# Corrosion of WC-VC-Co Hardmetal in Neutral Chloride Containing Media

Authors: C. N. Machio; D. S. Konadu; J. H. Potgieter; S. Potgieter-Vermaak; J. Van der Merwe
Journal: ISRN Corrosion
 (2013)

---

## Abstract

The effect of varying VC content on the corrosion behavior of WC-10 wt% Co hardmetals in sodium chloride (NaCl) and synthetic mine water (SMW) solutions has been investigated using anodic polarization scans and surface analytical methods. It is shown that the polarization behavior is active-pseudopassive in NaCl and active in SMW regardless of the VC content, while the corrosion resistance is poorer and independent of VC content in NaCl but better at high VC contents in SMW. The corrosion behavior of samples is explained using the effect of VC on the chemical composition of the binder.


---

## Body

## 1. Introduction

Corrosion is an important surface degradation process in some, if not all, applications of tungsten-carbide-(WC-) cobalt- (Co-) based hardmetals. Applications like tools for machining of metals [1] and for wear resistance in the mining industry [1] expose the WC-Co to fluids that can be corrosive, leading to a reduced useful life. The Co binder is the least corrosion resistant constituent [2], and efforts to improve WC-Co corrosion resistance have involved altering the chemical composition of the binder by introducing more corrosion resistant elements. Nickel [3], and chromium [4] especially, and recently, ruthenium [5] have been shown to markedly improve the corrosion resistance of WC-Co-based hardmetals.The corrosion resistance of WC-Co can also be improved by some transition carbides, which have been usually added in small amounts. Chromium carbide (Cr3C2), for example, added to WC-Co in amounts of about 0.5 wt.% markedly improves corrosion resistance [6]. The effect of vanadium carbide (VC) has not been as straight forward as that of chromium carbide. Earlier studies [6] found small additions of VC to WC-Co had at best a neutral effect on the corrosion resistance. Subsequent studies by other researchers, using higher amounts of VC have indicated otherwise. For example, studies in hydrochloric and sulphuric acids have indicated that 10 wt% VC improves the corrosion resistance of high Co content WC-Co [7]. This result has been confirmed by the current authors [8] who have shown that the corrosion resistance, determined from the corrosion current density at the free corrosion potential, increases with increasing VC content. The current article is extending the corrosion study of the materials to neutral chloride electrolytes to determine whether the improved corrosion resistance is solution independent. It has happened that observations made on the corrosion of WC-Co in acidic electrolytes do not appear to be reproduced in tests that use neutral chloride containing solutions [9].


## 2. Experimental

### 2.1. Materials

The nominal composition (wt.%) of the test materials and their magnetic saturation levels are given in Table1. The microstructures of the specimens are fully described elsewhere [8]. The VC content took values of 0, 0.4, 10, and 27 wt%. However, the VC, at the 10 and 27 wt.% content, occurred as the double carbide (W,V)C because WC dissolves in VC during sintering [10]. For easier referencing, the samples will be referred to using their VC content. The target binder content was 10 wt% Co for all the specimens, but samples 10 VC and 27 VC had 12 and 11 wt% Co, respectively. Comparison between the samples is still possible because the effect of cobalt content on the corrosion behavior of WC-Co hardmetals is known. For example, it is known that the current densities at (free) open circuit potential are a function of Co content, and in acidic solutions, the current densities increase with increasing Co content [11].Table 1
Nominal chemical composition and magnetic properties of test specimens.
Specimen
Approx. vol% Co
Magnetic saturation(4πσ) (G cm3 g−1)
WC-10Co
16
172
WC-0.4VC-10Co
16
185
WC-10VC-12Co
17
230
WC-27VC-11Co
13
194The magnetic saturation of the specimens increased with the introduction of VC and with Co content (Table1). Cobalt is the magnetic phase and the higher values with higher Co contents are expected. The magnetic saturation provides a measure of the solute content of the binder and is a quick technique for determining the quality of sintered WC-Co [12]. Generally, and within limits, the magnetic saturation decreases linearly with an increase of W content of the binder [13, 14].


