# Therapeutic Effects of Traditional Chinese Exercises on Musculoskeletal Pain: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

Authors: Zhenrui Li; Jie Zhuang; Shiwen Zhang; Qingyi He; Rui Zhao; Tursen Alima; Lei Fang
Journal: Pain Research and Management
 (2021)

---

## Abstract

Background. The number of patients with musculoskeletal pain, which seriously affects people’s quality of life, has increased. Traditional Chinese exercises are accepted and practiced to strengthen the body. Objective. This study aims to explore the efficacy of traditional Chinese exercises for the treatment of musculoskeletal pain. Methods. A comprehensive search of randomized controlled trials (RCTs) related to traditional Chinese exercises on patients with musculoskeletal pain was completed using PubMed, SinoMed, CNKI, VIP, and Wanfang Med Online databases. All RCTs published until February 2021 were considered. Two researchers independently screened the literature according to the predesigned inclusion and exclusion criteria, and data was extracted and assessed for their risk of bias via the Cochrane collaboration tool. Meta-analysis was performed using RevMan5.2 and Rx64 4.0.2 software. Results. A total of 45 RCT studies with 3178 patients were included. Traditional Chinese exercises were able to effectively alleviate patients with musculoskeletal pain (MD = −1.54, 95% confidence interval (−1.88, −1.19), P < 0.01). Among them, the Yi Jin Jing exercise was superior to other exercises, while Wu Qin Xi showed no significant effects. Besides, traditional Chinese exercises had significant positive effects on the dysfunction and stiffness of the waist and knee joints. Traditional Chinese exercises could effectively relieve the clinical symptoms of patients with musculoskeletal pain. Particularly, the Yi Jin Jing exercise presented the most significant positive effect on pain reduction.


---

## Body

## 1. Introduction

Pain is an unpleasant feeling and emotional experience related to actual or potential tissue damage [1]. It is considered the fifth vital characteristic after breathing, heartbeat, blood pressure, and pulse [2]. Notably, chronic pain has to have an increased impact on human health [3, 4]. In addition to causing physical pain, persistent pain can also cause emotional disorders such as anxiety and depression [5]. One of the most common forms of chronic pain is chronic musculoskeletal pain (CMP) [6], which is a chronic pain that occurs in soft tissues such as muscles, bones, joints, or tendons for more than three months [7, 8]. This type of persistent pain is the most common symptom of musculoskeletal system diseases [9], and it accounts for the largest proportion of persistent pain in various regions and in all age groups [10]. CMP involves more than 150 diseases of the human motor system [6], which are closely related to degenerative changes, and can lead to suffering and disability in the elderly population [11, 12]. Common CMPs include chronic low back pain, chronic osteoarthritis, osteoporosis, fibromyalgia syndrome, and myofascial pain syndrome [13]. About one-third of the world’s population suffers from pain in the musculoskeletal system [14–16]. People in the age group from 45 to 64 years old have a higher incidence of CMP than people over 65 [14, 17], being the incidence in women higher than in men [12].At present, the treatments for CMP include drug therapy, psychotherapy, and physical therapy. Drug therapy is the primary treatment, mainly using nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory analgesics, acetaminophen, tramadol, and other analgesics combined with antidepressants [13, 18]. However, there are many disadvantages in the conventional treatment model of chronic pain, such as severe side effects and poor results, causing patients to seek alternative therapies and self-regulation measures, such as acupuncture, yoga, and biofeedback therapy [19]. Studies [20–23] show that traditional Chinese exercises have shown to have good results in CMP treatment. Traditional Chinese exercises mainly include Tai Chi, Wu Qin Xi, Ba Duan Jin, and Yi Jin Jing. These exercises are widely used to prevent and treat various chronic diseases, but there is a lack of systematic meta-analysis on traditional Chinese exercises in CMP treatment. This study systematically evaluates the efficacy of traditional Chinese exercises for CMP treatment, providing evidence-based information for the clinical application of traditional Chinese exercises for CMP.


## 2. Materials and Methods

### 2.1. Search Strategy and Article Selection

The two researchers independently conducted a comprehensive search on PubMed, SinoMed, CNKI, VIP, and Wanfang Med Online databases for studies using traditional exercises to treat musculoskeletal pain until February 2021, regardless of their language. The search terms used were (“Tai Chi” OR “Ba Duan Jin exercise” OR “Yi Jin Jing exercise” OR “Wu Qin Xi exercise”) AND (“chronic low back pain” OR “knee osteoarthritis” OR “osteoporosis” OR “Fibromyalgia syndrome”). According to the characteristics of different databases, the subject words and free words were combined.The preliminary screening was based on the title and abstract. Due to the wide range of interventions and diseases in these articles, only articles that included traditional Chinese exercises for musculoskeletal pain were considered. Two reviewers independently assessed the eligibility of these documents. When in disagreement, the two reviewers checked the full text of the article in question, and an agreement was only reached after discussion. After, an overall evaluation of the selected articles was made. Studies that met the following criteria were included in the study: (1) randomized controlled trials are included, (2) patients are adults with CMP, (3) the intervention type was by using traditional Chinese exercises, (4) peer-review publications are included, and (5) the difference between the experimental group and the control group’s intervention is the use of traditional Chinese exercises, or the intervention method of the experimental group was the traditional Chinese exercises, and other therapies or standard therapies, or the intervention method of the control group was standard treatment or other therapies used in the experimental group besides the traditional Chinese exercises. If more than two groups in trials met the above criteria, the traditional Chinese exercise group was selected as the experimental group and the nonacupuncture treatment group was considered the control group for one-to-many comparisons. Trials that met any of the following criteria are excluded: (1) duplicated publications, (2) non-RCT research, (3) unavailable full text or missing data, and (4) low-quality research [24].


