# Extraction of Clinical Indicators That Are Associated with the Heat/Nonheat and Excess/Deficiency Patterns in Pattern Identifications for Stroke

Authors: Ju Ah Lee; Mi Mi Ko; Jungsup Lee; Byoung-Kab Kang; Terje Alraek; Stephen Birch; Myeong Soo Lee
Journal: Evidence-Based Complementary and Alternative Medicine
 (2015)

---

## Abstract

The aim of this study is to extract indicators that are associated with the heat/nonheat and excess/deficiency patterns in stroke pattern identification through the large-scale analysis of clinical data. Two experts, who had more than three years of clinical experience with stroke, independently performed the pattern identification. We analyzed indicators of clinical data with two doctors’ concurrent diagnoses on the patient’s pattern identification. To verify heat/nonheat and excess/deficiency patterns, which are the basic elements of pattern identification, we grouped 960 patients diagnosed as the fire-heat pattern, the Yin deficiency pattern, and the Qi deficiency pattern in to two groups, the heat/nonheat group and the excess/deficiency group. We then extracted significant indicators using univariate and multivariate analysis. As a result of the comparison of 65 indicators, we were able to extract 10 indicators for the heat pattern, 6 for the nonheat pattern, 9 for the excess pattern, and 10 for the deficiency pattern. Extracted indicators in this study can be used for pattern identification in the context of stroke. These are positive indicators from large-scale clinical studies and are greatly expected to be crucial discriminant indicators in individual pattern identification henceforth.


---

## Body

## 1. Introduction

In Korea, many stroke patients receive traditional medical care because the country has its own system of traditional alternative medicine called traditional Korean medicine (TKM), the role of which has been emphasized in stroke management [1]. In TKM and traditional Chinese medicine (TCM), disease is defined as a condition with collapsed equilibrium. TKM doctors make it a rule to restore the imbalance to treat diseases. Pattern identification, a unique diagnostic system of TKM and TCM [2], is the process of overall analysis of clinical data to determine the location, cause, and nature of a patient’s disease with an integrative viewpoint that involves the etiology, pathology, and treatment method [3]. There are many classifications in stroke pattern identification, including organ pattern identification, eight-pattern identification, and qi-blood identification. However, the basic elements of pattern identification, such as the discrimination of excessive/deficiency and heat/nonheat patterns, are the same. There were several previous studies on pattern identification, such as a study that diagnosed IBS with the excess/deficiency pattern [4], a study on the period of menstruation [5], and study on traditional Chinese medicine syndromes in women with a frequently recurring cystitis [6]. However, these studies have many limitations because they did not use validated criteria for their TCM diagnoses and hence the reliability of the work. And there are 2 studies that examined reliability of 8-principle diagnosis [7]. However, no study was found to evaluate actual clinical data and extract meaningful indicators. These studies focused only on pattern of disease. Therefore, we adopted an alternative approach, which is to group research subjects into broad categories based on essential patterns of the TCM diagnosis, such as heat/nonheat and excess/deficiency patterns, rather than a detailed TCM diagnosis. First, we made indicators of pattern identification for stroke using Delphi process that is a practical way of generating consensus from a group of expert practitioners [8]. Next, based on the clinical data from a multicenter, large population, the Korean Standard Differentiation of the Symptoms and Signs of Stroke involved 5 categories: the fire-heat pattern, the damp-phlegm pattern, the Yin deficiency pattern, the Qi deficiency pattern, and the blood stasis pattern [9, 10]. Blood stasis pattern was excluded due to rare diagnosis (n=89). Therefore, we extract significant clinical indicators, which affect two pairs of distinct patterns of TCM diagnosis in stroke through data of four patterns: the fire-heat pattern, the damp-phlegm pattern, the Yin deficiency pattern, and the Qi deficiency pattern.


## 2. Participants and Methods

### 2.1. Participants

This study was a community-based multicenter trial. We collected data on stroke patients who had been hospitalized in fifteen oriental medicine university hospitals nationwide from November 2006 to February 2010. Inclusion criteria included having acute stroke with a neurological deficit that persisted for over 24 hours; being finally diagnosed as stroke by imaging, including computerized tomography and magnetic resonance imaging; and agreeing to participate within 30 days of stroke onset. In addition, there were exclusion criteria. Exclusion criteria included traumatic stroke, including epidural hemorrhage and subdural hemorrhage; degenerative brain disease; a stroke concomitant with a brain tumor; and patients unable to communicate symptoms.


### 2.2. Data Collection and Gold Standard for Inclusion

We utilized the case report form (CRF) with a high reliability, collected data on the symptoms and signs, and recorded the score on the 3-point Likert scale for the standardization of stroke diagnosis that had been developed by an expert committee organized by the Korean Institute of Oriental Medicine (KIOM). The principle of symptoms and signs of each patterns extraction was as follows. First, we reflected the characteristic of stroke symptoms to exclude its own symptoms such as hemiparesis, dysphagia, dysarthria, and facial palsy. Second, we identified stroke patterns based on the present state of TKM clinically. Also we considered the association with the previous studies. Finally, we reflected the recent trend of stroke in TKM literature. And two independent physicians conducted this pattern identification. The gold standard was set up as two physicians’ concurrent diagnosis which is an identical pattern as a result of diagnostic decision of two TKM physicians. The physicians had at least three years of clinical experiences with stroke and identified the PI of each participating patient. We used data from 960 patients who were diagnosed as the fire-heat pattern, the Yin deficiency pattern, or the Qi deficiency pattern. All of the involved researchers received formal training with standard operation procedures (SOPs) twice a year to exclude all of the possible individual differences.


### 2.3. Assumption for the Extraction of Clinical Indicators of the Heat/Nonheat Pattern and the Excess/Deficiency Pattern

We assumed that the three patterns (the fire-heat pattern, the Yin deficiency pattern, and the Qi deficiency pattern) lie on either side of the space that consists of two axes: the excess/deficiency axis and the heat/nonheat axis. As coldness is mentioned in neither the classical literatures nor the common opinion from the experts, we assumed only the existence and nonexistence of heat. However, this assumption only focused on stroke. We thought normal heat/cold pattern discrimination was replaced by heat/absence of heat signs because cold is not a recognized feature in PI for stroke, while heat is a common pattern and a method is needed to discriminate heat signs.With the exception of the damp-phlegm pattern and blood stagnation pattern, which are taken as pathological products, we suppose that the fire-heat pattern involves the excess and heat patterns, the Qi deficiency pattern involves deficiency and nonheat patterns, and the Yin deficiency pattern involves deficiency and heat patterns.


