# 188W/188Re Generator System and Its Therapeutic Applications

Authors: A. Boschi; L. Uccelli; M. Pasquali; A. Duatti; A. Taibi; G. Pupillo; J. Esposito
Journal: Journal of Chemistry
 (2014)

---

## Abstract

The188Re radioisotope represents a useful radioisotope for the preparation of radiopharmaceuticals for therapeutic applications, particularly because of its favorable nuclear properties. The nuclide decay pattern is through the emission of a principle beta particle having 2.12 MeV maximum energy, which is enough to penetrate and destroy abnormal tissues, and principle gamma rays (E
γ
=
155 keV), which can efficiently be used for imaging and calculations of radiation dose. 188Re may be conveniently produced by 188W/188Re generator systems. The challenges related to the double neutron capture reaction route to provide only modest yield of the parent 188W radionuclide indeed have been one of the major issues about the use of 188Re in nuclear medicine. Since the specific activity of 188W used in the generator is relatively low (<185 GBq/g), the eluted Re
188
O
4
- can have a low radioactive concentration, often ineffective for radiopharmaceutical preparation. However, several efficient postelution concentration techniques have been developed, which yield clinically useful Re
188
O
4
- solutions. This review summarizes the technologies developed for the preparation of 188W/188Re generators, postelution concentration of the 188Re perrhenate eluate, and a brief discussion of new chemical strategies available for the very high yield preparation of 188Re radiopharmaceuticals.


---

## Body

## 1. Introduction

Rhenium-188 is currently considered a very attractive candidate for a wide variety of therapeutic applications. Its properties include emission of a high energy beta particle with a maximum energy of 2.12 MeV, a 155 keV (15%) gamma photon for imaging, and versatile chemistry for attachment to a variety of targeting molecules, which make188Re an important candidate for applications where deep tissue penetration is a benefit. Emission of gamma photons, which can be readily imaged, is an added benefit that permits evaluation of biodistribution, pharmacokinetics, and dosimetry. Rhenium-188 is a Rhenium-186 radioisotope, which was the first rhenium radioisotope applied in nuclear medicine, owing to its E
β
max
⁡ of 1.07 MeV and E
γ of 137 keV (very close to the 140 keV of Tc
99
m).Rhenium-188 of modest specific activity can be produced by direct activation in a nuclear reactor. Irradiation of natural rhenium element inside a fission-reactor-driven and high-flux neutron field yields a mixture of186Re and 188Re [1], being the relative contribution of each radioisotope dependent on the irradiation time and postbombardment decay [2]. Both 186Re and 188Re under radionuclidic purity form may instead be prepared by irradiating the highly enriched targets, 185Re and 187Re, respectively, in research reactors. Direct production using isotopically enriched targets inside reactors often yields carrier-added (CA) radioisotopes, having specific activity values high enough for the preparation of selected radiopharmaceuticals useful for bone pain palliation therapy, hepatocarcinoma, radiosynovectomy, and intravascular radionuclide therapy (IVRNT). However, the specific activities of (n
,
γ) produced 186Re and 188Re are not adequate for radiolabelling molecules such as peptides and antibodies which seek low density targets such as receptors and tumour antigens.The production method of choice for188Re is by the decay of the longer lived 188W parent (t
1
/
2, 69.4 d), which is produced through a double neutron capture reaction on 186W. Preparation of 188Re from a 188W/188Re generator is instead quite interesting, as it provides a long-term source for no-carrier-added (NCA) 188Re at the nuclear medicine departments [3–5]. Depending upon the specific activity of 188W, chromatography based on alumina or a gel type generator can be performed. In both cases, no-carrier-added (NCA) 188Re is eluted with saline solution in the form of sodium perrhenate. The chromatographic generator with alumina is suitable for high specific activity 188W, and the technology is similar to that used for 99Mo/Tc
99
m generators assembled with fission produced 99Mo. The 24 h postgenerator 188Re elution in-growth of 62% and high elution yields (75–85%) result in daily yields of about 50%, with consistently low 188W parent breakthrough (<10−6) [6, 7]. Simple postelution concentration methods have been developed to provide very high radioactive concentration solutions of 188Re for radiolabelling (>25,9 GBq/mL saline from a 37 GBq generator) [4–8]. A postelution concentration step can be used to concentrate the perrhenate solution to very high radioactive concentration. Gels and polymers containing zirconium or titanium can be used. The reported advantages of these systems are the ability to use low specific activity of 188W and the possibility to obtain high radioactive concentration suitable for radiopharmaceutical applications.This paper reviews the availability and use of188Re including reactor production of 188W, the development of techniques for the preparation 188W/188Re generators and concentration systems, and the most important chemical strategies development in the last years for the preparation of 188Re radiopharmaceuticals.


## 2. Reactor Production of188W

Tungsten-188 is a key example where very high thermal neutron flux is required for production of sufficient specific activity for practical use for the adsorption-based188W/188Re generator [4, 9–14]. Because of the double neutron capture reaction step, modest thermal cross-section values (Table 1), and product burn-up, the 188W is reactor produced with relatively low specific activity [11]. For example, 24 d irradiation even at high thermal flux level of Φ
th
>
10
15 cm−2s−1 yields 188W with a specific activity of only 148–185 GBq/g [9]. Use of this relatively low specific activity 188W requires larger amounts of alumina for the generator column, thus increasing the eluent volume and decreasing the 188Re concentration (activity/volume (MBq/mL)) [4, 5]. The increase in specific activity using very high flux reactors is dramatically illustrated for the production of 188W from enriched 186W by the 186W(n
,
γ) 187W(n
,
γ) 188W pathway (Figure 1). The modest 186W and 187W neutron capture cross-sections (Figure 1), the competing burn-up of the 188W product [13], and the significant self-shielding that has been observed [11, 12] are factors that decrease the 188W specific activity.Table 1
Examples of nuclear constants for nuclides in the188
W production chain.
Nuclide
Decay constant,λ (s−1)
Cross-section,σ (b)
Values for resonance integral,I (b)
186
W
—
37.9
485
187
W
8.09
×
10
-
6
64.0
2760; 10
188
W
1.16
×
10
-
7
12
0; 50 000; 1.4
187Re
—
76.4
300
188Re
1.13
×
10
-
5
<2
—Figure 1
Scheme for reactor production of188W.At the Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL, Oak Ridge, Tennessee, USA), the high flux isotope reactor (HFIR), production of188W from both 186W-enriched metal and oxide tungsten targets, has been evaluated over the past several years [4, 8–11]. Tungsten-188 having adequate specific activity suitable for the production of 188W/188Re generators can be accomplished also in only a limited number of the research reactors, that is, SM Reactor, RIAR, Dimitrovgrad, Russian Federation, and BR2 Reactor, Belgium.


### 2.1. Availability of Enriched186W Target Material

Ideally,188W should be produced by neutron irradiation of enriched 186W targets, especially for the subsequent preparation of high activity 188W/188Re generators. The use of enriched targets is also required to minimize co-production of other radioactive species. In addition, the use of enriched targets reduces the target volume considerably, since the W targets are quite large because of the modest 188W production yields. Furthermore, because of the relatively low specific activity of 188W produced by the double neutron capture process, even at very high thermal flux, the highest specific activity 188W is generally sought to minimize the amount of adsorbent required for loading of the traditional aluminium oxide adsorption type generator. The irradiation of high purity natural W results in much lower specific activity and requires even higher levels of the alumina adsorbent [14]. Although large electromagnetically separated quantities of highly enriched 186W are available on the world market and mechanical-driven (i.e.,) centrifuge enrichment method has also been demonstrated on a small scale, another strategy has been demonstrated feasility, that is the recovery of nonactivated 186W from used generators, since only a small fraction of 186W is transmuted to 188W during the reactor irradiation process. By increasing the pH of the generator eluent, salts of tungstic acid can be readily removed [15]. The use of ammonium hydroxide with peroxide, for instance, can remove >95% of the available W from the alumina column. Subsequent precipitation with nitric acid (chloride complexes have limited solubility), recovery by centrifugation and then heating at high temperature, readily converts the W to the oxide, which could then conceivably be used for preparation of additional targets for neutron irradiation. Although long decay periods would be expected to reduce the activity of the residual radioactivity to manageable levels, this recovered W would still be radioactive with longer lived contaminants. Target fabrication with this material would thus probably require special handling. Nonetheless, this approach could represent a possible method for recovery of the 186W target material.A strategy currently used at ORNL [12, 14] involves the use of enriched metallic 186W targets that are pressed into pellets and subsequently sintered at high temperature prior to neutron irradiation. This approach dramatically increases the target density and thus the loading and 188W production capability per target, and about 5 g of these discs (8–10/target) can be loaded into one HFIR hydraulic tube target assembly. The issue of self-shielding may need to be taken into account, as this decreases the specific activity compared with the use of granular/powder targets [10]. Although the total 188W activity produced per target is higher with the pressed targets, since significantly more target material can be used per target holder, the 188W specific activity decreases as the mass of the enriched 186W increases. Although the key factors leading to such a discrepancy are still not well understood, the specific activity of the irradiated 186W-enriched pellets is considerably less (20–25%) than the specific activity of the irradiated granular/powder enriched 186W target [9].


## 2.1. Availability of Enriched186W Target Material

Ideally,188W should be produced by neutron irradiation of enriched 186W targets, especially for the subsequent preparation of high activity 188W/188Re generators. The use of enriched targets is also required to minimize co-production of other radioactive species. In addition, the use of enriched targets reduces the target volume considerably, since the W targets are quite large because of the modest 188W production yields. Furthermore, because of the relatively low specific activity of 188W produced by the double neutron capture process, even at very high thermal flux, the highest specific activity 188W is generally sought to minimize the amount of adsorbent required for loading of the traditional aluminium oxide adsorption type generator. The irradiation of high purity natural W results in much lower specific activity and requires even higher levels of the alumina adsorbent [14]. Although large electromagnetically separated quantities of highly enriched 186W are available on the world market and mechanical-driven (i.e.,) centrifuge enrichment method has also been demonstrated on a small scale, another strategy has been demonstrated feasility, that is the recovery of nonactivated 186W from used generators, since only a small fraction of 186W is transmuted to 188W during the reactor irradiation process. By increasing the pH of the generator eluent, salts of tungstic acid can be readily removed [15]. The use of ammonium hydroxide with peroxide, for instance, can remove >95% of the available W from the alumina column. Subsequent precipitation with nitric acid (chloride complexes have limited solubility), recovery by centrifugation and then heating at high temperature, readily converts the W to the oxide, which could then conceivably be used for preparation of additional targets for neutron irradiation. Although long decay periods would be expected to reduce the activity of the residual radioactivity to manageable levels, this recovered W would still be radioactive with longer lived contaminants. Target fabrication with this material would thus probably require special handling. Nonetheless, this approach could represent a possible method for recovery of the 186W target material.A strategy currently used at ORNL [12, 14] involves the use of enriched metallic 186W targets that are pressed into pellets and subsequently sintered at high temperature prior to neutron irradiation. This approach dramatically increases the target density and thus the loading and 188W production capability per target, and about 5 g of these discs (8–10/target) can be loaded into one HFIR hydraulic tube target assembly. The issue of self-shielding may need to be taken into account, as this decreases the specific activity compared with the use of granular/powder targets [10]. Although the total 188W activity produced per target is higher with the pressed targets, since significantly more target material can be used per target holder, the 188W specific activity decreases as the mass of the enriched 186W increases. Although the key factors leading to such a discrepancy are still not well understood, the specific activity of the irradiated 186W-enriched pellets is considerably less (20–25%) than the specific activity of the irradiated granular/powder enriched 186W target [9].


