# Moving “Forward” inPlasmodium Genetics through a Transposon-Based Approach

Authors: Bharath Balu
Journal: Journal of Tropical Medicine
 (2012)

---

## Abstract

The genome sequence of the human malaria parasite,Plasmodium falciparum, was released almost a decade ago. A majority of the Plasmodium genome, however, remains annotated to code for hypothetical proteins with unknown functions. The introduction of forward genetics has provided novel means to gain a better understanding of gene functions and their associated phenotypes in Plasmodium. Even with certain limitations, the technique has already shown significant promise to increase our understanding of parasite biology needed for rationalized drug and vaccine design. Further improvements to the mutagenesis technique and the design of novel genetic screens should lead us to some exciting discoveries about the critical weaknesses of Plasmodium, and greatly aid in the development of new disease intervention strategies.


---

## Body

## 1. Introduction

Malaria is a serious global health problem causing clinical illness in hundreds of millions of people and killing around a million, each year [1]. Intervention strategies to control the disease have been largely ineffective due to increased parasite drug resistance, ineffective vector control measures, and inadequate knowledge about parasite biology to identify new drug and vaccine targets. The need to discover critical weaknesses in the parasite that could be exploited in designing novel antiparasitic strategies is greater than ever. Since the release of the Plasmodium genome sequence, several large-scale functional studies have advanced our overall knowledge tremendously about parasite biology [2–6]. However, in spite of such enormous efforts, almost 50% of the genome remains annotated to code for hypothetical proteins in all Plasmodium species [7]. It is imperative to understand the functions and essentiality of these hypothetical proteins to facilitate the identification of novel drug or vaccine targets.


## 2. Difficulties inPlasmodium Genetics

The first and foremost obstacle in functional characterization of thePlasmodium genome is our limited ability to genetically manipulate the parasite [8]. Out of all the Plasmodium species that cause human malaria, only the blood stages of P. falciparum can be cultured in vitro effectively and is the only life cycle stage amenable to transfection with exogenous DNA. While electroporation is most effective in transfecting P. falciparum [9, 10], the transfection efficiency is very low, in the range of 10−6 [11]. The rodent malaria parasite, P. berghei, can be transfected with much higher efficiency and, therefore, has been used more extensively in targeted gene knockout studies [12]. Furthermore, transfections in P. falciparum are limited to circular plasmid DNA and the parasite’s ability to maintain these plasmids as episomes makes it difficult to isolate the rare genomic integration events [13, 14]. Lastly, the parasite’s haploid genome in the blood stages limits manipulation and identification of genes essential for parasite development.


## 3. Reverse Genetics versus Forward Genetics

There are two possible approaches to functional characterization of a genome: (1) a reverse genetic approach, where a gene of interest is disrupted and the resulting phenotype is studied and (2) a forward genetic approach, where a phenotype of interest is first chosen and a pool of randomly generated mutants is subjected to a screen for the phenotype of interest (Figure1). Both these approaches have been equally effective, depending on the organism studied [15–18]. Functional characterization of the yeast genome is a great example of a successful reverse genetic approach [19]. A genome-wide knockout study has been feasible in yeast because of the ease of introducing exogenous DNA and the high efficiency of homologous recombination, and a large amount of phenotypic information is currently available for each gene knockout [20]. In higher organisms such as the fruit fly, forward genetic screens using transposon-mediated insertional mutagenesis have been preferred and have provided great information regarding gene functions [21–23]. A recent branch of forward genetics using small molecules has been very promising in many organisms, including Plasmodium [24–28]. Such chemical genetic approaches directly inhibit protein function and are often reversible. This paper will focus specifically on a transposon-based forward genetic approach and its applications in Plasmodium.Figure 1
A schematic representation of forward and reverse genetic approaches for genetic association of phenotypes.  Reverse genetics starts with the selection of gene of interest and culminates with the phenotypic analysis of its disruption.  Forward genetics starts by selecting a phenotype of interest and ends in identifying gene(s) responsible for that phenotype.


