# A Simple Microstrip Bandstop Filter Using Cross-Coupling Stubs

Authors: Leung Chiu; Quan Xue
Journal: International Journal of Microwave Science and Technology
 (2012)

---

## Abstract

This paper presents an alterative implementation of a shunt open-circuited stub for multilayer microwave circuit. With making use of the proposed implementation, a simple and compact bandstop filter with a district bandstop characteristics and a first spurious at the third harmonic is proposed. The proposed filter exhibits about 12.5% fractional bandwidth of −10 dB signal rejection at the center frequency of 2.04 GHz and flat group delay at the pass bands. Besides, by cascading a number of the proposed bandstop filters designed at the different frequencies, multiband bandstop filters can be easily realized. A dual- (tri-) band design at the center frequencies of 2 GHz and 3 GHz (and 4 GHz) is designed, realized, and measured. The proposed bandstop filter well suits the nowadays multilayer and compact radio frequency integrated circuit design.


---

## Body

## 1. Introduction

Bandstop filter is one of the indispensable components for radio frequency and microwave circuits’ applications. This filter rejects unwanted signals such as harmonic and spurious signals and allows desired signal to pass through. Recently, a kind of bandstop filter has been integrated into nonlinear circuits such as mixer, oscillator, and amplifier to enhance their performances [1–3].Electromagnetic band gap (EBG) and resonant structures are found interesting in designing bandstop filter. EBG structure exhibits bandstop effect because of the band gap effect [4, 5]. EBG structure is a periodic structure; hence, the strength of the bandstop effectiveness is determined by the number of stage of the unit cells. It occupies large circuit area if a strong or a significant bandstop effect is required.Patterned ground structures and resonance cells belong to the family of the resonant structures. They provide bandstop effect by its nature resonance characteristics. For the patterned ground structure, the slotted pattern on the ground plane can be modeled as anLC resonator to have strong bandstop effect; however, strong radiation is found on the pattern ground to introduce electromagnetic compatibility and interference issues. Besides, the reported works on the resonance cells cannot achieve low insertion losses at the both lower and higher pass bands at the same time leading to the limited applications [6].A shunt open-circuited stub is the simplest bandstop structure for microwave circuit design. Figure1 shows the schematic diagram of the proposed bandstop structure modified from a simple shunt open-circuited stub and its frequency response. It exhibits distinct bandstop characteristics with sharp roll-off and the first spurious response at the third harmonic. It consists of a pair of quarter wavelength open-circuited stubs separated by quarter wavelength, where Z0 is the port impedance, ZS is the characteristics impedance of the shunt stub, and C is capacitance between the two stubs. Cross-coupling between the two stubs helps to enhance the bandstop effect by introducing two transmission zeros within the stop band. A bandstop filter with similar schematic diagram was reported in [7]. The idea is realized by planar microstrip lines; however, it is still found that it occupies large circuit area.(a) Schematic diagram of the proposed bandstop filter. (b) Calculated frequency response of the|S21| with different C and fixed ZS = 100 Ω. (c) Calculated frequency response of the |S21| with different ZS and fixed C = 0.03 pF.
(a)
(b)
(c)In this paper, a multilayer structure to realize the modified bandstop structure as shown in Figure1(a) is proposed. Recently, low-temperature cofire ceramic and CMOS techniques are found particularly suitable to realize multilayer structure to further reduce the circuit size. The proposed concept provides an alternative solution for the integrated circuit to realize shunt open-circuited stubs and other related circuit elements.


## 2. Analysis

A simple open circuit shunt stub is the simplest way to realize bandstop filter that stops the signal at the frequency with stub’s electrical length of 90°. The roll-off of the filter can be improved by increasing the number of the shunt stub; however, the circuit size will be increased too. Cross-coupling is introduced into the design with two shunt stubs and maintained roll-off performance. The characteristic impedances of the two shunt stubs and the section of transmission line areZS and Z0, respectively. The electrical lengths of all lines are 90°. The cross-coupling is modeled by the capacitor C connecting between the ends of the two stubs.With the symmetric structure of the proposed filter, even- and odd-mode analysis can be applied. TheS-parameters of the structure shown in Figure 1(a) are given by(1)S11=S22=12{1-j((Z0/ZS)tan2θ+tanθ)1+j((Z0/ZS)tan2θ+tanθ)S11=S22+=12+1+j[(Z0/ZS)((2ωCZS+tan2θ)/(2ωCZStan2θ-1))+(1/tanθ)]1-j[(Z0/ZS)((2ωCZS+tan2θ)/(2ωCZStan2θ-1))+(1/tanθ)]}S12=S21=12{1-j((Z0/ZS)tan2θ+tanθ)1+j((Z0/ZS)tan2θ+tanθ)S12=S21+=12-1+j[(Z0/ZS)((2ωCZS+tan2θ)/(2ωCZStan2θ-1))+(1/tanθ)]1-j[(Z0/ZS)((2ωCZS+tan2θ)/(2ωCZStan2θ-1))+(1/tanθ)]},where θ=(πf/4f0). f and f0 are the center frequency and operating frequency, respectively. Z0 = 50 Ω is chosen and is the same as port impedance. Parametric studies with different values of C and ZS are shown in Figures 1(b) and 1(c), respectively. The cross-coupling introduces two transmission zeros at the stop band. The larger C results in the stronger cross-coupling between the two stubs. The stop band bandwidth and roll-off can be improved by introducing suitable cross-coupling. With keeping the same C, the stop band bandwidth is adjusted by the characteristic impedance ZS of the stubs. The bandwidth is reduced with increasing ZS.