## 3. Processing of188W

### 3.1. Tungsten Metal and Tungsten Oxide Targets

Although a variety of postirradiation processing strategies are possible, processing of188W has usually involved postirradiation basic dissolution of 186W oxide targets and/or high temperature oxidative processing of metallic enriched 186W targets [8–10]. Relatively large enriched 186W targets are required to produce multicurie levels of 188W. Use of granular/powder oxide targets can simplify the processing, since dissolution in sodium hydroxide solution with heating is straightforward. Enriched 186W targets under powder form are routinely used for production of 188W at the SM reactor at the Research Institute of Atomic Reactors (RIAR) in Dimitrovgrad, Russia. However, although powder metal of oxide targets was routinely used for 188W production in the ORNL HFIR for many years [12–14], transition to use of the highly enriched 186W pressed and sintered targeted geometry was originally explored as a strategy to increase the 186W mass per target [11]. More recently, the pressed discs have become the target of choice at ORNL because of the requirements for use of available hot cells and the need to minimize hot cell contamination resulting from potential release of the highly radioactive powder. Subsequent removal of any radionuclide impurities is possible, such as with ion exchange chromatography as is used at RIAR [16]. The purification procedure is based on treating the sodium tungstate solution in a mixture of acetic acid and hydrogen peroxide, with subsequent passage through cation exchange resin [17]. To perform this procedure, the sodium tungstate basic solution is evaporated to moist salts, and the residue is dissolved in acetic acid solution containing 3–5 vol.% hydrogen peroxide. The solution is passed through the column filled with the KU-2 cation exchanger (an analogue of Dowex-50). Tungsten forms anionic peroxide complexes that are not retained by the resin, whereas many other metals, unable to produce anionic acetate or peroxide complexes, are retained in cationic form and have distribution ratios higher than 102. The tungsten peroxide complexes are destroyed by heating of the purified solution to 60–80°C, with precipitation of tungstic acid. If metallic granular/powder or pressed/sintered enriched 186W targets are used, as at ORNL, the irradiated target material is first heated to 750–800°C in a quartz furnace while a stream of air is passed over the target material for conversion to tungsten oxide for subsequent dissolution in base, as shown in Figures 2 and 3. In this case, the contaminating levels of most of the 191Os radionuclidic impurities are also swept away from the target for subsequent trapping in base. At ORNL, the resulting sodium tungstate stock solution is not purified further, since the possible presence of low amounts of the 191Os and 192Ir impurities present in the 188Re generator eluents used for radiopharmaceuticals preparation has been shown to be without consequences.Figure 2
ORNL postirradiation processing scheme for pressed/sintered enriched186W metal targets [16].Figure 3
Apparatus used at ORNL for postirradiation conversion of metallic enriched186W targets to tungsten oxide [16].


### 3.2. Radionuclide Impurities

Both191Os (t
1
/
2
=
15.4 d, gamma emission at 129.42 KeV, 29%) and 192Ir (t
1
/
2
=
73.8 d, gamma emission at 316.51 KeV, 83%) radionuclides are produced during irradiation of 186W targets; the levels are produced depending upon the irradiation parameters. Although not yet documented in detail, it can be assumed that these two impurities are coproduced by a series of transformations coming from the decay of 190Os that is formed during neutron irradiation of enriched 186W [16]. However, at secular equilibrium, these two radionuclide impurities usually are not detected in the gamma spectrum of 188W and 188Re because of the intensity of the 159 keV gamma photon emitted from 188Re.The presence of60Co in decayed samples of the 188Re eluate from 188W/188Re generators probably results from activation of the low levels of natural cobalt (59Co) present in the Al material used to construct the hydraulic tube units. It is assumed that, after irradiation, small amounts of the Al base material probably accompany the irradiated 186W material, which is removed after opening the hydraulic tube assembly. Most of the 191Os is removed during the oxidative conversion of the metallic W target to tungsten oxide, and any remaining 191Os and 192Ir is generally only detected in small amounts by gamma spectroscopy following decay of 188Re in the saline eluted bolus. These impurities are slowly eluted from the generators in only very small amounts. If the tandem cation/anion postconcentration system is used, as in the general practice in most clinical centres, essentially all the 192Ir is trapped on the column during concentration.Tungsten-188 breakthrough can be also present in188Re eluates (with values typically in the 10−6 range). However, any 188W breakthrough can be effectively removed by subsequent postelution process by passage of the bolus through a small, commercially available alumina QMA Sep-Pak column [18].


## 3.1. Tungsten Metal and Tungsten Oxide Targets

Although a variety of postirradiation processing strategies are possible, processing of188W has usually involved postirradiation basic dissolution of 186W oxide targets and/or high temperature oxidative processing of metallic enriched 186W targets [8–10]. Relatively large enriched 186W targets are required to produce multicurie levels of 188W. Use of granular/powder oxide targets can simplify the processing, since dissolution in sodium hydroxide solution with heating is straightforward. Enriched 186W targets under powder form are routinely used for production of 188W at the SM reactor at the Research Institute of Atomic Reactors (RIAR) in Dimitrovgrad, Russia. However, although powder metal of oxide targets was routinely used for 188W production in the ORNL HFIR for many years [12–14], transition to use of the highly enriched 186W pressed and sintered targeted geometry was originally explored as a strategy to increase the 186W mass per target [11]. More recently, the pressed discs have become the target of choice at ORNL because of the requirements for use of available hot cells and the need to minimize hot cell contamination resulting from potential release of the highly radioactive powder. Subsequent removal of any radionuclide impurities is possible, such as with ion exchange chromatography as is used at RIAR [16]. The purification procedure is based on treating the sodium tungstate solution in a mixture of acetic acid and hydrogen peroxide, with subsequent passage through cation exchange resin [17]. To perform this procedure, the sodium tungstate basic solution is evaporated to moist salts, and the residue is dissolved in acetic acid solution containing 3–5 vol.% hydrogen peroxide. The solution is passed through the column filled with the KU-2 cation exchanger (an analogue of Dowex-50). Tungsten forms anionic peroxide complexes that are not retained by the resin, whereas many other metals, unable to produce anionic acetate or peroxide complexes, are retained in cationic form and have distribution ratios higher than 102. The tungsten peroxide complexes are destroyed by heating of the purified solution to 60–80°C, with precipitation of tungstic acid. If metallic granular/powder or pressed/sintered enriched 186W targets are used, as at ORNL, the irradiated target material is first heated to 750–800°C in a quartz furnace while a stream of air is passed over the target material for conversion to tungsten oxide for subsequent dissolution in base, as shown in Figures 2 and 3. In this case, the contaminating levels of most of the 191Os radionuclidic impurities are also swept away from the target for subsequent trapping in base. At ORNL, the resulting sodium tungstate stock solution is not purified further, since the possible presence of low amounts of the 191Os and 192Ir impurities present in the 188Re generator eluents used for radiopharmaceuticals preparation has been shown to be without consequences.Figure 2
ORNL postirradiation processing scheme for pressed/sintered enriched186W metal targets [16].Figure 3
Apparatus used at ORNL for postirradiation conversion of metallic enriched186W targets to tungsten oxide [16].


## 3.2. Radionuclide Impurities

Both191Os (t
1
/
2
=
15.4 d, gamma emission at 129.42 KeV, 29%) and 192Ir (t
1
/
2
=
73.8 d, gamma emission at 316.51 KeV, 83%) radionuclides are produced during irradiation of 186W targets; the levels are produced depending upon the irradiation parameters. Although not yet documented in detail, it can be assumed that these two impurities are coproduced by a series of transformations coming from the decay of 190Os that is formed during neutron irradiation of enriched 186W [16]. However, at secular equilibrium, these two radionuclide impurities usually are not detected in the gamma spectrum of 188W and 188Re because of the intensity of the 159 keV gamma photon emitted from 188Re.The presence of60Co in decayed samples of the 188Re eluate from 188W/188Re generators probably results from activation of the low levels of natural cobalt (59Co) present in the Al material used to construct the hydraulic tube units. It is assumed that, after irradiation, small amounts of the Al base material probably accompany the irradiated 186W material, which is removed after opening the hydraulic tube assembly. Most of the 191Os is removed during the oxidative conversion of the metallic W target to tungsten oxide, and any remaining 191Os and 192Ir is generally only detected in small amounts by gamma spectroscopy following decay of 188Re in the saline eluted bolus. These impurities are slowly eluted from the generators in only very small amounts. If the tandem cation/anion postconcentration system is used, as in the general practice in most clinical centres, essentially all the 192Ir is trapped on the column during concentration.Tungsten-188 breakthrough can be also present in188Re eluates (with values typically in the 10−6 range). However, any 188W breakthrough can be effectively removed by subsequent postelution process by passage of the bolus through a small, commercially available alumina QMA Sep-Pak column [18].


## 4. The188W/188Re Generator System

### 4.1. Alumina Based188W/188Re Generators

Alumina based chromatographic generator systems, similar to those available forTc
99
m, are prepared for obtaining 188Re. At ORNL, active acidic aluminium oxide is used to prepare the columns. Tungsten-188 with a maxima specific activity of 185 GBq per gram of tungsten as sodium tungstate in 0.26 mol L−1 of NaOH, with a concentration of 7.6 GBq per millilitre, can be used. The pH level of the Na2 188WO4 solution (0.26 mol L−1 of NaOH) has to be adjusted to 2-3 with 0.1 mol L−1 HCl, and the required amount of activity is loaded onto the column under controlled vacuum pressure (flow rate: 1 mL/min.). The column, placed in shielded housing and handled inside appropriate facilities, is washed with 100 mL of 0.9% NaCl solution (normal saline) and, after allowing growth of the 188Re, eluted with 10 mL of saline. Table 2 summarizes the characteristics of the commercial 188W/188Re generators available in the world market.Table 2
The characteristics of the commercial188W/188Re generators.
Institution/suppliers
Strength
Column material
Specific activity of W-188
Remarks
ORNL, TN, USA
9.25 GBq (250 mCi) to 111 GBq (3 Ci) cGMP system
Alumina
148–185 GBq (4-5 Ci)/g
>500 generators since 1986.
Dimitrovgrad, Russia
3.7–111 GBq (0.1–3 Ci) Sterile cGMP system
Alumina
185 GBq (5 Ci)/g
Regular production and supply.
IRE, Belgium
Up to 55.4 GBq (1.5 Ci)
Alumina
185 GBq (5 Ci)/g
Generator is available with an automatic concentration module.
ITM AG, Germany
Unknown
Alumina
185 GBq (5 Ci)/g
Regular production and supply.
Polatom, Poland
18.5 GBq (500 mCi) cGMP system
Use of99
Mo
/
99
mTc column system
185 GBq (5 Ci)/g
Regular production and supply.
IDB, Holland
3.7–18.5 GBq (100–500 mCi)
Alumina
Unknown
Regular production and supply.Rhenium-188 having very high radionuclidic and radiochemical purity (>99%) can be eluted from the alumina based generator with high elution efficiency (>80%). Nonetheless, most often the188Re eluted from an alumina column chromatography generator is not suitable for the direct formulation of radiopharmaceuticals; a postelution concentration of the generator eluent solution is essential to obtain Re
188
O
4
- having radioactive concentration sufficient for radiopharmaceutical formulation.


