# Design of Commute Carpooling Based on Fixed Time and Routes

Authors: Guiliang Zhou; Kai Huang; Lina Mao
Journal: International Journal of Vehicular Technology
 (2014)

---

## Abstract

Although the private carpooling market of China has grown rapidly, it has been embarrassed by problems such as obstructed information, disordered expense, and frequent crimes currently. In this paper, a commute carpooling program based on fixed time and routes is designed and corresponding carpooling information platform is built to realize information retrieval, information matching, and mutual selection and evaluation. We have practiced the program in Huaian, China, and then evaluated it using the improved time-expense impedance model and VISSIM simulation system. The result shows that the carpooling program can reduce 65%~86% of the time-expense impedance and optimize some network parameters up to 20%~40%. Since it will help in reducing the travel time and cost greatly, improving safety and economy during carpooling, and easing the traffic congestion, it is a worthy carpooling mode to be extended in China.


---

## Body

## 1. Introduction

In China, some growing problems have constrained the development of urban transport and society, which include the crowded city population, the substantial increase of private cars, the urban road congestion, and the traffic pollution [1–3]. According to the data from 2000 to 2012, the private car ownership increased from 6.25 million to 88.38 million. The annual average growth rate was about 122.60%. However, the road mileage increased from 1679.90 thousand kilometers to 4234.50 thousand kilometers. The annual average growth rate was about 107.37%. The road construction is hard to meet the traffic demand. See Figure 1.Figure 1
The road mileage and private car ownership in China, 2000–2012.Traffic congestion, environmental pollution, energy shortages, taxi difficulties, and other issues cause people to begin exploring new and green private car trip modes [4]. A survey shows that there is only one person in 80% of private cars by highway gate during the morning peak hours in Beijing. Such trip efficiency apparently brought great pressure to traffic and environment and caused serious waste of transportation resources [5]. Carpooling will reduce about 400 thousand cars traveling every day in Beijing. Also, the automobile exhaust is causing serious effect on urban environment, and carpooling can reduce the emission of nitrogen oxides and the greenhouse gas (GHG). Besides, just like bus, regular carpooling is an effective way to encourage public transportation.Since the high private car ownership with high empty-loading rate wastes huge traffic resources and moreover causes serious traffic congestion and exhaust emission pollution, research on green and economical trip mode is imperative [6]. The paper studies green traffic development of regional central city and puts forward the green transportation development strategy of commuting carpooling based on fixed time and routes innovatively. It is supported by Ministry of Housing and Urban Rural Development project Study on the Green Transportation Development Strategy in Regional Central City. By means of the opportunity of constructing Huai’an as the central city in northern Jiangsu, it takes Huai’an as the pilot to design and realize the program. This is a theory and practice innovation attempt of green transport development.


## 2. Related Work

Carpooling has been attempted in different forms worldwide. It is relatively mature in Europe and America, where it has become a normal lifestyle [7, 8]. The most representative system is the high occupancy vehicle (HOV) in California, which provides carpooling cars with dedicated lanes [9]. Now, private carpooling in China is in the exploratory stage. Though many cities have tried it, the effects are not ideal because of irrational organization.Moni Naor proposed the fairness problem of carpooling in “On Fairness in the Carpool Problem.” In order to insure sustainable carpooling, organizers should allocate some regular round-trip participants to the drivers. Furthermore, the concept of a fair share for the participants (Frank-Williams share) was defined. And a fair share of axiomatic characteristics to implement carpooling was provided [10].In “A Cloud Computing Framework for Real-Time Carpooling Services,” Zhang et al. put forward a carpooling service based on cloud computing [11]. It proposes that using computer client and mobile client through cloud computing to carpool could increase the efficiency of carpooling.However, the development of carpooling is not smoothly in China [12]. One of the main works of research is legitimacy of carpooling. In “Tied Bus-Taking with Consideration,” the author made analysis on legitimacy. The paper thought that carpooling is different from unlicensed cars for the compensatory payment is lower than drivers’ expenses [13].From existing research, there is no researcher involved in commute carpooling on fixed time and routes yet. This paper will study the commute carpooling based on fixed time and routes.


