# Species, Risk Factors, and Antimicrobial Susceptibility Profiles of Bacterial Isolates from HIV-Infected Patients Suspected to Have Pneumonia in Mekelle Zone, Tigray, Northern Ethiopia

Authors: Gebre Adhanom; Dawit Gebreegziabiher; Yemane Weldu; Araya Gebreyesus Wasihun; Tadele Araya; Haftom Legese; Bruno S. Lopes; Muthupandian Saravanan
Journal: BioMed Research International
 (2019)

---

## Abstract

Background. Pneumonia is a condition, where bacterial infections are implicated as the most common causes of morbidity and mortality in humans. The actual burden of HIV-infected patients with pneumonia is not well documented in Mekelle region of Ethiopia. This study estimated the prevalence of bacterial pneumonia in HIV patients, antimicrobial susceptibility patterns of pathogens implicated in pneumonia, and associated risk factors in Mekelle zone, Tigray, Northern Ethiopia, during August-December 2016.Methods. Sputum specimens were collected from 252 HIV seropositive individuals with suspected pneumonia. Data on sociodemographics and risk factors were also collected using a structured questionnaire. Blood, Chocolate, and Mac Conkey agar plates (Oxoid, Hampshire, UK) were used to grow the isolates. The isolated colonies were identified based on Gram stain, colony morphology, pigmentation, hemolysis, and biochemical tests. The antimicrobial susceptibility test was performed using the modified Kirby-Bauer disc diffusion method. The analysis was performed using SPSS version 22 and p-value < 0.05 with corresponding 95% confidence interval (CI) was considered statistically significant.Results. Out of the 252 samples, 110 (43.7%) were positive for various bacterial species. The predominant bacterial species wereKlebsiella pneumoniae (n=26, 23.6 %) followed byStreptococcus pneumoniae (n=17, 15.5 %),Escherichia coli (n=16, 14.5%),Klebsiellaspp. (n=15, 13.6%), Staphylococcus aureus(n=9, 8.2%),Enterobacter spp. (n=7, 6.3%),Pseudomonas aeruginosa(4, n=3.6%),Proteus spp. (n=4, 3.6%),Citrobacter freundii (n=7, 6.3%),Streptococcus pyogenes(3, 2.7%), andHaemophilus influenzae(n=2, 1.8%). Young age (18-29), recent CD4+ count less than 350 cells/mL, alcohol consumption, and HIV WHO stage II showed significant association with the occurrence of bacterial pneumonia. Resistance to penicillin, co-trimoxazole, and tetracycline was observed in 81.8%, 39.8%, and 24.5% of the isolates, respectively.Conclusions. The problem of pneumonia among HIV patients was significant in the study area. The high prevalence of drug-resistant bacteria isolated from the patient’s samples possesses a health risk in immunocompromised HIV patients. There is a need to strengthen and expand culture and susceptibility procedures for the administration of appropriate therapy to improve patients management and care which may aid in decreasing the mortality.


---

## Body

## 1. Background

Respiratory infections are the leading cause of morbidity and mortality in HIV-infected individuals [1]. It is also the most frequent cause of hospital admission in HIV-infected people worldwide with an incidence of 20-25 episodes per 100 hospital admissions per year [2]. About 70% of HIV patients have a pulmonary complication during the evolution of the disease, mainly as a consequence of infectious etiology [2]. During respiration, the respiratory tract, especially nose, nasopharynx, and oropharynx, comes into contact with a large number of bacteria that may cause life-threatening respiratory infections [3]. Lower respiratory tract infections (LRTIs) are among the most prevalent diseases of human beings worldwide [4], which result in around 7 million deaths annually [5]. Pneumonia is an acute respiratory illness which is one of the most common LRTI, mainly caused by bacteria, viruses, and fungi [6, 7].Bacterial pneumonia is the most frequent cause of pulmonary infections, which is among the most common causes of respiratory failure in HIV- infected patients [2, 8]. The incidence of bacterial pneumonia in HIV-infected patients ranges from 1.93 to 19.2% of cases per year in Nigeria [9]. HIV-infected individuals have a sixfold greater risk of bacterial pneumonia than the noninfected individuals [10] and estimated greater than one-third of all persons with AIDS will develop at least one episode of severe bacterial pneumonia over the course of their HIV infection [10]. If bacterial pneumonia is not properly treated, it causes further complications leading to empyema, meningitis, pericarditis, hepatitis, and arthritis [10].The most common pathogens that cause bacterial pneumonia areS. pneumoniae,H. influenzae,K. pneumoniae,P. aeruginosa,E. coli, andS. aureus[11]. Among thisS. pneumoniae is considered the predominant bacterial pathogen across all age groups and accounts for approximately 30% of pneumonia cases [12].The incidence of bacterial drug resistance is high due to empirical drug administration and poor adherence to treatment standards. Hence, specific antibiotic therapy is fundamental to manage and control bacterial pneumonia in HIV patients [13]. Therefore, identifying the bacterial cause and performing antibiotic susceptibility testing are vital [2].In Northern Ethiopia, there is a high prevalence of HIV-infected patients [14]. However, there is no study which shows the real burden of bacterial pneumonia among HIV positive individuals in this region. In addition, the antimicrobial susceptibility patterns of the common bacterial agents for pneumonia are not known. Therefore, this study was performed to assess the burden of bacterial pneumonia, the risk factors, and antimicrobial susceptibility of bacterial isolates in HIV positive individuals with suspected pneumonia at ART clinics of Mekelle zone, Tigray, Northern Ethiopia.


## 2. Methods

### 2.1. Study Design, Specimen Collection, and Transportation

A multicentre cross-sectional study was conducted from August-December 2016 at different ART clinics of Mekelle zone, Tigray, Ethiopia. A total of 252 HIV patients with suspected pneumonia were included in the study based on the inclusion/exclusion criteria. Sociodemographic, clinical, and risk-factor related data were collected using a structured and pretested questionnaire. Pneumonia suspected individuals showing clinical symptoms such as shortness of breath, chest pain, fever, chills, tiredness, and cough were examined by clinicians and the sputum samples were collected and transported to medical microbiology laboratory, Mekelle University, College of Health Sciences by medical laboratory technologists for analysis within 2 hrs or stored at 4°C until further processing.