#### 4.1.1. Postelution Concentration of188Re Perrhenate from the Generator

The use of low specific activity188W and of old generators results in low radioactivity concentrations of the eluted 188Re perrhenate, which is often not suitable for radiolabelling of biomolecules. Postelution concentration is essential in such cases. Reports in the literature [7, 18–20] on effective postelution concentration of 188Re using tandem ion exchange columns prompted an exploration of possible means of postelution concentration of the 188Re perrhenate eluate. Postelution concentration of no-carrier-added 188Re perrhenate is based on its selective retention on a tiny anion exchange column and subsequent recovery in a small volume of suitable eluent. This concentration of perrhenate is possible only when the 188Re eluate is free of any other macroscopic anionic species. Three different methods of postelution concentration can be used, as described below.Use of IC-Ag and Sep-Pak Accell Plus QMA Anion Exchanger Column. The technology developed at ORNL uses a Maxi-Clean IC-Ag; Ag+ form cation exchanger cartridge (Alltech Associates, USA) and a Sep-Pak Accell Plus QMA anion exchange cartridge (Waters Corporation, Milford, USA) was used in the first method of postelution concentration, as reported by Guhlke et al. [18–20]. The Maxi-Clean IC-Ag cartridge was conditioned with 5 mL of deionized water. Rhenium-188 eluate obtained from a 188W/188Re generator in 10 mL of normal saline solution was freed of macroscopic Cl
- ions as AgCl precipitate by passage through an Alltech IC-Ag
+ cation exchange cartridge. This 188Re perrhenate eluate free of chloride anion was then passed through the small Sep-Pak Accell Plus QMA anion exchange cartridge (130 mg) to retain the perrhenate and was subsequently reeluted with a very small volume (1 mL) of normal saline. The effluent from the IC-Ag cartridge and a few mL of deionized water used for washing were measured to assess any loss of 188Re activity in the concentration process. Using this method, 188Re yield of 79
±
3% was obtained, with a concentration factor of about 10. The 188W breakthrough was well below 10
-
4% and at times was undetectable. In Figure 4 a schematic drawn of 188Re generator and concentration system with IC-Ag and Sep-Pak Accell Plus QMA anion exchanger column is reported. The complete generator setup consists of an attachment for the generator effluent for flow through an alumina QMA SepPak, which effectively removes low levels of any 188W breakthrough and then through a tandem silver-cation/QMA anion column for concentration of the 188Re eluate to usable radioactive concentration.Figure 4
Schematic drawn of188Re generator and concentration system with of IC-Ag and Sep-Pak Accell Plus QMA anion exchanger column [19].Use of Dowex 1X8 and AgCl Column. A Dowex 1X8 anion exchanger (Cl-form, 200–400 mesh) with a capacity of 3–5 meq/g (Sigma Chemicals) and extra pure AgCl were used in this method of postelution concentration [21]. Between 10 and 12 mg of Dowex 1X8 resin was taken in a 2 mL syringe and placed in a polypropylene tube (~8 mm × 1 mm) with a few millilitres of water. The other end of the tube was packed with glass wool. Both ends of the tube were fitted with miniature barbed polypropylene fittings. Ten millilitres of normal saline solution was passed through the resin column and washed with 5 mL of water (~5 bed volumes of the resin column). Between 1 and 1.5 g of commercial AgCl salt was taken in a glass column (12 mm × 8 mm) with a sintered disc (G-2), closed with a silicon rubber septum, washed with a few millilitres of deionized water, and used. Between 20 and 40 mL of 188Re eluate in normal saline obtained from the generator was passed through the Dowex 1X8 anion exchange column (placed in appropriate shielding) at a flow rate of 2-3 mL/min using controlled vacuum pressure. The activities in the effluent from the Dowex 1 column and in the subsequent washings with a few millilitres of deionized water were measured to assess the adsorption of the perrhenate. These were treated as radioactive waste and appropriately disposed of. The no-carrier-added 188Re perrhenate adsorbed on the tiny anion exchange column was reeluted with 5-6 mL of 0.2 mol dm−3 NaI solution and passed through the AgCl column (1 g, 12 mm × 8 mm) placed in proper shielding (6-7 mm of lead). The effluent of 188Re perrhenate obtained by washing the column with 1.5–1.8 mL of deionized water was collected in a 10 mL vial. This 188Re perrhenate was free of iodide (removed as AgI precipitate) and isotonic with normal saline. In this system, there was a loss of 188Re activity (6–12% in the case of 20 mL primary eluate volume and 17–25% in the case of 40 mL primary eluate volume) and the yield of 188Re was about 72.4
±
12%. However, the 188W breakthrough was below 10
-
4%. The presence of Ag on 188Re eluate was not determined. However Chattopadhyay et al. [22] demonstrated that the quality of the [Tc
99
m]NaTcO4 concentrated with this procedure complies with the specifications applicable for radiopharmaceutical use.Use of a Single Column of DEAE Cellulose. The third method devised for postelution concentration involved the construction of a generator bed free of chloride ions and elution of the 188Re perrhenate in acetate buffer. This method was based on earlier work with Tc
99
m pertechnetate [23, 24]. The 188Re perrhenate eluted was then trapped on a DEAE cellulose column and eluted in a small volume of saline. Briefly, the generator was washed initially with approximately 200 mL of 1 : 1 vol./vol. 0.025 mol dm−3 NH4OAc: 0.7 mol dm−3 AcOH at ~pH 3, to remove the chloride (Cl−) ions. The effluents were checked for the absence of chloride ions by AgNO3 testing. The generator was then set aside to allow for the growth of 188Re. The 188W/188Re generator was then eluted with 20–25 mL of acidic ammonium acetate [17] and passed through a small anion exchange column of DEAE cellulose (300 mg, 10 mm × 8 mm) to trap 188Re perrhenate. Subsequently, 188Re was recovered in 4 mL of normal saline. The mean practical yield of 188Re in this method was 72.9
±
2.3% (n
=
11). The time required for the concentration process was 15–20 min. The DEAE cellulose column was flushed with 5-6 mL of deionized water to keep the system ready for the next elution.


### 4.2. Novel Materials for Column Matrix for Use in Radionuclide Generators

Materials with a higher capacity for tungsten adsorption are of great interest owing to the low specific activities of188W, which necessitates the use of large alumina columns, which in turn leads to low radioactive concentration or to tungsten breakthrough. Dadachov et al. [25] proposed a new concept in which 188W obtained by (n
,
γ) reaction of natural tungsten can be incorporated into a titanium tungstate based gel. Brodskaya et al. [26] have reported a method for chromatographic separation of tungsten and rhenium using organophosphorus resins. A major disadvantage of this process is the radiation degradation of the resin, which is sensitive to radiation damage. Another alternative approach is emerging from research being conducted in Japan [27, 28] in which reactor irradiated molybdenum (i.e., low specific activity) was adsorbed into a zirconium polymer, with higher uptake capacity for 99Mo than for alumina. Chakravarty et al. [29] used nanocrystalline zirconia, a high capacity sorbent material tested for its utility in the preparation of 188W/188Re generators. The structural investigation of the material was carried out using X-ray diffraction, surface area determination, FTIR, and TEM micrograph analysis. Various experimental parameters were optimized to separate 188Re from 188W. The capacity of the material was found to be ~325 mg W/g at the optimum pH. A chromatographic 188W/188Re generator was developed using this material from which >80% of 188Re generated could be eluted with 0.9% saline solution, with high radionuclidic, radiochemical, and chemical purity and appreciably high radioactive concentration suitable for radiopharmaceutical applications. Application of titanium polymer prepared by the polymerization reaction of TiCl4 with isopropyl alcohol for the preparation of a 188W/188Re generator and the elution characteristics of 188Re were studied by Venkatesh et al. [30]. For the synthesis of the polymeric titaniumadsorbent, titanium tetrachloride was mixed with isopropyl alcohol in the ratio of 1 : 2 in a beaker with vigorous stirring. The material obtained was water soluble. To make this into an insoluble polymer, it was heated for 2 h at 150°C. This product was insoluble in water and in most of the mineral acids and alkaline. Thedried cake was ground to a fine powder and sieved with a 25–50 mesh sieve. The distribution ratio (K
d) of 188W in 0.1 mol dm−3 HNO3 was determined at different time intervals and the results indicated that about 45 min is required to reach the equilibration. In all subsequent experiments, the polymer was adsorbed with the 188W activity for 45 min. It was observed that the maximum adsorption of 188W as tungstate on thetitanium polymer occurred at pH 5-6. While both 188W-tungstate and 188Re asperrhenate were adsorbed, when eluted with saline, perrhenate exhibited farless affinity (approximately 600-fold lower) for the matrix. In order to estimate the saturation capacity of the titanium polymer and the concentration at which breakthrough begins, adsorption of 188W on the titanium polymer was determined under dynamic conditions using an ion exchange chromatographic column in the presence of different carrier concentrations of tungsten in the feed. The breakthrough capacity and saturation capacity of tungsten were found to be 62 and 120 mg/g, respectively, indicating that approximately 62 mg of tungsten per gram of titanium polymer can be loaded without any breakthrough being observed. A process demonstration run was carried out with this adsorbent using 1 mCi of 188W, and the elution behavior of the 188Re was studied. It was observed that only about 60–70% of the 188Re on the column could be eluted with saline, but that approximately 92% of this was eluted in the first 3–5 mL. Further study of this material is needed and will be done as the next step in generator development.Monroy-Guzman et al. [31] prepared 188W/188Re generators based on 188W-tungstates and hydroxyapatite. The titanium tungstate gels were synthesized from tetrabutyl orthotitanate and sodium 188W-tungstate solutions. Gels were prepared using 188W-tungstate solutions of four different pH values (in the range of 1.95–12) at a Ti : W molar ratio of 1 : 1. The gels were stirred and dried for 2.5 h at 80°C and then placed on polyethylene columns. The zirconium tungstate gels were prepared from zirconium ethoxide solutions and sodium 188W-tungstate solutions following the process described above. Gels were prepared using 188W-tungstate solutions of four different pH values at a Zr : W molar ratio of 1 : 1. The columns were washed with 50 mL of 0.9% NaCl and were eluted every three days for a period of three months. They found that the pH level of the 188W-tungstate solution used for the preparation of the titanium and zirconium 188W-tungstate based generators influence the efficiency and the 188W breakthrough of the generators. Both parameters decreased when the gels were synthesized with more acidic 188W-tungstate solutions. The best 188Re elution efficiency (~73%) was obtained from the titanium 188W-tungstate based generators; however, the lowest 188W breakthrough (0.3%) was obtained from the zirconium 188W-tungstate based generators. The 188Re radiochemical purity obtained from both types of generator is less in the gels prepared with basic 188W-tungstate solutions (83–87%) than in those prepared with acidic 188W-tungstate solution, which had a 188Re radiochemical purity of 100%.Theα
W
/
Re separation factors shown in Figure 5 indicate that tungsten and rhenium can be readily separated with 0.9% NaCl solutions at pH levels below 7.5. Based on these data, hydroxyapatite based generators were constructed using four 0.9% NaCl solutions at pH 5.5, 6.0, 6.3, and 6.5 (series A), and using hydroxyapatite particles of three sizes (series B). Results on the performance of these generators are shown in Figures 6 and 7. For all the 188Re eluates obtained in both series, the pH was 6.5, the phosphate concentration was greater than 1000 ppm, and the radiochemical purity was greater than 90%. The lowest 188W breakthrough and highest average elution volumes were obtained in the generators eluted with 0.9% NaCl solution at pH 6.5 and with hydroxyapatite particles between 38 and 75 μm in size. The efficiency of the 188W/188Re generators decreased with the pH value of the NaCl solution, but the particle size of the hydroxyapatite appeared to have no significant effect. The mean efficiencies obtained were about 65%, whereas the elution volumes and 188W breakthrough values decreased with a decrease of the hydroxyapatite particle size and with an increase of the pH value of the NaCl solution. The generators in series A and B showed that phosphate ions are released during the elution of 188Re, leading to the proposal to wash the generators after elution with 0.9% NaCl solutions, using 0.01 mol dm−3 CaCl2 or 0.004 mol dm−3 NaH2PO4 solutions, in order to avoid the dissolution of hydroxyapatite.Figure 5
Separation factors of tungsten and rhenium (α
W
/
Re) on hydroxyapatite [31].Figure 6
Performance of the hydroxyapatite based188W/188Re generators as a function of the 0.9% NaCl solution pH (series A) [31].Figure 7
Performance of the hydroxyapatite based188W/188Re generators as a function of the hydroxyapatite particle size (series B) [31].A third series of generators (series C) was then fabricated and evaluated using the method previously described. The performance of these generators as a function of the eluent is shown in Figure8. Washing the generators with 0.01 mol dm−3 CaCl2 or 0.004 mol dm−3 NaH2PO4 solutions after elution with 0.9% NaCl solutions caused an increase of the 188W breakthrough in the 188Re eluate.Figure 8
Performance of the hydroxyapatite based188W/188Re generators as a function of the eluent (series C) [31].However, there was no apparent effect on the188Re elution efficiency, the eluate pH, or the radiochemical purity. The presence of phosphate ions in the 188Re eluates shows that the hydroxyapatite continues to dissolve.