## 3. Multilayer Shunt Open-CircuitedStub Implementation

Figure2 shows the geometry of the proposed implementation of microstrip shunt open-circuited stub. It consists of three conductor layers, namely, ground plane, middle strip layer, and upper strip layer. Dielectric substrate is completely filled between the layers. The dielectric substrate used has dielectric constant of 2.65, substrate thickness of each dielectric layer of 0.8 mm, and metal thickness of 0.02 mm. The thicknesses of the two dielectric substrates are not necessarily equal, while these thicknesses are assigned to be equal in this paper.Figure 2
3D and side views of the proposed open-circuit stubs (conductor only). (a) Version 1: the middle conductor connected to the upper-layer conductor. (b) Version 2: the middle conductor connected to the ground layer.The proposed implementation has no difference from the conventional microstrip line, except that there are a middle conductor layer and a metallic via between middle and either upper or ground layer. The two different versions of the implementations as shown in Figures2(a) and 2(b) are exactly the same theoretically. It is preferable to connect the middle and ground layers by the metallic via as shown in Figure 2(b), since it can have smaller insertion loss and is easier to integrate lumped element or active device on the upper layer than that as shown in Figure 2(a) in the practical implementation.Figure3(a) shows the equivalent circuit model of the structure as shown in Figure 2(b). The length of the conductor at the middle is set to be quarter wavelength. By tuning its width, the characteristics impedance of shunt stub in the equivalent circuit can be changed. Figure 3 shows the bandstop characteristics with different conductor width at the middle layer. The parametric study showing the relationship between the conductor width and the corresponding characteristics impedance (ZS) is shown in Figure 3(b).(a) The equivalent circuit model of the structure as shown in Figure2(b). (b) Simulated frequency responses of |S21| of the structure as shown in Figure 2(b) with different width at middle layer and the corresponding equivalent ZS, where θ is set to be 90° at 2 GHz.
(a)
(b)


## 4. Application: Bandstop Filter

### 4.1. Single-Band Design

A working prototype was realized by a standard printed circuit board fabrication technique. The dielectric substrate used is the same as reported in previous section. By arranging two shunt open-circuited stubs in the antiparallel configuration as shown in Figure4, a bandstop filter is realized. With keeping uniform width of a 50 Ω line, we just tune the line width (W=1.5 mm), the line length (Ll = 23 mm), the line separation (S=1.44 mm), and the overlapping line (LO = 20.2 mm). The entire printed circuit board size is 10 cm by 5 cm.3D and side views of the proposed bandstop filter using the proposed implementation with dimensions of the line width (W=1.5 mm), the line length (Ll=23 mm), the line separation (S=1.44 mm), and the overlapping line (LO=20.2 mm).
(a)
(b)Figure5 shows the both simulated and measured S-parameters and group delays of the proposed bandstop filter. The corresponding values of the circuit model as shown in Figure 1(a) are Z0 = 50 Ω, ZS = 209 Ω, and C = 3.55 fF, and the center frequency is set to be 2 GHz. It exhibits distinct stop band at the center frequency of 2.04 GHz with the first spurious response at about 6 GHz. The measured −10 dB signal rejection bandwidth is 12.5%. Acceptable agreement between the model, the simulation, and the measurement is obtained. However, the soldering between the via and the conductors are not modeled resulting in the inaccurate prediction especially of the return loss performance as shown in Figure 5(b).Calculated, simulated, and measured performances of the proposed single-bandstop filter. (a)S21, (b) S11, and (c) group delay.
(a)
(b)
(c)


### 4.2. Multiband Design

In order to meet different standards simultaneously, dual-band or multiband designs should be employed to meet the various specializations. By connecting a number of the proposed bandstop filters designed at different frequencies in series connection as shown in Figure6, a multiband design can easily be realized. A dual-band design at the center frequencies of about 2 GHz and 3 GHz and a triband design at the center frequencies of about 2 GHz, 3 GHz, and 4 GHz are realized to demonstrate the multiband concept. Their simulated and measured performances are shown in Figure 7. The dual-band design offers two distinct stop bands at the center frequencies of 2.04 GHz and 2.87 GHz with fractional bandwidths of 12.5% and 11.8%, respectively, while the triband design offers an extra stop band at the center frequencies of 3.97 GHz with fractional bandwidths of 13.9%. The dimension of each section of the multiband bandstop filter can be designed separately and each section is almost independent to others. The 3 GHz bandstop filter (BSF2) has physical dimensions of W=1.50 mm, Ll=16.0 mm, S=1.44 mm, and LO=13.2 mm and electrical parameters of Z0=50 Ω, ZS=209 Ω, and C=2.37 fF. The 4 GHz bandstop filter (BSF3) has physical dimensions of W=1.50 mm, Ll=11.5 mm, S=1.44 mm, and LO=8.70 mm and electrical parameters of Z0=50 Ω, ZS=209 Ω, and C = 1.78 fF. The two filters were built on the two separated printed circuit boards with physical size of 10 cm by 5 cm. The proposed bandstop filters achieve very compact design without changing the signal line, while some of the previously proposed filters such as [5–7] achieve bandstop performance by etching 2D patterns on the single line or dielectric substrate.Geometries of the proposed multiband bandstop filters consisting a number of subbandstop filters (BSFs). (a) Dual-band bandstop filter. (b) Triband bandstop filter.
(a)
(b)MeasuredS-parameters of the proposed multiband bandstop filters. (a) Dual-band bandstop filter. (b) Triband bandstop filter.
(a)
(b)


