# A 7-Level Single DC Source Cascaded H-Bridge Multilevel Inverter with a Modified DTC Scheme for Induction Motor-Based Electric Vehicle Propulsion

Authors: Farid Khoucha; Khoudir Marouani; Mohamed Benbouzid; Abdelaziz Kheloui; Abdeslam Mamoune
Journal: International Journal of Vehicular Technology
 (2013)

---

## Abstract

This paper presents a new hybrid cascaded H-bridge multilevel inverter motor drive DTC scheme for electric vehicles where each phase of the inverter can be implemented using a single DC source. Traditionally, each phase of the inverter requiresn DC source for 2n+1 output voltage levels. In this paper, a scheme is proposed that allows the use of a single DC source as the first DC source which would be available from batteries or fuel cells, with the remaining (n−1) DC sources being capacitors. This scheme can simultaneously maintain the capacitors of DC voltage level and produce a nearly sinusoidal output voltage due to its high number of output levels. In this context, high performances and efficient torque and flux control are obtained, enabling a DTC solution for hybrid multilevel inverter powered induction motor drives intended for electric vehicle propulsion. Simulations and experiments show that the proposed multilevel inverter and control scheme are effective and very attractive for embedded systems such as automotive applications.


---

## Body

## 1. Introduction

Currently, automotive applications such as EV’s seem to constitute an increasingly effective alternative to conventional vehicles, allowing vehicle manufacturers to fulfill users requirements (dynamic performances and fuel consumption) and environmental constraints (pollutant emissions reduction) [1].The electric propulsion system is the heart of EV. It consists of the motor drive, transmission device, and wheels. In fact, the motor drive, comprising the electric motor, the power converter, and the electronic controller, is the core of the EV propulsion system. The motor drive is configured to respond to a torque demand set by the driver [2].The induction motor seems to be a very interesting solution for EV’s propulsion. FOC and DTC have emerged as the standard industrial solutions to achieve high dynamic performance [3–5]. However some drawbacks of both methods have motivated important research efforts in the last decades. Particularly for DTC, the high torque ripple and the variable switching frequency introduced by the hysteresis comparators have been extensively addressed [6, 7]. In addition, several contributions that combine DTC principles together with PWM and SVM have been reported to correct these problems. This approach is based on the load angle control, from which a voltage reference vector is computed which is finally modulated by the inverter [8]. Although one major feature of classic DTC is the absence of modulators and linear controllers, this approach has shown significant improvements and achieves similar dynamic performance.On the other hand, power converter technology is continuously developing, and cascaded multilevel inverters have become a very attractive solution for EV applications, due to its modular structure, higher voltage capability, reduced common mode voltages, near sinusoidal outputs, and smaller or even no output filter [9–12]. In general, cascaded multilevel inverter may be classified in two groups. The first one refers to the amplitude of isolated DC sources devoted to supply each H-bridge cell. If the amplitude of all sources is equal, then the inverter is called symmetrical; otherwise, if at least one of the sources presents different amplitude, then it will be called asymmetrical. The second classification labels the multilevel inverter whether hybrid or not. If the converter is implemented with different semiconductor device technologies, different nature of DC sources (fuel cells, batteries, and supercapacitors) and/or if it presents a hybrid modulation strategy, then it is classified as hybrid [13–15]. This structure greatly simplifies the converter complexity.The proposed control algorithm eliminates the need of additional isolated DC sources. The control strategy regulates the DC link voltages of capacitors connected to the smallest voltages of a two-cell 7-level cascaded H-bridge inverter [16]. Specifically and in comparison to previous works [17, 18], the proposed control does not use an angle for capacitor voltage regulation but a comparison voltage level. This will facilitate a DSP implementation.The carried out simulations and experiments validate the voltage control strategy and confirm the high dynamic performance of the proposed method, presenting very low torque ripple.


