2+) can be adsorbed in the layers to maintain charge balance [32]. These cations can be exchanged by other organic/inorganic cations, making Mt an efficient adsorbent for cationic contaminants [33].


### 2.1.1. Inorganic Modified Mt

Na-Mt has better physicochemical properties compared to Ca-Mt, such as strong cation exchangeability, high dispersion in the water medium, large expansion capacity, and great thermal stability [34]. Therefore, Na-Mt is frequently used as the raw material to prepare Mt-nZVI. Alternatively, K-Mt [21] and Al-Mt [33] have also been used to synthesize Mt-nZVI.Due to electrostatic interaction, the negatively charged Na-Mt-supported nZVI normally favors the adsorption of cationic contaminants [33, 35], while the positively charged K-Mt- and Al-Mt-supported nZVIs favor the adsorption of anionic contaminants [21, 33, 36]. For example, Sheng et al. [25] revealed that the removal efficiency of U(VI) (100 mg L-1) by Na-Bt-supported nZVI (0.2 g L-1) reached 99.2% after 90 min, which was higher than that by Al-Bt-supported nZVI (65.6%) (Table 2). Li et al. [35] found that Na-Bt-supported nZVI had higher removal efficiency for Ni(II) (98.5%) compared to Al-Bt-supported nZVI (45.4%) under the same condition (Table 2). However, the removal efficiency of K-Mt-supported nZVI and Al-Mt-supported nZVI for Cr(VI) was higher than that of Na-Mt-supported nZVI [21]. The method of inorganic modification of Mt is relatively simple, which can improve the adsorption of Mt-nZVI to target inorganic contaminants.Table 2
Representative studies dealing with contaminant removal from water by Mt-nZVI.
AdsorbentsParticle size (nm)SSA (m2 g-1)Target contaminantsOperational conditionsAdsorption capacity (mg·g−1)EfficiencyReferenceBt-nZVI—39.94Cr(VI)C0=50mgL−1,C=4gL−1,pH=5—100% in 180 min[81]Mt-nZVI——Cr(VI)C0=20mgL−1,C=2.75gL−1,pH=5.531.6599.75% in 240 min[15]Mt-nZVI——Cr(VI)C0=50mgL−1,C=0.33gL−1,pH=590.9—[43]Hexadecyltrimethylammonium bromide-modified Mt-supported nZVI109.9Bt-nZVI53.2—Cr(VI)C0=50mgL−1,C=1gL−1,pH=9—56.8% in 60 min[95]Bt-supported organosolv lignin-stabilized nZVI20.162.3% in 60 minZeolite-supported nZVI11.729.1Pb(II)C0=200mgL−1,C=2.5gL−1,pH=3‐6115.1±11.099% in 40 min[77]Mt-nZVI9.320.9105.5±9.0Bt-nZVI20-5024.3-46.5Pb(II)C0=200mgL−1,C=1gL−1,pH=7—95% in 240 min[50]Na-Mt-supported nZVI31.8U(VI)C0=100mgL−1,C=0.2gL−1, initial pH99.2% in 90 min[25]Al-Mt-supported nZVI46.965.6% in 90 minMt-nZVI—91.42U(VI)C0=0.1mgL−1,C=0.1gL−1,pH=3—97.8% in 3 min[32]Mt-nZVI40.1Zn(II)C0=50mgL−1,C=5gL−1,pH=510.33—[34]Bt-nZVI—42.88Cu(II)C0=100mgL−1,C=1gL−1,pH=5±0.373.3771% in 16 h[88]Bt- and graphene oxide-supported nZVIs42.3547.3283.8982% in 16 hNa-Mt-supported nZVI—46.9Ni(II)C0=200mgL−1,C=0.25gL−1,pH=6—98.5% in 120 min[35]Al-Mt-supported nZVI31.845.4% in 120 minBt-nZVI30-7029.8NO3-C0=50mgL−1,C=0.5gL−1,pH=7—100% in 120 min[86]Mt-nZVI—11.78NO3-C0=60mgL−1,C=0.67gL−1,pH=7.0±0.3—32.6±1.9% in 24 h[99]Mt-nZVI30-170—Se(VI)C0=200mgL−1,C=2.5gL−1,pH=734.2142.76% in 24 h[76]As(V)54.7568.43% in 24 hMt-nZVI—36.97As(III)C0=5mgL−1,C=1gL−1,pH=759.9—[82]As(V)45.5Bt-nZVI10-6066.5Co(II)C0=100mgL−1,C=1.25gL−1, initial pH—90.0% in 120 min[49]N,N,N-trimethyl-1-dodecanaminium salt-modified Mt-supported nZVI<5—2,4-DichlorophenolC0=20mgL−1,C=15mgL−1, initial pH—>99% in 10 h[19]Mt-nZVI——TrichloroethyleneC0=250mgL−1,C=4gL−1, initial pH—78.7% in 12 h[102]Mt-nZVI56.1% in 12 hCetyltrimethylammonium bromide- (CTMAB-) modified Mt-supported nZVI30–9036.431Decabromodiphenyl etherC0=2mgL−1,C=0.6gL−1,pH=5.5—98.02% in 24 h[73]Tetramethylammonium-modified Mt-supported nZVI0.5—Decabromodiphenyl etherC0=2.5mgL−1,C=4gL−1,pH=9.6—>80% in 90 min[42]Cetyltrimethylammonium bromide- (CTMAB-) modified Mt-supported nZVI—29.5PentachlorophenolC0=53mgL−1,C=0.6gL−1,pH=6—96.2% in 120 min[40]Mt-nZVI—47.4—49.6% in 120 minMt-nZVI84—Bisphenol AC0=25mgL−1,C=0.4gL−1,pH=3—99.3% in 30 min[64]CTMAB-modified Mt-supported nZVI—36.4Tetrabromobisphenol AC0=10mgL−1,C=0.1gL−1,pH=7—98.6% in 60 min[26]Bisphenol A94.7% in 60 minBt-nZVI—39.94Acid violet red BC0=800mgL−1,C=2.8gL−1, initial pH—95.6% in 9 min[74]Bt-nZVI—39.94Methyl orangeC0=100mgL−1,C=1gL−1,pH=5.699.80% in 40 min[24]Mt-nZVI——Rhodamine 6GC0=5000mgL−1,C=10gL−1, initial pH500100% in 15 min[78]Bt-nZVI40–12047.4NitrobenzeneC0=200mgL−1,C=0.3gL−1,pH=6—87.2% in 90 min[41]Cetyltrimethylammonium-modified Bt-supported nZVI40-9031.498.2% in 60 minCTMAB-modified Mt-supported nZVI——SulfamethazineC0=20mgL−1,C=1.5mM,pH=6.8—92% in 5 min[44]Mt-nZVI76% in 5 minMt-nZVI——OxytetracyclineC0=100mgL−1,C=0.6gL−1,pH=5—99% in 20 min[75]Bt-nZVI——AmoxicillinC0=20mgL−1,C=4gL−1, initial pH5.593.5% in 40 min[91]SSA denotes the specific surface area;C0 and C denote the concentration of contaminants and adsorbents, respectively.


### 2.1.2. Organic Modified Mt

While Mt is hydrophilic and negatively charged, organic contaminants are usually hydrophobic [37]. Consequently, some nonionic or anionic organic compounds have poor adsorption affinity with Mt-nZVI [38]. To overcome the limitations, cationic surfactants have been used as modifiers of Mt [39]. Quaternary ammonium salt cations are common cationic surfactants such as cetyltrimethylammonium (CTMA) [40, 41], cetyltrimethylammonium bromide (CTMAB) [26, 42], and hexadecyltrimethylammonium bromide (HDTMA) [43].The advantages of using organic modified Mt-supported nZVI to remove organic compounds have been reported. Substituting the inorganic cations (e.g., Na+) with organic ammonium cations (e.g., DTA+) in the Mt interlayer can further increase the layer spacing and enhance the adsorption capacity of organic contaminants on Mt by changing the surface of Mt from hydrophilic to hydrophobic [19, 42, 44]. For example, Li et al. [40] reported that the efficiency of pentachlorophenol (53 mg L-1) removed by CTMA-modified Bt-supported nZVI (0.6 g L-1) reached 96.2% within 120 min at pH 6, which was higher than that by Bt-nZVI (49.6%). Moreover, the degradation efficiency of decabromodiphenyl ether (DBDE) by tetramethylammonium- (TMA-) modified smectite-supported nZVI was 10 times greater than that by nZVI. Note that the organic modified Mt can also inhibit the rapid consumption of nZVI by forming a hydrophobic environment in the clay interlayer. For example, Jia and Wang [19] used N,N,N-trimethyl-1-dodecanaminium salt- (DTA+-) modified smectite-supported nZVI to remove 2,4-dichlorophenol (2,4-DCP) and found that almost 100% of 2,4-DCP could be dechlorinated even after five cycles on organo-smectite-supported nZVI, but smectite-supported nZVI only dechlorinated twice.


## 2.1.1. Inorganic Modified Mt

Na-Mt has better physicochemical properties compared to Ca-Mt, such as strong cation exchangeability, high dispersion in the water medium, large expansion capacity, and great thermal stability [34]. Therefore, Na-Mt is frequently used as the raw material to prepare Mt-nZVI. Alternatively, K-Mt [21] and Al-Mt [33] have also been used to synthesize Mt-nZVI.Due to electrostatic interaction, the negatively charged Na-Mt-supported nZVI normally favors the adsorption of cationic contaminants [33, 35], while the positively charged K-Mt- and Al-Mt-supported nZVIs favor the adsorption of anionic contaminants [21, 33, 36]. For example, Sheng et al. [25] revealed that the removal efficiency of U(VI) (100 mg L-1) by Na-Bt-supported nZVI (0.2 g L-1) reached 99.2% after 90 min, which was higher than that by Al-Bt-supported nZVI (65.6%) (Table 2). Li et al. [35] found that Na-Bt-supported nZVI had higher removal efficiency for Ni(II) (98.5%) compared to Al-Bt-supported nZVI (45.4%) under the same condition (Table 2). However, the removal efficiency of K-Mt-supported nZVI and Al-Mt-supported nZVI for Cr(VI) was higher than that of Na-Mt-supported nZVI [21]. The method of inorganic modification of Mt is relatively simple, which can improve the adsorption of Mt-nZVI to target inorganic contaminants.Table 2
Representative studies dealing with contaminant removal from water by Mt-nZVI.
AdsorbentsParticle size (nm)SSA (m2 g-1)Target contaminantsOperational conditionsAdsorption capacity (mg·g−1)EfficiencyReferenceBt-nZVI—39.94Cr(VI)C0=50mgL−1,C=4gL−1,pH=5—100% in 180 min[81]Mt-nZVI——Cr(VI)C0=20mgL−1,C=2.75gL−1,pH=5.531.6599.75% in 240 min[15]Mt-nZVI——Cr(VI)C0=50mgL−1,C=0.33gL−1,pH=590.9—[43]Hexadecyltrimethylammonium bromide-modified Mt-supported nZVI109.9Bt-nZVI53.2—Cr(VI)C0=50mgL−1,C=1gL−1,pH=9—56.8% in 60 min[95]Bt-supported organosolv lignin-stabilized nZVI20.162.3% in 60 minZeolite-supported nZVI11.729.1Pb(II)C0=200mgL−1,C=2.5gL−1,pH=3‐6115.1±11.099% in 40 min[77]Mt-nZVI9.320.9105.5±9.0Bt-nZVI20-5024.3-46.5Pb(II)C0=200mgL−1,C=1gL−1,pH=7—95% in 240 min[50]Na-Mt-supported nZVI31.8U(VI)C0=100mgL−1,C=0.2gL−1, initial pH99.2% in 90 min[25]Al-Mt-supported nZVI46.965.6% in 90 minMt-nZVI—91.42U(VI)C0=0.1mgL−1,C=0.1gL−1,pH=3—97.8% in 3 min[32]Mt-nZVI40.1Zn(II)C0=50mgL−1,C=5gL−1,pH=510.33—[34]Bt-nZVI—42.88Cu(II)C0=100mgL−1,C=1gL−1,pH=5±0.373.3771% in 16 h[88]Bt- and graphene oxide-supported nZVIs42.3547.3283.8982% in 16 hNa-Mt-supported nZVI—46.9Ni(II)C0=200mgL−1,C=0.25gL−1,pH=6—98.5% in 120 min[35]Al-Mt-supported nZVI31.845.4% in 120 minBt-nZVI30-7029.8NO3-C0=50mgL−1,C=0.5gL−1,pH=7—100% in 120 min[86]Mt-nZVI—11.78NO3-C0=60mgL−1,C=0.67gL−1,pH=7.0±0.3—32.6±1.9% in 24 h[99]Mt-nZVI30-170—Se(VI)C0=200mgL−1,C=2.5gL−1,pH=734.2142.76% in 24 h[76]As(V)54.7568.43% in 24 hMt-nZVI—36.97As(III)C0=5mgL−1,C=1gL−1,pH=759.9—[82]As(V)45.5Bt-nZVI10-6066.5Co(II)C0=100mgL−1,C=1.25gL−1, initial pH—90.0% in 120 min[49]N,N,N-trimethyl-1-dodecanaminium salt-modified Mt-supported nZVI<5—2,4-DichlorophenolC0=20mgL−1,C=15mgL−1, initial pH—>99% in 10 h[19]Mt-nZVI——TrichloroethyleneC0=250mgL−1,C=4gL−1, initial pH—78.7% in 12 h[102]Mt-nZVI56.1% in 12 hCetyltrimethylammonium bromide- (CTMAB-) modified Mt-supported nZVI30–9036.431Decabromodiphenyl etherC0=2mgL−1,C=0.6gL−1,pH=5.5—98.02% in 24 h[73]Tetramethylammonium-modified Mt-supported nZVI0.5—Decabromodiphenyl etherC0=2.5mgL−1,C=4gL−1,pH=9.6—>80% in 90 min[42]Cetyltrimethylammonium bromide- (CTMAB-) modified Mt-supported nZVI—29.5PentachlorophenolC0=53mgL−1,C=0.6gL−1,pH=6—96.2% in 120 min[40]Mt-nZVI—47.4—49.6% in 120 minMt-nZVI84—Bisphenol AC0=25mgL−1,C=0.4gL−1,pH=3—99.3% in 30 min[64]CTMAB-modified Mt-supported nZVI—36.4Tetrabromobisphenol AC0=10mgL−1,C=0.1gL−1,pH=7—98.6% in 60 min[26]Bisphenol A94.7% in 60 minBt-nZVI—39.94Acid violet red BC0=800mgL−1,C=2.8gL−1, initial pH—95.6% in 9 min[74]Bt-nZVI—39.94Methyl orangeC0=100mgL−1,C=1gL−1,pH=5.699.80% in 40 min[24]Mt-nZVI——Rhodamine 6GC0=5000mgL−1,C=10gL−1, initial pH500100% in 15 min[78]Bt-nZVI40–12047.4NitrobenzeneC0=200mgL−1,C=0.3gL−1,pH=6—87.2% in 90 min[41]Cetyltrimethylammonium-modified Bt-supported nZVI40-9031.498.2% in 60 minCTMAB-modified Mt-supported nZVI——SulfamethazineC0=20mgL−1,C=1.5mM,pH=6.8—92% in 5 min[44]Mt-nZVI76% in 5 minMt-nZVI——OxytetracyclineC0=100mgL−1,C=0.6gL−1,pH=5—99% in 20 min[75]Bt-nZVI——AmoxicillinC0=20mgL−1,C=4gL−1, initial pH5.593.5% in 40 min[91]SSA denotes the specific surface area;C0 and C denote the concentration of contaminants and adsorbents, respectively.


