# Development of Control Structure for Hybrid Wind Generators with Active Power Capability

Authors: Mehdi Niroomand; Dong-Jun Won
Journal: Advances in Power Electronics
 (2014)

---

## Abstract

A hierarchical control structure is proposed for hybrid energy systems (HES) which consist of wind energy system (WES) and energy storage system (ESS). The proposed multilevel control structure consists of four blocks: reference generation and mode select, power balancing, control algorithms, and switching control blocks. A high performance power management strategy is used for the system. Also, the proposed system is analyzed as an active power filter (APF) with ability to control the voltage, to compensate the harmonics, and to deliver active power. The HES is designed with parallel DC coupled structure. Simulation results are shown for verification of the theoretical analysis.


---

## Body

## 1. Introduction

To have sustainable growth and social progress, it is necessary to fulfil the energy need by utilizing the renewable energy resources like wind, photovoltaic, biomass, hydro, cogeneration, and so forth [1]. Wind energy is one of the most important renewable energy sources on earth. During the last decade, there has been heavy growth in both the size and the power of wind energy converters [1, 2].In normal operation, wind turbine produces a continuous variable output power. These power variations are mainly caused by the effect of turbulence, wind gradient, and tower-shadow and control system in the power system. Thus, the network needs to manage for such fluctuations. In the event of increasing grid disturbance, an energy storage system (ESS) for wind energy generating system is generally required to compensate the fluctuation generated by wind turbine [3].In addition, when an ESS is added to a wind energy system, the grid-tie inverter in this system can exchange both active and reactive power with distribution system by varying the amplitude and phase angle of the converter voltage with respect to the line terminal voltage. This hybrid system can improve power quality of distribution system like an active power filter (APF) [4–8].To achieve good ability of power quality improvement, a high performance control system should be designed for hybrid energy systems [8, 9]. Also, for good interaction between different sources, good power balancing should be considered. There are some researches about power balancing strategy and control algorithm for hybrid energy systems [10–16] and active power filters [17–19] that present some techniques. In this paper, a hierarchical control structure was proposed for hybrid energy systems. It consists of reference generation and mode select, power balancing, control algorithms, and switching control blocks. Also, a high performance power management strategy is used for the system. With this power balancing strategy, the system could easily provide ancillary services to grid and acting as an APF [10].This paper is organized as follows. In Section2, firstly, circuit diagrams of HES are reviewed. Then the proposed structure for HES and the structure of ESS were presented. Section 3 describes hierarchical control structure and power management system was proposed for the system. Finally, simulation results and conclusion are presented in Sections 4 and 5, respectively.


## 2. Topology of HES

### 2.1. Circuit Diagram

As mentioned in Introduction, HES can improve power quality of distribution system. There are some structures for HES. One structure that has been widely used is AC coupled structure [4]. Figure 1 shows circuit diagram of an AC coupled structure. This is a shunt-connected inverter and its DC link is supported using an ESS.Figure 1
AC-coupled structure of HES.DC-coupled structure is another structure for HES. In DC-coupled structure the grid voltages and frequencies are decoupled from other sources. All sources are connected to a DC link before being connected to the grid through an inverter.Cascade structure that has been widely used is based on the direct connection of a battery bank to the DC bus of the grid-connected inverter. Figure2 shows cascade structure. In this structure, wind power is sent to the battery bank via a PWM rectifier. The stochastic nature of the wind power output and power demand leads to a fast charge/discharge action of batteries and fast battery aging [20].Figure 2
Cascade DC-coupled structure of HES.To enable more efficient use of batteries, a parallel DC-coupled structure has been presented in researches [20, 21]. Figure 3 shows parallel DC-coupled structure. A first interest is that the battery bank is connected to the DC bus via a DC/DC converter, thus making it possible to obtain an optimized charge/discharge operation mode. A second advantage is that different energy storage can be added and is also connected to the DC bus via another DC/DC converter. In this paper, parallel DC-coupled structure is considered for proposed HES.Figure 3
Parallel DC-coupled structure of HES.


### 2.2. Energy Storage System Structure

In an HES, energy storage system plays an important role. It should supply needed power for fast fluctuation and long time instability. In this paper, in order to benefit from various technology advantages and its simplicity, a battery bank is considered [10, 22].


