# Diversity Assessment of Some Sesame (Sesamum indicum L.) Genotypes Cultivated in Northern Ghana Using Morphological and Simple Sequence Repeat (SSR) Markers

Authors: Raphael Adu-Gyamfi; Ruth Prempeh; Issahaku Zakaria
Journal: Advances in Agriculture
 (2019)

---

## Abstract

In Ghana, sesame is cultivated in some districts of northern Ghana. Genotypes cultivated are land races that are low yielding leading to decline in production. There is the need for improvement of these land races to generate high yielding cultivars. Characterization of genetic diversity of the sesame land races will be of great value in assisting in parental lines selection for sesame breeding programmes in Ghana. Twenty-five sesame land races were collected from five districts in northern Ghana noted for sesame cultivation. Seeds collected were planted in three replicates in randomized complete block design and were evaluated for a number of morphological characters. Data collected were subjected to Principal Component Analysis (PCA) and a dendrogram showing similarity between the accessions were drawn. Data on number of capsules per plant, number of seeds per capsule, and plant height at flowering were subjected to analysis of variance using GenStat Discovery Edition 4. Molecular genetic diversity was assessed by using thirty eight SSR markers widely distributed across sesame genome to characterize the materials. Twenty-one out of the 38 primers were polymorphic. Cluster analyses using the Euclidean similarity test and a complete link clustering method were used to make a dendrogram out of the morphological data. Analysis of variance showed that capsule number was significantly different; a range of 54.9 and 146.7 was produced. The number of seeds per capsule varied significantly and the variation between highest and lowest accession in seed production was 33%. Plant height was also significantly different ranging from 60.6 to 94.1 cm. Using morphological traits the accessions clustered into two major groups and two minor groups and variation among accessions were 10-61%. On the other hand, SSR marker-based dendrogram revealed five major and two minor groups. It showed that variation among the accessions was low, 10-20%. Heterozygosity was 0.52, total alleles produced were 410, and average allele per locus was 19.52. Six accessions, C3, C4, S5, W1, W3, and W5 fell in five different clusters in the SSR dendrogram and in six clusters in the morphomolecular based dendrogram. These accessions were noted for high capsule number per plant and seeds number per capsule and are recommended for consideration as potential parental lines for breeding programme for high yield.


---

## Body

## 1. Introduction

The plantSesamum indicum is an important edible oil seed crop. It is commonly referred to as ‘the queen of the oil seeds’ by virtue of the excellent quality of oil it produces. Sesame seeds are considered to have the highest oil contents among major oilseed crops including peanut and soybean and rapeseed with 50 to 60% oil [1]. Sesame seed oil has diverse health benefits including reducing cholesterol levels and lowering blood pressure [2, 3]. Antimicrobial compounds have been reported to be present in sesame plant and seed [4, 5]. It is also rich in proteins, vitamins, and antioxidants such as sesamin and sesamolin [1]. The seeds are most commonly used in soups while the young leaves are used as a soup vegetable. Various parts of the plants are also used in native medicines. The stems are usually burned as fuel where firewood is scarce and the ash is commonly used for local soap production. The pressed cake remaining after the oil is extracted is a rich source of protein for farm animals.In Ghana, the crop is cultivated in some parts of northern Ghana but production has been declining due to low yields among other factors. The use of landraces which are of low yielding by farmers mainly accounts for this trend. In recent past, production is picking up through the promotion by SNV, Ghana (Netherlands Development Organization), an international NGO [6]. Improved yield depends on the use of improved genotypes. Genotypes in Ghana are low in yield ranging between 150 and 200 kg/ha. Improvement of sesame requires knowledge of the genetic diversity of germplasm as well as genetic relationships among accessions [7]. There is therefore the need for assembling genotypes and characterizing them to determine the similarity or differences that exists between them. Knowledge on this will help in the improvement of the crop for higher grain and oil yield. Morphological descriptors have over the years been used in characterization [8–12]. They permit easy identification and differentiation of accessions. Generally, these descriptors have high heritability, suggesting that they are expressed in different environments. They have played essential role in crop improvement since the beginning of modern breeding programme [13]. However, cultivar characterization when based on morphological descriptors alone can be subjected to errors from variations in environmental conditions.Molecular markers have been widely used for checking the identity and purity of cultivars and for assessing their genetic variability in different crops. In sesame, the genetic diversity has been detected using markers such as amplified fragment length polymorphism (AFLP), sequence-related amplified polymorphisms (SRAP), random amplified polymorphic DNA (RAPD), and intersimple sequence repeat (ISSR). Characterization of sesame genotypes using molecular markers is of great value in assisting parental line and breeding strategy design selection [14]. Simple sequence repeats (SSRs) that enable exploration of the sesame genome have also been reported in many studies [15–19]. Considering the importance of the crop, it is anticipated that varieties which are more productive than those currently grown by farmers can be developed. It is therefore necessary that sesame germplasm in Ghana is collected and characterized. The objective of this study was to determine the genetic variability among sesame accessions cultivated in selected districts of northern Ghana using morphological and SSR markers.


## 2. Materials and Methods

### 2.1. Morphological Characterization

Five districts in Northern Ghana situated in semiarid ecological zone where sesame is predominantly cultivated were selected for the study. Subsequently, five farmers per district were selected using the snow ball method and sesame seeds were collected from each farmer. A total of twenty five sesame accessions were collected for the study (Table1). They were grown in the experimental field of the University for Development Studies, Nyankpala campus, in a randomized complete block design with three replicates. Evaluation was carried out on all the accessions according to a set of morphological descriptors for sesame [20]. Data for morphological characterization were taken at three, six, and nine weeks after planting and at harvest. Morphological characterization of accessions was based on eleven qualitative and quantitative traits. Some of the morphological characters evaluated were stem hairiness, leaf hairiness, number of flowers/axil, height at flower initiation, and branching pattern. Others include number of branches per plant, length of first capsule, capsule hairiness, carpels/capsule, number of capsule/plant, and seeds per capsule.Table 1
Details of sesame accessions used for the studies.
Sample ID District Sample ID District C1 Chereponi S4 Saboba C2 Chereponi S5 Saboba C3 Chereponi T1 Tatale C4 Chereponi T2 Tatale C5 Chereponi T3 Tatale K1 Kassena Nankana T4 Tatale K2 Kassena Nankana T5 Tatale K3 Kassena Nankana W1 West Mamprusi K4 Kassena Nankana W2 West Mamprusi K5 Kassena Nankana W3 West Mamprusi S1 Saboba W4 West Mamprusi S2 Saboba W5 West Mamprusi S3 Saboba


### 2.2. Molecular Characterization

Molecular characterization was conducted at the CSIR-Crops Research Institute, Fumesua, in the Ashanti Region. The twenty-five sesame accessions were established in a screen-house. Young apical leaves about 200 mg per sample were harvested and genomic DNA extracted using CTAB Protocol.