## 3. Design of Commute Carpooling Based on Fixed Time and Routes

### 3.1. Design of Carpooling Process

The fixed time and routes carpooling can be operated and managed by a pure public welfare or part-public welfare and part-profit company, which could be founded and supervised by the local transportation management office. The company’s primary task is building information platform for fixed time and routes carpooling, which is the basis for connecting both sides of carpooling. Also, the company is responsible for checking the effectiveness and legitimacy of the information of drivers and passengers. Besides, it is necessary to focus on those participants with illegal violation and bad credit history. Those serious cases can be directly rejected to join the carpooling system, in order to ensure the security, efficiency, and economy of the carpooling. In addition, all the personal information is invisible. The information which is accepted or rejected will be sent to users through the information platform directly.The carpooling process is shown in Figure2. Drivers register or login in the information platform and release the carpooling information of running time, location, and routes. Passengers register, login in, and submit the carpooling application with trip time, location, and routes information. Then, the information platform summarizes, checks, and matches all the information from drivers and passengers. Once successful, the system will send matched results to participants by computer and mobile client automatically. If participants are satisfied with matched results, the carpooling will be implemented on time. Otherwise, system must match the information circularly. Drivers or passengers can also directly select each other according to the information displayed without automatic matching by system. Participants will feedback their selections to the system. After completing, both sides of carpooling will make mutual evaluation on the platform. In order to improve the convenience of carpooling and mutual evaluation, the mobile APP software can be developed later so as to improve dynamic real-time carpooling information updates.Figure 2
The flowchart of fixed time and routes carpooling.


### 3.2. Design of Carpooling Information Platform

The information platform needs to support carpooling information from participants, as well as routes and time selection. Visualization operations by users, including user login, identity authentication, order management, and other functions are mainly realized by the Presentation Layer. Mutual selection and information matching are mainly processed by the Logical Layer. The Data Access Layer shows the progress of data dealing. The structure of the carpooling information platform is shown in Figure3.Figure 3
The structure of carpooling information platform.


#### 3.2.1. Function Design of Carpooling Information Platform

Information platform on fixed time and routes carpooling can use cloud storage and retrieval service. Functions of the platform mainly include information retrieval, information matching, mutual selection, and mutual evaluation.The specific functions are the following.(i)
Information Retrieval. Drivers access the information platform, release carpooling information such as vehicle running time and routes, and query the passenger information. Passengers login the system, submit carpooling applications, namely trip time, location, and routes information, and check the driver information.
(ii)
Information Matching. The information system summarizes drivers’ time, routes information, and passengers’ carpooling demand information and matches them reasonably. Then the matching results will be fed back to both sides in time so as to complete the next step.
(iii)
Mutual Selection. Drivers (passengers) select passengers (drivers) according to their own requirements and the initial matching information; if they select each other, then the matching will be successful. Otherwise, the system will continue matching information. The carpooling information will be processed by the platform once released by both sides. The system will send the matching information to drivers and passengers for mutual selection. Passengers judge the driver’s driving ability and the vehicle condition. Drivers check the number of passengers, the working place, and time. If satisfying mutual selection cannot be reached, the system will match information again until both sides are satisfied with the matching results so as to realize the humanized carpooling and improve the carpooling efficiency.
(iv)
Mutual Evaluation. The drivers and passengers will make mutual evaluation on the completed trip. The evaluation results will be recorded as personal credibility directly, which will affect the success rate of next carpooling. For drivers, bad reputation will seldom make people willing to take their cars, thus affecting carpooling income. For passengers, bad credit will cause drivers reluctant to carpool with them and then greatly affect their commute convenience and economy. Mutual evaluation can be made through the mobile client anywhere [14].


#### 3.2.2. Design of the Presentation Layer of Information Platform

Currently, relying on the Transportation Research Institute of Huaiyin Institute of Technology, Jiangsu, the carpooling program has established the fixed time and routes information platform [15]. The main interfaces of the platform are shown in Figure 4.Figure 4
The main interfaces of carpooling system.


#### 3.2.3. Design of the Business Logical Layer of Information Platform

Information matching is the key step during the designing of business Logical Layer. The results can be fed back to both sides of carpooling for confirming the selection timely only with rapid and effective information matching. Therefore, the paper constructed a mathematical model for information matching. The specific mathematical model is as follows:IFP
(
d
k
,
t
l
)
⊆
O
(
d
i
,
t
j
), THEN information matching succeeds;
IFP
(
d
k
,
t
l
)
⊄
O
(
d
i
,
t
j
), THEN information matching fails;
O
(
d
i
,
t
j
): the drivers’ time set corresponding to going through certain site
(1)
i
,
j
—
1
,
2
,
3
,
…
;
P
(
d
k
,
t
l
): the passengers’ origins and destinations and corresponding time set
(2)
l
,
k
—
1
,
2
,
3
,
…
.The system will output the matching results directly when the passengers’ routes and time accord with the drivers’ information and then wait for the mutual selection by drivers and passengers.