## 2.1.2. Organic Modified Mt

While Mt is hydrophilic and negatively charged, organic contaminants are usually hydrophobic [37]. Consequently, some nonionic or anionic organic compounds have poor adsorption affinity with Mt-nZVI [38]. To overcome the limitations, cationic surfactants have been used as modifiers of Mt [39]. Quaternary ammonium salt cations are common cationic surfactants such as cetyltrimethylammonium (CTMA) [40, 41], cetyltrimethylammonium bromide (CTMAB) [26, 42], and hexadecyltrimethylammonium bromide (HDTMA) [43].The advantages of using organic modified Mt-supported nZVI to remove organic compounds have been reported. Substituting the inorganic cations (e.g., Na+) with organic ammonium cations (e.g., DTA+) in the Mt interlayer can further increase the layer spacing and enhance the adsorption capacity of organic contaminants on Mt by changing the surface of Mt from hydrophilic to hydrophobic [19, 42, 44]. For example, Li et al. [40] reported that the efficiency of pentachlorophenol (53 mg L-1) removed by CTMA-modified Bt-supported nZVI (0.6 g L-1) reached 96.2% within 120 min at pH 6, which was higher than that by Bt-nZVI (49.6%). Moreover, the degradation efficiency of decabromodiphenyl ether (DBDE) by tetramethylammonium- (TMA-) modified smectite-supported nZVI was 10 times greater than that by nZVI. Note that the organic modified Mt can also inhibit the rapid consumption of nZVI by forming a hydrophobic environment in the clay interlayer. For example, Jia and Wang [19] used N,N,N-trimethyl-1-dodecanaminium salt- (DTA+-) modified smectite-supported nZVI to remove 2,4-dichlorophenol (2,4-DCP) and found that almost 100% of 2,4-DCP could be dechlorinated even after five cycles on organo-smectite-supported nZVI, but smectite-supported nZVI only dechlorinated twice.


## 2.2. Methods of Synthesizing Mt-nZVI

### 2.2.1. Liquid-Phase Reduction

Wang and Zhang [45] were the first to develop a liquid-phase reduction method to prepare nZVI. This technique has then become the most widely used method to prepare nZVI in laboratories [46]. In this approach, nZVI is synthesized by reduction of Fe3+ or Fe2+ in aqueous solutions using NaBH4 under N2 atmosphere (Equations (1) and (2)) [31, 47]:
(1)4Fe3++3BH4−+9H2O⟶4Fe0+3BO3−+12H++6H2(2)2Fe2++BH4−+3H2O⟶2Fe0+BO3−+4H++3H2The Mt-nZVI is synthesized by a slightly modified liquid-phase reduction method with Mt as support [21]. Briefly, Mt-nZVI is typically prepared under N2 atmosphere by using NaBH4 to reduce Fe3+ or Fe2+ to Fe0 in the presence of Mt as the supporting material (Figure 3(a)). The Mt is used as a layered template to limit the size of the nZVI formed at the nanoscale (60-80 nm) and direct the distribution of nZVI clusters [19, 48–50]. The scanning electron microscope (SEM) images of Bt-supported nZVI (Bt-nZVI) (Figure 4(a)) synthesized by the aforementioned method showed that the aggregation of nZVI particles was decreased due to Bt [51]. Various organic or inorganic modifiers can be used to modify Mt before the preparation of Mt-nZVI to improve its adsorption performance and dispersibility in organic media [33], which are detailed later in the paper.Figure 3
Illustration of the synthesis process of Mt-nZVI by different methods: (a) liquid-phase reduction; (b) heteroaggregates of Mt with nZVIs; (c) green synthesis method; (d) thermal reduction method.
(a)(b)(c)(d)Figure 4
SEM images of (a) Bt-nZVI [51] synthesized by liquid-phase reduction and (b) heteroaggregates of Mt with nZVIs [15]. TEM images of (c) Bt and (d) Bt-supported “green” nZVI synthesized by green synthesis [60]. SEM images of (e) Fe-Mt and (f) Fe-Mt-H2 synthesized by thermal reduction method [64].
(a)(b)(c)(d)(e)(f)There exist several drawbacks to the liquid-phase reduction method. First, it is relatively expensive due to the high cost of NaBH4 [52]. Second, NaBH4 may destroy some chemical bonds in Mt or Bt, resulting in a change of the proportion of Mt or Bt [50]. Third, the nZVI is hard to be evenly distributed on the template surfaces. For example, Wang et al. [53] prepared Mt-nZVI and observed that more nZVI particles were dispersed at the edge of the Mt, and few particles were distributed in the middle part of Mt. This ununiform distribution of nZVI on template surfaces could affect the mobility of the composite in the environment because the distribution morphology of nZVI on the template surfaces influences the interaction energy between the composite and the collector surfaces and accordingly the attachment.


### 2.2.2. Heteroaggregates of Mt with nZVIs

Yin et al. [15] presented a novel technique to prepare Mt-nZVI based on the liquid-phase reduction method. Specifically, nZVI colloidal suspension was first synthesized by the liquid-phase reduction reaction [54], and the nZVIs were allowed to attach to surfaces of Mt in solutions in a monolayer (Figure 3(b)). The Mt solution was prepared by sedimentation siphon separation [55]. The SEM images of Mt-nZVI synthesized by this method showed that the nZVI particles were evenly distributed on the Mt surfaces in a monolayer (Figure 4(b)) [15].In this approach, the sizes of nZVI particles could be changed via the liquid-phase reduction method and the concentration of the attached nZVI particles on Mt could be controlled by varying experimental conditions (e.g., the ratio of concentrations of Mt and nZVI in suspension) [15]. The fabricated heteroaggregates of nZVIs with Mt had a unique micro/nanostructure. This structure favors the heteroaggregates to attach to collector surfaces and then detach even with a minor change of system conditions [56, 57]. Therefore, the Mt-nZVI has great mobility in the subsurface environments through continuous capture and release, showing the promise for the in situ treatment of contaminants in soil [15]. Note that the previous method can also change the sizes of nZVI particles by changing experimental conditions.


### 2.2.3. Green Synthesis

The chemical synthesis methods of Mt-nZVI may lead to toxic chemicals (e.g., borohydride) absorbed on their surfaces [58]. Alternatively, the green synthesis method used plant extracts containing naturally derived polyphenolic compounds (instead of NaBH4) as reducing agents to synthesize Mt-nZVI [59]. For example, Soliemanzadeh and Fekri [60] used green tea extracts to prepare Bt-loaded “green” nZVI. The green tea extract solution was prepared by heating the plant extracts to a temperature close to the boiling point, and then it was mixed with the Bt and Fe2+ solution (Figure 3(c)). The transmission electron microscope (TEM) images (Figures 4(e) and 4(f)) indicated that nZVIs were successfully supported on the Bt surface. Moreover, the composite material prepared by this method was found to be effective for the adsorption of Cr(VI) in contaminated soil and aqueous environments.The green synthesis method has the following advantages. First, plant extracts can better stabilize the reaction surface of nanoparticles than NaBH4 and decrease their biotoxicity [52]. Second, excess polyphenols in solution during preparation could encapsulate the synthesized Mt-nZVI and prevent its further oxidation [58]. Third, the use of natural active biological components can reduce the total cost of the synthesis process [61]. However, it should be noted that plant extracts may not completely reduce iron to nZVI, resulting in other forms of iron on template surfaces. Moreover, the preparation method of “green” extracts is relatively complicated, and the disposal of residues after extraction needs to be addressed [62]. These limitations decrease the application of green synthesis [28].


### 2.2.4. Thermal Reduction Method

Mt-nZVI can also be obtained through the thermal reduction of iron compounds [28]. In this method, the thermal energy and gaseous reducing agents were adopted to drive the reduction of iron oxide or hydrous Fe2+ at elevated temperatures in the presence of Mt [63]. For instance, Yang et al. [64] added an aqueous dispersion of Mt to the mixture of ferric nitrate and sodium carbonate to synthesize iron-pillared Mt (Fe-Mt) [65] and obtained Fe0-Mt composites (Fe-Mt-H2) through thermal reduction under mixed H2 and N2 atmosphere (Figure 3(d)). The SEM images of Fe-Mt showed that small needle-like Fe particles attached to the surface of Mt (Figure 4(e)). With high-temperature pyrolysis, small needle-like protrusions distributed on the Mt surfaces partially turned into large cube-like particles (Figure 4(f)). Compared with Mt-nZVI prepared by the aforementioned liquid-phase reduction, Fe-Mt-H2 embedded more Fe0 in Mt with larger sizes, which might be more difficult to be oxidized.The thermal reduction method is cheaper and energy-saving because it does not require NaBH4 for Fe ion reduction compared to the liquid-phase reduction method. The production of toxic chemicals is also avoided [12]. The method is also environmentally friendly because only gaseous products are generated [28]. However, this method requires high-temperature conditions, which is energy-consuming and may bring potential risks during the preparation [31].Although the cost of producing Mt-nZVI has been reduced, large-scale preparation and application are still expensive. Further improvement is thus necessary to produce high-quality, low-cost, and environmentally friendly Mt-nZVI. For example, it is vital to develop some cheap and environmentally friendly reducing agents to replace NaBH4. Additionally, different modifying agents can be used to introduce various functional groups into the Mt interlayer to increase Mt-nZVI’s adsorption activity to target contaminants [66].


## 2.2.1. Liquid-Phase Reduction

Wang and Zhang [45] were the first to develop a liquid-phase reduction method to prepare nZVI. This technique has then become the most widely used method to prepare nZVI in laboratories [46]. In this approach, nZVI is synthesized by reduction of Fe3+ or Fe2+ in aqueous solutions using NaBH4 under N2 atmosphere (Equations (1) and (2)) [31, 47]:
(1)4Fe3++3BH4−+9H2O⟶4Fe0+3BO3−+12H++6H2(2)2Fe2++BH4−+3H2O⟶2Fe0+BO3−+4H++3H2The Mt-nZVI is synthesized by a slightly modified liquid-phase reduction method with Mt as support [21]. Briefly, Mt-nZVI is typically prepared under N2 atmosphere by using NaBH4 to reduce Fe3+ or Fe2+ to Fe0 in the presence of Mt as the supporting material (Figure 3(a)). The Mt is used as a layered template to limit the size of the nZVI formed at the nanoscale (60-80 nm) and direct the distribution of nZVI clusters [19, 48–50]. The scanning electron microscope (SEM) images of Bt-supported nZVI (Bt-nZVI) (Figure 4(a)) synthesized by the aforementioned method showed that the aggregation of nZVI particles was decreased due to Bt [51]. Various organic or inorganic modifiers can be used to modify Mt before the preparation of Mt-nZVI to improve its adsorption performance and dispersibility in organic media [33], which are detailed later in the paper.Figure 3
Illustration of the synthesis process of Mt-nZVI by different methods: (a) liquid-phase reduction; (b) heteroaggregates of Mt with nZVIs; (c) green synthesis method; (d) thermal reduction method.
(a)(b)(c)(d)Figure 4
SEM images of (a) Bt-nZVI [51] synthesized by liquid-phase reduction and (b) heteroaggregates of Mt with nZVIs [15]. TEM images of (c) Bt and (d) Bt-supported “green” nZVI synthesized by green synthesis [60]. SEM images of (e) Fe-Mt and (f) Fe-Mt-H2 synthesized by thermal reduction method [64].
(a)(b)(c)(d)(e)(f)There exist several drawbacks to the liquid-phase reduction method. First, it is relatively expensive due to the high cost of NaBH4 [52]. Second, NaBH4 may destroy some chemical bonds in Mt or Bt, resulting in a change of the proportion of Mt or Bt [50]. Third, the nZVI is hard to be evenly distributed on the template surfaces. For example, Wang et al. [53] prepared Mt-nZVI and observed that more nZVI particles were dispersed at the edge of the Mt, and few particles were distributed in the middle part of Mt. This ununiform distribution of nZVI on template surfaces could affect the mobility of the composite in the environment because the distribution morphology of nZVI on the template surfaces influences the interaction energy between the composite and the collector surfaces and accordingly the attachment.