### 2.3. Genomic DNA Extraction

Samples were grinded to fine powder with liquid nitrogen and one ml of freshly prepared CTAB buffer was added to each tube. Precipitation of nucleic acids was performed using Phenol Chloroform isoamyl alcohol and then washed with 70% ethanol. Further precipitation of DNA was done using low salt TE (1X) buffer. RNAase was added to degrade the RNA and, finally, purification of DNA was carried out. DNA pellet was dissolved in low salt TE (1X) buffer. Quality check was carried out on 0.8% agarose gel and quantification of genomic DNA conducted using Nanaodrop 2000c Spectrophotometer.


### 2.4. Genotyping Using Simple Sequence Repeat (SSR) Markers

A total of 38 primers were used to genotype the sesame accessions to determine polymorphic primers that would produce scorable bands at the expected band size. Twenty-one out of the 38 primers were polymorphic (Table2) and produced scorable bands. Subsequently, the 21 SSR primers were used to screen the 25 accessions using SeeAMP™ PCR thermal cycler. DNA amplification was performed in a reaction volume of 10 μL containing 50 ng of DNA template, 1X PCR reaction buffer (15 mM Tris-HCl), 2 mM dNTPs, 1 U of Taq DNA polymerase, 10 μM of forward and reverse primers, and sterile distilled water. The PCR conditions were programmed for an initial denaturation step of 94°C for 5 min, followed by 35 cycles of denaturation at 94°C for 45 s, annealing temperature (depending on the primer) for 45 s, extension at 72°C for 1 min, and then a final extension of 72°C for 10 min. The PCR products were run on 6% PAGE gels after which they were stained with ethidium bromide and visualized using Alpha-Imager HP system. Data was scored using the Alpha-View software inbuilt within the Alpha-Imager HP system.Table 2
List of 21 SSR primers used for the study.
Primer Annealing temp (°C) Expected band size Primer Annealing temp (°C) Expected band size BU668385 52 185 - 240 BU670264 51 350 - 400 BU668626 53 290 - 310 BU669462 51 182 - 228 BU667505 53 230 - 250 BU669409 51 160 - 190 BU670690 52 220 - 240 BU669908 51 181 - 199 BU668961 51 181 - 223 BU668438 51 187 - 224 BU670450 52 185 - 232 BU670516 55 210 - 260 BU670128 52 120 - 160 BU669957 49 220 - 240 BU668318 52 140 - 170 BU670003 54 170 - 240 BU669684 50 280 - 320 BU670334 52 480 - 510 BU667382 50 184 - 196 HQ236490 53 290 - 310 BU667375 50 222 - 236


### 2.5. Data Analysis

Data on morphological traits were subjected to Principal Component Analysis (PCA) and a dendrogram showing similarity between the accessions was constructed. Yield and plant height data, namely, number of capsules per plant, number of seeds per capsule, and plant height at flowering, were subjected to analysis of variance using GenStat Discovery Edition 4.Cluster analyses were carried out using the Euclidean similarity test and a complete link clustering method. The genetic analysis package (PowerMarker version 3.0 [21]) was used to generate the following statistics: number of alleles per locus, major allele frequency, observed heterozygosity (HO), expected heterozygosity (HE), and polymorphic information content (PIC) [22]. Dendrogram was constructed using DarWIN 6 software. The morphological and molecular Euclidean distance were combined to construct circular dendrogram using the R software.


## 2.1. Morphological Characterization

Five districts in Northern Ghana situated in semiarid ecological zone where sesame is predominantly cultivated were selected for the study. Subsequently, five farmers per district were selected using the snow ball method and sesame seeds were collected from each farmer. A total of twenty five sesame accessions were collected for the study (Table1). They were grown in the experimental field of the University for Development Studies, Nyankpala campus, in a randomized complete block design with three replicates. Evaluation was carried out on all the accessions according to a set of morphological descriptors for sesame [20]. Data for morphological characterization were taken at three, six, and nine weeks after planting and at harvest. Morphological characterization of accessions was based on eleven qualitative and quantitative traits. Some of the morphological characters evaluated were stem hairiness, leaf hairiness, number of flowers/axil, height at flower initiation, and branching pattern. Others include number of branches per plant, length of first capsule, capsule hairiness, carpels/capsule, number of capsule/plant, and seeds per capsule.Table 1
Details of sesame accessions used for the studies.
Sample ID District Sample ID District C1 Chereponi S4 Saboba C2 Chereponi S5 Saboba C3 Chereponi T1 Tatale C4 Chereponi T2 Tatale C5 Chereponi T3 Tatale K1 Kassena Nankana T4 Tatale K2 Kassena Nankana T5 Tatale K3 Kassena Nankana W1 West Mamprusi K4 Kassena Nankana W2 West Mamprusi K5 Kassena Nankana W3 West Mamprusi S1 Saboba W4 West Mamprusi S2 Saboba W5 West Mamprusi S3 Saboba


## 2.2. Molecular Characterization

Molecular characterization was conducted at the CSIR-Crops Research Institute, Fumesua, in the Ashanti Region. The twenty-five sesame accessions were established in a screen-house. Young apical leaves about 200 mg per sample were harvested and genomic DNA extracted using CTAB Protocol.


## 2.3. Genomic DNA Extraction

Samples were grinded to fine powder with liquid nitrogen and one ml of freshly prepared CTAB buffer was added to each tube. Precipitation of nucleic acids was performed using Phenol Chloroform isoamyl alcohol and then washed with 70% ethanol. Further precipitation of DNA was done using low salt TE (1X) buffer. RNAase was added to degrade the RNA and, finally, purification of DNA was carried out. DNA pellet was dissolved in low salt TE (1X) buffer. Quality check was carried out on 0.8% agarose gel and quantification of genomic DNA conducted using Nanaodrop 2000c Spectrophotometer.