## 2. Multilevel Inverter Topology

The power circuit of the cascaded H-bridge multilevel inverter is illustrated in Figure1. The inverter is composed by the series  connection of power cells, each one containing an H-bridge inverter and an isolated DC source. In the particular case of asymmetric inverters these sources are not equal (V1>V2). The asymmetry of the input voltages can reduce or, when properly designed, eliminate redundant output levels, maximizing the number of different levels generated by the inverter. Therefore, this topology can achieve the same output voltage quality with less number of semiconductors, space, costs, and internal fault probability than the symmetric fed topology.Figure 1
Hybrid cascaded multilevel converter topology.A particular celli can generate three voltage levels (+Vi,0,-Vi). The total inverter output voltage for a particular phase j is then defined by
(1)viN=∑j=1mvij=∑j=1mVj(Sj1-Sj2),i∈{a,b,c},
where viN is the total output voltage of phase i (resp., the neutral of the inverter N), the output voltage of cell of phase, and the switching state associated to cell.It should be noticed how the output voltage of one cell is defined by one of the four binary combinations of the switching state, with “1” and “0” representing the “On” and “Off” states of the corresponding switch, respectively.The inverter generates different voltage levels (e.g., an inverter withm=4 cells can generate (2m+1-1=31) different voltage levels). When using three-phase systems, the number of different voltage vectors is given by 3nl(nl-1)+1, where nl is the number of levels. For example, for the m=4 case with 31 levels there are 2791 different voltage vectors. Table 1 summarizes the output levels for an asymmetric 7-level inverter using only m=2 cells per phase (only phase voltage is given). An example of the voltage waveform for an asymmetric 7-level inverter is illustrated by Figure 2.Table 1
7-Level asymmetric cascaded inverter switching states.
n
l
Cell 1
Cell 2
Total
S
11
S
12
v
a
1
S
21
S
22
v
a
2
v
a
N
1
1
0
3vDC
0
0
0
3vDC
2
1
0
3vDC
0
1
-
v
DC
2vDC
3
0
0
0
1
0
v
DC
v
DC
4
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
5
0
0
0
0
1
-
v
DC
−vDC
6
0
1
−3vDC
1
0
v
DC
−2vDC
7
0
1
−3vDC
0
0
0
−3vDCFigure 2
Asymmetric multilevel inverter with 7-level output voltage synthesis.


## 3. DTC-PWM Control

### 3.1. DTC Basic Principles

The stator voltage space vector (vs) of an induction motor is related to the stator flux vector ψs in a stator fixed coordinate system by
(2)vs=Rsis+dψsdt.Neglecting the voltage drop in the stator resistanceRs, the stator flux vector is the time integral of the stator voltage vector. Hence, for a small sampling period Ts, (2) can be expressed by
(3)Δψs≈vsTs.On the other hand, the motor torque is related to the stator and rotor fluxes by(4)Te=32pkσLs|ψs||ψr|sin(δ),
where k=Lm/Ls. If both flux magnitudes are kept constant in (4), the torque can be controlled directly by changing the load angle. This can be easily achieved, since variations in the stator flux vector change the load angle due to slower rotor flux dynamics.Considering (3) and (4) it follows that the stator voltage vector can be used to manipulate the load angle and consequently to control the torque.