## 2.2.2. Heteroaggregates of Mt with nZVIs

Yin et al. [15] presented a novel technique to prepare Mt-nZVI based on the liquid-phase reduction method. Specifically, nZVI colloidal suspension was first synthesized by the liquid-phase reduction reaction [54], and the nZVIs were allowed to attach to surfaces of Mt in solutions in a monolayer (Figure 3(b)). The Mt solution was prepared by sedimentation siphon separation [55]. The SEM images of Mt-nZVI synthesized by this method showed that the nZVI particles were evenly distributed on the Mt surfaces in a monolayer (Figure 4(b)) [15].In this approach, the sizes of nZVI particles could be changed via the liquid-phase reduction method and the concentration of the attached nZVI particles on Mt could be controlled by varying experimental conditions (e.g., the ratio of concentrations of Mt and nZVI in suspension) [15]. The fabricated heteroaggregates of nZVIs with Mt had a unique micro/nanostructure. This structure favors the heteroaggregates to attach to collector surfaces and then detach even with a minor change of system conditions [56, 57]. Therefore, the Mt-nZVI has great mobility in the subsurface environments through continuous capture and release, showing the promise for the in situ treatment of contaminants in soil [15]. Note that the previous method can also change the sizes of nZVI particles by changing experimental conditions.


## 2.2.3. Green Synthesis

The chemical synthesis methods of Mt-nZVI may lead to toxic chemicals (e.g., borohydride) absorbed on their surfaces [58]. Alternatively, the green synthesis method used plant extracts containing naturally derived polyphenolic compounds (instead of NaBH4) as reducing agents to synthesize Mt-nZVI [59]. For example, Soliemanzadeh and Fekri [60] used green tea extracts to prepare Bt-loaded “green” nZVI. The green tea extract solution was prepared by heating the plant extracts to a temperature close to the boiling point, and then it was mixed with the Bt and Fe2+ solution (Figure 3(c)). The transmission electron microscope (TEM) images (Figures 4(e) and 4(f)) indicated that nZVIs were successfully supported on the Bt surface. Moreover, the composite material prepared by this method was found to be effective for the adsorption of Cr(VI) in contaminated soil and aqueous environments.The green synthesis method has the following advantages. First, plant extracts can better stabilize the reaction surface of nanoparticles than NaBH4 and decrease their biotoxicity [52]. Second, excess polyphenols in solution during preparation could encapsulate the synthesized Mt-nZVI and prevent its further oxidation [58]. Third, the use of natural active biological components can reduce the total cost of the synthesis process [61]. However, it should be noted that plant extracts may not completely reduce iron to nZVI, resulting in other forms of iron on template surfaces. Moreover, the preparation method of “green” extracts is relatively complicated, and the disposal of residues after extraction needs to be addressed [62]. These limitations decrease the application of green synthesis [28].


## 2.2.4. Thermal Reduction Method

Mt-nZVI can also be obtained through the thermal reduction of iron compounds [28]. In this method, the thermal energy and gaseous reducing agents were adopted to drive the reduction of iron oxide or hydrous Fe2+ at elevated temperatures in the presence of Mt [63]. For instance, Yang et al. [64] added an aqueous dispersion of Mt to the mixture of ferric nitrate and sodium carbonate to synthesize iron-pillared Mt (Fe-Mt) [65] and obtained Fe0-Mt composites (Fe-Mt-H2) through thermal reduction under mixed H2 and N2 atmosphere (Figure 3(d)). The SEM images of Fe-Mt showed that small needle-like Fe particles attached to the surface of Mt (Figure 4(e)). With high-temperature pyrolysis, small needle-like protrusions distributed on the Mt surfaces partially turned into large cube-like particles (Figure 4(f)). Compared with Mt-nZVI prepared by the aforementioned liquid-phase reduction, Fe-Mt-H2 embedded more Fe0 in Mt with larger sizes, which might be more difficult to be oxidized.The thermal reduction method is cheaper and energy-saving because it does not require NaBH4 for Fe ion reduction compared to the liquid-phase reduction method. The production of toxic chemicals is also avoided [12]. The method is also environmentally friendly because only gaseous products are generated [28]. However, this method requires high-temperature conditions, which is energy-consuming and may bring potential risks during the preparation [31].Although the cost of producing Mt-nZVI has been reduced, large-scale preparation and application are still expensive. Further improvement is thus necessary to produce high-quality, low-cost, and environmentally friendly Mt-nZVI. For example, it is vital to develop some cheap and environmentally friendly reducing agents to replace NaBH4. Additionally, different modifying agents can be used to introduce various functional groups into the Mt interlayer to increase Mt-nZVI’s adsorption activity to target contaminants [66].


## 2.3. Advantages of Using Mt to Support nZVI

The clay minerals are nontoxic, low cost, and environmentally friendly. Moreover, they have a high surface area and adsorption ability [67, 68]. A number of studies demonstrated that the adsorption capacity of Mt was stronger than that of other clay minerals [69–71]. Furthermore, the combination of Mt and nZVI can result in a synergetic effect between adsorption by the Mt and removal by nZVI particles [31]. There are several advantages of using Mt to support nZVI, such as improvement of the dispersion and mobility and reduction of the particle size and oxidation tendency [21, 26]. These advantages will be elaborated on in detail in the following.


### 2.3.1. Increased Dispersion

Typically, the bare nZVI particles were spherical and formed prominent chainlike aggregates; adding Mt into nZVI can improve the dispersibility of nZVI [19]. Several possible reasons have been used to explain the increased dispersion of nZVI in Mt. First, during the preparation of the Mt-nZVI, Fe3+(or Fe2+) is uniformly absorbed into the interlayer of Mt through ion exchange [19]. This can control the nucleation of nZVI clusters produced by the reduction of Fe3+(or Fe2+) and limit the growth of particles, thereby preventing the aggregation of nZVI clusters [72]. Second, the interlaminar distance (between clay sheets) of Mt clay is between 0.1 and 0.8 nm, which creates an ideal template to carry nZVI clusters (Figure 2) [18]. Adding nZVI into Mt can increase its interlayer spacing. The basal spacing of Mt-nZVI calculated by Pang et al. [73] was 2.450 nm, which was 0.571 nm larger than that of Mt. This phenomenon might be explained by the fact that the hydration radius of Fe3+ was much larger than that of Na+, and when Na+ was replaced by Fe3+, the interlayer spacing of Mt was increased. In short, the nZVI clusters have intercalated the interlayers of Mt and acted as pillars, thus expanding the interlayer distance. In addition, the surface area of Mt is much larger than that of nZVI, which can significantly increase the surface dispersion of nZVI [21]. Third, as a 2 : 1 layer silicate due to the swelling of the interlayer, the layers in Mt are separated into discrete single-layer units, which make Mt highly accessible in the suspension to some extent, thereby enhancing the reactivity of Mt-nZVI [72, 74]. Notably, the nZVI aggregation decreased as Mt loadings increased [22, 68, 75].


### 2.3.2. Small nZVI Size

The presence of templates such as Mt or Bt can reduce particle sizes of nZVI [76]. For example, Arancibia-Miranda et al. [77] found that the average diameter of Mt-nZVI was 9.3 nm, which was smaller than that of nZVI (16.9 nm). The X-ray diffraction (XRD) patterns from Peng et al. [26] have shown that the peak value of the organo-Mt- (OMt-) supported nZVI (OMt-nZVI) was weaker and broader at 44.78° compared with that of bare nZVI (Figure 5(a)), indicating the smaller crystallite size of nZVI within OMt-nZVI. The sizes of nZVI can be further decreased with the increase of the mass ratios of Mt/iron [68, 75, 76].Figure 5
XRD patterns of (a) (A) OMt, (B) OMt-nZVI, and (C) nZVI [26] and (b) (A) nZVI, (B) Mt-nZVI, (C) K-Mt-supported nZVI (K-Mt-nZVI), and (D) starch-stabilized K-Mt-nZVI [21].
(a)(b)Smaller size of nZVI means larger SSA and stronger adsorption capacity [34]. Compared with Mt, the SSA of Mt-nZVI is increased as a result of massive nZVI particles supported on the surface or interlayers of Mt [24, 36]. Although the SSA of Mt-nZVI is lower than that of nZVI, the stability and reactivity of nZVI are stronger after being monodispersed on Mt [68].


### 2.3.3. Improved nZVI’s Stability against Oxidization

The nZVI is easily oxidized when exposed to the air, which greatly affects its reducibility [72]. Mt can reduce the surface corrosion of nZVI and improve its stability [12]. According to the XRD results of Mt-nZVI by Zhang et al. [21] (Figure 5(b)), the characteristic peaks of iron oxide were not observed, indicating that the nZVI particles were not oxidized or only a small part of them was oxidized to form amorphous iron oxide. Rao et al. [78] investigated the antioxidant abilities of Mt-nZVI and nZVI by observing their color changes in the air at different time slots. The black nZVI solution totally turned yellow at 72 h, while only a small part of the Mt-nZVI solution turned yellow, revealing that nZVI loaded on Mt was more difficult to be oxidized compared to pristine nZVI. This phenomenon can be explained by the fact that Mt has a layered structure, and when the nZVIs are inserted in the interlayer of Mt, they were not readily available for oxidization [25].Li et al. [79] found that fewer oxides were formed on Bt-nZVI compared to nZVI. The removal efficiency of Se(VI) by Bt-nZVI only decreased 3.7% after four cycle experiments. The results indicated that Bt-nZVI displayed much higher stability and reusability than nZVI, which was partly due to the fact that Bt inhibited the oxidation of nZVI. Another possible reason was the buffering effect of some particular functional groups of Bt [79]. Moreover, when Fe2O3 was formed and precipitated on the surfaces of nZVI during the reaction of Bt-nZVI with contaminants, Bt could help to transfer some precipitates from nZVI surfaces and prolong the reactivity of nZVI [65].


### 2.3.4. Other Advantages

Tomasevic et al. [67] and Kerkez et al. [69] demonstrated that the total pore volume of the Mt-nZVI was larger than that of Mt and nZVI. This is because of the formation of more mesoporous structures by the intercalated nZVI, which enhanced the diffusion and adsorption of contaminants [26]. In addition, the introduction of Mt may improve the sustainability of nZVI, inhibit the rapid consumption of nZVI, and ultimately enhance the service life of composite materials [19]. Finally, Bt-nZVI has higher stability (lower sedimentation) and greater mobility in porous media than nZVI [80]. For example, Shi et al. [68] conducted column experiments and revealed that the sedimentation rate of Mt-nZVI was greatly decreased and its mobility was significantly increased compared with that of bare nZVI. This is because the zeta potentials of nZVI particles changed from positive to negative after the addition of Mt, which led to the repulsive interaction between Bt-nZVI and quartz sand [80].


## 2.3.1. Increased Dispersion

Typically, the bare nZVI particles were spherical and formed prominent chainlike aggregates; adding Mt into nZVI can improve the dispersibility of nZVI [19]. Several possible reasons have been used to explain the increased dispersion of nZVI in Mt. First, during the preparation of the Mt-nZVI, Fe3+(or Fe2+) is uniformly absorbed into the interlayer of Mt through ion exchange [19]. This can control the nucleation of nZVI clusters produced by the reduction of Fe3+(or Fe2+) and limit the growth of particles, thereby preventing the aggregation of nZVI clusters [72]. Second, the interlaminar distance (between clay sheets) of Mt clay is between 0.1 and 0.8 nm, which creates an ideal template to carry nZVI clusters (Figure 2) [18]. Adding nZVI into Mt can increase its interlayer spacing. The basal spacing of Mt-nZVI calculated by Pang et al. [73] was 2.450 nm, which was 0.571 nm larger than that of Mt. This phenomenon might be explained by the fact that the hydration radius of Fe3+ was much larger than that of Na+, and when Na+ was replaced by Fe3+, the interlayer spacing of Mt was increased. In short, the nZVI clusters have intercalated the interlayers of Mt and acted as pillars, thus expanding the interlayer distance. In addition, the surface area of Mt is much larger than that of nZVI, which can significantly increase the surface dispersion of nZVI [21]. Third, as a 2 : 1 layer silicate due to the swelling of the interlayer, the layers in Mt are separated into discrete single-layer units, which make Mt highly accessible in the suspension to some extent, thereby enhancing the reactivity of Mt-nZVI [72, 74]. Notably, the nZVI aggregation decreased as Mt loadings increased [22, 68, 75].


## 2.3.2. Small nZVI Size

The presence of templates such as Mt or Bt can reduce particle sizes of nZVI [76]. For example, Arancibia-Miranda et al. [77] found that the average diameter of Mt-nZVI was 9.3 nm, which was smaller than that of nZVI (16.9 nm). The X-ray diffraction (XRD) patterns from Peng et al. [26] have shown that the peak value of the organo-Mt- (OMt-) supported nZVI (OMt-nZVI) was weaker and broader at 44.78° compared with that of bare nZVI (Figure 5(a)), indicating the smaller crystallite size of nZVI within OMt-nZVI. The sizes of nZVI can be further decreased with the increase of the mass ratios of Mt/iron [68, 75, 76].Figure 5
XRD patterns of (a) (A) OMt, (B) OMt-nZVI, and (C) nZVI [26] and (b) (A) nZVI, (B) Mt-nZVI, (C) K-Mt-supported nZVI (K-Mt-nZVI), and (D) starch-stabilized K-Mt-nZVI [21].
(a)(b)Smaller size of nZVI means larger SSA and stronger adsorption capacity [34]. Compared with Mt, the SSA of Mt-nZVI is increased as a result of massive nZVI particles supported on the surface or interlayers of Mt [24, 36]. Although the SSA of Mt-nZVI is lower than that of nZVI, the stability and reactivity of nZVI are stronger after being monodispersed on Mt [68].