### 2.4. Set-Up of an Independent Variable and a Dependent Variable

Among 65 clinical indicators, those with an appearance of less than 5% of the frequency were excluded. Each indicator was established as an independent variable after conversion to the binary form (existence and nonexistence of symptoms or signs). Dependent variables were grouped into two (heat/nonheat and excess/deficiency patterns): the fire-heat pattern and the Yin deficiency pattern to the heat pattern; the fire-heat pattern to the excess pattern; and the Yin deficiency pattern and the Qi deficiency pattern to the deficiency pattern.


### 2.5. Statistical Analysis

A univariate cross tabulation was performed for all of the independent variables and the binary dependent variables. We adopted multilogistic regression analysis for the indicators that showed a significant difference after univariate analysis. The analysis was performed using SAS, version 5.1.


## 2.1. Participants

This study was a community-based multicenter trial. We collected data on stroke patients who had been hospitalized in fifteen oriental medicine university hospitals nationwide from November 2006 to February 2010. Inclusion criteria included having acute stroke with a neurological deficit that persisted for over 24 hours; being finally diagnosed as stroke by imaging, including computerized tomography and magnetic resonance imaging; and agreeing to participate within 30 days of stroke onset. In addition, there were exclusion criteria. Exclusion criteria included traumatic stroke, including epidural hemorrhage and subdural hemorrhage; degenerative brain disease; a stroke concomitant with a brain tumor; and patients unable to communicate symptoms.


## 2.2. Data Collection and Gold Standard for Inclusion

We utilized the case report form (CRF) with a high reliability, collected data on the symptoms and signs, and recorded the score on the 3-point Likert scale for the standardization of stroke diagnosis that had been developed by an expert committee organized by the Korean Institute of Oriental Medicine (KIOM). The principle of symptoms and signs of each patterns extraction was as follows. First, we reflected the characteristic of stroke symptoms to exclude its own symptoms such as hemiparesis, dysphagia, dysarthria, and facial palsy. Second, we identified stroke patterns based on the present state of TKM clinically. Also we considered the association with the previous studies. Finally, we reflected the recent trend of stroke in TKM literature. And two independent physicians conducted this pattern identification. The gold standard was set up as two physicians’ concurrent diagnosis which is an identical pattern as a result of diagnostic decision of two TKM physicians. The physicians had at least three years of clinical experiences with stroke and identified the PI of each participating patient. We used data from 960 patients who were diagnosed as the fire-heat pattern, the Yin deficiency pattern, or the Qi deficiency pattern. All of the involved researchers received formal training with standard operation procedures (SOPs) twice a year to exclude all of the possible individual differences.


## 2.3. Assumption for the Extraction of Clinical Indicators of the Heat/Nonheat Pattern and the Excess/Deficiency Pattern

We assumed that the three patterns (the fire-heat pattern, the Yin deficiency pattern, and the Qi deficiency pattern) lie on either side of the space that consists of two axes: the excess/deficiency axis and the heat/nonheat axis. As coldness is mentioned in neither the classical literatures nor the common opinion from the experts, we assumed only the existence and nonexistence of heat. However, this assumption only focused on stroke. We thought normal heat/cold pattern discrimination was replaced by heat/absence of heat signs because cold is not a recognized feature in PI for stroke, while heat is a common pattern and a method is needed to discriminate heat signs.With the exception of the damp-phlegm pattern and blood stagnation pattern, which are taken as pathological products, we suppose that the fire-heat pattern involves the excess and heat patterns, the Qi deficiency pattern involves deficiency and nonheat patterns, and the Yin deficiency pattern involves deficiency and heat patterns.


## 2.4. Set-Up of an Independent Variable and a Dependent Variable

Among 65 clinical indicators, those with an appearance of less than 5% of the frequency were excluded. Each indicator was established as an independent variable after conversion to the binary form (existence and nonexistence of symptoms or signs). Dependent variables were grouped into two (heat/nonheat and excess/deficiency patterns): the fire-heat pattern and the Yin deficiency pattern to the heat pattern; the fire-heat pattern to the excess pattern; and the Yin deficiency pattern and the Qi deficiency pattern to the deficiency pattern.


## 2.5. Statistical Analysis

A univariate cross tabulation was performed for all of the independent variables and the binary dependent variables. We adopted multilogistic regression analysis for the indicators that showed a significant difference after univariate analysis. The analysis was performed using SAS, version 5.1.


## 3. Results

### 3.1. Number of Participants

The patients included consisted of 444 patients with the fire-heat pattern, 207 with the Yin deficiency pattern, and 313 with the Qi deficiency pattern (Table1).Table 1
Demographic parameters of enrolled participants.
Characteristics
QD
YD
FH
P
N
313
207
440
Sex (M/F)
107/206
91/116
334/106
<0.0001
Age (year)
67.37  ±  11.53
69.27  ±  12.37
65.75  ±  11.98
0.0019
Smoking (none/stop/active)
41/40/232
40/32/135
170/107/163
<0.0001
Drinking (none/stop/active)
68/31/214
58/19/130
214/55/171
<0.0001
Weight (kg)
56.66 ± 9.19
56.97 ± 11.25
64.97 ± 10.78
<0.0001
BMI (kg/m2)
22.74 ± 2.99
22.87 ± 4.43
24.16 ± 3.0
<0.0001
Waist circumference (cm)
84.57 ± 8.81
82.77 ± 9.16
88.33 ± 9.34
<0.0001
WHR
0.93 ± 0.11
0.93 ± 0.15
0.95 ± 0.10
NS
TOAST classification
LAA
51
47
117
0.0073
CE
20
15
34
SVO
182
95
199
SOE
7
7
5
SUE
14
10
22
Medical history
TIA (n, %)
26 (8.31)
20 (9.66)
35 (7.99)
NS
Hypertension (n, %)
180 (57.51)
123 (59.42)
258 (58.77)
NS
Hyperlipidemia (n, %)
35 (11.18)
18 (8.70)
54 (12.33)
NS
Diabetes (n, %)
82 (26.20)
47 (22.71)
116 (26.48)
NS
Heart disease (n, %)
17 (5.43)
12 (5.80)
26 (5.92)
NS
Data was expressed as frequencies for categorical variables and expressed as mean ± standard deviation for continuous variables. YD: Yin deficiency; QD: Qi deficiency; FH: fire-heat; NS: not significant.P values were calculated by chi-square test or ANOVA.


### 3.2. Selection of Variables to Be Involved in an Analysis

Six clinical indicators of the 65 indicators on the CRF that appeared at a frequency of less than 5% were found: darkish complexion, headache like flush, headache with nausea, stabbing headache, bluish purple tongue, and purple spots on the tongue. This clinical consideration was generally executed prior to multivariate analysis.


