# A Novel Dual-Shorting Point PIFA (GSM850 to IMT-A) for Mobile Handsets

Authors: Pengcheng Li; Jin Pan; Deqiang Yang; Pingzai Nie
Journal: International Journal of Antennas and Propagation
 (2013)

---

## Abstract

A novel planar inverted-F antenna (PIFA) with dual-shorting points is proposed for multiband mobile handsets. The antenna comprises a meandered strip, a feeding point, two shorting points,
and a slotted ground plane. For bandwidth enhancement of DCS/PCS/UMTS/WLAN 11.b/LTE2300/2500 and IMT-Advanced (International Mobile Telecommunications-Advanced),
the antenna applies a dual-shorting points design, which generates a multimode between 1707 and 2815 MHz. The proposed antenna has good impedance matching characteristics
for GSM (824–960 MHz)/DCS (1710–1880 MHz)/PCS (1850–1990 MHz)/UMTS (1920–2170 MHz)/LTE
(2300–2400 MHz, 2500–2690 MHz)/WLAN 11.b (2400–2480 MHz) and IMT-A (4200–4800 MHz).
The measured radiation efficiencies of the proposed antenna were all higher than 60% in GSM850/900, DCS/PCS, UMTS, LTE2300/2500, and WLAN 802.11 b, and it is up to 86% in IMT-A.


---

## Body

## 1. Introduction

With the rapid development of wireless communications, the multistandard mobile communication systems (MSMCS) are required with low cost and compact size. Recently, the long-term evolution (LTE) system is introduced to afford better mobile services to the wireless wide area network (WWAN) and 4G (IMT-Advanced) [1–3]. Owing to the overall size limited for the placing of mobile terminal antenna, it becomes more difficult to achieve wide bandwidths. Conventional planar inverted-F antennas (PIFAs) are no longer a suitable option because of narrow bandwidth.In order to obtain a wide frequency band, the coupled-fed structure is usually applied [4–7]. However, the performance, especially the high-frequency band, is susceptible to the width of the coupling gap. It is difficult to manufacture, and the cost will be increased significantly. Also, it is not suitable for IMT-A (4200–4800 MHz) operation. In order to obtain a compact-size antenna with large and multiple-frequency band, many other constructions for PIFA are applied with probe feeding [1–3, 8]. However, in these designs, it is difficult to realize multiband and wideband operations at the same time. Besides, with microelectromechanical systems (MEMS) element [4–7, 9], the cost is increased inevitably.In this paper, a compact and low-profile antenna is presented. The proposed design has a wide bandwidth, a reduced size, and a high efficiency [10–13]. The presented PIFA occupies a small volume of 46 × 19 × 5.5 mm3. In particular, low-frequency band operation is achieved by two parallel open-end slots on the ground plane. Based on the joint disposition of the PIFA and a meandered monopole in the structure, the multiband operation is realized. Reflection coefficient less than −6 dB is obtained in 704–970 MHz (31.8% relative bandwidth, GSM850/900), 1575–2820 MHz (56.7% relative bandwidth, DCS/PCS/UMTS/LTE2300/25000), and 3850–5490 MHz (35.1% relative bandwidth, IMT-A), respectively.Another issue of mobile terminal antenna is the radiation efficiency. In our design, the efficiency is up to 69% at low-frequency band, it and is more than 52% in the high-frequency band. The structure of the rest of the paper is given as follows. In Section2, geometric structure and prototype of the PIFA is first presented. With dual-shorting point structure, the effect of antenna geometric parameters on performance is discussed in details. To validate our design, simulation and measurement results are demonstrated in Section 3 for comparison. Finally, conclusions are summarized in Section 4.


