# Equalization Technique for Balancing the Modulation Ratio Characteristics of the Single-Phase-to-Three-Phase Matrix Converter

Authors: Vengadeshwaran  Velu; Norman Mariun; Mohd Amran Mohd Radzi; Nashiren Farzilah Mailah
Journal: Scientific Programming
 (2016)

---

## Abstract

Three-phase system has numerous advantages over the single-phase system in terms of instantaneous power, stability, and cost. Three-phase systems are not available in every location particularly in remote rural areas, hill stations, low voltage distribution homes, and so forth. Having a system that is capable of converting directly the readily available single-phase system to three phases will have greater usability in various applications. The routine techniques adopted in the direct ac-ac single-phase-to-three-phase converters do not yield the best desired outputs because of their complexity in the segregation process and bidirectional nature of the input signal. Other initiatives use ac-dc-ac converters which are huge and costly due to dc link energy storage devices. Further, none of these systems provide a convincing result in producing the standard three-phase output voltages that are 120° away from each other. This paper proposes an effective direct ac-ac single-phase-to-three-phase conversion technique based on space vector pulse width modulation based matrix converter system that produces a convincing three-phase output signals from a single-phase source with balanced modulation index characteristics. The details of the scientific programming adopted on the proposed technique were presented.


---

## Body

## 1. Introduction

Conversion of single phase to three phases (SP2TP) is always an interesting task in the ac-ac converters sector. Having a converter that takes a single-phase source as an input and produces three phases balanced as output helps to run three-phase loads under single-phase source. Single-phase-to-three-phase matrix converter is one of the most advanced direct ac-ac converters which can be designed for the conversion of the single-phase system to three-phase system. This converter has high prospects in those applications where only single-phase source is available such as home, remote town, and mobile power source. When the ratings of the single-phase induction motor are greater than 0.5 kW, it becomes uneconomical to operate at higher load conditions [1]. Single-phase-to-three-phase converters are widely used in electric locomotives and rural areas where only single-phase power is available due to technical or economic reasons [2]. Conventional single-phase-to-three-phase converters produce unbalanced voltages which have negative effects on the load. The impact of having unbalanced voltages on the induction motor load results in the production of negative sequence voltages which in turn causes excessive losses, overvoltages, mechanical oscillations, and interference with control circuits. Among the various types of converters, conversion of single-phase system to three-phase system is regarded as the most complex one. The major difficulty of such converters is the alternating and bidirectional nature of the input signal which is required to be segregated into three output signals. Advanced scientific programming methods help to solve this complex engineering problem. Matrix converter is designed using the IGBT based bidirectional switches for direct ac-ac conversions. The bidirectional switches are designed in such a way that they should not short-circuit the voltage sources and open-circuit the current sources [3]. On the other hand, the ac-dc-ac converter adopts rectifier-inverter concepts where the single-phase ac voltage is converted to dc voltage in the first stage and in the second inverter stage, the dc voltage is inverted back to three-phase voltages. Despite the THD, losses of ac-dc-ac converter are much lesser compared to direct ac-ac converter; other issues such as additional cost due to bulk storage devices are major drawbacks. Thus, the direct ac-ac converters are more compact in size and cost. For many years, simple carrier based sinusoidal based PWM modulation schemes are used in many applications [4]. However, advance switching algorithm such as space vector based PWM modulation scheme can be employed to segregate the input signal along with the bidirectional IGBT switches based matrix converter to produce the required three-phase output waveforms. Using scientific programming methods, advanced modulation scheme can be implemented using state-of-the-art engineering simulation application and interfacing with the digital signal processor and other control circuits in real time. Space vector pulse width modulation is a unique technique that makes the switching complexity of ac-ac converters much easier. Employing the space vector PWM technique for the single-phase-to-three-phase conversion is the main contribution of the paper. Adjustable speed drives are considered matured due to advances in power semiconductor devices and lower cost. Active devices continue to improve whereas the passive devices such as energy storage capacitor occupy huge system volume, weight, and reliability [5]. Similar research initiative suggests that matrix converter can be operated under buck-boost mode with variable frequencies but under Z-Source topology [6]. Cycloconverters based static converters produced balanced output voltages but suffer from high low order harmonics [7]. Another initiative suggests having two capacitor converters for more balanced operation of induction motor using single-phase supply [8] which are tedious and unreliable. However, all these drawbacks can be overcome by incorporating advance programming techniques based on space vector PWM. This paper provides the design details of the space vector PWM programming based simulation model of the single-phase-to-three-phase matrix converter system and its performance under different load conditions.


