# Efficacy of Some Botanical Extracts againstTrogoderma granarium in Wheat Grains with Toxicity Evaluation

Authors: Aly S. Derbalah
Journal: The Scientific World Journal
 (2012)

---

## Abstract

In an attempt to find alternative control methods for stored products insects, extracts of seven plant species (Cassia senna, Caesalpinia gilliesii, Thespesia populnea var. acutiloba, Chrysanthemum  frutescens, Euonymus japonicus, Bauhinia purpurea, and Cassia fistula) were evaluated under laboratory conditions for their ability to protect wheat (Triticum spp.) grains against Trogoderma granarium insect. Moreover, gas chromatography-mass spectrometry (GC-MS) analysis was carried to identify the chemical components of the most effective plant extract against T. granarium. Furthermore, the safety of the most effective plant extract was evaluated with respect to biochemical and histological changes in treated rats relative to control. The results revealed that, the tested botanical extracts showed high efficiency against T. granarium with respect to mortality and progeny of the adults. C. senna was the most effective botanical extract against T. granarium. The GC-MS analysis of the most effective plant extract showed the presence of different bioactive compounds that is known by its insecticidal activity. The most effective plant extract showed no toxicity on treated rats relative to control with respect to biochemical and histological changes. The results suggest the ability of using these plant extracts for wheat grains protection as a safe alternative to insecticides.


---

## Body

## 1. Introduction

Stored products of agricultural and animal origin are attacked by more than 600 species of beetle pests, 70 species of moths, and about 355 species of mites causing quantitative and qualitative losses [1], and insect contamination in food commodities is an important quality control problem of concern for food industries. In industrialized countries like Canada and Australia there is zero tolerance for insects in food grains [2]. T. granarium is among the most serious and of widest occurrence in stores in tropical and subtropical regions of Asia and Africa [3] and is common in geographical areas characterized by high temperature and low humidity [4].Control of stored-product insect populations is primarily dependent upon continued applications of insecticides [2]. In spite of its efficacy, their repeated use for several decades has disrupted biological control system by natural enemies and led to outbreaks of insect pests, widespread development of resistance, undesirable effects on nontarget organisms, and environmental and human health concerns [2, 5].These problems have highlighted the need for the development of new types of selective insect-control alternatives. Plants may provide potential alternative to currently used insect-control agents because they constitute a rich source of bioactive chemicals [6]. Since these are often active against a limited number of species including specific target insect, they are often biodegradable to nontoxic products, potentially suitable for use in integrated pest management, and they could lead to the development of new classes of safer insect-control agents. Much effort has, therefore, been focused on plant-derived materials for potentially useful products as commercial insect-control agents. Little work has been done to manage stored-product insects by using aromatic medicinal plants despite their excellent pharmacological actions [7, 8].Most of the alternatives insecticides substances were tested against insects attacking stored products in order to establish new control practices with lower mammalian toxicity and lower persistence in the environment relative to insecticides. Therefore, studies should conduct not only on the evaluation of botanical extracts against the target pests but also on their safety on human health that are in demand. Although the assessment of enzymes activity in the blood is generally a more sensitive measure of compound toxicity than histopathological changes and can be assessed within a shorter time, the tissue alterations are considered a confirmatory and supporting diagnostic role in the case of certain abnormalities in blood sampling [9].Therefore, this study attempted to evaluate insecticidal activity of some newly used plant extracts (C. senna, C. gilliesii, T. populnea var. acutiloba, C. frutescens, E. japonicus, B. purpurea, and C. fistula) againstT. granariumin wheat grains with respect to progeny and mortality of the insect adults, to identify the chemical components of the most effective plant extract againstT. granarium, and finally to evaluate the toxicity of the most effective plant extract on rats with respect to biochemical and histological changes relative to control.


## 2. Materials and Methods

### 2.1. The Insect

T. granarium(Everts) was obtained from the Department of Stored Product Pests Control, Research Institute of Plant Protection, Sakha, Kafr El-Shiekh. This strain was reared free of insecticidal contamination for several years at30±2°C and 70%±5 relative to humidity. The cultures were maintained under the same conditions in the Pesticide Department, Faculty of Agriculture, Kafr El-Shiekh University, Egypt. The culture was raised by infesting 30 pairs of newly emergedT. granariumadults into 500 g of wheat grains in large box. After that, 35 d newly emerged (F1) adults were collected and used to infest the wheat samples.


### 2.2. The Stored Product

Wheat grains were used to cultureT. granarium and to evaluate the efficacy of tested plant extracts as well as malathion against the same insect as well. Wheat grains were stored in airtight tins until being required for experiments. The experiments were carried out in a room kept at a constant temperature of 25°C and 70% r.h.


### 2.3. Plants and Preparation of Crude Extracts

The leaves of seven medicinal plant species (C. senna, C. gilliesii, T. populnea var. acutiloba, C. frutescens, E. japonicus, B. purpurea, and C. fistula) were collected from a local nursery at Kafr El-Sheikh, Monofia, Gharbia, and Alexandria Governorates, Egypt. C. senna (Alexandrian Senna), belonging to the family Fabaceae, is native to tropical Africa and cultivated in Egypt and Sudan. C. gilliesii (bird of paradise), belonging to the family Fabaceae, is native to tropical America, mainly Argentina and Uruguay. T. populnea var. acutiloba (Portia Tree), belonging to the family Malvaceae, is native to South Africa. C. frutescens (marguerite daisy), belonging to the family Asteraceae, is native to the Canary Islands. E. japonicus (Japanese Spindle), belonging to the family Celastraceae, is native to Japan, Korea, and China. B. purpurea (Purple camel’s foot), belonging to the family Fabaceae, is native to South China. C. fistula (Cassias), belonging to the family Fabaceae, is native to southern Asia. The different leave samples were oven dried for 24 h at 70°C and, then, finely powdered using a blender. Each sample (25 g) was extracted twice with 300 mL of methanol at room temperature for 2 days. The extracts were filtered through Whatman filter paper (no. 15), Whatman Inc. (North Americ) USA. The combined filtrate was concentrated to dryness by rotary evaporation at 40°C.