## 2.3.3. Improved nZVI’s Stability against Oxidization

The nZVI is easily oxidized when exposed to the air, which greatly affects its reducibility [72]. Mt can reduce the surface corrosion of nZVI and improve its stability [12]. According to the XRD results of Mt-nZVI by Zhang et al. [21] (Figure 5(b)), the characteristic peaks of iron oxide were not observed, indicating that the nZVI particles were not oxidized or only a small part of them was oxidized to form amorphous iron oxide. Rao et al. [78] investigated the antioxidant abilities of Mt-nZVI and nZVI by observing their color changes in the air at different time slots. The black nZVI solution totally turned yellow at 72 h, while only a small part of the Mt-nZVI solution turned yellow, revealing that nZVI loaded on Mt was more difficult to be oxidized compared to pristine nZVI. This phenomenon can be explained by the fact that Mt has a layered structure, and when the nZVIs are inserted in the interlayer of Mt, they were not readily available for oxidization [25].Li et al. [79] found that fewer oxides were formed on Bt-nZVI compared to nZVI. The removal efficiency of Se(VI) by Bt-nZVI only decreased 3.7% after four cycle experiments. The results indicated that Bt-nZVI displayed much higher stability and reusability than nZVI, which was partly due to the fact that Bt inhibited the oxidation of nZVI. Another possible reason was the buffering effect of some particular functional groups of Bt [79]. Moreover, when Fe2O3 was formed and precipitated on the surfaces of nZVI during the reaction of Bt-nZVI with contaminants, Bt could help to transfer some precipitates from nZVI surfaces and prolong the reactivity of nZVI [65].


## 2.3.4. Other Advantages

Tomasevic et al. [67] and Kerkez et al. [69] demonstrated that the total pore volume of the Mt-nZVI was larger than that of Mt and nZVI. This is because of the formation of more mesoporous structures by the intercalated nZVI, which enhanced the diffusion and adsorption of contaminants [26]. In addition, the introduction of Mt may improve the sustainability of nZVI, inhibit the rapid consumption of nZVI, and ultimately enhance the service life of composite materials [19]. Finally, Bt-nZVI has higher stability (lower sedimentation) and greater mobility in porous media than nZVI [80]. For example, Shi et al. [68] conducted column experiments and revealed that the sedimentation rate of Mt-nZVI was greatly decreased and its mobility was significantly increased compared with that of bare nZVI. This is because the zeta potentials of nZVI particles changed from positive to negative after the addition of Mt, which led to the repulsive interaction between Bt-nZVI and quartz sand [80].


## 3. The Reaction Mechanisms of Mt-nZVI

There are four typical pathways to remove contaminants by Mt-nZVI (Figure6), including adsorption [19, 81, 82], reduction [18, 26, 83], precipitation [16, 21], and oxidation [44]. These mechanisms can occur simultaneously or sequentially when using them to remove contaminants. Particularly, adsorption is commonly the major removal mechanism for Mt, while reduction is the main mechanism for the nZVI [18, 19]. These processes are described in detail in the following.Figure 6
Schematic model of reaction mechanisms of Mt-nZVI with various contaminants.Adsorption has been considered a typical reaction process for contaminant removal by Mt-nZVI. As mentioned above, Mt-nZVI has small particle sizes, large SSA, and abundant active sites due to functional groups, which have a great ability for adsorbing many contaminants [15]. Additionally, nZVI has a core-shell structure (Figure 6). Specifically, the core is mainly nZVI, and the shell is the product due to oxidation of the nZVI. The shell can be oxidized to Fe2+ (fast process) and further to Fe3+ (slower process) by dissolved oxygen in aqueous media according to Equations (3) and (4) [30]:
(3)2Fe0+O2+2H2O⟶2Fe2++4OH−(4)4Fe2++O2+4H+⟶4Fe3++2H2OThe outer oxidized layer of nZVI will thicken once exposed in water or air even if this process is reduced due to the Mt. This positively charged layer can act as an efficient adsorbent for various contaminants with negative charges through electrostatic interaction [27]. Reduction was regarded to be the main mechanism of contaminant removal by Mt-nZVI, in which nZVI plays as an electron provider [33, 84]. Generally speaking, the removal mechanisms of Mt-nZVI on heavy metals depend on its E0 (Table 3) [29]. The heavy metals with more positive standard redox potential (E0) than nZVI (E0=−0.44V) such as Pb(II) and Ni(II) can be removed by reduction and adsorption [85]. For example, Wang et al. [34] showed that Mt-nZVI could remove Pb(II) to Pb0 by reduction and adsorption. First, Pb(II) ions were absorbed on the surface of Mt-nZVI (Equations (5) and (6)). Then, it was converted to Pb0 through reduction by nZVI (Equation (7)) [34]:
(5)Pb2++Mt⟶Pb2+−Mt(6)Pb2++FexOyHz⟶Pb2+−FexOyHz(7)Pb2+−MtorPb2+−FexOyHz+2e−⟶Pb0−MtorPb0−FexOyHzTable 3
The standard redox potentials (E0) of heavy metals at 25°C [29].
Heavy metalE0 (V)Half reactionsRemoval mechanismReferenceZn-0.76Zn2+↔Zn2+Adsorption[68]Fe-0.44Fe2++2e−↔FeReduction[29]Ni-0.23Ni2++2e−↔NiReduction and adsorption[85]Pb-0.13Pb2++2e−↔PbReduction and adsorption[108]U0.27UO22++4H++2e−↔U4++2H2OReduction and precipitation[25]Cu0.34Cu2++2e−↔CuReduction and precipitation[88]As0.56H3AsO4+2H++2e−↔HAsO2+2H2OReduction and precipitation[76]Cr1.36Cr2O72−+14H++6e−↔2Cr3++7H2OReduction and precipitation[16]When theE0 of the compound is smaller or similar to that of nZVI, Mt-nZVI removes it purely by adsorption. For example, due to the fact that E0 of Zn(II) is much smaller than that of nZVI, Fe0 cannot reduce it into Zn0, but it is absorbed and deposited on the Mt-nZVI in the form of Zn(II) [53, 68, 81]. In contrast, the reduction reaction of Mt-nZVI occurs for heavy metals with higher E0 (e.g., Cr(VI) is preferentially reduced in the presence of nZVI) [12]. Interestingly, Mt-nZVI can reduce nitrate to ammonium and nitrogen gas (Equations (8)–(10)) [86]:
(8)Fe0+NO3−+2H+⟶Fe2++H2O+NO2–(9)3Fe0+NO2−+8H+⟶3Fe2++2H2O+NH4+(10)3Fe0+2NO2−+8H+⟶3Fe2++4H2O+N2gThis means that Mt-nZVI may help to reduce the amount of total nitrogen in the water. Mt-nZVI can also provide electrons for the reduction of halogenated organics. The halogenated organics are reduced to the olefins and alkane by reductive dehalogenation (Equations (11) and (12)) [8]:
(11)Fe0⟶Fe2++2e−(12)R−X+H++2e−⟶RH+X−The reaction involves the adsorption of contaminants onto the Mt-nZVI surface and subsequent breakage of the carbon-halogen bonds [52]. Based on the reductive dehalogenation, Mt-nZVI could remove chlorinated and brominated organics [19, 31].The precipitation mechanism may occur between heavy metals and iron ions. This can significantly decrease the toxicity and mobility of heavy metals since the formed precipitation is stable [87]. For instance, Cr(VI) can be removed by Mt-nZVI through adsorption, reduction, and precipitation [16, 36, 43, 81]. The reaction includes (1) the adsorption of Cr(VI) on the surface of Mt-nZVI, (2) the reduction to Cr(III) with the oxidation of nZVI to Fe3+, and (3) the formation of chromium hydroxide or chromium iron hydroxide precipitation (Equations (13) and (14)):
(13)Cr2O72−+2Fe0+14H+⟶2Cr3++7H2O+2Fe3+(14)Cr3++Fe3++6OH−⟶CrOH3+FeOH3Mt-nZVI can also remove U(VI), Cu(II), Se(IV), and As(V) through above processes [25, 33, 82, 88]. In some special environmental remediation systems (e.g., the Fe0–H2O mixture system), oxidation is also a possible reaction mechanism. Mt-nZVI can degrade and oxidize a series of organic compounds in the presence of oxidants. For example, Diao et al. [22, 23] used Bt-nZVI as a catalyst to activate persulfate for the removal of phenol. The results indicated that the presence of persulfate in Bt-nZVI could significantly promote the oxidation of phenol. The reaction mechanisms include the following: (1) SO42- was formed by the reaction of aqueous Fe2+ with persulfate, and (2) phenol was degraded by SO42- and hydroxyl radicals (⋅OH). These processes can be described in the following equations:
(15)2Fe0+O2+4H+⟶2Fe2++2H2O(16)Fe2++S2O82−⟶Fe3++SO4−+SO42−(17)H2O+SO4−⟶HSO4−+O•H(18)Phenol+SO4−/O•H⟶oxidationproductBao et al. [89] added H2O2 when using Mt-nZVI to remove bisphenol A. They found that the bisphenol A degradation mechanism might involve a couple of adsorption reactions with the Fenton-like reaction (e.g., a reaction system made up of H2O2 and Fe2+). The combination of H2O2 and Fe2+ could generate ⋅OH, which had a strong capability to oxidize a variety of organic compounds (Equations (19) and (20)) [1]:
(19)Fe0+H2O2+2H+⟶Fe2++2H2O(20)Fe2++H2O2⟶Fe3++O•H+OH−Kerkez et al. [56] reported that the heterogeneous Fenton oxidation system was considerably superior in dye decolorization than the reduction degradation mechanism. Chen et al. [65] used Fe-pillared Mt as a heterogeneous photo-Fenton catalyst to enhance the degradation efficiency of dyes. However, under common natural environmental conditions, oxidation is rare for the removal of contaminants by Mt-nZVI [90].The synergistic effect between nZVI and Mt on the removal of many contaminants has been reported [50, 79]. For example, the removal efficiency of Mt-nZVI for Cr(VI) (99%) is even better than the sum (72%) of individual removal efficiency of nZVI and Mt (66% and 6%, respectively) [81]. The synergistic effect is due to several reasons. First, as mentioned previously, the Mt can decrease the size of nZVI and enhance the dispersity of nZVI, thus providing more effective electron donors and active sites [18]. Second, the Mt of Mt-nZVI can facilitate the capture of contaminants from the solution on the Mt-nZVI surfaces through exchange and adsorption due to its high cation exchange capacity and SSA [50]. For example, the negatively charged Mt can attract cationic contaminants (such as Pb, Cd, and Cu) via electrostatic attraction and promote the mass transfer of these contaminants from the solution to the nZVI surface, thereby improving the removal efficiency [33]. Third, the pH buffering effect of silanol groups in the Mt may also promote the synergetic effect of Mt on the reduction of contaminants by nZVI [79]. Finally, the interlayer of raw Mt can be modified by cation exchange reaction. Therefore, the surface and structure of Mt can be adjusted to create properties compatible with various contaminants [33], which will be discussed in Section 5.


## 4. Factors Affecting Mt-nZVI Reactivity

When applying Mt-nZVI for water and soil remediation, the reactivity of Mt-nZVI with contaminants is dependent on a variety of environmental conditions (e.g., pH, temperature, and dosage of the adsorbent). The impact of environmental factors on the removal of contaminants by Mt-nZVI is frequently examined using experimental methods such as batch and column techniques [15]. Understanding the impact of environmental conditions is critical to optimizing the procedure for the removal of contaminants via Mt-nZVI.


### 4.1. pH

The pH value can change the surface properties of Mt-nZVI and species of the molecules or irons, thereby affecting the removal efficiency [90]. First, the surface equipotential point of Mt-nZVI and accordingly the affinity for contaminants change with pH [47]. When Mt is dispersed in the aqueous solution, the Si-O and Al-O bonds in the crystal lattice can be broken [50]. When the aqueous solution is acidic, the broken bond will adsorb H+ ions, resulting in positive charges of the crystal lattice. In contrast, the bond is adsorbed by the OH- and the lattice is negatively charged under alkaline conditions [80, 83]. Hence, Mt-nZVI has a stronger adsorption capacity for cationic contaminants at higher pH values (e.g., Co(II) [49], U(VI) [25], Zn(II) [53], and Pb(II) [50, 77]). In addition, nZVI in the solution will form a passive film of iron hydroxide at a higher pH value, further enhancing the adsorption of cationic contaminants [36]. At a low pH value, Mt-nZVI has a stronger adsorption capacity for anionic contaminants (e.g., Cr(VI) [43, 53, 80], phenol [22, 89], halogenated organic contaminants [42, 73], nitrobenzene [70], and acid dyestuff [24, 69, 74, 78]). More H+ can promote the reaction and consume more nZVIs, and the nZVI corrosion produces abundant hydrogen at lower pH values, which may support the hydrogenation reaction between organic compounds and hydrogen [45]. Notably, the pH not only changes properties of Mt-nZVI but also affects the charges of target contaminants (e.g., HCrO4− (pH=2‐5), Cr2O72− or CrO42− (pH>5)) [62].