### 2.2. Electrochemical Measurements

Electrochemical measurements were carried out using the conventional setup of a three-electrode cell in which the test specimen is the working electrode, an inert material, in the case here, graphite rod, is the counter electrode (CE) and a reference electrode against which all potentials are reported. The reference electrode used was a silver/silver chloride electrode (SSE) (in saturated KCl) and was connected to the test cell via a Luggin probe capillary. All tests were done at room temperature and the electrolytes were neither deaerated nor aerated during testing.The electrolytes used were 1 M sodium chloride (NaCl) and synthetic mine water (SMW) whose composition is given in Table2. They were chosen to represent the mining environment where WC-Co is used to combat wear [23]. The composition of the SMW given in Table 2 is the most aggressive mine water found in the gold mines of South Africa [15, 24].Table 2
Synthetic mine water composition [15].
Compound
Concentration(mg/L)
Na2SO4
1237
CaCl2
1038
MgSO4
199
NaCl
1380Test samples were polished to a 1μm surface finish after being made electrically conductive by attaching an aluminum sticker tape to one face in a cold-mounted mold. After immersion in the electrolytes, the open circuit potential (OCP) was allowed to stabilize for two hours. Potentiodynamic anodic polarisation measurements were done using an Autolab potentiostat/galvanostat connected to a personal computer with a General Purpose Electrochemical System (GPES) software. As in an earlier study [8], potential was varied from −600 mV to +1200 mV at a scan rate of 2 mV/s for all the samples. This scan rate was similar to those used in literature [25, 26]. The corrosion potential (Ecorr), corrosion current density (icorr), and corrosion rates were retrieved from the corrosion measurement data using the intersection of the anodic and cathodic Tafel lines.Chronoamperometry measurements were performed immediately on specimens at the end of their potential sweeps to investigate the corrosion products on their surfaces. The measurements were done for eight hours at potentials selected from the anodic polarisation curves.Samples were characterised for phases before and after corrosion testing using a Phillips PW 1710 X-ray diffractometer. Surfaces of specimens after chronoamperometric tests were analyzed using a Raman spectrometer (Senterra, Bruker Optics) coupled with a Peltier cooled CCD detector (576×288 pixels) equipped with a 532 nm wavelength laser. The vanadium content of the test electrolytes after chronoamperometric testing was determined using a Spectro Genesis inductively coupled plasma—optical emitting spectrometer (ICP-OES).


## 2.1. Materials

The nominal composition (wt.%) of the test materials and their magnetic saturation levels are given in Table1. The microstructures of the specimens are fully described elsewhere [8]. The VC content took values of 0, 0.4, 10, and 27 wt%. However, the VC, at the 10 and 27 wt.% content, occurred as the double carbide (W,V)C because WC dissolves in VC during sintering [10]. For easier referencing, the samples will be referred to using their VC content. The target binder content was 10 wt% Co for all the specimens, but samples 10 VC and 27 VC had 12 and 11 wt% Co, respectively. Comparison between the samples is still possible because the effect of cobalt content on the corrosion behavior of WC-Co hardmetals is known. For example, it is known that the current densities at (free) open circuit potential are a function of Co content, and in acidic solutions, the current densities increase with increasing Co content [11].Table 1
Nominal chemical composition and magnetic properties of test specimens.
Specimen
Approx. vol% Co
Magnetic saturation(4πσ) (G cm3 g−1)
WC-10Co
16
172
WC-0.4VC-10Co
16
185
WC-10VC-12Co
17
230
WC-27VC-11Co
13
194The magnetic saturation of the specimens increased with the introduction of VC and with Co content (Table1). Cobalt is the magnetic phase and the higher values with higher Co contents are expected. The magnetic saturation provides a measure of the solute content of the binder and is a quick technique for determining the quality of sintered WC-Co [12]. Generally, and within limits, the magnetic saturation decreases linearly with an increase of W content of the binder [13, 14].