### 2.2. Inclusion and Exclusion Criteria

HIV seropositive, highly active antiretroviral therapy users and nonusers aged ≥ 18 with a diagnosis of pneumonia as described by the clinician were included. Patients who were critically ill, who cannot produce sputum, suspected pulmonary tuberculosis and who took antibiotics during the past two week period were excluded.


### 2.3. Specimen Processing

Smear was prepared from each sputum sample for Gram staining and slides were examined under low power field (l0X). Sputum samples with > 25 polymorphonuclear leukocytes and <10 epithelial cells were accepted for culture. Samples that had more than 10 epithelial cells and less than 25 polymorphonuclear leukocytes per low power field were discarded [15, 16].


### 2.4. Cultivation and Identification of Isolates

Blood, Chocolate, and Mac Conkey agar plates (Oxoid, Hampshire, UK) were prepared as per the manufacturers’ instructions. Using a calibrated wire loop, approximately 0.1μL purulent sputum sample was streaked onto each agar plate. Chocolate agar plates were incubated at 37°C for 24 hours in a candle jar. MacConkey agar and blood agar plates were incubated aerobically at 37°C for 24 hours [15, 16]. After incubation, the plates were inspected for any growth and negative plates were incubated for an additional 24 hours. Quantitative sputum culture analysis was carried out and the significant bacterial count was reported on observing an excess of 106 CFU/mL [17]. More than 100 CFU were considered significant for bacterial growth in this study. A single pure culture colony of each isolate was stored in nutrient broth with 10% glycerol stock solution for identification. Gram-positive cocci were differentiated and identified based on Gram stain, patterns of hemolysis on blood agar, colonial characteristics, catalase test, coagulase test, optochin susceptibility, and bacitracin susceptibility. Gram-negative bacteria were also identified based on Gram stain, colonial morphology and pigmentation, oxidase test, carbohydrate fermentation, H2S production, citrate utilization, motility, indole formation, urea hydrolysis and growth in blood agar with “X”, and “V” factors forH. influenzae.


### 2.5. Antimicrobial Susceptibility Testing

The antimicrobial susceptibility test was performed using the Kirby-Bauer disc diffusion test method [16]. The antimicrobial discs used for susceptibility testing were amikacin (AK,30μg), ciprofloxacin (CIP,5μg), ceftriaxone (CTR,30μg), chloramphenicol (C,10μg),co-trimoxazole (COT,25μg), erythromycin (ERY,15μg), gentamicin (GN,10μg), Methicillin (MET, 30μg)penicillin (P,10 units), and tetracycline (TE,30μg). Muller-Hinton agar (MHA) plates were used for the nonfastidious organism, whereas MHA supplemented with 5% sheep blood were used forS. pneumoniaeandHaemophilus spp. using a standard procedure [16]. The results were interpreted using the guidelines described by the CLSI (2016) standards. Multidrug resistance was defined by nonsusceptibility to at least one agent in three or more antimicrobial categories as described earlier by Magiorakoset al. [18].


### 2.6. Quality Assurance

The training was provided to data collectors on how to perform the questionnaire and sampling processing. The filled questionnaires were checked for their completeness. Media preparations were made based on the manufacturer’s instruction. Quality control slides were incorporated during Gram staining. Standard operating procedures were followed during specimen collection, handling, transportation, microbiological analysis, and interpretation. Five percent of media per batch were incubated overnight for sterility check. Reference strainsS. aureusATCC25923,E. coli ATCC25922, andP. aeruginosaATCC27853 were used during cultivation and antimicrobial susceptibility testing [16].


### 2.7. Statistical Analysis

Data was analyzed using SPSS version 22, and descriptive statistics, bivariate, and multivariate logistic regression were employed. A bivariate logistic regression model was used to determine the possible association of each variable with the outcome variable and multivariate analysis was done to those independent variables with p-value < 0.05 to identify factors that are independently associated with the dependent variable. P-value <0.05 with 95% confidence interval was considered as statistically significant.


## 2.1. Study Design, Specimen Collection, and Transportation

A multicentre cross-sectional study was conducted from August-December 2016 at different ART clinics of Mekelle zone, Tigray, Ethiopia. A total of 252 HIV patients with suspected pneumonia were included in the study based on the inclusion/exclusion criteria. Sociodemographic, clinical, and risk-factor related data were collected using a structured and pretested questionnaire. Pneumonia suspected individuals showing clinical symptoms such as shortness of breath, chest pain, fever, chills, tiredness, and cough were examined by clinicians and the sputum samples were collected and transported to medical microbiology laboratory, Mekelle University, College of Health Sciences by medical laboratory technologists for analysis within 2 hrs or stored at 4°C until further processing.


## 2.2. Inclusion and Exclusion Criteria

HIV seropositive, highly active antiretroviral therapy users and nonusers aged ≥ 18 with a diagnosis of pneumonia as described by the clinician were included. Patients who were critically ill, who cannot produce sputum, suspected pulmonary tuberculosis and who took antibiotics during the past two week period were excluded.


## 2.3. Specimen Processing

Smear was prepared from each sputum sample for Gram staining and slides were examined under low power field (l0X). Sputum samples with > 25 polymorphonuclear leukocytes and <10 epithelial cells were accepted for culture. Samples that had more than 10 epithelial cells and less than 25 polymorphonuclear leukocytes per low power field were discarded [15, 16].