### 4.2. Temperature

Temperature can change the energy of the reaction system, thus influencing contaminant removal efficiency by Mt-nZVI [90]. For example, Shi et al. [81] found that 82.4% of Cr(VI) was removed by Mt-nZVI at 40°C, while only 73.4% of Cr(VI) was reduced at 25°C in 60 min. A possible explanation was that high temperature could facilitate the molecular thermodynamic movement and average kinetic energy of contaminants [46]. The increase in the removal efficiency with increasing temperature was observed for degradation of organic contaminants, such as sulfamethazine [44], methyl orange [24], and amoxicillin [91] by OMt-nZVI. Overall, increasing temperature has a positive effect on the ability of Mt-nZVI to adsorb contaminants, which favors in situ remediations of the environment.The thermodynamic parameters (e.g., change in free energy (ΔG), enthalpy change (ΔH), and change in entropy (ΔS)) can reveal the reaction mechanisms [92]. For example, the thermodynamic study by Wang [92] demonstrated that the adsorption of rare earth elements by Mt-nZVI was spontaneous based on the negative ΔG values and exothermic since the value of ΔH was negative. In addition, the randomness of the system after adsorption was decreased (negative value of ΔS). Moreover, the adsorption reaction of Pb(II) and Cr(VI) on Mt-nZVI was spontaneous (ΔG<0) and exothermic (ΔH<0) [15, 34].


### 4.3. Dosage of the Adsorbent

The dosage of Mt-nZVI has a significant impact on the removal of contaminants. Shi et al. [51] presented that the removal efficiency of Cr(VI) by 3 g L-1 of M-nZVI was 100% after contacting for 3 h at pH 5, while only 54.6% Cr(VI) was removed when Bt-nZVI concentration was 1 g L-1. This observation could be explained by the fact that for a given condition, the increase in the dosage of Mt-nZVI increased the surface area and adsorption sites of Mt-nZVI, which promoted the reduction of contaminants [50, 60, 91, 93–95]. Using an optimum dosage of the adsorbent is also of great significance for saving application costs [90].Wu et al. [44] observed that the sulfamethazine degradation increased from 58% to 97% with 10 min interaction when the OMt-nZVI dose increased from 0.15 mM to 1.5 mM. However, if the OMt-nZVI further increased from 1.5 mM to 12 mM, the degradation of sulfamethazine was reduced from 97% to 35%. Similarly, when the dose of Bt-nZVI exceeded 2 g L-1, the removal efficiency of chemical oxygen decreased slightly in wastewater [96]. This is likely because more Mt-nZVI dosage would induce greater aggregation of the Mt-nZVI, causing the decrease of the SSA and its dispersibility [22, 69].


### 4.4. Other Factors

The initial concentration of contaminants influences the relative adsorption sites of Mt-nZVI [16, 32, 74, 83]. Dissolved oxygen controls the adsorption capacity of Mt-nZVI by controlling the oxidation degree of nZVI particles [24, 73]. In addition to these factors, inorganic anions [44], reaction time [73], ionic strength [16, 32, 60], natural organic matter (e.g., humic acid), and other ions [67] have an influence on the activity of Mt-nZVI. However, due to the complexity of soil and water environments, the factors that influence the removal of contaminants by Mt-nZVI are not fully elucidated to date. Hence, further research is still necessary to identify the impact factors and to reveal the coupled influence of these factors on the removal of the contaminants in soil and water environments.


## 4.1. pH

The pH value can change the surface properties of Mt-nZVI and species of the molecules or irons, thereby affecting the removal efficiency [90]. First, the surface equipotential point of Mt-nZVI and accordingly the affinity for contaminants change with pH [47]. When Mt is dispersed in the aqueous solution, the Si-O and Al-O bonds in the crystal lattice can be broken [50]. When the aqueous solution is acidic, the broken bond will adsorb H+ ions, resulting in positive charges of the crystal lattice. In contrast, the bond is adsorbed by the OH- and the lattice is negatively charged under alkaline conditions [80, 83]. Hence, Mt-nZVI has a stronger adsorption capacity for cationic contaminants at higher pH values (e.g., Co(II) [49], U(VI) [25], Zn(II) [53], and Pb(II) [50, 77]). In addition, nZVI in the solution will form a passive film of iron hydroxide at a higher pH value, further enhancing the adsorption of cationic contaminants [36]. At a low pH value, Mt-nZVI has a stronger adsorption capacity for anionic contaminants (e.g., Cr(VI) [43, 53, 80], phenol [22, 89], halogenated organic contaminants [42, 73], nitrobenzene [70], and acid dyestuff [24, 69, 74, 78]). More H+ can promote the reaction and consume more nZVIs, and the nZVI corrosion produces abundant hydrogen at lower pH values, which may support the hydrogenation reaction between organic compounds and hydrogen [45]. Notably, the pH not only changes properties of Mt-nZVI but also affects the charges of target contaminants (e.g., HCrO4− (pH=2‐5), Cr2O72− or CrO42− (pH>5)) [62].


## 4.2. Temperature

Temperature can change the energy of the reaction system, thus influencing contaminant removal efficiency by Mt-nZVI [90]. For example, Shi et al. [81] found that 82.4% of Cr(VI) was removed by Mt-nZVI at 40°C, while only 73.4% of Cr(VI) was reduced at 25°C in 60 min. A possible explanation was that high temperature could facilitate the molecular thermodynamic movement and average kinetic energy of contaminants [46]. The increase in the removal efficiency with increasing temperature was observed for degradation of organic contaminants, such as sulfamethazine [44], methyl orange [24], and amoxicillin [91] by OMt-nZVI. Overall, increasing temperature has a positive effect on the ability of Mt-nZVI to adsorb contaminants, which favors in situ remediations of the environment.The thermodynamic parameters (e.g., change in free energy (ΔG), enthalpy change (ΔH), and change in entropy (ΔS)) can reveal the reaction mechanisms [92]. For example, the thermodynamic study by Wang [92] demonstrated that the adsorption of rare earth elements by Mt-nZVI was spontaneous based on the negative ΔG values and exothermic since the value of ΔH was negative. In addition, the randomness of the system after adsorption was decreased (negative value of ΔS). Moreover, the adsorption reaction of Pb(II) and Cr(VI) on Mt-nZVI was spontaneous (ΔG<0) and exothermic (ΔH<0) [15, 34].


## 4.3. Dosage of the Adsorbent

The dosage of Mt-nZVI has a significant impact on the removal of contaminants. Shi et al. [51] presented that the removal efficiency of Cr(VI) by 3 g L-1 of M-nZVI was 100% after contacting for 3 h at pH 5, while only 54.6% Cr(VI) was removed when Bt-nZVI concentration was 1 g L-1. This observation could be explained by the fact that for a given condition, the increase in the dosage of Mt-nZVI increased the surface area and adsorption sites of Mt-nZVI, which promoted the reduction of contaminants [50, 60, 91, 93–95]. Using an optimum dosage of the adsorbent is also of great significance for saving application costs [90].Wu et al. [44] observed that the sulfamethazine degradation increased from 58% to 97% with 10 min interaction when the OMt-nZVI dose increased from 0.15 mM to 1.5 mM. However, if the OMt-nZVI further increased from 1.5 mM to 12 mM, the degradation of sulfamethazine was reduced from 97% to 35%. Similarly, when the dose of Bt-nZVI exceeded 2 g L-1, the removal efficiency of chemical oxygen decreased slightly in wastewater [96]. This is likely because more Mt-nZVI dosage would induce greater aggregation of the Mt-nZVI, causing the decrease of the SSA and its dispersibility [22, 69].


## 4.4. Other Factors

The initial concentration of contaminants influences the relative adsorption sites of Mt-nZVI [16, 32, 74, 83]. Dissolved oxygen controls the adsorption capacity of Mt-nZVI by controlling the oxidation degree of nZVI particles [24, 73]. In addition to these factors, inorganic anions [44], reaction time [73], ionic strength [16, 32, 60], natural organic matter (e.g., humic acid), and other ions [67] have an influence on the activity of Mt-nZVI. However, due to the complexity of soil and water environments, the factors that influence the removal of contaminants by Mt-nZVI are not fully elucidated to date. Hence, further research is still necessary to identify the impact factors and to reveal the coupled influence of these factors on the removal of the contaminants in soil and water environments.


## 5. Remediation of Contaminated Water and Soil

### 5.1. Remediation of Contaminated Water

#### 5.1.1. Heavy Metals

Heavy metals enter the environment mainly through industrial production. They are difficult to be biodegraded and tend to accumulate in living organisms, thus posing a high potential risk to the ecosystem and human body [32]. Mt-nZVI has been applied to successfully remove heavy metals such as Pb(II), Zn(II), Cu(II), and particularly Cr(VI) in laboratory studies (Table 2).Yin et al. [15] examined the removal of Cr(VI) by Mt-nZVI. They found that the adsorption data was well described by the Langmuir model and pseudo-second-order kinetics (Table 4). The Cr(VI) was retained on the Mt-nZVI surface in a monolayer through chemical adsorption [60]. However, Shi et al. [51] showed that the removal of Cr(VI) by Bt-nZVI followed pseudo-first-order reaction kinetics. To improve the removal efficiency of Cr(VI) by Mt-nZVI, Mt or nZVI was modified [43, 95]. For example, Wu et al. [43] reported better removal capacity for Cr(VI) (109.9 mg g-1) by HDTMA-modified Mt-supported nZVI compared to Mt-nZVI (90.9 mg g-1) (Table 2). Wang et al. [95] fabricated Bt-supported organosolv lignin-stabilized nZVI and found that lignin could improve the loaded quantity and dispersity of nZVI. The Cr(VI) removal efficiency could reach 62.3% when the dosage of this fabricated structure was 1.0 g L-1 and initial Cr(VI) concentration was 50 mg L-1, which was higher than that of Bt-nZVI (56.8%).Table 4
Fitting results for the adsorption kinetic and isotherm models of contaminant removal by Mt-nZVI.
MaterialContaminantsAdsorption kinetic modelAdsorption isotherm modelReferenceMt-nZVICr(VI)Pseudo-second-orderLangmuir[15]OMt-nZVICr(VI)Pseudo-second-order—[43]Bt-nZVICr(VI)Pseudo-first-order—[51]Bt-nZVICr(VI)Pseudo-second-orderLangmuir[60]Mt-nZVIPb(II)Pseudo-second-orderLangmuir[77]Mt-nZVIPb(II)Pseudo-second-orderFreundlich[34]Zn(II)Pseudo-second-orderFreundlich, Temkin, and Dubinin–RadushkevichBt-nZVICu(II) and Zn(II)Pseudo-first-order—[68]Bt/graphene-supported nZVICu(II)Pseudo-second-order—[88]Bt-nZVIU(VI)Langmuir–Hinshelwood—[25]Mt-nZVIU(VI)Langmuir[71]Pillared Bt-supported nZVINO3-Langmuir–Hinshelwood—[86]Cetyltrimethylammonium bromide-modified Mt-supported nZVIDecabromodiphenyl etherPseudo-first-order—[73]Cetyltrimethylammonium-modified Bt-supported nZVIChlorophenolsLangmuir–HinshelwoodLangmuir[66]Cetyltrimethylammonium-modified Bt-supported nZVIPentachlorophenolLangmuir–Hinshelwood—[40]Bt-nZVIAcid violet red BPseudo-first-order—[74]Bt-nZVIMethyl orangePseudo-first-order—[24]Mt-nZVIRhodamine 6GPseudo-first-order—[78]Bt-nZVISe(VI)Langmuir–Hinshelwood—[79]Mt-nZVISe(VI)Pseudo-first-orderFreundlich[76]As(V)Pseudo-second-orderFreundlichCetyltrimethylammonium-modified Bt-supported nZVINitrobenzeneLangmuir–Hinshelwood—[41]Arancibia-Miranda et al. [77] observed that the maximum Pb(II) adsorption capacity on Mt-nZVI was 115.1±11.0mgg−1, and the reaction followed the pseudo-second-order kinetic model and the Langmuir model. Wang et al. [34] examined the adsorption of Zn(II) and Pb(II) by Mt-nZVI. The adsorption data of Zn(II) followed the Freundlich, Temkin, and Dubinin–Radushkevich isotherm models, meaning the copresence of physical and chemical adsorption. The Pb(II) adsorption process was chemisorption, and the reaction data was described by the Freundlich isotherm model. Shao et al. [88] presented that the removal efficiency of Cu(II) (C0=100mgL−1) was 82% in Bt- and graphene oxide-supported nZVIs (1 g L-1) within 16 h. The adsorption data followed the pseudo-second-order kinetic model.The applications of Mt-nZVI for the treatment of industrial wastewater have been reported. For example, Shi et al. [68] used Bt-nZVI to remediate electroplating wastewater and found that 100% Pb(II), 92.7% Cu(II), and 59.4% Zn(II) were removed within 1 h by 10 g L-1 Bt-nZVI. Wang et al. [97] studied the remediation effect of Bt-nZVI on leachate wastewater originating from Cr-polluted soil. The results indicated that 90% Cr(VI) from leachate wastewater with an initial concentration of 52.89 mg L-1 Cr(VI) could be removed within 10 min using 3 mg g-1 of Bt-nZVI.


#### 5.1.2. Uranium

U(VI), as a radioactive and toxic heavy metal, has relatively high solubility and mobility in the environment. Therefore, it readily invades the food chain [93]. Previous laboratory work demonstrated that soluble uranium compounds could be removed by using Mt-nZVI to reduce U(VI) to less-soluble U(IV) [25, 32, 33]. For example, Sheng et al. [25] revealed that the adsorption data of U(VI) on Bt-nZVI followed the Langmuir–Hinshelwood model, and the removal efficiency of U(VI) (100 mg L-1) reached 99.2% after 90 min when using 0.2 g L-1 Bt-nZVI. Kornilovych et al. [71] used clay (e.g., kaolinite, Mt, and palygorskite)-supported nZVI to remove U(VI) from mineralized groundwater. They found that the adsorption process was better described by the Langmuir model. Mt-nZVI had the highest adsorption capacity (about 120 mg g-1), which might be related to the high dispersibility of the Mt sample in the aqueous solution. Xu et al. [32] reported 97.8% U(VI) (100 mg L-1) removal by Mt-nZVI (0.1 g L-1) within 30 min at pH=3.0. The aforementioned work indicated that Mt-nZVI was suitable for the removal of U(VI) from the aqueous solution.


