# Oxidative Stress Indexes for Diagnosis of Health or Disease in Humans

Authors: Martha A. Sánchez-Rodríguez; Víctor Manuel Mendoza-Núñez
Journal: Oxidative Medicine and Cellular Longevity
 (2019)

---

## Abstract

Oxidative stress (OS) is the imbalance between oxidant and antioxidant molecules, in favor of oxidants, that causes aging and disease. Many studies have been published that demonstrate the relationship between OS and human health and disease; however, the following questions arise: (i) how are we sure that the OS is present in a biological process? (ii) Is the OS reported in the different investigations equivalent? (iii) What are the best oxidant and antioxidant markers for OS diagnosis? (iv) Can we establish the types and the intensity of the OS? (v) Does OS index could be useful for research and/or application in clinical medicine? In this regard, several indexes have been proposed to measure OS in humans relative to the state of health and disease, among which the following can be highlighted:Oxidative Stress Index (OSI), Tiol Ratios (-SH/TT, -SS/-SH, and-SS/TT), Glutathione Ratio (GSSG/GSH), Oxidative Stress Score (OSS), and OXY-index. Therefore, the aim of this review is to present the state of the art of knowledge about OS indexes for diagnosis of health or disease in humans. We searched for articles in English or Spanish in the PubMed/MEDLINE and Scopus electronic databases published up until May 2019. The keywords used were “oxidative stress,” “index,” and “oxidative stress index.” It was identified 11479 records in both databases, and 490 articles were analyzed. Our review suggests that all indexes analyzed allow diagnose and differentiate the OS related to human health and disease. Also, the studies on OSI, Oxy-score, and OSS indexes have proven to be reliable, practical, and with clinical utility. However, it is necessary to continue with longitudinal studies, especially assess the usefulness of the indexes in the clinical prognosis, and make comparative studies between the different indexes.


---

## Body

## 1. Introduction

Since that Gerschman et al. and Harman in the 50s proposed the Free Radicals Theory to explain the disease and aging, respectively [1, 2], this theoretical orientation has had a great impulse, mainly after the description of superoxide dismutase (SOD), an antioxidant enzyme, in 1969 [3]. During these years, many researchers have sought the relation among different pathological events and the aging, with the free radicals (FR), oxidized molecules, and antioxidants, based on Free Radicals Theory.The term “oxidative stress” (OS) arises in 1985, as a proposal of Helmut Sies that expresses the imbalance between oxidant and antioxidant molecules, in favor of oxidants, that causes aging and disease [4]. This concept has revolutionized the field of knowledge of FR; thus, most of the research about the oxidants and antioxidants is referred as OS. Likewise, the studies of OS mechanisms had described that the reactions involved in this process are oxidation-reduction reactions (redox) [4, 5].In parallel, the knowledge about the homeostatic function of the FR, oxidants, and antioxidants has been emerging, highlighting its importance in the signaling and maintenance of cellular mechanisms, because FR and oxidants (called reactive species) are essential components in several processes such as phagocytosis and maintenance of the cell membrane, and physiological function such as immunological mechanisms and vascular function, among others [6, 7]. In this sense, actually it is recognized that OS may be separated in oxidative eustress and oxidative distress. In the oxidative eustress, the physiological mechanisms of the reactive species (RS) intervene, mainly by H2O2 reactions, and in the oxidative distress, there are the oxidative damage to biomolecules with disrupted redox signaling that may be causing disease and aging [4, 8]. Although these terms are little used, most researchers use the term OS when they refer at the imbalance between oxidant and antioxidant components.The central problem for the application of OS in biology and clinical medicine is its measurement, considering the complexity of the process and the number of components oxidants and antioxidants that make it up. In this sense, the OS has been measured using different markers, both biomolecules oxidized (lipids, proteins, and DNA) and antioxidants (enzymes and nonenzymatic antioxidants), besides of oxidants (reactive oxygen species), everything in biological samples (Table1) [4, 9–12].Table 1
Biomarkers used in the oxidative stress measurement in human fluids.
Oxidation markers
Lipids
(i) Conjugated dienes (CD)
(ii) Aldehydic products (a) Malondialdehyde (MDA)∗ (b) 4-hydroxy-2-nonenal (4-HNE)
(iii) Alkane exhalation
(iv) Total hydroperoxides (LOOH)
(v) Oxidized LDL (oxo-LDL)
(vi) F2-isoprostanes (F2-Iso)
(vii) Advanced lipid peroxidation end products (ALEs)
DNA
(i) Nucleotide oxidation (a) 8-hydroxy-guanosine (8OHG) (b) 8-hydroxy-desoxyguanosine (8OHdG) (c) Thymidine glycol (d) 7,8-dihydroxy-8-oxo-2′-deoxyguanosine (8oxodG) (e) 5-chlorouracil
(ii) Deoxyribose oxidation
Proteins
(i) Protein carbonyls
(ii) Advanced oxidation protein products (AOPP)
(iii) Amino acid oxidation (a) 3-nitro-tyrosine (b) 3-chloro-tyrosine
(iv) Ischemia-modified albumin (IMA)
(v) Advanced glycation end products (AGEs)
Oxidants
(i) Hydrogen peroxide (H2O2)
(ii) Superoxide anion radical (O2−⋅)
(iii) Nitric oxide (NO⋅)
Antioxidant markers
Nonenzymatic
(i) Vitamins (A, C, E)
(ii) Metals (Se, Zn)
(iii) Glutathione and cysteine
(iv) Uric acid
Enzymes
(i) Superoxide dismutase (SOD)
(ii) Glutathione peroxidase (GPx)
(iii) Glutathione reductase (GR)
(iv) Catalase (CAT)
Nonenzymatic antioxidant capacity
(i) Oxygen radical antioxidant capacity (ORAC)
(ii) Total radical-trapping antioxidant parameter (TRAP)
(iii) Total antioxidant capacity (TAC)
(iv) Total antioxidant status (TAS)
(v) Ferric reducing antioxidant potential (FRAP)
(vi) Antioxidant gap
(vii) Biological antioxidant potential (BAP)
∗We consider MDA and TBARS as the same because TBARS is the procedure most used to measure MDA.Another problem is the variety of methods used to measure the markers in biological samples due to the difference among them. Those methods have different sensibility and reliability and advantages and disadvantages, which hindering its interpretation, and some require very sophisticated techniques [9–11, 13], which have been widely discussed by Forman et al. and Marrocco et al. [9, 13].On the other hand, the measurements of OS for diagnosis of health or disease in humans must be with noninvasive procedures, so that the employment of blood, urine, or other biological fluids is the commonest.In this context, the following questions arise: (i) who are we sure that the OS is present in a biological process? (ii) Is the OS reported in the different investigations equivalent? (iii) What are the best oxidant and antioxidant markers for OS diagnosis? (iv) Can we establish the types and the intensity of the OS? (v) Does OS index could be useful for research and/or application in clinical medicine?Thus, starting from the theory of OS proposed by Sies et al. [4], if exposure to exogenous or endogenous oxidants increases or is insufficiently balanced by antioxidants, oxidative damage occurs to biomolecules, which gives the option to select different oxidants, oxidized molecules, and antioxidants to be measured in a research, making the comparability of the results difficult and generating confusion, perhaps because with individual markers, it is not considered that OS is an integral and dynamic process.With this view, several proposals have been published to evaluate the oxidant/oxidized components and the antioxidants integrally considering a global index to avoid the bias of each marker measurement, which are intended to demonstrate their ability to differentiate the health of the disease, as well the changes produced by the aging process, although the clinical value of the different proposals has not been systematized and/or analyzed.Therefore, the aim of this review of the literature is to present the state of the art of knowledge about OS indexes for diagnosis of health or disease in humans.


## 2. Material and Methods

### 2.1. Data Sources and Search Strategy

We searched for articles in English or Spanish in the PubMed/MEDLINE and Scopus electronic databases published up until May 2019, which included the measurement of oxidative stress using oxidative/antioxidant ratios or indexes. The keywords used were “oxidative stress,” “index,” and “oxidative stress index,” and the specific name of the index was found such as “OSI,” “glutathione ratio,” “thiol ratio,” “oxidative index,” “oxidative balance score,” “OBS,” “OXY score,” and “oxidative stress score.” References in each article were searched to identify missed studies.


### 2.2. Eligibility Criteria and Study Selection

We included the studies that involved human subjects, with experimental or observational design (cross-sectional or longitudinal), assessed any disease or health state as primary event, and used biological samples, no tissues, any age, and sex. We excluded animal and cell culture studies, conference abstracts without full text, case reports and case series, reviews of any kind, editorials, and opinion articles. Also, we excluded the studies that measured oxidants and antioxidants, but the authors did not relate them, that is, they did not calculate a sum or ratio between them.


### 2.3. Analysis of the Information

After removing the duplicate records, we screened the relevant studies from the references retrieved from the databases, reviewing the titles and abstracts. We obtained the full texts of the relevant studies to assess for inclusion or exclusion in this study.The author name, publication year, study design, country, population included (age group, sex), sample size (subjects included in the study), biological sample, main outcome, results, and conclusion related to the ratio or index were extracted from each included study.We found a great number of studies that use the oxidative stress index (OSI) and thiol ratios, so we analyzed this information in a different way to the rest of the ratios and indexes; in fact, the reference list of those indexes is in supplement files (availablehere).The topics included in this review are (i) oxidative balance, (ii) glutathione ratio, (iii) thiol ratios, (iv) oxidative stress index, (v) oxidative index, (vi) oxidative stress profile, (vii) OXY score, and (viii) oxidative stress score.


## 2.1. Data Sources and Search Strategy

We searched for articles in English or Spanish in the PubMed/MEDLINE and Scopus electronic databases published up until May 2019, which included the measurement of oxidative stress using oxidative/antioxidant ratios or indexes. The keywords used were “oxidative stress,” “index,” and “oxidative stress index,” and the specific name of the index was found such as “OSI,” “glutathione ratio,” “thiol ratio,” “oxidative index,” “oxidative balance score,” “OBS,” “OXY score,” and “oxidative stress score.” References in each article were searched to identify missed studies.


## 2.2. Eligibility Criteria and Study Selection

We included the studies that involved human subjects, with experimental or observational design (cross-sectional or longitudinal), assessed any disease or health state as primary event, and used biological samples, no tissues, any age, and sex. We excluded animal and cell culture studies, conference abstracts without full text, case reports and case series, reviews of any kind, editorials, and opinion articles. Also, we excluded the studies that measured oxidants and antioxidants, but the authors did not relate them, that is, they did not calculate a sum or ratio between them.


## 2.3. Analysis of the Information

After removing the duplicate records, we screened the relevant studies from the references retrieved from the databases, reviewing the titles and abstracts. We obtained the full texts of the relevant studies to assess for inclusion or exclusion in this study.The author name, publication year, study design, country, population included (age group, sex), sample size (subjects included in the study), biological sample, main outcome, results, and conclusion related to the ratio or index were extracted from each included study.We found a great number of studies that use the oxidative stress index (OSI) and thiol ratios, so we analyzed this information in a different way to the rest of the ratios and indexes; in fact, the reference list of those indexes is in supplement files (availablehere).The topics included in this review are (i) oxidative balance, (ii) glutathione ratio, (iii) thiol ratios, (iv) oxidative stress index, (v) oxidative index, (vi) oxidative stress profile, (vii) OXY score, and (viii) oxidative stress score.


## 3. Results and Discussion

It was identified 11479 records, in both databases, with the selected keywords. After removing the duplicate records and that did not meet the inclusion criteria, 501 full-text articles plus 14 records identified searching on articles references were eligible. After reviewing the full-text articles, 25 were excluded by different reasons. A total of 490 articles were analyzed (Figure1).Figure 1
Diagram of study selection for the review.The information is ordered according to the name of the index, trying to maintain a chronological order and with an increase in the complexity of the calculation, except the first section because we included a series of different calculations that have in common the use of a ratio and they do not have a specific name.