## 2.4. Cultivation and Identification of Isolates

Blood, Chocolate, and Mac Conkey agar plates (Oxoid, Hampshire, UK) were prepared as per the manufacturers’ instructions. Using a calibrated wire loop, approximately 0.1μL purulent sputum sample was streaked onto each agar plate. Chocolate agar plates were incubated at 37°C for 24 hours in a candle jar. MacConkey agar and blood agar plates were incubated aerobically at 37°C for 24 hours [15, 16]. After incubation, the plates were inspected for any growth and negative plates were incubated for an additional 24 hours. Quantitative sputum culture analysis was carried out and the significant bacterial count was reported on observing an excess of 106 CFU/mL [17]. More than 100 CFU were considered significant for bacterial growth in this study. A single pure culture colony of each isolate was stored in nutrient broth with 10% glycerol stock solution for identification. Gram-positive cocci were differentiated and identified based on Gram stain, patterns of hemolysis on blood agar, colonial characteristics, catalase test, coagulase test, optochin susceptibility, and bacitracin susceptibility. Gram-negative bacteria were also identified based on Gram stain, colonial morphology and pigmentation, oxidase test, carbohydrate fermentation, H2S production, citrate utilization, motility, indole formation, urea hydrolysis and growth in blood agar with “X”, and “V” factors forH. influenzae.


## 2.5. Antimicrobial Susceptibility Testing

The antimicrobial susceptibility test was performed using the Kirby-Bauer disc diffusion test method [16]. The antimicrobial discs used for susceptibility testing were amikacin (AK,30μg), ciprofloxacin (CIP,5μg), ceftriaxone (CTR,30μg), chloramphenicol (C,10μg),co-trimoxazole (COT,25μg), erythromycin (ERY,15μg), gentamicin (GN,10μg), Methicillin (MET, 30μg)penicillin (P,10 units), and tetracycline (TE,30μg). Muller-Hinton agar (MHA) plates were used for the nonfastidious organism, whereas MHA supplemented with 5% sheep blood were used forS. pneumoniaeandHaemophilus spp. using a standard procedure [16]. The results were interpreted using the guidelines described by the CLSI (2016) standards. Multidrug resistance was defined by nonsusceptibility to at least one agent in three or more antimicrobial categories as described earlier by Magiorakoset al. [18].


## 2.6. Quality Assurance

The training was provided to data collectors on how to perform the questionnaire and sampling processing. The filled questionnaires were checked for their completeness. Media preparations were made based on the manufacturer’s instruction. Quality control slides were incorporated during Gram staining. Standard operating procedures were followed during specimen collection, handling, transportation, microbiological analysis, and interpretation. Five percent of media per batch were incubated overnight for sterility check. Reference strainsS. aureusATCC25923,E. coli ATCC25922, andP. aeruginosaATCC27853 were used during cultivation and antimicrobial susceptibility testing [16].


## 2.7. Statistical Analysis

Data was analyzed using SPSS version 22, and descriptive statistics, bivariate, and multivariate logistic regression were employed. A bivariate logistic regression model was used to determine the possible association of each variable with the outcome variable and multivariate analysis was done to those independent variables with p-value < 0.05 to identify factors that are independently associated with the dependent variable. P-value <0.05 with 95% confidence interval was considered as statistically significant.


## 3. Results

### 3.1. Sociodemographic Characteristics

This study was conducted among 252 study participants. Out of 224 (88.9%) were urban dwellers and 28 (11.1%) were rural dwellers. The mean age of study participants was 40.58 ± 9.9, range 18-67 years old, and 50% being male and the rest female (Table1).Table 1
Sociodemographic characteristics of the study participants in ART clinics of Mekelle zone, Tigray, Northern Ethiopia, August 2016-December 2016 (n=252).
Variables Frequency Percent (%)  Gender Male 127 50.4 Female 125 49.6 Age (in years) 18-29 30 11.9 30-39 98 38.9 40-49 75 29.8 50-67 49 19.4 Residence Urban 224 88.9 Rural 28 11.1 Occupation Farmer 19 7.5 Employed 78 31 Unemployed 110 43.6 Self-employed 45 17.9 Educational level Illiterate 42 16.7 Read and write 33 13.1 1-8 80 31.7 9-12 59 23.4 College and above 38 15.1


### 3.2. Prevalence of Bacterial Pneumonia

Bacterial pneumonia was observed in 110 (43.7 %) and out of those 59 (46.6 %) of them were male participants (Table2). Bacterial pneumonia was found highest in age group 18-29 (n=15, 50 %) and lowest in the age group 50-67, 14 (28.6%). Out of the 110 isolates, 95 (42.4 %) were isolated from urban dwellers. The predominant bacterial species wereKlebsiella pneumoniae (n=26, 23.6 %) followed byStreptococcus pneumoniae (n=17, 15.5 %),Escherichia coli (n=16, 14.5%),Klebsiellaspp. (n=15, 13.6%), Staphylococcus aureus(n=9, 8.2%),Enterobacter spp. (n=7, 6.3%),Pseudomonas aeruginosa(4, n=3.6%),Proteus spp. (n=4, 3.6%),Citrobacter freundii (n=7, 6.3%),Streptococcus pyogenes(3, 2.7%), andHaemophilus influenzae(n=2, 1.8%).Table 2
Rate of bacterial pneumonia with regard to the sociodemographic characteristics among pneumonia suspected HIV patients in ART clinics of Mekelle zone, Northern Ethiopia, August 2016-December 2016.
Variables Bacterial occurrence Total Positive N (%) Negative N (%)  Gender Male 59 (46.6) 68 (53.5) 127 Female 51 (40.8) 74(59.2) 125 Age (in years) 18-29 15 (50) 15 (50) 30 30-39 47 (48) 51 (52) 98 40-49 34 (45.3) 41 (54.7) 75 50-67 14 (28.6) 35 (71.4) 49 Residence Urban 95 (42.4) 129 (57.6) 224 Rural 15 (53.6) 13 (46.4) 28 Occupation Farmer 9 (47.4) 10 (52.6) 19 Employed 32 (41) 46 (59) 78 Unemployed 46 (41.8) 64 (58.2) 110 Self-employed 23 (51.1) 22 (48.9) 45 Educational level Illiterate 14 (33.3) 28 (66.7) 42 Read and write 10 (30.3) 23 (69.7) 33 1-8 37 (46.3) 43 (53.7) 80 9-12 30 (50.8) 29 (49.2) 59 College and above 19 (50) 19 (50) 38