## 3.1. Design of Carpooling Process

The fixed time and routes carpooling can be operated and managed by a pure public welfare or part-public welfare and part-profit company, which could be founded and supervised by the local transportation management office. The company’s primary task is building information platform for fixed time and routes carpooling, which is the basis for connecting both sides of carpooling. Also, the company is responsible for checking the effectiveness and legitimacy of the information of drivers and passengers. Besides, it is necessary to focus on those participants with illegal violation and bad credit history. Those serious cases can be directly rejected to join the carpooling system, in order to ensure the security, efficiency, and economy of the carpooling. In addition, all the personal information is invisible. The information which is accepted or rejected will be sent to users through the information platform directly.The carpooling process is shown in Figure2. Drivers register or login in the information platform and release the carpooling information of running time, location, and routes. Passengers register, login in, and submit the carpooling application with trip time, location, and routes information. Then, the information platform summarizes, checks, and matches all the information from drivers and passengers. Once successful, the system will send matched results to participants by computer and mobile client automatically. If participants are satisfied with matched results, the carpooling will be implemented on time. Otherwise, system must match the information circularly. Drivers or passengers can also directly select each other according to the information displayed without automatic matching by system. Participants will feedback their selections to the system. After completing, both sides of carpooling will make mutual evaluation on the platform. In order to improve the convenience of carpooling and mutual evaluation, the mobile APP software can be developed later so as to improve dynamic real-time carpooling information updates.Figure 2
The flowchart of fixed time and routes carpooling.


## 3.2. Design of Carpooling Information Platform

The information platform needs to support carpooling information from participants, as well as routes and time selection. Visualization operations by users, including user login, identity authentication, order management, and other functions are mainly realized by the Presentation Layer. Mutual selection and information matching are mainly processed by the Logical Layer. The Data Access Layer shows the progress of data dealing. The structure of the carpooling information platform is shown in Figure3.Figure 3
The structure of carpooling information platform.


### 3.2.1. Function Design of Carpooling Information Platform

Information platform on fixed time and routes carpooling can use cloud storage and retrieval service. Functions of the platform mainly include information retrieval, information matching, mutual selection, and mutual evaluation.The specific functions are the following.(i)
Information Retrieval. Drivers access the information platform, release carpooling information such as vehicle running time and routes, and query the passenger information. Passengers login the system, submit carpooling applications, namely trip time, location, and routes information, and check the driver information.
(ii)
Information Matching. The information system summarizes drivers’ time, routes information, and passengers’ carpooling demand information and matches them reasonably. Then the matching results will be fed back to both sides in time so as to complete the next step.
(iii)
Mutual Selection. Drivers (passengers) select passengers (drivers) according to their own requirements and the initial matching information; if they select each other, then the matching will be successful. Otherwise, the system will continue matching information. The carpooling information will be processed by the platform once released by both sides. The system will send the matching information to drivers and passengers for mutual selection. Passengers judge the driver’s driving ability and the vehicle condition. Drivers check the number of passengers, the working place, and time. If satisfying mutual selection cannot be reached, the system will match information again until both sides are satisfied with the matching results so as to realize the humanized carpooling and improve the carpooling efficiency.
(iv)
Mutual Evaluation. The drivers and passengers will make mutual evaluation on the completed trip. The evaluation results will be recorded as personal credibility directly, which will affect the success rate of next carpooling. For drivers, bad reputation will seldom make people willing to take their cars, thus affecting carpooling income. For passengers, bad credit will cause drivers reluctant to carpool with them and then greatly affect their commute convenience and economy. Mutual evaluation can be made through the mobile client anywhere [14].


### 3.2.2. Design of the Presentation Layer of Information Platform

Currently, relying on the Transportation Research Institute of Huaiyin Institute of Technology, Jiangsu, the carpooling program has established the fixed time and routes information platform [15]. The main interfaces of the platform are shown in Figure 4.Figure 4
The main interfaces of carpooling system.