### 3.3. Univariate and Multivariate Analysis to Extract Clinical Indicators for the Heat Pattern and the Nonheat Pattern

After performing a multivariate analysis on the clinical indicators that had a significant difference in univariate analysis, we determined nine important clinical indicators: reddened complexion, blood-shot eyes, aphtha or tongue sore, fetid mouth odor, yellow fur, strong purse, surging purse, heat vexation and aversion to heat, and obesity. These factors displayed odds ratios greater than 1.0. Ten important clinical indicators were as follows: drowsiness, like to lie down, feeling powerless and lazy, pale complexion, pale face and malar flush, pale tongue, teeth-marked tongue, mirror tongue, weak purse, fine purse, and frequent urination. These factors displayed odds ratios of less than 1.0 (Table2). Whole results of univariate and multivariate analysis to extract clinical indicators for the heat pattern and the nonheat pattern were shown in Supplemental Table 1 available online at http://dx.doi.org/10.1155/2014/869894.Table 2
Results of multivariate analysis in excessive pattern and deficiency pattern.
Clinical indicator
Deficiency
Excessive
cOR (95% CI)
P
aOR (95% CI)
P
q01_2
46 (8.85)
70 (15.91)
0.615 (0.286, 1.322)
NS
0.721 (0.236, 2.198)
NS
q01_3
146 (28.08)
58 (13.18)
2.346 (1.222, 4.507)
0.0104
2.881 (1.007, 8.243)
0.0485
q02_1
308 (59.23)
133 (30.23)
1.689 (0.94, 3.032)
NS
1.888 (0.713, 4.995)
NS
q02_2
345 (66.35)
125 (28.41)
1.382 (0.762, 2.507)
NS
1.073 (0.386, 2.984)
NS
q03_1_1
179 (34.42)
22 (5)
2.947 (1.178, 7.375)
0.0209
2.826 (0.622, 12.835)
NS
q03_1_2
123 (23.65)
64 (14.55)
1.179 (0.537, 2.587)
NS
0.754 (0.23, 2.467)
NS
q03_1_3
14 (2.69)
3 (0.68)
2.772 (0.42, 18.321)
NS
0.759 (0.055, 10.523)
NS
q03_1_4
90 (17.31)
32 (7.27)
2.646 (1.09, 6.425)
0.0315
2.302 (0.58, 9.135)
NS
q03_1_5
60 (11.54)
284 (64.55)
0.2 (0.094, 0.424)
<0.0001
0.103 (0.03, 0.353)
0.0003
q03_2
79 (15.19)
39 (8.86)
1.33 (0.622, 2.842)
NS
0.461 (0.142, 1.493)
NS
q04_3_2
15 (2.88)
31 (7.05)
0.139 (0.046, 0.42)
0.0005
0.157 (0.023, 1.05)
NS
q05_1
275 (52.88)
190 (43.18)
1.279 (0.78, 2.099)
NS
1.169 (0.538, 2.54)
NS
q06_1
74 (14.23)
90 (20.45)
0.859 (0.466, 1.585)
NS
2.504 (0.899, 6.973)
NS
q06_2
207 (39.81)
71 (16.14)
1.623 (0.858, 3.07)
NS
1.552 (0.505, 4.774)
NS
q07_1_1
23 (4.42)
37 (8.41)
0.306 (0.119, 0.79)
0.0144
0.133 (0.03, 0.584)
0.0075
q07_1_2
59 (11.35)
111 (25.23)
0.439 (0.228, 0.844)
0.0135
0.331 (0.122, 0.9)
0.0304
q07_4
157 (30.19)
182 (41.36)
0.515 (0.314, 0.842)
0.0082
0.679 (0.323, 1.429)
NS
q08_1_1
138 (26.54)
38 (8.64)
3.625 (1.229, 10.692)
0.0196
4.806 (0.962, 24.009)
NS
q08_1_2
221 (42.5)
147 (33.41)
2.079 (0.806, 5.364)
NS
1.703 (0.402, 7.222)
NS
q08_1_3
140 (26.92)
224 (50.91)
0.81 (0.319, 2.054)
NS
0.626 (0.149, 2.626)
NS
q08_2_1
101 (19.42)
216 (49.09)
0.281 (0.14, 0.563)
0.0003
0.487 (0.159, 1.488)
NS
q08_2_2
244 (46.92)
136 (30.91)
0.809 (0.437, 1.498)
NS
1.466 (0.553, 3.883)
NS
q08_3_1
102 (19.62)
201 (45.68)
0.56 (0.32, 0.98)
0.0422
0.439 (0.188, 1.026)
NS
q08_4_1
102 (19.62)
110 (25)
2.073 (1.178, 3.647)
0.0114
2.011 (0.841, 4.808)
NS
q08_5_1
85 (16.35)
40 (9.09)
2.317 (1.122, 4.784)
0.0231
4.518 (1.616, 12.632)
0.004
q08_5_4
34 (6.54)
15 (3.41)
4.956 (1.61, 15.257)
0.0053
15.977 (1.97, 129.6)
0.0095
q10_1
128 (24.62)
150 (34.09)
0.657 (0.389, 1.108)
NS
1.572 (0.672, 3.679)
NS
q11_1
205 (39.42)
146 (33.18)
1.799 (1.1, 2.941)
0.0193
2.598 (1.166, 5.788)
0.0195
q11_3
115 (22.12)
125 (28.41)
0.927 (0.543, 1.581)
NS
0.92 (0.412, 2.052)
NS
q12_4
73 (14.04)
86 (19.55)
0.683 (0.369, 1.262)
NS
1.262 (0.463, 3.446)
NS
q13_1
47 (9.04)
18 (4.09)
1.403 (0.532, 3.695)
NS
2.322 (0.443, 12.154)
NS
q14_1_1
116 (22.31)
189 (42.95)
0.957 (0.517, 1.772)
NS
0.398 (0.148, 1.068)
NS
q14_1_2
232 (44.62)
94 (21.36)
1.726 (0.934, 3.189)
NS
1.318 (0.508, 3.419)
NS
q14_2_1
127 (24.42)
38 (8.64)
1.097 (0.525, 2.294)
NS
1.619 (0.504, 5.204)
NS
q14_2_2
137 (26.35)
199 (45.23)
0.637 (0.371, 1.095)
NS
0.668 (0.285, 1.564)
NS
q14_3_1
108 (20.77)
297 (67.5)
0.494 (0.271, 0.9)
0.0212
0.441 (0.176, 1.104)
NS
q14_3_2
298 (57.31)
55 (12.5)
2.026 (1.037, 3.957)
0.0388
2.024 (0.726, 5.642)
NS
q14_4
229 (44.04)
23 (5.23)
6.098 (3.055, 12.172)
<0.0001
3.416 (1.208, 9.659)
0.0205
q14_5
90 (17.31)
161 (36.59)
0.912 (0.544, 1.528)
NS
0.755 (0.334, 1.71)
NS
q14_7
13 (2.5)
96 (21.82)
0.093 (0.034, 0.254)
<0.0001
0.087 (0.02, 0.38)
0.0012
q15_1
208 (40)
292 (66.36)
0.503 (0.308, 0.821)
0.006
0.341 (0.156, 0.744)
0.0069
q15_2_1
49 (9.42)
74 (16.82)
1.411 (0.68, 2.927)
NS
0.782 (0.272, 2.249)
NS
q15_2_2
35 (6.73)
69 (15.68)
0.423 (0.192, 0.931)
0.0327
0.853 (0.256, 2.848)
NS
q15_2_3
85 (16.35)
29 (6.59)
2.074 (0.959, 4.484)
NS
2.55 (0.781, 8.33)
NS
q16_1_1
76 (14.62)
125 (28.41)
0.44 (0.246, 0.786)
0.0056
0.391 (0.138, 1.113)
NS
Data was expressed as yes (%). Excessive: fire-heat pattern; deficiency: Qi deficiency pattern and Yin deficiency Pattern;cOR means crude odds ratio and aOR means odds ratio adjusted by sex, age, BMI, WHR, smoking, and drinking status. NS: not significant.


