# Microstructure and Wear Behavior of CoCrFeMnNbNi High-Entropy Alloy Coating by TIG Cladding

Authors: Wen-yi Huo; Hai-fang Shi; Xin Ren; Jing-yuan Zhang
Journal: Advances in Materials Science and Engineering
 (2015)

---

## Abstract

Alloy cladding coatings are widely prepared on the surface of tools and machines. High-entropy alloys are potential replacements of nickel-, iron-, and cobalt-base alloys in machining due to their excellent strength and toughness. In this work, CoCrFeMnNbNi HEA coating was produced on AISI 304 steel by tungsten inert gas cladding. The microstructure and wear behavior of the cladding coating were studied by X-ray diffraction, scanning electron microscopy, energy dispersive spectrometer, microhardness tester, pin-on-ring wear tester, and 3D confocal laser scanning microscope. The microstructure showed up as a nanoscale lamellar structure matrix which is a face-centered-cubic solid solution and niobium-rich Laves phase. The microhardness of the cladding coating is greater than the structure. The cladding coating has excellent wear resistance under the condition of dry sliding wear, and the microploughing  in the worn cladding coating is shallower and finer than the worn structure, which is related to composition changes caused by forming the nanoscale lamellar structure of Laves phase.


---

## Body

## 1. Introduction

In 1995, Yeh et al. developed the high-entropy alloy (HEA) system [1–3], which is a multielement system that can crystallize as simple phases, despite containing different elements [4]. They are based on the promising alloy design ideas of configurational entropy maximization. Compared with the classic alloys, they generally have a better performance. The equiatomic and nonequiatomic HEAs which crystallize in the face-centered cubic (FCC) have been paid wide attention owing to their excellent property of toughness, among which the CoCrFeMnNi HEA system is a typical one [5–10]. The low diffusion rate of HEAs at high and low temperatures makes their applications in harsh condition possible [5–7]. From what have been analyzed above, the HEA cladding coating has also been extensively studied and shown to have enormous potential in surface engineering. The excellent properties they showed are the same with the HEAs. However, the HEA cladding coating system is confined to AlxFeCoNiCuCr [11], FeCoNiCrCu [12], TiVCrAlSi [13, 14], 6FeNiCoCrAlTiSi [15], NiCrAlCoCu [16], NiCrAlCoMo [16], CoCrCuFeNiNbx [17], and so on.Tungsten inert gas (TIG) cladding is one of the common and economical methods of surface treatment and surface alloying, which can easily provide the substrate metallurgical bond with cladding coating. There is always one dominant element in conventional cladding coating systems; however, many multicomponent mixed powders which contain nickel-, iron-, and cobalt-base alloys have been cladded on the substrates. Recently, HEA cladding coatings have been well prepared by TIG cladding [16]. In this study, CoCrFeMnNbNi HEA coating has been produced on the surface of AISI 304 steel substrate by TIG cladding, and its wear behavior has been researched exhaustively.


## 2. Experimental Procedure

### 2.1. Preparation of the Cladding Coating

The AISI 304 steel was machined into a rectangular specimen with dimension of 50 mm × 40 mm × 8 mm as a substrate. Table1 lists the chemical proportion of the coating material. The Co, Cr, Fe, Mn, Nb, and Ni powder (purity > 99.9 Wt.%) was prepared as raw materials. Figure 1 shows the atomic radii of elements. Apparently, Nb has the largest atomic size among the elements. Even compared with Nb, there is little difference among the atomic radius values of Co, Cr, Fe, Mn, and Ni. So it can be expected that Nb makes the effect of lattice distortion and solid solution improve to a large extent.Table 1
Chemical composition of the mixed powder.
Element
Co
Cr
Fe
Mn
Nb
Ni
At. [%]
16.66
16.67
16.66
16.67
16.67
16.67
Wt. [%]
15.78
13.93
14.95
14.72
24.89
15.73Figure 1
Atomic radii of elements.The mixed powder was well mixed without any kind of binders and it was manufactured into small pieces with dimension of 30 mm × 10 mm × 2 mm through compacting and pressure working. The equipment used in this process was a WE-30 hydraulic universal testing machine with dedicated mold. By using WS-500 inverter DC TIG welder in cladding, under an argon atmosphere, the piece was synthesized on the surface of substrate. Table2 lists the parameters of the cladding.Table 2
Parameters of the cladding.
Cladding current [A]
210
Traveling speed [m/s]
2 × 10−3
Argon, flow rate [L/min]
12
Arc gap [m]
3.5 × 10−3
Electrode type
W-1.5% lanthanum
Electrode polarity
DCSP


