# Heavy Metal Residues in Soil and Accumulation in Maize at Long-Term Wastewater Irrigation Area in Tongliao, China

Authors: Yintao Lu; Hong Yao; Dan Shan; Yichen Jiang; Shichao Zhang; Jun Yang
Journal: Journal of Chemistry
 (2015)

---

## Abstract

Soil and plant samples were collected from Tongliao, China, during the maize growth cycle between May and October 2010. Heavy metals, such as Cr, Pb, Ni, and Zn, were analyzed. The concentrations of Cr, Pb, Ni, and Zn in the wastewater-irrigated area were higher than those in the topsoil from the groundwater-irrigated area. The concentrations of metals in the maize increased as follows: Pb < Ni < Zn < Cr. In addition, Cr, Pb, and Ni mainly accumulated in the maize roots, and Zn mainly accumulated in the maize fruit. The results of translocation factors (TF) and bioconcentration factors (BCF) of maize for heavy metals revealed that maize is an excluder plant and a potential accumulator plant and can serve as an ideal slope remediation plant. In addition, the increasing heavy metal contents in soils that have been polluted by wastewater irrigation must result in the accumulation of Cr, Pb, Ni, and Zn in maize. Thus, the pollution level can be decreased by harvesting and disposing of and recovering the plant material.


---

## Body

## 1. Introduction

Industrial and municipal wastewaters are increasingly being used as valuable resources for urban and periurban agriculture irrigation because of their availability, which partially solves the problem of effluent disposal [1, 2]. The concentrations of heavy metals in sewage effluents are usually low, but long-term use of these wastewaters on agricultural lands often results in the buildup of elevated levels of metals in soils [3]. Because most plant roots are located in the soil, they can play important roles in metal removal via filtration, adsorption, and cation exchange, as well as through plant-induced chemical changes in the rhizosphere [4, 5]. Cabbage,Amaranthus, spinach, radish, lady’s finger, and forage grasses grown in sewage sludge amended soils had higher Cd, Cr, Co, Cu, Pb, Ni, and Zn concentrations compared to those grown in unamended soils [6]. Trace heavy metals are essential nutrients that become harmful and toxic when their concentrations exceed recommended standards [7]. Therefore, long-term irrigation using industrial/municipal wastewater results in the buildup of heavy metals in soils, which can restrict soil function, result in toxicity to plants, and contaminate the food chain by affecting food quality and safety [8].Heavy metals often coexist in soil and plant systems. The distributions of heavy metals in the soil and their availability to plants are regulated by several factors, including soil characteristics, plant species, fertilization and irrigation characteristics, and the interrelationships between these factors. The composition and conditions of the soil are important factors that affect Cr mobility [9, 10]. In addition, the environmental conditions in the rhizosphere may provide information regarding the potential impacts of plant roots on Cr mobility [11]. Plant factors include physical processes (such as root intrusion); water and ion fluxes and their relationships with membrane transport kinetics, ion interactions, and the metabolic fate of the absorbed ions; and the ability of plants to adapt metabolically to changing metal stresses in the environment [12]. Some studies have shown the spatial distribution of heavy metals in wastewater irrigation areas [13, 14]. In addition, several studies have emphasized the risks of heavy metal accumulation in topsoils irrigated with wastewater [15–19]. Furthermore, several studies have demonstrated that wastewater-irrigated plants may absorb and accumulate heavy metals at concentrations that are greater than the maximum permissible limits, which can result in serious public health problems [20–22]. Although Shah et al. [7] studied the accumulation of heavy metals in different plants, few studies have been published regarding the accumulation of heavy metal in different plant organs. In addition, some heavy metals are not toxic to plants and serve as essential nutrients, such as Zn and Cu [23]. These nutrients are often deficient in calcareous soils and must be supplied [24]. Therefore, it is important to assess heavy metal pollutant concentrations in crops to ensure safe food production and prevent environmental and public health risks.Maize (Zea maysL.) is an edible flowering plant in the Gramineae family and is a warm-season crop that is easily grown during the spring and summer. Additionally, maize serves as the main food source for humans and animals around the world. Inner Mongolia is a large agriculture province that serves as an important maize production area for China. The wastewater irrigation area considered in this study mainly includes Tongliao City and Hohhot City. Wastewater irrigation has occurred in Tongliao since the 1970s for more than 30 years over an area of 750 h m3. Numerous studies have reported the accumulation of different heavy metals in plant tissues [25, 26]. However, limited information is available regarding the heavy metal concentrations and long-term effects of wastewater irrigation in maize production systems. In this study, fertilizer and long-term wastewater application were conducted with maize fruit production in an arid area in Tongliao, China. The overall objectives of this study were to (1) investigate the temporal changes of heavy metals during the maize growth cycle, (2) investigate the heavy metal accumulation in maize organs and determine the accumulation and excluder abilities of maize for four metals, and (3) determine the changes in the heavy metal concentrations in wastewater- and groundwater-irrigated area.