### 2.4. Effect of Tested Plant Extracts and Malathion on Progeny ofT. granarium

The tested plant extracts at concentration levels of 100, 300, and 500 ppm were used to evaluate its efficacy againstT. granarium. Malathion was used as recommended compound against T. granarium at concentration levels of 5, 10, and 20 mg/L. Each concentration was applied in three replicates, and each replicate contained 20 g of wheat grains. The treatment of wheat grains was carried out by dipping wheat grains in water solution of malathion and botanical extracts at tested concentration levels twice consecutively for 5 seconds and subsequently spread on top of plastic sheets to dry for 90 min. The control treatment was carried using water only and replicated three times. Then, 10 adults of T. granarium were transferred to treated wheat grains which were put in a 85×75 mm plastic jar and kept at30±2°C and 70%±5 r.h, according to the method described by Kestenholz et al. [10]. The emerged adults from the hatched eggs were recorded after 6 weeks of treatment. These adults were used to calculate the reduction percentages inT. granarium progeny from the use of the tested plant extracts as well as malathion compared to the control as shown in the following equation as described by El-Lakwah et al. [11]:(1)%Reduction=MNEC-MNETMNEC×100,MNEC=Meanno.ofthosewhichemergedinthecontrol,MNET=No.ofthosewhichemergedinthetreatment.


### 2.5. Efficiency of the Tested Plant Extracts and Malathion on Adults, Pupae, and Larvae ofT. granarium Beetle by Mean Mortality

Wheat grains were treated with the tested plant extracts and malathion for protection against larvae, pupae, and adults ofT. granarium at concentration levels mentioned before. Each concentration was applied in three replicates and in each replicate contained 20 gm of wheat grains. The treatment of wheat grains was carried out by dipping wheat grains in aqueous solution of malathion and botanical extracts at the tested concentration levels twice consecutively for 5 seconds and subsequently spread on top of plastic sheets to dry for 90 min. The control treatment was carried using water only and replicated three times. Then, 10 adults, pupae, and larvae of T. granarium were transferred to treated wheat grains which were put in a 85×75 mm glass jar and kept at30±2°C and 70%±5 r.h, according to the method described by Kestenholz et al. [10]. The glass jars were covered with cotton cloths held on with rubber bands. The number of dead adults, pupae, and larvae in each jar was counted after one and two weeks and the percentage of insect mortality was recorded.


### 2.6. Chemical Composition of the Most Effective Plant Extract

GC/MS analysis was carried to identify the components of the most effective plant extract(C. senna) according to the method described by Durate-Almeida et al. [12]. The samples were injected three times for confirmation. The analysis was conducted on HP 6890 GC system coupled with a 5973 network mass selective detector with a capillary column of HP-5MS (60m×0.25mm, film thickness 0.25 m). The oven temperature program was turned on at 50°C, held for 2 min, and then raised up to 200°C at a rate of 5°C·min−1. Helium was used as the carrier gas at a flow rate 1.0 mL·min−1, with a split ratio equal to 1/50. The detector and injector temperatures were 250 and 200°C, respectively. Some of the detected compounds in the tested plant extracts were identified by comparison of their retention indices (RIs) and mass spectra fragmentation with the available analytical standards (1,8 Cineole, Linalool, and Butanoic acid). They were also identified by comparison of their RIs and mass spectra fragmentation with those stored in the Wiley and NIST libraries associated with GC-MS. Several other compounds could be identified only through the second method. The samples were analyzed by the Central Laboratory for Pesticides, Agriculture Research Centre, Cairo, Egypt.


### 2.7. Toxicity Assessments

#### 2.7.1. Animal Treatment

The used adult Wistar male rats(Rattus norvegicus) with 8 weeks old and 80–100 gm in weight were obtained from Faculty of Medicine, Tanta University. Wister rats were housed in wire cages under standard conditions with free access to drinking water and food. The rats were kept in temperature-controlled room with 14 hours light and 10 hrs dark cycles. The rats were given a standard diet as described by Romestaing et al. [13]. Before treatment, rats were left two weeks for adaptation. The animals were randomly divided into two groups each comprising of three animals one group for the treatment with the most effective plant extract (C. senna) till 21 days and the second group for control. The most effective plant extract was administered to rats orally at concentration level of 500 mg/kg body weight. Control group rats were orally administrated with equal amount of almond oil. After 21 days the rats were sacrificed under anesthesia. Then, the blood samples were taken by cardiac puncture in vials containing heparin. Moreover, specimens from kidney and liver were taken from each treatment and kept in neutral buffered formalin 10% for histopathological test.


#### 2.7.2. Enzymes Assays

Blood samples were centrifuged at 4500 rpm for 15 min at 4°C and the blood serum was used to determine the Glutamate Pyruvate Transaminase (GPT), creatinine, and alkaline phosphatase (ALP) according to the methods described by Barham and Trinder [14], Reitman and Frankel [15], and Wilkinson et al. [16], respectively.


#### 2.7.3. Histopathological Test

The histopathology test was carried out at Histopathology Laboratory, Department of Histopathology, Faculty of Veterinary Medicine, Kafr El-Sheikh University, according to the method described by Bancroft and Stevens [17].


### 2.8. Statistical Analysis

Data from the experiments were statistically analyzed using one-way repeated measurement analysis of variance. For mortality experiments, the statistical analysis was carried out after mortality percentages were corrected. Newman-Keuls’s multiple range test using a computer program SAS (Version 6.12, SAS Institute Inc., Cary, NC, USA) was used to separate means.