## 2. Antenna Design and Parametric Study

The proposed antenna structure is shown in Figure1. Length of handset boxes model used in the simulation and measurement is as those used today.Proposed antenna configuration: (a) geometry of the proposed antenna, (b) detailed dimensions of the patch (top view), and (c) detailed dimensions of the ground plane (back view).
(a)
(b)
(c)Its dimensions are given as follows:L1=110 mm, L2=55 mm, L3=38 mm, L4=6 mm, L5=8 mm, L6=6 mm, L7=1 mm, L8=3 mm, L9=32 mm, L10=24 mm, L11=10 mm, L12=10 mm, and L13=40 mm. The little inductor is only 2 × 2 mm2. But the presented PIFA totally occupies 46 × 19 mm2.Figure1(a) shows the 3D mode of the proposed antenna. Points A (A1 and A2) and point C are the shorting points and the feeding point, respectively. For practical mobile handset application, the PIFA is fed using a 50 ohm minicoaxial line at point C. At point B, there is a chip-inductor-loaded strip which contributes to a wideband covering the DCS/PCS/UMTS/LTE2300/2500 and WLAN 11.b operation [9–12, 14–16]. The chip inductor used in the PIFA has an inductance of 11.5 nH. With the shorting points A1 and A2 in Figures 1(a) and 1(b), the meandered strip is proposed as a PIFA with two shorting points. In Figure 1(c), the two slots of the ground plane are applied for the low-frequency resonant band and for enhancing the antenna return loss in the lower part of the band [7, 9, 14–16].Based on the bandwidth specification of 3 : 1 VSWR (6 dB return loss), which is widely approved as the fundamental design requirement of the internal handset antenna, the simulatedS parameter of the proposed PIFA covers 745–1175 MHz, 1707–2815 MHz, and 3600–4900 MHz [11–13, 17–21]. The chip inductor with an inductance of 11.5 nH (L) is applied to the proposed PIFA. This chip inductor is used to improve the bandwidth required for DCS/PCS.Figure2 shows the influence of the chip inductor L for S parameter. Stronger influence on the impedance matching of DCS/PCS/UMTS can be observed, while the inductor L is changed from 4 to 16 nH. When a smaller inductance is used, the obtained bandwidth is decreased due to the decreasing of its resonant mode. After the optimizing, the impedance matching is improved when L is 11.5 nH. A comparison of the simulation reflection coefficient and the input impedance (including the real and imaginary parts) is presented in Figure 3. Quite different from the obtained two resonant modes at about 1800 and 2600 MHz of the proposed PIFA, there is only one resonant mode excited at about 1900 for the single-shorted point antenna. The structure is helpful in achieving better impedance matching for UMTS/WLAN 11.b/LTE2300/2500 operation. In addition, as seen in Figure 3(c), the excited resonant mode for the higher-frequency band (2300–3000 MHz) is contributed by dual-shorting points.Figure 2
SimulatedS parameter as a function of L.Simulated results with shorting points 1 and 2: (a) input impedance (reactance), (b) input impedance (resistance), and (c)S parameter.
(a)
(b)
(c)The resonant mode at 1700 MHz and 2600 MHz also shifts down with the increasing of the length of the meandered strip (the functionL8). In Figure 4(a), the simulated S11 (1400–3000 MHz) is presented when the length L8 varied from 2 mm to 4 mm. Besides, other parameters of the antenna are the same as given in Figure 1. Strong effects on the excited resonant modes indicate that proper selection of the L8 is important in the proposed PIFA. The impedance matching over the DCS/PCS band is also strengthened. The simulated results of three different lengths L8=3, 3.8, and 4.6 mm are presented in Figure 4(b). Similar results can be observed compared with the results shown in Figure 4(a). The length L8 of the meandered strip has a significant effect on the band of 4200–4800 MHz (IMT-A).S parameter as a function of (a) L8 (1400–3000 MHz) and (b) L8 (4000–5000 MHz).
(a)
(b)


## 3. Measured Results

Based on the parameters study in Section2, the PIFA prototype is manufactured as shown in Figure 5. Figure 6 presents the measured S parameter and the simulated S parameter. Because the value of L is not accurate to 11.5 nH, the measured data result is even better than that of the simulation. Three wide operating bands have been obtained for the antenna.Photos of the manufactured antenna: (a) top side and (b) back side.
(a)
(b)MeasuredS parameter and simulated S parameter: (a) 600–3000 MHz and (b) 3000–6000 MHz.
(a)
(b)The radiation patterns, the total efficiency, and the peak gain are measured by the SATIMO measurement system. Figure7 shows the normalized pattern in three principal planes. The measured total efficiency including the mismatching loss for the proposed antenna is presented in Figure 8. Over the lower band (800–1000 MHz and 1600–3000 MHz, Figures 8(a) and 8(b)), the total efficiency and the peak gain of the operation frequency band are 52%–55% and 0.3–2.8 dBi, respectively. For the upper band shown in Figure 8(c), the antenna gain varies from 0.7 to 4.1 dBi, while the total efficiency is better than 52%. From the obtained results, the proposed design for PIFA is a good option for practical internal mobile applications.Measured 2D radiation patterns: (a) 900 MHz, (b) 1900 MHz, (c) 2500 MHz, and (d) 4500 MHz.
(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)Measured antenna peak gain and radiation efficiency: (a) GSM850/900, (b) DCS1800/PCS1900/UMTS/WLAN 11.b/LTE2300/2500, and (c) IMT-A.
(a)
(b)
(c)


## 4. Conclusions

This paper presents a new design for PIFA. Using two open-end parallel slots in the ground plane, a significant improvement in the antenna operational bandwidth at the lower-frequency band can be achieved. The higher-frequency operating band is achieved by comprising two meandered monopoles. Thus, triple-band impedance (704–970 MHz, 1575–2820 MHz, and 3850–5490 MHz) for VSWR ≦ 3 is obtained. The main design dimensions of the meandered strip are studied and discussed. Measured results show that the proposed antenna has good radiation characteristics, including total efficiency and peak gain. With the presence of the multiband and the wideband features, the proposed design of PIFA is attractive for the practical mobile phones.



---

*Source: 436808-2013-09-02.xml*