## 2. Materials and Methods

### 2.1. Description of the Study Area

The study area is located in Tongliao, which is in the northeastern region of China (43°38′11′′–45°50′13′′N; 119°13′28′′–122°31′52′′E). This area is located in the semiarid grassland area in the North Temperate Zone and has a continental monsoon climate with a mean annual temperature of 5°C. In addition, this area is arid with an annual water deficit of 350 mm because the potential evaporation exceeds precipitation. The dry season is from November to April, and the wet season is from June to September. The dominant vegetation species is maize, and the wastewater treatment plant in Tongliao City treats approximately 70,000 m3/d of sewage. Most of the treated effluent flows into the Xiliao River, and some of the effluent is used for irrigating suburban farms. Farmers generally used a primary sedimentation pond to treat effluent without any biological treatment from 1985 to 2007. After 2007, farmers began to use a secondary sedimentation pond after the effluent was subjected to anaerobic-anoxic-oxic processes at wastewater treatment plants. No detailed data are available regarding the use of wastewater for irrigation from 1985 to 2007. However, the main quality parameter levels of TSW (the treated sewage) and groundwater were just below the USW (the untreated sewage). All parameters were within the limits of the GB20922-2007 requirements and corresponded with agricultural water quality standards. The COD, BOD5, TN, and TP concentrations in the irrigation wastewater from 1985 were greater in the groundwater. Thus, long-term wastewater irrigation can enhance these concentrations in the soil.


### 2.2. Sampling of Soil and Maize

The field soil samples were collected in Tongliao, China, during the maize growth cycles from May to October 2010 (Figure1). Two sites were considered in the study area. Site 1 is a demonstration area of maize growth with two fertilizer applications and four wastewater irrigations. Site 2 is the control area for wastewater and/or groundwater irrigation and was used to study the impacts of wastewater irrigation on the soil. At site 1, 18 soils (collected in the topsoil at depths of 0–20 cm) and maize (including root, stem, leaves, and fruit) samples were collected. The maize samples were collected in triplicate from the field when the maize was mature. The samples were placed in clean plastic bags before being transported to the laboratory for analysis. At site 2, 42 soil samples were collected around the irrigation drain and in the farming area at depths of 0–20 cm. Of these samples, 20 were collected in the wastewater-irrigated area and 20 were collected in the groundwater-irrigated area. The other 2 sampling sites were collected at nine different depths from the top of the soil, 0–20 cm, 20–40 cm, 40–60 cm, 60–80 cm, 80–100 cm, 100–110 cm, 110–130 cm, 130–150 cm, and 150–170 cm. These samples were collected from the wastewater-irrigated and groundwater-irrigated areas, respectively. The soil samples were placed in sealed polyethylene plastic bag. After extraction, the soil and plant samples were preserved in ice-packed coolers before transferring them to the laboratory and storing at 4°C in a cold room until analysis.Figure 1
Location of the study site. Site 1 shows the maize growth area that was used to study the temporal changes of the heavy metal concentrations in soils and maize organs. Site 2 is the control area of wastewater and/or groundwater irrigation and was used to study the impacts of wastewater irrigation on the soil.


### 2.3. Sample Treatment and Analysis

Before treatment, the soil samples were passed through a 100-mesh sieve. Soil samples were digested in aqua regia at 160°C, as previously described [27]. The maize samples were cleaned with deionized water and the leaves, roots, stems, and fruit were separated. After oven-drying the samples at 70°C until a constant weight was achieved, the samples were ground to powder. All samples were passed through a 40-mesh nylon plastic sieve after drying. Next, the subsamples were digested in 5 mL of concentrated Analar HNO3 at 160°C [20]. The Cr and Pb concentrations were determined using ICP-OES (Perkin-Elmer OPTIMA-2000, USA), and the Ni and Zn concentrations were measured using ICP-MS (Agilent 7500a). The glassware used for measuring the metal concentrations was soaked in 20% HNO3 overnight. Blank samples were included with every 12 samples to check for contamination. One reference soil from the Chinese National Standard Soil Bank (GBW07402 (GSS-2)) was used with each of the 12 samples to validate the accuracy of the metal analysis. All of the analyses were carried out in triplicate, and the standard deviations were within ±5% of the mean.


### 2.4. Data Processing and Statistical Analysis

In this study, the translocation factor (TF) and the bioconcentration factor (BCF) were calculated using the ratio of the heavy metal concentrations in the roots and shoots [TF =Cshoot/Croot] and the ratio of the heavy metal concentrations in the soils and shoots [BCF = Cshoot/Csoil], respectively [28–30]. To determine the heavy metal concentrations in the shoots, the values found for the leaves and stems were multiplied by the total biomass of each organ and were added to obtain the total mass of the heavy metals in the aerial organs. Next, this result was divided by the total mass of the aerial organs (stems plus leaves) [26]. The heavy metal data were subjected to a one-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) using the Statistical Package for Social Science (IBM SPSS Statistics 19) and the means were separated by using Duncan’s multiple range test (DMRT) as described by Steel and Torrie [31] (at P<0.05). In addition, Pearson’s correlation coefficient was used to determine the relationships between the heavy metal concentrations in the soils and plants at P<0.05.


