# Effect of UV Laser Conditioning on the Structure of KDP Crystal

Authors: Decheng Guo; Xiaodong Jiang; Jing Huang; Fengrui Wang; Hongjie Liu; Xiaotao Zu
Journal: Advances in Condensed Matter Physics
 (2014)

---

## Abstract

Multiparametric raster scanning experiments for KDP crystals are carried out to study the laser conditioning efficiency as a function of laser fluence, fluence step, and pulse sequence by using ultraviolet (UV) laser irradiation with pulse duration of approximately 7 ns. It indicates that damage resistance of KDP can be enhanced after conditioning process. And laser conditioning efficiency depends on the maximal fluence which is below the damage threshold. Raman spectra and photothermal absorption have also been studied on KDP crystals before and after multiparametric laser conditioning. Photothermal absorption data reveal that absorbance of conditioned KDP crystal decreases with the increase of laser fluence and the damage threshold of low absorption area is higher. Raman analysis reveals that the effectiveness of laser conditioning relies mainly on the individual mode of PO4 molecule.


---

## Body

## 1. Introduction

Potassium dihydrogen phosphate (KDP), with good physical properties including large nonlinear optical coefficient, good structural quality, and mechanical properties, is used in many large-aperture laser systems as frequency conversion crystal and electrooptic switching. However, its maximal fluence remains a significant limitation in high power laser project [1]. In order to increase the laser induced damage threshold (LIDT), two confirmed treatments for improving laser resistibility have been demonstrated, including thermal annealing [2, 3] and laser conditioning [4, 5]. Laser conditioning is the reliable mitigation method, which gives the most convincing results [6, 7]. Laser conditioning efficiency is largely determined by the preexposure laser parameters, such as laser fluence, wavelength, pulse number, and length [8, 9]. For instance, Negres et al. reported the effectiveness of laser conditioning with 355 nm, 2.5 ns laser pulses with increasing fluence in deuterated potassium dihydrogen phosphate (DKDP) crystals as a function of fluence step and number of pulses per step. Their results demonstrate that a key laser parameter in achieving the best damage performance at 355 nm is the maximal fluence and that this parameter is material dependent [4]. DeMange et al. investigated the damage behavior of KDP and DKDP crystals under 1064 nm, 532 nm, and 355 nm irradiation subsequent to laser conditioning. Their results reveal that the level of conditioning is strongly dependent on the conditioning wavelength [10].The mechanisms of laser conditioning are still not well understood, although there is a strong implication that the interaction of intrinsic and/or extrinsic defects with subdamage laser fluence plays a key role [11–13]. In order to understand this, most research using nondestructive techniques is performed such as Raman spectrum and optical absorption. These techniques give information on the physical and chemical nature of the defects. Marshall and coworkers described that the 266 nm light causes a broad absorption band at 300 nm–650 nm via two-photo absorption [14]. Woods et al. observed a weak correlation between the scattering centers and the initiation sites of damage [15]. Damiani et al. [16] investigated the KDP with different nondestructive optical diagnostics during the conditioning using an excimer laser at 351 nm. They demonstrated a correlation between the optical signal intensity and the laser induced damage thresholds (LIDT). But there are few reports about structural changes for KDP crystals during the raster scanning conditioning process.In this paper, we attempt to use a nondestructive optical analysis approach by studying the effect of scan-conditioning via using an Nd-YAG laser at 355 nm with different laser parameters. Structural modification for KDP after irradiation was characterized by using Raman spectra and photothermal absorption. The correlations between the spectral information and conditioning effect are discussed. This work aims to obtain a better knowledge of the laser conditioning mechanism.