## 2.1. Circuit Diagram

As mentioned in Introduction, HES can improve power quality of distribution system. There are some structures for HES. One structure that has been widely used is AC coupled structure [4]. Figure 1 shows circuit diagram of an AC coupled structure. This is a shunt-connected inverter and its DC link is supported using an ESS.Figure 1
AC-coupled structure of HES.DC-coupled structure is another structure for HES. In DC-coupled structure the grid voltages and frequencies are decoupled from other sources. All sources are connected to a DC link before being connected to the grid through an inverter.Cascade structure that has been widely used is based on the direct connection of a battery bank to the DC bus of the grid-connected inverter. Figure2 shows cascade structure. In this structure, wind power is sent to the battery bank via a PWM rectifier. The stochastic nature of the wind power output and power demand leads to a fast charge/discharge action of batteries and fast battery aging [20].Figure 2
Cascade DC-coupled structure of HES.To enable more efficient use of batteries, a parallel DC-coupled structure has been presented in researches [20, 21]. Figure 3 shows parallel DC-coupled structure. A first interest is that the battery bank is connected to the DC bus via a DC/DC converter, thus making it possible to obtain an optimized charge/discharge operation mode. A second advantage is that different energy storage can be added and is also connected to the DC bus via another DC/DC converter. In this paper, parallel DC-coupled structure is considered for proposed HES.Figure 3
Parallel DC-coupled structure of HES.


## 2.2. Energy Storage System Structure

In an HES, energy storage system plays an important role. It should supply needed power for fast fluctuation and long time instability. In this paper, in order to benefit from various technology advantages and its simplicity, a battery bank is considered [10, 22].


## 3. Control System Structure

As mentioned in Introduction, wind turbine produces a continuous variable output power and it causes some fluctuation in power system. An ESS can compensate some of this fluctuation. Also, when an ESS was added to a wind energy system, the grid-tie inverter in this system can exchange both active and reactive power with distribution system. This hybrid system can improve power quality of distribution system similar to an APF. Hence, the control system of an HES should have these capabilities.


### 3.1. Hierarchical Structure (Proposed Structure)

The proposed control scheme for the HES has hierarchical structure. It consists of four blocks: reference generation and mode select, power balancing strategy, control algorithm, and switching control block. They are based on concepts of instantaneous power on the synchronous-rotatingd
q reference frame as depicted in Figure 4. Rotating reference frame is used because it offers higher accuracy than stationary frame-based techniques [23]. All blocks make use of control variables that are feasible to be locally measured. The following sections explains these blocks.Figure 4
The proposed hierarchical control structure for HES.


### 3.2. Reference Generation and Mode Select Block

The “reference generation and mode select” is responsible for determining the active and reactive power exchange between the HES and the utility system. Figure4(a) shows the structure of this block. This block has two main modes: mode 1 and mode 2. In mode 1, HES can deliver active power to power system and also can enhance voltage profile by reactive power injection. In mode 2, HES can deliver active power to power system and also compensate harmonic parts of utility current to reach unity power factor.In both modes, active reference is determined to control the active power exchanged with the electric system. In mode 1, for generating active reference, the average power of wind system and stored energy was considered. But in mode 2, the active power required to compensate harmonic parts of nonlinear current was added.Reactive reference in mode 1 is determined to control the voltage at the point of common coupling (PCC) of HES and power system. This control mode shows a very good performance in conventional static VAR compensators (with no energy storage). In this mode, a voltage regulation droop is used to allow the terminal voltage of the HES to vary in proportion with the compensating reactive current. The reference for terminal voltage including droop system is obtained as follows:(1)
v
sref
_
droop
=
v
s
_
ref
-
i
inv
_
out
×
k
droop
,
where i
inv
_
out is the output current of grid-tie inverter, v
s
_
ref is the reference of line voltage, k
droop is droop gain determined by user, and v
sref
_
droop is the reference for terminal voltage.Reactive reference in mode 2 was determined to compensate harmonic and reactive parts of load current. In this mode, the power factor of power system is equal to unity.The active and reactive powers, which are exchanged with the grid, can be calculated through the “two-wattmeter” method [24]:
(2)
p
g
=
v
13
i
1
+
v
23
i
2
q
g
=
3
(
v
13
i
1
-
v
23
i
2
)
,
where v
13 and v
23 are line to line voltages, i
1 and i
2 are line currents, and p
g and q
g are the active and reactive power exchanged between HES and grid. To generate current reference of inverter, currents should be extracted from (2) as follows:
(3)
i
1
inv
_
ref
=
(
2
v
13
-
v
23
)
p
g
_
ref
+
3
v
23
q
g
_
ref
2
v
13
2
-
2
v
13
v
23
+
2
v
23
2
i
2
inv
_
ref
=
(
2
v
23
-
v
13
)
p
g
_
ref
+
3
v
13
q
g
_
ref
2
v
13
2
-
2
v
13
v
23
+
2
v
23
2
.
Then, the a
b
c currents should be transformed to synchronous reference frame with Park transform. With this block, proposed HES can improve power quality of distribution system, in addition to active power delivery.