## 2.1. Description of the Study Area

The study area is located in Tongliao, which is in the northeastern region of China (43°38′11′′–45°50′13′′N; 119°13′28′′–122°31′52′′E). This area is located in the semiarid grassland area in the North Temperate Zone and has a continental monsoon climate with a mean annual temperature of 5°C. In addition, this area is arid with an annual water deficit of 350 mm because the potential evaporation exceeds precipitation. The dry season is from November to April, and the wet season is from June to September. The dominant vegetation species is maize, and the wastewater treatment plant in Tongliao City treats approximately 70,000 m3/d of sewage. Most of the treated effluent flows into the Xiliao River, and some of the effluent is used for irrigating suburban farms. Farmers generally used a primary sedimentation pond to treat effluent without any biological treatment from 1985 to 2007. After 2007, farmers began to use a secondary sedimentation pond after the effluent was subjected to anaerobic-anoxic-oxic processes at wastewater treatment plants. No detailed data are available regarding the use of wastewater for irrigation from 1985 to 2007. However, the main quality parameter levels of TSW (the treated sewage) and groundwater were just below the USW (the untreated sewage). All parameters were within the limits of the GB20922-2007 requirements and corresponded with agricultural water quality standards. The COD, BOD5, TN, and TP concentrations in the irrigation wastewater from 1985 were greater in the groundwater. Thus, long-term wastewater irrigation can enhance these concentrations in the soil.


## 2.2. Sampling of Soil and Maize

The field soil samples were collected in Tongliao, China, during the maize growth cycles from May to October 2010 (Figure1). Two sites were considered in the study area. Site 1 is a demonstration area of maize growth with two fertilizer applications and four wastewater irrigations. Site 2 is the control area for wastewater and/or groundwater irrigation and was used to study the impacts of wastewater irrigation on the soil. At site 1, 18 soils (collected in the topsoil at depths of 0–20 cm) and maize (including root, stem, leaves, and fruit) samples were collected. The maize samples were collected in triplicate from the field when the maize was mature. The samples were placed in clean plastic bags before being transported to the laboratory for analysis. At site 2, 42 soil samples were collected around the irrigation drain and in the farming area at depths of 0–20 cm. Of these samples, 20 were collected in the wastewater-irrigated area and 20 were collected in the groundwater-irrigated area. The other 2 sampling sites were collected at nine different depths from the top of the soil, 0–20 cm, 20–40 cm, 40–60 cm, 60–80 cm, 80–100 cm, 100–110 cm, 110–130 cm, 130–150 cm, and 150–170 cm. These samples were collected from the wastewater-irrigated and groundwater-irrigated areas, respectively. The soil samples were placed in sealed polyethylene plastic bag. After extraction, the soil and plant samples were preserved in ice-packed coolers before transferring them to the laboratory and storing at 4°C in a cold room until analysis.Figure 1
Location of the study site. Site 1 shows the maize growth area that was used to study the temporal changes of the heavy metal concentrations in soils and maize organs. Site 2 is the control area of wastewater and/or groundwater irrigation and was used to study the impacts of wastewater irrigation on the soil.


## 2.3. Sample Treatment and Analysis

Before treatment, the soil samples were passed through a 100-mesh sieve. Soil samples were digested in aqua regia at 160°C, as previously described [27]. The maize samples were cleaned with deionized water and the leaves, roots, stems, and fruit were separated. After oven-drying the samples at 70°C until a constant weight was achieved, the samples were ground to powder. All samples were passed through a 40-mesh nylon plastic sieve after drying. Next, the subsamples were digested in 5 mL of concentrated Analar HNO3 at 160°C [20]. The Cr and Pb concentrations were determined using ICP-OES (Perkin-Elmer OPTIMA-2000, USA), and the Ni and Zn concentrations were measured using ICP-MS (Agilent 7500a). The glassware used for measuring the metal concentrations was soaked in 20% HNO3 overnight. Blank samples were included with every 12 samples to check for contamination. One reference soil from the Chinese National Standard Soil Bank (GBW07402 (GSS-2)) was used with each of the 12 samples to validate the accuracy of the metal analysis. All of the analyses were carried out in triplicate, and the standard deviations were within ±5% of the mean.