## 4. Transposon-Mediated Mutagenesis inPlasmodium

### 4.1. Rationale

Reverse genetic studies inPlasmodium, especially in the most lethal human malaria parasite P. falciparum, have been hampered by low efficiencies of transfection and homologous recombination [8]. Although a few medium-scale gene knockout approaches have been attempted in P. falciparum, they were extremely tedious, labor intensive, and fall much short of the genome-wide knockouts needed for rationalized drug and vaccine design [29, 30]. Forward genetic studies might offer a quicker and more efficient way to characterize the Plasmodium genome. The transposition event, which includes finding one target sequence from hundreds of thousands in the genome, should be much more efficient than homologous recombination at a single locus in the genome. Performing genetic screens might thus be faster and more effective in identifying genes involved in critical biological processes of the parasite.ThepiggyBac transposable element has been used extensively for insertional mutagenesis in numerous invertebrate and vertebrate species [31–35]. The ability to transmobilize piggyBac, through separate expression of the piggyBac transposase, has immensely contributed to the wide adaptability of the system to multiple organisms [36]. piggybac’s ability to more randomly insert into the genome, compared to other transposable elements, increases the likelihood of achieving genome-wide insertions and supports its application in insertional mutagenesis studies [35]. The target site for piggyBac insertion is TTAA and more than 300,000 TTAA target sites can be found in the AT-rich Plasmodium genome, providing a platform for genome-wide mutagenesis [37].


### 4.2. Methodology

ThepiggyBac system was first successfully adapted to P.  falciparum [38] and has recently been extended to P. berghei [39]. The basic design for piggyBac insertional mutagenesis in Plasmodium uses a two-plasmid approach. The first plasmid consists of a Plasmodium drug selection cassette flanked by the piggyBac5′ and 3′ terminal repeats, and the second plasmid drives the expression of the piggyBac transposase, required for the enzymatic cleavage and genomic insertion of the piggyBac terminal repeats (Figure 2). The transposase plasmid lacks a drug-selection cassette and is lost in a few generations, thereby preventing continuous movement of piggyBac. In P. berghei, a transgenic line containing the piggyBac transposase in the genome was also shown to be very effective in insertional mutagenesis and remobilization of previously inserted piggyBac element [39]. The precise insertion and excision mechanisms of piggyBac leave no footprints behind following remobilization, allowing phenotype rescue of any knockout [34].Figure 2
Basic plasmid designs forpiggyBac mutagenesis in Plasmodium.  The donor plasmid consists of a Plasmodium drug selection cassette flanked by the terminal repeats (TR) of piggyBac.  The helper plasmid provides the piggyBac transposase, which mediates the transposition event into the Plasmodium genome upon cotransfection with the donor plasmid.


### 4.3. Efficiency ofpiggyBac Mutagenesis in Plasmodium

piggyBac insertions into the genome can be obtained within 3-4 weeks in P. falciparum compared to 6–12 months needed to obtain homologous recombination events, and 1–10 insertions can be obtained per transfection depending on the conditions used [38]. Genomic insertions of piggyBac can be obtained in much higher numbers in P. berghei due to its increased transfection efficiency. Analyses of approximately 200 piggyBac insertion sites in P. falciparum and 120 in P. berghei show an almost equal distribution in the coding and noncoding regions of the genome, as predicted by the equal distribution of TTAA target sites in both coding and noncoding regions [39, 40]. This is an important finding considering the higher AT-richness in the noncoding regions of the genome. While a slight bias was observed for insertions into the 5′ untranslated regions (UTRs) of genes in the initial study in P. falciparum, this bias was most likely due to the higher growth rate of clones with insertions in UTRs compared to those with insertions in coding sequences, in a mixed population of transformed parasites, and this bias for 5′ UTRs was not observed in experiments where the transfection was followed by immediate cloning of parasites (Balu and Adams, unpublished data).There appears to be no striking bias for insertion into any particular chromosome or chromosomal region. Furthermore,piggyBac inserts into genes of all functional categories and shows no significant preference for genes expressed in the transformed blood stages. An equivalent number of piggyBac insertions were observed in genes exclusively expressed in other parasite life cycle stages, indicating the accessibility to these genes in the parasite’s blood stages. Such observations confirm the randomness of piggyBac insertions and demonstrate its effectiveness as a tool for genome-wide insertional mutagenesis in Plasmodium. Additionally, in both P. falciparum and P. berghei, mostly single piggyBac insertions are obtained per genome, allowing easy correlation of genotypes to their respective phenotypes [39, 40].