### 3.3. Power Balancing Block

In this wind/ESS hybrid energy system, some power-electronic converters are used to regulate the power transfer with each source. According to a chosen power flow, the following two power balancing strategies were discussed in previous researches [10], “grid-following strategy” and “source-following strategy”. In “grid-following strategy” the line-current loop is used to regulate the DC link voltage and in “source-following strategy” the line-current loop is used to control the grid active power, and also the DC bus voltage is regulated with the wind turbine system and ESS. Comparison of two control strategies shows the source following strategy has better performance on the grid power regulation than the grid-following strategy, and it can provide ancillary services according to the microgrid’s requirements. In this paper, source following control strategy is considered for the HES. Figure 4(b) shows the block diagram of this strategy.In proposed HES, the reference of gear torque is determined by(4)
T
gear
_
ref
=
p
wind
_
ref
Ω
tur
,
where T
gear
_
ref is the reference of gear torque of wind system, Ω
tur is rotational speed of gear, and p
wind
_
ref is the reference of wind power. The main power balance equation is
(5)
p
Battery
=
p
dc
_
ref
+
p
wind
-
p
inv
,
where p
Battery is power of battery, p
wind is power of wind system, p
inv is power of grid-tie inverter, and p
dc
_
ref is the required power for DC link voltage control.As shown in Figure4(b), in proposed power balance strategy, the references of currents of grid-tie inverter (i
d
_
inv
_
ref and i
q
_
inv
_
ref) are free for power quality improvement.


### 3.4. Control Algorithms Block

The control algorithms block makes the expected output to dynamically track the reference values set by the “reference generation and mode select block” and the “power balancing block.” This block consists of current reference generation for ESS control, gear torque controller for wind power convection via PWM rectifier, and current control of grid-tie inverter.The current control design is based on a linearization of the state-space averaged model of the grid-tie inverter. The basic equations governing the operation of this circuit in abc-frame are(6)
v
a
-
v
inv
a
=
L
(
d
i
L
a
d
t
)
,
v
b
-
v
inv
b
=
L
(
d
i
L
b
d
t
)
,
v
c
-
v
inv
_
c
=
L
(
d
i
L
c
d
t
)
,
where v
a
,
b
,
c are line voltages, v
inv
_
a
,
b
,
c are the output voltages of inverter, L is the inductance of output filter of inverter, and i
L is current of L. Rewriting (6) in synchronous rotating reference frame yields [23]
(7)
[
d
i
L
d
d
t
d
i
L
q
d
t
]
=
[
0
ω
-
ω
0
]
·
[
i
L
d
i
L
q
]
+
[
1
L
0
0
1
L
]
[
v
d
-
v
inv
_
d
v
q
-
v
inv
_
q
]
,
where ω
=
d
θ
/
d
t is the synchronous angular velocity. Equation (7) shows a coupling term between d and q axes which influences the dynamic behaviour of the model. Therefore, in order to achieve a fully decoupled active and reactive power control, a feed-forward decoupled controller is used for inverter. Figure 4(c) shows this controller in detail.Also, to extract the current reference for output current of DC/DC converter, power of battery should be divided by DC link voltage as follows:(8)
i
conv
_
ref
=
p
Battery
v
dc
,
where i
conv
_
ref is reference of output current of DC/DC converter and v
dc is DC link voltage.


### 3.5. Switching Control Block

Basic scheme of switching control block of proposed HES was shown in Figure4(d). The switching control block provides dynamic control of input signals for inverter and DC/DC converter. This level is responsible for generating the triggering control signals for the switches of the inverter, according to the modulation techniques (SPWM) and types of semiconductors (IGBTs) and for the switches of DC/DC converter.


## 3.1. Hierarchical Structure (Proposed Structure)

The proposed control scheme for the HES has hierarchical structure. It consists of four blocks: reference generation and mode select, power balancing strategy, control algorithm, and switching control block. They are based on concepts of instantaneous power on the synchronous-rotatingd
q reference frame as depicted in Figure 4. Rotating reference frame is used because it offers higher accuracy than stationary frame-based techniques [23]. All blocks make use of control variables that are feasible to be locally measured. The following sections explains these blocks.Figure 4
The proposed hierarchical control structure for HES.