## 2.2. Electrochemical Measurements

Electrochemical measurements were carried out using the conventional setup of a three-electrode cell in which the test specimen is the working electrode, an inert material, in the case here, graphite rod, is the counter electrode (CE) and a reference electrode against which all potentials are reported. The reference electrode used was a silver/silver chloride electrode (SSE) (in saturated KCl) and was connected to the test cell via a Luggin probe capillary. All tests were done at room temperature and the electrolytes were neither deaerated nor aerated during testing.The electrolytes used were 1 M sodium chloride (NaCl) and synthetic mine water (SMW) whose composition is given in Table2. They were chosen to represent the mining environment where WC-Co is used to combat wear [23]. The composition of the SMW given in Table 2 is the most aggressive mine water found in the gold mines of South Africa [15, 24].Table 2
Synthetic mine water composition [15].
Compound
Concentration(mg/L)
Na2SO4
1237
CaCl2
1038
MgSO4
199
NaCl
1380Test samples were polished to a 1μm surface finish after being made electrically conductive by attaching an aluminum sticker tape to one face in a cold-mounted mold. After immersion in the electrolytes, the open circuit potential (OCP) was allowed to stabilize for two hours. Potentiodynamic anodic polarisation measurements were done using an Autolab potentiostat/galvanostat connected to a personal computer with a General Purpose Electrochemical System (GPES) software. As in an earlier study [8], potential was varied from −600 mV to +1200 mV at a scan rate of 2 mV/s for all the samples. This scan rate was similar to those used in literature [25, 26]. The corrosion potential (Ecorr), corrosion current density (icorr), and corrosion rates were retrieved from the corrosion measurement data using the intersection of the anodic and cathodic Tafel lines.Chronoamperometry measurements were performed immediately on specimens at the end of their potential sweeps to investigate the corrosion products on their surfaces. The measurements were done for eight hours at potentials selected from the anodic polarisation curves.Samples were characterised for phases before and after corrosion testing using a Phillips PW 1710 X-ray diffractometer. Surfaces of specimens after chronoamperometric tests were analyzed using a Raman spectrometer (Senterra, Bruker Optics) coupled with a Peltier cooled CCD detector (576×288 pixels) equipped with a 532 nm wavelength laser. The vanadium content of the test electrolytes after chronoamperometric testing was determined using a Spectro Genesis inductively coupled plasma—optical emitting spectrometer (ICP-OES).


## 3. Results

### 3.1. Potentiodynamic Polarisation Behaviour

Figures1 and 2 show the potentiodynamic polarisation curves of the samples in 1 M NaCl and SMW, respectively. As was the case in a previous study, the anodic polarization behavior for each specimen was repeatable (Figure 3). The anodic polarization behavior in NaCl, where all samples showed pseudopassive behavior, is similar to that observed in HCl acid solutions [8]. The pseudopassive behavior was more pronounced for the base alloy WC-10Co, the specimen with the least magnetic saturation (Table 1).Figure 1
Potentiodynamic curves of the samples in NaCl.Figure 2
Potentiodynamic curves of the samples in SMW.Figure 3
Repeatability of 27 wt% VC in 1 M NaCl.The pseudopassive behavior observed for WC-10Co hardmetal in the NaCl test solution is in contrast with other literatures [27] where dilute (0.1 M) NaCl solutions were used. This is because the higher Cl− anion concentration used in this study compared to literature favours passivation [28].Compared to NaCl, anodic dissolution occurred continuously, without any pseudopassive behavior, for all specimens during potentiodynamic polarization in SMW (Figure2). The behavior of the base alloy was in line with literature [9].


### 3.2. Corrosion Parameters

Table3 presents the corrosion parameters of the specimens in NaCl and SMW. Vanadium carbide additions of 0.4 wt% VC, levels used for grain refinement, simultaneously made the Ecorr more negative, and the corrosion current density higher than that of the base alloy in both electrolytes. A similar trend was obtained in acidic solutions [8]. Higher VC contents made Ecorr nobler in NaCl compared to the base alloy. However, the corrosion current density increased and appeared to be independent of the VC content, an observation that was different from that found for HCl and H2SO4 acidic solutions which had a similar potentiodynamic polarization behavior and where current density decreased with increasing VC content [8].Table 3
Electrochemical parameters of the WC-VC-Co samples in NaCl and SMW.
NaCl
SMW
E
corr (V) (v SSE)
i
corr (μA/cm2)
E
corr (V) (v SSE)
i
corr (μA/cm2)
WC-10Co
−0.399
0.03
−0.313
0.18
WC-0.4VC-10Co
−0.469
0.20
−0.474
0.21
WC-10VC-12C0
−0.370
0.36
−0.296
0.15
WC-27VC-11Co
−0.361
0.28
−0.379
0.08There was no observable trend of the effect of increasing VC content onEcorr in SMW: 10 wt% VC increased Ecorr to a more nobler value, while 27 wt% VC decreased it to a lesser noble value, compared to the base alloy. However, the corrosion current densities decreased to values lower than those of the base alloy, the decrease tempered by the cobalt content.