### 4.4. Applications ofpiggyBac Mutagenesis

The most benefiting application of insertional mutagenesis will be the ability to perform forward genetic screens to identify genes contributing to a phenotype of interest. A medium-scale forward genetic screen using approximately 200P. falciparum  piggyBac insertional mutants was able to identify several genes and pathways crucial for intraerythrocytic development of the parasite [41]. Although genes essential for in vitro intraerythrocytic development could not be identified due to the haploid genome, mutants with reduced growth rates of up to 70% could be isolated. It is also important to realize that many of the genes affected in these severely attenuated mutants might be essential for in vivo development, as the host immune system might effectively clear a slowly spreading infection. For example, disruption of the P. falciparum  ccr4-not associated factor 1 (caf1) results in severe attenuation of intraerythrocytic growth in vitro but, despite multiple attempts, the gene remains refractory to disruption in P. berghei, suggesting its essentiality in vivo [42].Another key finding of this forward genetic study inP. falciparum is the significance of nucleic acid binding and nucleic acid metabolism genes in intraerythrocytic development [41]. A majority of genes in this category includes RNA-binding proteins that play a potential role in posttranscriptional gene regulatory mechanisms, thus identifying this process as a high-value target for therapeutic intervention. A follow-up investigation of one of the genes identified in this study substantiates the potential of forward genetic screens in Plasmodium (Figure 3). Functional characterization of the caf1 null mutant reveals a critical role for this gene in temporal gene regulation in P. falciparum, and its disruption leads to premature egress from host cells, severely attenuating the intraerythrocytic growth rate [42], providing valuable insights into a largely unknown but critical parasite biological process. Further characterization of this gene regulatory pathway might identify other crucial parasite-specific proteins with great potential as antimalarial drug targets.Figure 3
An example of a successful forward genetic approach inP. falciparum.  A screen for attenuated intraerythrocytic growth indicates the significance of post-transcriptional gene regulation in these stages.  Functional characterization of CCR4-Associated Factor 1 has revealed a role in temporal regulation of gene expression in P. falciparum, implying its importance in intraerythrocytic development.While transposon-mediated mutagenesis does not offer a direct way to identify essential genes in the haploid blood stages, its ability to rapidly identify nonessential regions of the genome will be significant in directing our antimalarial drug discovery efforts. Genes that show no reduction in intraerythrocytic growth rate upon disruption can be immediately discarded from consideration as putative intraerythrocytic drug targets. However, their expression and functions in other life cycle stages should be considered for transmission-blocking strategies or for targeting the parasite liver stages.piggyBac offers an excellent vehicle for stable transgene expression in Plasmodium without constant drug pressure, which would be required during episomal expression [43–45]. Moreover, insertions in the noncoding regions that do not affect parasite growth can be readily obtained for use in drug-response assays. Expression of parasite proteins as GFP fusions using piggyBac allows subcellular localization studies to be performed with ease [44]. Since the insertions are stably maintained in the genome, genes expressed in other parasite life cycle stages can also be studied. DNA sequences up to 7 kb in length including the drug selection cassette can be inserted into the genome quite efficiently; however, longer sequences might require higher levels of transposase for efficient insertion. Most importantly, any parasite line of interest can be readily transformed with piggyBac unlike the mycobacteriophage Bxb1-based system, where genomic insertion of phage recombination sites through homologous recombination is a prerequisite to stable expression [46].Promoter trapping using transposable elements provided very useful information about gene expression in higher eukaryotes [47, 48]. Promoter trapping has been possible in both P. falciparum and P. berghei using piggyBac [37, 39]. However, in the current era of large-scale functional genomics, whole-genome transcriptome and other expression studies have provided abundant information about timing and levels of gene expression in Plasmodium and the information obtained from promoter trapping might be insignificant. Also, while promoter trapping can help determine active promoters, it cannot identify the exact promoter region, which would still have to be determined through conventional reporter assays.