## 4.1. Alumina Based188W/188Re Generators

Alumina based chromatographic generator systems, similar to those available forTc
99
m, are prepared for obtaining 188Re. At ORNL, active acidic aluminium oxide is used to prepare the columns. Tungsten-188 with a maxima specific activity of 185 GBq per gram of tungsten as sodium tungstate in 0.26 mol L−1 of NaOH, with a concentration of 7.6 GBq per millilitre, can be used. The pH level of the Na2 188WO4 solution (0.26 mol L−1 of NaOH) has to be adjusted to 2-3 with 0.1 mol L−1 HCl, and the required amount of activity is loaded onto the column under controlled vacuum pressure (flow rate: 1 mL/min.). The column, placed in shielded housing and handled inside appropriate facilities, is washed with 100 mL of 0.9% NaCl solution (normal saline) and, after allowing growth of the 188Re, eluted with 10 mL of saline. Table 2 summarizes the characteristics of the commercial 188W/188Re generators available in the world market.Table 2
The characteristics of the commercial188W/188Re generators.
Institution/suppliers
Strength
Column material
Specific activity of W-188
Remarks
ORNL, TN, USA
9.25 GBq (250 mCi) to 111 GBq (3 Ci) cGMP system
Alumina
148–185 GBq (4-5 Ci)/g
>500 generators since 1986.
Dimitrovgrad, Russia
3.7–111 GBq (0.1–3 Ci) Sterile cGMP system
Alumina
185 GBq (5 Ci)/g
Regular production and supply.
IRE, Belgium
Up to 55.4 GBq (1.5 Ci)
Alumina
185 GBq (5 Ci)/g
Generator is available with an automatic concentration module.
ITM AG, Germany
Unknown
Alumina
185 GBq (5 Ci)/g
Regular production and supply.
Polatom, Poland
18.5 GBq (500 mCi) cGMP system
Use of99
Mo
/
99
mTc column system
185 GBq (5 Ci)/g
Regular production and supply.
IDB, Holland
3.7–18.5 GBq (100–500 mCi)
Alumina
Unknown
Regular production and supply.Rhenium-188 having very high radionuclidic and radiochemical purity (>99%) can be eluted from the alumina based generator with high elution efficiency (>80%). Nonetheless, most often the188Re eluted from an alumina column chromatography generator is not suitable for the direct formulation of radiopharmaceuticals; a postelution concentration of the generator eluent solution is essential to obtain Re
188
O
4
- having radioactive concentration sufficient for radiopharmaceutical formulation.


### 4.1.1. Postelution Concentration of188Re Perrhenate from the Generator

The use of low specific activity188W and of old generators results in low radioactivity concentrations of the eluted 188Re perrhenate, which is often not suitable for radiolabelling of biomolecules. Postelution concentration is essential in such cases. Reports in the literature [7, 18–20] on effective postelution concentration of 188Re using tandem ion exchange columns prompted an exploration of possible means of postelution concentration of the 188Re perrhenate eluate. Postelution concentration of no-carrier-added 188Re perrhenate is based on its selective retention on a tiny anion exchange column and subsequent recovery in a small volume of suitable eluent. This concentration of perrhenate is possible only when the 188Re eluate is free of any other macroscopic anionic species. Three different methods of postelution concentration can be used, as described below.Use of IC-Ag and Sep-Pak Accell Plus QMA Anion Exchanger Column. The technology developed at ORNL uses a Maxi-Clean IC-Ag; Ag+ form cation exchanger cartridge (Alltech Associates, USA) and a Sep-Pak Accell Plus QMA anion exchange cartridge (Waters Corporation, Milford, USA) was used in the first method of postelution concentration, as reported by Guhlke et al. [18–20]. The Maxi-Clean IC-Ag cartridge was conditioned with 5 mL of deionized water. Rhenium-188 eluate obtained from a 188W/188Re generator in 10 mL of normal saline solution was freed of macroscopic Cl
- ions as AgCl precipitate by passage through an Alltech IC-Ag
+ cation exchange cartridge. This 188Re perrhenate eluate free of chloride anion was then passed through the small Sep-Pak Accell Plus QMA anion exchange cartridge (130 mg) to retain the perrhenate and was subsequently reeluted with a very small volume (1 mL) of normal saline. The effluent from the IC-Ag cartridge and a few mL of deionized water used for washing were measured to assess any loss of 188Re activity in the concentration process. Using this method, 188Re yield of 79
±
3% was obtained, with a concentration factor of about 10. The 188W breakthrough was well below 10
-
4% and at times was undetectable. In Figure 4 a schematic drawn of 188Re generator and concentration system with IC-Ag and Sep-Pak Accell Plus QMA anion exchanger column is reported. The complete generator setup consists of an attachment for the generator effluent for flow through an alumina QMA SepPak, which effectively removes low levels of any 188W breakthrough and then through a tandem silver-cation/QMA anion column for concentration of the 188Re eluate to usable radioactive concentration.Figure 4
Schematic drawn of188Re generator and concentration system with of IC-Ag and Sep-Pak Accell Plus QMA anion exchanger column [19].Use of Dowex 1X8 and AgCl Column. A Dowex 1X8 anion exchanger (Cl-form, 200–400 mesh) with a capacity of 3–5 meq/g (Sigma Chemicals) and extra pure AgCl were used in this method of postelution concentration [21]. Between 10 and 12 mg of Dowex 1X8 resin was taken in a 2 mL syringe and placed in a polypropylene tube (~8 mm × 1 mm) with a few millilitres of water. The other end of the tube was packed with glass wool. Both ends of the tube were fitted with miniature barbed polypropylene fittings. Ten millilitres of normal saline solution was passed through the resin column and washed with 5 mL of water (~5 bed volumes of the resin column). Between 1 and 1.5 g of commercial AgCl salt was taken in a glass column (12 mm × 8 mm) with a sintered disc (G-2), closed with a silicon rubber septum, washed with a few millilitres of deionized water, and used. Between 20 and 40 mL of 188Re eluate in normal saline obtained from the generator was passed through the Dowex 1X8 anion exchange column (placed in appropriate shielding) at a flow rate of 2-3 mL/min using controlled vacuum pressure. The activities in the effluent from the Dowex 1 column and in the subsequent washings with a few millilitres of deionized water were measured to assess the adsorption of the perrhenate. These were treated as radioactive waste and appropriately disposed of. The no-carrier-added 188Re perrhenate adsorbed on the tiny anion exchange column was reeluted with 5-6 mL of 0.2 mol dm−3 NaI solution and passed through the AgCl column (1 g, 12 mm × 8 mm) placed in proper shielding (6-7 mm of lead). The effluent of 188Re perrhenate obtained by washing the column with 1.5–1.8 mL of deionized water was collected in a 10 mL vial. This 188Re perrhenate was free of iodide (removed as AgI precipitate) and isotonic with normal saline. In this system, there was a loss of 188Re activity (6–12% in the case of 20 mL primary eluate volume and 17–25% in the case of 40 mL primary eluate volume) and the yield of 188Re was about 72.4
±
12%. However, the 188W breakthrough was below 10
-
4%. The presence of Ag on 188Re eluate was not determined. However Chattopadhyay et al. [22] demonstrated that the quality of the [Tc
99
m]NaTcO4 concentrated with this procedure complies with the specifications applicable for radiopharmaceutical use.Use of a Single Column of DEAE Cellulose. The third method devised for postelution concentration involved the construction of a generator bed free of chloride ions and elution of the 188Re perrhenate in acetate buffer. This method was based on earlier work with Tc
99
m pertechnetate [23, 24]. The 188Re perrhenate eluted was then trapped on a DEAE cellulose column and eluted in a small volume of saline. Briefly, the generator was washed initially with approximately 200 mL of 1 : 1 vol./vol. 0.025 mol dm−3 NH4OAc: 0.7 mol dm−3 AcOH at ~pH 3, to remove the chloride (Cl−) ions. The effluents were checked for the absence of chloride ions by AgNO3 testing. The generator was then set aside to allow for the growth of 188Re. The 188W/188Re generator was then eluted with 20–25 mL of acidic ammonium acetate [17] and passed through a small anion exchange column of DEAE cellulose (300 mg, 10 mm × 8 mm) to trap 188Re perrhenate. Subsequently, 188Re was recovered in 4 mL of normal saline. The mean practical yield of 188Re in this method was 72.9
±
2.3% (n
=
11). The time required for the concentration process was 15–20 min. The DEAE cellulose column was flushed with 5-6 mL of deionized water to keep the system ready for the next elution.