## 2.4. Genotyping Using Simple Sequence Repeat (SSR) Markers

A total of 38 primers were used to genotype the sesame accessions to determine polymorphic primers that would produce scorable bands at the expected band size. Twenty-one out of the 38 primers were polymorphic (Table2) and produced scorable bands. Subsequently, the 21 SSR primers were used to screen the 25 accessions using SeeAMP™ PCR thermal cycler. DNA amplification was performed in a reaction volume of 10 μL containing 50 ng of DNA template, 1X PCR reaction buffer (15 mM Tris-HCl), 2 mM dNTPs, 1 U of Taq DNA polymerase, 10 μM of forward and reverse primers, and sterile distilled water. The PCR conditions were programmed for an initial denaturation step of 94°C for 5 min, followed by 35 cycles of denaturation at 94°C for 45 s, annealing temperature (depending on the primer) for 45 s, extension at 72°C for 1 min, and then a final extension of 72°C for 10 min. The PCR products were run on 6% PAGE gels after which they were stained with ethidium bromide and visualized using Alpha-Imager HP system. Data was scored using the Alpha-View software inbuilt within the Alpha-Imager HP system.Table 2
List of 21 SSR primers used for the study.
Primer Annealing temp (°C) Expected band size Primer Annealing temp (°C) Expected band size BU668385 52 185 - 240 BU670264 51 350 - 400 BU668626 53 290 - 310 BU669462 51 182 - 228 BU667505 53 230 - 250 BU669409 51 160 - 190 BU670690 52 220 - 240 BU669908 51 181 - 199 BU668961 51 181 - 223 BU668438 51 187 - 224 BU670450 52 185 - 232 BU670516 55 210 - 260 BU670128 52 120 - 160 BU669957 49 220 - 240 BU668318 52 140 - 170 BU670003 54 170 - 240 BU669684 50 280 - 320 BU670334 52 480 - 510 BU667382 50 184 - 196 HQ236490 53 290 - 310 BU667375 50 222 - 236


## 2.5. Data Analysis

Data on morphological traits were subjected to Principal Component Analysis (PCA) and a dendrogram showing similarity between the accessions was constructed. Yield and plant height data, namely, number of capsules per plant, number of seeds per capsule, and plant height at flowering, were subjected to analysis of variance using GenStat Discovery Edition 4.Cluster analyses were carried out using the Euclidean similarity test and a complete link clustering method. The genetic analysis package (PowerMarker version 3.0 [21]) was used to generate the following statistics: number of alleles per locus, major allele frequency, observed heterozygosity (HO), expected heterozygosity (HE), and polymorphic information content (PIC) [22]. Dendrogram was constructed using DarWIN 6 software. The morphological and molecular Euclidean distance were combined to construct circular dendrogram using the R software.


## 3. Results

### 3.1. Morphological Characterization

#### 3.1.1. Number of Capsules Formed per Plant and Number of Seeds per Capsule

Capsules formed per plant varied significantly (P=0.001) among the accessions (Table 3). Most of the Tatale accessions, with the exception of T1, produced similar number of capsules per plant (83.7-95.4). Three of the Saboba accessions (S3, S4 and S5) produced more than 100 capsules per plant. Three of the accessions from Chereponi (C1, C3 and C4) and West Mamprusi (W2, W3, and W5) also produced more than 100 capsules per plant (Table 3).Table 3
Number of capsules per plant and seeds per capsule.
Accession Capsule/plant DMRT Accession seed/capsule DMRT∗ SI 54.9 a SI 52.2 a T1 59.5 ab T1 60.0 b K3 61 ab C5 62.9 bc K1 62.2 ab K1 63.3 bc C2 69.9 abc S2 64.0 bc S2 71.0 abcd K3 64.7 bc C5 74.8 abcde W4 67.3 cd W4 80.9 abcdef C2 68.0 cde K5 81.8 abcdef T2 70.3 def T5 83.7 abcdef K5 71.9 defg T4 83.8 abcdef K2 72.7 efgh T2 84.2 abcdef T4 73.0 efghi K2 94.1 abcdefg W2 73.9 fghi T3 95.4 abcdefg T5 74.8 fghij C3 98.6 bcdefgh C1 75.0 fghij S3 102.9 bcdefghi C4 75.0 fghij K4 109.2 cdefghi S3 75.0 fghij C1 111.6 cdefghi K4 76.0 ghij W2 115.9 defghi T3 76.0 ghij S4 118.3 efghi W1 76.33 ghij C4 123.0 fghi S4 77.0 ghij W1 135.0 ghi C3 77.9 hij S5 140.4 hi S5 78.0 hij W3 140.7 hi W5 78.5 ij W5 146.7 i W3 80.0 j ∗Duncan multiple range test.The number of seeds per capsule varied significantly (P=0.001) among the accessions. The number of seeds per capsule followed the same pattern as the number of capsule per plant (Table 3). Three of the five accessions that produced the least number of capsules (S1, K1 and T1) were also among the five accessions that produced the least number of seeds per capsule. West Mamprusi accessions (W3 and W5) produced the highest number of seeds per capsule as well as top capsule producers. The variation between the highest and the least seed producer was about 33%.


#### 3.1.2. Plant Height at Flowering

There was significant difference among the accessions (P=0.001) in terms of plant height at flowering (Figure 1). The height ranges from 60.6 to 94.1 cm. Each district had accession that was below 70 cm in height. The Kassena Nankana accessions were relatively shorter while those of Chereponi were taller and the tallest accession (C3) was found in that district.Figure 1
Plant height of sesame accessions collected from some districts in northern Ghana. Error bars represent standard error of means.