### 3.2.3. Design of the Business Logical Layer of Information Platform

Information matching is the key step during the designing of business Logical Layer. The results can be fed back to both sides of carpooling for confirming the selection timely only with rapid and effective information matching. Therefore, the paper constructed a mathematical model for information matching. The specific mathematical model is as follows:IFP
(
d
k
,
t
l
)
⊆
O
(
d
i
,
t
j
), THEN information matching succeeds;
IFP
(
d
k
,
t
l
)
⊄
O
(
d
i
,
t
j
), THEN information matching fails;
O
(
d
i
,
t
j
): the drivers’ time set corresponding to going through certain site
(1)
i
,
j
—
1
,
2
,
3
,
…
;
P
(
d
k
,
t
l
): the passengers’ origins and destinations and corresponding time set
(2)
l
,
k
—
1
,
2
,
3
,
…
.The system will output the matching results directly when the passengers’ routes and time accord with the drivers’ information and then wait for the mutual selection by drivers and passengers.


## 3.2.1. Function Design of Carpooling Information Platform

Information platform on fixed time and routes carpooling can use cloud storage and retrieval service. Functions of the platform mainly include information retrieval, information matching, mutual selection, and mutual evaluation.The specific functions are the following.(i)
Information Retrieval. Drivers access the information platform, release carpooling information such as vehicle running time and routes, and query the passenger information. Passengers login the system, submit carpooling applications, namely trip time, location, and routes information, and check the driver information.
(ii)
Information Matching. The information system summarizes drivers’ time, routes information, and passengers’ carpooling demand information and matches them reasonably. Then the matching results will be fed back to both sides in time so as to complete the next step.
(iii)
Mutual Selection. Drivers (passengers) select passengers (drivers) according to their own requirements and the initial matching information; if they select each other, then the matching will be successful. Otherwise, the system will continue matching information. The carpooling information will be processed by the platform once released by both sides. The system will send the matching information to drivers and passengers for mutual selection. Passengers judge the driver’s driving ability and the vehicle condition. Drivers check the number of passengers, the working place, and time. If satisfying mutual selection cannot be reached, the system will match information again until both sides are satisfied with the matching results so as to realize the humanized carpooling and improve the carpooling efficiency.
(iv)
Mutual Evaluation. The drivers and passengers will make mutual evaluation on the completed trip. The evaluation results will be recorded as personal credibility directly, which will affect the success rate of next carpooling. For drivers, bad reputation will seldom make people willing to take their cars, thus affecting carpooling income. For passengers, bad credit will cause drivers reluctant to carpool with them and then greatly affect their commute convenience and economy. Mutual evaluation can be made through the mobile client anywhere [14].


## 3.2.2. Design of the Presentation Layer of Information Platform

Currently, relying on the Transportation Research Institute of Huaiyin Institute of Technology, Jiangsu, the carpooling program has established the fixed time and routes information platform [15]. The main interfaces of the platform are shown in Figure 4.Figure 4
The main interfaces of carpooling system.


## 3.2.3. Design of the Business Logical Layer of Information Platform

Information matching is the key step during the designing of business Logical Layer. The results can be fed back to both sides of carpooling for confirming the selection timely only with rapid and effective information matching. Therefore, the paper constructed a mathematical model for information matching. The specific mathematical model is as follows:IFP
(
d
k
,
t
l
)
⊆
O
(
d
i
,
t
j
), THEN information matching succeeds;
IFP
(
d
k
,
t
l
)
⊄
O
(
d
i
,
t
j
), THEN information matching fails;
O
(
d
i
,
t
j
): the drivers’ time set corresponding to going through certain site
(1)
i
,
j
—
1
,
2
,
3
,
…
;
P
(
d
k
,
t
l
): the passengers’ origins and destinations and corresponding time set
(2)
l
,
k
—
1
,
2
,
3
,
…
.The system will output the matching results directly when the passengers’ routes and time accord with the drivers’ information and then wait for the mutual selection by drivers and passengers.


## 4. Experiment

The experiment was carried out in Huai’an, China. It made detailed regulations on various aspects, which include market survey, carpooling time, and routes selection, formulating expense, checking vehicles and drivers, supervising carpooling, and fee settlement, to ensure the safety and economy of commute carpooling. In the following, evaluations on experiment results of part areas in Huai’an will be conducted from two aspects: the time-expense and the entire network.