## 4.1.1. Postelution Concentration of188Re Perrhenate from the Generator

The use of low specific activity188W and of old generators results in low radioactivity concentrations of the eluted 188Re perrhenate, which is often not suitable for radiolabelling of biomolecules. Postelution concentration is essential in such cases. Reports in the literature [7, 18–20] on effective postelution concentration of 188Re using tandem ion exchange columns prompted an exploration of possible means of postelution concentration of the 188Re perrhenate eluate. Postelution concentration of no-carrier-added 188Re perrhenate is based on its selective retention on a tiny anion exchange column and subsequent recovery in a small volume of suitable eluent. This concentration of perrhenate is possible only when the 188Re eluate is free of any other macroscopic anionic species. Three different methods of postelution concentration can be used, as described below.Use of IC-Ag and Sep-Pak Accell Plus QMA Anion Exchanger Column. The technology developed at ORNL uses a Maxi-Clean IC-Ag; Ag+ form cation exchanger cartridge (Alltech Associates, USA) and a Sep-Pak Accell Plus QMA anion exchange cartridge (Waters Corporation, Milford, USA) was used in the first method of postelution concentration, as reported by Guhlke et al. [18–20]. The Maxi-Clean IC-Ag cartridge was conditioned with 5 mL of deionized water. Rhenium-188 eluate obtained from a 188W/188Re generator in 10 mL of normal saline solution was freed of macroscopic Cl
- ions as AgCl precipitate by passage through an Alltech IC-Ag
+ cation exchange cartridge. This 188Re perrhenate eluate free of chloride anion was then passed through the small Sep-Pak Accell Plus QMA anion exchange cartridge (130 mg) to retain the perrhenate and was subsequently reeluted with a very small volume (1 mL) of normal saline. The effluent from the IC-Ag cartridge and a few mL of deionized water used for washing were measured to assess any loss of 188Re activity in the concentration process. Using this method, 188Re yield of 79
±
3% was obtained, with a concentration factor of about 10. The 188W breakthrough was well below 10
-
4% and at times was undetectable. In Figure 4 a schematic drawn of 188Re generator and concentration system with IC-Ag and Sep-Pak Accell Plus QMA anion exchanger column is reported. The complete generator setup consists of an attachment for the generator effluent for flow through an alumina QMA SepPak, which effectively removes low levels of any 188W breakthrough and then through a tandem silver-cation/QMA anion column for concentration of the 188Re eluate to usable radioactive concentration.Figure 4
Schematic drawn of188Re generator and concentration system with of IC-Ag and Sep-Pak Accell Plus QMA anion exchanger column [19].Use of Dowex 1X8 and AgCl Column. A Dowex 1X8 anion exchanger (Cl-form, 200–400 mesh) with a capacity of 3–5 meq/g (Sigma Chemicals) and extra pure AgCl were used in this method of postelution concentration [21]. Between 10 and 12 mg of Dowex 1X8 resin was taken in a 2 mL syringe and placed in a polypropylene tube (~8 mm × 1 mm) with a few millilitres of water. The other end of the tube was packed with glass wool. Both ends of the tube were fitted with miniature barbed polypropylene fittings. Ten millilitres of normal saline solution was passed through the resin column and washed with 5 mL of water (~5 bed volumes of the resin column). Between 1 and 1.5 g of commercial AgCl salt was taken in a glass column (12 mm × 8 mm) with a sintered disc (G-2), closed with a silicon rubber septum, washed with a few millilitres of deionized water, and used. Between 20 and 40 mL of 188Re eluate in normal saline obtained from the generator was passed through the Dowex 1X8 anion exchange column (placed in appropriate shielding) at a flow rate of 2-3 mL/min using controlled vacuum pressure. The activities in the effluent from the Dowex 1 column and in the subsequent washings with a few millilitres of deionized water were measured to assess the adsorption of the perrhenate. These were treated as radioactive waste and appropriately disposed of. The no-carrier-added 188Re perrhenate adsorbed on the tiny anion exchange column was reeluted with 5-6 mL of 0.2 mol dm−3 NaI solution and passed through the AgCl column (1 g, 12 mm × 8 mm) placed in proper shielding (6-7 mm of lead). The effluent of 188Re perrhenate obtained by washing the column with 1.5–1.8 mL of deionized water was collected in a 10 mL vial. This 188Re perrhenate was free of iodide (removed as AgI precipitate) and isotonic with normal saline. In this system, there was a loss of 188Re activity (6–12% in the case of 20 mL primary eluate volume and 17–25% in the case of 40 mL primary eluate volume) and the yield of 188Re was about 72.4
±
12%. However, the 188W breakthrough was below 10
-
4%. The presence of Ag on 188Re eluate was not determined. However Chattopadhyay et al. [22] demonstrated that the quality of the [Tc
99
m]NaTcO4 concentrated with this procedure complies with the specifications applicable for radiopharmaceutical use.Use of a Single Column of DEAE Cellulose. The third method devised for postelution concentration involved the construction of a generator bed free of chloride ions and elution of the 188Re perrhenate in acetate buffer. This method was based on earlier work with Tc
99
m pertechnetate [23, 24]. The 188Re perrhenate eluted was then trapped on a DEAE cellulose column and eluted in a small volume of saline. Briefly, the generator was washed initially with approximately 200 mL of 1 : 1 vol./vol. 0.025 mol dm−3 NH4OAc: 0.7 mol dm−3 AcOH at ~pH 3, to remove the chloride (Cl−) ions. The effluents were checked for the absence of chloride ions by AgNO3 testing. The generator was then set aside to allow for the growth of 188Re. The 188W/188Re generator was then eluted with 20–25 mL of acidic ammonium acetate [17] and passed through a small anion exchange column of DEAE cellulose (300 mg, 10 mm × 8 mm) to trap 188Re perrhenate. Subsequently, 188Re was recovered in 4 mL of normal saline. The mean practical yield of 188Re in this method was 72.9
±
2.3% (n
=
11). The time required for the concentration process was 15–20 min. The DEAE cellulose column was flushed with 5-6 mL of deionized water to keep the system ready for the next elution.


## 4.2. Novel Materials for Column Matrix for Use in Radionuclide Generators

Materials with a higher capacity for tungsten adsorption are of great interest owing to the low specific activities of188W, which necessitates the use of large alumina columns, which in turn leads to low radioactive concentration or to tungsten breakthrough. Dadachov et al. [25] proposed a new concept in which 188W obtained by (n
,
γ) reaction of natural tungsten can be incorporated into a titanium tungstate based gel. Brodskaya et al. [26] have reported a method for chromatographic separation of tungsten and rhenium using organophosphorus resins. A major disadvantage of this process is the radiation degradation of the resin, which is sensitive to radiation damage. Another alternative approach is emerging from research being conducted in Japan [27, 28] in which reactor irradiated molybdenum (i.e., low specific activity) was adsorbed into a zirconium polymer, with higher uptake capacity for 99Mo than for alumina. Chakravarty et al. [29] used nanocrystalline zirconia, a high capacity sorbent material tested for its utility in the preparation of 188W/188Re generators. The structural investigation of the material was carried out using X-ray diffraction, surface area determination, FTIR, and TEM micrograph analysis. Various experimental parameters were optimized to separate 188Re from 188W. The capacity of the material was found to be ~325 mg W/g at the optimum pH. A chromatographic 188W/188Re generator was developed using this material from which >80% of 188Re generated could be eluted with 0.9% saline solution, with high radionuclidic, radiochemical, and chemical purity and appreciably high radioactive concentration suitable for radiopharmaceutical applications. Application of titanium polymer prepared by the polymerization reaction of TiCl4 with isopropyl alcohol for the preparation of a 188W/188Re generator and the elution characteristics of 188Re were studied by Venkatesh et al. [30]. For the synthesis of the polymeric titaniumadsorbent, titanium tetrachloride was mixed with isopropyl alcohol in the ratio of 1 : 2 in a beaker with vigorous stirring. The material obtained was water soluble. To make this into an insoluble polymer, it was heated for 2 h at 150°C. This product was insoluble in water and in most of the mineral acids and alkaline. Thedried cake was ground to a fine powder and sieved with a 25–50 mesh sieve. The distribution ratio (K
d) of 188W in 0.1 mol dm−3 HNO3 was determined at different time intervals and the results indicated that about 45 min is required to reach the equilibration. In all subsequent experiments, the polymer was adsorbed with the 188W activity for 45 min. It was observed that the maximum adsorption of 188W as tungstate on thetitanium polymer occurred at pH 5-6. While both 188W-tungstate and 188Re asperrhenate were adsorbed, when eluted with saline, perrhenate exhibited farless affinity (approximately 600-fold lower) for the matrix. In order to estimate the saturation capacity of the titanium polymer and the concentration at which breakthrough begins, adsorption of 188W on the titanium polymer was determined under dynamic conditions using an ion exchange chromatographic column in the presence of different carrier concentrations of tungsten in the feed. The breakthrough capacity and saturation capacity of tungsten were found to be 62 and 120 mg/g, respectively, indicating that approximately 62 mg of tungsten per gram of titanium polymer can be loaded without any breakthrough being observed. A process demonstration run was carried out with this adsorbent using 1 mCi of 188W, and the elution behavior of the 188Re was studied. It was observed that only about 60–70% of the 188Re on the column could be eluted with saline, but that approximately 92% of this was eluted in the first 3–5 mL. Further study of this material is needed and will be done as the next step in generator development.Monroy-Guzman et al. [31] prepared 188W/188Re generators based on 188W-tungstates and hydroxyapatite. The titanium tungstate gels were synthesized from tetrabutyl orthotitanate and sodium 188W-tungstate solutions. Gels were prepared using 188W-tungstate solutions of four different pH values (in the range of 1.95–12) at a Ti : W molar ratio of 1 : 1. The gels were stirred and dried for 2.5 h at 80°C and then placed on polyethylene columns. The zirconium tungstate gels were prepared from zirconium ethoxide solutions and sodium 188W-tungstate solutions following the process described above. Gels were prepared using 188W-tungstate solutions of four different pH values at a Zr : W molar ratio of 1 : 1. The columns were washed with 50 mL of 0.9% NaCl and were eluted every three days for a period of three months. They found that the pH level of the 188W-tungstate solution used for the preparation of the titanium and zirconium 188W-tungstate based generators influence the efficiency and the 188W breakthrough of the generators. Both parameters decreased when the gels were synthesized with more acidic 188W-tungstate solutions. The best 188Re elution efficiency (~73%) was obtained from the titanium 188W-tungstate based generators; however, the lowest 188W breakthrough (0.3%) was obtained from the zirconium 188W-tungstate based generators. The 188Re radiochemical purity obtained from both types of generator is less in the gels prepared with basic 188W-tungstate solutions (83–87%) than in those prepared with acidic 188W-tungstate solution, which had a 188Re radiochemical purity of 100%.Theα
W
/
Re separation factors shown in Figure 5 indicate that tungsten and rhenium can be readily separated with 0.9% NaCl solutions at pH levels below 7.5. Based on these data, hydroxyapatite based generators were constructed using four 0.9% NaCl solutions at pH 5.5, 6.0, 6.3, and 6.5 (series A), and using hydroxyapatite particles of three sizes (series B). Results on the performance of these generators are shown in Figures 6 and 7. For all the 188Re eluates obtained in both series, the pH was 6.5, the phosphate concentration was greater than 1000 ppm, and the radiochemical purity was greater than 90%. The lowest 188W breakthrough and highest average elution volumes were obtained in the generators eluted with 0.9% NaCl solution at pH 6.5 and with hydroxyapatite particles between 38 and 75 μm in size. The efficiency of the 188W/188Re generators decreased with the pH value of the NaCl solution, but the particle size of the hydroxyapatite appeared to have no significant effect. The mean efficiencies obtained were about 65%, whereas the elution volumes and 188W breakthrough values decreased with a decrease of the hydroxyapatite particle size and with an increase of the pH value of the NaCl solution. The generators in series A and B showed that phosphate ions are released during the elution of 188Re, leading to the proposal to wash the generators after elution with 0.9% NaCl solutions, using 0.01 mol dm−3 CaCl2 or 0.004 mol dm−3 NaH2PO4 solutions, in order to avoid the dissolution of hydroxyapatite.Figure 5
Separation factors of tungsten and rhenium (α
W
/
Re) on hydroxyapatite [31].Figure 6
Performance of the hydroxyapatite based188W/188Re generators as a function of the 0.9% NaCl solution pH (series A) [31].Figure 7
Performance of the hydroxyapatite based188W/188Re generators as a function of the hydroxyapatite particle size (series B) [31].A third series of generators (series C) was then fabricated and evaluated using the method previously described. The performance of these generators as a function of the eluent is shown in Figure8. Washing the generators with 0.01 mol dm−3 CaCl2 or 0.004 mol dm−3 NaH2PO4 solutions after elution with 0.9% NaCl solutions caused an increase of the 188W breakthrough in the 188Re eluate.Figure 8
Performance of the hydroxyapatite based188W/188Re generators as a function of the eluent (series C) [31].However, there was no apparent effect on the188Re elution efficiency, the eluate pH, or the radiochemical purity. The presence of phosphate ions in the 188Re eluates shows that the hydroxyapatite continues to dissolve.