### 3.1. Oxidative Balance

One simple form to measure the oxidative/antioxidant balance is calculating a ratio. The first proposal to use a ratio to measure oxidative balance was the oxidized/reduced glutathione (GSSG/GSH). Initial studies in animal models indicated that its increase is an index of OSin vivo and suggests that it can be used as a complement of other parameters [14]. Thus, this ratio has been used in many studies in humans over the past 10 years, so we analyzed its importance in a separate section.The first reports of an attempt to find the relationship between the oxidant and antioxidant counterparts of a biological sample, and not the evaluation of individual markers, are two studies conducted on seminal samples. In these studies, reactive oxygen species (ROS) and total antioxidant capacity were measured, both by chemiluminescence, and a score called ROS-TAC score was calculated. The computation of the ROS-TAC score is complex, with mathematical transformations, standardizations, and a principal component analysis as part of the computation [15, 16], which makes it an impractical score; thus, there is neither study with it.To avoid complex calculations that are not easy to apply to the clinical setting, the researchers resorted to obtaining ratios between an oxidized molecule and an antioxidant. In this sense, the most used oxidation markers have been lipoperoxide level, measured as malondialdehyde (MDA or TBARS) or total lipid hydroperoxides (LOOH), but for the measurement of the antioxidants, a variety of parameters have been used, such as antioxidant enzymes (superoxide dismutase [SOD] or glutathione peroxidase [GPx]) and different ways to measure the nonenzymatic antioxidant capacity (total antioxidant capacity [TAC], ferric reducing antioxidant potential [FRAP], total radical-trapping antioxidant parameter [TRAP], oxygen radical antioxidant [ORAC]) [17–24]. The most commonly used biological samples are the components of the blood, although these reasons have also been applied in measurements obtained from saliva and follicular fluid (Table 2).Table 2
Characteristics and findings of studies that used different individual oxidant and antioxidant biomarkers and calculated a ratio.
Author, year [reference]
Study design/country
Population (age, sex)/sample size
Biological sample/ratio used
Clinical event
Results
Conclusion
Pabón A. et al., 2003 [17]
Cross-sectional/Colombia
Adults (15-37 y, both sexes)/84 subjects with malaria23 control subjects
Plasma, erythrocyte/MDA:TASMDA : GPx
Noncomplicated malaria
MDA/TAS index was 3.5-fold more in patients. MDA/GPx index was increased by 6-fold.
High OS in patients with malaria. Recommended MDA/TAS as OS marker.
Harma M. et al., 2003 [18]
Cross-sectional/Turkey
Adults (mean 30 y, female)/38 women with CHM31 healthy subjects
Plasma/FRAP : TP
Complete hydatidiform mole (CHM)
The mean FRAP/TP index was higher in patients with CHM than in healthy pregnant women.
The authors did not conclude about the FRAP/TP ratio.
Kocyigit A. et al., 2004 [19]
Cross-sectional/Turkey
Children (2-13 y, both sexes)/42 asthmatic children30 healthy children
Plasma/MDA : TAC
Asthma
MDA/TAC ratio was significantly higher in patients.
The authors did not conclude about the MDA/TAC ratio directly.
Agha-Hosseini F. et al., 2012 [20]
Cross-sectional/Iran
Adults (25-82 y, both sexes)/32 subjects with OLP26 subjects with OSCC30 healthy subjects
Saliva/FRAP : MDA
Oral lichen planus (OLP)Oral squamous cell carcinoma (OSCC)
FRAP/MDA ratio was lower in patients with OSCC than both OLP and control.FRAP/MDA ratio was lower in patients with OLP compared to control.
Patients with OLP and OSCC are susceptible to an imbalance of antioxidant-OS.
Venturini D. et al. 2015 [21]
Intervention study/Brazil
Adults (51±8y, both sexes)/21 subjects in fish oil group26 subjects in fish oil+extra virgin olive oil group13 subjects in extra virgin olive oil group42 control subjects
Plasma/TRAP : AOPPAOPP : TRAP
Metabolic syndrome (MetS)
There was an increase in TRAP/AOPP index and a decrease in AOPP/TRAP index in users of fish oil-extra virgin olive oil (FOO) compared with fish oil.
The fish oil and extra virgin olive oil have beneficial synergistic effects on OS, using the ratio, in patients with MetS.
de Almeida J. P. et al., 2016 [22]
Cross-sectional/Brazil
Adults (46-60 y, both sexes)/32 subjects with HCV+HypoD26 subjects with HCV+Normal D89 control subjects
Plasma/AOPP : TRAP
Chronic hepatitis C (HCV) and hypovitaminosis D (HypoD)
HCV patients with hypovitaminosis D had higher AOPP/TRAP.
The authors did not conclude directly about the AOPP/TRAP.
Costa NT. et al., 2016 [23]
Cross-sectional/Brazil
Adults (18-70 y, both sexes)/91 RA patients without IR82 RA patients with IR97 healthy
Plasma/AOPP : TRAP
Rheumatoid arthritis (RA) and insulin resistance (IR)
The patients with IR had higher AOPP/TRAP compared to the patients without IR and not using antitumor necrosis factor-α.
The authors did not conclude directly about the AOPP/TRAP.
Becatti M. et al., 2018 [24]
Longitudinal/Australia
Adults (35±3y, female)/45 infertile women45 control women
Plasma, follicular fluid (FF)/ORAC : MDA
Infertile women undergoing assisted reproductive technology procedures
The plasma ORAC/MDA ratio was about 3.4-fold lower than the control, and the FF ratio was about sixfold lower than the control. Both the plasma and FF ratios results were correlated.
The use of these ratios could help define the critical role of OS markers and their optimum levels in the female reproductive system.
AOPP: advanced oxidation protein products; FRAP: ferric reducing antioxidant potential; GPx: glutathione peroxidase; MDA: malondialdehyde; OS: oxidative stress; TAC: total antioxidant capacity; TAS: total antioxidant status; TP: total peroxides; TRAP: total radical-trapping antioxidant parameter.Regarding the name used to refer the ratio, some authors called it as “oxidative stress index” (OSI) [22, 23], although this term is most used for other relation that we discuss later. Becatti et al. called their ratio as “redox index,” and they define it as a reliable estimation of redox status in humans [24], but neither is it a good option because they measure the ORAC/MDA ratio which is not necessarily a measure of redox status. Therefore, we think it is better to express only the calculated ratio to refer it.The ratio can be calculated from the oxidized molecule to antioxidant, since the shift of the balance toward the oxidative side is considered to represent OS. The lipids oxidized, measured as MDA, or proteins oxidized, measured as advanced oxidation protein products (AOPP), are the main used oxidized molecules, related to total antioxidant status (TAS) or TRAP as antioxidant measure; thus, the MDA/TAS and AOPP/TRAP ratios are recommended indicators of the OS [17, 21]. The use of the ratio toward the antioxidant side indicates only the antioxidant-oxidant imbalance [20, 24].Another way to get the oxidizing/antioxidant ratio is to measure the oxidants like superoxide anion (O2−⋅) and nitric oxide (NO), and glutathione (GSH) or melatonin as antioxidants, although their use should not be frequent, because it exists only one report about melatonin in which it was calculated the NO/melatonin and MDA/melatonin ratios; the authors suggest that these ratios reflect an oxidant-antioxidant balance and could be used to determine OS homeostasis [25], but we should consider that within the OS homeostasis, melatonin is not one of the essential markers. On the other hand, if we calculate the ratio with the oxidants (O2−⋅, NO2−) and GSH as the antioxidant, a problem may arise because the measurement of the oxidants is not easy to apply at patient samples; thus, there remains doubt about its possible usefulness [26].


