# Primary Spinal Germ Cell Tumors: A Case Analysis and Review of Treatment Paradigms

Authors: Joshua J. Loya; Henry Jung; Caroline Temmins; Nam Cho; Harminder Singh
Journal: Case Reports in Medicine
 (2013)

---

## Abstract

Objective. Primary intramedullary spinal germ cell tumors are exceedingly rare. As such, there are no established treatment paradigms. We describe our management for spinal germ cell tumors and a review of the literature. Clinical Presentation. We describe the case of a 45-year-old man with progressive lower extremity weakness and sensory deficits. He was found to have enhancing intramedullary mass lesions in the thoracic spinal cord, and pathology was consistent with an intramedullary germ cell tumor. A video presentation of the case and surgical approach is provided. Conclusion. As spinal cord germinomas are highly sensitive to radiation and chemotherapy, a patient can be spared radical surgery. Diverse treatment approaches exist across institutions. We advocate biopsy followed by local radiation, with or without adjuvant chemotherapy, as the optimal treatment for these tumors. Histological findings have prognostic value if syncytiotrophoblastic giant cells (STGCs) are found, which are associated with a higher rate of recurrence. The recurrence rate in STGC-positive spinal germinomas is 33% (2/6), whereas it is only 8% in STGC-negative tumors (2/24). We advocate limited volume radiotherapy combined with systemic chemotherapy in patients with high risk of recurrence. To reduce endocrine and neurocognitive side effects, cranio-spinal radiation should be used as a last resort in patients with recurrence.