### 3.3. Chronoamperometry Studies

Chronoamperometric tests were done at 0.8 V (v SSE) for the base alloy and 0.7 V (v SSE) for the WC-VC-Co hardmetals in 1 M NaCl based on pseudopassivation at these potentials. Due to the continuous dissolution of all the samples during anodic polarization in SMW, a potential of 1.1 V (v SSE) was used for all the samples. Figure4 shows the variation of current density for tests in the NaCl solution. The base alloy passivated instantaneously and had the least steady state current density, unlike the VC specimens. VC additions at the level used for grain refinement (0.4 wt% VC) led to fluctuations in the current density curve, implying some pitting corrosion. The current for the high VC content alloys decreased quickly and then increased before decreasing again. Decreasing current densities are associated with a build-up of corrosion products on the test surface [29] while increases suggest oxidation events [17], that are caused by the fracture and/or fall off of the corrosion product that had formed on the surface to expose the underlying surface.Figure 4
Chronoamperometry curves of the samples in NaCl.There was no instantaneous passivation for any specimen in SMW (Figure5). In addition to the base alloy, 27VC also attained a steady state current density. As was the case in NaCl (Figure 4), the base alloy had the least steady state current. Current fluctuations were observed for specimen 0.4VC, an indication of pitting, but the fluctuations were less pronounced than in NaCl (Figure 4).Figure 5
Chronoamperometry curves of samples in SMW.


### 3.4. Surface Phases after Corrosion

The results of the XRD patterns of the samples before corrosion have been published elsewhere [8]. Figures 6 and 7 are XRD patterns showing the change of surface phases after chronoamperometric testing in NaCl and SMW, respectively. Cobalt peaks, observed in all the specimens before corrosion, were absent after corrosion. This occurrence was in line with literature where the Co binder phase in WC-Co-based hardmetals corrodes preferentially [2]. Tungsten oxides appeared to have formed for some specimens, but the XRD analysis was inconclusive, necessitating further analysis using Raman spectroscopy (Figures 8 and 9). In contrast, there were no XRD peaks for vanadium-based corrosion phases on the surfaces of the VC-containing specimens after corrosion in any of the test electrolyte (Figures 6 and 7).XRD pattern of the corrosion products of the samples on (a) WC-10Co, (b) WC-0.4VC-10Co, (c) WC-10VC-12Co, and (d) WC-27VC-11Co in NaCl.
(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)XRD pattern of the corrosion products of the samples on (a) WC-10Co, (b) WC-0.4VC-10Co, (c) WC-10VC-12Co, and (d) WC-27VC-11Co in SMW.
(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)Raman spectra of corroded product on (a) WC-10Co, (b) WC-0.4VC-10Co, (c) WC-10VC-12Co, and (d) WC-27VC-11Co in NaCl.
(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)Raman spectra of after corrosion in SMW (a) WC-10Co, (b) WC-0.4VC-10Co, (c) WC-10VC-12Co, and (d) WC-27VC-11Co.
(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)Some of the VC-containing specimens did not have XRD peaks for VC (which occurs as (V,W)C) after corrosion (10VC and 27VC) specimens in NaCl and 10VC in SMW as presented earlier in [8]). These peaks were present after corrosion in acid solutions, where corrosion rates were at least an order of magnitude higher than [8]. It is possible that in the current case, the (V,W)C grains fell out during specimen handling due to the dissolution of the binder, as has been observed in literature [30].Figures8 and 9 show the Raman spectra obtained on the samples after testing in NaCl and SMW, respectively. The corrosion products for all test specimens were tungsten-oxide based, even though they had not been detected by XRD analysis in some cases, especially in SMW (Figure 7). Tables 4 and 5 allocate the Raman bands to their possible sources based on observations in literature. The literature of WO3-based films indicates that Raman bands below 190 cm−1 are caused by lattice vibration of crystalline WO3; bands between 190 and 400 cm−1 are due to bending of O–W–O bonds; those in the range 500–900 cm−1 are characteristic of stretching O–W–O bonds; and bands in the vicinity of 950, characteristic of hydrated WO3, are caused by the stretching of terminal W=O bonds [16, 17, 19–21, 31, 32].Table 4
Raman shifts after corrosion in NaCl.
Specimen
Raman bands
Possible phase
References
WC-10C
133 & 249
WO3
[16]
814.5
WO3
[17]
679 & 958.5
WO3·2H2O
[16]
WC-0.4VC-10Co
131
WO3
[16]
697
WO3
[18]
813.5
WO3
[17]
881.5
WO3·nH2O
[19]
968.5
WO3·2H2O
[16]
WC-10VC-12Co
131 & 803
WO3
[16]
261 & 962
WO3·2H2O
[20]
WC-27VC-11Co
132.5, 262.5, 700, & 805.5
WO3
[16]Table 5
Raman bands after corrosion in SMW.
Specimen
Raman bands
Possible phase
Reference
WC-10Co
133, 262.5, 704.5 & 808
WO3
[16, 21]
WC-0.4VC-10Co
139
WO3
[21]
743
Cubic WO3
[20]
891
WO3
[19]
955
WO3·2H2O
[16]
WC-10VC-12Co
129, 263, & 802
WO3
[21]
980
WO3·nH2O
[22]
WC-27VC-11Co
130, 263, 708, & 803
WO3
[21]
327
CaWO4
[19]No Raman band matches were found for possible vanadium-based corrosion products, for example, vanadium oxide, vanadium oxy-chloride (VOCl3), whose Raman bands are available in literature [33, 34]. However, during the chronoamperometric tests, light green solids were observed to form in the solutions. Inductive coupled plasma optical emitting spectrometry (ICP-OES) analysis of the electrolytes indicated the presence of vanadium cations probably V(II) (Table 6) indicating that the green solids that formed were probably VCl2, which is known to be green [35].Table 6
ICP-OES results of VC containing corrosion product solutions after dissolution in SMW and NaCl.
Sample
Vanadium content (ppm)
SMW
NaCl
WC-0.4VC
46.7
±
1.3
83.1
±
3.5
WC-10VC
15.1
±
3.7
24.9
±
2.7
WC-27VC
58.4
±
3.1
2.0
±
0.3The formation of WO3 as a film accounts for WC-VC-Co pseudopassive behavior in acidic test media [8], and in the current study, the observation of pseudopassivity in the neutral 1 M NaCl test solution (Figure 1). Its formation on the specimens tested in SMW was however not accompanied by pseudopassive behaviour. The difference in pseudopassive behavior between the NaCl and SMW could have been caused by the difference in Cl− anion concentrations, where the higher concentrations in NaCl encouraged passivation compared to the low concentration obtained in the SMW [28]. It is also possible that the WO3 film formed in SMW had poorer adhesion properties.