### 2.2. Data Extraction and Quality Appraisal

Review 5.2 software was used for literature quality evaluation and Rx64 4.0.2 for data analysis. The main result was the visual analog scale (VAS). The weighted mean difference and 95% confidence interval (CI) are used for analysis. When the mean difference between different studies was too significant, SMD was selected as the combined statistic. Significant heterogeneity between the studies was considered using the random-effects model, andP < 0.05 was set as a significant difference. The funnel chart was used to identify publication bias. The symmetry of the funnel chart was evaluated by bias regression analysis. When asymmetric, trimming and filling methods were used to adjust the publication bias in the meta-analysis.


## 2.1. Search Strategy and Article Selection

The two researchers independently conducted a comprehensive search on PubMed, SinoMed, CNKI, VIP, and Wanfang Med Online databases for studies using traditional exercises to treat musculoskeletal pain until February 2021, regardless of their language. The search terms used were (“Tai Chi” OR “Ba Duan Jin exercise” OR “Yi Jin Jing exercise” OR “Wu Qin Xi exercise”) AND (“chronic low back pain” OR “knee osteoarthritis” OR “osteoporosis” OR “Fibromyalgia syndrome”). According to the characteristics of different databases, the subject words and free words were combined.The preliminary screening was based on the title and abstract. Due to the wide range of interventions and diseases in these articles, only articles that included traditional Chinese exercises for musculoskeletal pain were considered. Two reviewers independently assessed the eligibility of these documents. When in disagreement, the two reviewers checked the full text of the article in question, and an agreement was only reached after discussion. After, an overall evaluation of the selected articles was made. Studies that met the following criteria were included in the study: (1) randomized controlled trials are included, (2) patients are adults with CMP, (3) the intervention type was by using traditional Chinese exercises, (4) peer-review publications are included, and (5) the difference between the experimental group and the control group’s intervention is the use of traditional Chinese exercises, or the intervention method of the experimental group was the traditional Chinese exercises, and other therapies or standard therapies, or the intervention method of the control group was standard treatment or other therapies used in the experimental group besides the traditional Chinese exercises. If more than two groups in trials met the above criteria, the traditional Chinese exercise group was selected as the experimental group and the nonacupuncture treatment group was considered the control group for one-to-many comparisons. Trials that met any of the following criteria are excluded: (1) duplicated publications, (2) non-RCT research, (3) unavailable full text or missing data, and (4) low-quality research [24].


## 2.2. Data Extraction and Quality Appraisal

Review 5.2 software was used for literature quality evaluation and Rx64 4.0.2 for data analysis. The main result was the visual analog scale (VAS). The weighted mean difference and 95% confidence interval (CI) are used for analysis. When the mean difference between different studies was too significant, SMD was selected as the combined statistic. Significant heterogeneity between the studies was considered using the random-effects model, andP < 0.05 was set as a significant difference. The funnel chart was used to identify publication bias. The symmetry of the funnel chart was evaluated by bias regression analysis. When asymmetric, trimming and filling methods were used to adjust the publication bias in the meta-analysis.


