# Electrodeposition of Oriented Cerium Oxide Films

Authors: Adele Qi Wang; Teresa D. Golden
Journal: International Journal of Electrochemistry
 (2013)

---

## Abstract

Cerium oxide films of preferred orientation are electrodeposited under anodic conditions.  A complexing ligand, acetate, was used to stabilize the cerium (III) ion in solution for deposition of the thin films. Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy showed that the ligand and metal tended to bind as a weakly bidentate complex. The crystallite size of the films was in the nanometer range as shown by Raman spectroscopy and was calculated from X-ray diffraction data. Crystallite sizes from 6 to 20 nm were obtained under the anodic deposition conditions. Sintering of the (111) oriented films showed an increase in the (111) orientation with temperatures up to 900°C. Also, the crystallite size increased from 20 nm to 120 nm under sintering conditions. Addition of the deposited films to the substrate improved corrosion resistance for the substrate.


---

## Body

## 1. Introduction

The fabrication of cerium oxide films is of interest due to broad applications for these films [1–6].  Cerium oxide can function as a catalyst, structure barrier for insulator on silicon, buffer layer on superconductor materials, and an anticorrosion coating on metals [7–12].  The texture of these thin films can affect the mechanical, electronic, and corrosion properties.Electrochemical deposition is an attractive method for the synthesis of thin films. It offers the advantages of low processing temperature, high purity of deposition, and controlled thickness of the film. Cathodic electrodeposition (i.e., base generation electrochemical methods) was first introduced for the plating of cerium oxide films [13–17]. However, producing CeO2 films with the base generation method is limited since the as-produced films tend to be powdery and loosely adherent.It is possible to obtain thin films of cerium oxide by stabilizing Ce3+ in solution with a weakly bound ligand [18–20]. With a high enough oxidation potential at the electrode surface, an equilibrium can be established where Ce(ΙΙΙ)-L has a slow release of Ce3+ from the complex for available oxidation. This mechanism has been described previously in greater detail [19]. These films can be electrodeposited under potentiostatic control and produce polycrystalline films of random orientation [18–21].  XANE study on electrodeposited cerium-related thin films revealed that anodic deposition preferred the Ce(ΙV) compounds, while cathodic base generation method led to the formation of high percentage of Ce(ΙΙΙ) species in the composition [22].For corrosion protection, cerium oxide has been used as coatings on stainless steel. While stainless steel can give protection against corrosion in certain environments, there is a need for resistance in other environments. This can be especially true for such places as coal and heavy oil plants [23] or in marine environments [24]. Since nickel has been increasing in price over recent years, there is an interest in shifting from austenitic to ferritic steels where possible. One of the largest drawbacks to using ferritic stainless steels, such as type 430, is less resistance to corrosion. Pitting corrosion especially in chloride containing environments can be a problem for type 430 stainless steel [25].In this work, CeO2 is deposited with a preferred crystalline orientation. This is accomplished by precisely controlling the deposition parameters. The resulting films are characterized by scanning electron microscopy, X-ray diffraction, Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy, and Raman spectroscopy. The sintering ability and corrosion protection of the films are also studied.


## 2. Experimental

An EG&G Princeton Applied Research (PAR) Model 273A potentiostat/galvanostat was used to electrochemically deposit CeO2 films.  The electrochemical cell was kept at constant temperature with a Fisher Scientific Model 1016D circulator.  The deposition was conducted in an undivided cell and regular three-electrode configuration.  The working electrode was prepared by mounting stainless steel (type 430, nominal composition 0.12% C, 1% Mn, 1% Si, 0.04% P, 0.03% S, 0.75% Ni, 17% Cr, Fe) or platinum in epoxy and then polished, rinsed, and ultrasonicated to a mirror finish.  Platinum wire or mesh was used as the counter electrode and a saturated calomel electrode (SCE) as the reference.  The electrolyte consisted of 0.1 M Ce(NO3)3·6H2O (99.5% pure, Alfa AESAR) and sodium acetate (Fisher) as a ligand.  Ce(NO3)3 and ligand concentrations were 0.1 M throughout the study. All the solutions were prepared using deionized water. Solution pH was adjusted with NaOH and monitored with a Corning pH meter and Pasco Scientific pH electrode throughout the deposition experiments. Each deposition was completed in 24–48 hours.The deposited film together with the substrate was sintered in air. A temperature ramping procedure was used starting at 260°C with a ramping rate of 1°C/min to the desired temperature value, keeping the value for one hour, and finally decreasing the temperature at a ramping rate of 1°C/min to 260°C.The structure and phase composition of the electrochemical deposited films were identified by X-ray diffraction (XRD) with a Siemens D500 diffractometer using Cu Kα radiation (λ = 0.15405 nm).  The tube source was operated at 40 kV and 30 mA.The surface morphology of the films was characterized by a scanning electron microscope (SEM), JOEL JSM-T300 with an accelerating voltage of 5–25 kV.Raman spectra were obtained using a Yvon Dilor XY800 Raman microprobe equipped with a nitrogen-cooled multichannel (CCD) detector, with an excitation wavelength of 514.54 nm laser radiation at 10 mW of power to prevent local heating of the sample. All the spectra were recorded between 200 and 4000 cm−1 with 3 cm−1 spectra resolution, 719 mm focal length, 600 lines/mm gratings, and 10x objective focused to 10 μm spot size. At least three spectra were randomly collected from different areas of the films and plotted.Infrared spectra were obtained using a Perkin-Elmer 1760X FTIR spectrophotometer. For each sample, 40 scans were collected in the range of 4000–400 cm−1 with a resolution of 4 cm−1.Linear polarization and Tafel experiment were done with EG&G 273A potentiostat using EG&G 352 softcorrΙΙΙ.