## 3.1. Potentiodynamic Polarisation Behaviour

Figures1 and 2 show the potentiodynamic polarisation curves of the samples in 1 M NaCl and SMW, respectively. As was the case in a previous study, the anodic polarization behavior for each specimen was repeatable (Figure 3). The anodic polarization behavior in NaCl, where all samples showed pseudopassive behavior, is similar to that observed in HCl acid solutions [8]. The pseudopassive behavior was more pronounced for the base alloy WC-10Co, the specimen with the least magnetic saturation (Table 1).Figure 1
Potentiodynamic curves of the samples in NaCl.Figure 2
Potentiodynamic curves of the samples in SMW.Figure 3
Repeatability of 27 wt% VC in 1 M NaCl.The pseudopassive behavior observed for WC-10Co hardmetal in the NaCl test solution is in contrast with other literatures [27] where dilute (0.1 M) NaCl solutions were used. This is because the higher Cl− anion concentration used in this study compared to literature favours passivation [28].Compared to NaCl, anodic dissolution occurred continuously, without any pseudopassive behavior, for all specimens during potentiodynamic polarization in SMW (Figure2). The behavior of the base alloy was in line with literature [9].


## 3.2. Corrosion Parameters

Table3 presents the corrosion parameters of the specimens in NaCl and SMW. Vanadium carbide additions of 0.4 wt% VC, levels used for grain refinement, simultaneously made the Ecorr more negative, and the corrosion current density higher than that of the base alloy in both electrolytes. A similar trend was obtained in acidic solutions [8]. Higher VC contents made Ecorr nobler in NaCl compared to the base alloy. However, the corrosion current density increased and appeared to be independent of the VC content, an observation that was different from that found for HCl and H2SO4 acidic solutions which had a similar potentiodynamic polarization behavior and where current density decreased with increasing VC content [8].Table 3
Electrochemical parameters of the WC-VC-Co samples in NaCl and SMW.
NaCl
SMW
E
corr (V) (v SSE)
i
corr (μA/cm2)
E
corr (V) (v SSE)
i
corr (μA/cm2)
WC-10Co
−0.399
0.03
−0.313
0.18
WC-0.4VC-10Co
−0.469
0.20
−0.474
0.21
WC-10VC-12C0
−0.370
0.36
−0.296
0.15
WC-27VC-11Co
−0.361
0.28
−0.379
0.08There was no observable trend of the effect of increasing VC content onEcorr in SMW: 10 wt% VC increased Ecorr to a more nobler value, while 27 wt% VC decreased it to a lesser noble value, compared to the base alloy. However, the corrosion current densities decreased to values lower than those of the base alloy, the decrease tempered by the cobalt content.