### 4.1. The Comprehensive Evaluation of Time and Expense

Considering double indexes of time and expense, ordinary traffic impedance model cannot analyze the carpooling program accurately and need to be improved. We put forward an improved time-expense traffic impedance model to evaluate it(3)
Q
=
a
*
T
+
E
Q—The time-expense impedance;
T—Carpooling time (h);
E—Carpooling expense (Ұ);
a—Preference coefficient, 1.02.The traffic impedance (Q) is obtained by summing the traffic expense and weighted time. It is necessary to multiply time by the preference coefficient. After collecting and analyzing the preferable selection of citizens about travel burden, the time overweighs the expense and the result of preference coefficient is 1.02, which means people consider time more than the expense.For the different dimensions and dimensional units in the expression, it is necessary to normalize the data. By comprising, Min-Max standardization is selected to normalize them to[
0
,
1
]. Following is the transition function:
(4)
x
k
=
x
-
x
min
⁡
x
max
⁡
-
x
min
⁡
.Among them,x is the sample data; x
k is the normalized sample data; x
min
⁡ is the minimum of sample data; x
max
⁡ is the maximum of sample data.One relatively mature route during the experiment was chosen to analyze, which is South Huaihai Road from Rose Garden to Huaihai Plaza. Most of people in Rose Garden are commuters, and twenty percentage of them own private cars. Huaihai Plaza is located at the center of Huai’an city, and it is the intersection of the main roads, as well as the necessary path for most of commuters. The original data obtained by investigating was comparatively analyzed among multiple transportation modes, then normalized and used for (3). The results are shown as Table 1.Table 1
The average time-expense impedance of multiple trip modes.
Trip mode
Bus
Private car
Taxi
Carpooling
Time (h)
0.35
0.18
0.19
0.20
Expense (Yuan)
2.00
11.57
26.00
2.50
Traffic impendance (Q)
1.02
0.40
1.06
0.14Table1 shows that the time-expense impedance of carpooling is the lowest, followed by private car, then bus, and taxi. The impedance of taxi and bus is 7 times as much as carpooling, and private car is about 3 times. Carpooling can reduce 65%~86% of the traffic impedance. It is easy to conclude that people will be forced to take private cars rather than bus or taxi if they have no chance to carpool. If possible, people will give priority to carpooling for short trip time and low cost. Therefore, compared with bus, taxi, and private car, carpooling has obvious advantages on saving time and trip expense greatly.