## 2.1. The Insect

T. granarium(Everts) was obtained from the Department of Stored Product Pests Control, Research Institute of Plant Protection, Sakha, Kafr El-Shiekh. This strain was reared free of insecticidal contamination for several years at30±2°C and 70%±5 relative to humidity. The cultures were maintained under the same conditions in the Pesticide Department, Faculty of Agriculture, Kafr El-Shiekh University, Egypt. The culture was raised by infesting 30 pairs of newly emergedT. granariumadults into 500 g of wheat grains in large box. After that, 35 d newly emerged (F1) adults were collected and used to infest the wheat samples.


## 2.2. The Stored Product

Wheat grains were used to cultureT. granarium and to evaluate the efficacy of tested plant extracts as well as malathion against the same insect as well. Wheat grains were stored in airtight tins until being required for experiments. The experiments were carried out in a room kept at a constant temperature of 25°C and 70% r.h.


## 2.3. Plants and Preparation of Crude Extracts

The leaves of seven medicinal plant species (C. senna, C. gilliesii, T. populnea var. acutiloba, C. frutescens, E. japonicus, B. purpurea, and C. fistula) were collected from a local nursery at Kafr El-Sheikh, Monofia, Gharbia, and Alexandria Governorates, Egypt. C. senna (Alexandrian Senna), belonging to the family Fabaceae, is native to tropical Africa and cultivated in Egypt and Sudan. C. gilliesii (bird of paradise), belonging to the family Fabaceae, is native to tropical America, mainly Argentina and Uruguay. T. populnea var. acutiloba (Portia Tree), belonging to the family Malvaceae, is native to South Africa. C. frutescens (marguerite daisy), belonging to the family Asteraceae, is native to the Canary Islands. E. japonicus (Japanese Spindle), belonging to the family Celastraceae, is native to Japan, Korea, and China. B. purpurea (Purple camel’s foot), belonging to the family Fabaceae, is native to South China. C. fistula (Cassias), belonging to the family Fabaceae, is native to southern Asia. The different leave samples were oven dried for 24 h at 70°C and, then, finely powdered using a blender. Each sample (25 g) was extracted twice with 300 mL of methanol at room temperature for 2 days. The extracts were filtered through Whatman filter paper (no. 15), Whatman Inc. (North Americ) USA. The combined filtrate was concentrated to dryness by rotary evaporation at 40°C.


## 2.4. Effect of Tested Plant Extracts and Malathion on Progeny ofT. granarium

The tested plant extracts at concentration levels of 100, 300, and 500 ppm were used to evaluate its efficacy againstT. granarium. Malathion was used as recommended compound against T. granarium at concentration levels of 5, 10, and 20 mg/L. Each concentration was applied in three replicates, and each replicate contained 20 g of wheat grains. The treatment of wheat grains was carried out by dipping wheat grains in water solution of malathion and botanical extracts at tested concentration levels twice consecutively for 5 seconds and subsequently spread on top of plastic sheets to dry for 90 min. The control treatment was carried using water only and replicated three times. Then, 10 adults of T. granarium were transferred to treated wheat grains which were put in a 85×75 mm plastic jar and kept at30±2°C and 70%±5 r.h, according to the method described by Kestenholz et al. [10]. The emerged adults from the hatched eggs were recorded after 6 weeks of treatment. These adults were used to calculate the reduction percentages inT. granarium progeny from the use of the tested plant extracts as well as malathion compared to the control as shown in the following equation as described by El-Lakwah et al. [11]:(1)%Reduction=MNEC-MNETMNEC×100,MNEC=Meanno.ofthosewhichemergedinthecontrol,MNET=No.ofthosewhichemergedinthetreatment.


## 2.5. Efficiency of the Tested Plant Extracts and Malathion on Adults, Pupae, and Larvae ofT. granarium Beetle by Mean Mortality

Wheat grains were treated with the tested plant extracts and malathion for protection against larvae, pupae, and adults ofT. granarium at concentration levels mentioned before. Each concentration was applied in three replicates and in each replicate contained 20 gm of wheat grains. The treatment of wheat grains was carried out by dipping wheat grains in aqueous solution of malathion and botanical extracts at the tested concentration levels twice consecutively for 5 seconds and subsequently spread on top of plastic sheets to dry for 90 min. The control treatment was carried using water only and replicated three times. Then, 10 adults, pupae, and larvae of T. granarium were transferred to treated wheat grains which were put in a 85×75 mm glass jar and kept at30±2°C and 70%±5 r.h, according to the method described by Kestenholz et al. [10]. The glass jars were covered with cotton cloths held on with rubber bands. The number of dead adults, pupae, and larvae in each jar was counted after one and two weeks and the percentage of insect mortality was recorded.


## 2.6. Chemical Composition of the Most Effective Plant Extract

GC/MS analysis was carried to identify the components of the most effective plant extract(C. senna) according to the method described by Durate-Almeida et al. [12]. The samples were injected three times for confirmation. The analysis was conducted on HP 6890 GC system coupled with a 5973 network mass selective detector with a capillary column of HP-5MS (60m×0.25mm, film thickness 0.25 m). The oven temperature program was turned on at 50°C, held for 2 min, and then raised up to 200°C at a rate of 5°C·min−1. Helium was used as the carrier gas at a flow rate 1.0 mL·min−1, with a split ratio equal to 1/50. The detector and injector temperatures were 250 and 200°C, respectively. Some of the detected compounds in the tested plant extracts were identified by comparison of their retention indices (RIs) and mass spectra fragmentation with the available analytical standards (1,8 Cineole, Linalool, and Butanoic acid). They were also identified by comparison of their RIs and mass spectra fragmentation with those stored in the Wiley and NIST libraries associated with GC-MS. Several other compounds could be identified only through the second method. The samples were analyzed by the Central Laboratory for Pesticides, Agriculture Research Centre, Cairo, Egypt.