#### 3.1.3. Clustering Sesame Accessions by Morphological Traits

The average linkage grouping method identified by Principal Clustering Analysis produced four clusters (Figure2). Individuals within any cluster were more closely related than individuals in different clusters. The dendrogram shows that there was some level of variation among the accessions, 38.8-90% similarity. The accessions were grouped into two major clusters A and B, and two minor ones, clusters C and D that have fewer number of accessions (Figure 2). Cluster B was the largest with 14 accessions. This cluster consisted of accessions from all the five districts: two accessions from Chereponi district C2 and C5, four of the five accessions from Kassena Nankana district K1, K2, K3, and K5, all the accessions from Tatale district T1-T5, W1 and W4 from West Mamprusi district, and one from Saboba district, S2. The second largest cluster, A, was related to cluster B at similarity index of (58.0%). It contained nine genotypes and they include the rest of the accessions from Chereponi, Kassena Nankana, and West Mamprusi districts, C1, C3. C4, K4, W2, W3, and W5. The Saboba accessions were diverse; they were found in all the four clusters. Two accessions, S4 and S5, were part of Cluster A. Cluster C having only accession S3 was related to Cluster B at similarity index of (56.0%) and Cluster D containing only accession S1 was distantly related to the rest of the 24 accessions at similarity index of 38.8%.Figure 2
Average linkage-based dendrogram showing hierarchical grouping patterns of 25 sesame accessions (C1-W5) in four clusters based on 11 major quantitative and qualitative morphophysiological traits. 1=C1, 2=C2, 3=C3, 4=C4, 5=C5, 6=K1, 7=K2, 8=K3, 9=K4, 10=K5, 11=S2, 12=S3, 13=S4, 14=S5, 15=S1. 16=T1, 17=T2, 18=T3, 19=T4, 20=T5, 21=W1, 22=W2, 23=W3, 24=W4, 25=W5.


### 3.2. Molecular Characterization

#### 3.2.1. Genetic Diversity

A total of 410 alleles with an average of 19.5 alleles per locus were observed in the accessions (Table4). The highest number of alleles was detected by primer BU668318 which also produced the lowest major allele frequency. Primer BU667375 which produced the least numbers of allele showed more diversity in the form of genotype number, gene diversity, heterozygosity, and PIC (Table 4). The major allele frequency ranged between 0.08 and 0.28 with an average for the population being 0.17. The genotype number was analogous to the allele number with a total of 395 and average of 18.81 per locus. The average gene diversity among the samples was 0.91 which was similar to the polymorphic information content (PIC). PIC ranges from 0.80 to 0.96. Heterozygosity among the accessions ranged from 0.04 to 1.00 with an average of 0.56 (Table 4).Table 4
Summary statistics of genetic variation among sesame accessions using SSR markers.
Marker No. of Allele Major  Allele  Frequency Genotype  No Gene  Diversity Heterozygosity PIC BU667375 7.00 0.24 8.00 0.82 0.04 0.80 BU667382 18.00 0.24 15.00 0.88 1.00 0.87 BU667505 18.00 0.12 18.00 0.92 0.28 0.92 BU668318 33.00 0.08 24.00 0.96 1.00 0.96 BU668385 25.00 0.20 22.00 0.92 0.52 0.92 BU668438 24.00 0.16 23.00 0.94 0.92 0.93 BU668626 14.00 0.12 17.00 0.92 0.16 0.91 BU668961 26.00 0.12 23.00 0.94 0.80 0.94 BU669409 22.00 0.14 21.00 0.93 0.92 0.93 BU669462 14.00 0.20 18.00 0.90 0.32 0.89 BU669684 17.00 0.16 17.00 0.91 0.36 0.90 BU669908 21.00 0.12 22.00 0.93 0.88 0.92 BU670128 13.00 0.28 12.00 0.85 0.12 0.84 BU670264 21.00 0.16 20.00 0.93 0.32 0.93 BU670334 24.00 0.10 25.00 0.95 0.56 0.94 BU670516 18.00 0.20 18.00 0.91 0.40 0.90 BU670690 26.00 0.08 24.00 0.95 0.80 0.95 BU670450 9.00 0.28 8.00 0.82 0.04 0.80 BU669957 22.00 0.20 17.00 0.92 1.00 0.91 BU670003 20.00 0.14 19.00 0.93 0.64 0.92 HQ236490 18.00 0.14 24.00 0.92 0.68 0.92  Mean 19.52 0.17 18.81 0.91 0.56 0.91


#### 3.2.2. Dendrogram Analysis

The dendrogram generated is presented in Figure3. The molecular analysis showed that variation among the accessions was low 10-20%. The dendrogram revealed two main clusters, A and B, at similarity index of 80%. Cluster A was subdivided into four subclusters, I-IV. Cluster B was also subclustered into three, V-VII. Subcluster I consisted of three accessions from West Mamprusi, W1, W2, and W3. Another West Mamprusi accession, W4, lonely in cluster II, was related to Subcluster I accessions at similarity index of 83.5%. Subcluster III consists of all accessions from Tatale together with accession W5 from West Mamprusi. Saboba accessions were split into 3 subclusters. Accession S1 stood alone in subcluster IV. Two other accessions from Saboba, S2 and S3, were in close association with two accessions from Chereponi, C4 and C5, together forming subcluster V. Saboba and Chereponi used to be one district and it is probable that the same materials were distributed among the farmers. Subcluster VI consists of the other three accessions from Chereponi, C1, C2, and C3, and one accession collected from Kassena Nankana, K5. The other four accessions from Kassena Nankana have similarity with the two remaining accessions from Saboba and they together formed subcluster VII (K1-K4, S4 and S5). Accessions from a district that are found in one cluster may be more closely related to that particular cluster mates than the district members outside that cluster.Figure 3
Dendrogram of 25 sesame accessions screened with 21 SSR markers using complete link Euclidean cluster method.


### 3.3. Morphological and Molecular Cluster Analysis

When morphological and molecular Euclidean distance values were combined the accessions clustered into fifteen groups (Figure4). The Chereponi accessions were found in four clusters (B, L, J, and G). The Kassena Nankana accessions fell into five different clusters (C, E, J, M, and O) The Saboba accessions also clustered into five groups (A, B, D, F, and K). Accession S1 consistently separated out into a solitary cluster (A) showing that it is different from its cohort and other accessions. The Tatale accessions grouped into five different accessions (D, E, G, N, and O). The West Mamprusi accessions were not widely dispersed as they fell into three accessions that were not far apart (E, H, and I).Figure 4
Associations among 25 sesame accessions revealed by circular clustering analysis on the basis of combined morphological and molecular Euclidean distance values. 1=C1, 2=C2, 3=C3, 4=C4, 5=C5, 6=K1, 7=K2, 8=K3, 9=K4, 10=K5, 11=S1, 12=S2, 13=S3, 14=S4, 15=S5. 16=T1, 17=T2, 18=T3, 19=T4, 20=T5, 21=W1, 22=W2, 23=W3, 24=W4, 25=W5.