## 2.4. Data Processing and Statistical Analysis

In this study, the translocation factor (TF) and the bioconcentration factor (BCF) were calculated using the ratio of the heavy metal concentrations in the roots and shoots [TF =Cshoot/Croot] and the ratio of the heavy metal concentrations in the soils and shoots [BCF = Cshoot/Csoil], respectively [28–30]. To determine the heavy metal concentrations in the shoots, the values found for the leaves and stems were multiplied by the total biomass of each organ and were added to obtain the total mass of the heavy metals in the aerial organs. Next, this result was divided by the total mass of the aerial organs (stems plus leaves) [26]. The heavy metal data were subjected to a one-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) using the Statistical Package for Social Science (IBM SPSS Statistics 19) and the means were separated by using Duncan’s multiple range test (DMRT) as described by Steel and Torrie [31] (at P<0.05). In addition, Pearson’s correlation coefficient was used to determine the relationships between the heavy metal concentrations in the soils and plants at P<0.05.


## 3. Results and Discussion

### 3.1. Temporal Characteristics of the Soil Metal Concentrations during the Maize Growth Cycle

Figure2 shows the temporal changes in the heavy metal concentrations during the maize growth cycle (from May to October) at site 1. In addition, the changes in the metal concentrations showed a strong temporal character. The highest mean concentration of Cr in the soil was 12.05 mg/kg, which occurred in September, and the lowest mean concentration was 11.12 mg/kg, which occurred in June. Soil Cr plays important roles in the metabolism of cholesterol, fat, and glucose. Banks et al. indicated that the plant uptake of Cr accounted for less than 1% of the Cr that was removed from the soil [10]. Therefore, the Cr concentration in the soil mainly showed an accumulation effect due to the fertilizer and wastewater inputs. The highest mean Pb concentration in the soil was 12.39 mg/kg, which occurred in September, and the lowest mean concentration was 10.89 mg/kg, which occurred in May. Although the Pb contents in plants depend on different environmental factors [26, 32], the Pb contents of plants grown in uncontaminated soils are usually between 0.1 and 10 mg/kg, with an average of 2 mg/kg [33]. These results indicated that the soil was contaminated with Pb due to agricultural activities. The highest mean Ni concentration in the soil was 6.74 mg/kg and occurred during September, and the lowest concentration was 5.9 mg/kg and occurred during May. In small quantities, Ni is necessary for regulating lipid contents in tissues and for forming red blood cells. Various factors influence this result. First, the overall uptake of Ni by plants depends on the Ni2+ concentration, plant metabolism, soil or solution acidity, presence of other metals, and organic matter composition [34]. In addition, Ni may compete with other essential metal ions during absorption by roots [35]. The changes in the Cr, Pb, and Ni concentrations in the soil increased from May to September and decreased in October. In this area, the soils were fertilized regularly and irrigated with wastewater to promote maize growth from May to September. However, concerns exist regarding the accumulation of heavy metals in soils after wastewater irrigation and fertilization, which could result in their transfer to maize roots and maize fruit. The concentrations of heavy metals that result from fertilization and wastewater are higher than the intake of maize, which results in the buildup of heavy metal residues in the soil. Fendorf et al. determined that waste Cr and Pb are considered to have low bioaccessibility soon after they enter the soil [36].Figure 2
Temporal variations of the soil heavy metal concentrations at site 1. (a) Changes in the Cr concentration; (b) changes in the Pb concentration; (c) changes in the Ni concentration; and (d) changes in the Zn concentration.
(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)The highest mean Zn concentration in the soil was 12.13 mg/kg, which occurred in October, and the lowest mean concentration was 8.47 mg/kg, which is in June. The Zn concentration in the soil was low and hardly changed. Outridge and Noller indicated that Zn is an essential element for all plants and that the mean concentration of Zn in normal plants (aboveground tissues) is 66 mg/kg [37]. However, Zn deficiencies are common in calcareous soils. The Chernozems and Kastanozems soil groups have a high pH and CaCO3 content, which indicates that they are Mn and Zn deficient [38]. The calcareous soils were covered by topsoil and were mainly composed of CaCO3. In addition, Jiménez et al. indicated that the Zn and Cu concentrations in the plants were closely related to the soil CaCO3 contents and electrical conductivity [39].