## 5.188Re-Radiopharmaceuticals

### 5.1. Reduction of the Tetraoxo Rhenium-188 Anion

Rhenium-188 is aβ-emitting nuclide that is currently attracting much interest as a potential candidate for therapeutic applications because of its useful nuclear properties and availability. Another important advantage of employing 188Re-radiopharmaceuticals comes from the easy availability of this radionuclide, which is produced through a transportable generator system under the chemical form of the tetraoxo perrhenate anion [188ReO4]− in physiological solution. This situation, therefore, parallels completely that of the nuclide Tc
99
m, which is obtained through the 99Mo/Tc
99
m generator system in the form of [
Tc
99m
O
4
]
-, which always constitutes the starting compound for preparing Tc
99
m-radiopharmaceuticals. Likewise [188ReO4]− is the ubiquitous starting compound for the preparation of 188Re-radiopharmaceuticals. However, since technetium and rhenium belong to the same group 7 of the transition series, the similarities between Tc
99
m and 188Re radiopharmaceuticals are even more pronounced. In fact, owing to lanthanide contraction, technetium and rhenium have almost identical ionic radii. This indicates that, when these two elements form analogous complexes having exactly the same chemical structure and stability and differ only in the metal center, these species should exhibit the same “in vivo” biological behavior. Despite this, there exists a fundamental difference between the values of the standard reduction potentials of the redox reactions involving technetium and rhenium compounds. On average, E
° of a technetium process is 200 mV higher than that of the corresponding rhenium process. This implies that reduction of [188ReO4]− should be much more difficult than that of [
Tc
99m
O
4
]
-. As a consequence, the methods utilized for the preparation of 188Re-radiopharmaceuticals cannot simply follow routes employed for obtaining Tc
99
m complexes, and usually more drastic conditions are required [32].This fact always constitutes a fundamental obstacle for the development of new188Re-radiopharmaceuticals. A solution to this problem has been proposed [33]. This approach was inspired by a general phenomenon in coordination chemistry that goes under the name of “expansion of the coordination sphere.” This phenomenon indicates a redox process in which the metal undergoes a concomitant expansion of its coordination arrangement in going from the initial to the final oxidation state. For instance, in all radiopharmaceutical preparations involving [188ReO4]−, the starting Re(VII) center should be converted from the tetraoxo anion to the final complex which, usually, has a five- or six-coordination arrangement. The molecular geometry, therefore, should undergo a sudden change from tetrahedral to a more expanded square pyramidal or octahedral geometry. This geometrical process has a great impact on the standard reduction potential of the redox reaction and, generally, its effect determines a decrease of the E
° value. It follows, therefore, that if the reduction process was accomplished without the occurrence of such dramatic, geometrical changes, their detrimental influence on E
° would be completely cancelled. This result could be easily achieved by first transforming the tetrahedral perrhenate anion into some intermediate Re(VII) complex having a more expanded coordination sphere, by simple substitution of the oxo-groups with some suitable ligand, but without changing the starting metal oxidation state. In this way, the reduction process yielding the final product would take place between this intermediate Re(VII) compound, and not from the tetraoxo anion. It was found that oxalate ions (C
2
O
4
2
-) were excellent ligands for producing intermediate Re(VII) complexes possessing an expanded octahedral geometry [34].Consequently, addition of this species in preparations involving the reaction of [188ReO4]− with SnCl2, in the presence of some appropriate coordinating ligand, dramatically improved the yield of formation of the final radiopharmaceutical.The first application of the above mentioned strategy was carried out for preparing the complex [188ReO(DMSA)2] (DMSA = dianionic dimercaptosuccinic acid) [33]. This complex had been previously obtained under strong conditions, by heating [188ReO4]− at high temperature for a prolonged time, and in the presence of a large amount of SnCl2 as a reductant. Such conditions are completely unsuitable for any “in vivo” clinical study in humans. However, addition of oxalate ions changed dramatically the course of this reaction.


### 5.2. Nitrido Rhenium-188 Complexes

The oxalate-based approach has been subsequently utilized to develop the first efficient procedure for producing the [188Re≡N]2+ core from [188ReO4]−, at tracer level and under physiological conditions [34]. For this purpose, the method originally developed for the tracer-level preparation of the analogous [T
99m
c
≡N]2+ was employed [35]. This method was based on the reaction of [
Tc
99m
O
4
]
- with DTCZ and SnCl2 to afford a mixture of intermediate Tc
99
m complexes all characterized by the presence of a terminal Tc≡N group. In this procedure, the species DTCZ played the role of an efficient donor of nitrido nitrogen groups (N3−), and SnCl2 was used as reducing agent. After addition of a suitable dithiocarbamate ligand (L), the intermediate mixture was suddenly converted into a single product corresponding to the complex [Tc
99
m(N)(L)2] [36]. When a similar procedure was applied to the preparation of the analogous nitrido 188Re complexes starting from generator-produced [188ReO4]−, no formation of the final products was obtained. This finding was in close agreement with results obtained in a similar attempt to prepare 186Re nitrido complexes using various derivatives of DTCZ and other sources of N3− groups, which completely failed to give the desired compounds [37]. However, addition of sodium oxalate dramatically changed the outcome of the reaction, and the complexes [188Re(N)(L)2] were obtained with a final yield > 95%. These results clearly suggest that the key step in the production of the compounds [188Re(N)(L)2] was the reduction of the 188Re perrhenate anion. Biological experiments carried out in rats showed that the biodistribution of [188Re(N)(L)2] complexes parallels exactly that observed for the analogous Tc
99
m complexes [Tc
99
m(N)(L)2]. In particular, heart was one of the most important target organs. This fact clearly demonstrates that, inside a matching pair of technetium complexes possessing identical molecular structure and stability toward “in vivo” redox reactions, the corresponding radiocompounds always exhibit the same biological behavior.