## 3.1. Morphological Characterization

### 3.1.1. Number of Capsules Formed per Plant and Number of Seeds per Capsule

Capsules formed per plant varied significantly (P=0.001) among the accessions (Table 3). Most of the Tatale accessions, with the exception of T1, produced similar number of capsules per plant (83.7-95.4). Three of the Saboba accessions (S3, S4 and S5) produced more than 100 capsules per plant. Three of the accessions from Chereponi (C1, C3 and C4) and West Mamprusi (W2, W3, and W5) also produced more than 100 capsules per plant (Table 3).Table 3
Number of capsules per plant and seeds per capsule.
Accession Capsule/plant DMRT Accession seed/capsule DMRT∗ SI 54.9 a SI 52.2 a T1 59.5 ab T1 60.0 b K3 61 ab C5 62.9 bc K1 62.2 ab K1 63.3 bc C2 69.9 abc S2 64.0 bc S2 71.0 abcd K3 64.7 bc C5 74.8 abcde W4 67.3 cd W4 80.9 abcdef C2 68.0 cde K5 81.8 abcdef T2 70.3 def T5 83.7 abcdef K5 71.9 defg T4 83.8 abcdef K2 72.7 efgh T2 84.2 abcdef T4 73.0 efghi K2 94.1 abcdefg W2 73.9 fghi T3 95.4 abcdefg T5 74.8 fghij C3 98.6 bcdefgh C1 75.0 fghij S3 102.9 bcdefghi C4 75.0 fghij K4 109.2 cdefghi S3 75.0 fghij C1 111.6 cdefghi K4 76.0 ghij W2 115.9 defghi T3 76.0 ghij S4 118.3 efghi W1 76.33 ghij C4 123.0 fghi S4 77.0 ghij W1 135.0 ghi C3 77.9 hij S5 140.4 hi S5 78.0 hij W3 140.7 hi W5 78.5 ij W5 146.7 i W3 80.0 j ∗Duncan multiple range test.The number of seeds per capsule varied significantly (P=0.001) among the accessions. The number of seeds per capsule followed the same pattern as the number of capsule per plant (Table 3). Three of the five accessions that produced the least number of capsules (S1, K1 and T1) were also among the five accessions that produced the least number of seeds per capsule. West Mamprusi accessions (W3 and W5) produced the highest number of seeds per capsule as well as top capsule producers. The variation between the highest and the least seed producer was about 33%.


### 3.1.2. Plant Height at Flowering

There was significant difference among the accessions (P=0.001) in terms of plant height at flowering (Figure 1). The height ranges from 60.6 to 94.1 cm. Each district had accession that was below 70 cm in height. The Kassena Nankana accessions were relatively shorter while those of Chereponi were taller and the tallest accession (C3) was found in that district.Figure 1
Plant height of sesame accessions collected from some districts in northern Ghana. Error bars represent standard error of means.


### 3.1.3. Clustering Sesame Accessions by Morphological Traits

The average linkage grouping method identified by Principal Clustering Analysis produced four clusters (Figure2). Individuals within any cluster were more closely related than individuals in different clusters. The dendrogram shows that there was some level of variation among the accessions, 38.8-90% similarity. The accessions were grouped into two major clusters A and B, and two minor ones, clusters C and D that have fewer number of accessions (Figure 2). Cluster B was the largest with 14 accessions. This cluster consisted of accessions from all the five districts: two accessions from Chereponi district C2 and C5, four of the five accessions from Kassena Nankana district K1, K2, K3, and K5, all the accessions from Tatale district T1-T5, W1 and W4 from West Mamprusi district, and one from Saboba district, S2. The second largest cluster, A, was related to cluster B at similarity index of (58.0%). It contained nine genotypes and they include the rest of the accessions from Chereponi, Kassena Nankana, and West Mamprusi districts, C1, C3. C4, K4, W2, W3, and W5. The Saboba accessions were diverse; they were found in all the four clusters. Two accessions, S4 and S5, were part of Cluster A. Cluster C having only accession S3 was related to Cluster B at similarity index of (56.0%) and Cluster D containing only accession S1 was distantly related to the rest of the 24 accessions at similarity index of 38.8%.Figure 2
Average linkage-based dendrogram showing hierarchical grouping patterns of 25 sesame accessions (C1-W5) in four clusters based on 11 major quantitative and qualitative morphophysiological traits. 1=C1, 2=C2, 3=C3, 4=C4, 5=C5, 6=K1, 7=K2, 8=K3, 9=K4, 10=K5, 11=S2, 12=S3, 13=S4, 14=S5, 15=S1. 16=T1, 17=T2, 18=T3, 19=T4, 20=T5, 21=W1, 22=W2, 23=W3, 24=W4, 25=W5.


## 3.1.1. Number of Capsules Formed per Plant and Number of Seeds per Capsule

Capsules formed per plant varied significantly (P=0.001) among the accessions (Table 3). Most of the Tatale accessions, with the exception of T1, produced similar number of capsules per plant (83.7-95.4). Three of the Saboba accessions (S3, S4 and S5) produced more than 100 capsules per plant. Three of the accessions from Chereponi (C1, C3 and C4) and West Mamprusi (W2, W3, and W5) also produced more than 100 capsules per plant (Table 3).Table 3
Number of capsules per plant and seeds per capsule.
Accession Capsule/plant DMRT Accession seed/capsule DMRT∗ SI 54.9 a SI 52.2 a T1 59.5 ab T1 60.0 b K3 61 ab C5 62.9 bc K1 62.2 ab K1 63.3 bc C2 69.9 abc S2 64.0 bc S2 71.0 abcd K3 64.7 bc C5 74.8 abcde W4 67.3 cd W4 80.9 abcdef C2 68.0 cde K5 81.8 abcdef T2 70.3 def T5 83.7 abcdef K5 71.9 defg T4 83.8 abcdef K2 72.7 efgh T2 84.2 abcdef T4 73.0 efghi K2 94.1 abcdefg W2 73.9 fghi T3 95.4 abcdefg T5 74.8 fghij C3 98.6 bcdefgh C1 75.0 fghij S3 102.9 bcdefghi C4 75.0 fghij K4 109.2 cdefghi S3 75.0 fghij C1 111.6 cdefghi K4 76.0 ghij W2 115.9 defghi T3 76.0 ghij S4 118.3 efghi W1 76.33 ghij C4 123.0 fghi S4 77.0 ghij W1 135.0 ghi C3 77.9 hij S5 140.4 hi S5 78.0 hij W3 140.7 hi W5 78.5 ij W5 146.7 i W3 80.0 j ∗Duncan multiple range test.The number of seeds per capsule varied significantly (P=0.001) among the accessions. The number of seeds per capsule followed the same pattern as the number of capsule per plant (Table 3). Three of the five accessions that produced the least number of capsules (S1, K1 and T1) were also among the five accessions that produced the least number of seeds per capsule. West Mamprusi accessions (W3 and W5) produced the highest number of seeds per capsule as well as top capsule producers. The variation between the highest and the least seed producer was about 33%.