### 3.4. Univariate and Multivariate Analyses to Extract Clinical Indicators in the Excessive Pattern and Deficiency Pattern

After performing a multivariate analysis on clinical indicators that displayed a significant difference on univariate analysis, we identified nine important clinical indicators: pale face and malar flush, reddened complexion, red eye, aphtha or tongue sore, fetid mouth odor, red tongue, dry fur, rapid purse, heat in the palms and soles, and gauntness (odds ratio > 1.0). We identified ten important clinical indicators: looking powerless and lazy, pale complexion, low voice, white fur, teeth-marked tongue, and weak purse (odds ratio < 1.0) (Table3). Whole results of univariate and multivariate analysis to extract clinical indicators for the excessive pattern and deficiency pattern were shown in Supplemental Table 2.Table 3
Results of multivariate analysis in heat pattern and nonheat pattern.
Clinical indicator
Heat
Nonheat
cOR (95% CI)
P
aOR (95% CI)
P
q01_2
97 (14.99)
19 (6.07)
2.891 (1.119, 7.464)
0.0283
1.471 (0.369, 5.868)
NS
q01_3
103 (15.92)
101 (32.27)
0.74 (0.416, 1.319)
NS
0.63 (0.259, 1.532)
NS
q02_1
233 (36.01)
208 (66.45)
0.729 (0.397, 1.337)
NS
0.579 (0.235, 1.43)
NS
q02_2
229 (35.39)
241 (77)
0.409 (0.219, 0.764)
0.005
0.516 (0.213, 1.249)
NS
q03_1_1
43 (6.65)
158 (50.48)
0.205 (0.112, 0.375)
<0.0001
0.279 (0.112, 0.694)
0.006
q03_1_4
105 (16.23)
17 (5.43)
5.985 (2.764, 12.961)
<0.0001
4.776 (1.591, 14.335)
0.0053
q03_1_5
321 (49.61)
23 (7.35)
4.581 (2.402, 8.735)
<0.0001
6.929 (2.589, 18.547)
0.0001
q03_2
69 (10.66)
49 (15.65)
0.801 (0.419, 1.531)
NS
1.025 (0.372, 2.824)
NS
q04_3_2
40 (6.18)
6 (1.92)
2.034 (0.487, 8.495)
NS
1.854 (0.267, 12.87)
NS
q05_1
288 (44.51)
177 (56.55)
0.916 (0.52, 1.614)
NS
1.022 (0.436, 2.394)
NS
q06_1
130 (20.09)
34 (10.86)
1.191 (0.618, 2.292)
NS
0.946 (0.316, 2.83)
NS
q06_2
131 (20.25)
147 (46.96)
0.496 (0.279, 0.88)
0.0165
0.361 (0.141, 0.921)
0.0329
q07_1_1
48 (7.42)
12 (3.83)
2.203 (0.796, 6.096)
NS
2.863 (0.572, 14.328)
NS
q07_1_2
138 (21.33)
32 (10.22)
2.727 (1.324, 5.614)
0.0065
2.713 (0.917, 8.023)
NS
q07_4
250 (38.64)
89 (28.43)
0.958 (0.583, 1.576)
NS
0.794 (0.388, 1.624)
NS
q08_1_1
62 (9.58)
114 (36.42)
0.425 (0.145, 1.25)
NS
0.974 (0.197, 4.817)
NS
q08_1_2
228 (35.24)
140 (44.73)
0.657 (0.24, 1.8)
NS
1.516 (0.337, 6.814)
NS
q08_1_3
318 (49.15)
46 (14.7)
3.119 (1.102, 8.826)
0.0321
9.338 (1.918, 45.477)
0.0057
q08_2_1
269 (41.58)
48 (15.34)
2.023 (0.987, 4.148)
NS
2.688 (0.952, 7.588)
NS
q08_2_2
205 (31.68)
175 (55.91)
0.436 (0.239, 0.795)
0.0067
0.478 (0.202, 1.132)
NS
q08_3_1
235 (36.32)
68 (21.73)
0.812 (0.452, 1.461)
NS
0.633 (0.27, 1.48)
NS
q08_4_1
178 (27.51)
34 (10.86)
2.175 (1.151, 4.111)
0.0167
4.771 (1.71, 13.318)
0.0028
q08_5_1
61 (9.43)
64 (20.45)
0.46 (0.242, 0.877)
0.0182
0.264 (0.106, 0.662)
0.0045
q08_5_4
41 (6.34)
8 (2.56)
3.018 (0.902, 10.102)
NS
6.052 (1.018, 35.979)
0.0478
q09_1
131 (20.25)
44 (14.06)
1.829 (0.715, 4.68)
NS
1.151 (0.303, 4.368)
NS
q09_3
99 (15.3)
26 (8.31)
0.81 (0.254, 2.575)
NS
1.356 (0.277, 6.639)
NS
q10_2
140 (21.64)
45 (14.38)
1.164 (0.632, 2.143)
NS
1.455 (0.571, 3.709)
NS
q11_3
184 (28.44)
56 (17.89)
1.199 (0.679, 2.12)
NS
1.356 (0.607, 3.031)
NS
q14_1_1
241 (37.25)
64 (20.45)
0.971 (0.502, 1.876)
NS
1.336 (0.503, 3.551)
NS
q14_1_2
162 (25.04)
164 (52.4)
0.472 (0.26, 0.855)
0.0133
0.491 (0.202, 1.191)
NS
q14_2_1
70 (10.82)
95 (30.35)
1.376 (0.704, 2.691)
NS
1.619 (0.582, 4.504)
NS
q14_2_2
285 (44.05)
51 (16.29)
3.207 (1.763, 5.833)
0.0001
3.874 (1.625, 9.235)
0.0022
q14_3_1
350 (54.1)
55 (17.57)
1.34 (0.679, 2.644)
NS
1.049 (0.387, 2.846)
NS
q14_3_2
149 (23.03)
204 (65.18)
0.434 (0.231, 0.816)
0.0096
0.365 (0.144, 0.921)
0.0328
q14_4
114 (17.62)
138 (44.09)
0.933 (0.532, 1.636)
NS
2.03 (0.847, 4.86)
NS
q14_5
201 (31.07)
50 (15.97)
1.503 (0.82, 2.755)
NS
2.104 (0.887, 4.993)
NS
q14_7
101 (15.61)
8 (2.56)
2.97 (1.003, 8.795)
0.0495
2.55 (0.554, 11.732)
NS
q15_1
390 (60.28)
110 (35.14)
1.446 (0.885, 2.364)
NS
1.517 (0.7, 3.112)
NS
q15_2_1
107 (16.54)
16 (5.11)
4.983 (1.857, 13.37)
0.0014
6.95 (1.646, 29.345)
0.0083
q15_2_2
87 (13.45)
17 (5.43)
0.988 (0.417, 2.341)
NS
0.502 (0.146, 1.727)
NS
q15_2_3
54 (8.35)
60 (19.17)
0.51 (0.253, 1.027)
NS
0.569 (0.204, 1.586)
NS
q15_3
85 (13.14)
22 (7.03)
1.61 (0.675, 3.84)
NS
1.383 (0.384, 4.986)
NS
q16_1_1
161 (24.88)
40 (12.78)
1.597 (0.799, 3.191)
NS
1.877 (0.626, 5.63)
NS
q16_1_2
140 (21.64)
47 (15.02)
1.731 (0.83, 3.61)
NS
1.06 (0.362, 3.102)
NS
Data was expressed as yes (%). Heat: fire-heat pattern and Yin deficiency pattern; Nonheat: Qi deficiency pattern;cOR means crude odds ratio and aOR means odds ratio adjusted by sex, age, BMI, WHR, smoking, and drinking status. NS: not significant.