## 2.7. Toxicity Assessments

### 2.7.1. Animal Treatment

The used adult Wistar male rats(Rattus norvegicus) with 8 weeks old and 80–100 gm in weight were obtained from Faculty of Medicine, Tanta University. Wister rats were housed in wire cages under standard conditions with free access to drinking water and food. The rats were kept in temperature-controlled room with 14 hours light and 10 hrs dark cycles. The rats were given a standard diet as described by Romestaing et al. [13]. Before treatment, rats were left two weeks for adaptation. The animals were randomly divided into two groups each comprising of three animals one group for the treatment with the most effective plant extract (C. senna) till 21 days and the second group for control. The most effective plant extract was administered to rats orally at concentration level of 500 mg/kg body weight. Control group rats were orally administrated with equal amount of almond oil. After 21 days the rats were sacrificed under anesthesia. Then, the blood samples were taken by cardiac puncture in vials containing heparin. Moreover, specimens from kidney and liver were taken from each treatment and kept in neutral buffered formalin 10% for histopathological test.


### 2.7.2. Enzymes Assays

Blood samples were centrifuged at 4500 rpm for 15 min at 4°C and the blood serum was used to determine the Glutamate Pyruvate Transaminase (GPT), creatinine, and alkaline phosphatase (ALP) according to the methods described by Barham and Trinder [14], Reitman and Frankel [15], and Wilkinson et al. [16], respectively.


### 2.7.3. Histopathological Test

The histopathology test was carried out at Histopathology Laboratory, Department of Histopathology, Faculty of Veterinary Medicine, Kafr El-Sheikh University, according to the method described by Bancroft and Stevens [17].


## 2.7.1. Animal Treatment

The used adult Wistar male rats(Rattus norvegicus) with 8 weeks old and 80–100 gm in weight were obtained from Faculty of Medicine, Tanta University. Wister rats were housed in wire cages under standard conditions with free access to drinking water and food. The rats were kept in temperature-controlled room with 14 hours light and 10 hrs dark cycles. The rats were given a standard diet as described by Romestaing et al. [13]. Before treatment, rats were left two weeks for adaptation. The animals were randomly divided into two groups each comprising of three animals one group for the treatment with the most effective plant extract (C. senna) till 21 days and the second group for control. The most effective plant extract was administered to rats orally at concentration level of 500 mg/kg body weight. Control group rats were orally administrated with equal amount of almond oil. After 21 days the rats were sacrificed under anesthesia. Then, the blood samples were taken by cardiac puncture in vials containing heparin. Moreover, specimens from kidney and liver were taken from each treatment and kept in neutral buffered formalin 10% for histopathological test.


## 2.7.2. Enzymes Assays

Blood samples were centrifuged at 4500 rpm for 15 min at 4°C and the blood serum was used to determine the Glutamate Pyruvate Transaminase (GPT), creatinine, and alkaline phosphatase (ALP) according to the methods described by Barham and Trinder [14], Reitman and Frankel [15], and Wilkinson et al. [16], respectively.


## 2.7.3. Histopathological Test

The histopathology test was carried out at Histopathology Laboratory, Department of Histopathology, Faculty of Veterinary Medicine, Kafr El-Sheikh University, according to the method described by Bancroft and Stevens [17].


## 2.8. Statistical Analysis

Data from the experiments were statistically analyzed using one-way repeated measurement analysis of variance. For mortality experiments, the statistical analysis was carried out after mortality percentages were corrected. Newman-Keuls’s multiple range test using a computer program SAS (Version 6.12, SAS Institute Inc., Cary, NC, USA) was used to separate means.


## 3. Results

### 3.1. Effect of Tested Plant Extracts and Malathion on Progeny ofT. granarium

The numbers of emerged adults ofT. granarium were significantly decreased in all treatments (the tested plant extracts and malathion) relative to the control, as shown in Table 1. Moreover, the tested plant extracts delayed the progeny of the tested insect three weeks relative to control treatment. Increasing the concentration level of all tested treatments reduced the emergence of T. granarium even more (concentration dependent).C. senna extract followed by malathion and B. purpurea was the most effective treatment while C. furtescens extract was the least effective one.Table 1
Effect of the tested plant extracts and malathion on progeny ofT. granarium.
TreatmentsConcentration level (mg/L)% ReductionCassia senna10095bc300100a500100a10082gCaesalpinia gilliesii30092.5cd50097.5ab10070iThespesia populnea var. acutiloba30090ed50092.5cdChrysanthemum frutescens10062j30070i50085f10070iEuonymus japonicus30090ed50095bcBauhinia purpurea10097.5ab30097.5ab500100aCassia fistula10080hg30092.5cd50095bcMalathion580hg1097ab20100aControl0.00.00ka,b,c,d,e,f,g,h,i,j,kSeparation of means according to the Student Newman Keuls multiple range test (P<0.05).