## 3.1.2. Plant Height at Flowering

There was significant difference among the accessions (P=0.001) in terms of plant height at flowering (Figure 1). The height ranges from 60.6 to 94.1 cm. Each district had accession that was below 70 cm in height. The Kassena Nankana accessions were relatively shorter while those of Chereponi were taller and the tallest accession (C3) was found in that district.Figure 1
Plant height of sesame accessions collected from some districts in northern Ghana. Error bars represent standard error of means.


## 3.1.3. Clustering Sesame Accessions by Morphological Traits

The average linkage grouping method identified by Principal Clustering Analysis produced four clusters (Figure2). Individuals within any cluster were more closely related than individuals in different clusters. The dendrogram shows that there was some level of variation among the accessions, 38.8-90% similarity. The accessions were grouped into two major clusters A and B, and two minor ones, clusters C and D that have fewer number of accessions (Figure 2). Cluster B was the largest with 14 accessions. This cluster consisted of accessions from all the five districts: two accessions from Chereponi district C2 and C5, four of the five accessions from Kassena Nankana district K1, K2, K3, and K5, all the accessions from Tatale district T1-T5, W1 and W4 from West Mamprusi district, and one from Saboba district, S2. The second largest cluster, A, was related to cluster B at similarity index of (58.0%). It contained nine genotypes and they include the rest of the accessions from Chereponi, Kassena Nankana, and West Mamprusi districts, C1, C3. C4, K4, W2, W3, and W5. The Saboba accessions were diverse; they were found in all the four clusters. Two accessions, S4 and S5, were part of Cluster A. Cluster C having only accession S3 was related to Cluster B at similarity index of (56.0%) and Cluster D containing only accession S1 was distantly related to the rest of the 24 accessions at similarity index of 38.8%.Figure 2
Average linkage-based dendrogram showing hierarchical grouping patterns of 25 sesame accessions (C1-W5) in four clusters based on 11 major quantitative and qualitative morphophysiological traits. 1=C1, 2=C2, 3=C3, 4=C4, 5=C5, 6=K1, 7=K2, 8=K3, 9=K4, 10=K5, 11=S2, 12=S3, 13=S4, 14=S5, 15=S1. 16=T1, 17=T2, 18=T3, 19=T4, 20=T5, 21=W1, 22=W2, 23=W3, 24=W4, 25=W5.


## 3.2. Molecular Characterization

### 3.2.1. Genetic Diversity

A total of 410 alleles with an average of 19.5 alleles per locus were observed in the accessions (Table4). The highest number of alleles was detected by primer BU668318 which also produced the lowest major allele frequency. Primer BU667375 which produced the least numbers of allele showed more diversity in the form of genotype number, gene diversity, heterozygosity, and PIC (Table 4). The major allele frequency ranged between 0.08 and 0.28 with an average for the population being 0.17. The genotype number was analogous to the allele number with a total of 395 and average of 18.81 per locus. The average gene diversity among the samples was 0.91 which was similar to the polymorphic information content (PIC). PIC ranges from 0.80 to 0.96. Heterozygosity among the accessions ranged from 0.04 to 1.00 with an average of 0.56 (Table 4).Table 4
Summary statistics of genetic variation among sesame accessions using SSR markers.
Marker No. of Allele Major  Allele  Frequency Genotype  No Gene  Diversity Heterozygosity PIC BU667375 7.00 0.24 8.00 0.82 0.04 0.80 BU667382 18.00 0.24 15.00 0.88 1.00 0.87 BU667505 18.00 0.12 18.00 0.92 0.28 0.92 BU668318 33.00 0.08 24.00 0.96 1.00 0.96 BU668385 25.00 0.20 22.00 0.92 0.52 0.92 BU668438 24.00 0.16 23.00 0.94 0.92 0.93 BU668626 14.00 0.12 17.00 0.92 0.16 0.91 BU668961 26.00 0.12 23.00 0.94 0.80 0.94 BU669409 22.00 0.14 21.00 0.93 0.92 0.93 BU669462 14.00 0.20 18.00 0.90 0.32 0.89 BU669684 17.00 0.16 17.00 0.91 0.36 0.90 BU669908 21.00 0.12 22.00 0.93 0.88 0.92 BU670128 13.00 0.28 12.00 0.85 0.12 0.84 BU670264 21.00 0.16 20.00 0.93 0.32 0.93 BU670334 24.00 0.10 25.00 0.95 0.56 0.94 BU670516 18.00 0.20 18.00 0.91 0.40 0.90 BU670690 26.00 0.08 24.00 0.95 0.80 0.95 BU670450 9.00 0.28 8.00 0.82 0.04 0.80 BU669957 22.00 0.20 17.00 0.92 1.00 0.91 BU670003 20.00 0.14 19.00 0.93 0.64 0.92 HQ236490 18.00 0.14 24.00 0.92 0.68 0.92  Mean 19.52 0.17 18.81 0.91 0.56 0.91