## 2. Experimental Set-Up and Procedure

### 2.1. The Scan Layout

The experimental layout is drawn in Figure1. The laser source is an Nd-YAG laser operating at 355 nm. The laser has a Gaussian temporal profile with pulse duration of about 7 ns. The maximum energy is 200 mJ, and the maximum repetition rate is 10 Hz. The KDP sample was cut to 50 × 50 × 5 mm3 size plate and positioned in the laser beam with a three-dimensional motorized stage. A CCD acts as a scattering diagnostic to capture the image of bulk damage orthogonally to the direction of laser propagation, through the side of the sample.Figure 1
Optical layout of laser conditioning and damage test experiment.For the conditioning experiments the sample was scanned continuously along thex-axis and then stopped along the y-axis at the end of each scan as shown in Figure 2. The diameter between two adjacent spots is the diameter determined from the 90%-of-peak-fluence beam.Figure 2
Schematic of scan-conditioning on a crystal.


### 2.2. Experimental Procedure

We measured the crystal by two different methods before and after laser conditioning. Photothermal measurement was performed with photothermal common-path interferometer by using a 2.0~2.5 mW He-Ne laser at 632.8 nm as probe light under the Nd-YAG laser excitation at 355 nm. The principle is to measure the absorption of the material with a photothermal effect. Light energy absorbed and not lost by subsequent emission results in sample heating. This heating results in a temperature change and changes in thermodynamic parameters of the sample which are related to temperature. Measurements of the temperature, pressure, or density changes that occur due to optical absorption are ultimately the basis for the photothermal spectroscopic methods; Raman spectra measurement was performed with a Nicolet Raman 950 spectrometer by using a 1064 nm laser as excitation source with a power of 4 mW at room temperature.For the experiments, the KDP crystal was separated into four different areas of 20 × 20 mm2. One squared area is a pristine region. The other three areas are exposed to the conditioning pulse with subdamage threshold fluence.


## 2.1. The Scan Layout

The experimental layout is drawn in Figure1. The laser source is an Nd-YAG laser operating at 355 nm. The laser has a Gaussian temporal profile with pulse duration of about 7 ns. The maximum energy is 200 mJ, and the maximum repetition rate is 10 Hz. The KDP sample was cut to 50 × 50 × 5 mm3 size plate and positioned in the laser beam with a three-dimensional motorized stage. A CCD acts as a scattering diagnostic to capture the image of bulk damage orthogonally to the direction of laser propagation, through the side of the sample.Figure 1
Optical layout of laser conditioning and damage test experiment.For the conditioning experiments the sample was scanned continuously along thex-axis and then stopped along the y-axis at the end of each scan as shown in Figure 2. The diameter between two adjacent spots is the diameter determined from the 90%-of-peak-fluence beam.Figure 2
Schematic of scan-conditioning on a crystal.


## 2.2. Experimental Procedure

We measured the crystal by two different methods before and after laser conditioning. Photothermal measurement was performed with photothermal common-path interferometer by using a 2.0~2.5 mW He-Ne laser at 632.8 nm as probe light under the Nd-YAG laser excitation at 355 nm. The principle is to measure the absorption of the material with a photothermal effect. Light energy absorbed and not lost by subsequent emission results in sample heating. This heating results in a temperature change and changes in thermodynamic parameters of the sample which are related to temperature. Measurements of the temperature, pressure, or density changes that occur due to optical absorption are ultimately the basis for the photothermal spectroscopic methods; Raman spectra measurement was performed with a Nicolet Raman 950 spectrometer by using a 1064 nm laser as excitation source with a power of 4 mW at room temperature.For the experiments, the KDP crystal was separated into four different areas of 20 × 20 mm2. One squared area is a pristine region. The other three areas are exposed to the conditioning pulse with subdamage threshold fluence.