### 3.2. Glutathione Ratio

As we noted above, the GSSG/GSH ratio is the first attempt to assess the OS as a dynamic way, since this coupler represents the oxidant/antioxidant homeostasis. After a series of animal studies, Curello et al. in 1987 improved the assay of total and oxidized glutathione in blood samples, which has been useful in monitoring of clinical status [27]. From this, different procedures have been developed with various technologies to carry out the measurement not only in blood but also in other biological samples and tissues. In this sense, pitfalls in the measurement of both reduced and oxidized glutathione with those technologies have recently been discussed, pointed an alert in the interpretation of the results [28]; however, glutathione ratio is an indicator of OS widely used.The ratio can be analyzed from GSH to GSSG or inversely GSSG to GSH; in either direction, it is considered as a marker of intracellular OS. If the ratio is obtained from reduced to oxidized glutathione, low values indicate OS; in the opposite direction, a high value denotes OS. Many studies have been realized using the ratio in both ways; thus, we revised them by separation. It is important to keep in mind that most of the time, the glutathione ratio is used as another marker of the OS, as was suggested from the beginning of its use [14], not as an individual indicator, like the ratios pointed above.Furthermore, it is possible to express the glutathione ratio as redox potential (Eh GSH/GSSG), which is a way to represent the redox environment in biological fluids [29]. The redox potential is calculated by the Nernst equation as follows [30]:
(1)EhmV=E0+RT2FlnGSSG/GSH2,where E0=−264mV (GSH/GSSG couple standard potential for pH 7.4), R is the gas constant (8.314 J/°Kmol), T is the absolute temperature (°K), F is the Faraday constant (9.6485×104 C/mol), and GSH and GSSG are the concentrations in moles/liter. In the interpretation, higher Eh values indicate a greater potential for oxidation or OS.The first studies in humans that use this ratio have begun in the 90s. In this review, we found three reports in this decade. Two who obtained the GSSG/GSH ratio of measurements made in the blood of newborns and whose results suggest its use as a noninvasive method to evaluate the OS [31, 32]. The other research is an experimental study with free fatty acid (FFA) infusions in which the lipoperoxide level was measured through the MDA and LOOH, in addition to the GSH/GSSG ratio. In this study, the role of the ratio in the effect sought is not directly concluded, but an inference is made when it considers that the OS intensifies with the increase of FFA [33].Subsequently, in this century, an avalanche of information has emerged. Twenty-four articles located inform the use of the GSH/GSSG ratio to evaluate the antioxidant/oxidant balance, which is on the Table3 [33–55]. The sample mainly used is whole blood and its derivatives (erythrocytes, polymorphonuclear cells, or plasma), and other markers are added, such as oxidation products, oxidants, and enzymatic and nonenzymatic antioxidants, to obtain a more comprehensive measurement of the OS, although it is possible to use exclusively the glutathione ratio, but remember that this ratio measures only the intracellular OS [35, 36, 49, 51, 55]. Regarding to the GSSG/GSH ratio, fifteen studies were localized, and blood is the biological sample used mainly, but also it is possible to measure glutathione in saliva [56, 57]. As in the previous ratio, it is common to add more OS markers [30, 31, 56–68], and the measurement of the ratio from oxidized to reduced form is a good marker of oxidant/antioxidant imbalance in different clinical situations (Table 4).Table 3
Characteristics and findings of studies that used reduced to oxidized glutathione ratio (GSH/GSSG).
Author, year [reference]
Study design/country
Population (age, sex)/sample size
Biological sample/other markers
Main outcome
Results
Conclusion
Paolisso G. et al., 1996 [33]
Experimental study with free fatty acids (FFA) infusions/Italy
Adults (33±1y, both sexes)/10 subjects with intralipid continuum infusion9 subjects with 6 h intralipid infusion11 subjects with insulin infusion
Plasma/MDA, LOOH
Effect of FFA on OS
The GSH/GSSG ratio diminished after 6 h of FFA infusion and continued to 24 h, although the better effect was at 6 h. After a wash-out period, the ratio returns to basal value.
The OS intensifies with the increase of FFA, inferring that the ratio measures the OS.
Abramson JL. et al., 2005 [34]
Cross-sectional/USA
Adults (44±9y, both sexes)/126 subjects without CHD
Plasma/FORT
Association between OS and high sensitivity CRP (hsCRP)
The GSH/GSSG ratio showed little association with hsCRP.
The ratio was not strongly associated with CRP.
Gherghel D. et al., 2005 [35]
Cross-sectional/UK
Older adults (70±10y, both sexes)/21 POAG patients34 control subjects
Blood/none
Glutathione status in primary open-angle glaucoma (POAG)
The GSH/GSSG ratio was similar in both sexes. No differences between study group and control were observed in redox index, after correction for age and gender.
The authors did not conclude about the ratio because the results were not significant.
Yeh CC. et al., 2006 [36]
Cross-sectional/Taiwan
Adults (27-83 y, female)/112 women with BC40 control subjects
Blood, tumor tissue/none
Glutathione status in breast cancer (BC)
GSH/TGSSG ratio was decreased in the blood of the patients with breast cancer, and breast cancer tissue was increased, especially in stage II.
There was an imbalance in the glutathione redox status in the breast tumor patients.
Ashfaq S. et al., 2006 [37]
Cross-sectional/USA
Adults (30-65 y, both sexes)/114 healthy subjects
Blood/cysteine and its redox state
Thiols status and early atherosclerosis
After adjusting for traditional risk factors and hs-CRP, the GSH/GSSG ratio is an independent predictor of intima-media thickness.
Glutathione redox state is an independent predictor for the presence of early atherosclerosis.
Nikolaidis MG. et al., 2007 [38]
Experimental of isokinetic exercise/Greece
Adults (23±2y, female)/12 women in isokinetic exercise
Blood/MDA, TAC, PC
Effect of repeated muscle-damaging exercise on the time-course changes in indices of muscle damage
Exercise decreased the GSH/GSSG ratio at several time points after both exercise bouts.
The authors did not conclude directly with the ratio but shown an effect across it.
Harzallah O. et al., 2008 [39]
Cross-sectional/Tunisia
Adults (22–61 y, both sexes)/40 subjects with BD40 healthy subjects
Blood/MDA, CAT, SOD, GPx
Association between OS and Behçet’s disease (BD)
The GSH/GSSG ratio was reduced in BD patients.
Exist an OS in BD as shown by the diminution of the ratio.
Youssef H. et al., 2009 [40]
Cross-sectional postexercise effect/Lebanon
Adolescents (14-19 y, female)/29 overweight girls17 normal weight girls
Blood/F2-Iso, LOOH, ox-LDL, SOD, GPx, vit. C, vit. E,β-carot.
Effect of incremental ergocycle exercise on OS
The overweight adolescents presented the GSH/GSSG ratio lower.No changes for GSH/GSSH were observed in both groups after exercise.
Exercise exacerbates OS in the overweight adolescents; GSH/GSSG ratio is a good marker.
Tsai SM. et al., 2009 [41]
Cross-sectional/Taiwan
Adults (31-81 y, both sexes)/54 HBV-associated HCC patients57 control subjects
Blood/O2⋅−, MDA, SOD, GPx, vit. A, C, E
Changes in OS in chronic hepatitis B virus (HBV)-associated hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) patients
The ratio of GSH/GSSG of HBV-associated HCC patients was lower than that of controls.
Changes in the GSH demonstrated that HBV-associated HCC patients had undergone OS during their clinical disease progression.
Huang YS. et al., 2009 [30]
Cross-sectional/China
Adults (41-76 y, both sexes)/56 patients plaque-forming42 patients with intima-media thickening34 subjects with normal intima-media
Plasma/MDA, ox-LDL
Relationship between glutathione redox status and the atherosclerosis
GSH/GSSG redox status was positively correlated with the intima thickness.
Peroxidative glutathione redox status may be a sensitive and reliable index for monitoring OS in atherosclerosis.
Kleinsorge EC. et al., 2011 [42]
Cross-sectional/Argentina
Adults (23±2y, both sexes)/26 photocopy machine operators52 control subjects
Erythrocyte/MDA, CAT, DICA
To determinate the oxidative damage in photocopier operators
GSH/GSSG is similar between operators and controls.
The authors did not discuss or conclude about the ratio.
Patel RS. et al., 2011 [43]
Cross-sectional/USA
Adults and elderly (20-70 y, both sexes)/169 healthy subjects
Plasma/cysteine ratio, dROMs
Relationship between novel markers of OS and arterial elastic properties
The redox potential of GSH/GSSG showed modest association with carotid-femoral pulse wave velocity.
After multivariate adjustment for confounders, GSH/GSSG is not associated with impaired arterial elasticity.
Zepeda RJ. et al., 2012 [44]
Prospective randomized single blind clinical trial/Chile
Adults (30-75 y, both sexes)/23 patients with EH in carvedilol therapy21 patients with EH in nebivolol therapy30 normotensive patients
Erythrocyte/NOx, FRAP, MDA, 8-Iso
Effect of carvedilol and nebivolol on the OS and endothelial function in patients with essential hypertension (EH)
In patients with carvedilol, GSH/GSSG ratio was higher compared with patients who received nebivolol.
As part of the antihypertensive mechanism, carvedilol seems to reinforce the antioxidant system.
Llorente-Cantarero FJ. et al., 2012 [45]
Cross-sectional/Spain
Children (7-12 y, both sexes)/138 healthy subjects
Erythrocyte/MDA, 4-HNE, PC, NOx, SOD, GPx
To identify gender-based biomarkers for OS in children
Girls had a lower GSH/GSSG ratio than boys.
The authors did not conclude about the ratio directly.
Ntalapascha M. et al., 2013 [46]
Observational prospective/Greece
Adults (30-65 y, male)/18 patients with severe OSAS13 control subjects
Erythrocyte/MDA, PC, 8-Iso, CAT, SOD, TAC
Assess the OS in patients with obstructive sleep apnea syndrome (OSAS)
The overnight (morning–night) change (%) of GSH/GSSG ratio was different between OSAS and controls.
OSAS might be associated with increased OS possibly via GSH/GSSG pathway.
Shah D. et al., 2013 [47]
Cross-sectional/India
Adults (29±8y, both sexes)/40 patients with SLE40 healthy subjects
Erythrocyte/MDA, SOD, CAT, GPx, ROS production, total thiols
Association between glutathione pathway and systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) severity
Altered redox state (GSH/GSSG) was found in SLE patients.The severity of disease was allied with altered GSH/GSSG.
GSH depletion may be coupled with the severity of the disease.
Victor VM. et al., 2014 [48]
Observational prospective of testosterone (T) therapy/Spain
Adults (29±10y, transsexual)/57 female-to-male transsexuals (FtMs)
Polymorpho-nuclear cells/mitochondrial O2 consumption, membrane potential, ROS production
The effect of T treatment on the redox state of leukocytes of FtMs subjects
GSH/GSSG ratio was lower in patients post-T treatment
Treatment of FtMs with T can induce a state of OS.
Enns GM. et al., 2014 [49]
Cross-sectional/USA
All ages (0.5-50 y, both sexes)/62 subjects with mitochondrial disease (MitD)59 healthy subjects
Blood/none
To determine the redox status in mitochondrial diseases and if the redox imbalance is an indicator of clinical status
The GSH/GSSG ratio was lower in MitD patients, and redox potential was higher compared with controls.
GSH and GSSG levels may be biomarkers of mitochondrial dysfunction, and the evaluation of redox potential may be useful in monitoring of clinical status in MitD.
Schmitt B. et al., 2015 [50]
Randomized crossover trial/France
Adults (38-67 y, both sexes)/20 subjects with metabolic syndrome
Blood/reduced thiols, vit. E
To compare the effect on glutathione status of a sublingual form of GSH, compared with oral GSH and N-acetylcysteine (NAC)
A higher GSH/GSSG ratio was observed in sublingual GSH group compared with oral GSH and NAC groups.
The authors conclude about the effectivity of the treatments based in the GSH results.
Karimi R. et al., 2016 [51]
Cross-sectional/USA
Adults (48±28y, both sexes)/268 subjects
Blood/none
Seafood Hg exposure is related to a shift in redox status (low GSH/GSSG or high redox potential (Eh))
Blood Hg concentration was associated with changes in GSH/GSSG ratio and redox potential.
Hg exposure from seafood is linked to a shift in redox status toward OS.
Atkin M. et al., 2016 [52]
A double-blind, placebo-controlled crossover pilot/UK
Adults (18-70 y, both sexes)/26 subjects with T2DM
Blood/LOOH, TAS
Aged garlic extract (AGE) may improve OS in high-risk cardiovascular subjects with type 2 diabetes (T2DM)
No difference was found in GSH/GSSG ratio.
There is no clinical benefit of adding AGE, in the short term, to usual medical therapy in patients with T2DM.
Galicia-Moreno M. et al., 2016 [53]
Cross-sectional/Mexico
Adults (43±1y, both sexes)/57 subjects with ALC130 control subjects
Blood/MDA, PC
To evaluate the role of OS in alcoholic liver cirrhosis (ALC)
There were no differences in the GSH/GSSG ratio between groups.Active alcohol consumption had a tendency to produce glutathione oxidation.
ALC subjects have an increase in OS in the early stages of disease severity and abstinence from alcohol consumption favors GSH in patients with advanced disease severity.
Moreno-Solís G. et al., 2017 [54]
Observational/Spain
Infants (1-11 months, both sexes)/45 infants with RSV-AB27 healthy infants
Erythrocyte/MDA, 4-HNE, GPx
Association between OS and acute bronchiolitis caused by respiratory syncytial virus (RSV-AB) and its severity
The GSH/GSSG ratio was lower in RSV-AB infants and decrease if the infants need oxygen therapy.
The authors propose the use of GSSG and the GSH/GSSG ratio as biomarkers linked to the pathogenesis of RSV-AB.
Vacchi-Suzzi C. et al., 2018 [55]
Cross-sectional cohort/USA
Adults (≥18 y, both sexes)/282 healthy
Blood/none
Association between blood lead level (BLL) and glutathione (GSH) redox biomarkers
Increasing exposure to Pb was associated with lower levels of GSH/GSSG ratio and more positive GSH redox potential.
Blood Pb is associated with lower levels of GSH and the GSH/GSSG ratio.
β-carot.: β-carotene; CAT: catalase; CHD: coronary heart disease; dROMs: derivatives of reactive oxygen metabolites; DICA: damage index by Comet assay; F2-Iso: 15 F2α-isoprostanes; FORT: free oxygen radical test; FRAP: ferric reducing antioxidant potential; GPx: glutathione peroxidase; GR: glutathione reductase; GST: glutathione-S-transferase; 4-HNE: 4-hydroxyalkenal; hsCRP: high sensitivity C-reactive protein; 8-Iso: 8-isoprostanes; LOOH: lipid hydroperoxides; MDA: malondialdehyde; NOx: nitrite plus nitrate; O2−⋅: superoxide anion radical; OS: oxidative stress; ox-LDL: oxidized low-density lipoprotein; PC: protein carbonyls; ROS: reactive oxygen species; SOD: superoxide dismutase; TAC: total antioxidant capacity; TAS: total antioxidant status; TGSSG: total glutathione; vit. A: vitamin A; vit. C: vitamin C; vit. E: α-tocopherol.Table 4
Characteristics and findings of studies that used oxidized to reduced glutathione ratio (GSSG/GSH).
Author, year [reference]
Study design/country
Population (age, sex)/sample size
Biological sample/other markers
Main outcome
Results
Conclusion
Németh I. 1994 [31]
Prospective longitudinal/Hungary
Infants (gestational age 26-34 weeks, both sexes)/25 newborn premature infants with IRDS20 premature infants as control
Blood/none
GSSG/GSH in the blood could be an index of O2 toxicity in pathological status of premature newborns.
Premature infants with IRDS have GSSG/GSH ratio higher than control newborns. A negative correlation between the redox ratio and the arterio-alveolar oxygen ratio was found.
It is recommended the use of the blood GSSG/GSH ratio as a noninvasive measure ofin vivo OS.
Papp A. et al., 1999 [32]
Cross-sectional/Hungary
Infants who had been born prematurely (6 weeks-6 y, both sexes)/12 infants with active ROP38 patients with ROP56 control subjects
Erythrocyte/none
Glutathione status of erythrocytes in patients with retinopathy of prematurity (ROP)
Infants with active disease have the highest GSSG/GSH ratio.
The GSSG/GSH ratio may be a screen for active ROP in premature infants.
Annuk M. et al., 2001 [58]
Cross-sectional/Sweden
Adults (66±10y, both sexes)/37 subjects with CRF37 control subjects
Serum/CD, MDA, LOOH, TAA, LPF
Relationship between OS and endothelial function in chronic renal failure (CRF)
The GSSG/GSH ratio was lower in patients with CRF. Endothelium-dependent vasodilation was negatively correlatedGSSG/GSH.
The authors did not conclude directly about the ratio, but they assume that this ratio is a marker of OS.
Sáez GT. et al., 2004 [59]
Observational prospective of antihypertensive treatment/Spain
Adults (mean 46 y, both sexes)/36 subjects withβ-blockers33 subjects with telmisartan20 subjects without treatment
Blood, peripheral mononuclear cells/MDA
Impact of antihypertensive treatments on OSOS
After 3 months of antihypertensive treatment, the GSSG/GSH ratio was reduced; the beneficial effect of treatment increases over time.
The authors did not conclude directly about the ratio. Antihypertensive treatment improved the increased OS.
Skalicky J. et al., 2008 [60]
Cross-sectional/Czech Republic
Adults (51±9y, both sexes)/20 subjects obese with MetS20 subjects obese without MetS48 controls
Blood/TAS, vit. E, MDA, allantoin,α1-AP
OS in obesity with and without metabolic syndrome (MetS)
The obese patients with MetS have the highest GSSG/GSH ratio.
The authors did not conclude directly about the ratio, but they indicate that imbalance oxidative/antioxidative status is a risk in obese adults.
Lind L. et al., 2008 [61]
Prospective study/Sweden
Older adults (70 y, both sexes)/1016 subjects
Serum/CD, ox-LDL, TAC, homocysteine
Relationship between OS and brachial artery intima-media thickness (IMT) and grey scale median of the intima-media complex (IM-GSM)
The GSSG/GSH ratio was related to brachial artery IM-GSM after adjustment of traditional risk factors and inflammatory markers.
The low levels of the ratio indicate a reduced antioxidant activity.
Mercken EM. et al., 2009 [62]
Experimental/Netherlands
Adults (56±7y, both sexes)/15 COPD patients10 controls
Erythrocyte/MDA, uric acid
OS is differentially triggered by contracting peripheral muscles in COPD patients compared with controls
GSSG/GSH ratio tended to be increased in COPD patients and tended to be increased immediately after exercise.
The authors did not conclude directly about the ratio, although they discuss that the ratio slightly increased in COPD patients after exercise.
Real JT. et al., 2010 [63]
Cross-sectional/Spain
Adults (40±13y, both sexes)/30 patients with HF30 controls
Circulating mononuclear cells (CMC)/MDA, XO, SOD, CAT, GPx
Analyze the OS levels in CMC from familiar hypercholesterolemia (HF) patients and controls
GSSG/GSH ratio was significantly higher in FH patients compared with controls.
The authors did not conclude directly about the ratio, but they affirm that there is an important alteration of OS regulation in FH.
Rusanova I. et al., 2010 [64]
Cross-sectional/Panama
Children (6 months-15 y, both sexes)/95 patients with SCD40 healthy
Erythrocyte/MDA, 4-HNE, NOx, GPx, GR, SOD
To correlateβ-globin gene haplotypes with the OS in pediatric patients with sickle cell disease (SCD)
GSSG/GSH ratio was higher in patients with SCD.
Based on the ratio, the findings support the existence of oxidative damage in sickle cells.
Petrillo S. et al., 2013 [65]
Cross-sectional/Italy
All (4-64 y, does not specify sex)/14 patients with X-ALD30 healthy
LymphocyteErythrocyte/total thiols, PC, SOD, GPx
Define the role of the glutathione in X-linked adrenoleuko-dystrophy (X-ALD)
The GSSG/GSH ratio was increased in patients with adrenomyelo-neuropathy.
The balance among glutathione forms is a hallmark and a potential biomarker of the X-ALD.
De Tursi Ríspoli L. et al., 2013 [66]
Observational prospective of bariatric surgery/Spain
Adults (43±1y, both sexes)/28 patients with morbid obesity
Erythrocyte/MDA, 8-oxo-dG
Assessment of OS variations and its relationship with the weight loss after a duodenal crossing surgical
The GSSG/GSH ratio diminished across one year from 3 months after the surgery.
The authors did not conclude directly about the ratio, but they infer that weight loss improves antioxidant status.
Bagan J. et al., 2014 [56]
Observational/Spain
Adults (61±10y, sex is not specified)/24 patients treated with intravenous bisphosphonates (ivBPs) and BRONJ20 patients treated with ivBPs and without BRONJ17 controls
SerumSaliva/MDA, 8-oxo-dG
Changes of OS in patients with bisphosphonate-related osteonecrosis of the jaw (BRONJ)
The GSSG/GSH ratio was a prognostic factor for the development of BRONJ after adjusted by confounders.
The GSSG/GSH was a significant factor predicting the development of BRONJ.
Blasco H. et al., 2017 [67]
Preliminary study/France
Adults (65±14y, both sexes)/10 ALS patients 10 controls
Blood/MDA, 8-OHdG, TAS
Association of OS and amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS)
Higher GSSG/GSH ratio in ALS patients and correlations were found between the ratio and clinical markers.
The systemic alteration of the redox status in ALS patients was confirmed.
Arana C. et al., 2017 [57]
Observational/Spain
Adults (18-65 y, both sexes)/24 patients with T2DM and good metabolic control27 patients T2DM with poor metabolic control19 nondiabetic patients
Saliva/GPx, GR
Association between OS and periodontal disease in type 2 diabetes mellitus (T2DM) patients
Both diabetic groups showed higher GSSG/GSH quotients, being higher ratio in diabetic patients with poor metabolic control.
Poor metabolic control in T2DM patients is associated with higher levels of salivary OS.
Bellanti F. et al., 2018 [68]
Population-based cross-sectional study/Italy
Older adults (77±6y, both sexes)/48 sarcopenic67 nonsarcopenic
Blood/MDA, 4-HNE
Association between OS and sarcopenic obesity in terms of glutathione balance
Sarcopenic had GSSG/GSH ratio higher than nonsarcopenic patients. There is a strong association between the Framingham CVD risk and GSSG/GSH in the sarcopenic-obese patients.
Redox balance analysis would be a useful part of a multidimensional evaluation in aging.
α1-AP: α1-antiproteinase; CD: conjugate dienes; GPx: glutathione peroxidase; GR: glutathione reductase; 4-HNE: 4-hydroxyalkenal; 8-OHdG: 8-hydroxy-2′-deoxyguanosine; LOOH: lipid hydroperoxides; LPF: oxidation resistance of lipoprotein fraction; MDA: malondialdehyde; NOx: nitrite plus nitrate; 8-oxo-dG: 8-oxo-deoxiguanosina; OS: oxidative stress; ox-LDL: oxidized low-density lipoprotein; PC: protein carbonyls; SOD: superoxide dismutase; TAA: total antioxidant activity; TAC: total antioxidant capacity; TAS: total antioxidant status; vit. E: α-tocopherol; XO: xanthine oxidase.The redox potential (Eh) is a complement of the GSH/GSSG ratio to evaluate the redox status [30, 34, 37, 43, 49, 51, 55], but it can be used as an independent measurement since it provides indirect information about the redox state of all cell types, although the measurement has been performed only in erythrocytes, because the cells have similar essential functions [69].Nevertheless, the glutathione ratio seems to be a promise OS marker, it is limited because it only measures intracellular environment without considering other OS components as antioxidant enzymes and oxidized biomolecules.