## 3.3. Chronoamperometry Studies

Chronoamperometric tests were done at 0.8 V (v SSE) for the base alloy and 0.7 V (v SSE) for the WC-VC-Co hardmetals in 1 M NaCl based on pseudopassivation at these potentials. Due to the continuous dissolution of all the samples during anodic polarization in SMW, a potential of 1.1 V (v SSE) was used for all the samples. Figure4 shows the variation of current density for tests in the NaCl solution. The base alloy passivated instantaneously and had the least steady state current density, unlike the VC specimens. VC additions at the level used for grain refinement (0.4 wt% VC) led to fluctuations in the current density curve, implying some pitting corrosion. The current for the high VC content alloys decreased quickly and then increased before decreasing again. Decreasing current densities are associated with a build-up of corrosion products on the test surface [29] while increases suggest oxidation events [17], that are caused by the fracture and/or fall off of the corrosion product that had formed on the surface to expose the underlying surface.Figure 4
Chronoamperometry curves of the samples in NaCl.There was no instantaneous passivation for any specimen in SMW (Figure5). In addition to the base alloy, 27VC also attained a steady state current density. As was the case in NaCl (Figure 4), the base alloy had the least steady state current. Current fluctuations were observed for specimen 0.4VC, an indication of pitting, but the fluctuations were less pronounced than in NaCl (Figure 4).Figure 5
Chronoamperometry curves of samples in SMW.


## 3.4. Surface Phases after Corrosion

The results of the XRD patterns of the samples before corrosion have been published elsewhere [8]. Figures 6 and 7 are XRD patterns showing the change of surface phases after chronoamperometric testing in NaCl and SMW, respectively. Cobalt peaks, observed in all the specimens before corrosion, were absent after corrosion. This occurrence was in line with literature where the Co binder phase in WC-Co-based hardmetals corrodes preferentially [2]. Tungsten oxides appeared to have formed for some specimens, but the XRD analysis was inconclusive, necessitating further analysis using Raman spectroscopy (Figures 8 and 9). In contrast, there were no XRD peaks for vanadium-based corrosion phases on the surfaces of the VC-containing specimens after corrosion in any of the test electrolyte (Figures 6 and 7).XRD pattern of the corrosion products of the samples on (a) WC-10Co, (b) WC-0.4VC-10Co, (c) WC-10VC-12Co, and (d) WC-27VC-11Co in NaCl.
(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)XRD pattern of the corrosion products of the samples on (a) WC-10Co, (b) WC-0.4VC-10Co, (c) WC-10VC-12Co, and (d) WC-27VC-11Co in SMW.
(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)Raman spectra of corroded product on (a) WC-10Co, (b) WC-0.4VC-10Co, (c) WC-10VC-12Co, and (d) WC-27VC-11Co in NaCl.
(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)Raman spectra of after corrosion in SMW (a) WC-10Co, (b) WC-0.4VC-10Co, (c) WC-10VC-12Co, and (d) WC-27VC-11Co.