## 3. Results and Analysis

### 3.1. Performance of Laser Conditioning

The dependence of conditioning efficiency on preexposure laser parameters was measured by using R/1 scanning mode. Pristine KDP crystals were exposed first to the conditioning pulse at different parameters including fluence, pulse number, and fluence step. And then the bulk damage probability test was measured by 1/1 mode; the results were shown in Figures3(a), 3(b), and 3(c) separately. The samples were scanned at different ramped fluence procedures: 0.77–1.84–2.82 J/cm2, 0.77–1.84–2.82–3.77 J/cm2, and 0.77–1.84–2.82–3.77–4.59 J/cm2 which are called three-fluence, four-fluence, and five-fluence scanning, respectively. As shown in Figure 3(a), the damage threshold increases with increasing preexposure pulse fluence starting from the lowest tested three-fluence scanning after raster-conditioning. The damage probability fluence for the four-fluence scanning is ~1.22X higher than that of three-fluence scanning. And that for five-fluence scanning is ~1.18X higher than that of four-fluence scanning. So it is clear that the higher laser fluence enhances the damage resistance further.Results of 1-on-1 damage testing of R-on-1 scan-conditioned KDP crystals with multiparametric conditions: (a) laser fluence; (b) pulse number; (c) fluence step. Light gray lines were fitted linear.
(a)
(b)
(c)As shown in Figure3(b), the damage probability fluence with three pulses is 1.1X higher than that with two pulses (the preexposure fluence is 4.59 J/cm2). But the damage probability fluence with four pulses is smaller than that with two and three pulses. Therefore, this result indicates that an appropriate quantity of scanning pulses can improve the effect of conditioning, but too many pulses may decrease the conditioning efficiency.As shown in Figure3(c), the damage probability fluence with two fluence steps (ramping fluence interval is about 1.5 J/cm2) is 1.2X higher than that with one fluence step (ramping fluence interval is about 1 J/cm2). And the result of three fluence steps (ramping fluence interval is about 2 J/cm2) is smaller than the others. Consequently, this result indicated that an appropriate level of scanning steps can improve the effect of conditioning, but too big steps may decrease the conditioning efficiency.As shown in Figure3, the laser conditioning with subdamage threshold fluence can improve the laser damage resistance capability of KDP crystals. The laser conditioning efficiency increases with increase in preexposure pulse fluence, while an appropriate quantity of scanning pulses and steps can enhance the conditioning efficiency further. In other words, the effectiveness of laser conditioning relies mainly on the maximal conditioning fluence. For this case, the possible explanation is that the first conditioning pulse with the lower fluence only passivizes the biggest defect clusters. And with the increase of laser fluence, smaller and smaller clusters are treated [17]. For the process of multiple-pulses conditioning, it may be understood with defect absorber model. Under the irradiation of successive laser pulses, defect absorber and surrounding material are easy to be heated up to decomposition temperature due to the energy accumulation [11]. Therefore, the appropriate number of pulses can increase the effectiveness of laser conditioning. The energy cumulative effect can also explain the influence of fluence step on the laser conditioning efficiency. However, some other changes occur in surrounding material or absorber itself due to thermochemical and mechanochemical process before being heated up to decomposition temperature. That is why the appropriate fluence step can increase the damage resistance rather than the maximum fluence.


### 3.2. Photothermal Absorption

Absorption coefficient of the KDP crystal is measured with a photothermal common-path interferometer which is based on a consistent interference approach to the optical detection. Three areas are scanned. The result is displayed in Figure4. The absorption coefficient after raster-conditioning decreases with the increasing in preexposure pulse fluence.Figure 4
Photothermal absorption measurement of KDP crystal.In order to understand the correlation between the absorption and laser induced damage, the damage threshold of two different areas measured by 1-on-1 mode is given in Figure5. Apparently, the area of the low absorption value has the high damage resistance. For this area, laser pulse with 7 J/cm2 cannot raise the damage incident. At 9.3 J/cm2 the damage probability is 50%. For the area with strong absorption, the probability increases to 90% at 9.3 J/cm2. Consequently, it intimates that the initial damage may be correlated with the absorption due to changing of various defects in bulk KDP crystal. Further, in the laser conditioning process, various types of defects which exist in crystal are treated. The precursor defects may be annihilated due to the thermally activated migration or induced phase transition and a subsequent crystalline rearrangement by high temperature. As a consequence, some defect absorption vanishes [18]. Therefore, damage resistibility of low absorption area is higher than that of strong absorption area.Figure 5
1-on-1 test of the KDP for two absorbing areas.