## 4.1. Rationale

Reverse genetic studies inPlasmodium, especially in the most lethal human malaria parasite P. falciparum, have been hampered by low efficiencies of transfection and homologous recombination [8]. Although a few medium-scale gene knockout approaches have been attempted in P. falciparum, they were extremely tedious, labor intensive, and fall much short of the genome-wide knockouts needed for rationalized drug and vaccine design [29, 30]. Forward genetic studies might offer a quicker and more efficient way to characterize the Plasmodium genome. The transposition event, which includes finding one target sequence from hundreds of thousands in the genome, should be much more efficient than homologous recombination at a single locus in the genome. Performing genetic screens might thus be faster and more effective in identifying genes involved in critical biological processes of the parasite.ThepiggyBac transposable element has been used extensively for insertional mutagenesis in numerous invertebrate and vertebrate species [31–35]. The ability to transmobilize piggyBac, through separate expression of the piggyBac transposase, has immensely contributed to the wide adaptability of the system to multiple organisms [36]. piggybac’s ability to more randomly insert into the genome, compared to other transposable elements, increases the likelihood of achieving genome-wide insertions and supports its application in insertional mutagenesis studies [35]. The target site for piggyBac insertion is TTAA and more than 300,000 TTAA target sites can be found in the AT-rich Plasmodium genome, providing a platform for genome-wide mutagenesis [37].


## 4.2. Methodology

ThepiggyBac system was first successfully adapted to P.  falciparum [38] and has recently been extended to P. berghei [39]. The basic design for piggyBac insertional mutagenesis in Plasmodium uses a two-plasmid approach. The first plasmid consists of a Plasmodium drug selection cassette flanked by the piggyBac5′ and 3′ terminal repeats, and the second plasmid drives the expression of the piggyBac transposase, required for the enzymatic cleavage and genomic insertion of the piggyBac terminal repeats (Figure 2). The transposase plasmid lacks a drug-selection cassette and is lost in a few generations, thereby preventing continuous movement of piggyBac. In P. berghei, a transgenic line containing the piggyBac transposase in the genome was also shown to be very effective in insertional mutagenesis and remobilization of previously inserted piggyBac element [39]. The precise insertion and excision mechanisms of piggyBac leave no footprints behind following remobilization, allowing phenotype rescue of any knockout [34].Figure 2
Basic plasmid designs forpiggyBac mutagenesis in Plasmodium.  The donor plasmid consists of a Plasmodium drug selection cassette flanked by the terminal repeats (TR) of piggyBac.  The helper plasmid provides the piggyBac transposase, which mediates the transposition event into the Plasmodium genome upon cotransfection with the donor plasmid.


## 4.3. Efficiency ofpiggyBac Mutagenesis in Plasmodium

piggyBac insertions into the genome can be obtained within 3-4 weeks in P. falciparum compared to 6–12 months needed to obtain homologous recombination events, and 1–10 insertions can be obtained per transfection depending on the conditions used [38]. Genomic insertions of piggyBac can be obtained in much higher numbers in P. berghei due to its increased transfection efficiency. Analyses of approximately 200 piggyBac insertion sites in P. falciparum and 120 in P. berghei show an almost equal distribution in the coding and noncoding regions of the genome, as predicted by the equal distribution of TTAA target sites in both coding and noncoding regions [39, 40]. This is an important finding considering the higher AT-richness in the noncoding regions of the genome. While a slight bias was observed for insertions into the 5′ untranslated regions (UTRs) of genes in the initial study in P. falciparum, this bias was most likely due to the higher growth rate of clones with insertions in UTRs compared to those with insertions in coding sequences, in a mixed population of transformed parasites, and this bias for 5′ UTRs was not observed in experiments where the transfection was followed by immediate cloning of parasites (Balu and Adams, unpublished data).There appears to be no striking bias for insertion into any particular chromosome or chromosomal region. Furthermore,piggyBac inserts into genes of all functional categories and shows no significant preference for genes expressed in the transformed blood stages. An equivalent number of piggyBac insertions were observed in genes exclusively expressed in other parasite life cycle stages, indicating the accessibility to these genes in the parasite’s blood stages. Such observations confirm the randomness of piggyBac insertions and demonstrate its effectiveness as a tool for genome-wide insertional mutagenesis in Plasmodium. Additionally, in both P. falciparum and P. berghei, mostly single piggyBac insertions are obtained per genome, allowing easy correlation of genotypes to their respective phenotypes [39, 40].