(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)Some of the VC-containing specimens did not have XRD peaks for VC (which occurs as (V,W)C) after corrosion (10VC and 27VC) specimens in NaCl and 10VC in SMW as presented earlier in [8]). These peaks were present after corrosion in acid solutions, where corrosion rates were at least an order of magnitude higher than [8]. It is possible that in the current case, the (V,W)C grains fell out during specimen handling due to the dissolution of the binder, as has been observed in literature [30].Figures8 and 9 show the Raman spectra obtained on the samples after testing in NaCl and SMW, respectively. The corrosion products for all test specimens were tungsten-oxide based, even though they had not been detected by XRD analysis in some cases, especially in SMW (Figure 7). Tables 4 and 5 allocate the Raman bands to their possible sources based on observations in literature. The literature of WO3-based films indicates that Raman bands below 190 cm−1 are caused by lattice vibration of crystalline WO3; bands between 190 and 400 cm−1 are due to bending of O–W–O bonds; those in the range 500–900 cm−1 are characteristic of stretching O–W–O bonds; and bands in the vicinity of 950, characteristic of hydrated WO3, are caused by the stretching of terminal W=O bonds [16, 17, 19–21, 31, 32].Table 4
Raman shifts after corrosion in NaCl.
Specimen
Raman bands
Possible phase
References
WC-10C
133 & 249
WO3
[16]
814.5
WO3
[17]
679 & 958.5
WO3·2H2O
[16]
WC-0.4VC-10Co
131
WO3
[16]
697
WO3
[18]
813.5
WO3
[17]
881.5
WO3·nH2O
[19]
968.5
WO3·2H2O
[16]
WC-10VC-12Co
131 & 803
WO3
[16]
261 & 962
WO3·2H2O
[20]
WC-27VC-11Co
132.5, 262.5, 700, & 805.5
WO3
[16]Table 5
Raman bands after corrosion in SMW.
Specimen
Raman bands
Possible phase
Reference
WC-10Co
133, 262.5, 704.5 & 808
WO3
[16, 21]
WC-0.4VC-10Co
139
WO3
[21]
743
Cubic WO3
[20]
891
WO3
[19]
955
WO3·2H2O
[16]
WC-10VC-12Co
129, 263, & 802
WO3
[21]
980
WO3·nH2O
[22]
WC-27VC-11Co
130, 263, 708, & 803
WO3
[21]
327
CaWO4
[19]No Raman band matches were found for possible vanadium-based corrosion products, for example, vanadium oxide, vanadium oxy-chloride (VOCl3), whose Raman bands are available in literature [33, 34]. However, during the chronoamperometric tests, light green solids were observed to form in the solutions. Inductive coupled plasma optical emitting spectrometry (ICP-OES) analysis of the electrolytes indicated the presence of vanadium cations probably V(II) (Table 6) indicating that the green solids that formed were probably VCl2, which is known to be green [35].Table 6
ICP-OES results of VC containing corrosion product solutions after dissolution in SMW and NaCl.
Sample
Vanadium content (ppm)
SMW
NaCl
WC-0.4VC
46.7
±
1.3
83.1
±
3.5
WC-10VC
15.1
±
3.7
24.9
±
2.7
WC-27VC
58.4
±
3.1
2.0
±
0.3The formation of WO3 as a film accounts for WC-VC-Co pseudopassive behavior in acidic test media [8], and in the current study, the observation of pseudopassivity in the neutral 1 M NaCl test solution (Figure 1). Its formation on the specimens tested in SMW was however not accompanied by pseudopassive behaviour. The difference in pseudopassive behavior between the NaCl and SMW could have been caused by the difference in Cl− anion concentrations, where the higher concentrations in NaCl encouraged passivation compared to the low concentration obtained in the SMW [28]. It is also possible that the WO3 film formed in SMW had poorer adhesion properties.