### 3.3. Antimicrobial Susceptibility Pattern of Bacterial Isolates

Out of the tested antibiotics, 39.8% (n=40 isolates) were resistant to co-trimoxazole and 24.5% (n=26) for tetracycline. In this study, 81.8% (n=9) Gram-positive isolates and 27.6% (n=8) were resistant to penicillin and erythromycin, respectively (Table3). Similarly, 10.7% (n=8) of Gram-negative isolates were resistant to ceftriaxone (Table 3). On the other hand, most of the isolates were less resistant to amikacin (n=6, 6.8%) and ciprofloxacin (n=8, 9.1%). Methicillin resistance was observed in 44.4% (n=4) isolates ofS. aureus(Table 3). Multidrug resistance was observed in 18% (n=15) of isolates (Table 4).Table 3
Antimicrobial susceptibility patterns of bacterial isolates among pneumonia suspected HIV patients in ART clinics of Mekelle zone, Northern Ethiopia, August-December 2016.
Isolates(n)  Antibiotics GN AK CTR P CIP COT ERY C TE MET  S. pneumoniae (17) S NT NT NT NT NT 6(35.3) 11(64.7) 14(82.4) 10(58.8) NT R      11(64.7) 6(35.3) 3(17.6) 7(41.2) S. aureus(9) S 8(88.9) 9(100) NT 2(22.2) 8(88.9) 6(66.7) 7(77.8) 9(1000 7(77.8) 5(55.6) R 1(11.1) 0  7(77.8) 1(11.1) 3(33.3) 2(22.2) 0 2(22.2) 4(44.4) S. pyogenes(3) S NT NT NT 1(33.3) NT 3(100) NT 1(33.3) 0 NT R    2(66.7)  0  2(66.7) 3(100) K. pneumoniae(26) S 21(80.8) 23(88.5) 24(92.3) NT 26(100) 15(57.7) NT 23(88.5) 19(73.1) NT R 5(19.2) 3(11.5) 2(7.7)  0 11(42.3)  3(11.5) 7(26.9) E. coli(16) S 14(87.5) 15(93.8) 13(81.3) NT 14(87.5) 10(62.5) NT 16(100) 15(93.8) NT R 2(12.5) 1(6.2) 3(18.7)  2(12.5) 6(37.5)  0 1(6.2) Klebsiellaspp. (15) S 14(93.3) 14(93.3) 14(93.3) NT 14(93.3) 14(93.3) NT 15(100) 14(93.3) NT R 1(6.7) 1(6.7) 1(6.7)  1(6.7) 1(6.7)  0 1(6.7) Enterobacterspp.(7) S 7(100) 7(100) 7(100) NT 3(42.9) 3(42.9) NT 3(42.9) 7(100) NT R 0 0 0  4(57.1) 4(57.1)  4(57.1) 0 Proteusspp.(4) S 4(100) 3(75) 4(100) NT 4(100) 4(100) NT 3(75) 3(75) NT R 0 1(25) 0  0 0  1(25) 1(25) Citrobacter freundii(7) S 7(100) 7(100) 5(71.4) NT 7(100) 5(71.4) NT 5(71.4) 5(71.4) NT R 0 0 2(28.6)  0 2(28.6)  2(28.6) 2(28.6) P. aeruginosa(4) S 3(75) 4(100) NT NT 4(100) NT NT NT NT NT R 1(25) 0   0 H. influenzae(2) S NT NT NT NT NT 0 NT 2(100) 0 NT R      2(100)  0 2(100) Total n (%) S 78(88.6) 82(93.2) 67(89.3) 3(27.2) 80(90.9) 62(60.8) 21(72.4) 91(85.8) 80(75.5) 5(55.6) R 10(11.4) 6(6.8) 8(10.7) 9(81.8) 8(9.1) 40(39.8) 8(27.6) 15(14.2) 26(24.5) 4(44.4) NT= not tested,Klebsiella spp. =other Klebsiella species.P = penicillin, CTR= ceftriaxone, GN = gentamicin, AK= amikacin, COT= co-trimoxazole, TE = tetracycline, C = chloramphenicol, CIP = ciprofloxacin, MET= methicillin, ERY= erythromycin, S= susceptible, and R= resistant. % is computed from each cell. Total= total calculated from both Gram negative and positive isolates for that specific antibiotics were tested.Table 4
Multidrug resistance patterns of bacterial pneumonia from pneumonia suspected HIV patients in ART clinics of Mekelle zone, Northern Ethiopia, August-December 2016.
Bacterial Isolates Antibiotics Total Ro R1 R2 R3 ≥ R4 MDR  K. pneumoniae 9(34.6) 7(30) 8(30.8) 1(3.8) 1(3.8) 2(7.7) 26(100) E. coli 9(56.3) 3(18.7) 2(12.5) 0(.00) 2(12.5) 2(12.5) 16(100) Klebsiella spp. 13(86.6) 1(6.7) 0(.00) 0(.00) 1(6.7) 1(6.7) 15(100) Citrobacter freundii 4(57.1) 1(14.3) 0(.00) 1(14.3) 1(14.3) 2(28.6) 7(100) Enterobacter spp. 3(42.9) 0(.00) 0(.00) 4(57.1) 0(.00) 4(57.1) 7(100) Proteus spp. 2(50) 1(25) 1(25) 0(.00) 0(.00) 0(.00) 4(100) P. aeruginosa 3(75) 1(25) 0(.00) 0(.00) 0(.00) NA 4(100) H. influenzae 0(.00) 2(100) 0(.00) 0(.00) 0(.00) NA 2(100) S. pneumoniae 2(11.8) 4(23.5) 10(58.8) 1(5.9) 0(.00) NA 17(100) S. aureus 3(33.4) 1(11.1) 2(22.2) 1(11.1) 2(22.2) 4(44.4)a 9(100) S. pyogenes 0(.00) 0(.00) 2(66.7) 1(33.3) 0(.00) NA 3(100)  Total 48(43.6) 21(19.1) 25(22.7) 9(8.2) 7(6.4) 15(17.9)b 110(100) R0: susceptible to all, R1: resistance to one, R2: resistance to two, R3: resistance to three, and ≥ R4: resistance to four and more antibiotics. MDR= multidrug resistance.Percenta is computed from the total number of S. aureus;percentb is computed from a total number of isolates, based on which MDR definition is applied.