### 3.5. Comparison of the Clinical Indicators That Explain the Heat/Nonheat Pattern and Excess/Deficiency Pattern

Comparing the results of the heat/nonheat pattern with those of the excess/deficiency pattern, four indicators were found for both heat and excess patterns: reddened complexion, red eye, aphtha or tongue soreness, and fetid mouth odor. Three indicators (pale complexion, teeth-marked tongue, and weak purse) were found in both nonheat and the deficiency patterns (Table4).Table 4
Comparison of clinical indicators that explain heat/nonheat pattern and excess/deficiency.
Excess
Deficiency
Heat
Reddened complexionRed eyeAphtha or tongue-soreFetid mouth odor
Nonheat
Pale complexion,Teeth-marked tongueWeak purse


## 3.1. Number of Participants

The patients included consisted of 444 patients with the fire-heat pattern, 207 with the Yin deficiency pattern, and 313 with the Qi deficiency pattern (Table1).Table 1
Demographic parameters of enrolled participants.
Characteristics
QD
YD
FH
P
N
313
207
440
Sex (M/F)
107/206
91/116
334/106
<0.0001
Age (year)
67.37  ±  11.53
69.27  ±  12.37
65.75  ±  11.98
0.0019
Smoking (none/stop/active)
41/40/232
40/32/135
170/107/163
<0.0001
Drinking (none/stop/active)
68/31/214
58/19/130
214/55/171
<0.0001
Weight (kg)
56.66 ± 9.19
56.97 ± 11.25
64.97 ± 10.78
<0.0001
BMI (kg/m2)
22.74 ± 2.99
22.87 ± 4.43
24.16 ± 3.0
<0.0001
Waist circumference (cm)
84.57 ± 8.81
82.77 ± 9.16
88.33 ± 9.34
<0.0001
WHR
0.93 ± 0.11
0.93 ± 0.15
0.95 ± 0.10
NS
TOAST classification
LAA
51
47
117
0.0073
CE
20
15
34
SVO
182
95
199
SOE
7
7
5
SUE
14
10
22
Medical history
TIA (n, %)
26 (8.31)
20 (9.66)
35 (7.99)
NS
Hypertension (n, %)
180 (57.51)
123 (59.42)
258 (58.77)
NS
Hyperlipidemia (n, %)
35 (11.18)
18 (8.70)
54 (12.33)
NS
Diabetes (n, %)
82 (26.20)
47 (22.71)
116 (26.48)
NS
Heart disease (n, %)
17 (5.43)
12 (5.80)
26 (5.92)
NS
Data was expressed as frequencies for categorical variables and expressed as mean ± standard deviation for continuous variables. YD: Yin deficiency; QD: Qi deficiency; FH: fire-heat; NS: not significant.P values were calculated by chi-square test or ANOVA.


## 3.2. Selection of Variables to Be Involved in an Analysis

Six clinical indicators of the 65 indicators on the CRF that appeared at a frequency of less than 5% were found: darkish complexion, headache like flush, headache with nausea, stabbing headache, bluish purple tongue, and purple spots on the tongue. This clinical consideration was generally executed prior to multivariate analysis.