## 3. Results

### 3.1. Documents Selection

A total of 5878 articles were retrieved by searching the databases mentioned above. Finally, according to the inclusion and exclusion criteria, 45 studies [25–69] were included in this meta-analysis (Figure 1). All the included research intervention methods were based on traditional Chinese exercises. Among them, 14 studies [25–38] used Tai Chi, 17 studies used Ba Duan Jin exercise [39–55], eight studies [56–63] used Yi Jin Jing exercise, and six studies [64–69] used Wu Qin Xi exercise. In the same studies, 22 focused on knee osteoarthritis, 14 on low back pain, seven on osteoporosis, and two on fibromyalgia syndrome. All the included studies were randomized controlled trials. The characteristics and quality evaluation of the included studies are shown in Table 1 and Figure 2.Figure 1
Document screening flow chart.Table 1
Basic characteristics of the included studies.
StudyExample (person)Average age (y)Mode of interventionDiseaseEnding indicatorExperimental groupControl groupExperimental groupControl groupTest groupControl groupLee et al. [25]291570.2 ± 4.866.9 ± 6.0Tai ChiNo interventionKnee osteoarthritis③Liu et al. [26]151558.13 ± 5.3858.4 ± 5.08Tai ChiCore stability trainingLow back pain①Liu et al. [26]151358.13 ± 5.3860.67 ± 2.58Tai ChiNo rehabilitation planLow back pain①Zhu et al. [27]232364.61 ± 3.4064.53 ± 3.43Tai ChiNo rehabilitation planKnee osteoarthritis③Brismée et al. [28]221970.8 ± 9.868.8 ± 8.9Tai ChiHealth educationKnee osteoarthritis③Fransen et al. [29]565570.8 ± 6.369.6 ± 6.1Tai ChiSpa courseKnee osteoarthritis③Fransen et al. [29]564170.8 ± 6.370.0 ± 6.3Tai ChiNoneKnee osteoarthritis③Wortley et al. [30]15969.5 ± 6.770.5 ± 5.0Tai ChiOpen motion chain resistance trainingKnee osteoarthritis③Wortley et al. [30]15968.1 ± 5.370.5 ± 5.0Tai ChiNoneKnee osteoarthritis③Song et al. [31]222164.8 ± 6.062.5 ± 5.6Tai ChiConventional treatmentKnee osteoarthritis③Xu and Zhang [32]838521.05 ± 1.1521.34 ± 2.06Tai ChiNoneLow back pain①Zhao et al. [33]303058.8 ± 3.260.1 ± 2.8Tai ChiNoneOsteoporosis①Zheng et al. [34]404066.25 ± 6.0167.10 ± 6.51Tai ChiDrug treatmentKnee osteoarthritis①Zhou et al. [35]454571.8672.25Tai ChiDrug treatmentOsteoporosis①Xu and Tang [36]151462.89 ± 2.7963.47 ± 2.85Tai ChiEducation and stretching sessions andKnee osteoarthritis③Fan [37]202055.7 ± 8.6456.4 ± 9.12Tai ChiMoxibustionLow back pain①Tong et al. [38]323232.60 ± 6.4632.66 ± 6.53Tai ChiSleep in a hard bedLow back pain①An et al. [39]141465.4 ± 8.264.6 ± 6.7Ba Duan Jin exerciseNo interventionKnee osteoarthritis③Ye et al. [40]252564.48 ± 7.8163.08 ± 3.65Ba Duan Jin exercisePhysical exerciseKnee osteoarthritis③Yang et al. [41]404054.20 ± 13.3053.94 ± 13.42Ba Duan Jin exerciseRegular massage combined with waist and dorsal muscle exerciseLow back pain①Chen [42]505061.2 ± 4.960.8 ± 5.8Ba Duan Jin exerciseChinese medicinal dietOsteoporosis①Chen et al. [43]303063.57 ± 4.7162.27 ± 4.66Ba Duan Jin exerciseRehabilitation physiotherapy, health education, strict sleeper rigid bed, drug treatmentOsteoporosis①Du and Zhao [44]4040Ba Duan Jin exerciseSodium alan phosphate + calcium agent osteoporosisOsteoporosis①Li and Feng [45]303045.77 ± 2.1146.38 ± 2.33Ba Duan Jin exerciseSET therapyLow back pain①②Liu et al. [46]303026.6 ± 0.827.3 ± 1.1Ba Duan Jin exerciseGeneral physiotherapyLow back pain①Liu [47]303053.26 ± 3.8753.47 ± 3.61Ba Duan Jin exerciseRegular careKnee osteoarthritis③Wu [48]262655.92 ± 9.2556.46 ± 9.13Ba Duan Jin exerciseIntermediate electrotherapyLow back pain①Wang and Zhao [49]525146.51 ± 4.3145.97 ± 4.22Ba Duan Jin exerciseRehabilitation trainingLow back pain①②Wang et al. [50]101017.10 ± 1.2017.60 ± 1.08Ba Duan Jin exercisePure wormwood box moxibustion + eight brocadesLow back pain①②Wang et al. [50]101016.90 ± 1.1017.60 ± 1.08Ba Duan Jin exerciseAuricular-plaster therapy + pure wormwood box moxibustionLow back pain①②Wan et al. [51]303040.97 ± 11.6242.87 ± 10.87Ba Duan Jin exerciseManipulation maneuverFibromyalgia syndrome①Su and Deng [52]404058.93 ± 4.0159.12 ± 3.88Ba Duan Jin exerciseTake medicineOsteoporosis①Peng et al. [53]474468.49 ± 4.6869.67 ± 4.36Ba Duan Jin exerciseTake medicineOsteoporosis①Pang et al. [54]323246.33 ± 9.4647.25 ± 8.43Ba Duan Jin exerciseTake medicineLow back pain①Zheng and Cheng [55]293057.01 ± 5.5958.63 ± 5.07Ba Duan Jin exerciseAcupuncture treatmentKnee osteoarthritis①③Yang [56]283021.52 ± 1.9520.41 ± 2.09Yi Jin Jing exerciseNoneLow back pain①Ye et al. [57]262660.83 ± 9.5261.80 ± 8.26Yi Jin Jing exercisePerkin ontology and balance trainingKnee osteoarthritis①③Zhao and Zhang [58]333373.84 ± 4.6972.94 ± 5.97Yi Jin Jing exerciseWestern medicine treatmentKnee osteoarthritis①③Zhao et al. [59]454564.00 ± 8.9761.00 ± 7.52Yi Jin Jing exerciseInject sodium glassateKnee osteoarthritis①Zhen et al. [60]4040Yi Jin Jing exerciseMoxibustionKnee osteoarthritis①③Zhen et al. [60]4040Yi Jin Jing exerciseWestern medicine treatmentKnee osteoarthritis①③Wu and Lu [61]454554.56 ± 10.0758.02 ± 7.93Yi Jin Jing exerciseMassage and intra-articular ozone injectionKnee osteoarthritis①③Li et al. [62]3030Yi Jin Jing exerciseMassage manipulation therapyKnee osteoarthritis③Li et al. [63]626769.5 ± 4.869.3 ± 4.5Yi Jin Jing exercisePhysiotherapyKnee osteoarthritis①③Xiao et al. [64]343470.7 ± 9.3670.2 ± 10.35Wu Qin Xi exerciseRehabilitation treatmentKnee osteoarthritis③Zhang et al. [65]212152.90 ± 10.5756.19 ± 10.88Wu Qin Xi exerciseOral amitriptyline hydrochloride tabletsFibromyalgia syndrome①Lei et al. [66]323152.91 ± 15.8053.88 ± 14.17Wu Qin Xi exerciseRehabilitation gymnasticsLow back pain①Ning et al. [67]262840.73 ± 11.5242.13 ± 11.18Wu Qin Xi exerciseNuclear myocardial force training and five poultry exercisesLow back pain①②Tang et al. [68]303060.36 ± 4.7359.86 ± 5.92Wu Qin Xi exerciseMassage combined with isokinetic trainingKnee osteoarthritis①Ping and Liao [69]2020Wu Qin Xi exerciseStanding exerciseKnee osteoarthritis③Note: ① VAS; ② ODI; ③ WOMAC.Figure 2
Bias risk assessment of included literature.