### 3.3. Thiol Ratios

The thiols are compounds with high vulnerability to the oxidation by reactive species, mainly of oxygen, due to their -SH group, which is oxidized to their disulfide (-SS-). As this is an oxidation reaction, the imbalance between both forms in favor of the oxidized molecule is considered as OS, being a dynamic homeostasis involved in many diseases and alterations of the physiological state [70, 71]. Many proteins, nonproteins, and low molecular mass thiols have -SH group, but only cysteine and glutathione are considerate in the redox balance, where cysteine represents the extracellular environment and glutathione the intracellular. Then, the term “thiol ratio” is used to refer the measurement of these aminothiols together, both in its oxidized and reduced forms. There are some techniques to their measurement, less complex and automated what has facilitated its use in different investigations.After the proposal of an automated procedure to evaluate native thiol (-SH), total thiol (TT), and thiol-disulfide (-SS) [70], -SH/TT, -SS/-SH, and -SS/TT ratios have been calculated; where if the value of -SH/TT ratio is low and both ratios of -SS are high, the OS is present. Also, it is possible to present the result as a percentage, multiplying the total obtained by 100.Its use has spread widely to become the second most popular indicator of OS so far. In this review, we found sixty-six studies that refer them. All the studies, except one [72], were carried out in Turkey in a variety of age groups and clinical situations since 2015. The thiols can be measured in serum/plasma, but semen sample [72] and aqueous humor [73] also have been used, and they are applicable to evaluate the oxidative state in a variety of clinical events, from alterations during pregnancy, cardiovascular, psychiatric, neurological, hereditary, infectious diseases, etc. Although the information is abundant, the analysis result has not shown substantial differences among the studies, because all agree in recommending the thiol ratios to their use in clinical events; therefore, we only did a descriptive analysis of the information (Table 5) and presented references found in a supplementary file in case of any reader is interested in consulting the information.Table 5
Studies that have used the thiol ratios to measure the oxidative stress by age group and clinical event studied.
Age group
Clinical event
Number or studies
Adults (18-65 y)
Alterations in the pregnancy
8
Cardiovascular diseases
4
Respiratory diseases
4
Skin disorders
4
Psychiatric disorders
3
Metabolic disorders
3
Surgery
2
Neurologic disorders
2
Other disorders
10
Older adults (>65 y)
Ocular disorders
3
Different events
4
Children (<18 y)
Neurologic disorders
4
Genetic disorders
3
Different events
8
Adults-older adults (>18 y)
Different events
3
Children-adults (<65 y)
Neurologic disorder
1
Total
66It is important to note that, contrary to glutathione ratio, the thiol ratios generally do not need other markers to interpret the OS, although antioxidant enzymes, FRAP, TAC, total oxidant capacity (TOC), and ischemia-modified albumin (IMA), have been some of the other markers included to complement the interpretation.The thiol ratios are the OS markers used more recently, but like the glutathione ratio, to make a complete interpretation of the OS, it is necessary to include antioxidant enzymes and oxidized biomolecules.


### 3.4. Oxidative Stress Index (OSI)

All the previous proposals are recognizing that OS is a dynamic process, because they consider both the oxidizing and antioxidant components in a single calculation; however, only one type of oxidant and antioxidant is related, which is a disadvantage because it is necessary to evaluate many components to establish more effective if the OS is present. Hence, other proposals have emerged that consider the measurement of oxidant and antioxidant activity whose effect is produced by the action of several components of OS measured as one.Those are based in fact that the measurement of different oxidants and antioxidant molecules separately is not practical because they are costly and time-consuming, and frequently, the procedures are complex; moreover, their oxidant or antioxidant effects are additive [74, 75]; therefore, it is possible to measure the total oxidant or antioxidant capacities of a biological sample and related them in a ratio, called index.The antioxidant capacity is measured by different procedures identified by their acronyms:(i)
Ferric reducing antioxidant potential (FRAP) or total antioxidant potential (TAOP): measurement of the ability of the sample to reduce Fe3+ to Fe2+ as a result of antioxidant activity. The formation of a complex between Fe2+ and 2,4,6-tripyridyl-1,3,5-triazine (TPTZ) is measured [20, 76]
(ii)
Oxygen radical absorbance capacity (ORAC): inhibition measurement of the peroxyl radical-induced oxidation initiated by thermal decomposition of 2,20-azobis(2-amidinopropane) dihydrochloride (AAPH) [24]
(iii)
Total antioxidant activity (TAA): it is the assessment of the ability of a sample to inhibit linolenic acid peroxidation. The results are expressed as percentage of inhibition of linolenic acid peroxidation produced by samples [58]
(iv)
Total antioxidant capacity (TAC): the method is based on the hydroxyl radical (OH⋅) produced via the Fenton reaction using a mixing ferrous ion solution and H2O2. The OH⋅ generated reacts with o-dianisidine molecule to form dianisidyl radicals [75]
(v)
Total antioxidant status (TAS): the method is based on the production of the radical cation (ABTS⋅+) by the incubation of ABTS (2,20-azino-bis[3-ethylbenzothiazoline-6-sulphonic acid]) with peroxidase (metmyoglobin) and H2O2 [17]
(vi)
Total radical-trapping antioxidant parameter (TRAP): measurement of hydrosoluble and/or liposoluble plasma antioxidants using chemiluminescence inhibition time induced by 2,2-azobis(2-amidinopropane) [21]Except in TAA, the results in all the quoted methods are expressed as Trolox equivalents (μmol/L), which is the antioxidant standard.Likewise, the measurement of the oxidant capacity can be carried out by different methods:(i)
Total oxidative capacity (TOC): assay based on the oxidation of 3,5,3′,5′-tetramethylbenzidine (TMB) to colored radical cations in the presence of peroxides by peroxidase. It used to determine total peroxides in μmol/L [77, 78]
(ii)
Total oxidant status (TOS): it is the measurement of the oxidation of Fe2+ to Fe3+ by peroxides of the sample to produce a Fe3+-xylenol orange complex. This assay quantifies total peroxides; the results are expressed as H2O2μmol Eq/L [75]Some indexes are in the literature, but the most used is called “oxidative stress index” (OSI) initially proposed in 2003 [18]. This index has had few modifications across the time, but all the studies agree in that it is a ratio between TOS and TAS expressed in arbitrary units:
(2)OSIAU=TOSTAS,where OSI is in arbitrary units (AU), TOS is in μmol H2O2 Eq/L, and TAS is in μmol Trolox Eq/L. Sometimes, the result is multiplied by 100 to represent the percentage ratio.TAC or TAOP can also be used as antioxidant component because being in the same units (μmol Trolox Eq/L), and TOS may be replaced by TOC.As we pointed above, OSI is the index most frequently reported in the literature. In this review, we found 302 studies in humans since 2003 that use this index, the majority carried out in Turkey, mainly in adult events such as cardiovascular diseases, alterations in the pregnancy, and psychiatric disorders. As the thiol ratio information, after analyzing the studies, we observe that most research recommends the use of OSI without other important contributions to this review; thus, we present only a descriptive analysis and the references in the supplementary file. However, we want to note that the measurement of oxidant and antioxidant activities for the calculation of the index has been carried out on biological samples other than blood, such as semen [79–81], urine [82, 83], cerebrospinal fluid [84], amniotic fluid [85], vaginal washing fluid [86], and gingival crevicular fluid [87–89], in addition to the saliva [90–95] and aqueous humor [96, 97] that have also been used in the measurement of thiols (Table 6).Table 6
Studies that use the oxidative stress index (OSI) as a marker of oxidative stress separated by country, age group, and clinical event.
Country
Frequency (%)
Age group
Frequency (%)
Clinical event
Frequency (%)
Turkey
257 (85.1%)
Adults (18–65 y)
190 (63.0%)
Cardiovascular diseases
38 (12.6%)
Poland
13 (4.3%)
Adults-older adults (>18 y)
40 (13.2%)
Alterations in the pregnancy
32 (10.6%)
China
11 (3.7%)
Children (2–12 y)
35 (11.6%)
Psychiatric disorders
27 (9.0%)
India
4 (1.3%)
Neonates/infants (<2 y)
19 (6.3%)
Infectious diseases
17 (5.6%)
Estonia
3 (1.0%)
Older adults (>65 y)
8 (2.6%)
Cancer
15 (5.0%)
Thailand
3 (1.0%)
Adolescents (12–17 y)
5 (1.6%)
Skin disorders
15 (5.0%)
Ethiopia
2 (0.7%)
Children-adolescent (<18 y)
2 (0.7%)
Oral diseases
15 (5.0%)
Egypt
2 (0.7%)
Children to adults (<65 y)
2 (0.7%)
Respiratory diseases
14 (4.6%)
Romania
1 (0.3%)
All age groups
1 (0.3%)
Metabolic disorders
12 (4.0%)
Mexico
1 (0.3%)
Total
302
Other disorders
117 (38.6%)
Austria
1 (0.3%)
Total
302
Korea
1 (0.3%)
Iran
1 (0.3%)
Nigeria
1 (0.3%)
Serbia
1 (0.3%)
Total
302Like the other calculations, OSI also has been accompanied of several OS markers such as MDA, DNA damage, hydroperoxides, protein carbonyls, IMA, thiols, antioxidant enzymes, prolidase, paraoxonase, and antioxidant vitamins, many times in order to show the relationship between the different markers and prove their usefulness as an independent indicator of OS. All this information makes this index a very promising way to measure the OS; however, there are still doubts regarding its interpretation. Actually, for its interpretation, the increase in the value of the index indicates a greater intensity of OS, but it has not been clearly established which is the cut-off value for the OS, necessary value to better clinical application, because in clinical practice, it is important to be able to differentiate oxidative eustress and oxidative distress, as we have pointed early in this review.


