# A Novel Shape Compact Antenna for Ultrawideband Applications

Authors: Saad Hassan Kiani; Xin Cheng Ren; Muhammad Rizwan Anjum; Khalid Mahmood; Haider Ali; Naveed Jan; Muhammad Adil Bashir; Muhammad Abbas Khan
Journal: International Journal of Antennas and Propagation
 (2021)

---

## Abstract

Nowadays, more attention has been given into ultrawideband by dint of its extraordinary features over narrowband communication systems. This study presents a novel compact with tilted square frames shape antenna with partial ground plane. The proposed antenna is printed on commercially available Fr4 substrate with relative thickness of 1.6 mm. The antenna has compact dimensions of 14 × 18 mm2 with bandwidth ranging from 3.3 to 11.5 GHz. The peak gain obtained is 1.4 dBi with omnidirectional radiation characteristics throughout the entire bandwidth. The proposed antenna is fabricated, and the developed prototype measured results, which well agree with simulated results. With the performance parameters obtained and the well agreed measured results, the proposed antenna is well suitable for Wi-Fi, ISM, and UWB applications.


---

## Body

## 1. Introduction

The rapid progress of wireless communication systems has emerged the need of wideband antenna, since they cover majority of applications. After the announcement of ultrawide band (UWB) by federal services commission, several antennas designs have been proposed in order to be deployed on the industrial scale. With low energy consumption, better channel capacity characteristics within the partial range, unmanned vehicles (UAVs), and body area networks (WBANs) [1, 2], the UWB antennas are emerging as most promising candidates for future wireless communication systems [3, 4]. UWB antenna role as compared to the conventional narrowband antenna system is unique and vital. Also, printed antenna technology light weight and low-cost fabrication characteristics as compared to conventional antenna structures provide quick and reliable wireless communication access. In published literature, several antennas have been reported on UWB technology [5–10].In literature, several wide and ultrawideband antenna structures have been reported. With a size of 121 × 314 mm2, a wide band antenna is reported in [5] with bandwidth of approximately 4.6 GHz ranging from 3.4 to 8 GHz. The shape of the antenna comprises a leaf structure with partial ground plane. The proposed antenna is well developed but is difficult to integrate in RF circuits due to its unconventional size. Similarly, in [6], an UWB is proposed with the total size of 31 × 23 mm2, having bandwidth characteristics ranging from 3 to almost 15 GHz. The antenna is small in size, but the gain variations are quite big. In [7], a monopole antenna is presented with elliptical slot rings. With nearly gain up to 3.5 dBi, the antenna exhibits good flat gain near the entire resonating spectrum, but the size of antenna is quite large up to 100 × 100 mm2.A miniaturized UWB antenna with dimensions of 9.11 × 10.8 mm is proposed in [8] with an operating bandwidth of at least 1 GHz around a centre frequency of 4 GHz for implantable applications. The M-shaped antenna resonating with 5600 MHz bandwidth ranging from 3.25 to 8 GHz is covered in [9], with large size of 100 × 160 mm2. The V shape antenna with truncated ground plane is presented at [10]; the size of the antenna is 28 × 36 mm, and the gain varies between 0.5 and 2 dB. In [11–14], several antennas have been developed for UWB applications, but they come in large sizes. In [14], the wideband response of 8 GHz has been reported, but the size of the antenna is 50 × 50 mm. Such type of large sizes makes antenna difficult to embed in modern RF devices. A compact antenna with single notch characteristics has been reported in [15] using split ring slots. The size of the antenna is 23 × 20 mm. Similarly, in [16, 17], UWB antennas are proposed with band notch characteristics with approximate size of 30 × 34 mm2 and 32 × 36 mm2. A multilayered compact 3D antenna in [18] exhibits wideband impedance characteristics of 40%. The multilayer structure makes it complex to fabricate. A ring loaded circular patch in [19] covers the bandwidth from 4.27 to 8.72 GHz.In the reported works, the UWB structures are found to be at either exceptionally large or small with gain variations. The modern RF communication systems require the antennas to be compact in size, so that they could easily be embedded. Therefore, this research presents a novel UWB antenna with a compact size of 225 mm2 and flat gain of 1.2–1.4 dBi. The proposed antenna is well compact in size as compared to the published literature and is suitable for next generation UWB systems.