### 3.2. Efficiency of Tested Plant Extracts and Malathion onT. granarium Adults Determined by Mortality Values

The efficacy of the tested plant extracts and malathion againstT. granarium adults by means of mortality was presented in Table 2. The results showed thatC. senna was the most effective treatment against T. granarium adults followed by B. purpurea, C. gilliesii, E. japonicus, T. populnea var. acutiloba, C. fistula, malathion, and C. frutescens, respectively. The morality percentages of T. granariumwere significantly increased in the second week relative to the first week at all tested treatments. Increasing the concentration level of all tested treatments increased the mortality of T. granariumadults even more (concentration dependent).Table 2
Effect of the tested plant extracts and malathion on adult’s mortality ofT. granarium.
TreatmentsConcentration level (mg/L)% Mortality after one week% Mortality after two weekCassia senna10086.7abc100a30090abc100a50093abc100a10043de100aCaesalpinia gilliesii30060abc100a50086.7abc100a10040c90aThespesia populnea var. acutiloba30063d93a50083bc100aChrysanthemum frutescens10050de70b30060de97a50083bc100a10060de90aEuonymus japonicus30080c97a50096.7ab100aBauhinia purpurea10083bc100a30090abc100a50093abc100aCassia fistula10057e93a30063d100a50080c100aMalathion560de90a1080a93a2 087a100aControl0.000.00f0.00ca,b,c,d,e,f,g,h,i,j,kSeparation of means according to the Student Newman Keuls multiple range test (P<0.05).


### 3.3. Efficiency of Tested Plant Extracts and Malathion onT. granarium Pupae Determined by Mortality Values

The efficacy of the tested plant extracts and malathion againstT. granarium pupae by means of mortality was presented in Table 3. The results showed thatB. purpureawas the most effective treatment against T. granarium pupae followed by C. senna, C. gilliesii, E. japonicus, T. populnea var. acutiloba, C. fistula, malathion, and C. frutescens, respectively. The morality percentages of T. granariumpupae were significantly increased in the second week relative to the first week at all tested treatments. Increasing the concentration level of all tested treatments increased the mortality of T. granariumpupae even more (concentration dependent).Table 3
Effect of the tested plant extracts and malathion on mortality ofT. granarium pupae.
TreatmentsConcentration level (mg/L)% Mortality after one week% Mortality after two weekCassia senna10066.7def100a30086.7abc100a50093bc100a10043hi97abCaesalpinia gilliesii30047ghi100a50053fgh100a10033ig100aThespesia populnea var. acutiloba30060efg100a50080bcd100aChrysanthemum frutescens10033jg80de30047ghi87bc50053fgh100a10073cde80eEuonymus japonicas30080bcd93cd50083bcd100aBauhinia purpurea10080bcd100a30093ab100a500100a100aCassia fistula10033g93bc30040hi95bc50047gh100aMalathion547ghi67f1080bcd93abc2093ab100aControl0.000.00k0.00ga,b,c,d,e,f,g,h,i,j,kSeparation of means according to the Student Newman Keuls multiple range test (P<0.05).


### 3.4. Efficiency of Tested Plant Extracts and Malathion onT. granarium Larvae Determined by Mortality Values

The efficacy of the tested plant extracts and malathion againstT. granarium larvae by means of mortality was presented in Table 4. The results showed thatC. gilliesiiwas the most effective treatment against T. granarium larvae followed by E. japonicus, C. senna, B. purpurea, T. populnea var. acutiloba, malathion, C. furtescens, and C. fistula, respectively. Among the tested plant extracts, C. gilliesii extract was the most effective one and C. fistula extract recorded the lowest efficacy against the larvae of T. granarium. The mortality percentages of T. granariumlarvae were significantly increased in the second week relative to the first week at all tested treatments. Increasing the concentration level of all tested treatments increased the mortality of T. granariumlarvae even more (concentration dependent).Table 4
Effect of tested plant extracts and malathion on mortality ofT. granarium larvae.
TreatmentsConcentration level (mg/L)% Mortality after one week% Mortality after two weekCassia senna10080bc93a30093ab100a50097ab100a10080bc100aCaesalpinia gilliesii30093abc100a50094ab100a10046.6ef87bcThespesia populnea var. acutiloba30080bc100a50093ab100aChrysanthemum frutescens10047ef80c30053e87bc50060de93ab10060de100aEuonymus japonicus30073cd100a50093ab100aBauhinia purpurea10033fg93ab30053e100a50060de100aCassia fistula10037g87bc30047ef93ab50060de100aMalathion550ef87c1080bc93ab2093a100aControl0.000.00h0.00da,b,c,d,e,f,g,h,i,j,kSeparation of means according to the Student Newman Keuls multiple range test (P<0.05).


### 3.5. Composition of the Most Effective Botanical Extract

The identified chemical components of the most effective botanical extract (C. senna) against T. granarium were presented in Table 5. Eighteen compounds were identified from C. senna extract, separately with different percentages as shown in Table 5.The identified compounds were belonging to different fatty acids and their derivatives (eldyhydes, esters, and alcohols).Table 5
The main constituents ofC. senna plant extract identified by GC-MS analysis.
No.NameRetention time (min)% Area1Beta phellandrene4.331.52Mone inositol4.372.7531,8 Cineole4.9826.554Linalool5.7010.2853 cyclohexen-1-ol 4-methyl-1-(1-methylethyl)6.572.6963cyclohexene-1-methanol-alpha 4-trimethyl-p-menth 1-en-8-ol6.712.487Butanoic acid7.220.028α-Terpineol acetate8.1621.0699-Octadecanoic acid (z)2, 6 octadien-1-ol 3, 7 dimethyl acetate8.372.210Caryophyllene8.850.7511Cycloheptasiloxane tetradecamethyl9.251.712Croweacin9.7220.3131, 6 dodecatrien-3-ol 3, 7, 11 titramethyl9.951.1214Cyclononosiloxane octadecanmethyl11.972.2315Hexadecanoic acid methyl ester13.070.9416Tetratetracontane15.041.1917Tetra cosamethyl cyclododecasiloxane19.192.618Iron monocarbonyl 1,3 butadiene 1,4, dicarbonic acid diethyl ether20.131.83