### 3.3. Raman Spectroscopy

Figure6 shows Raman spectra of KDP at room temperature before and after laser conditioning. Spectral data and proposed assignment, which are in good accordance with the results of Serra et al. [19] and Agrawal and Perry [20], were described in Table 1. The Raman active modes belong to the A1, B1, B2, and E representations of the factor group D2d. Modes belonging to the B and E representations are simultaneously Raman and infrared active. According to Som et al., the peak observed at 114 cm−1 may be assigned to K-PO4 translatory vibrations [22]. The peak at 181 cm−1 can be assigned to the H2PO4 rotational band [21]. The strongest peak at 914 cm−1 can be assigned to PO4 totally symmetric stretching mode [23]. In this experiment, no apparent shifting of all the modes was observed with change in laser conditioning parameters. No other alteration in the intensity change of the 914 cm−1 mode which is attributed to the totally symmetric stretching model of PO4 tetrahedra is observed in Figures 6(b) and 6(c) compared to Figure 6(a). The intensity of the 914 cm−1 mode of conditioned crystal by the changing of laser fluence is lower than pristine crystal. Compared with pure KDP, the intensity of less than 300 cm−1 mode of laser conditioned crystals is decreased in all cases. The decrease of the intensity of all the modes may be attributed to the following possibilities: (1) depolarization of the Raman scattering light causing change of spectra, because depolarization will lower the intensity of all A1 modes [23], (2) the rotation of the crystal axes causing change of the Raman spectrum (the intensity of all the modes decreases for the spectra by changing the angle of crystal axes from 50° to 90° [24]), and (3) decrease of the absorption associated with the PO4 molecule causing decrease of Raman spectrum [23]. For the 914 cm−1 mode, changing of its intensity merely occurs at different conditioning fluence operation. And the effectiveness of laser conditioning relies mainly on the conditioning fluence. This result strongly indicates that the effectiveness of laser conditioning is associated with the individual mode of PO4 molecule. Therefore, in the laser conditioning process, the low laser fluence cannot cause severe vibration and a subsequent distortion of the PO4 tetrahedra [25]. For the modes located at 114, 170, and 181 cm−1, variation on intensity may be attributed to the decrease of the absorption due to recombination of electron-defects or release of lattice stress causing change of these modes under subdamage threshold laser irradiation. And there is no structural phase transition because the mode at 181 cm−1 did not show an anomalous behavior in the laser conditioning process [19]. These modes are also associated with PO4 tetrahedra, and then these changes suggest that the effectiveness of laser conditioning is associated with the small deformation of the PO4 tetrahedral units.Table 1
Assignment of Raman active mode frequencies of KDP at 300 K.
Mode
This work
Serra et al. [19]
Agrawal and Perry [20]
Assignment [21]
A1
356
363.9
360
δ
s  [PO2, P(OH)2
]
A1
914
916.9
918
ν
s  P(OH)2
B1
475
474.5
479
δ
r  [PO2, P(OH)2
]
B1
557
564.1
570
δ
sc  [PO2, P(OH)2
]
B2
181
179.5
174
Lattice vibrations
B2
391
394
386
γ
τ  P(OH)2
E
114
114
113
Lattice vibrations
ν
s: very strong, s: strong, m: medium, and w: weak.Comparison of Raman spectra obtained by multiparametric conditions: (a) laser fluence; (b) pulse number; (c) fluence step.
(a)
(b)
(c)