## 2. SP2TP Matrix Converter System

Conventionally, the four-quadrant matrix converter uses nine bidirectional switches which are constructed using 18 unipolar turn-off IGBTs and 18 reverse blocking diodes [10]. However, the proposed design only uses six bidirectional switches in the construction of the matrix converter. Figure 1 shows the block diagram of the single-phase-to-three-phase (SP2TP) matrix converter system. The SP2TP system adopts the direct ac-ac conversion technique that converts the single-phase alternating source voltage to three-phase alternating voltages that differ by 120° from each other. The SP2TP system is designed using six bidirectional switches with two switches being used for each phase.Figure 1
SP2TP matrix converter system [9].


## 3. Design of Matric Converter and Control System

Space vector pulse width modulation technique can be defined as the combined effect of the three-phase voltages or currents into an equivalent single space vector component derived from all the three-phase quantities at that instant. The derived equivalent vector component is termed as space vector. There are a number of space vector modulation (SVM) techniques available [11]. The ultimate object of the SVM is to produce output voltage and currents nearing unity power factor. However, due to number of hardware limitations, attaining unity power factor becomes more difficult [12]. This paper attempts to describe the most stable and simplest SVM technique for direct ac-ac conversions. Space vector modulation technique adopts the Rotating Magnetic Field theory in which the instantaneous resultant flux of the three alternating fluxes that are 120° away produces the rotating field at synchronous speed. The theoretical background of the space vector algorithm is given below.The three-phase sinusoidal currents are represented mathematically as follows:(1)ia=Imsin⁡ωt,ib=Imsin⁡ωt-120,ic=Imsin⁡ωt-240.In such three-phase system, the three sinusoidal currents produce three sinusoidal alternating fluxes that are equal in magnitude and 120° away from each other. At the moment when the “a-phase” current “ia” carries a maximum value and equals “Im” then the currents in other phases “ib” and “ic” are negative with the magnitudes of(2)ib=Imsin⁡-30,ic=Imsin⁡-150.Thus the resultant flux produced by the varying fluxes at any instant is equal to 1.5 times the maximum flux (ϕm). Considering all instants within a period will yield the condition that the resultant unit vector always equals the value of 1.5ϕm and traces a circle for every period of reference cycle. Figure 2 represents phasor diagram of the resultant flux.Figure 2
Resultant unit space vector.For any three-phase sinusoidal excitations, the maximum flux density produces sinusoidal distribution of fluxes with the maximum values that traces a circle. A similar rotating resultant flux can also be produced using two-phase system where the two voltages are equal in magnitude and differ by 90° [11]. These fluxes can also be represented as α and β components. Superimposing on the three-phase fluxes, the flux produced in the α direction and the flux produced in the β direction can be estimated as follows. The ampere-turn produced by the α and β components of the resultant flux can be expressed as (3)Niα=Niat+Nibtcos⁡120+Niccos⁡240,Niβ=Nibtsin⁡120+Nicsin⁡240.The α and β components of the resultant flux space vector can be expressed in complex form as (4)Niαt+jNiβt=Niαt+jiβt=NiR,where “is” is the current reference space vector which can be represented as(5)iR=iα+jiβ=iRejωt.Similarly the voltage reference space vector also can be represented as(6)VR=Vα+jVβ=VRejωt+θ.Thus the flux space vector is produced by the current space vector. However, this current space vector is produced by an equivalent voltage space vector [13]. In PWM operation, the average variation is circular. The PWM scheme should be such that the tip of the space vector with the average variation should trace a circle with uniform velocity equal to the input frequency. For any sinusoidal three-phase excitations, the tip of the average value of the space vector of the alternating quantity traces a circle with uniform velocity.Figure3 represents the circuit diagram of the single-phase-to-three-phase matrix converter circuit with the bidirectional switches. Each pole will have two states, say 1 and 0. If the top switch is ON, then it is represented as “1”; whereas the bottom switch is ON, then it is represented as “0.” For each pole there are two states, so for the three phases, there are eight states (23states).Figure 3