### 2.2. Characterization of the Cladding Coating

The crystalline phases were determined by an X’Pert PRO X-ray diffraction (XRD) for a 2θ range of 20° to 80° using Cu-Kα radiation. Microstructure was characterized by an EVO MA 10 scanning electron microscope (SEM) and an X-act X-ray energy dispersive spectrometer (EDS). The microhardness along the depth of the cross section was measured by using the HV-1000Z microhardness tester with a load of 1.96 N. An ML-100 pin-on-ring wear tester was used to measure the abrasive wear resistance of the cladding coating under the condition of dry sliding wear. The sample was electrode-discharge machined to a cylinder with the size of Φ 6 mm × 10 mm. The 180 grade silicon carbide sandpaper was used as the friction counterpart. The wear conditions were a sliding speed of 60 r/min, a radial feed rate of 1 mm/r, a rotating diameter of 70–220 mm, and a normal load of 40 N. The worn surfaces were scanned using a 3D confocal laser scanning microscope to study the wear behavior of the cladding coating.


## 2.1. Preparation of the Cladding Coating

The AISI 304 steel was machined into a rectangular specimen with dimension of 50 mm × 40 mm × 8 mm as a substrate. Table1 lists the chemical proportion of the coating material. The Co, Cr, Fe, Mn, Nb, and Ni powder (purity > 99.9 Wt.%) was prepared as raw materials. Figure 1 shows the atomic radii of elements. Apparently, Nb has the largest atomic size among the elements. Even compared with Nb, there is little difference among the atomic radius values of Co, Cr, Fe, Mn, and Ni. So it can be expected that Nb makes the effect of lattice distortion and solid solution improve to a large extent.Table 1
Chemical composition of the mixed powder.
Element
Co
Cr
Fe
Mn
Nb
Ni
At. [%]
16.66
16.67
16.66
16.67
16.67
16.67
Wt. [%]
15.78
13.93
14.95
14.72
24.89
15.73Figure 1
Atomic radii of elements.The mixed powder was well mixed without any kind of binders and it was manufactured into small pieces with dimension of 30 mm × 10 mm × 2 mm through compacting and pressure working. The equipment used in this process was a WE-30 hydraulic universal testing machine with dedicated mold. By using WS-500 inverter DC TIG welder in cladding, under an argon atmosphere, the piece was synthesized on the surface of substrate. Table2 lists the parameters of the cladding.Table 2
Parameters of the cladding.
Cladding current [A]
210
Traveling speed [m/s]
2 × 10−3
Argon, flow rate [L/min]
12
Arc gap [m]
3.5 × 10−3
Electrode type
W-1.5% lanthanum
Electrode polarity
DCSP


## 2.2. Characterization of the Cladding Coating

The crystalline phases were determined by an X’Pert PRO X-ray diffraction (XRD) for a 2θ range of 20° to 80° using Cu-Kα radiation. Microstructure was characterized by an EVO MA 10 scanning electron microscope (SEM) and an X-act X-ray energy dispersive spectrometer (EDS). The microhardness along the depth of the cross section was measured by using the HV-1000Z microhardness tester with a load of 1.96 N. An ML-100 pin-on-ring wear tester was used to measure the abrasive wear resistance of the cladding coating under the condition of dry sliding wear. The sample was electrode-discharge machined to a cylinder with the size of Φ 6 mm × 10 mm. The 180 grade silicon carbide sandpaper was used as the friction counterpart. The wear conditions were a sliding speed of 60 r/min, a radial feed rate of 1 mm/r, a rotating diameter of 70–220 mm, and a normal load of 40 N. The worn surfaces were scanned using a 3D confocal laser scanning microscope to study the wear behavior of the cladding coating.