## 2. Antenna Design

The proposed antenna is designed on commercially available FR4 substrate with relative permittivity of 4.3 and loss tangent of 0.02. The overall dimension of the proposed antenna is 18 × 14 × 1.6 mm3. Figure 1 shows the overall view and dimension of the proposed antenna.Figure 1
Proposed antenna design. (a) Front. (b) Back.
(a)(b)The printed monopole UWB antenna has been transformed in a sequence of steps. The aim of the proposed antenna was to resonate at ultrawideband range. Figure2 shows the step-by-step design development of the proposed antenna. In stage 1, a square frame tilted at 45° with half ground plane was introduced. In this stage, the resonance response achieved was almost 1.5 GHz ranging from 7 to 8.5 GHz. The second stage in the evolution introduced a square slot on the ground plane. The ground slot improved the reflection coefficient response up to 2.5 GHz. Then, the introduction of the square frames at 2.5 mm distance resulted in the proposed design, in which the resonance frequency shifted from 3.2 to 11.6 GHz. Also, the design showed the minimum reflection coefficient value of −29 dB at 6.3 GHz frequency.Figure 2
Design evolution of the proposed antenna.


### 2.1. Parametric Analysis

The proposed antenna has been tuned in number of steps to achieve the desired frequency band response. There were several parameters such as ground slot and transmission line length and width that involved in constant analysis. Figure3 shows the complete parametric analysis of our proposed design.Figure 3
Parametric analysis of the proposed antenna. (a) Ground slot. (b) Distance. (c) Feed length.
(a)(b)(c)In Figure3(a), it can be seen that the effect of the ground slot on the resonance response of the antenna is captivating. As the ground slot increases in size, the resonance response gets wider and the higher frequency response gets generated. This is limited to a certain threshold value of 4.25 mm, which exhibits the desired frequency response of the proposed antenna. After this point, the antenna starts exhibiting the dual band nature.The distance between the square frames has been set at 2.5 mm. In Figure3(b), the effect of the antenna on resonance has been observed. By looking at the figure, it is obvious that the increasing distance causes the antenna to be more focused in lower band and the response of the bandwidth decreases. Similarly, the feed length of the proposed antenna shows that with lower values, its impedance mismatches and the response of the antenna diminishes. At 12 mm length, the desired bandwidth is achieved which when further increased causes the bandwidth to abrupt.


## 2.1. Parametric Analysis

The proposed antenna has been tuned in number of steps to achieve the desired frequency band response. There were several parameters such as ground slot and transmission line length and width that involved in constant analysis. Figure3 shows the complete parametric analysis of our proposed design.Figure 3
Parametric analysis of the proposed antenna. (a) Ground slot. (b) Distance. (c) Feed length.
(a)(b)(c)In Figure3(a), it can be seen that the effect of the ground slot on the resonance response of the antenna is captivating. As the ground slot increases in size, the resonance response gets wider and the higher frequency response gets generated. This is limited to a certain threshold value of 4.25 mm, which exhibits the desired frequency response of the proposed antenna. After this point, the antenna starts exhibiting the dual band nature.The distance between the square frames has been set at 2.5 mm. In Figure3(b), the effect of the antenna on resonance has been observed. By looking at the figure, it is obvious that the increasing distance causes the antenna to be more focused in lower band and the response of the bandwidth decreases. Similarly, the feed length of the proposed antenna shows that with lower values, its impedance mismatches and the response of the antenna diminishes. At 12 mm length, the desired bandwidth is achieved which when further increased causes the bandwidth to abrupt.


## 3. Results and Discussion

This section discusses the results from the fabricated prototype and their comparison with the simulated results. The propose antenna is fabricated using the LPFK machine, and the measured reflection coefficient is found to be in good agreement with the simulated results. Slight variations are found in the measured results, but they can be attributed to the cable losses, connector losses, and random measurement set up losses. Figure4 shows the fabricated prototype with simulated and measured reflection coefficient.Figure 4
Simulated and measured reflection coefficient.The performance parameters of the proposed antenna are shown in Figure5. The peak gain simulated is found to be 1.4 dBi, while the measured gain is found to be at 1.389 dBi. The efficiency of the proposed antenna ranges from 60 to 68%. The gain is found to be at acceptable levels; since the proposed antenna is compact in size, the gain can be considered on satisfactory levels considering the size of the proposed antenna.Figure 5
Antenna efficiency and gain parameters.


### 3.1. Radiation Patterns

The radiation patterns of the antenna both simulated and measured in phi 90 and theta 90 plane are shown in Figure6. The radiation patterns of the proposed antenna were measured in an anechoic chamber. The antenna showed well-measured radiation patterns, and it can be observed that antenna exhibits an omnidirectional response. The radiation patterns measured are from 4.5, 5.5, 6, and 7 GHz. From the figure, it can be observed that the radiation patterns are stable across the entire bandwidth. The simulated and measured results slight variations can be due to the measurement set up errors. In phi 90 plane, the antenna exhibits a directional response at some frequency points. Overall, the proposed antenna shows satisfactory radiation pattern characteristics and exhibits response as required by UWB systems [11–14].Figure 6
Radiation patterns. (a) 4.5 GHz. (b) 5.5 GHz. (c) 6 GHz. (d) 7 GHz.
(a)(b)(c)(d)