### 3.2. Meta-Analysis results

#### 3.2.1. Visual Analog Scale (VAS) of Pain

A total of 28 RCT trials, which included 2239 patients, were analyzed. VAS scores of patients with musculoskeletal pain who intervened in the Chinese traditional exercise group were significantly lower than those in the control group [MD = −1.54, 95% CI (−1.88, −1.19),P < 0.01], as shown in Figure 3. According to the subgroup analysis based on the types of traditional exercises, Tai Chi, Ba Duan Jin exercises, and Yi Jin Jing exercise all presented significant therapeutic effects on the VAS score of patients with musculoskeletal pain. Among them, the Yi Jin Jing exercise showed the best therapeutic effect (Figure 4). The analysis between Wu Qin Xi exercise subgroups showed no statistical difference. Two studies [66, 67] treated the disease for low back pain within the subgroup, and one study [58] focused on knee osteoarthritis. According to the subgroup analysis based on the types of musculoskeletal pain diseases, the results show that traditional Chinese exercise therapy provided significant positive therapeutic effects on knee osteoarthritis, chronic low back pain, osteoporotic pain, and fibromyalgia. Among them, the treatment of osteoporosis pain provided the best results, as shown in Figure 5.Figure 3
Meta-analysis of the comparison of VAS between the traditional Chinese exercise group and the control group.Figure 4
Subgroup analysis of different VAS comparisons.Figure 5
Subgroup analysis of the comparison of pain VAS scores of different diseases.


#### 3.2.2. Oswestry Dysfunction Index (ODI) Score

Six studies, which included a total of 365 patients, were analyzed. The ODI scores of patients with musculoskeletal pain with the intervention of traditional Chinese exercise were significantly lower than those of the control group [MD = −2.73, 95% CI (−7.15, −1.69),P < 0.01], as shown in Figure 6. The six studies were all related to low back pain. According to the subgroup analysis of the exercise type, the intervention effect of Yi Jin Jing exercise [56] was significantly better than that of Tai Chi [45, 48–50] and Wu Qin Xi exercise [67].Figure 6
Meta-analysis of the comparison of ODI scores between the traditional Chinese exercise group and the control group.


#### 3.2.3. Western Ontario and McMaster University Osteoarthritis Index (WOMAC)

A total of 17 studies were evaluated using WOMAC. Due to the large difference in the mean between the study groups, SMD combined statistics were selected. The results showed that traditional Chinese exercise was used to treat knee arthritis and was able to reduce WOMAC pain [SMD = −0.50, 95% CI (−0.75, −0.25),P < 0.01], relieve joint WOMAC stiffness [SMD = −0.37, 95% CI (−0.75, −0.00), P < 0.01], and improve dysfunction [SMD = −0.57, 95% CI (−0.82, −0.32), P < 0.01]. All results were statistically significant, as shown in Figures 7–9. Besides, according to the type of exercise method, a subgroup analysis of WOMAC showed that the Ba Duan Jin exercise intervention was significantly better than other exercise methods in reducing pain and improving dysfunction. In contrast, the Yi Jin Jing exercise was superior to other exercises in improving joint stiffness.Figure 7
Meta-analysis of WOMAC pain comparison between the traditional Chinese exercise group and the control group.Figure 8
Meta-analysis of WOMAC stiffness comparison between the traditional Chinese exercise group and the control group.Figure 9
Meta-analysis of WOMAC physical function comparison between traditional Chinese exercise group and control group.


#### 3.2.4. Sensitivity Analysis

The sensitivity analyses of VAS exclude four studies with higher weights [38, 48, 49, 66], and the heterogeneity did not change significantly. The sensitivity analyses of ODI eliminate the two studies with higher weights [55, 56], and heterogeneity has changed significantly (I2 = 66%, T2 = 6.4961, P = 0.03), but the result does not change. Further analysis was done on two studies, and its heterogeneous sources may be related to the younger age of research subjects. Sensitivity analysis for WOMAC pain, excluding a study [46], reduced to moderate heterogeneity. Sensitivity analyses for WOMAC stiffness, WOMAC Physical Function, and Liu [47], Ye et al. [40], and Ye et al.’s [57] research studies were excluded. According to the Cochrane handbook [24], the three indicators are all reduced to moderate heterogeneity. The source of the articles’ heterogeneity may relate to the low age of the included patients and the imbalance of the gender ratio between men and women.