## 3.3. Univariate and Multivariate Analysis to Extract Clinical Indicators for the Heat Pattern and the Nonheat Pattern

After performing a multivariate analysis on the clinical indicators that had a significant difference in univariate analysis, we determined nine important clinical indicators: reddened complexion, blood-shot eyes, aphtha or tongue sore, fetid mouth odor, yellow fur, strong purse, surging purse, heat vexation and aversion to heat, and obesity. These factors displayed odds ratios greater than 1.0. Ten important clinical indicators were as follows: drowsiness, like to lie down, feeling powerless and lazy, pale complexion, pale face and malar flush, pale tongue, teeth-marked tongue, mirror tongue, weak purse, fine purse, and frequent urination. These factors displayed odds ratios of less than 1.0 (Table2). Whole results of univariate and multivariate analysis to extract clinical indicators for the heat pattern and the nonheat pattern were shown in Supplemental Table 1 available online at http://dx.doi.org/10.1155/2014/869894.Table 2
Results of multivariate analysis in excessive pattern and deficiency pattern.
Clinical indicator
Deficiency
Excessive
cOR (95% CI)
P
aOR (95% CI)
P
q01_2
46 (8.85)
70 (15.91)
0.615 (0.286, 1.322)
NS
0.721 (0.236, 2.198)
NS
q01_3
146 (28.08)
58 (13.18)
2.346 (1.222, 4.507)
0.0104
2.881 (1.007, 8.243)
0.0485
q02_1
308 (59.23)
133 (30.23)
1.689 (0.94, 3.032)
NS
1.888 (0.713, 4.995)
NS
q02_2
345 (66.35)
125 (28.41)
1.382 (0.762, 2.507)
NS
1.073 (0.386, 2.984)
NS
q03_1_1
179 (34.42)
22 (5)
2.947 (1.178, 7.375)
0.0209
2.826 (0.622, 12.835)
NS
q03_1_2
123 (23.65)
64 (14.55)
1.179 (0.537, 2.587)
NS
0.754 (0.23, 2.467)
NS
q03_1_3
14 (2.69)
3 (0.68)
2.772 (0.42, 18.321)
NS
0.759 (0.055, 10.523)
NS
q03_1_4
90 (17.31)
32 (7.27)
2.646 (1.09, 6.425)
0.0315
2.302 (0.58, 9.135)
NS
q03_1_5
60 (11.54)
284 (64.55)
0.2 (0.094, 0.424)
<0.0001
0.103 (0.03, 0.353)
0.0003
q03_2
79 (15.19)
39 (8.86)
1.33 (0.622, 2.842)
NS
0.461 (0.142, 1.493)
NS
q04_3_2
15 (2.88)
31 (7.05)
0.139 (0.046, 0.42)
0.0005
0.157 (0.023, 1.05)
NS
q05_1
275 (52.88)
190 (43.18)
1.279 (0.78, 2.099)
NS
1.169 (0.538, 2.54)
NS
q06_1
74 (14.23)
90 (20.45)
0.859 (0.466, 1.585)
NS
2.504 (0.899, 6.973)
NS
q06_2
207 (39.81)
71 (16.14)
1.623 (0.858, 3.07)
NS
1.552 (0.505, 4.774)
NS
q07_1_1
23 (4.42)
37 (8.41)
0.306 (0.119, 0.79)
0.0144
0.133 (0.03, 0.584)
0.0075
q07_1_2
59 (11.35)
111 (25.23)
0.439 (0.228, 0.844)
0.0135
0.331 (0.122, 0.9)
0.0304
q07_4
157 (30.19)
182 (41.36)
0.515 (0.314, 0.842)
0.0082
0.679 (0.323, 1.429)
NS
q08_1_1
138 (26.54)
38 (8.64)
3.625 (1.229, 10.692)
0.0196
4.806 (0.962, 24.009)
NS
q08_1_2
221 (42.5)
147 (33.41)
2.079 (0.806, 5.364)
NS
1.703 (0.402, 7.222)
NS
q08_1_3
140 (26.92)
224 (50.91)
0.81 (0.319, 2.054)
NS
0.626 (0.149, 2.626)
NS
q08_2_1
101 (19.42)
216 (49.09)
0.281 (0.14, 0.563)
0.0003
0.487 (0.159, 1.488)
NS
q08_2_2
244 (46.92)
136 (30.91)
0.809 (0.437, 1.498)
NS
1.466 (0.553, 3.883)
NS
q08_3_1
102 (19.62)
201 (45.68)
0.56 (0.32, 0.98)
0.0422
0.439 (0.188, 1.026)
NS
q08_4_1
102 (19.62)
110 (25)
2.073 (1.178, 3.647)
0.0114
2.011 (0.841, 4.808)
NS
q08_5_1
85 (16.35)
40 (9.09)
2.317 (1.122, 4.784)
0.0231
4.518 (1.616, 12.632)
0.004
q08_5_4
34 (6.54)
15 (3.41)
4.956 (1.61, 15.257)
0.0053
15.977 (1.97, 129.6)
0.0095
q10_1
128 (24.62)
150 (34.09)
0.657 (0.389, 1.108)
NS
1.572 (0.672, 3.679)
NS
q11_1
205 (39.42)
146 (33.18)
1.799 (1.1, 2.941)
0.0193
2.598 (1.166, 5.788)
0.0195
q11_3
115 (22.12)
125 (28.41)
0.927 (0.543, 1.581)
NS
0.92 (0.412, 2.052)
NS
q12_4
73 (14.04)
86 (19.55)
0.683 (0.369, 1.262)
NS
1.262 (0.463, 3.446)
NS
q13_1
47 (9.04)
18 (4.09)
1.403 (0.532, 3.695)
NS
2.322 (0.443, 12.154)
NS
q14_1_1
116 (22.31)
189 (42.95)
0.957 (0.517, 1.772)
NS
0.398 (0.148, 1.068)
NS
q14_1_2
232 (44.62)
94 (21.36)
1.726 (0.934, 3.189)
NS
1.318 (0.508, 3.419)
NS
q14_2_1
127 (24.42)
38 (8.64)
1.097 (0.525, 2.294)
NS
1.619 (0.504, 5.204)
NS
q14_2_2
137 (26.35)
199 (45.23)
0.637 (0.371, 1.095)
NS
0.668 (0.285, 1.564)
NS
q14_3_1
108 (20.77)
297 (67.5)
0.494 (0.271, 0.9)
0.0212
0.441 (0.176, 1.104)
NS
q14_3_2
298 (57.31)
55 (12.5)
2.026 (1.037, 3.957)
0.0388
2.024 (0.726, 5.642)
NS
q14_4
229 (44.04)
23 (5.23)
6.098 (3.055, 12.172)
<0.0001
3.416 (1.208, 9.659)
0.0205
q14_5
90 (17.31)
161 (36.59)
0.912 (0.544, 1.528)
NS
0.755 (0.334, 1.71)
NS
q14_7
13 (2.5)
96 (21.82)
0.093 (0.034, 0.254)
<0.0001
0.087 (0.02, 0.38)
0.0012
q15_1
208 (40)
292 (66.36)
0.503 (0.308, 0.821)
0.006
0.341 (0.156, 0.744)
0.0069
q15_2_1
49 (9.42)
74 (16.82)
1.411 (0.68, 2.927)
NS
0.782 (0.272, 2.249)
NS
q15_2_2
35 (6.73)
69 (15.68)
0.423 (0.192, 0.931)
0.0327
0.853 (0.256, 2.848)
NS
q15_2_3
85 (16.35)
29 (6.59)
2.074 (0.959, 4.484)
NS
2.55 (0.781, 8.33)
NS
q16_1_1
76 (14.62)
125 (28.41)
0.44 (0.246, 0.786)
0.0056
0.391 (0.138, 1.113)
NS
Data was expressed as yes (%). Excessive: fire-heat pattern; deficiency: Qi deficiency pattern and Yin deficiency Pattern;cOR means crude odds ratio and aOR means odds ratio adjusted by sex, age, BMI, WHR, smoking, and drinking status. NS: not significant.