### 3.2. Accumulation and Correlation of Heavy Metal Concentrations in Maize Organs

The concentrations of Cr, Pb, Ni, and Zn in maize roots, stems, leaves, and fruits are presented in Figure3. Each heavy metal exhibited a different trend in the different maize organs. The highest concentrations of Cr, Pb, and Ni were observed in the maize roots, with mean concentrations of 105.21, 5.12, and 6.56 mg/kg, respectively. The lowest values of the four maize bodies for Cr, Pb, and Zn occurred in the fruit, with mean values of 0.23, 0.49, and 0.18 mg/kg, respectively. These results indicated that large amounts of Cr, Pb, and Ni were maintained in the maize roots, despite the relatively low concentrations of these metals in the soil, especially Cr. In addition, Cr was absorbed well by the maize roots. However, contrasting results have shown that the Pb concentrations were lower in the roots than in the shoots of hot pepper and celery plants [40]. This difference potentially resulted from a change in the transfer direction of Pb. For example, when the direction is from down to up, Pb is prone to accumulate in the maize roots. However, when the direction is from up to down, Pb is prone to accumulate in the shoots. The changes of the Zn concentrations were different for the other three metals. The highest Zn concentrations occurred in the maize fruit, with a mean value of 6.92 mg/kg. The lowest Zn concentrations occurred in the maize stem, with a mean value of 2.11 mg/kg.Figure 3
Heavy metal concentrations in the roots, stems, leaves, and fruit of maize. (a) Cr; (b) Pb; (c) Ni; (d) Zn.
(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)Generally, the metal concentrations in maize increased as follows: Pb < Ni < Zn < Cr. The mean Cr, Pb, Ni, and Zn concentrations in the maize organs decreased in the following orders: root > leaves > stem > fruit, root > leaves > stem > fruit, root > stem > leaves > fruit, and fruit > root > leaves > stem, respectively. The same results were shown in several recent studies. For example, Thapliyal et al. considered that the Cr concentration decreased in the following order roots > leaves > fruit in green chili under untreated wastewater irrigation [41]. In addition, the different plant parts were reported to accumulate different amounts of heavy metals, with the greatest contents occurring in roots and leaves and the smallest contents occurring in flower buds and fruit [42].Rascio and Navari-Izzo reported that two types of higher plants can tolerate high heavy metal concentrations in the soil [43], accumulator plants and excluder plants. To determine if a plant is a metal accumulator or an excluder, the BCF and TF must be considered [44, 45]. Excluder plants can inhibit metal entrance into the plant or restrict root-to-shoot translocation (featuring TF < 1). Accumulator plants can actively take up heavy metals from the soil and translocate them from the root to the shoots, resulting in accumulation in their aboveground organs, featuring BCF ≥ 0.2 and TF > 1 [44, 45]. Table 1 presents the TF and BCF for maize at site 1. The TF values of the maize for Cr, Pb, Ni, and Zn were 0.12, 0.43, 0.23, and 0.64, respectively. The BCF values of the maize for Cr, Pb, Ni, and Zn were 1.03, 0.19, 0.25, and 0.26, respectively. Plant uptake is largely influenced by the bioavailability of metals, which is determined by both external (soil-associated) and internal (plant-associated) factors. However, the TF (internal factor) of maize for heavy metals increased in the following order: Cr < Ni < Pb < Zn. In addition, the BCF (external factor) increased in the following order: Pb < Ni < Zn < Cr. These increases are consistent with the results shown in Figure 3. The BCF and TF values of the maize for Pb, Ni, and Zn were all less than 1, which indicated lower Pb, Ni, and Zn concentrations in their root and aerial organs. Maize was an excluder plant for Pb, Ni, and Zn because it hindered the entrance of metal. The BCF values of maize for Cr, Ni, and Zn were ≥0.2. Thus, maize is a potential accumulator plant and can serve as an ideal slope remediation plant.Table 1
The accumulation of heavy metals (mg/kg) in maize roots, stems, leaves, and fruits, the maize TF and BCF values, and the ANOVA results for the heavy metals concentrations at site 1.
Cr
Pb
Ni
Zn
Root
105.21 ± 21.79a
5.12 ± 0.75a
6.56 ± 1.27a
4.51 ± 0.56a
Stem
9.29 ± 2.26bc
1.25 ± 0.26b
1.61 ± 1.00b
2.11 ± 0.75b
Leaves
15.63 ± 4.72b
3.57 ± 0.49c
1.40 ± 0.49b
3.98 ± 1.12a
Fruit
0.23 ± 0.11c
0.49 ± 0.07c
0.18 ± 0.06c
6.92 ± 0.97c
TF
0.12
0.43
0.23
0.64
BCF
1.03
0.19
0.25
0.26
Note: means followed by different letters within the same column are significantly different from each other atP < 0.05 according to DMRT.