## 3.1. Performance of Laser Conditioning

The dependence of conditioning efficiency on preexposure laser parameters was measured by using R/1 scanning mode. Pristine KDP crystals were exposed first to the conditioning pulse at different parameters including fluence, pulse number, and fluence step. And then the bulk damage probability test was measured by 1/1 mode; the results were shown in Figures3(a), 3(b), and 3(c) separately. The samples were scanned at different ramped fluence procedures: 0.77–1.84–2.82 J/cm2, 0.77–1.84–2.82–3.77 J/cm2, and 0.77–1.84–2.82–3.77–4.59 J/cm2 which are called three-fluence, four-fluence, and five-fluence scanning, respectively. As shown in Figure 3(a), the damage threshold increases with increasing preexposure pulse fluence starting from the lowest tested three-fluence scanning after raster-conditioning. The damage probability fluence for the four-fluence scanning is ~1.22X higher than that of three-fluence scanning. And that for five-fluence scanning is ~1.18X higher than that of four-fluence scanning. So it is clear that the higher laser fluence enhances the damage resistance further.Results of 1-on-1 damage testing of R-on-1 scan-conditioned KDP crystals with multiparametric conditions: (a) laser fluence; (b) pulse number; (c) fluence step. Light gray lines were fitted linear.
(a)
(b)
(c)As shown in Figure3(b), the damage probability fluence with three pulses is 1.1X higher than that with two pulses (the preexposure fluence is 4.59 J/cm2). But the damage probability fluence with four pulses is smaller than that with two and three pulses. Therefore, this result indicates that an appropriate quantity of scanning pulses can improve the effect of conditioning, but too many pulses may decrease the conditioning efficiency.As shown in Figure3(c), the damage probability fluence with two fluence steps (ramping fluence interval is about 1.5 J/cm2) is 1.2X higher than that with one fluence step (ramping fluence interval is about 1 J/cm2). And the result of three fluence steps (ramping fluence interval is about 2 J/cm2) is smaller than the others. Consequently, this result indicated that an appropriate level of scanning steps can improve the effect of conditioning, but too big steps may decrease the conditioning efficiency.As shown in Figure3, the laser conditioning with subdamage threshold fluence can improve the laser damage resistance capability of KDP crystals. The laser conditioning efficiency increases with increase in preexposure pulse fluence, while an appropriate quantity of scanning pulses and steps can enhance the conditioning efficiency further. In other words, the effectiveness of laser conditioning relies mainly on the maximal conditioning fluence. For this case, the possible explanation is that the first conditioning pulse with the lower fluence only passivizes the biggest defect clusters. And with the increase of laser fluence, smaller and smaller clusters are treated [17]. For the process of multiple-pulses conditioning, it may be understood with defect absorber model. Under the irradiation of successive laser pulses, defect absorber and surrounding material are easy to be heated up to decomposition temperature due to the energy accumulation [11]. Therefore, the appropriate number of pulses can increase the effectiveness of laser conditioning. The energy cumulative effect can also explain the influence of fluence step on the laser conditioning efficiency. However, some other changes occur in surrounding material or absorber itself due to thermochemical and mechanochemical process before being heated up to decomposition temperature. That is why the appropriate fluence step can increase the damage resistance rather than the maximum fluence.


## 3.2. Photothermal Absorption

Absorption coefficient of the KDP crystal is measured with a photothermal common-path interferometer which is based on a consistent interference approach to the optical detection. Three areas are scanned. The result is displayed in Figure4. The absorption coefficient after raster-conditioning decreases with the increasing in preexposure pulse fluence.Figure 4
Photothermal absorption measurement of KDP crystal.In order to understand the correlation between the absorption and laser induced damage, the damage threshold of two different areas measured by 1-on-1 mode is given in Figure5. Apparently, the area of the low absorption value has the high damage resistance. For this area, laser pulse with 7 J/cm2 cannot raise the damage incident. At 9.3 J/cm2 the damage probability is 50%. For the area with strong absorption, the probability increases to 90% at 9.3 J/cm2. Consequently, it intimates that the initial damage may be correlated with the absorption due to changing of various defects in bulk KDP crystal. Further, in the laser conditioning process, various types of defects which exist in crystal are treated. The precursor defects may be annihilated due to the thermally activated migration or induced phase transition and a subsequent crystalline rearrangement by high temperature. As a consequence, some defect absorption vanishes [18]. Therefore, damage resistibility of low absorption area is higher than that of strong absorption area.Figure 5
1-on-1 test of the KDP for two absorbing areas.