## 3. Results and Discussion

### 3.1. Microstructure

Figure2 shows the XRD pattern of the CoCrFeMnNbNi HEA coating. A face-centered-cubic (FCC) solid-solution phase and a Laves phase are obtained in the cladding coating due to the high-entropy effect which makes the total number of phases lower than the value of the maximum equilibrium allowed by the Gibbs phase rule. The FCC solid-solution phase is similar with the peak positions of (Fe, Ni) type, while the Laves phase is similar with the peak positions of Fe2Nb type.Figure 2
XRD pattern of CoCrFeMnNbNi HEA coating.Figure3 shows the microstructure of the surface of unetched CoCrFeMnNbNi HEA coating, which is composed of dendritic (DR) and interdendritic (ID) regions. From Figure 3, it can be seen that DR and ID regions are alternately arranged forming a lamellar colony. Its lamellar spacing is about 100~200 nm. Table 3 shows the chemical proportion of DR and ID. Considered in conjunction with Figure 3, it is obvious that the BSI contrast of DR regions is bright, which indicates that these regions contain much heavier elements. However, ID regions’ contrast is dark, which suggests that these regions contain less heavier elements. The EDS analysis suggests that DR regions are enriched with Nb, while ID regions are depleted with Nb. Figure 2 shows that the cladding coating is two phases: it is reasonable to infer that DR regions are Laves phase and ID regions are FCC solid-solution phase in the light of different content of niobium. The adding of Nb can effectively refine microstructure which may be attributed to the segregation of Nb in DR regions. The nucleation and growth of FCC solid-solution phase are retarded, which can be attributed to Nb solute atoms segregation in the forefront of solid-liquid (S-L) interface, and grain boundaries are favorable position for the location of niobium atoms [17]. In addition, Fe, Cr, and Ni, the principal elements of the AISI 304 steel substrate, participate in cladding process during the TIG cladding. These elements have diffused from the substrate to the coating surface to make their contents in the surface of cladding coating rise.Table 3
Chemical proportion of DR and ID (At. %).
Element
Co
Cr
Fe
Mn
Nb
Ni
DR
8.77
16.77
38.16
9.50
15.31
11.49
ID
8.71
19.12
40.75
10.88
6.32
14.22Figure 3
Microstructure of the surface of CoCrFeMnNbNi HEA coating.


### 3.2. Microhardness and Wear Behavior

Figure4 shows the microhardness profile of CoCrFeMnNbNi HEA coating. As what can be seen in it, the cladding coating presents a greater microhardness compared to the substrate. Excluding the high-entropy effect, the improvement in hardness can be ascribed to the Laves phase. The niobium added makes the crystal structure form the nanoscale Laves phase and reinforces the solution strengthening. The microhardness of transition zone is less than that of cladding coating surface for the reason that elements of the substrate (such as Fe, Cr, and Ni) have been excessively diffused during the process of solidification. It helps to enhance the cladding coating adhesion.Figure 4
Microhardness profile of CoCrFeMnNbNi HEA coating.Figure5 shows the mass losses of cladding coating and substrate as a function of sliding time. The CoCrFeMnNbNi HEA coating exhibited much lower mass loss compared with AISI 304 steel. It is clear that it has a lower wear rate than AISI 304 steel. The existence of Laves phase with nanoscale lamellar spacing leads to higher load capacity and protection of the surface against sliding wear scratches. Hard Laves phase resists destructive action during sliding and protects the surface against severe plastic deformation. The FCC solid-solution phase with great toughness protects the surface against brittle fracture.Figure 5
Mass losses of CoCrFeMnNbNi HEA coating and substrate as a function of sliding time.Figure6 shows the 3D microstructure of worn surfaces of AISI 304 steel and the CoCrFeMnNbNi HEA coating. On the worn surface of AISI 304 steel, microploughing is obvious. This can be attributed to plastic deformation during sliding. It is the typical characteristic of abrasive wear mechanism. The microploughing on worn surfaces of the cladding coating is shallower and finer compared with AISI 304 steel.3D microstructure of worn surfaces of AISI 304 steel and CoCrFeMnNbNi HEA coating (μm).
(a)
AISI 304 steel
(b)
CoCrFeMnNbNi HEA coating