## 3. Results and Discussion

Ce3+ has the electronic structure of 4f15d06s0, and as a trivalent member of lanthanide series, the most stable complexes are those with chelating oxygen ligands [26].  Previously, acetate and lactate have been shown as ligands to result in film formation of CeO2 on substrates [18–21].   Kulp et al.  studied acetate ions as stabilizing agents for cerium (III) to determine the predominant species in the deposition solution. At a pH of 6.1, the main species was CeOAc2+, and the cerium (ΙΙΙ)-ligand complex proved significant for the anodic deposition of CeO2films [21].  As a complexing agent, the acetate ion may be bound with the metal as a unidentate, bidentate, or bridging type with the later two classified as symmetrical or unsymmetrical (Figure 1) [27–29].  Unidentate oxygen ligands are less stable than the others and are prone to dissociation.Figure 1
Coordination modes of acetate with metal, M = metal; (a) unidentate; (b) bidentate, symmetrical; (b’) bidentate, unsymmetrical; (c) bridging, symmetrical; (c’) bridging, unsymmetrical.FTIR can be useful to probe the coordination between acetate and cerium (ΙΙΙ) species [28, 30–32]. Symmetrical and antisymmetric C–O stretching modes are at ~1415 ± 20 and ~1570 ± 20 cm−1, respectively. These two characteristic IR bands will alter in position and shape with different coordination modes. If acetate is a unidentate, one of the oxygen is used in bonding with the metal, leaving a double-bond (C=O) giving a 1590–1650 cm−1 peak for the antisymmetric stretch mode.  The large increase in the antisymmetric band and the corresponding decrease in the symmetrical band increase the frequency difference between these two emissions. With acetate as a bidentate ligand, the two C–O bonds retain equivalent stretching, giving no enhancement for the two bands [28]. Coupling between different acetate groups leads to multiple bands in the range of 1400–1550 cm−1, if more than one acetate bonds to a metal ion [32]. Bridging can also be regarded as an intermediate mode between uni- and bidentate coordinations [32].Solutions of cerium (ΙΙΙ) nitrate-acetate with a molar ratio of cerium (ΙΙΙ) to acetate in the range of 1 : 1 to 1 : 9 were run using FTIR. The results are shown in Figures 2 and 3. The acetate ligand alone in solution exists as ions and the two C–O stretching bands are equivalent indicating C=O and C–O−, as would be expected for the free ion (Figure 2).  Figure 3 shows the IR spectrum changes with the molar ratio between cerium (ΙΙΙ) and acetate increasing from 1 : 1 to 1 : 10.  At lower concentrations of acetate, the ~1415 cm−1 bands (symmetrical) are enhanced and split into two bands, at 1404 and 1352 cm−1, respectively, with weak peaks around 1560 and 1577 cm−1 (Figure 3). The pair of 1404 and 1560 cm−1, which results in the difference of ~156 cm−1 (Table 1), shows an enhanced bidentate complex [28]. The higher frequency of 1577 cm−1 is very weak so the predominant binding is with C–O−. The stronger intensities of the lower frequencies can be attributed to the complex having symmetrical properties, pointing to a symmetrical bidentate complex. These 1 : 1 metal : acetate results coincide with the luminescence and NMR results reported by Azenha et al.  which show that the dominant mode of complexation involved a weak, predominately bidentate binding of the metal ion, suggesting a [Ce(H2O)x(O2CCH3)]2+ species (where x  = 6 or 7) [33].   Kulp et al.,  also calculated this species as the predominant form in the electrodeposition solution [21].Table 1
IR assignment for Ce(III)-acetate complex and calculation of frequency difference (peak position in cm−1) according to Figure 3.
Emission
a
b
c
d
Diff1
Diff2
Emission type
Sym
Sym
An-sym
An-sym
Ce : Acetate
0 : 1
1417.6
1552
134.4
1 : 1
1352.8
1404
1560.0
1581.2
156
228.4
1 : 2
1350.9
1411.2
1556.4
1577.6
145.2
226.7
1 : 3
1350.9
1414.7
1554.6
1577.6
139.9
226.7
1 : 4
1353.9
1414.7
1556.1
1576.5
141.4
222.6
1 : 5
1350.9
1416.5
1554.6
1577.6
138.1
226.7
1 : 6
1347.8
1416.5
1554.2
1576.5
137.7
228.7
1 : 7
1351.6
1416.5
1556.1
1576.5
139.6
224.9
1 : 8
1349.7
1414.7
1556.1
1576.5
141.4
226.8
1 : 9
1347.8
1414.7
1556.1
1576.5
141.4
228.7
1 : 10
1350.7
1415.1
1556
1576.1
140.9
225.4Figure 2
FTIR spectra for acetate ion in solution.FTIR spectra for cerium (ΙΙΙ)-acetate complex in the range of 1000–1650 cm−1 and molar ratio of cerium and acetate (a) 1 : 1; (b) 1 : 6; (c) 1 : 10.
(a)
(b)