### 4.2. Evaluation of Road Network

The representative network of South Huaihai Road from Rose Garden to Huaihai Plaza was analyzed by VISSIM simulation system. We establish the VISSIM simulation model according to the actual situation of the network (shown in Figures5 and 6), collect sufficient data (shown in Tables 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, and 10), and adjust the simulation (shown in Table 11) in order to ensure the effectiveness of simulation. The study had compared the output data after carpooling from simulation system with the investigated data, which include average speed, average delay time, total travel time, total delay time, and total stopped delay (shown in Table 12 and Figure 7).Table 2
The traffic input flow of roads.
Road name
Lane type
Input flow (veh/h)   (motor vehicle)
Input flow (veh/h) (nonmotor vehicle)
South Huaihai Road
Motor lane
1000
1200
East Jiefang Road
Motor lane
700
800
West Jiefang Road
Motor lane
700
800
Huaishu Road
Mixed lane
100
100
East Xinmin Road
Motor lane
325
650
West Xinmin Road
Motor lane
320
650
East Huancheng Road
Motor lane
500
600
West Huancheng Road
Motor lane
375
450
East Street
Motor lane
296
600
West Street
Motor lane
320 veh/h
600Table 3
The average time-expense impedance of multiple trip modes.
Phase
Red/yellow
Yellow
End of the red light
End of the green light
Cycle
1 (South-North-Straight)
0
3
3
33
2 (South-North-Left)
0
3
36
63
3 (East-West-Straight)
0
3
66
93
4 (East-West-Left)
0
3
96
116
116Table 4
Signal timing of South Huaihai Road and Xinmin Road intersection.
Phase
Red/yellow
Yellow
End of the red light
End of the green light
Cycle
1 (South-North-Straight)
0
3
3
43
2 (South-North-Left)
0
3
46
61
3 (East-West-Straight-Left)
0
3
64
79
79Table 5
Signal timing of South Huaihai Road and Huancheng Road intersection.
Phase
Red/yellow
Yellow
End of the red light
End of the green light
Cycle
1 (South-North-Straight)
0
3
3
36
2 (South-North-Left)
0
3
39
52
3 (East-West-Straight-Left)
0
3
55
84
84Table 6
Signal timing of South Huaihai Road and East-West Street intersection.
Phase
Red/yellow
Yellow
End of the red light
End of the green light
Cycle
1 (South-North-Straight)
0
3
3
37
2 (South-North-Left)
0
3
40
57
3 (East-West-Straight-Left)
0
3
60
79
79Table 7
The path decision proportion of intersections (Left : Straight : Right).
Name
South → North
North → South
East → West
West → East
Intersection of Huaihai Road and Jiefang Road
2 : 6 : 3
2 : 5 : 3
Jiefang Road
3 : 4 : 3
1 : 1 : 1
Intersection of Huaihai Road and Xinmin Road
1 : 3 : 1
2 : 5 : 3
XinMin Road
3 : 2 : 6
2 : 2 : 1
Intersection of Huaihai Road and Huanchegn Road
1 : 2 : 2
3 : 5 : 2
Huancheng Road
5 : 2 : 4
4 : 3 : 4
Intersection of Huaihai Road and East-West Street
1 : 6 : 1
1 : 3 : 1
East-West Street
3 : 1 : 5
6 : 1 : 4Table 8
Traffic flow composition.
Section
Traffic composition
Proportion
Huaihai Road, Jiefang Road, Xinin Road, and Huancheng Road
Private car/large vehicle
97/3
All nonmotorized vehicle lanes
Bicycle/pedestrian
13/7
Huaishu Road
Car/bicycle/pedestrian
25/12/5
East-West Street
Car
1Table 9
Width of lanes.
Lane type
Motor lane
Nonmotorized vehicle lane
Mixed lane
Width (unit: meter)
3.5
4.0
3.5Table 10
Number of lanes (bidirectional).
Name
South Huaihai Road
Jiefang Road
Huaishu Road
Xinmin Road
Huancheng Road
East-West Street
Number of lanes
6
6
2
2
2
2Table 11
The comparison of speed.
Direction
Surveyed speed (km/h)
Emulational speed (km/h)
Error
South
37.0
36.1
2.4%
North
37.0
36.0
2.7%
East
37.5
38.5
2.7%
West
37.5
36.5
2.7%Table 12
Simulation results before and after carpooling.
Evaluation index
Before
After
Average speed (km/h), vehicle class car
18.23
21.48
Total stopped delay (h), vehicle class car
144.79
74.80
Total travel time (h), vehicle class car
339.33
243.35
Total delay time (h), vehicle class car
178.32
105.40
Average delay time per vehicle, vehicle class car
102.14
72.28Figure 5
Simulation diagram of South Huaihai Road.Figure 6
Simulation running diagram.Figure 7
The comparison chart of simulation results before and after carpooling.The simulation running diagram is shown in Figure6.The group members made investigation on the South Huaihai Road in April, 2014, to learn the basic operation status and collected necessary data of the network, which contains traffic input volume (see Table2), intersection signal timing (see Tables 3–6), path decision proportion of intersections (see Table 7), traffic flow composition (see Table 8), lane width (see Table 9), and number of lanes (see Table 10). Then these data were input into the simulation system to check the model.The survey data was inputted into the simulation model, and one of the intersections was chosen to do simulation test. Then the simulation results were compared with the actual survey data (see Table11) for evaluating the accuracy and reliability of the simulation model.Table11 shows that the simulation errors are all controlled within 5%. The simulation model has an ideal fitting with the reality and can be used for simulation experiments.The running results are shown in Table12.Table12 and Figure 7 show that after carpooling, the average speed rises 17.83%, the total stopped delay decreases 34.84%, the total travel time decreases 28.29%, the total delay time decreases 40.89%, and the average delay time per vehicle decreases 29.23%. From the simulation results, the network parameters were optimized up to 20%~40% after carpooling, which greatly improved the traffic congestion of the network.