## 4.4. Applications ofpiggyBac Mutagenesis

The most benefiting application of insertional mutagenesis will be the ability to perform forward genetic screens to identify genes contributing to a phenotype of interest. A medium-scale forward genetic screen using approximately 200P. falciparum  piggyBac insertional mutants was able to identify several genes and pathways crucial for intraerythrocytic development of the parasite [41]. Although genes essential for in vitro intraerythrocytic development could not be identified due to the haploid genome, mutants with reduced growth rates of up to 70% could be isolated. It is also important to realize that many of the genes affected in these severely attenuated mutants might be essential for in vivo development, as the host immune system might effectively clear a slowly spreading infection. For example, disruption of the P. falciparum  ccr4-not associated factor 1 (caf1) results in severe attenuation of intraerythrocytic growth in vitro but, despite multiple attempts, the gene remains refractory to disruption in P. berghei, suggesting its essentiality in vivo [42].Another key finding of this forward genetic study inP. falciparum is the significance of nucleic acid binding and nucleic acid metabolism genes in intraerythrocytic development [41]. A majority of genes in this category includes RNA-binding proteins that play a potential role in posttranscriptional gene regulatory mechanisms, thus identifying this process as a high-value target for therapeutic intervention. A follow-up investigation of one of the genes identified in this study substantiates the potential of forward genetic screens in Plasmodium (Figure 3). Functional characterization of the caf1 null mutant reveals a critical role for this gene in temporal gene regulation in P. falciparum, and its disruption leads to premature egress from host cells, severely attenuating the intraerythrocytic growth rate [42], providing valuable insights into a largely unknown but critical parasite biological process. Further characterization of this gene regulatory pathway might identify other crucial parasite-specific proteins with great potential as antimalarial drug targets.Figure 3
An example of a successful forward genetic approach inP. falciparum.  A screen for attenuated intraerythrocytic growth indicates the significance of post-transcriptional gene regulation in these stages.  Functional characterization of CCR4-Associated Factor 1 has revealed a role in temporal regulation of gene expression in P. falciparum, implying its importance in intraerythrocytic development.While transposon-mediated mutagenesis does not offer a direct way to identify essential genes in the haploid blood stages, its ability to rapidly identify nonessential regions of the genome will be significant in directing our antimalarial drug discovery efforts. Genes that show no reduction in intraerythrocytic growth rate upon disruption can be immediately discarded from consideration as putative intraerythrocytic drug targets. However, their expression and functions in other life cycle stages should be considered for transmission-blocking strategies or for targeting the parasite liver stages.piggyBac offers an excellent vehicle for stable transgene expression in Plasmodium without constant drug pressure, which would be required during episomal expression [43–45]. Moreover, insertions in the noncoding regions that do not affect parasite growth can be readily obtained for use in drug-response assays. Expression of parasite proteins as GFP fusions using piggyBac allows subcellular localization studies to be performed with ease [44]. Since the insertions are stably maintained in the genome, genes expressed in other parasite life cycle stages can also be studied. DNA sequences up to 7 kb in length including the drug selection cassette can be inserted into the genome quite efficiently; however, longer sequences might require higher levels of transposase for efficient insertion. Most importantly, any parasite line of interest can be readily transformed with piggyBac unlike the mycobacteriophage Bxb1-based system, where genomic insertion of phage recombination sites through homologous recombination is a prerequisite to stable expression [46].Promoter trapping using transposable elements provided very useful information about gene expression in higher eukaryotes [47, 48]. Promoter trapping has been possible in both P. falciparum and P. berghei using piggyBac [37, 39]. However, in the current era of large-scale functional genomics, whole-genome transcriptome and other expression studies have provided abundant information about timing and levels of gene expression in Plasmodium and the information obtained from promoter trapping might be insignificant. Also, while promoter trapping can help determine active promoters, it cannot identify the exact promoter region, which would still have to be determined through conventional reporter assays.