(c)With increasing amount of acetate, the 1350 cm−1 band decreases, but the splitting is still sustained (Figure 3), indicating, the coordination is two modes but with the bridging gradually dominating. Also the higher frequency band, ~1560 cm−1 gives a strong signal. FTIR results showed that for molar ratios of 1 : 2 to 1 : 7, similar IR spectra were obtained suggesting the saturation of coordination with increasing amounts of acetate. When the molar ratio is increased  to  as high as 8–10, the 1570 and 1550 cm−1 bands merge and give higher intensities. Considering the saturation of metal coordination, the extra free ions of acetate contribute more to the IR spectra. The coordination number of the Ce(ΙΙΙ)-acetate complex is estimated at 6-7 with weak bidentate coordination for the 1 : 1 complex and bridging at higher concentrations. More accurate determination of complex coordination number can be acquired by combining IR and solid-state NMR with single-crystal X-ray diffraction. Since the 1 : 1 ratio provided the least complicated complexation, this molar ratio was used in the deposition of the oriented films.Several parameters were explored to optimize the deposition of the CeO2 films with preferred orientation. The linear sweep voltammogram is shown in Figure 4 for the plating solution used for the cerium oxide film deposition. A small oxidation peak can be seen around a potential of ~0.95 V that is attributed to the conversion of Ce(ΙΙΙ) to Ce(ΙV) species [19]. While potentiostatic and galvanostatic modes were both shown to give CeO2 films, galvanostatic mode resulted in preferred orientation of the films when higher temperatures were used.  A range of current densities were studied at 25°C for anodic current densities between −0.06 and –0.90 mA/cm2.  The deposited films exhibited a random pattern, with increasing current, and the intensity of the (111) reflection decreases. The lower currents (i.e., –0.06 mA/cm2) are more conducive to the formation of preferred orientation. The effect of deposition temperature was then investigated at these lower current densities.Figure 4
Linear sweep voltammetry of cerium-acetate complex, pH = 7.5,T = 25°C, and ν = 50 mV/sec.Increasing the temperature increases the steady state current density for the cerium-acetate system. The X-ray diffraction patterns of the deposited films are shown for higher temperatures of 70° and 80°C (Figure5).  With increasing temperature, for the galvanostatic deposition, the CeO2 (111) reflection increases in intensity producing films with a preferred (111) orientation, while the potentiostatic deposition only produces random oriented films.  The intensity ratios (I/Io) for the CeO2 patterns in Figure 5 are shown in Table 2.  While the (111) intensity of the CeO2 increases, the substrate peak remains about the same intensity, indicating that the film thickness is approximately the same at all temperatures.  The film thicknesses for all depositions tend to be thin since CeO2 is not very conducting.Table 2
The preferred orientation of CeO2 at various temperatures compared to the random powder pattern for CeO2 (PDF number 81-0792) (data from Figure 5).
2θ (°)
hkl
PDF number 81-0792
25°C
40°C
50°C
60°C
70°C
80°C
28.54
111
100
100
100
100
100
100
100
33.03
200
29
29
—
—
—
—
—
47.51
220
46
47
12
14
3
—
—
56.34
311
36
33
2
2
—
—
—
59.36
400
6
7
4
3
3
3
3X-ray diffraction patterns of cerium oxide films deposited from a solution of 0.1 M Ce(NO3)3 and 0.1 M acetic acid pH = 7.5, y-axis X-ray intensity in cps. (a) Galvanostatic mode: deposition current density of −0.06 mA/cm2 at (A) 25, (B) 50, (C) 70, and (D) 80°C. (b) Potentiostatic mode: deposition potential of 1.10 V at (A) 25, (B) 50, and (C) 70°C.
(a)
(b)The potential monitored during galvanostatic deposition for a current density of −0.06 mA/cm2 is in the range of 0.7–1.0 V versus SCE.  Progressing through the deposition, the potential increases to 0.9–1.1 V. However, when these corresponding potentials are applied in the potentiostatic deposition, a random structure is obtained, not preferred oriented films.Raman spectroscopy is an effective tool to investigate the structure of cerium oxide and  crystalline size of the CeO2 [34–37]. Crystallite size is a significant parameter for the properties and application of the cerium oxide film. Smaller particle sizes and minimum film thickness of cerium oxide films lead to improvements for corrosion protection. Other researchers have demonstrated this for CeO2 films deposited by sol-gel and reactive sputtering methods [38, 39].  In Wang’s report, when the crystallite is larger than 20 nm, there will be one major shift for the 463 cm−1 peak in Raman; however, for crystallite sizes smaller than 10 nm, two more shifts at 270, 315 cm−1 appear and the intensities increase with decreasing crystal sizes [34]. The Raman spectra of the anodically deposited CeO2 are shown in Figure 6 for galvanostatic deposited CeO2 films with an applied current density of –0.06 mA/cm2.Figure 6
Raman spectra of CeO2 anodically electrodeposited on stainless steel by galvanostatic mode: j = −0.06 mA/cm2, T = 70°C.The reproducible spectra in each Raman spectra figure demonstrate the homogeneities of the deposited CeO2 film samples. The peak observed at ~450 cm−1 is about 14 cm−1 lower relative to the reported peak (464 cm−1) for microsized CeO2, indicating that the crystallites are in the nanosize range.  The lattice calculations, from the XRD patterns, support this observation for Raman.For XRD patterns which exhibit preferred orientation, the following   Scherrer equation  is used to estimate the crystallite size [40];