### 3.4. Associated Risk Factors

All variables with a significance value in the bivariate analysis were entered in to multiple logistic regression model and in multivariate analysis the variables age groups 18-29 (AOR = 3.8, 95 % CI: 1.25-11.52, P ≤ 0.018), age groups 30-39 (AOR = 3.4, 95% CI: 1.37-8.25, P ≤ 0.008), recent number of CD4+ cell count less than 350 (AOR = 2.4, 95 % CI:1.11-5.09, P≤ 0.026), alcohol consumption (AOR= 7.4, 95 % CI: 2.46-22.11, P ≤ 0.001), and WHO stage of II HIV infection (AOR= 5.4, 95 % CI: 2.00-14.36, P ≤ 0.001) were found to have statistically significant association with bacterial pneumonia. In the bivariate analysis, gender and occupation failed to show a significant association with the occurrence of bacterial pneumonia. Although not statistically significant, bacterial pneumonia was higher in cigarette smokers, in non-cART users, and in those who interrupt cART (Table5).Table 5
Bivariate and multivariate logistic regression analysis of factors associated with bacterial pneumonia in pneumonia suspected HIV patients in ART clinics of Mekelle zone, Northern Ethiopia, August-December 2016.
Variables Bacterial pneumonia COR (95% CI) P-value AOR (95% CI) P-value Positive Negative N (%) N (%)  Gender Male 59 (46.6) 68 (53.5) 1.3 (0.76-2.07) 0.366 Female 51 (40.8) 74 (59.2) 1 Age (in years) 18-29 15 (50) 15 (50) 2.5 (0.97-6.44) ∗ 0.058 3.8 (1.25-11.52) ∗ 0.018 30-39 47 (48) 51 (52) 2.3 (1.10-4.81) ∗ 0.026 3.4 (1.37-8.25) ∗ 0.008 40-49 34 (45.3) 41 (54.7) 2.1 (0.96-4.47) 0.063 2.0 (0.81-5.06) 0.132 50-67 14 (28.6) 35 (71.4) 1  1 Occupation Employed 32 (41) 46 (59) 1 Farmer 9 (47.4) 10 (52.6) 1.1 (0.35-3.72) 0.825 Unemployed 46 (40) 64 (60) 0.9 (0.30-2.66) 0.849 Self-employed 23 (51.1) 22 (48.9) 0.6 (0.31-1.35) 0.248 Recent CD4+ cells/μl <350 56 (57.7) 41 (42.3) 3.3 (1.7-6.34) ∗ 0.001 2.4 (1.11-5.09)∗ 0.026 350-500 34 (39.1) 53 (60.9) 1.5 (0.78-3.03) 0.211 1.2 (0.54-2.58) 0.686 >500 20 (29.4) 48 (70.6) 1  1 Cigarette smoking Yes 13 (65) 7 (35) 2.6 (0.99-6.72) 0.051 1.6 (0.44-5.50) 0.488 No 97 (41.8) 135 (58.2) 1  1 Use cART Yes 100 (41.8) 139 (58.2) 1  1 No 10 (76.9) 3 (23.1) 4.6 (1.24-17.27) 0.022 0.00 1.000 Ever interrupt cART Yes 16 (69.6) 7 (30.4) 3.6 (1.43-9.17) ∗ 0.007 2.5 (0.87-7.23) 0.090 No 84 (38.7) 133 (61.3) 1  1 Alcohol consumption Yes 22 (81.5) 5 (18.5) 6.9 (2.5-18.76) ∗ 0.001 7.4 (2.46-22.11)∗ 0.001 No 88 (39.1) 137 (60.9) 1  1 WHO Stage I 80 (38.6) 127 (61.4) 1  1 II 22 (75.9) 7 (24.1) 5.0 (2.04-12.22)∗ 0.001 5.4 (2.00-14.36)∗ 0.001 III 8 (50) 8 (50) 1.6 (0.57-4.40) 0.374 0.5 (0.13-1.97) 0.329 COR=crude odds ratio; CI=confidence interval; AOR=adjusted odds ratio; 1: referent; ∗statically significant.


## 3.1. Sociodemographic Characteristics

This study was conducted among 252 study participants. Out of 224 (88.9%) were urban dwellers and 28 (11.1%) were rural dwellers. The mean age of study participants was 40.58 ± 9.9, range 18-67 years old, and 50% being male and the rest female (Table1).Table 1
Sociodemographic characteristics of the study participants in ART clinics of Mekelle zone, Tigray, Northern Ethiopia, August 2016-December 2016 (n=252).
Variables Frequency Percent (%)  Gender Male 127 50.4 Female 125 49.6 Age (in years) 18-29 30 11.9 30-39 98 38.9 40-49 75 29.8 50-67 49 19.4 Residence Urban 224 88.9 Rural 28 11.1 Occupation Farmer 19 7.5 Employed 78 31 Unemployed 110 43.6 Self-employed 45 17.9 Educational level Illiterate 42 16.7 Read and write 33 13.1 1-8 80 31.7 9-12 59 23.4 College and above 38 15.1