### 3.2.2. Dendrogram Analysis

The dendrogram generated is presented in Figure3. The molecular analysis showed that variation among the accessions was low 10-20%. The dendrogram revealed two main clusters, A and B, at similarity index of 80%. Cluster A was subdivided into four subclusters, I-IV. Cluster B was also subclustered into three, V-VII. Subcluster I consisted of three accessions from West Mamprusi, W1, W2, and W3. Another West Mamprusi accession, W4, lonely in cluster II, was related to Subcluster I accessions at similarity index of 83.5%. Subcluster III consists of all accessions from Tatale together with accession W5 from West Mamprusi. Saboba accessions were split into 3 subclusters. Accession S1 stood alone in subcluster IV. Two other accessions from Saboba, S2 and S3, were in close association with two accessions from Chereponi, C4 and C5, together forming subcluster V. Saboba and Chereponi used to be one district and it is probable that the same materials were distributed among the farmers. Subcluster VI consists of the other three accessions from Chereponi, C1, C2, and C3, and one accession collected from Kassena Nankana, K5. The other four accessions from Kassena Nankana have similarity with the two remaining accessions from Saboba and they together formed subcluster VII (K1-K4, S4 and S5). Accessions from a district that are found in one cluster may be more closely related to that particular cluster mates than the district members outside that cluster.Figure 3
Dendrogram of 25 sesame accessions screened with 21 SSR markers using complete link Euclidean cluster method.


## 3.2.1. Genetic Diversity

A total of 410 alleles with an average of 19.5 alleles per locus were observed in the accessions (Table4). The highest number of alleles was detected by primer BU668318 which also produced the lowest major allele frequency. Primer BU667375 which produced the least numbers of allele showed more diversity in the form of genotype number, gene diversity, heterozygosity, and PIC (Table 4). The major allele frequency ranged between 0.08 and 0.28 with an average for the population being 0.17. The genotype number was analogous to the allele number with a total of 395 and average of 18.81 per locus. The average gene diversity among the samples was 0.91 which was similar to the polymorphic information content (PIC). PIC ranges from 0.80 to 0.96. Heterozygosity among the accessions ranged from 0.04 to 1.00 with an average of 0.56 (Table 4).Table 4
Summary statistics of genetic variation among sesame accessions using SSR markers.
Marker No. of Allele Major  Allele  Frequency Genotype  No Gene  Diversity Heterozygosity PIC BU667375 7.00 0.24 8.00 0.82 0.04 0.80 BU667382 18.00 0.24 15.00 0.88 1.00 0.87 BU667505 18.00 0.12 18.00 0.92 0.28 0.92 BU668318 33.00 0.08 24.00 0.96 1.00 0.96 BU668385 25.00 0.20 22.00 0.92 0.52 0.92 BU668438 24.00 0.16 23.00 0.94 0.92 0.93 BU668626 14.00 0.12 17.00 0.92 0.16 0.91 BU668961 26.00 0.12 23.00 0.94 0.80 0.94 BU669409 22.00 0.14 21.00 0.93 0.92 0.93 BU669462 14.00 0.20 18.00 0.90 0.32 0.89 BU669684 17.00 0.16 17.00 0.91 0.36 0.90 BU669908 21.00 0.12 22.00 0.93 0.88 0.92 BU670128 13.00 0.28 12.00 0.85 0.12 0.84 BU670264 21.00 0.16 20.00 0.93 0.32 0.93 BU670334 24.00 0.10 25.00 0.95 0.56 0.94 BU670516 18.00 0.20 18.00 0.91 0.40 0.90 BU670690 26.00 0.08 24.00 0.95 0.80 0.95 BU670450 9.00 0.28 8.00 0.82 0.04 0.80 BU669957 22.00 0.20 17.00 0.92 1.00 0.91 BU670003 20.00 0.14 19.00 0.93 0.64 0.92 HQ236490 18.00 0.14 24.00 0.92 0.68 0.92  Mean 19.52 0.17 18.81 0.91 0.56 0.91


## 3.2.2. Dendrogram Analysis

The dendrogram generated is presented in Figure3. The molecular analysis showed that variation among the accessions was low 10-20%. The dendrogram revealed two main clusters, A and B, at similarity index of 80%. Cluster A was subdivided into four subclusters, I-IV. Cluster B was also subclustered into three, V-VII. Subcluster I consisted of three accessions from West Mamprusi, W1, W2, and W3. Another West Mamprusi accession, W4, lonely in cluster II, was related to Subcluster I accessions at similarity index of 83.5%. Subcluster III consists of all accessions from Tatale together with accession W5 from West Mamprusi. Saboba accessions were split into 3 subclusters. Accession S1 stood alone in subcluster IV. Two other accessions from Saboba, S2 and S3, were in close association with two accessions from Chereponi, C4 and C5, together forming subcluster V. Saboba and Chereponi used to be one district and it is probable that the same materials were distributed among the farmers. Subcluster VI consists of the other three accessions from Chereponi, C1, C2, and C3, and one accession collected from Kassena Nankana, K5. The other four accessions from Kassena Nankana have similarity with the two remaining accessions from Saboba and they together formed subcluster VII (K1-K4, S4 and S5). Accessions from a district that are found in one cluster may be more closely related to that particular cluster mates than the district members outside that cluster.Figure 3
Dendrogram of 25 sesame accessions screened with 21 SSR markers using complete link Euclidean cluster method.


## 3.3. Morphological and Molecular Cluster Analysis

When morphological and molecular Euclidean distance values were combined the accessions clustered into fifteen groups (Figure4). The Chereponi accessions were found in four clusters (B, L, J, and G). The Kassena Nankana accessions fell into five different clusters (C, E, J, M, and O) The Saboba accessions also clustered into five groups (A, B, D, F, and K). Accession S1 consistently separated out into a solitary cluster (A) showing that it is different from its cohort and other accessions. The Tatale accessions grouped into five different accessions (D, E, G, N, and O). The West Mamprusi accessions were not widely dispersed as they fell into three accessions that were not far apart (E, H, and I).Figure 4
Associations among 25 sesame accessions revealed by circular clustering analysis on the basis of combined morphological and molecular Euclidean distance values. 1=C1, 2=C2, 3=C3, 4=C4, 5=C5, 6=K1, 7=K2, 8=K3, 9=K4, 10=K5, 11=S1, 12=S2, 13=S3, 14=S4, 15=S5. 16=T1, 17=T2, 18=T3, 19=T4, 20=T5, 21=W1, 22=W2, 23=W3, 24=W4, 25=W5.