### 3.2. Flux and Torque Control by Load Angle Tracking

In traditional DTC, the influence over the load angle of each voltage vector generated by the inverter is determined and stored in a lookup table, according to the stator flux position in the complex plane. This is difficult to extend for multilevel inverter fed drives, where the complexity increases in huge proportions in relation to the levels generated by the inverter. Therefore, it is easier to look at the problem in a different way: the torque error can be used to generate a reference load angleδ* necessary to correct the torque behavior. Then the desired load angle can be used to compute the exact voltage vector that will produce the necessary flux variation Δψs. This principle is illustrated in Figure 3. Note that once provided the reference load angle δ*, the reference stator flux vector ψs* can be computed by
(5)ψs*=|ψs*|cos(δ*+θr)+j|ψs*|sin(δ*+θr),
where |ψs*| is the fixed stator flux amplitude reference, and θr is the rotor flux vector angle. Note that (δ*+θr) corresponds to the reference stator flux vector angle θs*.Figure 3
Stator voltage vector influence over the stator flux vector.Then the desired stator voltage vectorvs* can be obtained by
(6)vs≈ΔψsTs=ψs*-ψsTs.Finallyvs* has to be generated by the inverter. This is commonly performed with PWM or SVM for 2-level inverters [19]. The use of a multilevel inverter will reduce the torque ripple amplitude due to the reduction of the rate of change of the common-mode voltage (number of step variations in a fixed time span), and, in this case, using the hybrid modulation method [20], a fixed-frequency output voltage will be obtained concentrating the voltage spectrum around the carrier frequency of the small power cell. Hence the most important drawbacks of traditional DTC are corrected. A simplified control diagram of the proposed strategy is shown in Figure 4. The outer speed control loop is omitted.Figure 4
Hybrid multilevel inverter-fed DTC motor drive with a single DC source.


## 3.1. DTC Basic Principles

The stator voltage space vector (vs) of an induction motor is related to the stator flux vector ψs in a stator fixed coordinate system by
(2)vs=Rsis+dψsdt.Neglecting the voltage drop in the stator resistanceRs, the stator flux vector is the time integral of the stator voltage vector. Hence, for a small sampling period Ts, (2) can be expressed by
(3)Δψs≈vsTs.On the other hand, the motor torque is related to the stator and rotor fluxes by(4)Te=32pkσLs|ψs||ψr|sin(δ),
where k=Lm/Ls. If both flux magnitudes are kept constant in (4), the torque can be controlled directly by changing the load angle. This can be easily achieved, since variations in the stator flux vector change the load angle due to slower rotor flux dynamics.Considering (3) and (4) it follows that the stator voltage vector can be used to manipulate the load angle and consequently to control the torque.


## 3.2. Flux and Torque Control by Load Angle Tracking

In traditional DTC, the influence over the load angle of each voltage vector generated by the inverter is determined and stored in a lookup table, according to the stator flux position in the complex plane. This is difficult to extend for multilevel inverter fed drives, where the complexity increases in huge proportions in relation to the levels generated by the inverter. Therefore, it is easier to look at the problem in a different way: the torque error can be used to generate a reference load angleδ* necessary to correct the torque behavior. Then the desired load angle can be used to compute the exact voltage vector that will produce the necessary flux variation Δψs. This principle is illustrated in Figure 3. Note that once provided the reference load angle δ*, the reference stator flux vector ψs* can be computed by
(5)ψs*=|ψs*|cos(δ*+θr)+j|ψs*|sin(δ*+θr),
where |ψs*| is the fixed stator flux amplitude reference, and θr is the rotor flux vector angle. Note that (δ*+θr) corresponds to the reference stator flux vector angle θs*.Figure 3
Stator voltage vector influence over the stator flux vector.Then the desired stator voltage vectorvs* can be obtained by
(6)vs≈ΔψsTs=ψs*-ψsTs.Finallyvs* has to be generated by the inverter. This is commonly performed with PWM or SVM for 2-level inverters [19]. The use of a multilevel inverter will reduce the torque ripple amplitude due to the reduction of the rate of change of the common-mode voltage (number of step variations in a fixed time span), and, in this case, using the hybrid modulation method [20], a fixed-frequency output voltage will be obtained concentrating the voltage spectrum around the carrier frequency of the small power cell. Hence the most important drawbacks of traditional DTC are corrected. A simplified control diagram of the proposed strategy is shown in Figure 4. The outer speed control loop is omitted.Figure 4
Hybrid multilevel inverter-fed DTC motor drive with a single DC source.