### 3.6. Toxicity Evaluation

#### 3.6.1. Effect of the Most Effective Plant Extract on Liver Enzymes

The Alkaline phosphatase and GPT activities are known as cytosolic marker enzymes reflecting hepatocellular necrosis as they are released into the blood after cell membrane damage. In the present study, therefore, both enzyme activities were used as indicators of hepatic damage. The obtained data in Table6 showed that there were no significant differences in the activity of ALT and GPT after 21 days of rat’s administration with the most effective plant extract at dose level of 500 mg/kg body weight relative to control treatment.Table 6
Effect of the most effective plant extract (C. senna) on serum GPT, ALT, and creatinine of treated rats at dose level of 500 mg/kg body weight.
TreatmentsSGPT U/LALP U/LCreatinine mg/dLControl65±1.39101±5.570.205±0.06C. senna67±3.57111±5.10.197±0.08


#### 3.6.2. Effect of the Most Effective Plant Extract on Kidney Function

Regarding the kidney function, there were no significant differences in creatinine level in rats administration with the most effective plant extract at dose level of 500 mg/kg relative to control (Table6). The normal creatinine in rats treated with the most effective plant extract relative to control treatment was assumed to be the normal kidney function. Moreover, the histology of kidney tissue treated with the most effective plant extract relative to control supports this explanation.


#### 3.6.3. The Histopathological Changes in the Kidney

The normal structure of kidney tissue in control treatment was shown in Figure1(a). However, for the rats treated with C. senna extract at dose level of 500 mg/kg, the tissue was some what like control with a small vaculation and degeneration in renal tubules (Figure 1(b)).Sections in kidney of rats treated withC. senna extract (b) at dose level of 500 mg/kg after 21 days of treatment relative to control (a).
(a)(b)


#### 3.6.4. The Histopathological Changes in the Liver

The normal structure of liver tissue in control treatment was shown in Figure2(a). However, the liver of rats treated with C. senna at dose level of 500 mg/kg showed that blood vessels engorged and hepatocyte contain vacuolated cytoplasm (Figure 2(b)).Sections in liver of rats treated withC. senna extract (b) at dose level of 500 mg/kg after 21 days of treatment relative to control (a).
(a)(b)


## 3.1. Effect of Tested Plant Extracts and Malathion on Progeny ofT. granarium

The numbers of emerged adults ofT. granarium were significantly decreased in all treatments (the tested plant extracts and malathion) relative to the control, as shown in Table 1. Moreover, the tested plant extracts delayed the progeny of the tested insect three weeks relative to control treatment. Increasing the concentration level of all tested treatments reduced the emergence of T. granarium even more (concentration dependent).C. senna extract followed by malathion and B. purpurea was the most effective treatment while C. furtescens extract was the least effective one.Table 1
Effect of the tested plant extracts and malathion on progeny ofT. granarium.
TreatmentsConcentration level (mg/L)% ReductionCassia senna10095bc300100a500100a10082gCaesalpinia gilliesii30092.5cd50097.5ab10070iThespesia populnea var. acutiloba30090ed50092.5cdChrysanthemum frutescens10062j30070i50085f10070iEuonymus japonicus30090ed50095bcBauhinia purpurea10097.5ab30097.5ab500100aCassia fistula10080hg30092.5cd50095bcMalathion580hg1097ab20100aControl0.00.00ka,b,c,d,e,f,g,h,i,j,kSeparation of means according to the Student Newman Keuls multiple range test (P<0.05).


## 3.2. Efficiency of Tested Plant Extracts and Malathion onT. granarium Adults Determined by Mortality Values

The efficacy of the tested plant extracts and malathion againstT. granarium adults by means of mortality was presented in Table 2. The results showed thatC. senna was the most effective treatment against T. granarium adults followed by B. purpurea, C. gilliesii, E. japonicus, T. populnea var. acutiloba, C. fistula, malathion, and C. frutescens, respectively. The morality percentages of T. granariumwere significantly increased in the second week relative to the first week at all tested treatments. Increasing the concentration level of all tested treatments increased the mortality of T. granariumadults even more (concentration dependent).Table 2
Effect of the tested plant extracts and malathion on adult’s mortality ofT. granarium.
TreatmentsConcentration level (mg/L)% Mortality after one week% Mortality after two weekCassia senna10086.7abc100a30090abc100a50093abc100a10043de100aCaesalpinia gilliesii30060abc100a50086.7abc100a10040c90aThespesia populnea var. acutiloba30063d93a50083bc100aChrysanthemum frutescens10050de70b30060de97a50083bc100a10060de90aEuonymus japonicus30080c97a50096.7ab100aBauhinia purpurea10083bc100a30090abc100a50093abc100aCassia fistula10057e93a30063d100a50080c100aMalathion560de90a1080a93a2 087a100aControl0.000.00f0.00ca,b,c,d,e,f,g,h,i,j,kSeparation of means according to the Student Newman Keuls multiple range test (P<0.05).


## 3.3. Efficiency of Tested Plant Extracts and Malathion onT. granarium Pupae Determined by Mortality Values

The efficacy of the tested plant extracts and malathion againstT. granarium pupae by means of mortality was presented in Table 3. The results showed thatB. purpureawas the most effective treatment against T. granarium pupae followed by C. senna, C. gilliesii, E. japonicus, T. populnea var. acutiloba, C. fistula, malathion, and C. frutescens, respectively. The morality percentages of T. granariumpupae were significantly increased in the second week relative to the first week at all tested treatments. Increasing the concentration level of all tested treatments increased the mortality of T. granariumpupae even more (concentration dependent).Table 3
Effect of the tested plant extracts and malathion on mortality ofT. granarium pupae.
TreatmentsConcentration level (mg/L)% Mortality after one week% Mortality after two weekCassia senna10066.7def100a30086.7abc100a50093bc100a10043hi97abCaesalpinia gilliesii30047ghi100a50053fgh100a10033ig100aThespesia populnea var. acutiloba30060efg100a50080bcd100aChrysanthemum frutescens10033jg80de30047ghi87bc50053fgh100a10073cde80eEuonymus japonicas30080bcd93cd50083bcd100aBauhinia purpurea10080bcd100a30093ab100a500100a100aCassia fistula10033g93bc30040hi95bc50047gh100aMalathion547ghi67f1080bcd93abc2093ab100aControl0.000.00k0.00ga,b,c,d,e,f,g,h,i,j,kSeparation of means according to the Student Newman Keuls multiple range test (P<0.05).