## 5. Future Directions

While the ability to obtain genomic integrations is tremendously high withpiggyBac compared to homologous recombination, we are still faced with the challenge of low transfection efficiency in Plasmodium. Successful forward genetic screens in other organisms usually involve achieving a “saturation” level of mutagenesis, where every gene in the genome has been perturbed in a single experiment. This might not be possible even in P. berghei, which can be transfected at a much higher efficiency than P. falciparum and where remobilization of piggyBac can be achieved. One should also be wary of the complications that could arise in correlating genotypes to phenotypes in case of uncontrolled remobilization events, and tight regulation of remobilization events will be a necessity for increasing genomic integration events without repeated transfections.Increasing the mutant pool available for screens is of high priority for the future. Since almost half of thepiggyBac insertions occur in noncoding regions, they may or may not affect gene expression. The most direct information from forward genetic screens can be obtained by using mutants with disrupted coding sequences, and obtaining as many of them as possible should be one of the prime objectives. Instead of overly speculating about reaching saturation level mutagenesis, the number of experiments needed to disrupt a significant number of genes, and comparison of transformation efficiencies with higher eukaryotes, it might be most beneficial to understand the limitations of Plasmodium genetics and make the best use of this system by generating a large number of single insertional mutant clones that could be used in screens. Performing screens in a mixed population of mutants, even if saturation level mutagenesis were possible, would present several challenges in Plasmodium. Negative phenotypic screens, such as attenuated growth, failure to produce gametocytes, and inability to infect the mosquito vector, will be of highest interest but extremely difficult to perform and tease out in mixed populations. Even if the phenotype were narrowed down to a set of genes, the lack of robust genetic complementation tools would severely limit further characterization.Considerable attention must also be given to developing new genetic screens targeted towards the many intriguing features of parasite development and pathogenesis. For example, phenotypic screens for adherence to endothelial cells, which is a critical component of disease pathogenesis, could identify novel mediators of this process. Screens directed towards the development of other parasite life cycle stages, such as gametocytes and sporozoites, should provide novel candidates for transmission-blocking strategies and contribute immensely to disease control and prevention strategies.The biggest limitation of insertional mutagenesis inPlasmodium is the inability to mutate and identify genes essential for blood stage development, as only the haploid blood stages of the parasite can be transfected. To overcome this deficiency, novel experimental designs that combine the piggyBac system with a conditional expression system such as the anhydrotetracycline-(ATc-) regulated system [49], need to be developed. One could envision placing the ATc-regulated promoter in between the piggyBac terminal repeats such that, upon insertion into the genome, it replaces an endogenous promoter but is still able to drive the expression of the downstream gene (Figure 4). Addition of ATc would turn off the expression of the downstream gene and its essentiality in blood-stage development could be evaluated. However, several factors would need to be considered for such an approach to work. Since piggyBac terminal repeats could be inserted into the genome in either orientation, it might be best to place two ATc-regulated promoters in between the piggyBac terminal repeats, one near each terminal repeat (Figure 4). The effectiveness of this system will depend upon its insertion in the 5′ UTR of a gene, and the similarity between the timing of expression from the ATc-regulated promoter and the endogenous promoter. Furthermore, the robustness of the ATc-regulated system would need to be tested as leaky expression through the ATc-regulated promoter would hinder the identification of essential genes. More robust systems using Plasmodium-specific factors might be required for tight regulation of gene expression.Figure 4
A putative scheme for identifying essential genes inPlasmodium using piggyBac mutagenesis.  The piggyBac plasmid containing two anhydrotetracycline-(ATc-) regulated promoters, one near each terminal repeat (TR), can be first inserted into the Plasmodium genome.  Upon insertion into the 5′ region of a gene, its endogenous promoter (EP) will be replaced by the ATc-regulated promoter.  Addition of ATc will block transcription of the gene, allowing the evaluation of its essentiality.In summary, the introduction of transposon mutagenesis toPlasmodium has provided new exploratory avenues to study this important parasite. With further refinement of the system and an increase in the mutant pool, a variety of forward genetic studies should be feasible and provide exciting discoveries about the malaria parasite’s enigmatic biology that could be exploited for developing novel antimalarial strategies.



---

*Source: 829210-2012-05-08.xml*