## 4.1. The Comprehensive Evaluation of Time and Expense

Considering double indexes of time and expense, ordinary traffic impedance model cannot analyze the carpooling program accurately and need to be improved. We put forward an improved time-expense traffic impedance model to evaluate it(3)
Q
=
a
*
T
+
E
Q—The time-expense impedance;
T—Carpooling time (h);
E—Carpooling expense (Ұ);
a—Preference coefficient, 1.02.The traffic impedance (Q) is obtained by summing the traffic expense and weighted time. It is necessary to multiply time by the preference coefficient. After collecting and analyzing the preferable selection of citizens about travel burden, the time overweighs the expense and the result of preference coefficient is 1.02, which means people consider time more than the expense.For the different dimensions and dimensional units in the expression, it is necessary to normalize the data. By comprising, Min-Max standardization is selected to normalize them to[
0
,
1
]. Following is the transition function:
(4)
x
k
=
x
-
x
min
⁡
x
max
⁡
-
x
min
⁡
.Among them,x is the sample data; x
k is the normalized sample data; x
min
⁡ is the minimum of sample data; x
max
⁡ is the maximum of sample data.One relatively mature route during the experiment was chosen to analyze, which is South Huaihai Road from Rose Garden to Huaihai Plaza. Most of people in Rose Garden are commuters, and twenty percentage of them own private cars. Huaihai Plaza is located at the center of Huai’an city, and it is the intersection of the main roads, as well as the necessary path for most of commuters. The original data obtained by investigating was comparatively analyzed among multiple transportation modes, then normalized and used for (3). The results are shown as Table 1.Table 1
The average time-expense impedance of multiple trip modes.
Trip mode
Bus
Private car
Taxi
Carpooling
Time (h)
0.35
0.18
0.19
0.20
Expense (Yuan)
2.00
11.57
26.00
2.50
Traffic impendance (Q)
1.02
0.40
1.06
0.14Table1 shows that the time-expense impedance of carpooling is the lowest, followed by private car, then bus, and taxi. The impedance of taxi and bus is 7 times as much as carpooling, and private car is about 3 times. Carpooling can reduce 65%~86% of the traffic impedance. It is easy to conclude that people will be forced to take private cars rather than bus or taxi if they have no chance to carpool. If possible, people will give priority to carpooling for short trip time and low cost. Therefore, compared with bus, taxi, and private car, carpooling has obvious advantages on saving time and trip expense greatly.