### 3.2. Surface Currents

Figure7 shows the surface currents patterns at the resonance frequency of 4.5, 5.5, 6, and 7 GHz. From the figure, the ground slot and plane can be observed, and the titled square frames are responsible for generating the resonances. The ground slot is helpful in generating the constructive interface of currents. Furthermore, in lower frequency values, the effect of the square flames can be seen forming constructive interface at the edges of the frames.Figure 7
Surface current patterns. (a) 4.5 GHz. (b) 5.5 GHz. (c) 6 GHz. (d) 7 GHz.
(a)(b)(c)(d)From Table1, it can be seen that the proposed antenna is compact in size, and also, the gain throughout the frequency range is nearly flat. Also, the proposed antenna offers omnidirectional radiation characteristics. With this small size and robust characteristics, the reported literature can be termed as a compact and potential candidate for future wireless systems.Table 1
Comparison table of proposed antenna with published literature.
ReferenceFrequency (GHz)Size (L × W)Gain (dBi)Efficiency (%)[5]3.4–8.0312 × 1213.9979[6]3.3–10.231 × 234.1N/A[9]3.25–8.85100 × 1605.485[10]3.1–10.625 × 263.8376[11]2.5–1250 × 50N/AN/A[12]3.2–10.640 × 404.0088[13]4.0–12.050 × 355.2580[14]3–14.540 × 342.475[20]4.8–5.930 × 355.365[21]4.4–4.6/5.4–5.626 × 254.89N/A[22]2.4 × 3.626.1 × 25.45.682Proposed3.3–11.514 × 181.460–68


## 3.1. Radiation Patterns

The radiation patterns of the antenna both simulated and measured in phi 90 and theta 90 plane are shown in Figure6. The radiation patterns of the proposed antenna were measured in an anechoic chamber. The antenna showed well-measured radiation patterns, and it can be observed that antenna exhibits an omnidirectional response. The radiation patterns measured are from 4.5, 5.5, 6, and 7 GHz. From the figure, it can be observed that the radiation patterns are stable across the entire bandwidth. The simulated and measured results slight variations can be due to the measurement set up errors. In phi 90 plane, the antenna exhibits a directional response at some frequency points. Overall, the proposed antenna shows satisfactory radiation pattern characteristics and exhibits response as required by UWB systems [11–14].Figure 6
Radiation patterns. (a) 4.5 GHz. (b) 5.5 GHz. (c) 6 GHz. (d) 7 GHz.
(a)(b)(c)(d)


## 3.2. Surface Currents

Figure7 shows the surface currents patterns at the resonance frequency of 4.5, 5.5, 6, and 7 GHz. From the figure, the ground slot and plane can be observed, and the titled square frames are responsible for generating the resonances. The ground slot is helpful in generating the constructive interface of currents. Furthermore, in lower frequency values, the effect of the square flames can be seen forming constructive interface at the edges of the frames.Figure 7
Surface current patterns. (a) 4.5 GHz. (b) 5.5 GHz. (c) 6 GHz. (d) 7 GHz.
(a)(b)(c)(d)From Table1, it can be seen that the proposed antenna is compact in size, and also, the gain throughout the frequency range is nearly flat. Also, the proposed antenna offers omnidirectional radiation characteristics. With this small size and robust characteristics, the reported literature can be termed as a compact and potential candidate for future wireless systems.Table 1
Comparison table of proposed antenna with published literature.
ReferenceFrequency (GHz)Size (L × W)Gain (dBi)Efficiency (%)[5]3.4–8.0312 × 1213.9979[6]3.3–10.231 × 234.1N/A[9]3.25–8.85100 × 1605.485[10]3.1–10.625 × 263.8376[11]2.5–1250 × 50N/AN/A[12]3.2–10.640 × 404.0088[13]4.0–12.050 × 355.2580[14]3–14.540 × 342.475[20]4.8–5.930 × 355.365[21]4.4–4.6/5.4–5.626 × 254.89N/A[22]2.4 × 3.626.1 × 25.45.682Proposed3.3–11.514 × 181.460–68


## 4. Conclusion

This research presents a novel three square tilted frame monopole antenna with a compact size. The proposed antenna is made with a square cut in the top middle section of the ground plane which helps in generating the wideband response from 3.3 to 11.6 GHz frequency. The total size of the antenna is 14 × 18 × 1.6 mm3, which is quite small as compared to published literature. Through the performance parameters, the antenna is found to be exhibiting good response. Moreover, the proposed antenna is fabricated, and measured results are in well agreement with the simulated results which validate that the proposed antenna is a good contender for UWB applications. In future, this work can further be improved with MIMO configuration and through metasurfaces.



---

*Source: 7004799-2021-10-06.xml*