#### 5.1.3. Nitrate

Nitrate (NO3-) is widely presented in the surface and groundwater due to the widespread use of nitrogen fertilizers and improper treatment of industrial wastewater, causing deterioration of water quality, eutrophication of rivers, and toxicities to organisms [98]. Numerous laboratory studies have shown that the nitrate can be reduced by Mt-nZVI [20, 86, 99]. Zhang et al. [86] combined nZVI and pillared Bt (prepared by intercalation with poly(hydroxo Al(III)) cations) to remove NO3- from the aqueous solution. The adsorption data was fitted well to the Langmuir–Hinshelwood model. This composite could completely remove NO3- at pH 7.0 within 120 min. The nZVI could only remove 62.3% NO3- under the same condition. Zhao et al. [99] used Mt-nZVI immobilized in sodium alginate (SA/Mt-nZVI) as electron donor-acceptor compounds to enhance the nitrogen (NO3--N) removal from constructed wetland (CW). The removal efficiency of NO3--N (C0=60mgL−1) by 0.67 mg L-1 SA/Mt-nZVI in CW was 32.60±1.9% at pH 7, which was higher than that by CW without adding sodium alginate. The introduction of SA/Mt-nZVI could enhance the biological diversity and richness in CW. These results meant that it might be feasible to add SA/Mt-nZVI as a carbon source to treat low C/N-polluted water.


#### 5.1.4. Halogenated Organic Compounds

Halogenated organic compounds are widely present in industrial wastewater. They have persistence, lipophilicity, high toxicity, and carcinogenicity [100]. They are difficult to be biodegraded and can be enriched in aquatic organisms [101]. Batch experiments have shown that Mt-nZVI could successfully degrade a large number of halogenated organics, such as chlorinated and brominated organics [19, 31]. For example, Pang et al. [73] demonstrated that the removal efficiency of decabromodiphenyl ether (C0=2mgL−1) by CTMAB-modified Mt-supported nZVI (0.6 g L-1) was 98.02%. The adsorption data fitted well to pseudo-first-order reaction. Yu et al. [42] applied TMA-modified smectite-supported nZVI (4 g L-1) to reduce 2.5 mg L-1 of DBDE. After a 9 h reaction, >80% DBDE was removed. This composite was shown to be much faster and more efficient for debromination compared to nZVI. Li et al. [40] immobilized CTMA onto Bt to load nZVI. They found that this novel composite had good stability and reusability, which could quickly and completely dechlorinate chlorophenols. The equilibrium adsorption was well described by the Langmuir and Langmuir–Hinshelwood kinetic models.Recently, nZVI was sulfurated to accelerate reduction efficiency for organochlorine compounds and maintain the stability of composite material in water [102]. For instance, Mt-supported sulfurated nZVI (Mt-S-nZVI) was synthesized [102] and exhibited higher removal efficiency for trichloroethylene (78.7%) than sulfurated nZVI and Mt-nZVI. Even aging for 30 days, Mt-S-nZVI could still retain 68.1% of trichloroethylene.


#### 5.1.5. Dyes

Dyes include high levels of organic contaminants with deep colors. Their degradation products may be carcinogenic and toxic to mammals [69]. Reaction using Mt-nZVI composite materials to remove dyes has become a promising method [31]. Lin et al. [74] reported that the removal efficiency of acid violet red B on Bt-nZVI was 95.6% in 9 min under the condition of 2.8 g L-1 of Bt-nZVI and 800 mg L-1 acid violet red B solution. This was higher than that of nZVI (75.1%). The adsorption was well fitted to the pseudo-first-order model. The degradation of azo dye methyl orange by Bt-nZVI was also fitted well to the pseudo-first-order model [24]. Kerkez et al. [69] demonstrated that Bt-nZVI had a higher adsorption capacity on degrading industrial azo dye Rosso Zetanyl B-NG compared with kaolin- and native clay-supported nZVIs. This was probably because the SSA of Bt was three times that of kaolin and natural clay (Table 2).Mt-nZVI has been combined with microwave treatment for the decolorization of dyes. Microwave treatment can directly heat the reactant molecules and provide more energy to the reaction system, accelerating the efficiency of the degradation reaction [103]. Rao et al. [78] applied Mt-nZVI to remove Rhodamine 6G (Rh 6G) through microwave treatment and revealed that the removal amount of Rh 6G reached 500 mg g-1 when the initial Rh 6G concentration was 5000 mg L-1 after degradation for 15 min by 10 g L-1 Mt-nZVI.


#### 5.1.6. Phenolic Compounds

Phenolic derivatives are frequently detected in the wastewater generated by the petrochemical, textile, and pharmaceutical industries [104]. They are highly toxic and harmful to organisms even at low concentrations [105]. Mt-nZVI composites have been proven to be highly efficient for removing phenolic compounds in the laboratory.Mt-nZVI coupled with oxidants (e.g., O3, H2O2, peroxymonosulfate, and persulfate) can enhance the degradation of phenolic compounds [22, 26, 64]. For instance, Bao et al. [89] reported that the adsorption capacity of bisphenol A on Bt-nZVI was increased in wastewater when H2O2 was added. Peng et al. [26] investigated tetrabromobisphenol A and bisphenol A removal using cetyltrimethylammonium bromide- (CTMAB-) modified Mt-supported nZVI in the aqueous solution. When O3 (4 mg L-1) was employed as an oxidant, this composite (0.1 g L-1) could remove up to 98.6% of tetrabromobisphenol A and 94.7% of bisphenol A during 60 min at pH 7 with an initial contaminant concentration of 10 mg L-1. Yang et al. [64] used Fe-Mt-H2 (0.4 g L-1) as an activator for peroxymonosulfate activation to remove bisphenol A (25 mg L-1) and found that more than 99.3% bisphenol A was degraded within 3 h at pH 3.


#### 5.1.7. Other Contaminants

Ren et al. [41] used CTMA-modified Bt to load nZVI. This composite could almost completely reduce nitrobenzene to aniline. The removal followed the Langmuir–Hinshelwood equation. Wu et al. [44] assessed the persulfate activated with OMt-nZVI-degraded sulfamethazine. Sulfamethazine (20 mg L-1) was degraded by up to 97% in 10 min by using 1.5 mM OMt-nZVI and 4 mM persulfate at pH 6.8. Additionally, Mt-nZVI also could effectively degrade atrazine [106], amoxicillin [91], and oxytetracycline [75].The Mt-nZVI is commonly used to treat a single type of contaminant in water. However, Suazo-Hernandez [76] investigated the coremoval of Se(VI) and As(V) using Mt-nZVI. The removal of Se(VI) was fitted well to pseudo-first-order reaction, while the removal of As(V) followed pseudo-second-order reaction. The adsorption of As(V) was the chemisorption process, and the adsorption of Se(VI) was mainly through the formation of bidentate inner-sphere complexes [107]. The removal efficiency of As(V) (68.43%) was higher compared with that of Se(VI) (42.76%). This work demonstrated that Mt-nZVI was effective to simultaneously remove both oxyanions (but with a marked preference for As(V)).


### 5.2. Remediation of Contaminated Soil

Although nZVI has excellent removal capability for various contaminants from water, the application of nZVI for soil remediation is challenging. Firstly, due to strong magnetic attractive forces, nZVIs often aggregate into micron-sized particles (homoaggregation) or are associated with minerals and organic colloids to form heteroaggregates. These aggregates frequently have low mobility in soils [29]. Secondly, the reactivity of nZVI may be decreased when it is released into the complex soil environment [47]. It is necessary to consider the interference of various soil components and the physicochemical properties of soil during the application of the nZVIs [12]. Finally, nZVI will be oxidized in the soil [108]. As mentioned previously, adding Mt into nZVI can improve the dispersibility of nZVI and reduce the surface corrosion of nZVI. Furthermore, loading nZVI on Mt can also increase the mobility of the nZVI. This is because the attraction between nZVI particles and soil grain surfaces can be eliminated by the strong repulsion between the Mt and the surfaces [15, 69].The advantages of using Mt-nZVI to remove contaminants from soil have been reported. For example, Soliemanzadeh and Fekri [60] used Bt-nZVI for the treatment of soil with 200 mg Cr kg-1. The soil samples were incubated at 25°C for 5 months and extracted with diethylenetriaminepentaacetic acid solutions. They found that the Cr was effectively removed by the composite, and the adsorption followed the Langmuir model with a maximum adsorption capacity of 66.10 mg g-1. Yu et al. [109] added ethanol to the soil slurry as an organic cosolvent to promote the degradation of decachlorobiphenyl by Bt-nZVI. The results showed that 70% of decachlorobiphenyl from the soil-water slurry containing 30 mg L-1 of decachlorobiphenyl could be dechlorinated within 13 h using 5 g L-1 of Bt-nZVI when the water/ethanol volume ratio was 1 : 1. Only 18% of decachlorobiphenyl was removed when ethanol was not added. This is likely because ethanol could increase the degree of decachlorobiphenyl desorption into the liquid phase, thereby enhancing the decachlorobiphenyl dechlorination with nZVI.Tomasevic et al. [67] used Bt-nZVI and kaolinite-supported nZVI to immobilize As, Pb, and Zn in the contaminated sediment from the Nadela river basin (Serbia). They showed that kaolinite and Bt could prevent the aggregation of nZVI and enhance their mobility in soil media and the treated sediment was safe for disposal. Liu et al. [94] assessed the removal of Cr(VI) by Bt-nZVI from soil suspended liquid. The maximum removal efficiency of Cr(VI) (15.68 mg L-1) was 99.75% at 35°C when the dosage of Bt-nZVI was 6 g L-1 and pH=5.


## 5.1. Remediation of Contaminated Water

### 5.1.1. Heavy Metals

Heavy metals enter the environment mainly through industrial production. They are difficult to be biodegraded and tend to accumulate in living organisms, thus posing a high potential risk to the ecosystem and human body [32]. Mt-nZVI has been applied to successfully remove heavy metals such as Pb(II), Zn(II), Cu(II), and particularly Cr(VI) in laboratory studies (Table 2).Yin et al. [15] examined the removal of Cr(VI) by Mt-nZVI. They found that the adsorption data was well described by the Langmuir model and pseudo-second-order kinetics (Table 4). The Cr(VI) was retained on the Mt-nZVI surface in a monolayer through chemical adsorption [60]. However, Shi et al. [51] showed that the removal of Cr(VI) by Bt-nZVI followed pseudo-first-order reaction kinetics. To improve the removal efficiency of Cr(VI) by Mt-nZVI, Mt or nZVI was modified [43, 95]. For example, Wu et al. [43] reported better removal capacity for Cr(VI) (109.9 mg g-1) by HDTMA-modified Mt-supported nZVI compared to Mt-nZVI (90.9 mg g-1) (Table 2). Wang et al. [95] fabricated Bt-supported organosolv lignin-stabilized nZVI and found that lignin could improve the loaded quantity and dispersity of nZVI. The Cr(VI) removal efficiency could reach 62.3% when the dosage of this fabricated structure was 1.0 g L-1 and initial Cr(VI) concentration was 50 mg L-1, which was higher than that of Bt-nZVI (56.8%).Table 4
Fitting results for the adsorption kinetic and isotherm models of contaminant removal by Mt-nZVI.
MaterialContaminantsAdsorption kinetic modelAdsorption isotherm modelReferenceMt-nZVICr(VI)Pseudo-second-orderLangmuir[15]OMt-nZVICr(VI)Pseudo-second-order—[43]Bt-nZVICr(VI)Pseudo-first-order—[51]Bt-nZVICr(VI)Pseudo-second-orderLangmuir[60]Mt-nZVIPb(II)Pseudo-second-orderLangmuir[77]Mt-nZVIPb(II)Pseudo-second-orderFreundlich[34]Zn(II)Pseudo-second-orderFreundlich, Temkin, and Dubinin–RadushkevichBt-nZVICu(II) and Zn(II)Pseudo-first-order—[68]Bt/graphene-supported nZVICu(II)Pseudo-second-order—[88]Bt-nZVIU(VI)Langmuir–Hinshelwood—[25]Mt-nZVIU(VI)Langmuir[71]Pillared Bt-supported nZVINO3-Langmuir–Hinshelwood—[86]Cetyltrimethylammonium bromide-modified Mt-supported nZVIDecabromodiphenyl etherPseudo-first-order—[73]Cetyltrimethylammonium-modified Bt-supported nZVIChlorophenolsLangmuir–HinshelwoodLangmuir[66]Cetyltrimethylammonium-modified Bt-supported nZVIPentachlorophenolLangmuir–Hinshelwood—[40]Bt-nZVIAcid violet red BPseudo-first-order—[74]Bt-nZVIMethyl orangePseudo-first-order—[24]Mt-nZVIRhodamine 6GPseudo-first-order—[78]Bt-nZVISe(VI)Langmuir–Hinshelwood—[79]Mt-nZVISe(VI)Pseudo-first-orderFreundlich[76]As(V)Pseudo-second-orderFreundlichCetyltrimethylammonium-modified Bt-supported nZVINitrobenzeneLangmuir–Hinshelwood—[41]Arancibia-Miranda et al. [77] observed that the maximum Pb(II) adsorption capacity on Mt-nZVI was 115.1±11.0mgg−1, and the reaction followed the pseudo-second-order kinetic model and the Langmuir model. Wang et al. [34] examined the adsorption of Zn(II) and Pb(II) by Mt-nZVI. The adsorption data of Zn(II) followed the Freundlich, Temkin, and Dubinin–Radushkevich isotherm models, meaning the copresence of physical and chemical adsorption. The Pb(II) adsorption process was chemisorption, and the reaction data was described by the Freundlich isotherm model. Shao et al. [88] presented that the removal efficiency of Cu(II) (C0=100mgL−1) was 82% in Bt- and graphene oxide-supported nZVIs (1 g L-1) within 16 h. The adsorption data followed the pseudo-second-order kinetic model.The applications of Mt-nZVI for the treatment of industrial wastewater have been reported. For example, Shi et al. [68] used Bt-nZVI to remediate electroplating wastewater and found that 100% Pb(II), 92.7% Cu(II), and 59.4% Zn(II) were removed within 1 h by 10 g L-1 Bt-nZVI. Wang et al. [97] studied the remediation effect of Bt-nZVI on leachate wastewater originating from Cr-polluted soil. The results indicated that 90% Cr(VI) from leachate wastewater with an initial concentration of 52.89 mg L-1 Cr(VI) could be removed within 10 min using 3 mg g-1 of Bt-nZVI.