## 4.2. Evaluation of Road Network

The representative network of South Huaihai Road from Rose Garden to Huaihai Plaza was analyzed by VISSIM simulation system. We establish the VISSIM simulation model according to the actual situation of the network (shown in Figures5 and 6), collect sufficient data (shown in Tables 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, and 10), and adjust the simulation (shown in Table 11) in order to ensure the effectiveness of simulation. The study had compared the output data after carpooling from simulation system with the investigated data, which include average speed, average delay time, total travel time, total delay time, and total stopped delay (shown in Table 12 and Figure 7).Table 2
The traffic input flow of roads.
Road name
Lane type
Input flow (veh/h)   (motor vehicle)
Input flow (veh/h) (nonmotor vehicle)
South Huaihai Road
Motor lane
1000
1200
East Jiefang Road
Motor lane
700
800
West Jiefang Road
Motor lane
700
800
Huaishu Road
Mixed lane
100
100
East Xinmin Road
Motor lane
325
650
West Xinmin Road
Motor lane
320
650
East Huancheng Road
Motor lane
500
600
West Huancheng Road
Motor lane
375
450
East Street
Motor lane
296
600
West Street
Motor lane
320 veh/h
600Table 3
The average time-expense impedance of multiple trip modes.
Phase
Red/yellow
Yellow
End of the red light
End of the green light
Cycle
1 (South-North-Straight)
0
3
3
33
2 (South-North-Left)
0
3
36
63
3 (East-West-Straight)
0
3
66
93
4 (East-West-Left)
0
3
96
116
116Table 4
Signal timing of South Huaihai Road and Xinmin Road intersection.
Phase
Red/yellow
Yellow
End of the red light
End of the green light
Cycle
1 (South-North-Straight)
0
3
3
43
2 (South-North-Left)
0
3
46
61
3 (East-West-Straight-Left)
0
3
64
79
79Table 5
Signal timing of South Huaihai Road and Huancheng Road intersection.
Phase
Red/yellow
Yellow
End of the red light
End of the green light
Cycle
1 (South-North-Straight)
0
3
3
36
2 (South-North-Left)
0
3
39
52
3 (East-West-Straight-Left)
0
3
55
84
84Table 6
Signal timing of South Huaihai Road and East-West Street intersection.
Phase
Red/yellow
Yellow
End of the red light
End of the green light
Cycle
1 (South-North-Straight)
0
3
3
37
2 (South-North-Left)
0
3
40
57
3 (East-West-Straight-Left)
0
3
60
79
79Table 7
The path decision proportion of intersections (Left : Straight : Right).
Name
South → North
North → South
East → West
West → East
Intersection of Huaihai Road and Jiefang Road
2 : 6 : 3
2 : 5 : 3
Jiefang Road
3 : 4 : 3
1 : 1 : 1
Intersection of Huaihai Road and Xinmin Road
1 : 3 : 1
2 : 5 : 3
XinMin Road
3 : 2 : 6
2 : 2 : 1
Intersection of Huaihai Road and Huanchegn Road
1 : 2 : 2
3 : 5 : 2
Huancheng Road
5 : 2 : 4
4 : 3 : 4
Intersection of Huaihai Road and East-West Street
1 : 6 : 1
1 : 3 : 1
East-West Street
3 : 1 : 5
6 : 1 : 4Table 8
Traffic flow composition.
Section
Traffic composition
Proportion
Huaihai Road, Jiefang Road, Xinin Road, and Huancheng Road
Private car/large vehicle
97/3
All nonmotorized vehicle lanes
Bicycle/pedestrian
13/7
Huaishu Road
Car/bicycle/pedestrian
25/12/5
East-West Street
Car
1Table 9
Width of lanes.
Lane type
Motor lane
Nonmotorized vehicle lane
Mixed lane
Width (unit: meter)
3.5
4.0
3.5Table 10
Number of lanes (bidirectional).
Name
South Huaihai Road
Jiefang Road
Huaishu Road
Xinmin Road
Huancheng Road
East-West Street
Number of lanes
6
6
2
2
2
2Table 11
The comparison of speed.
Direction
Surveyed speed (km/h)
Emulational speed (km/h)
Error
South
37.0
36.1
2.4%
North
37.0
36.0
2.7%
East
37.5
38.5
2.7%
West
37.5
36.5
2.7%Table 12
Simulation results before and after carpooling.
Evaluation index
Before
After
Average speed (km/h), vehicle class car
18.23
21.48
Total stopped delay (h), vehicle class car
144.79
74.80
Total travel time (h), vehicle class car
339.33
243.35
Total delay time (h), vehicle class car
178.32
105.40
Average delay time per vehicle, vehicle class car
102.14
72.28Figure 5
Simulation diagram of South Huaihai Road.Figure 6
Simulation running diagram.Figure 7
The comparison chart of simulation results before and after carpooling.The simulation running diagram is shown in Figure6.The group members made investigation on the South Huaihai Road in April, 2014, to learn the basic operation status and collected necessary data of the network, which contains traffic input volume (see Table2), intersection signal timing (see Tables 3–6), path decision proportion of intersections (see Table 7), traffic flow composition (see Table 8), lane width (see Table 9), and number of lanes (see Table 10). Then these data were input into the simulation system to check the model.The survey data was inputted into the simulation model, and one of the intersections was chosen to do simulation test. Then the simulation results were compared with the actual survey data (see Table11) for evaluating the accuracy and reliability of the simulation model.Table11 shows that the simulation errors are all controlled within 5%. The simulation model has an ideal fitting with the reality and can be used for simulation experiments.The running results are shown in Table12.Table12 and Figure 7 show that after carpooling, the average speed rises 17.83%, the total stopped delay decreases 34.84%, the total travel time decreases 28.29%, the total delay time decreases 40.89%, and the average delay time per vehicle decreases 29.23%. From the simulation results, the network parameters were optimized up to 20%~40% after carpooling, which greatly improved the traffic congestion of the network.


## 5. Conclusion

The study has designed commute carpooling program based on fixed time and routes, built the carpooling information platform, and realized functions including information retrieval, information matching, and mutual selection and mutual evaluation. Furthermore, it had built an improved traffic impedance evaluation model and a VISSIM simulation model to evaluate the effects of the program experimented in Huai’an. The result shows that the design has reduced the time-expense impedance by 65%~86% and optimized some network parameters up to 20%~40%, which have greatly reduced the trip time and cost, improved the security and economy of carpooling process, and eased the traffic congestion of network. This exploration on the fixed time and routes carpooling has also provided solid evidence and positive reference for China to liberate carpooling.



---

*Source: 634926-2014-12-31.xml*