(1)β=kλLcosθ,
where λ is the wavelength of the X-rays, θ  is the diffraction angle, L is the crystallite size, k is a constant dependent on the crystal shape, and β  is the corrected FWHM of the given peak.  From the (111) reflection of the CeO2 films, the crystallite sizes for the preferred oriented films ranged from 6 nm for films deposited at 25°C and  increased  to ~20 nm at higher deposition temperatures of 70°–80°C (Figure 7).Figure 7
Grain size versus deposition temperature for galvanostatic deposition of CeO2 on stainless steel with j = −0.06 mA/cm2.Type 430 is used extensively in SOFC interconnects and  is  exposed to high temperatures [41]. However, type 430 can become sensitized with continuous annealing at higher temperatures of 900°C or above [42]. The (111) preferred oriented CeO2 deposited films were sintered at various temperatures for short time periods (1 hr).  The CeO2 (111) reflection in XRD becomes shaper and more intense as the sintering temperature increases up to 900°C (Figure 8). As the temperature is raised to 1100°C at a constant rate for the thin electrodeposited CeO2 film, the XRD pattern shows a change in both composition and orientation. The CeO2 reverts to a random arrangement with 100-fold lower intensity. Accompanied with this is the evolution of strong substrate peaks indicating higher concentration of substrate components on the surface.  Above 900°C, oxidation of the substrate occurs during thermal treatment and migration of substrate ions to the surface. Sintering in an inert atmosphere may improve the temperature range at the higher limits.  Crystallite size also changes with sintering temperature for the preferred oriented CeO2 films (Figure 9). The estimated crystallite size increases from ~10 nm for the unsintered sample to ~120 nm at 900°C.  A crystallite size minimum is obtained at a sintering temperature of 300°C. It is reasonable to attribute this to the drying and dehydration of green films [43].Figure 8
The XRD patterns for cerium oxide films electrodeposited in galvanostatic mode:j = −0.06 mA/cm2, T = 80°C. (a) unsintered and sintered at temperatures of (b) 300°C, (c) 500°C, (d) 900°C, and (e) 1100°C.Figure 9
Crystallite size versus sintering temperature calculated from X-ray diffraction data of electrodeposited CeO2 films at 70°C with applied current density of −0.06 mA/cm2.The microstructure features of the preferred oriented CeO2 films with sintering are shown in Figure 10. The unsintered CeO2 film exhibits a very smooth surface with cracking and this is probably due to a large mismatch between the substrate and film or drying process [16, 43].  This type of cracking of CeO2 has also been observed for other wet chemical methods of deposition such as electrophoresis [14].  The cracking of the film is retained during sintering and shrinkage of the sample, and the cracking extends its width (Figures 10(b) and 10(c)), as the sintering temperature reaches 500 and 900°C [44]. For the 1100°C sintered sample, corrosion is seen to progress on the CeO2 surface, with the appearance of bulk corrosion products (Fe2O3, etc.) discerned in the SEM.SEM morphologies for CeO2 deposited with galvanostatic mode at 80°C, j = −0.06 mA/cm2; (a) unsintered: x7500; (b) sintered 500°C: x7500; (c) sintered at 900°C: x7500; (d) sintered at 1100°C: x7500.
(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)Linear polarization and Tafel plots were applied to test the corrosion protection effect of the as deposited cerium oxide oriented films. The electrochemical corrosion parameters are summarized in Table3. Calculated from the Tafel plots (Figure 11), the corrosion current decreases from ~7.94 × 10−9 for the substrate to 7.59 × 10−10  A·cm−2 for the CeO2 film coated substrate in a 0.1 M NaCl solution.  Correspondingly, the Rp decreases from 2.63 × 106 for the substrate to 6.69 × 107Ω·cm2 for the CeO2film coated stainless steel. The CeO2 coated substrate exhibits a corrosion positive of the bare stainless steel, indicating an anodic corrosion inhibition mechanism involved for CeO2 coatings. A compact and intact CeO2 film on the surface impedes the ejection of metal ions into the electrolyte, thereby inhibiting corrosion reactions. Generally the immersion experiment suggested cerium oxide/hydroxide as a cathodic inhibitor [10].  However, Crossland and coworkers investigated the formation of anodized cerium oxide/hydroxide film out of Al/Ce alloys and substantiated that this cerium-rich layer provides anodic inhibition to aluminum corrosion [11], which agrees with this study.Table 3
Parameters ofEcorr, icorr, and Rp of CeO2 film and stainless steel.
Material
E
corr (mV)
i
corr (A·cm−2)
R
p
(Ω·cm2)
CeO2 film
50.8
7.5 × 10−10
6.69 × 107
Stainless steel
20.9
7.94 × 10−9
2.63 × 106Figure 11
Tafel plots in 0.1 M NaCl solution.