---

## Body

## 1. Introduction

Germ cell tumors are similar in histology to germinal cells of the genital organs, and they may aberrantly arise in the central nervous system (CNS). Germ cell tumors account for 1% of all CNS tumors, and they are seen more frequently in Japan (3%) and East Asia (12.5%) [1]. They usually occur in the pineal or suprasellar regions and less frequently in the thalamus, basal ganglia, or ventricles. Spinal seeding of a germ cell tumor has been well documented in the form of drop metastases [2–4]; however, extremely rarely, germ cell tumors may be found within the spinal cord as a primary tumor.We present a patient with a primary intramedullary thoracic germ cell tumor. This patient is one of only a handful of reports of a primary spinal germ cell tumor from the western hemisphere (Table1).Table 1
Reported cases of primary spinal germ cell tumors.
Patient no.
Series
Country
Age/sex
Location
Medullary
Operation
Radiation craniospinal (Gy)
Radiation Local (Gy)
Chemotherapy
HCG
STGC
Followup
Recurrence
1
Hisa et al. [5]
Japan
5/M
T11-L3
IM, EM
Bx
—
35 + 75
Actinomycin + methotrexate + vincristine/bleomycin + cisplatin + vinblastine
+
+
6 months
R, NR after amputation of spinal cord
2
Zhu et al. [6]
China
7/M
T12-L1
IM
PR
ND
ND
—
+
+
—
—
3
Slagel et al. [7]
Japan
16/F
T11-L4
IM, EM
PR
—
30
—
—
—
28 months
NR
4
Aoyama et al. [8]
Japan
16/F
T9-T12
IM
PR
—
30.6
Ifosfamide + cisplatin + etoposide
+
—
3 years
NR
5
Chute et al. [9]
US
18/M
T6-T8
IM
Bx
—
50
—
+
—
6 months
NR
6
Huang et al. [10]
US
18/M
C3-C6
IM
PR
ND
ND
Bleomycin + cisplatin + etoposide
—
—
6 months
NR
7
Kiyuna et al. [11]
Japan
20/F
T11-L3
EM
TR
30.4
40
—
—
—
2 years
NR
8
Massimino et al. [12]
Italy
20/M
L2
IM
TR
30
9
Cisplatin + etoposide + bleomycin
+
+
33 months
NR
9
Kinoshita et al. [13]
Japan
21/F
T9-T11, L2-L3
IM
PR
—
25.2
Carboplatin + etoposide
—
—
3 years
NR
10
Takahashi et al. [14]
Japan
22/F
L1-L2
IM, EM
PR
57
30.6
Ifosfamide + carboplatin or cisplatin + etoposide
+
—
1.5 years
NR
11
Yamagata et al. [15]
Japan
24/F
T6-T7
IM
PR
25.6
19.8
Ifosfamide + cisplatin + etoposide
+
+
6 months
NR
12
Kawano and Tsujimura [16]
Japan
24/M
L1-L3
IM, EM
PR
16
40
—
—
—
ND
NR
13
Itoh et al. [17]
Japan
24/M
T11-T12
IM
TR
24.1
52.1
—
—
—
13 months
NR
14
Miyauchi et al. [18]
Japan
24/M
T12-L3
IM, EM
PR
15
40
—
—
—
15 months
NR
15
Nakata et al. [19]
Japan
27/M
T7-T9
IM
PR
—
48
—
—
—
1 year
R
16
Biswas et al. [20]
India
28/M
L2-L4
EM
TR
—
20
Bleomycin + cisplatin + etoposide
+
+
11 months
R
17
Tekkök and Sav
[21]
Turkey
28/M
L1-S2
EM
TR
54
51
Cisplatin + etoposide + bleomycin
—
—
22 months
R, NR after chemotherapy and reresection
18
Ganslandt et al. [22]
Germany
29/M
T12-L4
IM
TR
32
18.4
—
—
—
2 years
NR
19
Matsuoka et al. [23]
Japan
31/F
T12-L2
IM
PR
—
50
—
—
—
15 months
NR
20
Nagasawa et al. [24]
Japan
31/M
Midcervical
IM
—
—
51
—
—
—
40 months
NR
21
Sasaki et al. [25]
Japan
32/F
T3-T4
IM
—
27.5
19.8
Methotrexate + etoposide
+
+
5 years
NR
22
Watanabe et al. [26]
Japan
33/F
T1-T3
IM
PR
—
30
Carboplatin + etoposide
ND
—
1 year
NR
23
Hata et al. [27]
Japan
33/M
T7-T9
IM
PR
—
36
Carboplatin + etoposide
—
—
38 months
NR
24
Yamagata et al. [15]
Japan
33/M
T9-T11
IM
PR
24
—
Cisplatin + etoposide
—
—
2 years
NR
25
Hanafusa et al. [28]
Japan
34/F
T10-T11
IM
TR
30
45
—
—
—
24 months
NR
26
Matsuyama et al. [29]
Japan
34/F
T6-T8
IM
PR
—
46
—
—
—
12 months
NR
27
Aoyama et al. [8]
Japan
34/F
T8-T10
IM
Bx
—
30.6
Ifosfamide + cisplatin + etoposide
+
—
2 years
NR
28
Nakata et al. [19]
Japan
35/M
T6-T7
IM
TR
24
—
Carboplatin + etoposide
+
—
2 years
NR
29
Horvath et al. [30]
Japan
43/M
L1-L2
EM
TR
36
14
—
—
—
8 months
NR
30
Present case
USA
45/M
T2-T5
IM
PR
—
45
—
—
—
22 months
NR
Bx: biopsy; PR: partial resection; TR: total resection; HCG:β-human chorionic gonadotropin; STGC: syncytiotrophoblastic giant cells; M: male; F: female; R: recurrence; NR: norecurrence; bold font: patients with recurrence; IM: intramedullary; EM: extramedullary.


## 2. Case Report

### 2.1. Presentation

A 45-year-old man presented with numbness and weakness in his lower extremities, worsening over the course of a year. His weakness substantially worsened over the 4 months prior to presentation, during which he became fully dependent on a walker. He was also intermittently incontinent of urine and chronically constipated.On physical examination, from the T2 level and below, he had right loss greater than left loss of light touch, pinprick, and proprioception sensation. On motor examination, his right leg strength was 0/5 and his left leg strength was 4/5. He had bilateral clonus and muscle spasms in his legs.


### 2.2. Imaging

Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) demonstrated intramedullary signal within the upper thoracic spinal cord with diffuse enhancement and cord expansion (Figure1). Imaging of the remaining neural axis was negative. Testicular ultrasound and a CT of chest, abdomen, and pelvis were normal. Serum and CSF levels of AFP and β-HCG were within normal limits.Figure 1
Preoperative thoracic MRI shows three sagittal sequences (T1, T2, and T1 with gadolinium) on the left and an axial (T1 with gadolinium) on the right demonstrating an intramedullary mass between T2 and T5 (arrow).Differential diagnosis of this lesion included primary spinal cord neoplasm, such as astrocytoma and ependymoma, hemangioblastoma, intradural metastasis, and lymphoma. Ischemia and lupus myelitis were also included in the differential diagnosis. The patient was taken for open biopsy/resection of this lesion.