### 5.1.2. Uranium

U(VI), as a radioactive and toxic heavy metal, has relatively high solubility and mobility in the environment. Therefore, it readily invades the food chain [93]. Previous laboratory work demonstrated that soluble uranium compounds could be removed by using Mt-nZVI to reduce U(VI) to less-soluble U(IV) [25, 32, 33]. For example, Sheng et al. [25] revealed that the adsorption data of U(VI) on Bt-nZVI followed the Langmuir–Hinshelwood model, and the removal efficiency of U(VI) (100 mg L-1) reached 99.2% after 90 min when using 0.2 g L-1 Bt-nZVI. Kornilovych et al. [71] used clay (e.g., kaolinite, Mt, and palygorskite)-supported nZVI to remove U(VI) from mineralized groundwater. They found that the adsorption process was better described by the Langmuir model. Mt-nZVI had the highest adsorption capacity (about 120 mg g-1), which might be related to the high dispersibility of the Mt sample in the aqueous solution. Xu et al. [32] reported 97.8% U(VI) (100 mg L-1) removal by Mt-nZVI (0.1 g L-1) within 30 min at pH=3.0. The aforementioned work indicated that Mt-nZVI was suitable for the removal of U(VI) from the aqueous solution.


### 5.1.3. Nitrate

Nitrate (NO3-) is widely presented in the surface and groundwater due to the widespread use of nitrogen fertilizers and improper treatment of industrial wastewater, causing deterioration of water quality, eutrophication of rivers, and toxicities to organisms [98]. Numerous laboratory studies have shown that the nitrate can be reduced by Mt-nZVI [20, 86, 99]. Zhang et al. [86] combined nZVI and pillared Bt (prepared by intercalation with poly(hydroxo Al(III)) cations) to remove NO3- from the aqueous solution. The adsorption data was fitted well to the Langmuir–Hinshelwood model. This composite could completely remove NO3- at pH 7.0 within 120 min. The nZVI could only remove 62.3% NO3- under the same condition. Zhao et al. [99] used Mt-nZVI immobilized in sodium alginate (SA/Mt-nZVI) as electron donor-acceptor compounds to enhance the nitrogen (NO3--N) removal from constructed wetland (CW). The removal efficiency of NO3--N (C0=60mgL−1) by 0.67 mg L-1 SA/Mt-nZVI in CW was 32.60±1.9% at pH 7, which was higher than that by CW without adding sodium alginate. The introduction of SA/Mt-nZVI could enhance the biological diversity and richness in CW. These results meant that it might be feasible to add SA/Mt-nZVI as a carbon source to treat low C/N-polluted water.


### 5.1.4. Halogenated Organic Compounds

Halogenated organic compounds are widely present in industrial wastewater. They have persistence, lipophilicity, high toxicity, and carcinogenicity [100]. They are difficult to be biodegraded and can be enriched in aquatic organisms [101]. Batch experiments have shown that Mt-nZVI could successfully degrade a large number of halogenated organics, such as chlorinated and brominated organics [19, 31]. For example, Pang et al. [73] demonstrated that the removal efficiency of decabromodiphenyl ether (C0=2mgL−1) by CTMAB-modified Mt-supported nZVI (0.6 g L-1) was 98.02%. The adsorption data fitted well to pseudo-first-order reaction. Yu et al. [42] applied TMA-modified smectite-supported nZVI (4 g L-1) to reduce 2.5 mg L-1 of DBDE. After a 9 h reaction, >80% DBDE was removed. This composite was shown to be much faster and more efficient for debromination compared to nZVI. Li et al. [40] immobilized CTMA onto Bt to load nZVI. They found that this novel composite had good stability and reusability, which could quickly and completely dechlorinate chlorophenols. The equilibrium adsorption was well described by the Langmuir and Langmuir–Hinshelwood kinetic models.Recently, nZVI was sulfurated to accelerate reduction efficiency for organochlorine compounds and maintain the stability of composite material in water [102]. For instance, Mt-supported sulfurated nZVI (Mt-S-nZVI) was synthesized [102] and exhibited higher removal efficiency for trichloroethylene (78.7%) than sulfurated nZVI and Mt-nZVI. Even aging for 30 days, Mt-S-nZVI could still retain 68.1% of trichloroethylene.


### 5.1.5. Dyes

Dyes include high levels of organic contaminants with deep colors. Their degradation products may be carcinogenic and toxic to mammals [69]. Reaction using Mt-nZVI composite materials to remove dyes has become a promising method [31]. Lin et al. [74] reported that the removal efficiency of acid violet red B on Bt-nZVI was 95.6% in 9 min under the condition of 2.8 g L-1 of Bt-nZVI and 800 mg L-1 acid violet red B solution. This was higher than that of nZVI (75.1%). The adsorption was well fitted to the pseudo-first-order model. The degradation of azo dye methyl orange by Bt-nZVI was also fitted well to the pseudo-first-order model [24]. Kerkez et al. [69] demonstrated that Bt-nZVI had a higher adsorption capacity on degrading industrial azo dye Rosso Zetanyl B-NG compared with kaolin- and native clay-supported nZVIs. This was probably because the SSA of Bt was three times that of kaolin and natural clay (Table 2).Mt-nZVI has been combined with microwave treatment for the decolorization of dyes. Microwave treatment can directly heat the reactant molecules and provide more energy to the reaction system, accelerating the efficiency of the degradation reaction [103]. Rao et al. [78] applied Mt-nZVI to remove Rhodamine 6G (Rh 6G) through microwave treatment and revealed that the removal amount of Rh 6G reached 500 mg g-1 when the initial Rh 6G concentration was 5000 mg L-1 after degradation for 15 min by 10 g L-1 Mt-nZVI.


### 5.1.6. Phenolic Compounds

Phenolic derivatives are frequently detected in the wastewater generated by the petrochemical, textile, and pharmaceutical industries [104]. They are highly toxic and harmful to organisms even at low concentrations [105]. Mt-nZVI composites have been proven to be highly efficient for removing phenolic compounds in the laboratory.Mt-nZVI coupled with oxidants (e.g., O3, H2O2, peroxymonosulfate, and persulfate) can enhance the degradation of phenolic compounds [22, 26, 64]. For instance, Bao et al. [89] reported that the adsorption capacity of bisphenol A on Bt-nZVI was increased in wastewater when H2O2 was added. Peng et al. [26] investigated tetrabromobisphenol A and bisphenol A removal using cetyltrimethylammonium bromide- (CTMAB-) modified Mt-supported nZVI in the aqueous solution. When O3 (4 mg L-1) was employed as an oxidant, this composite (0.1 g L-1) could remove up to 98.6% of tetrabromobisphenol A and 94.7% of bisphenol A during 60 min at pH 7 with an initial contaminant concentration of 10 mg L-1. Yang et al. [64] used Fe-Mt-H2 (0.4 g L-1) as an activator for peroxymonosulfate activation to remove bisphenol A (25 mg L-1) and found that more than 99.3% bisphenol A was degraded within 3 h at pH 3.


### 5.1.7. Other Contaminants

Ren et al. [41] used CTMA-modified Bt to load nZVI. This composite could almost completely reduce nitrobenzene to aniline. The removal followed the Langmuir–Hinshelwood equation. Wu et al. [44] assessed the persulfate activated with OMt-nZVI-degraded sulfamethazine. Sulfamethazine (20 mg L-1) was degraded by up to 97% in 10 min by using 1.5 mM OMt-nZVI and 4 mM persulfate at pH 6.8. Additionally, Mt-nZVI also could effectively degrade atrazine [106], amoxicillin [91], and oxytetracycline [75].The Mt-nZVI is commonly used to treat a single type of contaminant in water. However, Suazo-Hernandez [76] investigated the coremoval of Se(VI) and As(V) using Mt-nZVI. The removal of Se(VI) was fitted well to pseudo-first-order reaction, while the removal of As(V) followed pseudo-second-order reaction. The adsorption of As(V) was the chemisorption process, and the adsorption of Se(VI) was mainly through the formation of bidentate inner-sphere complexes [107]. The removal efficiency of As(V) (68.43%) was higher compared with that of Se(VI) (42.76%). This work demonstrated that Mt-nZVI was effective to simultaneously remove both oxyanions (but with a marked preference for As(V)).


## 5.1.1. Heavy Metals

Heavy metals enter the environment mainly through industrial production. They are difficult to be biodegraded and tend to accumulate in living organisms, thus posing a high potential risk to the ecosystem and human body [32]. Mt-nZVI has been applied to successfully remove heavy metals such as Pb(II), Zn(II), Cu(II), and particularly Cr(VI) in laboratory studies (Table 2).Yin et al. [15] examined the removal of Cr(VI) by Mt-nZVI. They found that the adsorption data was well described by the Langmuir model and pseudo-second-order kinetics (Table 4). The Cr(VI) was retained on the Mt-nZVI surface in a monolayer through chemical adsorption [60]. However, Shi et al. [51] showed that the removal of Cr(VI) by Bt-nZVI followed pseudo-first-order reaction kinetics. To improve the removal efficiency of Cr(VI) by Mt-nZVI, Mt or nZVI was modified [43, 95]. For example, Wu et al. [43] reported better removal capacity for Cr(VI) (109.9 mg g-1) by HDTMA-modified Mt-supported nZVI compared to Mt-nZVI (90.9 mg g-1) (Table 2). Wang et al. [95] fabricated Bt-supported organosolv lignin-stabilized nZVI and found that lignin could improve the loaded quantity and dispersity of nZVI. The Cr(VI) removal efficiency could reach 62.3% when the dosage of this fabricated structure was 1.0 g L-1 and initial Cr(VI) concentration was 50 mg L-1, which was higher than that of Bt-nZVI (56.8%).Table 4
Fitting results for the adsorption kinetic and isotherm models of contaminant removal by Mt-nZVI.
MaterialContaminantsAdsorption kinetic modelAdsorption isotherm modelReferenceMt-nZVICr(VI)Pseudo-second-orderLangmuir[15]OMt-nZVICr(VI)Pseudo-second-order—[43]Bt-nZVICr(VI)Pseudo-first-order—[51]Bt-nZVICr(VI)Pseudo-second-orderLangmuir[60]Mt-nZVIPb(II)Pseudo-second-orderLangmuir[77]Mt-nZVIPb(II)Pseudo-second-orderFreundlich[34]Zn(II)Pseudo-second-orderFreundlich, Temkin, and Dubinin–RadushkevichBt-nZVICu(II) and Zn(II)Pseudo-first-order—[68]Bt/graphene-supported nZVICu(II)Pseudo-second-order—[88]Bt-nZVIU(VI)Langmuir–Hinshelwood—[25]Mt-nZVIU(VI)Langmuir[71]Pillared Bt-supported nZVINO3-Langmuir–Hinshelwood—[86]Cetyltrimethylammonium bromide-modified Mt-supported nZVIDecabromodiphenyl etherPseudo-first-order—[73]Cetyltrimethylammonium-modified Bt-supported nZVIChlorophenolsLangmuir–HinshelwoodLangmuir[66]Cetyltrimethylammonium-modified Bt-supported nZVIPentachlorophenolLangmuir–Hinshelwood—[40]Bt-nZVIAcid violet red BPseudo-first-order—[74]Bt-nZVIMethyl orangePseudo-first-order—[24]Mt-nZVIRhodamine 6GPseudo-first-order—[78]Bt-nZVISe(VI)Langmuir–Hinshelwood—[79]Mt-nZVISe(VI)Pseudo-first-orderFreundlich[76]As(V)Pseudo-second-orderFreundlichCetyltrimethylammonium-modified Bt-supported nZVINitrobenzeneLangmuir–Hinshelwood—[41]Arancibia-Miranda et al. [77] observed that the maximum Pb(II) adsorption capacity on Mt-nZVI was 115.1±11.0mgg−1, and the reaction followed the pseudo-second-order kinetic model and the Langmuir model. Wang et al. [34] examined the adsorption of Zn(II) and Pb(II) by Mt-nZVI. The adsorption data of Zn(II) followed the Freundlich, Temkin, and Dubinin–Radushkevich isotherm models, meaning the copresence of physical and chemical adsorption. The Pb(II) adsorption process was chemisorption, and the reaction data was described by the Freundlich isotherm model. Shao et al. [88] presented that the removal efficiency of Cu(II) (C0=100mgL−1) was 82% in Bt- and graphene oxide-supported nZVIs (1 g L-1) within 16 h. The adsorption data followed the pseudo-second-order kinetic model.The applications of Mt-nZVI for the treatment of industrial wastewater have been reported. For example, Shi et al. [68] used Bt-nZVI to remediate electroplating wastewater and found that 100% Pb(II), 92.7% Cu(II), and 59.4% Zn(II) were removed within 1 h by 10 g L-1 Bt-nZVI. Wang et al. [97] studied the remediation effect of Bt-nZVI on leachate wastewater originating from Cr-polluted soil. The results indicated that 90% Cr(VI) from leachate wastewater with an initial concentration of 52.89 mg L-1 Cr(VI) could be removed within 10 min using 3 mg g-1 of Bt-nZVI.