## 4. Hybrid Modulation Strategy

The hybrid modulation is specially conceived for the asymmetric multilevel H-bridge inverter structure [14].The basic idea is to take advantage of the different power rates among the cells to reduce switching losses and improve the converter efficiency. From Figure5 it can be seen that the inverter generates a rectangular waveform, which is at the same frequency of the reference (turn-on and -off only one time during a half reference cycle). The remaining of the output voltage, second trace in Figure 5, is synthesized by the auxiliary inverter at high switching frequency (with sinusoidal PWM). This completes the generation of a multilevel stepped waveform with a high-frequency component (similar to a multicarrier-based PWM), but with the difference that fewer switching losses are produced to achieve it. Typical output waveform of the inverter using this modulation is shown in the third trace of Figure 5. Note that the output has 7 different voltage levels given by all the possible combinations of the series connection of (+VDC,0,-VDC) and (+2VDC,0,-2VDC).Figure 5
Desired output, auxiliary and main inverter voltage waveforms.


## 5. Capacitor Voltage Control

Capacitor voltage control in the auxiliary inverter is a challenging task [14, 21]. The proposed control method is based on a hybrid modulation that consists of adjusting the main inverter turn-on. This indeed corresponds to adjusting the active and reactive powers that the main inverter injects to the load (if α is chosen to be exactly 18°, the main inverter injects only active power). By shifting the voltage waveform synthesized by the main inverter (Figure 6), one could also inject some reactive power, which can be used to charge or discharge the auxiliary inverter capacitor.Figure 6
Variation of the main inverter conduction angle byVcm variation.Therefore, the proposed algorithm, illustrated by Figure7, regulates the capacitor voltage by an appropriate adjustment of Δα which is given by the PI regulator and acts directly on the variation of the comparison level Vcm that controls the main inverter turn-on and -off. The closed loop regulation for each phase is done by measuring the capacitor voltage. From the capacitors voltage error, the PI regulator gives directly the necessary ΔVcm to be added to the initial comparison level which leads to changing the conduction angle α of the main inverter that allows the secondary inverter capacitor charging.Figure 7
Closed-loop control of the capacitor voltages.


## 6. Experimental and Simulations Results

### 6.1. Hybrid Modulation Strategy Implementation

The above-discussed hybrid modulation strategy has been experimentally implemented (Figure8). The proposed hybrid modulation strategy main results are illustrated by Figure 9. As abovementioned, the inverter generates a rectangular waveform, which is at the same frequency of the reference (Figure 9(a)). The remaining of the output voltage is synthesized by the auxiliary inverter at high switching frequency with sinusoidal PWM (Figure 9(b)). Figure 9(c) shows the typical output waveform of the 7-level inverter under hybrid modulation.Figure 8
7-level single DC source cascaded H-bridge multilevel inverter.Desired output, main, auxiliary, and inverter voltage and current waveforms of the realized 7-level inverter under hybrid modulation.
(a)
Main H-bridge inverter voltages
(b)
Secondary H-bridge inverter voltages and auxiliary source (feeding the H-bridge) current
(c)
The main outputs


### 6.2. Simulation Tests on an Induction Motor-Based EV Propulsion

To evaluate the dynamic performances of the proposed control strategy, numerical simulations have been carried out on an EV propelled by an induction motor supplied with 7-level single DC source cascaded multilevel inverter (Figure4).Simulations were done using the standardized ECE-15 and EUDC driving cycle [22]. The achieved performances are illustrated by Figures 10 to 15.Figure 10
Speed with the ECE-15 + EUDC driving cycle.The simulation results show that the speed reference required by the driver is well-tracked as shown by Figure10. One can see that the induction motor developed torque presents fewer ripples compared to a traditional DTC (Figure 11). This is due to the quality of the voltage supplying the inverter (Figure 12). Consequently, the stator currents are almost sinusoidal (Figure 13) and better dynamics are obtained; operating practically with constant flux (Figure 14).Figure 11
Reference and developed torques.Figure 12
Output voltage waveform.Figure 13
Stator currents waveforms.Magnitude and locus of the stator flux in the DTC-PWM.
(a)
Flux magnitude
(b)
Flux locusCapacitor voltage waveforms.
(a)
Phase a
(b)
Phase b
(c)
Phase c
(d)
Capacitor voltage comparison zoomFigure15 shows the capacitor voltages waveforms which supply each auxiliary H-bridge of the three phase hybrid multilevel inverter. One can notice the oscillations around the reference. Moreover, these voltages are quiet identical. However, their difference becomes very large when there is a significant acceleration or deceleration requested by the driver. Indeed, in these cases, different amounts of energy are required due to the induction motor operating point fast variation.The above-presented simulation results confirm that, independently of the requested speed and torque, the capacitor voltages are controlled and the validity of the proposed control approach is proven.