## 4. Discussion

Capsule number was diverse, a range of 54.9 and 146.7. It has been reported that in a row planting in a Mediterranean environment the number of capsules formed were between 43.0 and 47.2 [23]. Another study also reported that the capsules formed per plant among different accessions taken from six countries in two continents were in the range of 78 and 232 [24].Variation in capsule number reported among 129 accessions by [7] ranged between 21.0–197 capsules per plant among. This study produced capsules higher than that reported by [23] but similar to that of [7, 24].The numbers of seeds recorded by the current study were higher than what was reported by [23]. They reported 47. 1-50.4 seeds per capsule. Reference [24] obtained much higher seed number in their study of fifteen accessions from six countries (88-138 seeds per capsule). In a study in Turkey [7], seeds per capsule were in the range of 34.0–84.0 which is similar to what was obtained in this study. The variation in seed number may be influenced by seed size. Plants that produce plenty seeds tend to have smaller seed size. The number of capsules and seeds per plant and 1000 seed weight of sesame have been reported to have strong correlation with yield [25]. Sesame genotypes express diverse plant height. References [23, 24] reported higher plant height of sesame in Vietnam and Mediterranean environment (126.4–161.6 cm and 99.3 and 139.9 cm, respectively). These were quite higher than height observed in the Ghanaian accessions used in this study. The height obtained in this study was however closer to that observed by [7]. According to [7] shorter accessions may be more resistant to lodging than taller ones. They observed some accessions that combined shortness with higher capsule and seed numbers. Therefore, accessions that are short and produce many capsules and seeds need to be selected for breeding. In our study, the shortest accession W1 was among the top six accessions that produced higher capsule per plant and seeds per capsule and would be a potential candidate for parental line selectionDiversity of genotypes from different origin can be studied by either morphological traits, geographical origin, or using molecular marker techniques like SSR markers. These markers are considered a powerful tool to investigate variability in plants [26–28]. Sesame has been cultivated in northern Ghana over the years and genotypes used are normally landraces that have spread among the farmers. There has not been any breeding program in Ghana where these landraces have been improved for some of the economically important traits and subsequently released to farmers. Based on the morphological characterization, variation observed among the accessions was high, 10-61.2%. The two main clusters obtained in morphological dendrogram had accessions from each of the districts. Studies by [29] revealed that sesame genotypes from different geographical origin clustered together. It appears that sesame accessions cultivated in northern Ghana are similar and that it is these same materials that are exchanged between farmers. All the accessions from Tatale district and four from Kassena Nankana district are grouped together with other accessions from the three remaining districts in one cluster. This shows that it is the same genotype that the farmers cultivate in the districts. Could it be domestication that has narrowed genetic basis of this cultivated sesame as suggested by [14]?The SSR markers used in this study revealed higher number of alleles as compared with other studies [15, 28]. The PIC demonstrates the informativeness of the markers with values ranging from 0 to 1 and locus having PIC values near to 1 are more desirable [28]. The average PIC value for all the 21 SSR marker loci was 0.91 which was higher than the 0.56 obtained when 44 sesame cultivars were studied by [28]. Quantitatively the degree of polymorphism can also be measured by heterozygosity which is unbiased estimator of variance [30]. The values of heterozygosity indicate the diversity level of the molecular marker. When the value is high, the molecular marker’s diversity is high too. The average heterozygosity obtained in the Ghanaian accessions was 0.52 which was comparable with the 0.59 obtained by [28].SSR’s dendrogram clustering was better in revealing the true diversity in the accessions than that observed by the morphological clustering. Diversity revealed by the SSR markers showed that variation among the accessions was lower than revealed by morphological, 10.0-20.0% as compared to the 10.0-61.2% recorded by morphological characterization. This could be due to the fact that the environment has so much effect on the phenotype as with morphological traits whereas the environment does not have any effect on the SSR markers. SSR markers are reported to give a good discrimination between closely related individuals [31]. The SSR markers used for this study gave more subgroups than the morphological data but the variation among the groups were low. Reference [32] observed that no relationship existed between genetic diversity and origin of accessions in composition of clusters; however, they found that some Iranian sesame genotypes have the tendency to cluster together. In this study the Tatale and some Kassena-Nankana accessions grouped together like the way the Iranian genotypes behaved in the study [32]. Our study agrees with other studies by [29, 33] where clustering of genotypes did not indicate any clear division based on their geographical origin.The analysis of variance revealed that the top five capsule producing accessions were C4, W1, S5, W3, and W5 while the top five accessions that produced higher number of seeds per capsule were S4, C3, S5, W5, and W3. The dendrogram constructed with molecular data shows that, for the top five capsule producers, C4 belongs to Cluster V, W1 and W3 belong to Cluster I, and W5 and S5 belong to Clusters III and VII, respectively. In the case of the top five seed producer accessions, the molecular based dendrogram put them in four clusters. S4 and S5 were grouped into Cluster VII, C3 in Cluster VI, and W5 and W3 were found in Clusters III and I, respectively. S4 and S5 are closely related; they fell into Cluster VII. Based on position of capsule and seed production S5 will be selected over S4 for consideration as potential parental line. W1 and W3 are found in one cluster, I. W1 combines shortness of plant height with profuse capsule formation while W3 is the highest seed producing genotype. W3 is selected over W1 but, due to shortness and prolific capsule development, W1 will also be selected as a potential parental line. C4 is selected on the basis of being the fifth highest capsule producing genotype while C3 is also considered as a potential parental line because of being the fourth highest seed producing genotype. W5 is selected as a potential parental line because it is the highest capsule producing and the second highest seed producing genotype.When morphological and molecular data were combined these top six accessions were found in different clusters in the resulting dendrogram showing that they exhibit some degree of variation and have the potential to be parental lines.


## 5. Conclusion

It can be concluded that the SSR markers revealed the true variation in the accessions better than the morphological markers. The accessions cultivated in the five districts are similar with diversity of 10-20% as revealed by the SSR markers. There were few accessions that produced more capsules and seeds that showed diversity. The combination of morphological and molecular data revealed more diversity among the accessions as they grouped into 15 clusters. It is recommended that the six accessions, C3, C4, S5, W1, W3, and W5 found in five different clusters and noted for their high capsule and seed production should be considered as potential parental lines for breeding programs to improve the sesame accessions.



---

*Source: 6067891-2019-02-03.xml*