## 3.2. Reference Generation and Mode Select Block

The “reference generation and mode select” is responsible for determining the active and reactive power exchange between the HES and the utility system. Figure4(a) shows the structure of this block. This block has two main modes: mode 1 and mode 2. In mode 1, HES can deliver active power to power system and also can enhance voltage profile by reactive power injection. In mode 2, HES can deliver active power to power system and also compensate harmonic parts of utility current to reach unity power factor.In both modes, active reference is determined to control the active power exchanged with the electric system. In mode 1, for generating active reference, the average power of wind system and stored energy was considered. But in mode 2, the active power required to compensate harmonic parts of nonlinear current was added.Reactive reference in mode 1 is determined to control the voltage at the point of common coupling (PCC) of HES and power system. This control mode shows a very good performance in conventional static VAR compensators (with no energy storage). In this mode, a voltage regulation droop is used to allow the terminal voltage of the HES to vary in proportion with the compensating reactive current. The reference for terminal voltage including droop system is obtained as follows:(1)
v
sref
_
droop
=
v
s
_
ref
-
i
inv
_
out
×
k
droop
,
where i
inv
_
out is the output current of grid-tie inverter, v
s
_
ref is the reference of line voltage, k
droop is droop gain determined by user, and v
sref
_
droop is the reference for terminal voltage.Reactive reference in mode 2 was determined to compensate harmonic and reactive parts of load current. In this mode, the power factor of power system is equal to unity.The active and reactive powers, which are exchanged with the grid, can be calculated through the “two-wattmeter” method [24]:
(2)
p
g
=
v
13
i
1
+
v
23
i
2
q
g
=
3
(
v
13
i
1
-
v
23
i
2
)
,
where v
13 and v
23 are line to line voltages, i
1 and i
2 are line currents, and p
g and q
g are the active and reactive power exchanged between HES and grid. To generate current reference of inverter, currents should be extracted from (2) as follows:
(3)
i
1
inv
_
ref
=
(
2
v
13
-
v
23
)
p
g
_
ref
+
3
v
23
q
g
_
ref
2
v
13
2
-
2
v
13
v
23
+
2
v
23
2
i
2
inv
_
ref
=
(
2
v
23
-
v
13
)
p
g
_
ref
+
3
v
13
q
g
_
ref
2
v
13
2
-
2
v
13
v
23
+
2
v
23
2
.
Then, the a
b
c currents should be transformed to synchronous reference frame with Park transform. With this block, proposed HES can improve power quality of distribution system, in addition to active power delivery.


## 3.3. Power Balancing Block

In this wind/ESS hybrid energy system, some power-electronic converters are used to regulate the power transfer with each source. According to a chosen power flow, the following two power balancing strategies were discussed in previous researches [10], “grid-following strategy” and “source-following strategy”. In “grid-following strategy” the line-current loop is used to regulate the DC link voltage and in “source-following strategy” the line-current loop is used to control the grid active power, and also the DC bus voltage is regulated with the wind turbine system and ESS. Comparison of two control strategies shows the source following strategy has better performance on the grid power regulation than the grid-following strategy, and it can provide ancillary services according to the microgrid’s requirements. In this paper, source following control strategy is considered for the HES. Figure 4(b) shows the block diagram of this strategy.In proposed HES, the reference of gear torque is determined by(4)
T
gear
_
ref
=
p
wind
_
ref
Ω
tur
,
where T
gear
_
ref is the reference of gear torque of wind system, Ω
tur is rotational speed of gear, and p
wind
_
ref is the reference of wind power. The main power balance equation is
(5)
p
Battery
=
p
dc
_
ref
+
p
wind
-
p
inv
,
where p
Battery is power of battery, p
wind is power of wind system, p
inv is power of grid-tie inverter, and p
dc
_
ref is the required power for DC link voltage control.As shown in Figure4(b), in proposed power balance strategy, the references of currents of grid-tie inverter (i
d
_
inv
_
ref and i
q
_
inv
_
ref) are free for power quality improvement.