## 3.3. Raman Spectroscopy

Figure6 shows Raman spectra of KDP at room temperature before and after laser conditioning. Spectral data and proposed assignment, which are in good accordance with the results of Serra et al. [19] and Agrawal and Perry [20], were described in Table 1. The Raman active modes belong to the A1, B1, B2, and E representations of the factor group D2d. Modes belonging to the B and E representations are simultaneously Raman and infrared active. According to Som et al., the peak observed at 114 cm−1 may be assigned to K-PO4 translatory vibrations [22]. The peak at 181 cm−1 can be assigned to the H2PO4 rotational band [21]. The strongest peak at 914 cm−1 can be assigned to PO4 totally symmetric stretching mode [23]. In this experiment, no apparent shifting of all the modes was observed with change in laser conditioning parameters. No other alteration in the intensity change of the 914 cm−1 mode which is attributed to the totally symmetric stretching model of PO4 tetrahedra is observed in Figures 6(b) and 6(c) compared to Figure 6(a). The intensity of the 914 cm−1 mode of conditioned crystal by the changing of laser fluence is lower than pristine crystal. Compared with pure KDP, the intensity of less than 300 cm−1 mode of laser conditioned crystals is decreased in all cases. The decrease of the intensity of all the modes may be attributed to the following possibilities: (1) depolarization of the Raman scattering light causing change of spectra, because depolarization will lower the intensity of all A1 modes [23], (2) the rotation of the crystal axes causing change of the Raman spectrum (the intensity of all the modes decreases for the spectra by changing the angle of crystal axes from 50° to 90° [24]), and (3) decrease of the absorption associated with the PO4 molecule causing decrease of Raman spectrum [23]. For the 914 cm−1 mode, changing of its intensity merely occurs at different conditioning fluence operation. And the effectiveness of laser conditioning relies mainly on the conditioning fluence. This result strongly indicates that the effectiveness of laser conditioning is associated with the individual mode of PO4 molecule. Therefore, in the laser conditioning process, the low laser fluence cannot cause severe vibration and a subsequent distortion of the PO4 tetrahedra [25]. For the modes located at 114, 170, and 181 cm−1, variation on intensity may be attributed to the decrease of the absorption due to recombination of electron-defects or release of lattice stress causing change of these modes under subdamage threshold laser irradiation. And there is no structural phase transition because the mode at 181 cm−1 did not show an anomalous behavior in the laser conditioning process [19]. These modes are also associated with PO4 tetrahedra, and then these changes suggest that the effectiveness of laser conditioning is associated with the small deformation of the PO4 tetrahedral units.Table 1
Assignment of Raman active mode frequencies of KDP at 300 K.
Mode
This work
Serra et al. [19]
Agrawal and Perry [20]
Assignment [21]
A1
356
363.9
360
δ
s  [PO2, P(OH)2
]
A1
914
916.9
918
ν
s  P(OH)2
B1
475
474.5
479
δ
r  [PO2, P(OH)2
]
B1
557
564.1
570
δ
sc  [PO2, P(OH)2
]
B2
181
179.5
174
Lattice vibrations
B2
391
394
386
γ
τ  P(OH)2
E
114
114
113
Lattice vibrations
ν
s: very strong, s: strong, m: medium, and w: weak.Comparison of Raman spectra obtained by multiparametric conditions: (a) laser fluence; (b) pulse number; (c) fluence step.
(a)
(b)
(c)


## 4. Conclusion

In order to better understand the process of laser scan-conditioning for KDP crystal, the structure properties of KDP crystals are investigated using photothermal absorption and Raman spectra by various laser conditioning parameters. The change of photothermal absorption is related to laser conditioning fluence. In the process of laser conditioning, Raman spectra show a decrease of the intensity of 914 cm−1 mode and less than 300 cm−1 mode. This result suggests that the effectiveness of laser conditioning may be associated with the individual mode of PO4 molecule.



---

*Source: 451048-2014-06-18.xml*