## 3.4. Efficiency of Tested Plant Extracts and Malathion onT. granarium Larvae Determined by Mortality Values

The efficacy of the tested plant extracts and malathion againstT. granarium larvae by means of mortality was presented in Table 4. The results showed thatC. gilliesiiwas the most effective treatment against T. granarium larvae followed by E. japonicus, C. senna, B. purpurea, T. populnea var. acutiloba, malathion, C. furtescens, and C. fistula, respectively. Among the tested plant extracts, C. gilliesii extract was the most effective one and C. fistula extract recorded the lowest efficacy against the larvae of T. granarium. The mortality percentages of T. granariumlarvae were significantly increased in the second week relative to the first week at all tested treatments. Increasing the concentration level of all tested treatments increased the mortality of T. granariumlarvae even more (concentration dependent).Table 4
Effect of tested plant extracts and malathion on mortality ofT. granarium larvae.
TreatmentsConcentration level (mg/L)% Mortality after one week% Mortality after two weekCassia senna10080bc93a30093ab100a50097ab100a10080bc100aCaesalpinia gilliesii30093abc100a50094ab100a10046.6ef87bcThespesia populnea var. acutiloba30080bc100a50093ab100aChrysanthemum frutescens10047ef80c30053e87bc50060de93ab10060de100aEuonymus japonicus30073cd100a50093ab100aBauhinia purpurea10033fg93ab30053e100a50060de100aCassia fistula10037g87bc30047ef93ab50060de100aMalathion550ef87c1080bc93ab2093a100aControl0.000.00h0.00da,b,c,d,e,f,g,h,i,j,kSeparation of means according to the Student Newman Keuls multiple range test (P<0.05).


## 3.5. Composition of the Most Effective Botanical Extract

The identified chemical components of the most effective botanical extract (C. senna) against T. granarium were presented in Table 5. Eighteen compounds were identified from C. senna extract, separately with different percentages as shown in Table 5.The identified compounds were belonging to different fatty acids and their derivatives (eldyhydes, esters, and alcohols).Table 5
The main constituents ofC. senna plant extract identified by GC-MS analysis.
No.NameRetention time (min)% Area1Beta phellandrene4.331.52Mone inositol4.372.7531,8 Cineole4.9826.554Linalool5.7010.2853 cyclohexen-1-ol 4-methyl-1-(1-methylethyl)6.572.6963cyclohexene-1-methanol-alpha 4-trimethyl-p-menth 1-en-8-ol6.712.487Butanoic acid7.220.028α-Terpineol acetate8.1621.0699-Octadecanoic acid (z)2, 6 octadien-1-ol 3, 7 dimethyl acetate8.372.210Caryophyllene8.850.7511Cycloheptasiloxane tetradecamethyl9.251.712Croweacin9.7220.3131, 6 dodecatrien-3-ol 3, 7, 11 titramethyl9.951.1214Cyclononosiloxane octadecanmethyl11.972.2315Hexadecanoic acid methyl ester13.070.9416Tetratetracontane15.041.1917Tetra cosamethyl cyclododecasiloxane19.192.618Iron monocarbonyl 1,3 butadiene 1,4, dicarbonic acid diethyl ether20.131.83


## 3.6. Toxicity Evaluation

### 3.6.1. Effect of the Most Effective Plant Extract on Liver Enzymes

The Alkaline phosphatase and GPT activities are known as cytosolic marker enzymes reflecting hepatocellular necrosis as they are released into the blood after cell membrane damage. In the present study, therefore, both enzyme activities were used as indicators of hepatic damage. The obtained data in Table6 showed that there were no significant differences in the activity of ALT and GPT after 21 days of rat’s administration with the most effective plant extract at dose level of 500 mg/kg body weight relative to control treatment.Table 6
Effect of the most effective plant extract (C. senna) on serum GPT, ALT, and creatinine of treated rats at dose level of 500 mg/kg body weight.
TreatmentsSGPT U/LALP U/LCreatinine mg/dLControl65±1.39101±5.570.205±0.06C. senna67±3.57111±5.10.197±0.08


### 3.6.2. Effect of the Most Effective Plant Extract on Kidney Function

Regarding the kidney function, there were no significant differences in creatinine level in rats administration with the most effective plant extract at dose level of 500 mg/kg relative to control (Table6). The normal creatinine in rats treated with the most effective plant extract relative to control treatment was assumed to be the normal kidney function. Moreover, the histology of kidney tissue treated with the most effective plant extract relative to control supports this explanation.