## 3.2. Prevalence of Bacterial Pneumonia

Bacterial pneumonia was observed in 110 (43.7 %) and out of those 59 (46.6 %) of them were male participants (Table2). Bacterial pneumonia was found highest in age group 18-29 (n=15, 50 %) and lowest in the age group 50-67, 14 (28.6%). Out of the 110 isolates, 95 (42.4 %) were isolated from urban dwellers. The predominant bacterial species wereKlebsiella pneumoniae (n=26, 23.6 %) followed byStreptococcus pneumoniae (n=17, 15.5 %),Escherichia coli (n=16, 14.5%),Klebsiellaspp. (n=15, 13.6%), Staphylococcus aureus(n=9, 8.2%),Enterobacter spp. (n=7, 6.3%),Pseudomonas aeruginosa(4, n=3.6%),Proteus spp. (n=4, 3.6%),Citrobacter freundii (n=7, 6.3%),Streptococcus pyogenes(3, 2.7%), andHaemophilus influenzae(n=2, 1.8%).Table 2
Rate of bacterial pneumonia with regard to the sociodemographic characteristics among pneumonia suspected HIV patients in ART clinics of Mekelle zone, Northern Ethiopia, August 2016-December 2016.
Variables Bacterial occurrence Total Positive N (%) Negative N (%)  Gender Male 59 (46.6) 68 (53.5) 127 Female 51 (40.8) 74(59.2) 125 Age (in years) 18-29 15 (50) 15 (50) 30 30-39 47 (48) 51 (52) 98 40-49 34 (45.3) 41 (54.7) 75 50-67 14 (28.6) 35 (71.4) 49 Residence Urban 95 (42.4) 129 (57.6) 224 Rural 15 (53.6) 13 (46.4) 28 Occupation Farmer 9 (47.4) 10 (52.6) 19 Employed 32 (41) 46 (59) 78 Unemployed 46 (41.8) 64 (58.2) 110 Self-employed 23 (51.1) 22 (48.9) 45 Educational level Illiterate 14 (33.3) 28 (66.7) 42 Read and write 10 (30.3) 23 (69.7) 33 1-8 37 (46.3) 43 (53.7) 80 9-12 30 (50.8) 29 (49.2) 59 College and above 19 (50) 19 (50) 38


## 3.3. Antimicrobial Susceptibility Pattern of Bacterial Isolates

Out of the tested antibiotics, 39.8% (n=40 isolates) were resistant to co-trimoxazole and 24.5% (n=26) for tetracycline. In this study, 81.8% (n=9) Gram-positive isolates and 27.6% (n=8) were resistant to penicillin and erythromycin, respectively (Table3). Similarly, 10.7% (n=8) of Gram-negative isolates were resistant to ceftriaxone (Table 3). On the other hand, most of the isolates were less resistant to amikacin (n=6, 6.8%) and ciprofloxacin (n=8, 9.1%). Methicillin resistance was observed in 44.4% (n=4) isolates ofS. aureus(Table 3). Multidrug resistance was observed in 18% (n=15) of isolates (Table 4).Table 3
Antimicrobial susceptibility patterns of bacterial isolates among pneumonia suspected HIV patients in ART clinics of Mekelle zone, Northern Ethiopia, August-December 2016.
Isolates(n)  Antibiotics GN AK CTR P CIP COT ERY C TE MET  S. pneumoniae (17) S NT NT NT NT NT 6(35.3) 11(64.7) 14(82.4) 10(58.8) NT R      11(64.7) 6(35.3) 3(17.6) 7(41.2) S. aureus(9) S 8(88.9) 9(100) NT 2(22.2) 8(88.9) 6(66.7) 7(77.8) 9(1000 7(77.8) 5(55.6) R 1(11.1) 0  7(77.8) 1(11.1) 3(33.3) 2(22.2) 0 2(22.2) 4(44.4) S. pyogenes(3) S NT NT NT 1(33.3) NT 3(100) NT 1(33.3) 0 NT R    2(66.7)  0  2(66.7) 3(100) K. pneumoniae(26) S 21(80.8) 23(88.5) 24(92.3) NT 26(100) 15(57.7) NT 23(88.5) 19(73.1) NT R 5(19.2) 3(11.5) 2(7.7)  0 11(42.3)  3(11.5) 7(26.9) E. coli(16) S 14(87.5) 15(93.8) 13(81.3) NT 14(87.5) 10(62.5) NT 16(100) 15(93.8) NT R 2(12.5) 1(6.2) 3(18.7)  2(12.5) 6(37.5)  0 1(6.2) Klebsiellaspp. (15) S 14(93.3) 14(93.3) 14(93.3) NT 14(93.3) 14(93.3) NT 15(100) 14(93.3) NT R 1(6.7) 1(6.7) 1(6.7)  1(6.7) 1(6.7)  0 1(6.7) Enterobacterspp.(7) S 7(100) 7(100) 7(100) NT 3(42.9) 3(42.9) NT 3(42.9) 7(100) NT R 0 0 0  4(57.1) 4(57.1)  4(57.1) 0 Proteusspp.(4) S 4(100) 3(75) 4(100) NT 4(100) 4(100) NT 3(75) 3(75) NT R 0 1(25) 0  0 0  1(25) 1(25) Citrobacter freundii(7) S 7(100) 7(100) 5(71.4) NT 7(100) 5(71.4) NT 5(71.4) 5(71.4) NT R 0 0 2(28.6)  0 2(28.6)  2(28.6) 2(28.6) P. aeruginosa(4) S 3(75) 4(100) NT NT 4(100) NT NT NT NT NT R 1(25) 0   0 H. influenzae(2) S NT NT NT NT NT 0 NT 2(100) 0 NT R      2(100)  0 2(100) Total n (%) S 78(88.6) 82(93.2) 67(89.3) 3(27.2) 80(90.9) 62(60.8) 21(72.4) 91(85.8) 80(75.5) 5(55.6) R 10(11.4) 6(6.8) 8(10.7) 9(81.8) 8(9.1) 40(39.8) 8(27.6) 15(14.2) 26(24.5) 4(44.4) NT= not tested,Klebsiella spp. =other Klebsiella species.P = penicillin, CTR= ceftriaxone, GN = gentamicin, AK= amikacin, COT= co-trimoxazole, TE = tetracycline, C = chloramphenicol, CIP = ciprofloxacin, MET= methicillin, ERY= erythromycin, S= susceptible, and R= resistant. % is computed from each cell. Total= total calculated from both Gram negative and positive isolates for that specific antibiotics were tested.Table 4
Multidrug resistance patterns of bacterial pneumonia from pneumonia suspected HIV patients in ART clinics of Mekelle zone, Northern Ethiopia, August-December 2016.
Bacterial Isolates Antibiotics Total Ro R1 R2 R3 ≥ R4 MDR  K. pneumoniae 9(34.6) 7(30) 8(30.8) 1(3.8) 1(3.8) 2(7.7) 26(100) E. coli 9(56.3) 3(18.7) 2(12.5) 0(.00) 2(12.5) 2(12.5) 16(100) Klebsiella spp. 13(86.6) 1(6.7) 0(.00) 0(.00) 1(6.7) 1(6.7) 15(100) Citrobacter freundii 4(57.1) 1(14.3) 0(.00) 1(14.3) 1(14.3) 2(28.6) 7(100) Enterobacter spp. 3(42.9) 0(.00) 0(.00) 4(57.1) 0(.00) 4(57.1) 7(100) Proteus spp. 2(50) 1(25) 1(25) 0(.00) 0(.00) 0(.00) 4(100) P. aeruginosa 3(75) 1(25) 0(.00) 0(.00) 0(.00) NA 4(100) H. influenzae 0(.00) 2(100) 0(.00) 0(.00) 0(.00) NA 2(100) S. pneumoniae 2(11.8) 4(23.5) 10(58.8) 1(5.9) 0(.00) NA 17(100) S. aureus 3(33.4) 1(11.1) 2(22.2) 1(11.1) 2(22.2) 4(44.4)a 9(100) S. pyogenes 0(.00) 0(.00) 2(66.7) 1(33.3) 0(.00) NA 3(100)  Total 48(43.6) 21(19.1) 25(22.7) 9(8.2) 7(6.4) 15(17.9)b 110(100) R0: susceptible to all, R1: resistance to one, R2: resistance to two, R3: resistance to three, and ≥ R4: resistance to four and more antibiotics. MDR= multidrug resistance.Percenta is computed from the total number of S. aureus;percentb is computed from a total number of isolates, based on which MDR definition is applied.