### 5.3. Rhenium-188 Lipiodol

Various attempts at labelling lipiodol for the treatment of hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) [38] with 188Re have been proposed, but most are exceedingly complicated and difficult to apply under controlled conditions. A simple and elegant approach involves the dissolution of a strongly lipophilic 188Re compound into lipiodol, which constitutes a highly hydrophobic material [39].Using this strategy,188Re would remain tightly retained as a consequence of the strong hydrophobic interaction between the lipophilic metal complex and the fatty oil. A key requirement of this approach is the need to produce, in high yield, a 188Re complex that possesses sufficient stability to be dissolved in lipiodol and sufficient lipophilicity to remain firmly trapped in this substance. An example of the application of this labelling method has been reported [40–45]. A series of oxo-complexes of 188Re was prepared by reacting [188ReO4]− with derivatives of the tetradentate ligand 3,3,10,10-tetramethyl-1,2-dithia-5,8-diazacyclodecane and then mixed with lipiodol. However, the final labelling yield was low and the 188Re complex was not stably retained in hepatoma. This result reflects the difficulty in obtaining 188Re complexes in satisfactory yield and the intrinsic instability of oxo-rhenium complexes. Following the same labelling strategy, an efficient procedure for labelling lipiodol with 188Re, at tracer level and under sterile and pyrogen-free conditions was developed, and the resulting radiolabelled product has been successfully employed in the treatment of a number of HCC patients [38]. This labelling procedure was based on the preliminary preparation of the highly lipophilic complex bis(diethyldithiocarbamato) nitrido [188Re] rhenium (188ReN-DEDC) carried out using a two-vial, freeze-dried kit formulation. This complex was, subsequently, mixed with lipiodol to yield the final radiopharmaceutical. The whole preparation involves different steps and complex manipulation of high-activity samples that dramatically increases radiation exposure of the operator, particularly in routine treatment of HCC patients. To overcome this problem, an automated system for the remote controlled preparation of 188Re-lipiodol using this labeling method had been developed. This synthesis module [46] (Figure 9) was designed to accommodate the two-vial kit formulation developed previously for manually conducting the preparation of 188Re-lipiodol in a hospital radiopharmacy. Through this procedure, the hydrophobic lipiodol was used as a solvent for solubilising the highly lipophilic radiocompound 188ReN-DEDC that, in turn, remained strongly trapped into the organic phase. Specifically, the two-vial kit formulation allowed the high-activity preparation of 188ReN-DEDC. The freeze-dried kit was, successively, produced at the Institute of Isotopes in Budapest, Hungary, following current regulatory requirements. The preparation of the complex 188ReN-DEDC was relatively simple as it involved mixing of [188ReO4]− with reagents in vial A and glacial acetic acid to yield the intermediate [188Re≡N]2+ core. This group was, then, converted into the final complex 188ReN-DEDC by addition of the content of vial B to vial A. Results showed that this preparation afforded 188ReN-DEDC in high yield (>95%). However, the critical step exposing the operator to the highest radiation burden is when withdrawal of the supernatant aqueous layer was performed by means of a syringe. As this operation had to be carried out after labelling, it required the manipulation of highly radioactive samples. It was found that the automated process was an ideal solution to overcome this important drawback. In the automated system, the content of reconstituted vials A and B were transferred to a reactor vial (R) where the preparation of the final complex 188ReN-DEDC was obtained by heating at 80°C. Most importantly, the manual separation was replaced by a chromatographic procedure carried out by passing the reaction solution pumped out of vial A through a C18 Sep- Pak cartridge onto which the complex 188ReN-DEDC was quantitatively retained. This allowed the elimination of the aqueous solvent and of any residual [188Re] perrhenate. Since [188ReO4]− is a highly hydrophilic substance that cannot be dissolved by nonpolar solvents, it constitutes an undesired contaminant in the final radiopharmaceutical that may cause release of activity from the target and uptake in other nontarget organs, particularly in the thyroid gland. Even if the complex 188ReN-DEDC formed with high RCP, the purification step always ensures that all polar radioactive impurities can be efficiently separated from the reaction bulk. Thus, their complete removal appears as a sharp improvement with respect to the nonautomated preparation. The lipophilic complex was, subsequently, recovered by eluting the cartridge with absolute ethanol and then sterilized by passing the resulting solution through a 0.22 μm filter before collecting it into the final recovering vial C. Lipiodol was finally introduced into vial C after evaporating ethanol by short heating under a nitrogen stream, thus causing the complete dissolution of the radioactive complex. The radiochemical yield and chemical identity of 188ReN-DEDC were checked by HPLC chromatography after preparation in the reactor vial R, and after evaporation of ethanol from vial C (Figure 9). Results showed that the complex was produced in high yield (>95%) and that it was recovered unaltered from vial C. Current advantages include a reduced operator assistance during the production process with a concomitant dramatic reduction of radiation exposure, and the possibility to afford high activity samples of 188Re-lipiodol (>5 GBq), thus allowing the daily treatment of a relatively large number of HCC patients. Whole-body γ-imaging of HCC patients within 1–4 h of intrahepatic arterial administration of 188Re-labeled lipiodol demonstrated excellent uptake in the lesion without significant activity in the gut and lungs [33]. Stable retention of activity in hepatoma was revealed at 20 h after administration with minimal increase in colonic activity and some uptake in the spleen. In particular, no lung activity was observed in any patient as opposed to treatment of hepatocellular carcinoma with 131I-lipiodol where lung uptake approaches 35% of administrated activity.Figure 9
Flowchart illustrating the automated system for the preparation of188Re-lipiodol [46].


### 5.4. New Methods for the Preparation of Rhenium-188 Nitride Radiopharmaceuticals

Recently a novel procedure for the preparation of nitride188ReN radiopharmaceuticals was reported [47]. The novel HO2C-PEG600-DTCZ nitrido nitrogen atom donor for the preparation of 188Re radiopharmaceuticals containing a metal nitrogen-multiple bond HO2C-PEG600-DTCZ was obtained by conjugation ofN-methyl-S-methyl dithiocarbazate [H2N–N (CH3)–C(=S)SCH3, HDTCZ] with polyethylene glycol 600 (PEG600). Asymmetrical heterocomplexes of the type [188Re(N)(PNP)(B)]0/+ (PNP = diphosphine ligands, B = DBODC, DEDC, NSH, H2OS, CysNAc, HDTCZ) and symmetrical nitride compounds of the type [188Re (N)(L)2] (L = DEDC, DPDC) have been prepared in high yield by using the newly designed nitride nitrogen atom donor HO2C-PEG600-DTCZ. In Figure 10 is reported the chemical structure of PNP, L, and B ligands. A two-step procedure was applied for preparing the above symmetrical and asymmetrical complexes. The first step involved the preliminary formation of a mixture of nitride 188Re precursors, which contained the [188Re≡N]2+ core, through reduction of generator eluted 188Re-perrhenate with tin(II) chloride in the presence of HO2C-PEG600-DTCZ. In the second step, the intermediate mixture was converted in either the final mixed asymmetrical complex by the simultaneous addition of diphosphine ligand and the suitable bidentate ligand B, or in the final symmetrical complex by the only addition of the bidentate ligand L. It was also demonstrated that the novel water soluble nitride nitrogen atom donor HO2C-PEG600-DTCZ did not show coordinating properties toward the 188Re≡N core.Figure 10
Chemical structure of PNP, L, and B ligands [47].More recently [48] a new molecular metallic fragment for labeling biologically active molecules with Tc
99
m and 188Re is described. This system is composed of a combination of tridentate π-donor and monodentate π-acceptor ligands bound to a [M≡N]2+ group (M = Tc
99
m, 188Re) in a pseudo square-pyramidal geometry (Figure 11). A simple structural model of the new metallic fragment was obtained by reacting the ligand 2,2′-iminodiethanethiol [H2NS2 = NH (CH2CH2SH)2] and monodentate tertiary phosphines with the [M≡N]2+ group (M
=
Tc
99
m, 188Re). In the resulting complexes (dubbed “3
+
1 complexes”), the tridentate ligand binds the [M≡N]2+ core through the two deprotonated, negatively charged, thiol sulfur atoms, and the neutral, protonated, amine nitrogen atom. The residual fourth position of the five-coordinated arrangement is occupied by a phosphine ligand. The chemical identity of these models Tc
99
m and 188Re compounds was established by comparison with the chromatographic properties of the corresponding complexes obtained at the macroscopic level with the long-lived Tc
99
g and natural Re isotopes. The investigation was further extended to comprise a series of ligands formed by simple combinations of two basic amino acids or pseudoamino acids to yield potential tridentate chelating systems having [S, N, S] and [N, N, S] as sets of π-donor atoms. Labeling yields andin vitrostability were investigated using different ancillary ligands [48]. Results showed that SNS-type ligands afforded the highest labeling yields and the most robust 3 + 1 nitrido complexes with both Tc
99
m and 188Re. Thus, this new chelating system can be conveniently employed for labeling peptides and other biomolecules with the [M≡N]2+ group.Figure 11
Schematic drawing of the molecular structure of “3
+
1” nitrido complexes (X = S, N; Y = monodentate ligand; M
=
Tc
99
m, 188Re) [48].


## 5.1. Reduction of the Tetraoxo Rhenium-188 Anion

Rhenium-188 is aβ-emitting nuclide that is currently attracting much interest as a potential candidate for therapeutic applications because of its useful nuclear properties and availability. Another important advantage of employing 188Re-radiopharmaceuticals comes from the easy availability of this radionuclide, which is produced through a transportable generator system under the chemical form of the tetraoxo perrhenate anion [188ReO4]− in physiological solution. This situation, therefore, parallels completely that of the nuclide Tc
99
m, which is obtained through the 99Mo/Tc
99
m generator system in the form of [
Tc
99m
O
4
]
-, which always constitutes the starting compound for preparing Tc
99
m-radiopharmaceuticals. Likewise [188ReO4]− is the ubiquitous starting compound for the preparation of 188Re-radiopharmaceuticals. However, since technetium and rhenium belong to the same group 7 of the transition series, the similarities between Tc
99
m and 188Re radiopharmaceuticals are even more pronounced. In fact, owing to lanthanide contraction, technetium and rhenium have almost identical ionic radii. This indicates that, when these two elements form analogous complexes having exactly the same chemical structure and stability and differ only in the metal center, these species should exhibit the same “in vivo” biological behavior. Despite this, there exists a fundamental difference between the values of the standard reduction potentials of the redox reactions involving technetium and rhenium compounds. On average, E
° of a technetium process is 200 mV higher than that of the corresponding rhenium process. This implies that reduction of [188ReO4]− should be much more difficult than that of [
Tc
99m
O
4
]
-. As a consequence, the methods utilized for the preparation of 188Re-radiopharmaceuticals cannot simply follow routes employed for obtaining Tc
99
m complexes, and usually more drastic conditions are required [32].This fact always constitutes a fundamental obstacle for the development of new188Re-radiopharmaceuticals. A solution to this problem has been proposed [33]. This approach was inspired by a general phenomenon in coordination chemistry that goes under the name of “expansion of the coordination sphere.” This phenomenon indicates a redox process in which the metal undergoes a concomitant expansion of its coordination arrangement in going from the initial to the final oxidation state. For instance, in all radiopharmaceutical preparations involving [188ReO4]−, the starting Re(VII) center should be converted from the tetraoxo anion to the final complex which, usually, has a five- or six-coordination arrangement. The molecular geometry, therefore, should undergo a sudden change from tetrahedral to a more expanded square pyramidal or octahedral geometry. This geometrical process has a great impact on the standard reduction potential of the redox reaction and, generally, its effect determines a decrease of the E
° value. It follows, therefore, that if the reduction process was accomplished without the occurrence of such dramatic, geometrical changes, their detrimental influence on E
° would be completely cancelled. This result could be easily achieved by first transforming the tetrahedral perrhenate anion into some intermediate Re(VII) complex having a more expanded coordination sphere, by simple substitution of the oxo-groups with some suitable ligand, but without changing the starting metal oxidation state. In this way, the reduction process yielding the final product would take place between this intermediate Re(VII) compound, and not from the tetraoxo anion. It was found that oxalate ions (C
2
O
4
2
-) were excellent ligands for producing intermediate Re(VII) complexes possessing an expanded octahedral geometry [34].Consequently, addition of this species in preparations involving the reaction of [188ReO4]− with SnCl2, in the presence of some appropriate coordinating ligand, dramatically improved the yield of formation of the final radiopharmaceutical.The first application of the above mentioned strategy was carried out for preparing the complex [188ReO(DMSA)2] (DMSA = dianionic dimercaptosuccinic acid) [33]. This complex had been previously obtained under strong conditions, by heating [188ReO4]− at high temperature for a prolonged time, and in the presence of a large amount of SnCl2 as a reductant. Such conditions are completely unsuitable for any “in vivo” clinical study in humans. However, addition of oxalate ions changed dramatically the course of this reaction.