## 4.1. Single-Band Design

A working prototype was realized by a standard printed circuit board fabrication technique. The dielectric substrate used is the same as reported in previous section. By arranging two shunt open-circuited stubs in the antiparallel configuration as shown in Figure4, a bandstop filter is realized. With keeping uniform width of a 50 Ω line, we just tune the line width (W=1.5 mm), the line length (Ll = 23 mm), the line separation (S=1.44 mm), and the overlapping line (LO = 20.2 mm). The entire printed circuit board size is 10 cm by 5 cm.3D and side views of the proposed bandstop filter using the proposed implementation with dimensions of the line width (W=1.5 mm), the line length (Ll=23 mm), the line separation (S=1.44 mm), and the overlapping line (LO=20.2 mm).
(a)
(b)Figure5 shows the both simulated and measured S-parameters and group delays of the proposed bandstop filter. The corresponding values of the circuit model as shown in Figure 1(a) are Z0 = 50 Ω, ZS = 209 Ω, and C = 3.55 fF, and the center frequency is set to be 2 GHz. It exhibits distinct stop band at the center frequency of 2.04 GHz with the first spurious response at about 6 GHz. The measured −10 dB signal rejection bandwidth is 12.5%. Acceptable agreement between the model, the simulation, and the measurement is obtained. However, the soldering between the via and the conductors are not modeled resulting in the inaccurate prediction especially of the return loss performance as shown in Figure 5(b).Calculated, simulated, and measured performances of the proposed single-bandstop filter. (a)S21, (b) S11, and (c) group delay.
(a)
(b)
(c)


## 4.2. Multiband Design

In order to meet different standards simultaneously, dual-band or multiband designs should be employed to meet the various specializations. By connecting a number of the proposed bandstop filters designed at different frequencies in series connection as shown in Figure6, a multiband design can easily be realized. A dual-band design at the center frequencies of about 2 GHz and 3 GHz and a triband design at the center frequencies of about 2 GHz, 3 GHz, and 4 GHz are realized to demonstrate the multiband concept. Their simulated and measured performances are shown in Figure 7. The dual-band design offers two distinct stop bands at the center frequencies of 2.04 GHz and 2.87 GHz with fractional bandwidths of 12.5% and 11.8%, respectively, while the triband design offers an extra stop band at the center frequencies of 3.97 GHz with fractional bandwidths of 13.9%. The dimension of each section of the multiband bandstop filter can be designed separately and each section is almost independent to others. The 3 GHz bandstop filter (BSF2) has physical dimensions of W=1.50 mm, Ll=16.0 mm, S=1.44 mm, and LO=13.2 mm and electrical parameters of Z0=50 Ω, ZS=209 Ω, and C=2.37 fF. The 4 GHz bandstop filter (BSF3) has physical dimensions of W=1.50 mm, Ll=11.5 mm, S=1.44 mm, and LO=8.70 mm and electrical parameters of Z0=50 Ω, ZS=209 Ω, and C = 1.78 fF. The two filters were built on the two separated printed circuit boards with physical size of 10 cm by 5 cm. The proposed bandstop filters achieve very compact design without changing the signal line, while some of the previously proposed filters such as [5–7] achieve bandstop performance by etching 2D patterns on the single line or dielectric substrate.Geometries of the proposed multiband bandstop filters consisting a number of subbandstop filters (BSFs). (a) Dual-band bandstop filter. (b) Triband bandstop filter.
(a)
(b)MeasuredS-parameters of the proposed multiband bandstop filters. (a) Dual-band bandstop filter. (b) Triband bandstop filter.
(a)
(b)


## 5. Conclusion

A new shunt stub implementation scheme is proposed for bandstop filter design. Distinct bandstop ability with sharp roll-off is achieved by cross-coupling between two quarter-wave shunt stubs separated by a section of transmission line with quarter wavelength long. A flat response of the group delay at the pass bands is achieved. By connecting several bandstop filters designed at the different frequencies, a multiband design can be easily realized. It is a simple bandstop structure, which well suits multilayer integrated circuit design. The proposed filter achieves 1D design, while the previous bandstop filter requires 2D patterns on the signal lines.



---

*Source: 473030-2012-08-08.xml*