## 6.1. Hybrid Modulation Strategy Implementation

The above-discussed hybrid modulation strategy has been experimentally implemented (Figure8). The proposed hybrid modulation strategy main results are illustrated by Figure 9. As abovementioned, the inverter generates a rectangular waveform, which is at the same frequency of the reference (Figure 9(a)). The remaining of the output voltage is synthesized by the auxiliary inverter at high switching frequency with sinusoidal PWM (Figure 9(b)). Figure 9(c) shows the typical output waveform of the 7-level inverter under hybrid modulation.Figure 8
7-level single DC source cascaded H-bridge multilevel inverter.Desired output, main, auxiliary, and inverter voltage and current waveforms of the realized 7-level inverter under hybrid modulation.
(a)
Main H-bridge inverter voltages
(b)
Secondary H-bridge inverter voltages and auxiliary source (feeding the H-bridge) current
(c)
The main outputs


## 6.2. Simulation Tests on an Induction Motor-Based EV Propulsion

To evaluate the dynamic performances of the proposed control strategy, numerical simulations have been carried out on an EV propelled by an induction motor supplied with 7-level single DC source cascaded multilevel inverter (Figure4).Simulations were done using the standardized ECE-15 and EUDC driving cycle [22]. The achieved performances are illustrated by Figures 10 to 15.Figure 10
Speed with the ECE-15 + EUDC driving cycle.The simulation results show that the speed reference required by the driver is well-tracked as shown by Figure10. One can see that the induction motor developed torque presents fewer ripples compared to a traditional DTC (Figure 11). This is due to the quality of the voltage supplying the inverter (Figure 12). Consequently, the stator currents are almost sinusoidal (Figure 13) and better dynamics are obtained; operating practically with constant flux (Figure 14).Figure 11
Reference and developed torques.Figure 12
Output voltage waveform.Figure 13
Stator currents waveforms.Magnitude and locus of the stator flux in the DTC-PWM.
(a)
Flux magnitude
(b)
Flux locusCapacitor voltage waveforms.
(a)
Phase a
(b)
Phase b
(c)
Phase c
(d)
Capacitor voltage comparison zoomFigure15 shows the capacitor voltages waveforms which supply each auxiliary H-bridge of the three phase hybrid multilevel inverter. One can notice the oscillations around the reference. Moreover, these voltages are quiet identical. However, their difference becomes very large when there is a significant acceleration or deceleration requested by the driver. Indeed, in these cases, different amounts of energy are required due to the induction motor operating point fast variation.The above-presented simulation results confirm that, independently of the requested speed and torque, the capacitor voltages are controlled and the validity of the proposed control approach is proven.


## 7. Conclusion

In this paper a control strategy has been proposed for a hybrid cascaded multilevel inverter with a modified DTC scheme intended for induction motor-based EV propulsion. In this case, the main inverter uses a single DC voltage source, and the auxiliary inverter capacitor voltages are controlled in each phase. In addition, DTC-PWM allows the operation with a fixed switching frequency, the reduction in the torque ripple without output filter, and high-performance torque and flux control.The proposed control method simplifies the DTC application in embedded systems by reducing the inverter cost and complexity (by decreasing the semiconductor and the source numbers). Moreover, there is no need for hysteresis comparators and lookup tables. All these key features make the proposed control approach very attractive for embedded systems such as automotive applications.



---

*Source: 718920-2013-02-14.xml*