### 3.3. Comparison of Heavy Metal Concentrations in the Soil Wastewater-Irrigated and Groundwater-Irrigated Areas

The heavy metal concentrations in different irrigation areas are presented in Table2. The metal concentrations in the wastewater-irrigated area were greater than in the groundwater-irrigated area, and the range and standard deviation were considerably greater in the wastewater-irrigated area, especially Zn. The Cr, Pb, Ni, and Zn concentrations in the wastewater-irrigated area were 23.17–39.54, 3.49–21.48, 5.64–18.60, and 25.48–297.50 mg/kg, respectively. The Cr, Pb, Ni, and Zn concentrations in the groundwater-irrigated area were 22.93–37.75, 3.97–21.14, 8.34–18.00, and 23.78–111.45 mg/kg, respectively. However, the average Cr, Pb, Ni, and Zn concentrations in the wastewater- and groundwater-irrigated areas were lower than the upper threshold of the National Standard for Soil Environment Quality (90 mg/kg for Cr, 35 mg/kg for Pb, 40 mg/kg for Ni, and 100 mg/kg for Zn). These results correspond with the findings of Avci and Deveci, who observed that the mean Cr, Ni, Pb, and Zn concentrations were somewhat greater in the wastewater-irrigated soil samples than in the control samples [46]. Tiwari et al. reported greater metal concentrations (Fe > Mn > Zn > Cd > Cu > Pb > Cr) in a soil that was irrigated with effluent than in a soil that was irrigated with tube well water [47].Table 2
Metal concentrations (mg/kg) in the soil samples collected from wastewater-irrigated and groundwater-irrigated areas (n = 20).
Wastewater-irrigated area
Groundwater-irrigated area
Cr
29.86 ± 4.46a
28.77 ± 3.67a
Pb
7.39 ± 4.21b
7.15 ± 4.84b
Ni
13.30 ± 3.76ab
12.84 ± 3.34b
Zn
86.00 ± 66.90c
62.54 ± 26.74c
Note: means followed by different letters within a column are significantly different from each other atP < 0.05 according to DMRT.In this study, the Cr, Pb, and Ni concentrations in the wastewater-irrigated area were greater than those in the groundwater-irrigated area at 0–130 cm, and the concentrations in the wastewater-irrigated area were lower at 130–170 cm (Figure4). This phenomenon depends on the irrigation conditions, soil properties, water cycles, biological processes, and so forth. The Zn concentrations at all soil depths in the wastewater-irrigated areas were greater than those in the groundwater-irrigated areas, except at a depth of 130–150 cm. It is known that Zn ions bind strongly to soil particles, cause metal pollution when dissolved in water, and inadvertently negate the activities of microorganisms and macroorganisms in the soil [48]. Maize roots are distributed in the topsoil, increase the heavy metal content in the soil, and must lead to the accumulation of Cr, Pb, Ni, and Zn in maize based on the result of the demonstration area of maize growth (site 1). However, because maize is a potential accumulator plant, it is possible to decrease pollution levels by harvesting, disposing of, and recovering the plant.Figure 4
The vertical profiles of heavy metals in soils from wastewater-irrigated and groundwater-irrigated areas. (a) Cr; (b) Pb; (c) Ni; (d) Zn.
(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)


## 3.1. Temporal Characteristics of the Soil Metal Concentrations during the Maize Growth Cycle

Figure2 shows the temporal changes in the heavy metal concentrations during the maize growth cycle (from May to October) at site 1. In addition, the changes in the metal concentrations showed a strong temporal character. The highest mean concentration of Cr in the soil was 12.05 mg/kg, which occurred in September, and the lowest mean concentration was 11.12 mg/kg, which occurred in June. Soil Cr plays important roles in the metabolism of cholesterol, fat, and glucose. Banks et al. indicated that the plant uptake of Cr accounted for less than 1% of the Cr that was removed from the soil [10]. Therefore, the Cr concentration in the soil mainly showed an accumulation effect due to the fertilizer and wastewater inputs. The highest mean Pb concentration in the soil was 12.39 mg/kg, which occurred in September, and the lowest mean concentration was 10.89 mg/kg, which occurred in May. Although the Pb contents in plants depend on different environmental factors [26, 32], the Pb contents of plants grown in uncontaminated soils are usually between 0.1 and 10 mg/kg, with an average of 2 mg/kg [33]. These results indicated that the soil was contaminated with Pb due to agricultural activities. The highest mean Ni concentration in the soil was 6.74 mg/kg and occurred during September, and the lowest concentration was 5.9 mg/kg and occurred during May. In small quantities, Ni is necessary for regulating lipid contents in tissues and for forming red blood cells. Various factors influence this result. First, the overall uptake of Ni by plants depends on the Ni2+ concentration, plant metabolism, soil or solution acidity, presence of other metals, and organic matter composition [34]. In addition, Ni may compete with other essential metal ions during absorption by roots [35]. The changes in the Cr, Pb, and Ni concentrations in the soil increased from May to September and decreased in October. In this area, the soils were fertilized regularly and irrigated with wastewater to promote maize growth from May to September. However, concerns exist regarding the accumulation of heavy metals in soils after wastewater irrigation and fertilization, which could result in their transfer to maize roots and maize fruit. The concentrations of heavy metals that result from fertilization and wastewater are higher than the intake of maize, which results in the buildup of heavy metal residues in the soil. Fendorf et al. determined that waste Cr and Pb are considered to have low bioaccessibility soon after they enter the soil [36].Figure 2
Temporal variations of the soil heavy metal concentrations at site 1. (a) Changes in the Cr concentration; (b) changes in the Pb concentration; (c) changes in the Ni concentration; and (d) changes in the Zn concentration.
(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)The highest mean Zn concentration in the soil was 12.13 mg/kg, which occurred in October, and the lowest mean concentration was 8.47 mg/kg, which is in June. The Zn concentration in the soil was low and hardly changed. Outridge and Noller indicated that Zn is an essential element for all plants and that the mean concentration of Zn in normal plants (aboveground tissues) is 66 mg/kg [37]. However, Zn deficiencies are common in calcareous soils. The Chernozems and Kastanozems soil groups have a high pH and CaCO3 content, which indicates that they are Mn and Zn deficient [38]. The calcareous soils were covered by topsoil and were mainly composed of CaCO3. In addition, Jiménez et al. indicated that the Zn and Cu concentrations in the plants were closely related to the soil CaCO3 contents and electrical conductivity [39].