#### 3.2.5. Publication Bias

The results show that VAS was biased (t = −3.2289, df = 29, P = 0.003082), and the use of the trimming filling method to adjust the published bias resulted in statistically significant differences (P < 0.001), as seen in Figure 10. WOMAC index of the three-funnel chart and metabias regression analysis shows no publication bias. Furthermore, the reliability of this study was high.Figure 10
The funnel plots of VAS.
(a)(b)


## 3.1. Documents Selection

A total of 5878 articles were retrieved by searching the databases mentioned above. Finally, according to the inclusion and exclusion criteria, 45 studies [25–69] were included in this meta-analysis (Figure 1). All the included research intervention methods were based on traditional Chinese exercises. Among them, 14 studies [25–38] used Tai Chi, 17 studies used Ba Duan Jin exercise [39–55], eight studies [56–63] used Yi Jin Jing exercise, and six studies [64–69] used Wu Qin Xi exercise. In the same studies, 22 focused on knee osteoarthritis, 14 on low back pain, seven on osteoporosis, and two on fibromyalgia syndrome. All the included studies were randomized controlled trials. The characteristics and quality evaluation of the included studies are shown in Table 1 and Figure 2.Figure 1
Document screening flow chart.Table 1
Basic characteristics of the included studies.
StudyExample (person)Average age (y)Mode of interventionDiseaseEnding indicatorExperimental groupControl groupExperimental groupControl groupTest groupControl groupLee et al. [25]291570.2 ± 4.866.9 ± 6.0Tai ChiNo interventionKnee osteoarthritis③Liu et al. [26]151558.13 ± 5.3858.4 ± 5.08Tai ChiCore stability trainingLow back pain①Liu et al. [26]151358.13 ± 5.3860.67 ± 2.58Tai ChiNo rehabilitation planLow back pain①Zhu et al. [27]232364.61 ± 3.4064.53 ± 3.43Tai ChiNo rehabilitation planKnee osteoarthritis③Brismée et al. [28]221970.8 ± 9.868.8 ± 8.9Tai ChiHealth educationKnee osteoarthritis③Fransen et al. [29]565570.8 ± 6.369.6 ± 6.1Tai ChiSpa courseKnee osteoarthritis③Fransen et al. [29]564170.8 ± 6.370.0 ± 6.3Tai ChiNoneKnee osteoarthritis③Wortley et al. [30]15969.5 ± 6.770.5 ± 5.0Tai ChiOpen motion chain resistance trainingKnee osteoarthritis③Wortley et al. [30]15968.1 ± 5.370.5 ± 5.0Tai ChiNoneKnee osteoarthritis③Song et al. [31]222164.8 ± 6.062.5 ± 5.6Tai ChiConventional treatmentKnee osteoarthritis③Xu and Zhang [32]838521.05 ± 1.1521.34 ± 2.06Tai ChiNoneLow back pain①Zhao et al. [33]303058.8 ± 3.260.1 ± 2.8Tai ChiNoneOsteoporosis①Zheng et al. [34]404066.25 ± 6.0167.10 ± 6.51Tai ChiDrug treatmentKnee osteoarthritis①Zhou et al. [35]454571.8672.25Tai ChiDrug treatmentOsteoporosis①Xu and Tang [36]151462.89 ± 2.7963.47 ± 2.85Tai ChiEducation and stretching sessions andKnee osteoarthritis③Fan [37]202055.7 ± 8.6456.4 ± 9.12Tai ChiMoxibustionLow back pain①Tong et al. [38]323232.60 ± 6.4632.66 ± 6.53Tai ChiSleep in a hard bedLow back pain①An et al. [39]141465.4 ± 8.264.6 ± 6.7Ba Duan Jin exerciseNo interventionKnee osteoarthritis③Ye et al. [40]252564.48 ± 7.8163.08 ± 3.65Ba Duan Jin exercisePhysical exerciseKnee osteoarthritis③Yang et al. [41]404054.20 ± 13.3053.94 ± 13.42Ba Duan Jin exerciseRegular massage combined with waist and dorsal muscle exerciseLow back pain①Chen [42]505061.2 ± 4.960.8 ± 5.8Ba Duan Jin exerciseChinese medicinal dietOsteoporosis①Chen et al. [43]303063.57 ± 4.7162.27 ± 4.66Ba Duan Jin exerciseRehabilitation physiotherapy, health education, strict sleeper rigid bed, drug treatmentOsteoporosis①Du and Zhao [44]4040Ba Duan Jin exerciseSodium alan phosphate + calcium agent osteoporosisOsteoporosis①Li and Feng [45]303045.77 ± 2.1146.38 ± 2.33Ba Duan Jin exerciseSET therapyLow back pain①②Liu et al. [46]303026.6 ± 0.827.3 ± 1.1Ba Duan Jin exerciseGeneral physiotherapyLow back pain①Liu [47]303053.26 ± 3.8753.47 ± 3.61Ba Duan Jin exerciseRegular careKnee osteoarthritis③Wu [48]262655.92 ± 9.2556.46 ± 9.13Ba Duan Jin exerciseIntermediate electrotherapyLow back pain①Wang and Zhao [49]525146.51 ± 4.3145.97 ± 4.22Ba Duan Jin exerciseRehabilitation trainingLow back pain①②Wang et al. [50]101017.10 ± 1.2017.60 ± 1.08Ba Duan Jin exercisePure wormwood box moxibustion + eight brocadesLow back pain①②Wang et al. [50]101016.90 ± 1.1017.60 ± 1.08Ba Duan Jin exerciseAuricular-plaster therapy + pure wormwood box moxibustionLow back pain①②Wan et al. [51]303040.97 ± 11.6242.87 ± 10.87Ba Duan Jin exerciseManipulation maneuverFibromyalgia syndrome①Su and Deng [52]404058.93 ± 4.0159.12 ± 3.88Ba Duan Jin exerciseTake medicineOsteoporosis①Peng et al. [53]474468.49 ± 4.6869.67 ± 4.36Ba Duan Jin exerciseTake medicineOsteoporosis①Pang et al. [54]323246.33 ± 9.4647.25 ± 8.43Ba Duan Jin exerciseTake medicineLow back pain①Zheng and Cheng [55]293057.01 ± 5.5958.63 ± 5.07Ba Duan Jin exerciseAcupuncture treatmentKnee osteoarthritis①③Yang [56]283021.52 ± 1.9520.41 ± 2.09Yi Jin Jing exerciseNoneLow back pain①Ye et al. [57]262660.83 ± 9.5261.80 ± 8.26Yi Jin Jing exercisePerkin ontology and balance trainingKnee osteoarthritis①③Zhao and Zhang [58]333373.84 ± 4.6972.94 ± 5.97Yi Jin Jing exerciseWestern medicine treatmentKnee osteoarthritis①③Zhao et al. [59]454564.00 ± 8.9761.00 ± 7.52Yi Jin Jing exerciseInject sodium glassateKnee osteoarthritis①Zhen et al. [60]4040Yi Jin Jing exerciseMoxibustionKnee osteoarthritis①③Zhen et al. [60]4040Yi Jin Jing exerciseWestern medicine treatmentKnee osteoarthritis①③Wu and Lu [61]454554.56 ± 10.0758.02 ± 7.93Yi Jin Jing exerciseMassage and intra-articular ozone injectionKnee osteoarthritis①③Li et al. [62]3030Yi Jin Jing exerciseMassage manipulation therapyKnee osteoarthritis③Li et al. [63]626769.5 ± 4.869.3 ± 4.5Yi Jin Jing exercisePhysiotherapyKnee osteoarthritis①③Xiao et al. [64]343470.7 ± 9.3670.2 ± 10.35Wu Qin Xi exerciseRehabilitation treatmentKnee osteoarthritis③Zhang et al. [65]212152.90 ± 10.5756.19 ± 10.88Wu Qin Xi exerciseOral amitriptyline hydrochloride tabletsFibromyalgia syndrome①Lei et al. [66]323152.91 ± 15.8053.88 ± 14.17Wu Qin Xi exerciseRehabilitation gymnasticsLow back pain①Ning et al. [67]262840.73 ± 11.5242.13 ± 11.18Wu Qin Xi exerciseNuclear myocardial force training and five poultry exercisesLow back pain①②Tang et al. [68]303060.36 ± 4.7359.86 ± 5.92Wu Qin Xi exerciseMassage combined with isokinetic trainingKnee osteoarthritis①Ping and Liao [69]2020Wu Qin Xi exerciseStanding exerciseKnee osteoarthritis③Note: ① VAS; ② ODI; ③ WOMAC.Figure 2
Bias risk assessment of included literature.