### 2.3. Operation

The patient was placed prone on the operating room table. Motor and sensory neuromonitoring was established prior to incision. Motor evoked potentials (MEPs) and somatosensory evoked potentials (SSEPs) were absent below the level of the lesion. The correct levels were ascertained using fluoroscopy. Bilateral laminectomies were then performed at T3, T4, and T5. After the thecal sac was decompressed, attention was turned towards opening the dura and identifying the tumor. At this time, the microscope was brought into the operation. Under the microscope, the dura was opened. The cord was noted to have yellow discoloration, but otherwise no gross abnormality was observed (see supplemental video in Supplementary Material available online athttp://dx.doi.org/10.1155/2013/798358, which demonstrates surgical approach and technique).The posterior median sulcus was then identified, and a midline myelotomy was performed. Upon entering the cord, the abnormal tissue appeared grayish and invasive and displayed no clear border between tumor and normal tissue. A biopsy sample was sent to pathology. An intraoperative frozen section favored a malignant metastasis or high-grade tumor. Given its lack of clear boundaries, poor neuromonitoring signals, and the risk of further compromise of his remaining neurological function, aggressive tumor debulking was not pursued.


### 2.4. Pathology

Pathology demonstrated the typical two-cell pattern of germinomas (Figure2). There was an infiltrate of cells with large prominent nuclei with well-defined borders and clear cytoplasm (see supplemental video for pathology images). There were also small round lymphocytes infiltrating the stroma. Immunohistologic staining was positive for placental alkaline phosphatase (PLAP), OCT3/4, and CD117. That, along with the dot-like positivity of the cytokeratin AE1/AE3, supported the diagnosis of a germ cell tumor. No syncytiotrophoblastic giant cells (STGCs) were present.Figure 2
Two-cell pattern of germ cell tumors (hematoxylin and eosin stain).


### 2.5. Postoperative Course

This patient received standard, fractionated external beam radiation therapy totaling 45 Gy in 1.8 Gy fractions to the upper thoracic spine. The patient’s neurological symptoms remained stable throughout his treatment course with mild improvement of the right lower extremity strength. Repeat imaging at 4 months showed complete resolution of the intramedullary spinal cord lesion. He received no chemotherapy due to his excellent response to radiation treatment. At 1-year followup, he remained free of radiographic evidence of disease with no drop metastases (Figure3), and at 23-month followup, he remained stable on clinical evaluation.Figure 3
Postoperative MRI at 1-year followup shows 3 sagittal sequences (T1, T2, and T1 with gadolinium) on the left and an axial (T1 with gadolinium) on the right demonstrating no evidence of tumor recurrence.


## 2.1. Presentation

A 45-year-old man presented with numbness and weakness in his lower extremities, worsening over the course of a year. His weakness substantially worsened over the 4 months prior to presentation, during which he became fully dependent on a walker. He was also intermittently incontinent of urine and chronically constipated.On physical examination, from the T2 level and below, he had right loss greater than left loss of light touch, pinprick, and proprioception sensation. On motor examination, his right leg strength was 0/5 and his left leg strength was 4/5. He had bilateral clonus and muscle spasms in his legs.


## 2.2. Imaging

Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) demonstrated intramedullary signal within the upper thoracic spinal cord with diffuse enhancement and cord expansion (Figure1). Imaging of the remaining neural axis was negative. Testicular ultrasound and a CT of chest, abdomen, and pelvis were normal. Serum and CSF levels of AFP and β-HCG were within normal limits.Figure 1
Preoperative thoracic MRI shows three sagittal sequences (T1, T2, and T1 with gadolinium) on the left and an axial (T1 with gadolinium) on the right demonstrating an intramedullary mass between T2 and T5 (arrow).Differential diagnosis of this lesion included primary spinal cord neoplasm, such as astrocytoma and ependymoma, hemangioblastoma, intradural metastasis, and lymphoma. Ischemia and lupus myelitis were also included in the differential diagnosis. The patient was taken for open biopsy/resection of this lesion.