## 3.2. Accumulation and Correlation of Heavy Metal Concentrations in Maize Organs

The concentrations of Cr, Pb, Ni, and Zn in maize roots, stems, leaves, and fruits are presented in Figure3. Each heavy metal exhibited a different trend in the different maize organs. The highest concentrations of Cr, Pb, and Ni were observed in the maize roots, with mean concentrations of 105.21, 5.12, and 6.56 mg/kg, respectively. The lowest values of the four maize bodies for Cr, Pb, and Zn occurred in the fruit, with mean values of 0.23, 0.49, and 0.18 mg/kg, respectively. These results indicated that large amounts of Cr, Pb, and Ni were maintained in the maize roots, despite the relatively low concentrations of these metals in the soil, especially Cr. In addition, Cr was absorbed well by the maize roots. However, contrasting results have shown that the Pb concentrations were lower in the roots than in the shoots of hot pepper and celery plants [40]. This difference potentially resulted from a change in the transfer direction of Pb. For example, when the direction is from down to up, Pb is prone to accumulate in the maize roots. However, when the direction is from up to down, Pb is prone to accumulate in the shoots. The changes of the Zn concentrations were different for the other three metals. The highest Zn concentrations occurred in the maize fruit, with a mean value of 6.92 mg/kg. The lowest Zn concentrations occurred in the maize stem, with a mean value of 2.11 mg/kg.Figure 3
Heavy metal concentrations in the roots, stems, leaves, and fruit of maize. (a) Cr; (b) Pb; (c) Ni; (d) Zn.
(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)Generally, the metal concentrations in maize increased as follows: Pb < Ni < Zn < Cr. The mean Cr, Pb, Ni, and Zn concentrations in the maize organs decreased in the following orders: root > leaves > stem > fruit, root > leaves > stem > fruit, root > stem > leaves > fruit, and fruit > root > leaves > stem, respectively. The same results were shown in several recent studies. For example, Thapliyal et al. considered that the Cr concentration decreased in the following order roots > leaves > fruit in green chili under untreated wastewater irrigation [41]. In addition, the different plant parts were reported to accumulate different amounts of heavy metals, with the greatest contents occurring in roots and leaves and the smallest contents occurring in flower buds and fruit [42].Rascio and Navari-Izzo reported that two types of higher plants can tolerate high heavy metal concentrations in the soil [43], accumulator plants and excluder plants. To determine if a plant is a metal accumulator or an excluder, the BCF and TF must be considered [44, 45]. Excluder plants can inhibit metal entrance into the plant or restrict root-to-shoot translocation (featuring TF < 1). Accumulator plants can actively take up heavy metals from the soil and translocate them from the root to the shoots, resulting in accumulation in their aboveground organs, featuring BCF ≥ 0.2 and TF > 1 [44, 45]. Table 1 presents the TF and BCF for maize at site 1. The TF values of the maize for Cr, Pb, Ni, and Zn were 0.12, 0.43, 0.23, and 0.64, respectively. The BCF values of the maize for Cr, Pb, Ni, and Zn were 1.03, 0.19, 0.25, and 0.26, respectively. Plant uptake is largely influenced by the bioavailability of metals, which is determined by both external (soil-associated) and internal (plant-associated) factors. However, the TF (internal factor) of maize for heavy metals increased in the following order: Cr < Ni < Pb < Zn. In addition, the BCF (external factor) increased in the following order: Pb < Ni < Zn < Cr. These increases are consistent with the results shown in Figure 3. The BCF and TF values of the maize for Pb, Ni, and Zn were all less than 1, which indicated lower Pb, Ni, and Zn concentrations in their root and aerial organs. Maize was an excluder plant for Pb, Ni, and Zn because it hindered the entrance of metal. The BCF values of maize for Cr, Ni, and Zn were ≥0.2. Thus, maize is a potential accumulator plant and can serve as an ideal slope remediation plant.Table 1
The accumulation of heavy metals (mg/kg) in maize roots, stems, leaves, and fruits, the maize TF and BCF values, and the ANOVA results for the heavy metals concentrations at site 1.
Cr
Pb
Ni
Zn
Root
105.21 ± 21.79a
5.12 ± 0.75a
6.56 ± 1.27a
4.51 ± 0.56a
Stem
9.29 ± 2.26bc
1.25 ± 0.26b
1.61 ± 1.00b
2.11 ± 0.75b
Leaves
15.63 ± 4.72b
3.57 ± 0.49c
1.40 ± 0.49b
3.98 ± 1.12a
Fruit
0.23 ± 0.11c
0.49 ± 0.07c
0.18 ± 0.06c
6.92 ± 0.97c
TF
0.12
0.43
0.23
0.64
BCF
1.03
0.19
0.25
0.26
Note: means followed by different letters within the same column are significantly different from each other atP < 0.05 according to DMRT.