## 3.2. Meta-Analysis results

### 3.2.1. Visual Analog Scale (VAS) of Pain

A total of 28 RCT trials, which included 2239 patients, were analyzed. VAS scores of patients with musculoskeletal pain who intervened in the Chinese traditional exercise group were significantly lower than those in the control group [MD = −1.54, 95% CI (−1.88, −1.19),P < 0.01], as shown in Figure 3. According to the subgroup analysis based on the types of traditional exercises, Tai Chi, Ba Duan Jin exercises, and Yi Jin Jing exercise all presented significant therapeutic effects on the VAS score of patients with musculoskeletal pain. Among them, the Yi Jin Jing exercise showed the best therapeutic effect (Figure 4). The analysis between Wu Qin Xi exercise subgroups showed no statistical difference. Two studies [66, 67] treated the disease for low back pain within the subgroup, and one study [58] focused on knee osteoarthritis. According to the subgroup analysis based on the types of musculoskeletal pain diseases, the results show that traditional Chinese exercise therapy provided significant positive therapeutic effects on knee osteoarthritis, chronic low back pain, osteoporotic pain, and fibromyalgia. Among them, the treatment of osteoporosis pain provided the best results, as shown in Figure 5.Figure 3
Meta-analysis of the comparison of VAS between the traditional Chinese exercise group and the control group.Figure 4
Subgroup analysis of different VAS comparisons.Figure 5
Subgroup analysis of the comparison of pain VAS scores of different diseases.


### 3.2.2. Oswestry Dysfunction Index (ODI) Score

Six studies, which included a total of 365 patients, were analyzed. The ODI scores of patients with musculoskeletal pain with the intervention of traditional Chinese exercise were significantly lower than those of the control group [MD = −2.73, 95% CI (−7.15, −1.69),P < 0.01], as shown in Figure 6. The six studies were all related to low back pain. According to the subgroup analysis of the exercise type, the intervention effect of Yi Jin Jing exercise [56] was significantly better than that of Tai Chi [45, 48–50] and Wu Qin Xi exercise [67].Figure 6
Meta-analysis of the comparison of ODI scores between the traditional Chinese exercise group and the control group.


### 3.2.3. Western Ontario and McMaster University Osteoarthritis Index (WOMAC)

A total of 17 studies were evaluated using WOMAC. Due to the large difference in the mean between the study groups, SMD combined statistics were selected. The results showed that traditional Chinese exercise was used to treat knee arthritis and was able to reduce WOMAC pain [SMD = −0.50, 95% CI (−0.75, −0.25),P < 0.01], relieve joint WOMAC stiffness [SMD = −0.37, 95% CI (−0.75, −0.00), P < 0.01], and improve dysfunction [SMD = −0.57, 95% CI (−0.82, −0.32), P < 0.01]. All results were statistically significant, as shown in Figures 7–9. Besides, according to the type of exercise method, a subgroup analysis of WOMAC showed that the Ba Duan Jin exercise intervention was significantly better than other exercise methods in reducing pain and improving dysfunction. In contrast, the Yi Jin Jing exercise was superior to other exercises in improving joint stiffness.Figure 7
Meta-analysis of WOMAC pain comparison between the traditional Chinese exercise group and the control group.Figure 8
Meta-analysis of WOMAC stiffness comparison between the traditional Chinese exercise group and the control group.Figure 9
Meta-analysis of WOMAC physical function comparison between traditional Chinese exercise group and control group.