## 3.4. Univariate and Multivariate Analyses to Extract Clinical Indicators in the Excessive Pattern and Deficiency Pattern

After performing a multivariate analysis on clinical indicators that displayed a significant difference on univariate analysis, we identified nine important clinical indicators: pale face and malar flush, reddened complexion, red eye, aphtha or tongue sore, fetid mouth odor, red tongue, dry fur, rapid purse, heat in the palms and soles, and gauntness (odds ratio > 1.0). We identified ten important clinical indicators: looking powerless and lazy, pale complexion, low voice, white fur, teeth-marked tongue, and weak purse (odds ratio < 1.0) (Table3). Whole results of univariate and multivariate analysis to extract clinical indicators for the excessive pattern and deficiency pattern were shown in Supplemental Table 2.Table 3
Results of multivariate analysis in heat pattern and nonheat pattern.
Clinical indicator
Heat
Nonheat
cOR (95% CI)
P
aOR (95% CI)
P
q01_2
97 (14.99)
19 (6.07)
2.891 (1.119, 7.464)
0.0283
1.471 (0.369, 5.868)
NS
q01_3
103 (15.92)
101 (32.27)
0.74 (0.416, 1.319)
NS
0.63 (0.259, 1.532)
NS
q02_1
233 (36.01)
208 (66.45)
0.729 (0.397, 1.337)
NS
0.579 (0.235, 1.43)
NS
q02_2
229 (35.39)
241 (77)
0.409 (0.219, 0.764)
0.005
0.516 (0.213, 1.249)
NS
q03_1_1
43 (6.65)
158 (50.48)
0.205 (0.112, 0.375)
<0.0001
0.279 (0.112, 0.694)
0.006
q03_1_4
105 (16.23)
17 (5.43)
5.985 (2.764, 12.961)
<0.0001
4.776 (1.591, 14.335)
0.0053
q03_1_5
321 (49.61)
23 (7.35)
4.581 (2.402, 8.735)
<0.0001
6.929 (2.589, 18.547)
0.0001
q03_2
69 (10.66)
49 (15.65)
0.801 (0.419, 1.531)
NS
1.025 (0.372, 2.824)
NS
q04_3_2
40 (6.18)
6 (1.92)
2.034 (0.487, 8.495)
NS
1.854 (0.267, 12.87)
NS
q05_1
288 (44.51)
177 (56.55)
0.916 (0.52, 1.614)
NS
1.022 (0.436, 2.394)
NS
q06_1
130 (20.09)
34 (10.86)
1.191 (0.618, 2.292)
NS
0.946 (0.316, 2.83)
NS
q06_2
131 (20.25)
147 (46.96)
0.496 (0.279, 0.88)
0.0165
0.361 (0.141, 0.921)
0.0329
q07_1_1
48 (7.42)
12 (3.83)
2.203 (0.796, 6.096)
NS
2.863 (0.572, 14.328)
NS
q07_1_2
138 (21.33)
32 (10.22)
2.727 (1.324, 5.614)
0.0065
2.713 (0.917, 8.023)
NS
q07_4
250 (38.64)
89 (28.43)
0.958 (0.583, 1.576)
NS
0.794 (0.388, 1.624)
NS
q08_1_1
62 (9.58)
114 (36.42)
0.425 (0.145, 1.25)
NS
0.974 (0.197, 4.817)
NS
q08_1_2
228 (35.24)
140 (44.73)
0.657 (0.24, 1.8)
NS
1.516 (0.337, 6.814)
NS
q08_1_3
318 (49.15)
46 (14.7)
3.119 (1.102, 8.826)
0.0321
9.338 (1.918, 45.477)
0.0057
q08_2_1
269 (41.58)
48 (15.34)
2.023 (0.987, 4.148)
NS
2.688 (0.952, 7.588)
NS
q08_2_2
205 (31.68)
175 (55.91)
0.436 (0.239, 0.795)
0.0067
0.478 (0.202, 1.132)
NS
q08_3_1
235 (36.32)
68 (21.73)
0.812 (0.452, 1.461)
NS
0.633 (0.27, 1.48)
NS
q08_4_1
178 (27.51)
34 (10.86)
2.175 (1.151, 4.111)
0.0167
4.771 (1.71, 13.318)
0.0028
q08_5_1
61 (9.43)
64 (20.45)
0.46 (0.242, 0.877)
0.0182
0.264 (0.106, 0.662)
0.0045
q08_5_4
41 (6.34)
8 (2.56)
3.018 (0.902, 10.102)
NS
6.052 (1.018, 35.979)
0.0478
q09_1
131 (20.25)
44 (14.06)
1.829 (0.715, 4.68)
NS
1.151 (0.303, 4.368)
NS
q09_3
99 (15.3)
26 (8.31)
0.81 (0.254, 2.575)
NS
1.356 (0.277, 6.639)
NS
q10_2
140 (21.64)
45 (14.38)
1.164 (0.632, 2.143)
NS
1.455 (0.571, 3.709)
NS
q11_3
184 (28.44)
56 (17.89)
1.199 (0.679, 2.12)
NS
1.356 (0.607, 3.031)
NS
q14_1_1
241 (37.25)
64 (20.45)
0.971 (0.502, 1.876)
NS
1.336 (0.503, 3.551)
NS
q14_1_2
162 (25.04)
164 (52.4)
0.472 (0.26, 0.855)
0.0133
0.491 (0.202, 1.191)
NS
q14_2_1
70 (10.82)
95 (30.35)
1.376 (0.704, 2.691)
NS
1.619 (0.582, 4.504)
NS
q14_2_2
285 (44.05)
51 (16.29)
3.207 (1.763, 5.833)
0.0001
3.874 (1.625, 9.235)
0.0022
q14_3_1
350 (54.1)
55 (17.57)
1.34 (0.679, 2.644)
NS
1.049 (0.387, 2.846)
NS
q14_3_2
149 (23.03)
204 (65.18)
0.434 (0.231, 0.816)
0.0096
0.365 (0.144, 0.921)
0.0328
q14_4
114 (17.62)
138 (44.09)
0.933 (0.532, 1.636)
NS
2.03 (0.847, 4.86)
NS
q14_5
201 (31.07)
50 (15.97)
1.503 (0.82, 2.755)
NS
2.104 (0.887, 4.993)
NS
q14_7
101 (15.61)
8 (2.56)
2.97 (1.003, 8.795)
0.0495
2.55 (0.554, 11.732)
NS
q15_1
390 (60.28)
110 (35.14)
1.446 (0.885, 2.364)
NS
1.517 (0.7, 3.112)
NS
q15_2_1
107 (16.54)
16 (5.11)
4.983 (1.857, 13.37)
0.0014
6.95 (1.646, 29.345)
0.0083
q15_2_2
87 (13.45)
17 (5.43)
0.988 (0.417, 2.341)
NS
0.502 (0.146, 1.727)
NS
q15_2_3
54 (8.35)
60 (19.17)
0.51 (0.253, 1.027)
NS
0.569 (0.204, 1.586)
NS
q15_3
85 (13.14)
22 (7.03)
1.61 (0.675, 3.84)
NS
1.383 (0.384, 4.986)
NS
q16_1_1
161 (24.88)
40 (12.78)
1.597 (0.799, 3.191)
NS
1.877 (0.626, 5.63)
NS
q16_1_2
140 (21.64)
47 (15.02)
1.731 (0.83, 3.61)
NS
1.06 (0.362, 3.102)
NS
Data was expressed as yes (%). Heat: fire-heat pattern and Yin deficiency pattern; Nonheat: Qi deficiency pattern;cOR means crude odds ratio and aOR means odds ratio adjusted by sex, age, BMI, WHR, smoking, and drinking status. NS: not significant.