Single-phase-to-three-phase matrix converter with bidirectional switches.The operating conditions of the 8 states are represented as 000, 001, 010, 011, 100, 101, 110, and 111 where 000 and 111 are zero states; 000 means that all the three bottom switches are ON and the output terminals are shorted to bottom switches. On the other hand, 111 means that all the three top switches are ON and the output terminals are shorted to the top switches. The states other than 000 and 111 are active states. The condition of various active states is shown in Figure4.Figure 4
Switching states in SVPWM.Downward arrow represents that the upper switch is closed and bottom switch is open in any particular pole and the upward arrow represents that bottom switch is closed and top switch is open in any particular pole. Similarly, three-phase voltages can be represented as a resultant voltageVR that travels in a circle [14]. The circular path is divided into six sectors to represent the six active states. V0,V1,V2,…,V7 represent the voltages of the eight possible states between each sector as shown in Figure 5.Figure 5
Sector representation of space vector modulation.At any particular moment, the resultant voltage vectorVR can be produced by appropriately firing the sector voltages at the given proportional time that depends on the sampling frequency. Sampling time Ts is the maximum time allocated to complete the switching of states to produce the particular instant resultant voltage vector. In sector-1, the sequence of triggering would beV0V1V2V7V7V2V1V0; however, the sum of the time taken for this triggering sequence should be equal to twice the sampling time [15]. The switching control of the PWM should be programmed in such a way to produce the space vector of voltage which traces a circle with uniform velocity.The radii of the hexagon are equal to the voltage space vector. For a two-level inverter, all the six active voltage vectors lie along the radii of the hexagon. It is also called as six-step inverter [16]. In order to generate switching sequences, VR should trace the circle with uniform velocity. If VR is in sector-1 and rotating at uniform speed, high frequency sampling signals are used to sample the rotating reference space voltage vector VR. Low sampling periods will enhance the quality of the space vector PWM signals. The average value is closest to the sinusoidal. On the other hand, having high frequency will also increase the losses, so an optimum sampling frequency has to be chosen. While sampling, until the next status is reached, the amplitude and angle of VR are assumed to be constant. During that period it switches between the boundary active vectors of the sector and with the zero vectors. The sampling period should be designed such that volt-sec (VR-Ts) balances the required amplitude of the voltage at that particular moment [17]. The components of VR-Ts along alpha and beta should be volt-sec equal to the volt-sec of active vectors of the particular section and to that of the zero vectors. If VR in sector-1 and the boundary voltage space vectors are V1 and V2, respectively, then the sampling period Ts can be represented by(7)Ts=T1+T2+T0,where T1, T2, and T0 are the sampling period for the active vectors V1  and  V2 and the zero vectors, respectively [11]. Generally, the average value of the resultant voltage vector is represented as follows:(8)∫0TsVRdt=∫0T0/2V0dt+∫T0/2T0/2+TnVndt+∫T0/2+TnT0/2+Tn+Tn+1Vn+1dt+∫T0/2+Tn+Tn+1TsV7dtand the sampling time Ts is(9)Ts=T0+Tn+Tn+1.The average voltage of the zero vectors (V0 and V7) is zero. Thus the fictitious time of the reference voltage vector can be represented as follows:(10)VRTs=Vα+jVβTs=VnTn+Vn+1Tn+1.By substituting the values of Vn and Vn+1, the reference voltage vector can be represented in the αβ components as(11)
V
α
V
β
T
s
=
2
3
V
S
cos
⁡
n
-
1
π
3
sin
⁡
n
-
1
π
3
T
n
+
cos
⁡
n
π
3
sin
⁡
n
π
3
T
n
+
1
,
V
α
V
β
T
s
=
2
3
V
S
cos
⁡
n
-
1
π
3
cos
⁡
n
π
3
sin
⁡
n
-
1
π
3
sin
⁡
n
π
3
T
n
T
n
+
1
,where “VS” is the RMS value of the source input voltage of the converter and n=1,2,3,… represents the sector. The triggering times for the various sectors can be expressed in terms of αβ components as (12)
T
n
T
n
+
1
=
3
2
T
s
V
S
sin
⁡
n
π
3
-
cos
⁡
n
π
3
-
sin
⁡
n
-
1
π
3
cos
⁡
n
-
1
π
3
·
V
α
V
β
.For any given reference space vector VR, corresponding Vα and Vβ components can be calculated, from which the duration of the active vectors in the respective sector can be estimated. The ultimate task of segregating the available single-phase waveform into three different waveforms that are 120° away from each other is achieved through the switching timings estimated from (12). Scientific programming is used to produce the triggering pulse durations to turn on the six bidirectional switches appropriately. Figure 6 shows the stages of segregation that takes place at every π/3 degrees for all the three phases. At any instant, any one of the phases has 2/3rd of its maximum value and the other two phases have 1/3rd of its maximum value in either direction.Figure 6
Segregation of input signal.