### 3.5. Oxidative INDEX

This is a proposal of Vassalle et al. (2008) that also related the serum oxidative/antioxidative capacities; only that for this index, the oxidative part is the measurement of total hydroperoxides by dROMs and to the serum antioxidant activity has used a procedure called OXY Adsorbent Test [98]; both methods are automated and commercial.The dROMs or derivatives of Reactive Oxygen Metabolites, also called diacron ROM, are based on the measurement of sample alkoxyl (RO⋅) and peroxyl (ROO⋅) radicals (sample peroxides) formed by iron, according to Fenton’s reaction. These radicals are able to oxidize an alkyl-substituted aromatic amine (A-NH2), such as N,N-diethyl-para-phenylenediamine (DEPPD), transforming it into a derivative ([A-NH2⋅]+). With some modifications in the procedure, this method also is called as free oxygen radical test (FORT), which reflects levels of organic hydroperoxides. Results are expressed in arbitrary units, called Carratelli units (Carr U), where one Carr U corresponds to 0.08 mg/dL H2O2. Values greater than 300 Carr U suggest OS [99–101].The OXY Adsorbent Test evaluates the antioxidant ability of each sample to oppose the oxidant action of hypochlorous acid (HClO) added in excess. The results are expressed asμmol HClO/mL, and low values indicate a reduced antioxidant capacity [102].Two aspects that we should highlight about this index is that it has only been used in serum as a biological sample and its calculation method, which makes its daily use difficult.In this sense, due to dROMs and OXY are in different measurement units, it is necessary to have a standardization according to the following formula [101, 102]:
(3)svvar=vvar−x¯varsvar,where svvar is the standard value of each measurement which is equivalent to z, vvar is the original value of each subject, x¯var is the mean of the parameter, and svar is the standard deviation of the parameter.After this calculation, a simple subtraction between standardized dROM and standardized OXY must be calculated:(4)OxidativeINDEX=svROM−svOXY.This index has proven its usefulness in comparisons between young vs. old people [103], men vs. women [104], and in several clinical settings, such as cardiovascular diseases [98, 106, 107], oral diseases [105, 111], neurological disorders [108], hepatic diseases [109, 112], and cancer [110], showing that it has the capacity to discriminate between the groups (Table 7). It is important to note that since this index evaluates the oxidative balance, no other OS marker was included in any study.Table 7
Characteristics and findings of studies that used Oxidative INDEX (ROM/OXY ratio).
Author, year [ref]
Study design/country
Population (age, sex)/sample size
Main outcome
Results
Conclusion
Vassalle C et al., 2008 [98]
Cross-sectional/Italy
Adults (65±10y, both sexes)/100 CAD patients 70 controls
Relationship between Oxidative INDEX and cardiovascular risk factors in coronary artery disease (CAD).
The Oxidative INDEX was higher in CAD patients, correlated with aging and increased with the number of cardiovascular risk factors.
Oxidative INDEX could represent a valuable tool in clinical setting.
Vassalle C et al., 2009 [103]
Cross-sectional/Italy
Adults (16-79 y, both sexes)/179 subjects
Obesity and smoking may accelerate the increase of the OS related to advancing age.
Obesity and smoking are risk factors for elevated Oxidative INDEX. The index steadily rises at a mean rate of 5.3% (0.017 AU) per year in the overall population.
The authors did not conclude directly about the index, but they infer that OS increases due the risk factors analyzed.
Vassalle C et al., 2011 [104]
Cross-sectional/Italy
Adults (48±12y, both sexes)/116 males216 females
Gender-related difference of OS
Age, high blood pressure, and smoking habit as factors associated with the index in men. Cigarette smoking and age are risk factors for an elevated OS in women.
The authors did not conclude directly about the index, but they infer that there is a difference in OS due to sex.
Tamaki N. et al., 2011 [105]
Observational longitudinal/Japan
Adults (44±19y, both sexes)/22 with CP22 controls
To monitor OS in subjects with chronic periodontitis (CP) following nonsurgical periodontal treatment
Patients with CP have higher OS than healthy subjects. Periodontal treatment was associated with a reduction in the index.
Nonsurgical periodontal treatment was effective in decreasing the index.
Vassalle C et al., 2012 [106]
ObservationalLongitudinalRetrospective/Italy
Adults (67±11y, both sexes/97 CAD patients
Prognostic of OS on the rate of major adverse cardiovascular events (MACE) in CAD patients
High level of the index is an independent predictor of MACE.
OS (calculated by the index) may be a useful tool to predict MACE in CAD patients.
Vassalle C et al., 2012 [107]
Case-control/Italy
Adults (66±9y, both sexes)/55 post-women108 men72 CAD patients
To assess oxidative stress status in coronary artery disease (CAD) patients according to gender
There is a difference in the index between men and women without CAD. Women with CAD had the index higher than men.
The index can be a predictor of CAD in women.
Capaccio P et al., 2012 [108]
Cross-sectional/Italy
Adults (47±14y, both sexes)/39 ISSNHL patients70 healthy subjects
To evaluate role of OS in idiopathic sudden sensorineural hearing loss (ISSNHL)
The index was higher in patients than in controls.
In ISSNH, there is an imbalanced oxidative status.
Terao M et al., 2014 [109]
Cross-sectional/Japan
Adults (46-61 y, both sexes)/29 with potential POPH32 with potential non-POPH
Association between the OS and portopulmonary hypertension (POPH) in cirrhotic patients
Potential POPH patients have higher oxidative index values.
The oxidative/antioxidative balance was exacerbated in patients with potential POPH.
Uchida D et al., 2016 [110]
Translational/Japan
Adults (27-90 y, both sexes)/84 CC patients80 PC patients
OS balance in pancreatic cancer (PC) and cholangiocarcinoma (CC) patients
The index was higher in CC patients with poor outcomes and not different in PC patients.
OS balance was dysregulated in CC patients with poor outcome.
Mizuno H et al., 2017 [111]
Randomized clinical trial/Japan
Adults (61±10y, both sexes)/T2DM and CP patients.20 periodontal treatment17 control group
Effect of nonsurgical periodontal treatment on OS balance patients with type 2 diabetes mellitus (T2DM) compared to no periodontal treatment
Systemic OS balance improved in the periodontal treatment group compared to the control group at 3 months.
In T2DM patients, nonsurgical periodontal treatment improved systemic OS.
Shimomura Y et al., 2017 [112]
ObservationalLongitudinal/Japan
Adults (>40 y, both sexes)/14 patients with NAFL44 patients with NASH11 patients with NASH-related HCC15 healthy
Correlation between OS-related markers and the clinical characteristic in nonalcoholic fatty liver disease (NAFL) and to characterize the OS balance in NAFL, nonalcoholic steatohepatitis (NASH), and NASH-related hepatocellular carcinoma (NASH-HCC)
The index positively correlated with BMI and HbA1c.The index was not significantly different among the patient groups.
The authors did not conclude directly about the index, only of these components.In the interpretation, being a standardized value, there can be negative and positive values in a range of - 3 to +3, with 0 being the ideal balance between oxidants and antioxidants; therefore, positive values indicate predominant oxidized damage and negative values an imbalance towards antioxidants. Moreover, it has been shown that if the 75th percentile of the data is calculated, a cut-off value can be obtained to establish the intensity of the OS, at least by deciding whether it is low or high [102, 106], although further studies need be carried out to confirm their usefulness as a diagnostic tool [108].Another index with total hydroperoxides measured by dROMs method has been described. For this index, the measurement of the biological antioxidant potential (BAP) is used as the antioxidant component.In the BAP method, the ability of plasma antioxidant components to give reducing equivalents to reactive species is determinate using Fe3+ that are reduced to Fe2+. The values are expressed in terms of iron-reducing activity by vitamin C as standard, considering as cut-off values: >2200 μmol/L as optimum status, <1600 μmol/L as deficient status, and <1400 μmol/L as high deficiency status [99, 113].An arbitrary index is calculated as a ratio. This index has been used in two directions(i)
Oxidant to antioxidant (dROMs/BAP) ratio, if it considers that the balance is disrupted by excessive production of dROMs or by low BAP
(ii)
Antioxidant to oxidant (BAP/dROMs) ratio, when it wants to measure the relative antioxidant capacityIn addition, two modifications to the BAP/dROMs ratio have emerged. First a proposal of Yamamoto et al. (2015) called mOA that is an adjustment of the ratio by the constant 7.541 [114]:
(5)mOA=BAP/dROMs7.451.In the other modifications, each BAP/dROMs value is divided by mean BAP/dROMs ratio; in its interpretation, a cut-off value <1.0 indicates an antioxidant potential decreased [115]. This is the only study that establishes a cut-off value; others use the ratios as quantitative values. Both indexes aim to show more clearly the antioxidant potential.These indexes have been used in research mainly in Japan; seven studies calculated the ratio in the oxidant direction to the antioxidant [99, 116–121], and six in the reverse direction [113, 122–124], including the investigations that calculated the modified ratios [106, 107] (Table 8). Only in one report the follicular fluid was used as a biological sample [116]; in the others, serum or plasma was used, and neither markers of the OS were included in the studies.Table 8
Characteristics and findings of studies that used ROM/BAP or BAP/ROM ratios.
Author, year [ref]
Study design/country
Population (age, sex)/sample size
Main outcome
Results
Conclusion
Kakita H et al., 2009 [116]
Case-control study/Japan
Preterm infants(31 weeks gestational age, both sexes)/22 infants with PVL22 healthy
Association between OS and neonatal cystic periventricular leukomalacia (PVL)
ROM/BAP was higher in early cystic PVL than in late cystic PVL or controls.Postnatal duration until cyst identification displayed a negative correlation with ROM/BAP
Neonates experiencing more OS at birth show earlier onset of cystic PVL
Hussein MH et al., 2011 [99]
ObservationalLongitudinal/Japan
Children (1.2-14.4 y, both sexes)/43 patients
Relationship between OS and post-liver transplantation duration
ROM/BAP correlated positively with hepatic enzymes and negatively with post-liver transplantation duration.
The ROM/BAP can serve as an index of patients’ laboratory results and oxidative status.
Chung DH et al., 2012 [117]
Intervention study/Korea
Adults (17-68 y, both sexes)/20 AR patients 20 NAR patients
To evaluate the susceptibility of patients with allergic rhinitis (AR) to OS compared with nonallergic rhinitis (NAR) patients
The ROM/BAP ratio was higher after surgery (nasal septoplasty) in the AR group than in the NAR group.
AR patients might be vulnerable to OS, due to their ROM/BAP imbalance.
Kaneko K et al., 2012 [118]
Intervention study/Japan
Children (0.14-5.38 y, both sexes)/19 patients with KD7 patients with febrile illnesses(FI)
Association between OS and Kawasaki disease (KD) and if intravenous immunoglobulin therapy (IVIG) is a scavenger of ROS
Children with KD had low value of the ROM/BAP ratio after IVIG.
Seems that OS has a role in the pathogenesis of acute KD.
Kakita H et al., 2012 [119]
Retrospective case-control study/Japan
Newborns (37-41 wk gestational age, both sexes)/6 hypothermia16 normothermia15 control group
To evaluate OS in asphyxiated infants and to determinate if hypothermia treatment has an effect on OS
The ROM/BAP ratio values gradually increased after birth in hypothermia and normothermia cases. After 7 days, the ratio was higher in normothermia cases.
Hypothermia attenuated the OS in asphyxiated newborns.
Hussein MH et al., 2013 [120]
ObservationalLongitudinal/Japan
Children (2-15 y, both sexes)/16 IMD patients10 BA patients
Assess the differences in OS between pediatric patients undergoing living-related liver transplantation due to inherited metabolic disease (IMD) or biliary atresia (BA)
The ROM/BAP ratio was higher in the IMD group.
Patients who receive living-related liver transplantation due to IMD are prone to higher ROM/BAP ratio.
Fukuda S et al., 2016 [121]
Experimental study/Japan
Adults (37±9y and 20±0.5y, both sexes)/12 females in acute stress condition24 subjects in subacute fatigue condition121 at-rest condition
Use dROMs and BAP to discriminate patients with chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS) from healthy volunteers experiencing acute and subacute fatigue, and at rest
The ROM/BAP ratio was higher after subacute fatigue. Resting condition produced higher ratio in patients with CFS than in healthy volunteers.
The markers might be useful for discriminate acute, subacute, and resting fatigue in healthy people and CFS patients.
Faienza MF et al., 2012 [113]
Cross-sectional/Italy
Children (11±3y, both sexes)/25 obese withMetS30 obese30 controls
Alterations in the oxidant/antioxidant status in obese children with and without metabolic syndrome (MetS)
Children without MetS had lower BAP/dROMs ratio than children with MetS. The ratio BAP/dROMs was higher in controls than no-MetS and MetS children.
The authors did not conclude directly about the index, but they infer that fat accumulation is involved in the pathogenesis of systemic OS.
Fukui T et al., 2015 [122]
Intervention study/Japan
Adults (58±11y, both sexes)/Patients with hyperuricemia29 patients treated with febuxostat14 patients treated with allopurinol
Effect of febuxostat compared with allopurinol on OS measured by BAP/dROMs ratio
No significant changes were observed in the BAP/dROMs ratio.
A regulatory mechanism may be counteracted changes in the OS balance caused by febuxostat administration.
Yamamoto K et al., 2015 [114]
Experimental pilot study/Japan
Adults (17-57 y, both sexes)/42 patients with active CD in treatment with anti-TNF-α antibodies
Effect of antitumor necrosis factor (TNF)-α treatment on OS in Crohn’s disease (CD) patients.It used a modified BAP/dROMs ratio (m-BAP/dROMs ratio).
Negative correlation between m-BAP/dROMs ratio and CD activity index before and after treatment. The ratio did not differ between the patients before treatment.
Anti-TNF-α therapy decreases OS in patients with CD but does not modify the antioxidant production.
Hatanaka H et al., 2015 [123]
Cross-sectional/Japan
Older adults (81±7y, both sexes)/72 AD patients 27 with VaD24 with MD53 nondemented patients
OS differs in the pathophysiology and cognitive decline of Alzheimer’s disease (AD), vascular dementia (VaD), and mixed Alzheimer’s/vascular dementia (MD).
BAP/dROM ratios were lower in the AD and MD groups than control. The minimental state scores correlated with the ratio in the AD patients.
An imbalance in oxidant/antioxidant defenses may be involved in the pathophysiology of the AD and MD.
Nakagawa K et al., 2016 [115]
Cross-sectional/Japan
Adults (37±3y, women)/26 patients with unilateral EM29 without EM
To evaluate OS in the environment of the follicular fluid (FF) of patients with endometrioma (EM)
The patients with a m-BAP/dROMratio<1.0 in the EM group was similar to the control group.
The oxidative/antioxidant potential in the FF of EM patients is similar to the controls.
Pesce M et al., 2018 [124]
Experimental study/Italy
Older adults (60-80 y, both sexes)/29 subjects in EG23 in control group
Effect of memory training (MT) on plasma oxidant and antioxidant capacity
BAP/d-ROMs ratio improved in experimental group (EG). BAP/d-ROMs ratio was positively correlated with the measurement of memory.
MT was associated with the increase in resistance against OS at the plasma level.
ROS: reactive oxygen species.Also, it draws attention that some researchers call the dROMs/BAP ratio “oxidative stress index” (OSI) [99, 116, 119–121] as the first index that we included in this review, which is logical because this index is an oxidant/antioxidant ratio; the difference is the form of evaluation of both components. In both OSI, the oxidative part is the measurement of total peroxides or hydroperoxides, which are the oxidation products of several molecules, such as lipids, proteins, and amino acids; therefore, this is a measure of oxidative damage, what does not happen with the antioxidant capacity. The TAC and BAP have different principles, as well as their measurement units; both determinate the total nonenzymatic antioxidant capacity of biological samples, but although BAP is the most recommended procedures [125], the results of the different studies shown that this parameter almost does not change, making the index show no difference [114, 115, 122], especially when it is used to see the antioxidant potential (BAP/dROMs).In summary, seems that the Oxidative INDEX can reflex the intensity of the OS better than the dROMs/BAP ratios, but these indexes do not include antioxidant enzymes, important elements in oxidative/antioxidative balance.