## 3.1. Microstructure

Figure2 shows the XRD pattern of the CoCrFeMnNbNi HEA coating. A face-centered-cubic (FCC) solid-solution phase and a Laves phase are obtained in the cladding coating due to the high-entropy effect which makes the total number of phases lower than the value of the maximum equilibrium allowed by the Gibbs phase rule. The FCC solid-solution phase is similar with the peak positions of (Fe, Ni) type, while the Laves phase is similar with the peak positions of Fe2Nb type.Figure 2
XRD pattern of CoCrFeMnNbNi HEA coating.Figure3 shows the microstructure of the surface of unetched CoCrFeMnNbNi HEA coating, which is composed of dendritic (DR) and interdendritic (ID) regions. From Figure 3, it can be seen that DR and ID regions are alternately arranged forming a lamellar colony. Its lamellar spacing is about 100~200 nm. Table 3 shows the chemical proportion of DR and ID. Considered in conjunction with Figure 3, it is obvious that the BSI contrast of DR regions is bright, which indicates that these regions contain much heavier elements. However, ID regions’ contrast is dark, which suggests that these regions contain less heavier elements. The EDS analysis suggests that DR regions are enriched with Nb, while ID regions are depleted with Nb. Figure 2 shows that the cladding coating is two phases: it is reasonable to infer that DR regions are Laves phase and ID regions are FCC solid-solution phase in the light of different content of niobium. The adding of Nb can effectively refine microstructure which may be attributed to the segregation of Nb in DR regions. The nucleation and growth of FCC solid-solution phase are retarded, which can be attributed to Nb solute atoms segregation in the forefront of solid-liquid (S-L) interface, and grain boundaries are favorable position for the location of niobium atoms [17]. In addition, Fe, Cr, and Ni, the principal elements of the AISI 304 steel substrate, participate in cladding process during the TIG cladding. These elements have diffused from the substrate to the coating surface to make their contents in the surface of cladding coating rise.Table 3
Chemical proportion of DR and ID (At. %).
Element
Co
Cr
Fe
Mn
Nb
Ni
DR
8.77
16.77
38.16
9.50
15.31
11.49
ID
8.71
19.12
40.75
10.88
6.32
14.22Figure 3
Microstructure of the surface of CoCrFeMnNbNi HEA coating.


## 3.2. Microhardness and Wear Behavior

Figure4 shows the microhardness profile of CoCrFeMnNbNi HEA coating. As what can be seen in it, the cladding coating presents a greater microhardness compared to the substrate. Excluding the high-entropy effect, the improvement in hardness can be ascribed to the Laves phase. The niobium added makes the crystal structure form the nanoscale Laves phase and reinforces the solution strengthening. The microhardness of transition zone is less than that of cladding coating surface for the reason that elements of the substrate (such as Fe, Cr, and Ni) have been excessively diffused during the process of solidification. It helps to enhance the cladding coating adhesion.Figure 4
Microhardness profile of CoCrFeMnNbNi HEA coating.Figure5 shows the mass losses of cladding coating and substrate as a function of sliding time. The CoCrFeMnNbNi HEA coating exhibited much lower mass loss compared with AISI 304 steel. It is clear that it has a lower wear rate than AISI 304 steel. The existence of Laves phase with nanoscale lamellar spacing leads to higher load capacity and protection of the surface against sliding wear scratches. Hard Laves phase resists destructive action during sliding and protects the surface against severe plastic deformation. The FCC solid-solution phase with great toughness protects the surface against brittle fracture.Figure 5
Mass losses of CoCrFeMnNbNi HEA coating and substrate as a function of sliding time.Figure6 shows the 3D microstructure of worn surfaces of AISI 304 steel and the CoCrFeMnNbNi HEA coating. On the worn surface of AISI 304 steel, microploughing is obvious. This can be attributed to plastic deformation during sliding. It is the typical characteristic of abrasive wear mechanism. The microploughing on worn surfaces of the cladding coating is shallower and finer compared with AISI 304 steel.3D microstructure of worn surfaces of AISI 304 steel and CoCrFeMnNbNi HEA coating (μm).
(a)
AISI 304 steel
(b)
CoCrFeMnNbNi HEA coating


## 4. Conclusion

The microhardness of the CoCrFeMnNbNi high-entropy alloy coating produced by TIG cladding increased significantly compared to the AISI 304 steel substrate. The microstructure showed up as a nanoscale lamellar structure matrix which is a face-centered-cubic solid solution and niobium-rich Laves phase. It is due to the fact that added Nb makes the nucleation and growth of face-centered-cubic solid-solution phase retard. The cladding coating has excellent wear resistance under the condition of dry sliding wear, which is due to the fact that hard Laves phase resists destructive action during sliding and protects the surface against severe plastic deformation and the FCC solid-solution phase with a great toughness protects the surface against brittle fracture.



---

*Source: 647351-2015-01-06.xml*