## 5.2. Nitrido Rhenium-188 Complexes

The oxalate-based approach has been subsequently utilized to develop the first efficient procedure for producing the [188Re≡N]2+ core from [188ReO4]−, at tracer level and under physiological conditions [34]. For this purpose, the method originally developed for the tracer-level preparation of the analogous [T
99m
c
≡N]2+ was employed [35]. This method was based on the reaction of [
Tc
99m
O
4
]
- with DTCZ and SnCl2 to afford a mixture of intermediate Tc
99
m complexes all characterized by the presence of a terminal Tc≡N group. In this procedure, the species DTCZ played the role of an efficient donor of nitrido nitrogen groups (N3−), and SnCl2 was used as reducing agent. After addition of a suitable dithiocarbamate ligand (L), the intermediate mixture was suddenly converted into a single product corresponding to the complex [Tc
99
m(N)(L)2] [36]. When a similar procedure was applied to the preparation of the analogous nitrido 188Re complexes starting from generator-produced [188ReO4]−, no formation of the final products was obtained. This finding was in close agreement with results obtained in a similar attempt to prepare 186Re nitrido complexes using various derivatives of DTCZ and other sources of N3− groups, which completely failed to give the desired compounds [37]. However, addition of sodium oxalate dramatically changed the outcome of the reaction, and the complexes [188Re(N)(L)2] were obtained with a final yield > 95%. These results clearly suggest that the key step in the production of the compounds [188Re(N)(L)2] was the reduction of the 188Re perrhenate anion. Biological experiments carried out in rats showed that the biodistribution of [188Re(N)(L)2] complexes parallels exactly that observed for the analogous Tc
99
m complexes [Tc
99
m(N)(L)2]. In particular, heart was one of the most important target organs. This fact clearly demonstrates that, inside a matching pair of technetium complexes possessing identical molecular structure and stability toward “in vivo” redox reactions, the corresponding radiocompounds always exhibit the same biological behavior.


## 5.3. Rhenium-188 Lipiodol

Various attempts at labelling lipiodol for the treatment of hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) [38] with 188Re have been proposed, but most are exceedingly complicated and difficult to apply under controlled conditions. A simple and elegant approach involves the dissolution of a strongly lipophilic 188Re compound into lipiodol, which constitutes a highly hydrophobic material [39].Using this strategy,188Re would remain tightly retained as a consequence of the strong hydrophobic interaction between the lipophilic metal complex and the fatty oil. A key requirement of this approach is the need to produce, in high yield, a 188Re complex that possesses sufficient stability to be dissolved in lipiodol and sufficient lipophilicity to remain firmly trapped in this substance. An example of the application of this labelling method has been reported [40–45]. A series of oxo-complexes of 188Re was prepared by reacting [188ReO4]− with derivatives of the tetradentate ligand 3,3,10,10-tetramethyl-1,2-dithia-5,8-diazacyclodecane and then mixed with lipiodol. However, the final labelling yield was low and the 188Re complex was not stably retained in hepatoma. This result reflects the difficulty in obtaining 188Re complexes in satisfactory yield and the intrinsic instability of oxo-rhenium complexes. Following the same labelling strategy, an efficient procedure for labelling lipiodol with 188Re, at tracer level and under sterile and pyrogen-free conditions was developed, and the resulting radiolabelled product has been successfully employed in the treatment of a number of HCC patients [38]. This labelling procedure was based on the preliminary preparation of the highly lipophilic complex bis(diethyldithiocarbamato) nitrido [188Re] rhenium (188ReN-DEDC) carried out using a two-vial, freeze-dried kit formulation. This complex was, subsequently, mixed with lipiodol to yield the final radiopharmaceutical. The whole preparation involves different steps and complex manipulation of high-activity samples that dramatically increases radiation exposure of the operator, particularly in routine treatment of HCC patients. To overcome this problem, an automated system for the remote controlled preparation of 188Re-lipiodol using this labeling method had been developed. This synthesis module [46] (Figure 9) was designed to accommodate the two-vial kit formulation developed previously for manually conducting the preparation of 188Re-lipiodol in a hospital radiopharmacy. Through this procedure, the hydrophobic lipiodol was used as a solvent for solubilising the highly lipophilic radiocompound 188ReN-DEDC that, in turn, remained strongly trapped into the organic phase. Specifically, the two-vial kit formulation allowed the high-activity preparation of 188ReN-DEDC. The freeze-dried kit was, successively, produced at the Institute of Isotopes in Budapest, Hungary, following current regulatory requirements. The preparation of the complex 188ReN-DEDC was relatively simple as it involved mixing of [188ReO4]− with reagents in vial A and glacial acetic acid to yield the intermediate [188Re≡N]2+ core. This group was, then, converted into the final complex 188ReN-DEDC by addition of the content of vial B to vial A. Results showed that this preparation afforded 188ReN-DEDC in high yield (>95%). However, the critical step exposing the operator to the highest radiation burden is when withdrawal of the supernatant aqueous layer was performed by means of a syringe. As this operation had to be carried out after labelling, it required the manipulation of highly radioactive samples. It was found that the automated process was an ideal solution to overcome this important drawback. In the automated system, the content of reconstituted vials A and B were transferred to a reactor vial (R) where the preparation of the final complex 188ReN-DEDC was obtained by heating at 80°C. Most importantly, the manual separation was replaced by a chromatographic procedure carried out by passing the reaction solution pumped out of vial A through a C18 Sep- Pak cartridge onto which the complex 188ReN-DEDC was quantitatively retained. This allowed the elimination of the aqueous solvent and of any residual [188Re] perrhenate. Since [188ReO4]− is a highly hydrophilic substance that cannot be dissolved by nonpolar solvents, it constitutes an undesired contaminant in the final radiopharmaceutical that may cause release of activity from the target and uptake in other nontarget organs, particularly in the thyroid gland. Even if the complex 188ReN-DEDC formed with high RCP, the purification step always ensures that all polar radioactive impurities can be efficiently separated from the reaction bulk. Thus, their complete removal appears as a sharp improvement with respect to the nonautomated preparation. The lipophilic complex was, subsequently, recovered by eluting the cartridge with absolute ethanol and then sterilized by passing the resulting solution through a 0.22 μm filter before collecting it into the final recovering vial C. Lipiodol was finally introduced into vial C after evaporating ethanol by short heating under a nitrogen stream, thus causing the complete dissolution of the radioactive complex. The radiochemical yield and chemical identity of 188ReN-DEDC were checked by HPLC chromatography after preparation in the reactor vial R, and after evaporation of ethanol from vial C (Figure 9). Results showed that the complex was produced in high yield (>95%) and that it was recovered unaltered from vial C. Current advantages include a reduced operator assistance during the production process with a concomitant dramatic reduction of radiation exposure, and the possibility to afford high activity samples of 188Re-lipiodol (>5 GBq), thus allowing the daily treatment of a relatively large number of HCC patients. Whole-body γ-imaging of HCC patients within 1–4 h of intrahepatic arterial administration of 188Re-labeled lipiodol demonstrated excellent uptake in the lesion without significant activity in the gut and lungs [33]. Stable retention of activity in hepatoma was revealed at 20 h after administration with minimal increase in colonic activity and some uptake in the spleen. In particular, no lung activity was observed in any patient as opposed to treatment of hepatocellular carcinoma with 131I-lipiodol where lung uptake approaches 35% of administrated activity.Figure 9
Flowchart illustrating the automated system for the preparation of188Re-lipiodol [46].


## 5.4. New Methods for the Preparation of Rhenium-188 Nitride Radiopharmaceuticals

Recently a novel procedure for the preparation of nitride188ReN radiopharmaceuticals was reported [47]. The novel HO2C-PEG600-DTCZ nitrido nitrogen atom donor for the preparation of 188Re radiopharmaceuticals containing a metal nitrogen-multiple bond HO2C-PEG600-DTCZ was obtained by conjugation ofN-methyl-S-methyl dithiocarbazate [H2N–N (CH3)–C(=S)SCH3, HDTCZ] with polyethylene glycol 600 (PEG600). Asymmetrical heterocomplexes of the type [188Re(N)(PNP)(B)]0/+ (PNP = diphosphine ligands, B = DBODC, DEDC, NSH, H2OS, CysNAc, HDTCZ) and symmetrical nitride compounds of the type [188Re (N)(L)2] (L = DEDC, DPDC) have been prepared in high yield by using the newly designed nitride nitrogen atom donor HO2C-PEG600-DTCZ. In Figure 10 is reported the chemical structure of PNP, L, and B ligands. A two-step procedure was applied for preparing the above symmetrical and asymmetrical complexes. The first step involved the preliminary formation of a mixture of nitride 188Re precursors, which contained the [188Re≡N]2+ core, through reduction of generator eluted 188Re-perrhenate with tin(II) chloride in the presence of HO2C-PEG600-DTCZ. In the second step, the intermediate mixture was converted in either the final mixed asymmetrical complex by the simultaneous addition of diphosphine ligand and the suitable bidentate ligand B, or in the final symmetrical complex by the only addition of the bidentate ligand L. It was also demonstrated that the novel water soluble nitride nitrogen atom donor HO2C-PEG600-DTCZ did not show coordinating properties toward the 188Re≡N core.Figure 10
Chemical structure of PNP, L, and B ligands [47].More recently [48] a new molecular metallic fragment for labeling biologically active molecules with Tc
99
m and 188Re is described. This system is composed of a combination of tridentate π-donor and monodentate π-acceptor ligands bound to a [M≡N]2+ group (M = Tc
99
m, 188Re) in a pseudo square-pyramidal geometry (Figure 11). A simple structural model of the new metallic fragment was obtained by reacting the ligand 2,2′-iminodiethanethiol [H2NS2 = NH (CH2CH2SH)2] and monodentate tertiary phosphines with the [M≡N]2+ group (M
=
Tc
99
m, 188Re). In the resulting complexes (dubbed “3
+
1 complexes”), the tridentate ligand binds the [M≡N]2+ core through the two deprotonated, negatively charged, thiol sulfur atoms, and the neutral, protonated, amine nitrogen atom. The residual fourth position of the five-coordinated arrangement is occupied by a phosphine ligand. The chemical identity of these models Tc
99
m and 188Re compounds was established by comparison with the chromatographic properties of the corresponding complexes obtained at the macroscopic level with the long-lived Tc
99
g and natural Re isotopes. The investigation was further extended to comprise a series of ligands formed by simple combinations of two basic amino acids or pseudoamino acids to yield potential tridentate chelating systems having [S, N, S] and [N, N, S] as sets of π-donor atoms. Labeling yields andin vitrostability were investigated using different ancillary ligands [48]. Results showed that SNS-type ligands afforded the highest labeling yields and the most robust 3 + 1 nitrido complexes with both Tc
99
m and 188Re. Thus, this new chelating system can be conveniently employed for labeling peptides and other biomolecules with the [M≡N]2+ group.Figure 11
Schematic drawing of the molecular structure of “3
+
1” nitrido complexes (X = S, N; Y = monodentate ligand; M
=
Tc
99
m, 188Re) [48].


## 6. Conclusion

The availability of188W/188Re generators and the use of high specific activity 188Re for a variety of important therapeutic applications in nuclear medicine and oncology still continues to be of widespread interest. The attractive radionuclidic and chemical properties of 188Re, and the possibility of obtaining 188Re in-house and on demand make this generator system ideal for many applications. Therefore the development of new chemical strategies allows to obtain in very high yield and in physiological condition 188Re-radiopharmaceutical which gives a new attractive prospective to the development of new Radiopharmaceuticals for therapy.



---

*Source: 529406-2014-05-08.xml*