### 3.6. Oxidative Stress Profile

As we explained above, all the ratios and indexes proposal only measure extracellular OS components or oxidative/antioxidative capacities of the biological samples, so missing other elements that also participate in the oxidative balance.Thus, in another attempt to measure oxidative/antioxidant balance, Cutler et al. in 2005 [126, 127] proposed the so-called “oxidative stress profile,” where it considers a lot of markers of oxidative damage, such as MDA, 4-HNE, hydroperoxides, isoprostanes, oxidized nucleic acids, protein carbonyls, antioxidants (endogenous and exogenous), and plus inflammation markers, such as interleukins, measured in both blood and urine samples. In total, these were suggested more than 50 elements in a proposal to assess the oxidative/antioxidative balance [127].In the interpretation of the results, cut-off values are established for optimum health and intervals outside the reference ones, making a balance between the oxidized components through an oxidation index and an antioxidant index, obtaining an average level of antioxidant protection and other oxidative damages summarized in four categories: (1) high protection-high damage, (2) high protection-low damage, (3) low protection-low damage, and (4) low protection-high damage [126, 127]. The limitations of this proposal are the high cost due to the large number of parameters to be measured; many of which require a measurement with sophisticated equipment and techniques and also the need to establish the cut-off values to calculate the indexes, mainly of the exogenous antioxidant markers, which are dependent on the diet and lifestyle, so they cannot be generalized in the populations, and finally, the complexity in interpreting the results.


### 3.7. OXY Score

Follow-up with the same objective of creating an index to measure the OS, Veglia et al. in 2006 proposed the so-called OXY score, an index derived from the computation of different parameters of the oxidative balance. This score includes individual measurements in plasma of free and total MDA (F-MDA, T-MDA) and the GSSG and GSH levels and moreover the urinary isoprostane-PF2α-III level (iPF2α) as the combined oxidative damage. The antioxidant counterpart includes GSH, α- and γ-tocopherol, and antioxidant capacity measured by the OXY Adsorbent Test, which the authors called individual antioxidant capacity [128].For calculation, first the F-MDA, T-MDA, iPF2α, and GSSG levels are log-transformed, then each marker must be standardized according to the formula previously describe, using the raw or log-transformed value as correspond. Later, the average of the standardized oxidants (damage score) and the average of the standardized antioxidants (protection score) must be calculated. Finally, the subtraction of a damage score minus protection score is the OXY score.Same as for Oxidative INDEX, if the result is near to zero, the levels of all markers are near the average normal values or there is a balance between oxidants and antioxidants, and positive values indicate an imbalance towards the oxidants [128, 129]. It has been suggested to compute the OXY score without the urinary iPF2α as a modified OXY score, with similar results [130].Although the ability of the OXY score to discriminate between different clinical conditions, age, and sex has been reported [127, 128], it is necessary to recognize that antioxidant enzymes are not included, being a score limiting [130]. Some drawbacks of the OXY score are the difficulty in calculating it, and the methods of measurement of all the markers are included, because they are complex and expensive; thus, it is not easily applicable to clinical and epidemiological settings.Another modification to the OXY score is reported, which is a global score for the OS associated with albuminuria to their use in chronic kidney disease patients (Albumin OXY score). This index included protein carbonyl and MDA to calculate the damage score, and superoxide (O2−⋅) scavenging activity, catalase (CAT), and TAC as the protection index. For the calculating, the authors followed the procedures indicated for the Oxidative INDEX and the OXY score and proposed a new calculation that includes logarithmic transformation, standardization, and final subtraction, integrating both proposals. Being standardized values, the interpretation is equal to the two indexes previously mentioned [131]. The main clinical disadvantages of this index are the complication in the calculation, the cost, and the complexity of some measurements, although the total number of markers to be measured was reduced.