## 2.3. Operation

The patient was placed prone on the operating room table. Motor and sensory neuromonitoring was established prior to incision. Motor evoked potentials (MEPs) and somatosensory evoked potentials (SSEPs) were absent below the level of the lesion. The correct levels were ascertained using fluoroscopy. Bilateral laminectomies were then performed at T3, T4, and T5. After the thecal sac was decompressed, attention was turned towards opening the dura and identifying the tumor. At this time, the microscope was brought into the operation. Under the microscope, the dura was opened. The cord was noted to have yellow discoloration, but otherwise no gross abnormality was observed (see supplemental video in Supplementary Material available online athttp://dx.doi.org/10.1155/2013/798358, which demonstrates surgical approach and technique).The posterior median sulcus was then identified, and a midline myelotomy was performed. Upon entering the cord, the abnormal tissue appeared grayish and invasive and displayed no clear border between tumor and normal tissue. A biopsy sample was sent to pathology. An intraoperative frozen section favored a malignant metastasis or high-grade tumor. Given its lack of clear boundaries, poor neuromonitoring signals, and the risk of further compromise of his remaining neurological function, aggressive tumor debulking was not pursued.


## 2.4. Pathology

Pathology demonstrated the typical two-cell pattern of germinomas (Figure2). There was an infiltrate of cells with large prominent nuclei with well-defined borders and clear cytoplasm (see supplemental video for pathology images). There were also small round lymphocytes infiltrating the stroma. Immunohistologic staining was positive for placental alkaline phosphatase (PLAP), OCT3/4, and CD117. That, along with the dot-like positivity of the cytokeratin AE1/AE3, supported the diagnosis of a germ cell tumor. No syncytiotrophoblastic giant cells (STGCs) were present.Figure 2
Two-cell pattern of germ cell tumors (hematoxylin and eosin stain).


## 2.5. Postoperative Course

This patient received standard, fractionated external beam radiation therapy totaling 45 Gy in 1.8 Gy fractions to the upper thoracic spine. The patient’s neurological symptoms remained stable throughout his treatment course with mild improvement of the right lower extremity strength. Repeat imaging at 4 months showed complete resolution of the intramedullary spinal cord lesion. He received no chemotherapy due to his excellent response to radiation treatment. At 1-year followup, he remained free of radiographic evidence of disease with no drop metastases (Figure3), and at 23-month followup, he remained stable on clinical evaluation.Figure 3
Postoperative MRI at 1-year followup shows 3 sagittal sequences (T1, T2, and T1 with gadolinium) on the left and an axial (T1 with gadolinium) on the right demonstrating no evidence of tumor recurrence.