## 3.4. Associated Risk Factors

All variables with a significance value in the bivariate analysis were entered in to multiple logistic regression model and in multivariate analysis the variables age groups 18-29 (AOR = 3.8, 95 % CI: 1.25-11.52, P ≤ 0.018), age groups 30-39 (AOR = 3.4, 95% CI: 1.37-8.25, P ≤ 0.008), recent number of CD4+ cell count less than 350 (AOR = 2.4, 95 % CI:1.11-5.09, P≤ 0.026), alcohol consumption (AOR= 7.4, 95 % CI: 2.46-22.11, P ≤ 0.001), and WHO stage of II HIV infection (AOR= 5.4, 95 % CI: 2.00-14.36, P ≤ 0.001) were found to have statistically significant association with bacterial pneumonia. In the bivariate analysis, gender and occupation failed to show a significant association with the occurrence of bacterial pneumonia. Although not statistically significant, bacterial pneumonia was higher in cigarette smokers, in non-cART users, and in those who interrupt cART (Table5).Table 5
Bivariate and multivariate logistic regression analysis of factors associated with bacterial pneumonia in pneumonia suspected HIV patients in ART clinics of Mekelle zone, Northern Ethiopia, August-December 2016.
Variables Bacterial pneumonia COR (95% CI) P-value AOR (95% CI) P-value Positive Negative N (%) N (%)  Gender Male 59 (46.6) 68 (53.5) 1.3 (0.76-2.07) 0.366 Female 51 (40.8) 74 (59.2) 1 Age (in years) 18-29 15 (50) 15 (50) 2.5 (0.97-6.44) ∗ 0.058 3.8 (1.25-11.52) ∗ 0.018 30-39 47 (48) 51 (52) 2.3 (1.10-4.81) ∗ 0.026 3.4 (1.37-8.25) ∗ 0.008 40-49 34 (45.3) 41 (54.7) 2.1 (0.96-4.47) 0.063 2.0 (0.81-5.06) 0.132 50-67 14 (28.6) 35 (71.4) 1  1 Occupation Employed 32 (41) 46 (59) 1 Farmer 9 (47.4) 10 (52.6) 1.1 (0.35-3.72) 0.825 Unemployed 46 (40) 64 (60) 0.9 (0.30-2.66) 0.849 Self-employed 23 (51.1) 22 (48.9) 0.6 (0.31-1.35) 0.248 Recent CD4+ cells/μl <350 56 (57.7) 41 (42.3) 3.3 (1.7-6.34) ∗ 0.001 2.4 (1.11-5.09)∗ 0.026 350-500 34 (39.1) 53 (60.9) 1.5 (0.78-3.03) 0.211 1.2 (0.54-2.58) 0.686 >500 20 (29.4) 48 (70.6) 1  1 Cigarette smoking Yes 13 (65) 7 (35) 2.6 (0.99-6.72) 0.051 1.6 (0.44-5.50) 0.488 No 97 (41.8) 135 (58.2) 1  1 Use cART Yes 100 (41.8) 139 (58.2) 1  1 No 10 (76.9) 3 (23.1) 4.6 (1.24-17.27) 0.022 0.00 1.000 Ever interrupt cART Yes 16 (69.6) 7 (30.4) 3.6 (1.43-9.17) ∗ 0.007 2.5 (0.87-7.23) 0.090 No 84 (38.7) 133 (61.3) 1  1 Alcohol consumption Yes 22 (81.5) 5 (18.5) 6.9 (2.5-18.76) ∗ 0.001 7.4 (2.46-22.11)∗ 0.001 No 88 (39.1) 137 (60.9) 1  1 WHO Stage I 80 (38.6) 127 (61.4) 1  1 II 22 (75.9) 7 (24.1) 5.0 (2.04-12.22)∗ 0.001 5.4 (2.00-14.36)∗ 0.001 III 8 (50) 8 (50) 1.6 (0.57-4.40) 0.374 0.5 (0.13-1.97) 0.329 COR=crude odds ratio; CI=confidence interval; AOR=adjusted odds ratio; 1: referent; ∗statically significant.