### 3.8. Oxidative Stress Score

All the indexes mentioned until now, except that proposed by Cutler and the Albumin OXY score, include an oxidant part and the non-enzymatic antioxidant capacity and do not take into account the antioxidant enzymes as part of the calculation. Thus, it seems necessary to include at least the main enzymes in the cell antioxidant process: superoxide dismutase (SOD), glutathione peroxidase (GPx), and/or catalase (CAT).In this sense, Amstad et al. in 1991 [132] showed in transformed cell lines of mice that the balance between the activities of SOD and CAT+GPx is more important to determine the oxidative effect than the absolute activity of a single enzyme. Following this proposal, it has developed a theoretical model of biochemical interaction between these three enzymes showing an additive effect between SOD and GPx, and synergistic effects between GPx and CAT to ensure a global cell protection [133, 134]. As we know, the oxygen in aerobic organisms is part of various biochemical reactions, such as the mitochondrial respiratory chain and phagocytosis. One characteristic of these biochemical processes is the transformation of molecular oxygen into O2−⋅, which is dismuted by SOD, forming H2O2 in a first step. Although it is currently recognized that H2O2 is an important molecule in redox regulation and signaling processes, it is also known that it is a molecule harmful for its oxidizing capacity; thus, living organisms have a series of enzymes H2O2-removing to maintain balance, being glutathione peroxidases as the main second step [8, 135]. An imbalance between the first and second steps has as the potential result of increasing H2O2 levels, which is possible because the reaction constant of SOD is higher than GPx, so H2O2 is formed quickly and is not eliminated in its entirety; in addition, this disproportion in the activity between SOD and GPx in favor of the first can produce an increase in lipoperoxidation [136]; therefore, the inclusion of these enzymes as part of an integral OS measurement is important.Another point to consider in the assessment of OS is to establish which cut-off values of the oxidative/antioxidative imbalance can be considered as harmful, to refer only to the oxidative distress. In this sense, in 2004, we proposed the integral and dynamic measurement of the OS through the evaluation of the antioxidant system efficiency, establishing the categories: (a) efficient antioxidant system (EAS) when the harmful action of the oxidants is effectively counteracted, (b) antioxidant enzymatic deficiency (ANED) if there is an inefficient or insufficient action of antioxidant enzymes, (c) exogenous antioxidants deficiency (EXAD) when there is an insufficient or inefficient action of non-enzymatic antioxidants causing oxidized the molecules, and (d) antioxidant system global deficiency (ASGD) if the enzymatic and nonenzymatic antioxidant components show an imbalance in favor of oxidized molecules [137, 138]. Later, we reorganized the interpretation considering the intensity of the OS, proposing four categories: without OS (WOS), low OS (LOS), moderate OS (MOS), and severe OS (SOS). About this, Lushchak in 2014 [139] also expressed the need to classify the OS based on the intensity, suggesting three levels: low, intermediate, and high, where the high can be interpreted as severe OS, very similar to our proposal.In order to reach our classification, an index was calculated which we call the oxidative stress score (SS) [140]. The SS includes, originally, the measurement of plasma MDA and DNA damage, the activities of the SOD and GPx erythrocyte enzymes, the total antioxidant plasma status (TAS), and the calculation of the SOD/GPx ratio as a marker of oxidation, and the antioxidant gap (GAP). In this sense, GAP represents the antioxidant capacity of other nonmeasured plasma components different to albumin and uric acid, such as antioxidant vitamins, bilirubin, and hormones, can be calculated from TAS, and albumin and uric acid levels multiplied by their value of Trolox equivalent antioxidant capacity (TEAC) using the formula [10]:
(6)GAP=TAS−albumin×TEAC+uricacid×TEAC,where TAS, albumin, and uric acid are in μmol/L, TEAC for albumin is 0.69, and TEAC for uric acid is 1.00.Low-molecular-weight antioxidants such as GSH and thiols are not included in the score because both are measured in TAS, and CAT neither is considered due to its role as H2O2 removal is relative in humans, because it is a peroxisomal enzyme [8].It was defined the cut-off values of each parameter based on the 90th percentile of healthy young subjects (20-45 y and both sexes), and a score 1 was given to each value above of cut-off (MDA, DNA damage, and SOD/GPx ratio) or under the cut-off (enzymatic and non-enzymatic markers), and 0 if the values are in normal range. After, a sum of all the components was obtained as a SS ranging from 0 to 7, representing the severity of the marker modifications. Then, the SS was categorized as follows [140]:
(i)
WOS ifSS=0‐1
(ii)
LOS ifSS=2‐3
(iii)
MOS ifSS=4‐5
(iv)
SOS ifSS=6‐7Also, we have excluded DNA damage because their procedure is not easily accessible; in this case, SS is ranging from 0 to 6 [141]. This index can be dichotomous, if SS≤3, we consider as without OS or eustress, and if SS>3, the subjects have high OS or distress [142].The SS has been used in several studies since 2005. It has probed in young, mid-aged, and older subjects, both sexes and different study designs (Table9). This index has shown to be useful to differentiate rural/urban residents [140] and pre/postmenopausal women [141, 146]. Also, it has been applied in cognitive impairment [138], chronic-degenerative diseases such as diabetes mellitus and arterial hypertension [142, 145], osteoporosis [143], and metabolic syndrome [144]. In addition, it has been used in clinical experimental studies demonstrating therapeutic [148] and of nutritional supplements effects [141, 151], as well as the efficiency of controlled physical exercise [147, 150].Table 9
Characteristics and findings of studies that use the oxidative stress score (SS)∗ in Mexicans.
Author, year [ref]
Study design
Population (age, sex)/sample size
Main outcome
Results
Conclusion
Sánchez-Rodríguez MA. et al. 2005 [141]
Clinical trial
Older adults(67±7y, both sexes)/63 subjects with exercise and antioxidant diet63 subjects with vitamins E 400 UI–C 500 mg/d63 subjects with vitamins E 400 UI–C 1000 mg/d80 controls
Effect of moderate physical exercise and antioxidant diet in comparison to oral vitamins C and E vs. severe OS
All groups with treatment after 1y had SS lower compared with pretest.Only 6 elderlies in the vitamin groups have severe OS after 1 y.
Moderate physical exercise and antioxidant diet have similar effect against severe OS than antioxidant vitamins in healthy elderlies.
Sánchez-Rodríguez MA. et al., 2006 [140]
Cross-sectional
Older adults(68±7y, both sexes)/121 subjects from Mexico City85 subjects from a rural residence
To compare different OS marker vs. an integral score that considers oxidized biomolecules and the antioxidant (enzymatic and nonenzymatic) systems
Only SOD activity was similar in both groups.In urban residence, 42% of elderly had severe OS compared with 10% of the subjects of rural residence.
The proposed SS may be useful for assessing the severity of OS.
Sánchez-Rodríguez MA. et al., 2006 [138]
Cross-sectional
Older adults (68±7y, both sexes)/104 subjects from Mexico City85 subjects from a rural area
Association between OS and cognitive impairment (CI) in elderly residents from rural and urban areas
Greater proportion of subjects with OS and CI in urban than in rural areas, being a risk factor.Higher OS and CI were observed in subjects >80 y of the urban area.
Elderly from urban area have more OS and greater risk of develop CI than inhabitants of rural communities.
Beristain-Pérez AS. et al., 2006 [142]
Cross-sectional
Older adults (67±7y, both sexes)/33 subjects with DM40 subjects with AH26 subjects with OA63 healthy subjects
OS as risk factor for chronic degenerative diseases (CDD): type 2 diabetes mellitus (DM), arterial hypertension (AH), or osteoarthritis (OA) in older adults
OS was higher in DM and AH subjects.OS is a risk factor for CDD.
The OS is a risk factor for CDD, mainly for DM and AH subjects.
Sánchez-Rodríguez MA. et al., 2007 [143]
Case-control study
Older adults (68±7y, both sexes)/44 subjects with osteoporosis50 healthy subjects
OS as an independent risk factor for osteoporosis in older adults
OS was higher in subjects with osteoporosis.OS is a significant risk factor for osteoporosis.
OS is a risk factor for osteoporosis.
Sánchez-Rodríguez MA. et al., 2010 [144]
Cross-sectional
Older adults (67±1y, both sexes)/63 with MetS50 healthy
Association between the number of metabolic syndrome (MetS) components and OS.
The percentage of severe OS in subjects with MetS was higher.The risk for OS increases with the number of components.
MetS is linked to severe OxS, and the risk for OS increases with the number of MetS components.
Mendoza-Núñez VM. et al., 2011 [145]
Cross-sectional
Adults and older adults (both sexes)/56 healthy adults (47±7y)60 DM adults (52±6y)40 healthy older adults (67±7y)72 DM older adults (68±7y)
Assess the additive effect of diabetes mellitus (DM) and aging on OS
DM is a risk factor for OS and a stronger factor in older subjects.
Aging and DM exerts an additive effect over the OS.
Sánchez-Rodríguez MA. et al., 2012 [146]
Cross-sectional
Adults (women)94 premenopausal (45±4y)93 postmenopausal (53±3y)
Influence of menopause as a risk factor for OS
SS was higher in postmenopause. There is an increase in the percentage of severe OS in postmenopausal women.
The decrease of estrogens in the postmenopause can cause OS, together with the symptoms of this period.
Rosado-Pérez J. et al., 2013 [147]
Quasiexperimental study
Older adults (60-74 y, both sexes)/43 subjects walking31 subjects in tai chi23 control subjects
Effect of the practice of tai chi and walking on OS
SS decrease in the tai chi and walking groups, but more evident in the tai chi group.
The practice of tai chi produces an antioxidant effect better than walking.
Sánchez-Rodríguez MA. et al., 2016 [148]
Randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled trial
Adults (53±1y, women)25 heathy with HT25 healthy with placebo25 MetS with HT25 MetS with placebo
Effect of oral hormone therapy (HT) (1 mg/day of estradiol valerate plus 5 mg/10 day of medroxyprogesterone) on OS in postmenopausal women with metabolic syndrome (MetS).
SS decrease after 6 mo in the two groups with HT, more evident in the women with MetS.The proportion of women with OS decreases in both groups of women with HT.
HT improves OS associated with MetS in postmenopause.
Sánchez-Rodríguez MA. et al., 2017 [149]
Cross-sectional
Adults (40-59 y, women)101 premenopausal101 postmenopausal
Relationship between OS with psychological disturbances, low self-esteem, and low quality of life in the postmenopause
Women with low self-esteem and low quality of life had higher SS.
OS is increased in women with low self-esteem and low quality of life.
Mendoza-Núñez VM. et al., 2018 [150]
Quasiexperimental study
Older adults with MetS (60-74 y, both sexes)60 subjects in TC50 control group
Effect of tai chi (TC) exercise on OS in older adults with metabolic syndrome (MetS)
Decrease in the SS after TC training.The percentage of subjects with OS in the TC group decreases after 6 mo.
The TC exercise has an antioxidative effect in the older adults with MetS.
Rosado-Pérez J., et al., 2019 [151]
Exploratory study of a single group
Older adults (71±6y, both sexes)/12 subjects
Effect of the dried fruit powder ofSechium edule (chayote) on OS in older adults with metabolic syndrome (MetS).
SS decrease after 6 weeks of treatment.
The drySechium edule has an antioxidant effect in older adults with MetS.
∗All studies defined OS using the stress score (SS).Other authors have suggested similar proposals to the SS. Initially, Goodman et al. in 2007 [152] developed an OSS with the same idea of us in the form to compute it, but they included prooxidant and antioxidant factors, mainly from diet and lifestyle, to reflect a prooxidant/antioxidant exposure balance. This score is different to our proposal, because they do not perform measurements, rather they use questionnaires to obtain the information and based on them the calculation is made. As the main intention of this index is the exposure balance, the name has been changed to oxidative balance score (OBS). The OBS is a very different index to those included in this review, so we will not discuss it, but it is important to note that it has been used mainly in cases of cancer [141, 153–155] and chronic diseases [156–158], besides it has been related to OS markers [159, 160], inflammation markers [161, 162], then too it carried out studies from its relationship with some gene expression and genetic polymorphism [163–166].On the other hand, based on the Goodman proposal [152], a study was carried out to determinate the association between adiposity measures and an OSS. The OSS was obtained from the blood measurements of GSH, GPx, vitamin C, MDA, and TAC, and some factors of lifestyle such as smoking, use of anti-inflammatory medication, nutritional supplement, and herbal product, adding a total of 9 components [167]. All the variables were categorized as 0 or 1, as we previously pointed. Although the idea is like to our SS, this index is more complex and included particular parameters such as the consumption anti-inflammatory medication and herbal product that are not necessarily useful in all the researchers.Another study used six blood oxidative stress markers: MDA, ox-LDL, total antioxidant reactivity (TAR), SOD, GPx, and CAT, and those were scored as 0, 1, and 2 according the mean and standard deviation (SD) of healthy subjects. A score of 0 was assigned if the measurement of MDA, ox-LDL, CAT, or SOD (oxidants) was rangingmean+1SD or if TAR and GPx (antioxidants) values were mean−1SD. When the values were between +1SD and +2SD of the oxidants or −1SD and −2SD of the antioxidants, a value of 1 point was assigned. A value of 2 points was scored if the oxidant values were more than +2SD or the antioxidant values were less than −2SD. In this case, OSS ranging from 0 to 12 and in a dichotomous way, 6 is the cut-off [168]. This OSS seems more accessible to clinical research than the previous, but it needs to be tested in other clinical settings, since it has only been used in phenylketonuria.In addition, in 2014, two variants of OSS have been published. The first is called OSI, because it analyzes the oxidant/antioxidant balance as the original OSI, but really is an index due to the oxidizing part which includes total lipoperoxides measured as their different forms (conjugated dienes, ketodienes, compounds with conjugated double bonds, conjugated trienes, and MDA), and in the antioxidant part, called the antioxidant defense (AOD), there is an evaluation ofα-tocopherol, retinol, and reduced and oxidized glutathione levels plus SOD activity. First is necessary to obtain the result of the division between each value and the mean value of the control group of each parameter. After that, a multiplication of the oxidized components is placed in the numerator and the multiplication of the antioxidant counterpart in the denominator. As the control value is 1, in the interpretation, values above 1 indicate OS [169]. As the calculation is complex, their use seems impractical.The last proposal includes 12 different blood OS parameters, four oxidized components (protein carbonyls, protein sulfhydryl, MDA, and 8-OHdG), and eight antioxidant components (SOD, GPx, glutathione reductase [GR], CAT, GSH, uric acid, bilirubin, and vitamin C). In the report, the calculation is not very explicit; only the authors explain that specificZ-scores of each parameter were computed, and after an OSS was calculated without explain how this is performed [170]; therefore, its application is doubtful.One common point in all those proposals is that MDA is used as oxidized marker; this is possible because this parameter is an index of lipoperoxidation involved in both recent and chronic damages, so although much has been questioned, especially its form of measurement, is the marker that best reflects the oxidative state in any health situation or disease. The other point to highlight is the use of the main antioxidant enzymes, SOD and GPx, which importance was discussed at the beginning of this section, together the measurement of the antioxidant capacity, a parameter, in which all the indexes shown here are in agreement, independently of the method by it is evaluated.Finally, all the proposals that were revised concord in an important aspect; the measurement of the involved oxidative stress markers as an indicator is more sensitive to the imbalance between oxidants and antioxidants than individual parameters.Indeed, the SS is a proposal with the advantage that it is possible to increase the number of markers (and therefore the total score), both oxidized molecules and antioxidants, being able to include oxidized proteins, DNA damage, and other enzymes or antioxidant molecules; as long as the cut-off values are taken to decide when the marker is increased or decreased, as the case may be.In this review, we analyzed the main indexes as indicators to measure oxidative stress grades linked to different clinical and health settings, highlighting the advantages and disadvantages of each of them. It should be noted that the modulating mechanisms of OS in humans are complex and interact with each other; hence, the SS can be useful to determine if an individual has a high level of OS and thus proceeds with a possible antioxidant therapy, thus improving your state of health and quality of life.It is worth mentioning as a limitation of this review that the indexes for measuring oxidative stress analyzed here are not the only ones. We find in the literature review of others, such as the prooxidant-antioxidant balance (PAB) [171] and the oxidation-reduction potential (ORP) [172], which were not included because their fundaments are outside the scope of this work.Despite the abundant information available so far, more clinical research is needed, especially on prognosis, to assess the usefulness of the different indices, and comparison studies between them, as well as an analysis of the literature of the indicators that evaluate both components, oxidant and antioxidant in a single measurement, as in the PAB, and the redox potential of a sample, such as the ORP.