## 4. General Discussion

The effect of increasing amounts VC on the corrosion resistance of WC-Co appears to have been mixed. The VC reduces the extent of the pseudopassive behavior in NaCl and does not change it in SMW; it does not alter the corrosion current density in NaCl, where the current density increases with Co content, while it reduces it in SMW; chronoamperometric current densities stabilize at higher values for specimens with VC. The trends in the results reported here suggest that VC impairs the corrosion resistance of WC-Co except in SMW where it reduces the current density. These results can be explained from two perspectives.In general, it can be expected that VC additions affect the corrosion resistance of WC-Co in two ways. In the first instance, vanadium atoms from the VC can go into solution in the Co binder and either on their own and/or in conjunction with W atoms that also go in solution in the Co, alter the corrosion resistance of the Co binder. Solute atoms of W improve the corrosion resistance of Co [22]. This effect can either be augmented or curtailed by the presence of VC through its effect on the quantity of W atoms going into the Co binder. The W solute content in Co can be determined from the magnetic saturation. It is known, broadly, that the magnetic saturation of conventional WC-Co increases with decreasing amounts of W atoms in Co [13, 14]. Judging from the magnetic saturations of the test specimens, which increase with VC content (Table 1), the introduction of VC reduced the amount of W atoms in the Co binders of these specimens.The reduction of the W solute content of the binders of the VC specimens deduced above explains a number of the observations in this study. Some authors have used the W solute content, captured in the magnetic saturation, to explain the corrosion behavior of WC-Co. According to literature, a low magnetic saturation, implying a higher W solute content of the Co binder, is associated with a more pronounced pseudopassive behavior in sulphuric acid [36]. The pronounced pseudopassive behavior observed for the base alloy in NaCl in the current study (Figure 1) can therefore be explained on the basis of its lower magnetic saturation (Table 1) compared to the other test specimens. By extension, the variation of magnetic saturation also explains the variation of corrosion current densities, icorr, in NaCl (Table 3), which increase with increasing magnetic saturation, that is, decreasing W solute content of the binder. This variation of current density associated with changing W solute content in Co is, as has already been mentioned, in line with literature, where lower Co binder W solute content is associated with poor corrosion resistance [22].The above thinking where magnetic saturation/Co binder W solute content explains corrosion behavior needs to be qualified, because it does not appear like this is a universal phenomenon: the relationship appears to be solution-specimen dependent. For example, corrosion of WC-Co in nitric acid is not explained by the magnetic saturation of the specimens [37]. The solution can play a role in accentuating the effect of the magnetic saturation. For example, the pronounced pseudopassive behavior observed for corrosion of the base alloy in NaCl in this study could have been aided by the effect of higher Cl− ion concentration, which also encourages pseudopassive behavior [28].The specificity of the solution-specimen dependence of the effect of magnetic saturation on corrosion, referred to above, appears to partly apply to the corrosion behavior in SMW, where all specimens continuously dissolved during potentiodynamic polarization (Figure2) and also where, generally, corrosion current densities, icorr, decreased even as the magnetic saturation was increasing (Table 3). The Cl− ion concentration in the SMW was much less, preventing the solution from predisposing specimens to pseudopassive behavior. The variation of icorr, in SMW can be loosely correlated with the variation of the volume fraction of the binder, meaning that the effect of VC on corrosion in SMW was probably through its effect on the volume fraction of the binder.The second possible impact of the VC on the corrosion of WC-Co hardmetal would be expected to be through its effect on the corrosion product. It has been suggested that vanadium is naturally passivating [38]. However, this tendency did not manifest itself in this study: for example, the potentiodynamic polarization behavior of the specimens was not changed in a positive way, for example, the emergence of true passivity, by the presence of VC (Figures 1 and 2). Also, no vanadium-based compound was detected on the corroded surfaces of the specimens in this study either by XRD studies (Figures 6 and 7) or by Raman spectroscopy (Figures 8 and 9). These two analysis techniques showed that no solid film of a vanadium compound formed on the surfaces of the test specimens after corrosion. It appears that a vanadium-based corrosion compound formed during corrosion, however, it dissolved in the test solutions (as shown by the presence of Vanadium ions in the test electrolytes (Table 6)), and, in some cases, precipitated out of the electrolytes and did not participate in forming a barrier to curtail corrosion. This failure to form a corrosion barrier explains the higher current densities observed for the VC specimens during chronoamperometric testing (Figures 4 and 5).The results of the 0.4 wt% VC specimen deserve some emphasis, given the importance of VC-grain refinement of WC-Co materials. Fine-grained WC-Co materials are important for wear applications. While the wear resistance is high, the current results have shown that the corrosion resistance is poorer than for any other specimen in the study. This specimen had a higher corrosion current density, in both electrolytes (Table3), and was the only specimen that pitted during chronoamperometric testing (Figures 4 and 5). Even though this has been reported in the literature of the corrosion of WC-Co in neutral chloride solutions [6, 9], the behavior had not been effectively explained. This detrimental effect stems, primarily, from the effect of VC on the Co binder W solute content: the VC restricts the amount of W that goes into solution in the Co binder during sintering by forming a (V,W)C film around the WC grains. This is the mechanism by which VC grain refiners are known to effect WC grain refinement [38]. The effect of low W solute content on corrosion has already been explained.


## 5. Conclusion

Investigations into the corrosion behaviour of WC-VC-Co hardmetals using potentiodynamic scans, XRD, and Raman spectroscopy measurements in 1 M NaCl and synthetic mine water (SMW) were undertaken. The observations can be summarized as follows.(i)
Specimens exhibit active-pseudopassive behavior in NaCl but the intensity of the pseudopassivation is impaired by the presence of VC. In SMW, all specimens actively corrode during anodic polarization with no impact whatsoever from VC. The negative impact in NaCl and the lack of impact in SMW are caused, primarily, by the fact that the VC does not participate in the formation of a protective film on the surfaces of the corroding samples, and, partly by the fact that the VC prevents W atoms from going into solution in the Co binder, that is, the VC fails to lower the magnetic saturation of samples.(ii)
Additions of VC to WC-Co at levels used for WC grain size refinement increase corrosion current densities and predispose specimens to pitting corrosion. This occurs because the VC reduces the amount of W atoms dissolving in the Co binder (increases the magnetic saturation compared to the base alloy).(iii)
The effect of high VC content on the corrosion resistance of WC-Co is solution dependent: high VC contents are not beneficial for corrosion resistance in NaCl, but greatly improve corrosion resistance in SMW.



---

*Source: 506759-2013-01-29.xml*