## 5.1.2. Uranium

U(VI), as a radioactive and toxic heavy metal, has relatively high solubility and mobility in the environment. Therefore, it readily invades the food chain [93]. Previous laboratory work demonstrated that soluble uranium compounds could be removed by using Mt-nZVI to reduce U(VI) to less-soluble U(IV) [25, 32, 33]. For example, Sheng et al. [25] revealed that the adsorption data of U(VI) on Bt-nZVI followed the Langmuir–Hinshelwood model, and the removal efficiency of U(VI) (100 mg L-1) reached 99.2% after 90 min when using 0.2 g L-1 Bt-nZVI. Kornilovych et al. [71] used clay (e.g., kaolinite, Mt, and palygorskite)-supported nZVI to remove U(VI) from mineralized groundwater. They found that the adsorption process was better described by the Langmuir model. Mt-nZVI had the highest adsorption capacity (about 120 mg g-1), which might be related to the high dispersibility of the Mt sample in the aqueous solution. Xu et al. [32] reported 97.8% U(VI) (100 mg L-1) removal by Mt-nZVI (0.1 g L-1) within 30 min at pH=3.0. The aforementioned work indicated that Mt-nZVI was suitable for the removal of U(VI) from the aqueous solution.


## 5.1.3. Nitrate

Nitrate (NO3-) is widely presented in the surface and groundwater due to the widespread use of nitrogen fertilizers and improper treatment of industrial wastewater, causing deterioration of water quality, eutrophication of rivers, and toxicities to organisms [98]. Numerous laboratory studies have shown that the nitrate can be reduced by Mt-nZVI [20, 86, 99]. Zhang et al. [86] combined nZVI and pillared Bt (prepared by intercalation with poly(hydroxo Al(III)) cations) to remove NO3- from the aqueous solution. The adsorption data was fitted well to the Langmuir–Hinshelwood model. This composite could completely remove NO3- at pH 7.0 within 120 min. The nZVI could only remove 62.3% NO3- under the same condition. Zhao et al. [99] used Mt-nZVI immobilized in sodium alginate (SA/Mt-nZVI) as electron donor-acceptor compounds to enhance the nitrogen (NO3--N) removal from constructed wetland (CW). The removal efficiency of NO3--N (C0=60mgL−1) by 0.67 mg L-1 SA/Mt-nZVI in CW was 32.60±1.9% at pH 7, which was higher than that by CW without adding sodium alginate. The introduction of SA/Mt-nZVI could enhance the biological diversity and richness in CW. These results meant that it might be feasible to add SA/Mt-nZVI as a carbon source to treat low C/N-polluted water.


## 5.1.4. Halogenated Organic Compounds

Halogenated organic compounds are widely present in industrial wastewater. They have persistence, lipophilicity, high toxicity, and carcinogenicity [100]. They are difficult to be biodegraded and can be enriched in aquatic organisms [101]. Batch experiments have shown that Mt-nZVI could successfully degrade a large number of halogenated organics, such as chlorinated and brominated organics [19, 31]. For example, Pang et al. [73] demonstrated that the removal efficiency of decabromodiphenyl ether (C0=2mgL−1) by CTMAB-modified Mt-supported nZVI (0.6 g L-1) was 98.02%. The adsorption data fitted well to pseudo-first-order reaction. Yu et al. [42] applied TMA-modified smectite-supported nZVI (4 g L-1) to reduce 2.5 mg L-1 of DBDE. After a 9 h reaction, >80% DBDE was removed. This composite was shown to be much faster and more efficient for debromination compared to nZVI. Li et al. [40] immobilized CTMA onto Bt to load nZVI. They found that this novel composite had good stability and reusability, which could quickly and completely dechlorinate chlorophenols. The equilibrium adsorption was well described by the Langmuir and Langmuir–Hinshelwood kinetic models.Recently, nZVI was sulfurated to accelerate reduction efficiency for organochlorine compounds and maintain the stability of composite material in water [102]. For instance, Mt-supported sulfurated nZVI (Mt-S-nZVI) was synthesized [102] and exhibited higher removal efficiency for trichloroethylene (78.7%) than sulfurated nZVI and Mt-nZVI. Even aging for 30 days, Mt-S-nZVI could still retain 68.1% of trichloroethylene.


## 5.1.5. Dyes

Dyes include high levels of organic contaminants with deep colors. Their degradation products may be carcinogenic and toxic to mammals [69]. Reaction using Mt-nZVI composite materials to remove dyes has become a promising method [31]. Lin et al. [74] reported that the removal efficiency of acid violet red B on Bt-nZVI was 95.6% in 9 min under the condition of 2.8 g L-1 of Bt-nZVI and 800 mg L-1 acid violet red B solution. This was higher than that of nZVI (75.1%). The adsorption was well fitted to the pseudo-first-order model. The degradation of azo dye methyl orange by Bt-nZVI was also fitted well to the pseudo-first-order model [24]. Kerkez et al. [69] demonstrated that Bt-nZVI had a higher adsorption capacity on degrading industrial azo dye Rosso Zetanyl B-NG compared with kaolin- and native clay-supported nZVIs. This was probably because the SSA of Bt was three times that of kaolin and natural clay (Table 2).Mt-nZVI has been combined with microwave treatment for the decolorization of dyes. Microwave treatment can directly heat the reactant molecules and provide more energy to the reaction system, accelerating the efficiency of the degradation reaction [103]. Rao et al. [78] applied Mt-nZVI to remove Rhodamine 6G (Rh 6G) through microwave treatment and revealed that the removal amount of Rh 6G reached 500 mg g-1 when the initial Rh 6G concentration was 5000 mg L-1 after degradation for 15 min by 10 g L-1 Mt-nZVI.


## 5.1.6. Phenolic Compounds

Phenolic derivatives are frequently detected in the wastewater generated by the petrochemical, textile, and pharmaceutical industries [104]. They are highly toxic and harmful to organisms even at low concentrations [105]. Mt-nZVI composites have been proven to be highly efficient for removing phenolic compounds in the laboratory.Mt-nZVI coupled with oxidants (e.g., O3, H2O2, peroxymonosulfate, and persulfate) can enhance the degradation of phenolic compounds [22, 26, 64]. For instance, Bao et al. [89] reported that the adsorption capacity of bisphenol A on Bt-nZVI was increased in wastewater when H2O2 was added. Peng et al. [26] investigated tetrabromobisphenol A and bisphenol A removal using cetyltrimethylammonium bromide- (CTMAB-) modified Mt-supported nZVI in the aqueous solution. When O3 (4 mg L-1) was employed as an oxidant, this composite (0.1 g L-1) could remove up to 98.6% of tetrabromobisphenol A and 94.7% of bisphenol A during 60 min at pH 7 with an initial contaminant concentration of 10 mg L-1. Yang et al. [64] used Fe-Mt-H2 (0.4 g L-1) as an activator for peroxymonosulfate activation to remove bisphenol A (25 mg L-1) and found that more than 99.3% bisphenol A was degraded within 3 h at pH 3.


## 5.1.7. Other Contaminants

Ren et al. [41] used CTMA-modified Bt to load nZVI. This composite could almost completely reduce nitrobenzene to aniline. The removal followed the Langmuir–Hinshelwood equation. Wu et al. [44] assessed the persulfate activated with OMt-nZVI-degraded sulfamethazine. Sulfamethazine (20 mg L-1) was degraded by up to 97% in 10 min by using 1.5 mM OMt-nZVI and 4 mM persulfate at pH 6.8. Additionally, Mt-nZVI also could effectively degrade atrazine [106], amoxicillin [91], and oxytetracycline [75].The Mt-nZVI is commonly used to treat a single type of contaminant in water. However, Suazo-Hernandez [76] investigated the coremoval of Se(VI) and As(V) using Mt-nZVI. The removal of Se(VI) was fitted well to pseudo-first-order reaction, while the removal of As(V) followed pseudo-second-order reaction. The adsorption of As(V) was the chemisorption process, and the adsorption of Se(VI) was mainly through the formation of bidentate inner-sphere complexes [107]. The removal efficiency of As(V) (68.43%) was higher compared with that of Se(VI) (42.76%). This work demonstrated that Mt-nZVI was effective to simultaneously remove both oxyanions (but with a marked preference for As(V)).


## 5.2. Remediation of Contaminated Soil

Although nZVI has excellent removal capability for various contaminants from water, the application of nZVI for soil remediation is challenging. Firstly, due to strong magnetic attractive forces, nZVIs often aggregate into micron-sized particles (homoaggregation) or are associated with minerals and organic colloids to form heteroaggregates. These aggregates frequently have low mobility in soils [29]. Secondly, the reactivity of nZVI may be decreased when it is released into the complex soil environment [47]. It is necessary to consider the interference of various soil components and the physicochemical properties of soil during the application of the nZVIs [12]. Finally, nZVI will be oxidized in the soil [108]. As mentioned previously, adding Mt into nZVI can improve the dispersibility of nZVI and reduce the surface corrosion of nZVI. Furthermore, loading nZVI on Mt can also increase the mobility of the nZVI. This is because the attraction between nZVI particles and soil grain surfaces can be eliminated by the strong repulsion between the Mt and the surfaces [15, 69].The advantages of using Mt-nZVI to remove contaminants from soil have been reported. For example, Soliemanzadeh and Fekri [60] used Bt-nZVI for the treatment of soil with 200 mg Cr kg-1. The soil samples were incubated at 25°C for 5 months and extracted with diethylenetriaminepentaacetic acid solutions. They found that the Cr was effectively removed by the composite, and the adsorption followed the Langmuir model with a maximum adsorption capacity of 66.10 mg g-1. Yu et al. [109] added ethanol to the soil slurry as an organic cosolvent to promote the degradation of decachlorobiphenyl by Bt-nZVI. The results showed that 70% of decachlorobiphenyl from the soil-water slurry containing 30 mg L-1 of decachlorobiphenyl could be dechlorinated within 13 h using 5 g L-1 of Bt-nZVI when the water/ethanol volume ratio was 1 : 1. Only 18% of decachlorobiphenyl was removed when ethanol was not added. This is likely because ethanol could increase the degree of decachlorobiphenyl desorption into the liquid phase, thereby enhancing the decachlorobiphenyl dechlorination with nZVI.Tomasevic et al. [67] used Bt-nZVI and kaolinite-supported nZVI to immobilize As, Pb, and Zn in the contaminated sediment from the Nadela river basin (Serbia). They showed that kaolinite and Bt could prevent the aggregation of nZVI and enhance their mobility in soil media and the treated sediment was safe for disposal. Liu et al. [94] assessed the removal of Cr(VI) by Bt-nZVI from soil suspended liquid. The maximum removal efficiency of Cr(VI) (15.68 mg L-1) was 99.75% at 35°C when the dosage of Bt-nZVI was 6 g L-1 and pH=5.


## 6. Conclusions and Future Challenges

The use of Mt-nZVI for the removal of contaminants from water and soil has received increasing attention. The common methods to prepare Mt-nZVI include the liquid-phase reduction method, green reduction method, and thermal reduction method. The nZVI particles have also been loaded on Mt surfaces in a monolayer to form a micro/nanostructure. The introduction of Mt can improve the dispersion and mobility of nZVI and reduce the particle size and oxidation tendency. The reaction mechanisms of Mt-nZVI with contaminants include adsorption, reduction, oxidation, and precipitation. The reaction is influenced by various environmental factors including pH, temperature, dosage of the adsorbent, and natural organic matter. Mt-nZVI has been shown to have high removal efficiency for contaminants such as heavy metals, uranium, nitrates, halogenated organic compounds, dyes, and phenolic compounds. While Mt-nZVI has been shown as a promising material for water and soil remediation, future work is still necessary to fulfill the large-scale application of Mt-nZVI, as shown in the following:(i)
More attention should be paid to exploring new preparation methods of Mt-nZVI with low cost. For example, it is desired to find some cheap and environmentally friendly reducing agents to replace NaBH4 for producing nZVI. It is also desired to develop methods to improve the adsorption performance of Mt(ii)
The underlying mechanisms between Mt-nZVI and target contaminants at a microscale are still not very clear and required to be further elucidated using modern analytical tools such as X-ray absorption spectroscopy and atomic force microscopy(iii)
The critical factors that affect the removal of contaminants via Mt-nZVI in soil and sediments still need to be identified. The influence mechanisms of these factors are also necessary to be elucidated(iv)
Although Mt can improve the mobility of nZVI in soil, it is still necessary to further improve the mobility of Mt-nZVI with novel methods to improve thein situ remediation efficiency. In addition, the efficiency of soil extraction is an important problem that needs to be addressed during the remediation of contaminated soils using Mt-nZVI(v)
Field experiments are still lacking, which are critical to assess the performance of Mt-nZVI for thein situ remediation of water and soil. Larger-scale field studies are also useful to explore the application of Mt-nZVI at a commercial scale(vi)
It is necessary to extend the reactivity of Mt-nZVI and increase its selectivity to target contaminants. For example, adding a hydrophobic coating to nZVI may extend the reactive lifetime of Mt-nZVI. Functionalization of chemical groups with Mt-nZVI can increase their selectivity to target contaminants(vii)
It is vital to conduct risk assessments of Mt-nZVI to ensure that they are safe while achieving their full potential because it is still not clear where they can pose a potential threat to organisms. It is also useful to develop mathematic models to simulate the transport of Mt-nZVI



---

*Source: 9340362-2021-08-27.xml*