### 3.6.3. The Histopathological Changes in the Kidney

The normal structure of kidney tissue in control treatment was shown in Figure1(a). However, for the rats treated with C. senna extract at dose level of 500 mg/kg, the tissue was some what like control with a small vaculation and degeneration in renal tubules (Figure 1(b)).Sections in kidney of rats treated withC. senna extract (b) at dose level of 500 mg/kg after 21 days of treatment relative to control (a).
(a)(b)


### 3.6.4. The Histopathological Changes in the Liver

The normal structure of liver tissue in control treatment was shown in Figure2(a). However, the liver of rats treated with C. senna at dose level of 500 mg/kg showed that blood vessels engorged and hepatocyte contain vacuolated cytoplasm (Figure 2(b)).Sections in liver of rats treated withC. senna extract (b) at dose level of 500 mg/kg after 21 days of treatment relative to control (a).
(a)(b)


## 3.6.1. Effect of the Most Effective Plant Extract on Liver Enzymes

The Alkaline phosphatase and GPT activities are known as cytosolic marker enzymes reflecting hepatocellular necrosis as they are released into the blood after cell membrane damage. In the present study, therefore, both enzyme activities were used as indicators of hepatic damage. The obtained data in Table6 showed that there were no significant differences in the activity of ALT and GPT after 21 days of rat’s administration with the most effective plant extract at dose level of 500 mg/kg body weight relative to control treatment.Table 6
Effect of the most effective plant extract (C. senna) on serum GPT, ALT, and creatinine of treated rats at dose level of 500 mg/kg body weight.
TreatmentsSGPT U/LALP U/LCreatinine mg/dLControl65±1.39101±5.570.205±0.06C. senna67±3.57111±5.10.197±0.08


## 3.6.2. Effect of the Most Effective Plant Extract on Kidney Function

Regarding the kidney function, there were no significant differences in creatinine level in rats administration with the most effective plant extract at dose level of 500 mg/kg relative to control (Table6). The normal creatinine in rats treated with the most effective plant extract relative to control treatment was assumed to be the normal kidney function. Moreover, the histology of kidney tissue treated with the most effective plant extract relative to control supports this explanation.


## 3.6.3. The Histopathological Changes in the Kidney

The normal structure of kidney tissue in control treatment was shown in Figure1(a). However, for the rats treated with C. senna extract at dose level of 500 mg/kg, the tissue was some what like control with a small vaculation and degeneration in renal tubules (Figure 1(b)).Sections in kidney of rats treated withC. senna extract (b) at dose level of 500 mg/kg after 21 days of treatment relative to control (a).
(a)(b)


## 3.6.4. The Histopathological Changes in the Liver

The normal structure of liver tissue in control treatment was shown in Figure2(a). However, the liver of rats treated with C. senna at dose level of 500 mg/kg showed that blood vessels engorged and hepatocyte contain vacuolated cytoplasm (Figure 2(b)).Sections in liver of rats treated withC. senna extract (b) at dose level of 500 mg/kg after 21 days of treatment relative to control (a).
(a)(b)


## 4. Discussion

The results of the present study implied that the tested plant extracts were effective againstT. granarium in stored wheat with respect to progeny of adults and mortality of all its stages (larvae, pupae, and adult). The efficacy of the plant extracts againstT. granarium insect in stored wheat with respect to progeny and adult mortality has been reported by many researchers [10, 18, 19]. However, the efficacy of the tested plant extracts, especially the most effective ones, has not been reported againstT. granarium and considered first report.Among the identified compounds fromC. sennaextract, some compounds such as 1,8 cineole, linalool, butanoic acid, α-terpineol acetate, and croweacin were detected with high percentages relative to other detected compounds. The insecticidal activity of C. sennaextract against T. granarium may be due to the presence of the previous fatty acids and its derivatives [20–24]. Moreover, the efficacy of the most effective plant extract at higher concentrations might actually have efficacy comparable to the chemical pesticides. In fact, the actual dosage of any one compound identified in this extract could be relatively low, safe, and economically feasible.Although the insecticidal activity of the most effective plant extract is attributed mainly to its major compounds mentioned before, the synergistic or antagonistic effect of some compounds in the mixture has to be considered [25]. Each of the plant extract components has its own contribution on biological activity of the extract against the tested insect.The mode of action of the bioactive natural monoter-penoids (hydrocarbons, alcohols, and ketones) isolated from plant extracts oils may be due to inhibition of acetylcholinesterase [26–28]. Since Lee et al. [28] reported that 1, 8-Cineole was the most potent inhibitor of AChE among the monoterpenes tested. This inhibition may be a mode of action for essential oils and monoterpenes against stored grain insects as well. Also, the mode of action of the tested botanical extracts may be largely attributable to its fumigant action [20, 29].The botanical extracts as pest control agents present two main characters: the first is their safety to the people and the environment, and the second is the less resistance development against it by the tested insect. Regarding the safety, the toxicity evaluation of the most effective plant extract revealed that there were some slight variations that occurred sporadically in treated rats relative to control with respect to enzyme markers and histopathology of treated organs. Moreover, the observed changes in the tissues were mostly uncorrelated with the dosages which reflect the safety of the tested plant extract on human health. With referring to resistance development, it is believed that it is difficult for the insect to develop resistance to such a mixture of bioactive components with, apparently, different mechanisms of insecticidal activity [30].This study is considered the first step toward more investigation and concern about using these effective botanical extracts as alternative for controlling of stored product pests. This will help to reduce the environmental pollution and the adverse effect on human health resulted from using insecticides since these botanical extracts revealed nonsignificant toxicity relative to the high dosage that were given orally and will not reach human by this dose as a residue under any conditions.


## 5. Conclusions

The insecticidal activity of the tested plant extracts againstT. granarium indicated the potential of some plant species (C. senna, B. purpurea, andC. gilliesii) as a natural source of insecticidal material. Insecticidal activity was confirmed in all the tested plant species, although the results showed variation in their effectiveness against T. granarium insect. The ability of using botanical products as alternative of chemical control ofT. granarium is possible if the problem of cost-effective commercial production can be solved. Moreover, some of these botanical extracts could find a place in IPM strategies, especially where the emphasis is on environmental, food safety and on replacing the more dangerous toxic insecticides. Work in this regard should continue to obtain information regarding its practical effectiveness under natural conditions to protect the stored products without any side effects.



---

*Source: 639854-2012-04-19.xml*