## 3. Discussion and Review of the Literature

We found 29 reported cases of primary spinal germ cell tumors in the literature, most having been described in young Japanese adults (22/29) (Table1). Spinal germinomas appear to occur slightly more often in males than in females (60% males versus 40% females). Similarly, pineal germinomas have a significantly higher incidence in males than in females [31]. Like intracranial germinomas, spinal germinomas occur primarily in the young population. We found the mean age to be approximately 26 years old with a median age of 28 years, ranging from 5 to 45 years. Our 45-year-old patient was the oldest of the cohort.Spinal germinomas occurred most frequently within the thoracic spinal cord (47%), followed by the thoracolumbar area (27%), the lumbar area (20%), and least frequently the cervical spinal cord (7%). Spinal germinomas are also primarily seen intramedullary in 70% of cases. They had both intramedullary and extramedullary components in 17% of cases and were purely extramedullary in 13% of cases.Histological findings of CNS germinomas may have prognostic value if STGCs are found, as these are associated with poorer prognosis and a higher rate of recurrence [32]. While STGCs characteristically produce β-HCG, which may lead to CSF or serum elevation of this hormone, elevated β-HCG levels do not definitively indicate the presence of STGCs.We found that while 37% (11/30) of cases had elevated levels ofβ-HCG, only 55% (6/11) of these 11 were STGC positive. However, 100% of cases that were STGC positive were also β-HCG positive (6/6) (Table 1).The overall recurrence rate of spinal cord germinomas after treatment was 13% (4/30), bolded in Table1. The recurrence rate in STGC-positive germinomas was 33% (2/6), whereas the recurrence rate was only 8% (2/24) in STGC-negative tumors (Table 1).Clinical symptoms and imaging features of primary spinal germ cell tumors are often indistinguishable from other spinal cord neoplasms. Only histological examination can establish a definitive diagnosis. If frozen-section biopsy during surgery suggests the possible diagnosis of germinoma, radical resection of the tumor should not be undertaken. However, if frozen section favors a high-grade tumor (as in our case), the extent of resection must be guided by preoperative neurological function, the reliability of neuromonitoring signals, the extent of cord compression, and the amount of medullary invasion.Like intracranial germinomas, spinal cord germinomas are also highly sensitive to radiation. Most cases can be successfully treated with external beam radiotherapy despite the lack of standard guidelines for fractionation and dose. In our particular case, 3D conformal external beam radiation therapy (EBRT) was utilized to treat the spinal cord from C7 to T7.  This field was treated to a dose of 45 Gy in 25 fractions using 15 MV photons and AP/PA portals.  Daily kV imaging was performed for image-guided radiotherapy (IGRT) to ensure precise patient positioning. In our review, we found the average amount of local radiation to be 35.7 ± 13.4 Gy and the average amount of craniospinal radiation to be 30.4 ± 12.1 Gy. In order to reduce the endocrine and neurocognitive side effects of craniospinal radiation, it should be reserved for patients with STGC-positive tumors or patients with recurrence.Intracranial germ cell tumors are also highly sensitive to chemotherapy, especially to platinum and alkylating agents. However, there are no standard guidelines for chemotherapy for spinal germinomas. In our case review, 50% of the patients received systemic chemotherapy.The common chemotherapeutic agents found to be effective for CNS germinomas are cisplatin, bleomycin, vinblastine, and etoposide.  The treatment with chemotherapy alone in CNS germinomas has been investigated [33]. In one study, 37 of 45 patients (82%) had a complete response to chemotherapy, but 20 of these patients relapsed at 18 months (median time) from diagnosis. Fortunately, most of these patients were salvaged with further therapy, which included radiation. Other reports corroborate that chemotherapy alone may have increased rates of relapse with subsequent need for salvage radiation [34].One report describes the complete remission of a pineal gland germinoma after 2 cycles of BEP therapy (bleomycin, etoposide, and cisplatin) with no further need for radiotherapy [35]. However, the patient of this report was only followed up for 15 months following tumor eradication. Others have reported great success in treating solitary pure germinomas with 3 or 4 cycles of cisplatin and etoposide (EP regimen), followed by 24 Gy local radiation therapy, as well as in treating HCG-secreting, multifocal, or disseminated germinomas with 4 to 5 cycles of ifosfamide, cisplatin, and etoposide (ICE regimen), followed by 24 Gy local radiation therapy [36]. Thus, the EP and ICE regimens can be highly effective in treating CNS germinomas and can reduce the dose and volume of radiotherapy.Generally, some form of radiation is recommended to maintain long-term control. Although chemotherapy has the advantage of decreasing the total dose of radiation, chemotherapy can have significant side effects. A treatment regimen consisting of PVB therapy (cisplatin, vinblastine, and bleomycin) or BEP therapy avoids the use of alkylating agents and can spare sterility; yet it can have significant renal and auditory toxicity [37]. Other long-term complications of chemotherapy have been recognized, such as secondary leukemia and solid tumors.


## 4. Conclusion

Although primary spinal cord germinomas are extremely rare, there are reports of these tumors primarily in the Japanese literature. Definitive diagnosis is imperative. As spinal cord germinomas are highly sensitive to radiation and chemotherapy, a patient can be spared radical surgery. Recurrence of spinal germinomas is uncommon and associated with STGC positivity.We advocate surgical biopsy followed by local radiation, with or without adjuvant chemotherapy, as the optimal means of treatment of spinal germ cell tumors with low risk of recurrence. Taking cue from the management of intracranial germ cell tumors, limited volume radiotherapy combined with systemic chemotherapy should be offered in patients with high risk of recurrence, for example, those with high serum/CSF B-HCG levels and intratumoral presence of STGCs.Craniospinal irradiation should be used as a last resort (due to its many neuroendocrine and neurocognitive side effects) in patients with recurrence.



---

*Source: 798358-2013-11-07.xml*