## 4. Conclusion

Cerium oxide (111) oriented thin films were successfully grown on stainless steel substrate with an anodic electrodeposition technique. A solution of cerium (ΙΙΙ) and a weak organic ligand (acetate) at pH = 7.5  were  used for the deposition.  Preliminary investigation of the coordination between Ce(ΙΙΙ) and the acetate ligand points to a bidentate complex for the 1 : 1 molar metal : acetate solutions.  Preferred orientation of CeO2 films was obtained by tailoring the deposition conditions, suggesting that the optimized deposition parameters for oriented polycrystalline CeO2 include current density lower than –0.06 mA/cm2 with galvanostatic deposition mode and deposition temperatures higher than 50°C.  X-ray diffraction showed the deposited films crystallite size in the nanometer size range, which was further confirmed with Raman. Scanning electron microscopy shows a smooth surface and cracked appearance of the deposits.  Sintering and corrosion experiments were conducted on the deposited films to further illustrate the properties and the possible applications of these thin films. Detailed investigations about optical, electrical, and catalytic properties of cerium oxide films may expand its application perspective.  Also, anodic electrodeposition is a relatively novel synthesis technique for ceramic oxides and worthwhile to extend to other materials. Praseodymium and neodymium oxide depositions with this method are underway in our research group.



---

*Source: 482187-2013-10-27.xml*