### 3.2.4. Sensitivity Analysis

The sensitivity analyses of VAS exclude four studies with higher weights [38, 48, 49, 66], and the heterogeneity did not change significantly. The sensitivity analyses of ODI eliminate the two studies with higher weights [55, 56], and heterogeneity has changed significantly (I2 = 66%, T2 = 6.4961, P = 0.03), but the result does not change. Further analysis was done on two studies, and its heterogeneous sources may be related to the younger age of research subjects. Sensitivity analysis for WOMAC pain, excluding a study [46], reduced to moderate heterogeneity. Sensitivity analyses for WOMAC stiffness, WOMAC Physical Function, and Liu [47], Ye et al. [40], and Ye et al.’s [57] research studies were excluded. According to the Cochrane handbook [24], the three indicators are all reduced to moderate heterogeneity. The source of the articles’ heterogeneity may relate to the low age of the included patients and the imbalance of the gender ratio between men and women.


### 3.2.5. Publication Bias

The results show that VAS was biased (t = −3.2289, df = 29, P = 0.003082), and the use of the trimming filling method to adjust the published bias resulted in statistically significant differences (P < 0.001), as seen in Figure 10. WOMAC index of the three-funnel chart and metabias regression analysis shows no publication bias. Furthermore, the reliability of this study was high.Figure 10
The funnel plots of VAS.
(a)(b)


## 3.2.1. Visual Analog Scale (VAS) of Pain

A total of 28 RCT trials, which included 2239 patients, were analyzed. VAS scores of patients with musculoskeletal pain who intervened in the Chinese traditional exercise group were significantly lower than those in the control group [MD = −1.54, 95% CI (−1.88, −1.19),P < 0.01], as shown in Figure 3. According to the subgroup analysis based on the types of traditional exercises, Tai Chi, Ba Duan Jin exercises, and Yi Jin Jing exercise all presented significant therapeutic effects on the VAS score of patients with musculoskeletal pain. Among them, the Yi Jin Jing exercise showed the best therapeutic effect (Figure 4). The analysis between Wu Qin Xi exercise subgroups showed no statistical difference. Two studies [66, 67] treated the disease for low back pain within the subgroup, and one study [58] focused on knee osteoarthritis. According to the subgroup analysis based on the types of musculoskeletal pain diseases, the results show that traditional Chinese exercise therapy provided significant positive therapeutic effects on knee osteoarthritis, chronic low back pain, osteoporotic pain, and fibromyalgia. Among them, the treatment of osteoporosis pain provided the best results, as shown in Figure 5.Figure 3
Meta-analysis of the comparison of VAS between the traditional Chinese exercise group and the control group.Figure 4
Subgroup analysis of different VAS comparisons.Figure 5
Subgroup analysis of the comparison of pain VAS scores of different diseases.


## 3.2.2. Oswestry Dysfunction Index (ODI) Score

Six studies, which included a total of 365 patients, were analyzed. The ODI scores of patients with musculoskeletal pain with the intervention of traditional Chinese exercise were significantly lower than those of the control group [MD = −2.73, 95% CI (−7.15, −1.69),P < 0.01], as shown in Figure 6. The six studies were all related to low back pain. According to the subgroup analysis of the exercise type, the intervention effect of Yi Jin Jing exercise [56] was significantly better than that of Tai Chi [45, 48–50] and Wu Qin Xi exercise [67].Figure 6
Meta-analysis of the comparison of ODI scores between the traditional Chinese exercise group and the control group.


## 3.2.3. Western Ontario and McMaster University Osteoarthritis Index (WOMAC)

A total of 17 studies were evaluated using WOMAC. Due to the large difference in the mean between the study groups, SMD combined statistics were selected. The results showed that traditional Chinese exercise was used to treat knee arthritis and was able to reduce WOMAC pain [SMD = −0.50, 95% CI (−0.75, −0.25),P < 0.01], relieve joint WOMAC stiffness [SMD = −0.37, 95% CI (−0.75, −0.00), P < 0.01], and improve dysfunction [SMD = −0.57, 95% CI (−0.82, −0.32), P < 0.01]. All results were statistically significant, as shown in Figures 7–9. Besides, according to the type of exercise method, a subgroup analysis of WOMAC showed that the Ba Duan Jin exercise intervention was significantly better than other exercise methods in reducing pain and improving dysfunction. In contrast, the Yi Jin Jing exercise was superior to other exercises in improving joint stiffness.Figure 7
Meta-analysis of WOMAC pain comparison between the traditional Chinese exercise group and the control group.Figure 8
Meta-analysis of WOMAC stiffness comparison between the traditional Chinese exercise group and the control group.Figure 9
Meta-analysis of WOMAC physical function comparison between traditional Chinese exercise group and control group.