## 4. Simulation of SP2TP Matrix Converter System

Matlab/Simulink application is used for the modelling and simulation of the proposed algorithm. The designed Simulink model is then converted into C++ coding for hardware implementation using digital signal processor and IGBT core and driver circuits. Figure7 shows the various modules of the space vector pulse width modulation section of the converter in which the desired output magnitude, frequency, and the converter input voltage are taken as reference.Figure 7
Simulation of space vector PWM algorithm for SP2TP matrix converter.The reference three-phase sinusoidal signals are converted to two-dimensionalα-β components with the sector information. A ramp signal is used for the sampling of space vector at high frequency. According to the sector the switching timing for each bidirectional switch is estimated. There are six PWM signal outputs for the six bidirectional switches of the matrix converter. Table 1 shows the simulation specification of the proposed model of the matrix converter system.Table 1
Simulation parameters of the matrix converter system.
Simulation parameters
Modulation scheme
Space vector PWM
Carrier wave
Ramp signal
Carrier amplitude (Vcm)
1 V
Carrier frequency (fc)
4500 Hz
Carrier wave ratio = (fc)/(fr)
90
Modulation index = (Vrm)/(Vcm)
1.0
V
r
e
f
amplitude (Vrm)
Sinusoidal, 1 V
V
r
e
f
frequency (fr) and angle
50 Hz, zero
3-ph ref amplitude
415 V
3-ph ref frequency & angle
50 Hz, zero
Number of samples per cycle
90
Sampling time period (Ts)
222.2µs
Seconds per degree
0.617µs
Number of degrees per sample
4
Sampling time per sector
3.33 msIn the Simulink model of the matrix converter circuit, six bidirectional switches are used to construct the matrix converter module. Each bidirectional switch is designed using two IGBTs switched with reversing blocking diodes and the snubber circuits as shown in Figure8. A three-phase balanced resistive load is used to study the output signals.Figure 8
Simulation of SP2TP matrix converter with unity power factor load.


## 5. Simulation Results of Matrix Converter

The simulation results of the proposed design are studied for the suitability and implementation for the practical applications. The standard 240 V, 50 Hz single-phase supply is applied as the input to the matrix converter system. Both the space vector modules and the matrix converter modules produce the expected outputs. Figure9 shows the output phase voltages of the matrix converter system and all the three-phase voltages are 120° away from each other. The combined waveform resembles the three-phase system waveforms.Figure 9
Output phases voltages of SP2TP matrix converter with unity power factor load.Figure10 shows the output line to line voltages of the matrix converter which are found to be sinusoidal and stable. The combined waveform exactly behaves like a three-phase system voltages.Figure 10
Output line voltages of SP2TP matrix converter with unity power factor load.Figure11 shows the input and output voltages of the matrix converter under unity power factor load. A star connected balanced resistive network is used as a unity power factor load. The power factor of the input voltage and current is found to be at unity. No phase angle difference is observed between the input and R-phase output currents.Figure 11
Voltages and currents under unity power factor load.Figure12 shows the input and output voltages of the matrix converter under lagging power factor load. A star connected balanced R-L load is used as a lagging power factor load. The output currents are found to be 120 degrees away from each other and more smoother compared to the resistive load.Figure 12
Voltages and currents under lagging power factor load.In order to determine the appropriate conditions in view of obtaining the balanced output voltages, the simulations were performed under different modulation indexes. The study on the modulation index characteristics is found to be the vital factor that governs the magnitude of the output voltages. The modulation index of the space vector pulse with modulation can be defined as the ratio of the product of square root times the space vector reference voltage to that of the input supply voltages. The modulation index is expressed as(13)Modulation  IndexMi=3VrefVS.The RMS values of the output voltages under the effect of varying the modulation index are tabulated in Table 2. Its corresponding modulation index characteristics are shown in Figure 13. The three output voltages are found to be unbalanced. Two of the output voltages are at equal values whereas one of the phases is having relatively low voltage output.Table 2
Output voltages under the effect of varying modulation index at 50 Hz reference frequency.
1-phVS
1-ph max
Mi
V
a
b
V
b
c
V
c
a
2541
3594
0.20
2319
1611
2220
1271
1797
0.40
1159
805.2
1110
847
1198
0.60
771.9
536.4
739.4
635
899
0.80
578.9
402.3
554.6
508
719
1.00
462.7
321.5
443.3
424
599
1.20
385.2
267.7
369.2
363
513
1.40
329.7
229.1
316
318
449
1.60
288.4
200.4
276.5
282
399
1.80
256.1
177.9
245.6
254
359
2.00
230.3
160
220.9Figure 13
Modulation index characteristics at 50 Hz reference frequency.From the modulation index characteristics, it is found that the output line to line voltages are inversely proportional to the modulation index used in the space vector modulation algorithm. The lower the modulation indexes, the higher the RMS values of the output voltages. However, the lower modulation index means the higher input supply voltage. So to increase the input voltage, additional step-up transformers are to be used.The model was studied under wide range of reference frequencies of space vector algorithm. In order to obtain balanced output voltages, the reference frequency of the space vector algorithm has to be increased beyond 150 Hz. When the reference frequency is varied, the simulation model alters the triggering pulses duration and corresponding control signals are produced in the digital signal processors. Thus, the output voltages of the converter are altered correspondingly. Table3 shows the magnitude of the line to line output voltages of the matrix converter under 200 Hz operation and its corresponding modulation characteristics show more balanced output voltages.Table 3
Output voltages under the effect of varying modulation index at 200 Hz reference frequency.
1-phVS
1-ph max
Mi
V
a
b
V
b
c
V
c
a
2541
3594
0.2
2090
2075
2056
1271
1797
0.4
1044
1037
1027
847
1198
0.6
695.8
690.6
684.3
635
899
0.8
521.7
517.9
513.1
508
719
1
417
413.9
410.1
424
599
1.2
347.2
344.6
341.1
363
513
1.4
297.1
294.9
292.2
318
449
1.6
259.9
258
255.6
282
399
1.8
230.8
229.1
227
254
359
2
207.5
206
204.1The modulation index characteristics obtained with the reference frequency of the program as 200 Hz are shown in Figure14. The RMS values of the output voltages are found to be balanced and proportional to each other at all values of modulation index.Figure 14
Modulation index characteristics at 200 Hz reference frequency.Scientific programming model provides more flexibility to choose a wide range of reference frequencies, so that converter can be tuned to generate range of voltages at different frequencies. However it is limited by the hardware realization issues. The appropriate modulated index and reference frequency have to be selected for the desired output voltages of the matrix converter.