## 3.3. Comparison of Heavy Metal Concentrations in the Soil Wastewater-Irrigated and Groundwater-Irrigated Areas

The heavy metal concentrations in different irrigation areas are presented in Table2. The metal concentrations in the wastewater-irrigated area were greater than in the groundwater-irrigated area, and the range and standard deviation were considerably greater in the wastewater-irrigated area, especially Zn. The Cr, Pb, Ni, and Zn concentrations in the wastewater-irrigated area were 23.17–39.54, 3.49–21.48, 5.64–18.60, and 25.48–297.50 mg/kg, respectively. The Cr, Pb, Ni, and Zn concentrations in the groundwater-irrigated area were 22.93–37.75, 3.97–21.14, 8.34–18.00, and 23.78–111.45 mg/kg, respectively. However, the average Cr, Pb, Ni, and Zn concentrations in the wastewater- and groundwater-irrigated areas were lower than the upper threshold of the National Standard for Soil Environment Quality (90 mg/kg for Cr, 35 mg/kg for Pb, 40 mg/kg for Ni, and 100 mg/kg for Zn). These results correspond with the findings of Avci and Deveci, who observed that the mean Cr, Ni, Pb, and Zn concentrations were somewhat greater in the wastewater-irrigated soil samples than in the control samples [46]. Tiwari et al. reported greater metal concentrations (Fe > Mn > Zn > Cd > Cu > Pb > Cr) in a soil that was irrigated with effluent than in a soil that was irrigated with tube well water [47].Table 2
Metal concentrations (mg/kg) in the soil samples collected from wastewater-irrigated and groundwater-irrigated areas (n = 20).
Wastewater-irrigated area
Groundwater-irrigated area
Cr
29.86 ± 4.46a
28.77 ± 3.67a
Pb
7.39 ± 4.21b
7.15 ± 4.84b
Ni
13.30 ± 3.76ab
12.84 ± 3.34b
Zn
86.00 ± 66.90c
62.54 ± 26.74c
Note: means followed by different letters within a column are significantly different from each other atP < 0.05 according to DMRT.In this study, the Cr, Pb, and Ni concentrations in the wastewater-irrigated area were greater than those in the groundwater-irrigated area at 0–130 cm, and the concentrations in the wastewater-irrigated area were lower at 130–170 cm (Figure4). This phenomenon depends on the irrigation conditions, soil properties, water cycles, biological processes, and so forth. The Zn concentrations at all soil depths in the wastewater-irrigated areas were greater than those in the groundwater-irrigated areas, except at a depth of 130–150 cm. It is known that Zn ions bind strongly to soil particles, cause metal pollution when dissolved in water, and inadvertently negate the activities of microorganisms and macroorganisms in the soil [48]. Maize roots are distributed in the topsoil, increase the heavy metal content in the soil, and must lead to the accumulation of Cr, Pb, Ni, and Zn in maize based on the result of the demonstration area of maize growth (site 1). However, because maize is a potential accumulator plant, it is possible to decrease pollution levels by harvesting, disposing of, and recovering the plant.Figure 4
The vertical profiles of heavy metals in soils from wastewater-irrigated and groundwater-irrigated areas. (a) Cr; (b) Pb; (c) Ni; (d) Zn.
(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)


## 4. Conclusions

Heavy metal concentrations in soils depend on the management of fertilization and wastewater irrigation. Thus, the Cr, Pb, and Ni concentrations were greater in the soils from May to September and decreased in October. The Zn concentration in the soil was closely related to the soil CaCO3 concentration and the electrical conductivity. In addition, the soil Zn concentrations changed differently compared to the soil Cr, Pb, and Ni concentrations. While Cr, Pb, and Ni mainly accumulated in the maize roots, Zn mainly accumulated in the maize fruit. Because TF < 1 and BCF ≥ 0.2, maize was considered as both an excluder plant for Pb, Ni, and Zn and a potential accumulator plant. In addition, maize is an ideal slope remediation plant. The metal concentrations in the wastewater-irrigated area were greater than in the groundwater-irrigated area. Greater heavy metal contents in the soil result in the accumulation of Cr, Pb, Ni, and Zn in the maize organs. However, because maize was a potential accumulator plant, we decreased the pollution level by harvesting, disposing of, and recovering the plant material.



---

*Source: 628280-2015-08-11.xml*