## 3.2.4. Sensitivity Analysis

The sensitivity analyses of VAS exclude four studies with higher weights [38, 48, 49, 66], and the heterogeneity did not change significantly. The sensitivity analyses of ODI eliminate the two studies with higher weights [55, 56], and heterogeneity has changed significantly (I2 = 66%, T2 = 6.4961, P = 0.03), but the result does not change. Further analysis was done on two studies, and its heterogeneous sources may be related to the younger age of research subjects. Sensitivity analysis for WOMAC pain, excluding a study [46], reduced to moderate heterogeneity. Sensitivity analyses for WOMAC stiffness, WOMAC Physical Function, and Liu [47], Ye et al. [40], and Ye et al.’s [57] research studies were excluded. According to the Cochrane handbook [24], the three indicators are all reduced to moderate heterogeneity. The source of the articles’ heterogeneity may relate to the low age of the included patients and the imbalance of the gender ratio between men and women.


## 3.2.5. Publication Bias

The results show that VAS was biased (t = −3.2289, df = 29, P = 0.003082), and the use of the trimming filling method to adjust the published bias resulted in statistically significant differences (P < 0.001), as seen in Figure 10. WOMAC index of the three-funnel chart and metabias regression analysis shows no publication bias. Furthermore, the reliability of this study was high.Figure 10
The funnel plots of VAS.
(a)(b)


## 4. Discussion

Traditional Chinese exercises have been widely used in clinics to prevent various diseases, improve the quality of life, and increase happiness [70]. The results of this study showed that Tai Chi, Yi Jin Jing exercise, and Ba Duan Jin exercise in traditional Chinese significantly reduced the pain score of musculoskeletal diseases consistently across multiple meta-analysis studies [71–74]. Among musculoskeletal diseases, traditional Chinese exercise had the most significant impact on osteoporosis pain, which may be related to the cause of pain in each subordinate disease. Chronic low back pain, knee osteoarthritis, and fibromyalgia syndrome may be caused by noninfectious inflammation of joints. Therefore, proper traditional Chinese exercises are expected to relieve muscle spasms, prevent muscle strength decline [75], and relieve pain caused by inflammation.Severe bone pain caused by osteoporosis, mainly due to the high bone turnover rate and increased bone resorption, leads to the destruction of bone microstructure. However, traditional Chinese exercise can improve bone biomechanics, regulating bone growth and development, promoting local blood circulation in bone, increasing bone cell activity, and reducing bone turnover and pain [52]. In the traditional Chinese exercise, Yi Jin Jing belongs to the group of high intensity of musculoskeletal strengthening exercises, and it is better than other traditional Chinese exercises for improving musculoskeletal diseases. However, there are only a few studies in this area. In analyzing the low back pain indicator ODI, traditional Chinese exercises play a significant therapeutic role. However, most studies are Tai Chi interventions on this indicator and could not distinguish the dominant types of exercises for the treatment of low back pain. For the intervention of knee arthritis, Tai Chi and Ba Duan Jin exercise had significantly positive effects on pain and stiffness in patients with knee arthritis, consistently with the results of previous studies by Xie et al. [74, 76–78]. However, the therapeutic effect of the Yi Jin Jing exercise was only noted for joint stiffness and dysfunction, while the Wu Qin Xi exercise did not present a significant therapeutic value on all the evaluated indicators.These results can be further analyzed from the specific characteristics of each exercise. In the process of these exercises, for changes in body posture and shifting of the gravity center, Tai Chi and Ba Duan Jin exercise apply more pressure to the knee joint than the Yi Jin Jing exercise. Also, the sports characteristics of Tai Chi focus more on the coordination of various parts of the body, the speed, strength, flexibility, and others [79]. Therefore, Tai Chi is used to improving the balance ability in the elderly and preventing falls [80, 81]. The Ba Duan Jin exercise comprises movements of holding the knees with hands, swinging the body, and moving the center of gravity, which is beneficial for multiangle and large-scale movement of the knee joint. Yi Jin Jing exercise mainly focuses on strengthening muscles and bones [82], and only a few movements are aimed at the knee joint. Although studies have explored the effect of Yi Jin Jing exercise on the knee joint, the current research [83, 84] only has focused on the dysfunction and activity of the knee joint. However, we cannot ignore the possibility that the available literature may be scarce and include biased results. Wu Qin Xi exercise did not have a significant therapeutic effect on musculoskeletal pain. This may be related to the design purpose of the Wu Qin Xi exercise, which was to imitate the five movements of the tiger, deer, bear, ape, and bird to stretch and strengthen their body to prevent diseases [85]. Therefore, the intensity of intervention on the musculoskeletal part of the body is not as focused as traditional Chinese exercises.Nonetheless, there are some limitations in our meta-analysis. Firstly, several uncontrollable variables of the patients, such as age and disease, may affect the results. Secondly, a few articles included in this review did not explicitly report the procedures for random sequence generation, allocation concealment, and the blinding of assessors. Hence, selection and detection biases may have affected the validity of our results. Finally, most of the participants in many research studies were elderly, which may contribute to a biased result. In the future, more RCTs that focused on the incidence of musculoskeletal pain in a specific age group may be needed to corroborate our results further.


## 5. Conclusion

The traditional Chinese therapeutic exercises provided a more significant improvement effect on VAS, ODI, and WOMAC scores, with the Yi Jin Jing exercise being the best exercise in changing VAS. The Ba Duan Jin exercise was the most impactful in treating joint stiffness. However, additional large-sample studies with strict designs are needed to prove the therapeutic effects of different traditional Chinese exercises in CMP patients.



---

*Source: 5584997-2021-05-11.xml*