## 6. Hardware Experimentation of Matrix Converter System

The hardware realization of the proposed model is shown in Figure15. The Code Composer Studio application is used for the real-time interface with the digital signal processor to produce the space vector algorithm based IGBT gate signals. The gate drive circuits and base board circuits are used to provide the appropriate gate voltages to the bidirectional switches. The developed hardware model is tested under different power factor loads.Figure 15
Hardware realization of matrix converter system.Figure16 shows the actual hardware experimental setup of the single-phase-to-three-phase matrix converter system. IGBT based bidirectional switches are used to design the matrix converter system. Texas Instrument DSP and the Concept IGBT Core Drives are used for the control operation. Synchronization circuit is used to synchronize the sinusoidal supply voltage with the control signals.Figure 16
Hardware realization of matrix converter system.The RMS values of the practical hardware circuits are slightly lower than the simulation circuits. Figure17 shows the practical line to line voltages compared with the simulation data. The variation is mainly due to the presence of odd harmonics in the hardware circuits.Figure 17
Comparison of simulation and practical line voltages.Figure18 shows the percentage total harmonic distortion (%THD) of the R-phase voltage under unity power factor load condition for both simulation and practical readings. Only odd harmonics are found to be present and the practical %THD is slightly higher compared to the simulation values. This is obvious due to the presence of odd harmonics.Figure 18
% total harmonic distortion in the output voltage of matrix converter.


## 7. Conclusion

Bidirectional switch based matrix converters are getting more popular due to their compact, convenient, and robust operation. State-of-the-art space vector PWM programming and switching techniques are employed in the gate triggering control of the matrix converters. The model was studied under different reference frequencies and modulation index conditions. The limitation of the proposed system is the unbalanced voltages produced due to odd harmonics presence. High harmonic contents are noticed which can be eliminated by incorporating proper filter circuits. Booster circuits also can be used to obtain the desired output voltage. The modulation characteristics are studied in view of obtaining the balanced three-phase output voltages. A significant behavior is noticed when the SP2TP matrix converter is operated above 150 Hz with appropriate modulation index; the output line to line voltages of the matrix converter are found to be balanced and differ by 120° away from each other and exactly resemble the three-phase system. Adjustment has to be done at programming level to achieve the desired outcomes of the converter. The magnitudes of the output voltages can be varied using booster circuits. There are lots of scopes for enhancing the system design through further research for more stable and quality outputs.



---

*Source: 6187926-2016-01-27.xml*