## 4. Discussion

In this study, the overall prevalence of bacterial pneumonia was found to be 43.7%. This is in line with the studies reported from Nigeria 42.9 % [19] and India 44.3 % [20]. This is due to the fact that individuals with compromised immune status are more susceptible to bacterial infections. On the other hand, our finding is higher than the findings from Malawi 29 % [13] and India 18.4 % [21] and lower than the study reported from Nigeria 55.6% [9]. The inconsistency may be due to sampling size variation, type of sample used, and immune status of the study participants.In our study,K. pneumoniaeandS. pneumoniaewere the predominant pathogens isolated as reported in similar studies from Nepal [22, 23] and India [20]. On the other hand, different predominant isolates, such asE. coli andP. aeruginosa were reported from Nigeria [9] whileS. pneumoniaeandH. influenzaewere reported from Uganda as dominant bacterial species [24]. A climatic and geographic variation could be the possible reasons for the different frequency of the bacterial isolates in different study area among HIV patients.E. coliwas the second most common Gram-negative bacterium to be isolated in our study; which in agreement with the study reported from Bahrain [25] and Nigeria [9]. Among the Gram-positivesS. aureus was the second most common species to be isolated; this is consistent with a study reported from the United States [26], Italy [27], and Greece [28]. The occurrence might be due to aspiration of the bacteria from the previously colonized site, prior hospitalization, contaminated foods eaten, and mostly systemic spread from blood to the lungs in these patients [26–28].WHO recommends co-trimoxazole as an intervention to reduce infections by opportunistic pathogens including bacterial pneumonia in HIV positive patients. In this study, about 39.8% and 24.5% of bacterial isolates were resistant to co-trimoxazole and tetracycline. This is similar to the study reported in Nigeria [9] and Tanzania [20]. This may be due to the consistent use of this antibiotic, which might contribute to the development of drug resistance. Out of the tested Gram-positive isolates, 81.8 % and 27.6 % were resistant to penicillin and erythromycin respectively. This might be because these antibiotics have been very commonly prescribed for many years during the course of infection.According to the international standard for the definition of drug resistance [18], 17.9% isolates were multidrug resistant. We did not have data from our study participants engaging in self-medication but empirical treatment still is a contributing factor for the emergence of drug resistance in these patients [9, 29]. Out of theS. aureusisolates, 44.4 % were methicillin resistance but because the sample size was low these results may not be significant. This is higher from the study reported from Bahrain, 10.5 % [25], and lower from Italy, 65% [27]In this study, age groups 18-29 and 30-39, alcohol consumption, recent CD4+ count less than 350 cells/μL, and WHO stage II of HIV infection showed significant association to have bacterial pneumonia. Age groups, 18-29 and 30-39, were 3.8 and 3.4 times more likely to have bacterial pneumonia, respectively, compared to the age group, 50-67 which is in agreement with studies reported from Nigeria [9] and Nepal [22]. The reason may be due to the fact that a large number of younger age groups of our study participants were within CD4+ cell count less than 350 cells/μL and WHO stage II compared to those aged between 50 and 67. This can contribute to increased bacterial pneumonia observed in our study participants. On the contrary, the studies reported in Spain [2], Netherlands [30], and France [31] bacterial pneumonia is also common in older age groups. The immune status, place of living, diet, deprivation, and affluence are some of the factors which may play a role in influencing the level of illness in a given population.Alcohol consumption is one of the potential risk factors identified, though our study did not identify the level of consumption; alcohol consumers were 7.4 times more likely to have bacterial pneumonia [32]. This may be due to the fact that alcohol consumers are prone to more oropharyngeal secretions due to alteration of their level of consciousness. Alcohol also has an effect on depressing cough, decreasing endothelial adherence, lowering chemotaxis, suppressing B and T-cell expansion, and function which contributes to poor clearance mechanism of lung cells which is in line with the studies reported from South Africa [32], Europe [33], and western North America [34].In this study, recently low CD4+ cell count was the other risk factor identified and individuals with recent CD4+ cell count less than 350 cells/μL were 2.4 times more likely to have bacterial pneumonia compared to those who had CD4+cell counts ≥ 500 cells/μL, consistent with the study reported from United States [10] and France [31]. WHO stage II of HIV infection is the other risk factor and these individuals were 5.4 times more likely to have bacterial pneumonia compared to those WHO stage I individuals. In addition to this, even though WHO stage III was not significantly associated, the probability of getting bacterial pneumonia is still higher in these patients comparing to WHO stage I. This might be related to unprogrammed activation of the immune system due to recurrent infections which contribute to damage of immune cells and the physical barriers of our respiratory mucosal membrane and simply make susceptible to different opportunistic infections [6].In this study, although not statistically significant, bacterial pneumonia was higher among cigarette smokers. Smoking lowers the action and number of cilia and inhibits the ability to prevent the entry of microorganisms to the respiratory tract. This is supported by studies reported earlier which indicate cigarette smoking increases the risk of bacterial pneumonia two times compared to nonsmokers [35].


## 5. Conclusions

In this study, the prevalence of bacterial pneumonia was 43.7 % caused majorly by Gram-negative bacterial species such asK. pneumoniae andE. coli. In Gram-positive isolates,S. pneumoniae andS. aureuswere the most dominant species of bacteria. Most isolates were susceptible to amikacin, ciprofloxacin, and ceftriaxone. Younger age group, the recent number of CD4+ cell count less than 350 cells, alcohol consumption, and WHO stage II of HIV infection showed significant association with bacterial pneumonia. Identification of the etiological agent and performing antimicrobial susceptibility testing in order to select an appropriate antimicrobial agent will be important in the management of bacterial pneumonia and limiting the evolution of resistant bacteria in the clinical setting.



---

*Source: 8768439-2019-05-05.xml*