## 3.5. Comparison of the Clinical Indicators That Explain the Heat/Nonheat Pattern and Excess/Deficiency Pattern

Comparing the results of the heat/nonheat pattern with those of the excess/deficiency pattern, four indicators were found for both heat and excess patterns: reddened complexion, red eye, aphtha or tongue soreness, and fetid mouth odor. Three indicators (pale complexion, teeth-marked tongue, and weak purse) were found in both nonheat and the deficiency patterns (Table4).Table 4
Comparison of clinical indicators that explain heat/nonheat pattern and excess/deficiency.
Excess
Deficiency
Heat
Reddened complexionRed eyeAphtha or tongue-soreFetid mouth odor
Nonheat
Pale complexion,Teeth-marked tongueWeak purse


## 4. Discussion

We provide important information for treatment by extracting clinical indicators that have reasonable and objective access to the heat/nonheat pattern and excess/deficiency pattern in acute stroke patients and present the relative risk. There are many diagnostic systems (e.g., organ pattern identification, eight-pattern identification, and qi-blood identification) in TKM [11], but they share certain features. The distinction between excessive/deficiency and heat/nonheat patterns are fundamental to pattern identification. Thus, it is indispensable for the identification of the heat/nonheat pattern and the excess/deficiency pattern. The potential advantages of this approach are the following: it may be easier for physicians to agree on the fundamental pattern types than on complex pattern types; it captures the important and essential factors for stroke pattern identifications; and it can be applied to herbal formulas based on herbal pharmacology. We tried to find clinical data that could identify the heat/nonheat pattern and excess/deficiency pattern by using the Korean Standard Differentiation of the Symptoms and Signs for Stroke that grouped similar patterns into 5 patterns in the context of stroke at TKM. Dissimilar to the previous pattern identification (PI) with 5 patterns agreed upon by stroke experts, we adopted PI with 3 patterns, in which the Damp-phlegm pattern and Blood stagnation pattern were eliminated [12].To extract indicators that can distinguish heat/nonheat based on this model, we set up Fire-heat/Yin deficiency versus Qi deficiency as independent variables. To extract indicators that could distinguish the excessive/deficiency pattern, Yin deficiency/Qi deficiency and fire-heat patterns were used as independent variables. Clinical data that did not show a significant difference on the chi-square test or that had a total frequency less than 5% were excluded. The others were set as the independent variables in a logistic regression analysis and verified the statistical influence of independent variables on dependent variables.As a result of the logistic regression analysis, 5 signs and 1 symptom in the excess/deficiency pattern and 8 signs and 6 symptoms in the heat/nonheat pattern were extracted as significant clinical data. This is because the signs like pulse and the tongue indicators were mainly weighted by physicians [13–15]. Physicians diagnose the heat/nonheat pattern and the excess/deficiency pattern by inspecting the existence and nonexistence of these indications. The mere extraction of indicators has certain limitations. It would be beneficial for providing the standardization of TKM in stroke and for evidence-based medicine if we made it possible to assess these factors quantitatively and qualitatively in further studies.In conclusion, this is the first study aimed to extract objective indicators to differentiate the heat/nonheat pattern and excess/deficiency pattern on the basis of clinical data. This demonstrates how to establish major patterns on a specific disease, how to divide the groups for comparison according to their components, and how to extract significant clinical indicators using a multivariate analysis. Although this study relates to stroke only, this approach has the potential to be applicable to other diseases because it adopts pattern identification, which is an essential diagnostic procedure in TKM treatment.This study enables us to obtain clinical evidence on pattern diagnosis, which was entirely dependent on the previous literature or expert opinions, and makes it possible to execute evidence-based diagnosis. It is highly likely that we will be able to use more obvious diagnostic evidence from systematic clinical trials in the future as fundamental studies evolve and treatment results accumulate. However, there are some limitations. This study shows only 5 patterns among the various possible patterns of TKM. It does not systematically reflect basic elements in PI from its inception but rather applied a Delphi technique to conventional PI. In this study, we analyzed only the cases that were not assessed to have accompanying patterns. Many physicians, however, understand the possibility of more than 2 patterns during PI and apply it to the clinical field [16, 17]. However, these accompanying patterns are complex. For that reason, this study excluded the accompanying patterns from the analysis and extracted important indicators of each pattern preferentially. Another limitation lies in the variation among raters, which is referred to frequently in TKM research. We made a great effort to minimize error by preparing SOPs and allowed raters to consult more than two SOPs.



---

*Source: 869894-2015-05-18.xml*