## 3.4. Control Algorithms Block

The control algorithms block makes the expected output to dynamically track the reference values set by the “reference generation and mode select block” and the “power balancing block.” This block consists of current reference generation for ESS control, gear torque controller for wind power convection via PWM rectifier, and current control of grid-tie inverter.The current control design is based on a linearization of the state-space averaged model of the grid-tie inverter. The basic equations governing the operation of this circuit in abc-frame are(6)
v
a
-
v
inv
a
=
L
(
d
i
L
a
d
t
)
,
v
b
-
v
inv
b
=
L
(
d
i
L
b
d
t
)
,
v
c
-
v
inv
_
c
=
L
(
d
i
L
c
d
t
)
,
where v
a
,
b
,
c are line voltages, v
inv
_
a
,
b
,
c are the output voltages of inverter, L is the inductance of output filter of inverter, and i
L is current of L. Rewriting (6) in synchronous rotating reference frame yields [23]
(7)
[
d
i
L
d
d
t
d
i
L
q
d
t
]
=
[
0
ω
-
ω
0
]
·
[
i
L
d
i
L
q
]
+
[
1
L
0
0
1
L
]
[
v
d
-
v
inv
_
d
v
q
-
v
inv
_
q
]
,
where ω
=
d
θ
/
d
t is the synchronous angular velocity. Equation (7) shows a coupling term between d and q axes which influences the dynamic behaviour of the model. Therefore, in order to achieve a fully decoupled active and reactive power control, a feed-forward decoupled controller is used for inverter. Figure 4(c) shows this controller in detail.Also, to extract the current reference for output current of DC/DC converter, power of battery should be divided by DC link voltage as follows:(8)
i
conv
_
ref
=
p
Battery
v
dc
,
where i
conv
_
ref is reference of output current of DC/DC converter and v
dc is DC link voltage.


## 3.5. Switching Control Block

Basic scheme of switching control block of proposed HES was shown in Figure4(d). The switching control block provides dynamic control of input signals for inverter and DC/DC converter. This level is responsible for generating the triggering control signals for the switches of the inverter, according to the modulation techniques (SPWM) and types of semiconductors (IGBTs) and for the switches of DC/DC converter.


## 4. Simulation Results

Time-domain simulations are carried out to verify the theory described above and evaluate the performance of the proposed control structure. The simulations are performed using PSIM software. Block diagram of simulation setup is shown in Figure5 and parameters of the system are given in Table 1.Table 1
System parameters.
Parameters
Ratings
Grid voltage
3-phase, 380 V, 50 Hz
Line series impedance
L = .03 mH, R = 25 m ohm
Load power
150 kVA
HES power
100 kVA
Wind system power
30 kWFigure 5
Block diagram of simulation setup.Figure5 presents performance of system in mode 1. Before t
=
90 ms HES works as a simple active generator. Before t
=
90 ms line voltage is less than reference of line voltage (Figure 6(a)). After t
=
90 ms, HES works with proposed control system and profile of line voltage is enhanced (Figure 6(a)). A little difference between line voltage and reference of line voltage is caused by droop system. After t
=
90 ms, the active power reference is not changed, but reactive power reference is increased to compensate line voltage (Figures 6(b), 6(c), and 6(d)).Simulation results, mode 1, voltage of PCC (before and after HES working).
(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)Figures7 and 8 show the performance of system in mode 2. In Figure 7, before t
=
720 ms HES works as a simple active generator. In this time, the current of HES is sinusoidal and line current is distorted by nonlinear loads. After t
=
720 ms HES works with proposed control system. In this time HES compensates the reactive and harmonic parts of line current and line current is sinusoidal.Simulation results, mode 2, (a) HES output current, (b) line current, and (c) line voltage.
(a)
(b)
(c)Simulation results, mode 2, (a) active power of HES, (b) reactive power of HES, (c) active power of source, (d) reactive power of source, and (e) power factor.
(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)
(e)Figure8 shows active and reactive power of HES and power system and its power factor. It can be obtained that, after HES was changed to mode 2, active power of HES was not changed significantly and only some variations were added to it (Figure 8(a)). Also, reactive power of HES was increased to compensate reactive and harmonic parts of loads (Figure 8(b)). Figure 8(e) shows power factor of power system. It can be found that HES could enhance power factor to unity.The other set of simulations demonstrates the system performance in variable DC link voltage (Figure9). This set simulates variation in DC link voltage caused by wind speed variation. Figure 9(a) shows good performance of HES, despite variation in DC link voltage (Figure 9(b)). This good performance is because of operation of controller. Figure 9(c) shows that when DC link voltage is low, output of controller is increased and when DC link voltage is high, output of controller is decreased.Simulation results in variable wind speed (mode 2), (a) HES output current, line voltage, line current, (b) DC link voltage, and (c) outputs of controller.
(a)
(b)
(c)


## 5. Conclusion

In this paper, a parallel DC-coupled HES consists of WES and ESS has been studied. The multilevel control structure is divided into 4 blocks: (1) reference generation and mode select, (2) power balancing, (3) control algorithms, and (4) switching control. Source-following strategy was used for power management of this hybrid system. With this power balancing strategy, the system could easily provide ancillary services to grid and acts as an APF. Simulation results confirm the validity of analysis and design.



---

*Source: 890945-2014-09-02.xml*