## 3.1. Oxidative Balance

One simple form to measure the oxidative/antioxidant balance is calculating a ratio. The first proposal to use a ratio to measure oxidative balance was the oxidized/reduced glutathione (GSSG/GSH). Initial studies in animal models indicated that its increase is an index of OSin vivo and suggests that it can be used as a complement of other parameters [14]. Thus, this ratio has been used in many studies in humans over the past 10 years, so we analyzed its importance in a separate section.The first reports of an attempt to find the relationship between the oxidant and antioxidant counterparts of a biological sample, and not the evaluation of individual markers, are two studies conducted on seminal samples. In these studies, reactive oxygen species (ROS) and total antioxidant capacity were measured, both by chemiluminescence, and a score called ROS-TAC score was calculated. The computation of the ROS-TAC score is complex, with mathematical transformations, standardizations, and a principal component analysis as part of the computation [15, 16], which makes it an impractical score; thus, there is neither study with it.To avoid complex calculations that are not easy to apply to the clinical setting, the researchers resorted to obtaining ratios between an oxidized molecule and an antioxidant. In this sense, the most used oxidation markers have been lipoperoxide level, measured as malondialdehyde (MDA or TBARS) or total lipid hydroperoxides (LOOH), but for the measurement of the antioxidants, a variety of parameters have been used, such as antioxidant enzymes (superoxide dismutase [SOD] or glutathione peroxidase [GPx]) and different ways to measure the nonenzymatic antioxidant capacity (total antioxidant capacity [TAC], ferric reducing antioxidant potential [FRAP], total radical-trapping antioxidant parameter [TRAP], oxygen radical antioxidant [ORAC]) [17–24]. The most commonly used biological samples are the components of the blood, although these reasons have also been applied in measurements obtained from saliva and follicular fluid (Table 2).Table 2
Characteristics and findings of studies that used different individual oxidant and antioxidant biomarkers and calculated a ratio.
Author, year [reference]
Study design/country
Population (age, sex)/sample size
Biological sample/ratio used
Clinical event
Results
Conclusion
Pabón A. et al., 2003 [17]
Cross-sectional/Colombia
Adults (15-37 y, both sexes)/84 subjects with malaria23 control subjects
Plasma, erythrocyte/MDA:TASMDA : GPx
Noncomplicated malaria
MDA/TAS index was 3.5-fold more in patients. MDA/GPx index was increased by 6-fold.
High OS in patients with malaria. Recommended MDA/TAS as OS marker.
Harma M. et al., 2003 [18]
Cross-sectional/Turkey
Adults (mean 30 y, female)/38 women with CHM31 healthy subjects
Plasma/FRAP : TP
Complete hydatidiform mole (CHM)
The mean FRAP/TP index was higher in patients with CHM than in healthy pregnant women.
The authors did not conclude about the FRAP/TP ratio.
Kocyigit A. et al., 2004 [19]
Cross-sectional/Turkey
Children (2-13 y, both sexes)/42 asthmatic children30 healthy children
Plasma/MDA : TAC
Asthma
MDA/TAC ratio was significantly higher in patients.
The authors did not conclude about the MDA/TAC ratio directly.
Agha-Hosseini F. et al., 2012 [20]
Cross-sectional/Iran
Adults (25-82 y, both sexes)/32 subjects with OLP26 subjects with OSCC30 healthy subjects
Saliva/FRAP : MDA
Oral lichen planus (OLP)Oral squamous cell carcinoma (OSCC)
FRAP/MDA ratio was lower in patients with OSCC than both OLP and control.FRAP/MDA ratio was lower in patients with OLP compared to control.
Patients with OLP and OSCC are susceptible to an imbalance of antioxidant-OS.
Venturini D. et al. 2015 [21]
Intervention study/Brazil
Adults (51±8y, both sexes)/21 subjects in fish oil group26 subjects in fish oil+extra virgin olive oil group13 subjects in extra virgin olive oil group42 control subjects
Plasma/TRAP : AOPPAOPP : TRAP
Metabolic syndrome (MetS)
There was an increase in TRAP/AOPP index and a decrease in AOPP/TRAP index in users of fish oil-extra virgin olive oil (FOO) compared with fish oil.
The fish oil and extra virgin olive oil have beneficial synergistic effects on OS, using the ratio, in patients with MetS.
de Almeida J. P. et al., 2016 [22]
Cross-sectional/Brazil
Adults (46-60 y, both sexes)/32 subjects with HCV+HypoD26 subjects with HCV+Normal D89 control subjects
Plasma/AOPP : TRAP
Chronic hepatitis C (HCV) and hypovitaminosis D (HypoD)
HCV patients with hypovitaminosis D had higher AOPP/TRAP.
The authors did not conclude directly about the AOPP/TRAP.
Costa NT. et al., 2016 [23]
Cross-sectional/Brazil
Adults (18-70 y, both sexes)/91 RA patients without IR82 RA patients with IR97 healthy
Plasma/AOPP : TRAP
Rheumatoid arthritis (RA) and insulin resistance (IR)
The patients with IR had higher AOPP/TRAP compared to the patients without IR and not using antitumor necrosis factor-α.
The authors did not conclude directly about the AOPP/TRAP.
Becatti M. et al., 2018 [24]
Longitudinal/Australia
Adults (35±3y, female)/45 infertile women45 control women
Plasma, follicular fluid (FF)/ORAC : MDA
Infertile women undergoing assisted reproductive technology procedures
The plasma ORAC/MDA ratio was about 3.4-fold lower than the control, and the FF ratio was about sixfold lower than the control. Both the plasma and FF ratios results were correlated.
The use of these ratios could help define the critical role of OS markers and their optimum levels in the female reproductive system.
AOPP: advanced oxidation protein products; FRAP: ferric reducing antioxidant potential; GPx: glutathione peroxidase; MDA: malondialdehyde; OS: oxidative stress; TAC: total antioxidant capacity; TAS: total antioxidant status; TP: total peroxides; TRAP: total radical-trapping antioxidant parameter.Regarding the name used to refer the ratio, some authors called it as “oxidative stress index” (OSI) [22, 23], although this term is most used for other relation that we discuss later. Becatti et al. called their ratio as “redox index,” and they define it as a reliable estimation of redox status in humans [24], but neither is it a good option because they measure the ORAC/MDA ratio which is not necessarily a measure of redox status. Therefore, we think it is better to express only the calculated ratio to refer it.The ratio can be calculated from the oxidized molecule to antioxidant, since the shift of the balance toward the oxidative side is considered to represent OS. The lipids oxidized, measured as MDA, or proteins oxidized, measured as advanced oxidation protein products (AOPP), are the main used oxidized molecules, related to total antioxidant status (TAS) or TRAP as antioxidant measure; thus, the MDA/TAS and AOPP/TRAP ratios are recommended indicators of the OS [17, 21]. The use of the ratio toward the antioxidant side indicates only the antioxidant-oxidant imbalance [20, 24].Another way to get the oxidizing/antioxidant ratio is to measure the oxidants like superoxide anion (O2−⋅) and nitric oxide (NO), and glutathione (GSH) or melatonin as antioxidants, although their use should not be frequent, because it exists only one report about melatonin in which it was calculated the NO/melatonin and MDA/melatonin ratios; the authors suggest that these ratios reflect an oxidant-antioxidant balance and could be used to determine OS homeostasis [25], but we should consider that within the OS homeostasis, melatonin is not one of the essential markers. On the other hand, if we calculate the ratio with the oxidants (O2−⋅, NO2−) and GSH as the antioxidant, a problem may arise because the measurement of the oxidants is not easy to apply at patient samples; thus, there remains doubt about its possible usefulness [26].


## 3.2. Glutathione Ratio

As we noted above, the GSSG/GSH ratio is the first attempt to assess the OS as a dynamic way, since this coupler represents the oxidant/antioxidant homeostasis. After a series of animal studies, Curello et al. in 1987 improved the assay of total and oxidized glutathione in blood samples, which has been useful in monitoring of clinical status [27]. From this, different procedures have been developed with various technologies to carry out the measurement not only in blood but also in other biological samples and tissues. In this sense, pitfalls in the measurement of both reduced and oxidized glutathione with those technologies have recently been discussed, pointed an alert in the interpretation of the results [28]; however, glutathione ratio is an indicator of OS widely used.The ratio can be analyzed from GSH to GSSG or inversely GSSG to GSH; in either direction, it is considered as a marker of intracellular OS. If the ratio is obtained from reduced to oxidized glutathione, low values indicate OS; in the opposite direction, a high value denotes OS. Many studies have been realized using the ratio in both ways; thus, we revised them by separation. It is important to keep in mind that most of the time, the glutathione ratio is used as another marker of the OS, as was suggested from the beginning of its use [14], not as an individual indicator, like the ratios pointed above.Furthermore, it is possible to express the glutathione ratio as redox potential (Eh GSH/GSSG), which is a way to represent the redox environment in biological fluids [29]. The redox potential is calculated by the Nernst equation as follows [30]:
(1)EhmV=E0+RT2FlnGSSG/GSH2,where E0=−264mV (GSH/GSSG couple standard potential for pH 7.4), R is the gas constant (8.314 J/°Kmol), T is the absolute temperature (°K), F is the Faraday constant (9.6485×104 C/mol), and GSH and GSSG are the concentrations in moles/liter. In the interpretation, higher Eh values indicate a greater potential for oxidation or OS.The first studies in humans that use this ratio have begun in the 90s. In this review, we found three reports in this decade. Two who obtained the GSSG/GSH ratio of measurements made in the blood of newborns and whose results suggest its use as a noninvasive method to evaluate the OS [31, 32]. The other research is an experimental study with free fatty acid (FFA) infusions in which the lipoperoxide level was measured through the MDA and LOOH, in addition to the GSH/GSSG ratio. In this study, the role of the ratio in the effect sought is not directly concluded, but an inference is made when it considers that the OS intensifies with the increase of FFA [33].Subsequently, in this century, an avalanche of information has emerged. Twenty-four articles located inform the use of the GSH/GSSG ratio to evaluate the antioxidant/oxidant balance, which is on the Table3 [33–55]. The sample mainly used is whole blood and its derivatives (erythrocytes, polymorphonuclear cells, or plasma), and other markers are added, such as oxidation products, oxidants, and enzymatic and nonenzymatic antioxidants, to obtain a more comprehensive measurement of the OS, although it is possible to use exclusively the glutathione ratio, but remember that this ratio measures only the intracellular OS [35, 36, 49, 51, 55]. Regarding to the GSSG/GSH ratio, fifteen studies were localized, and blood is the biological sample used mainly, but also it is possible to measure glutathione in saliva [56, 57]. As in the previous ratio, it is common to add more OS markers [30, 31, 56–68], and the measurement of the ratio from oxidized to reduced form is a good marker of oxidant/antioxidant imbalance in different clinical situations (Table 4).Table 3
Characteristics and findings of studies that used reduced to oxidized glutathione ratio (GSH/GSSG).
Author, year [reference]
Study design/country
Population (age, sex)/sample size
Biological sample/other markers
Main outcome
Results
Conclusion
Paolisso G. et al., 1996 [33]
Experimental study with free fatty acids (FFA) infusions/Italy
Adults (33±1y, both sexes)/10 subjects with intralipid continuum infusion9 subjects with 6 h intralipid infusion11 subjects with insulin infusion
Plasma/MDA, LOOH
Effect of FFA on OS
The GSH/GSSG ratio diminished after 6 h of FFA infusion and continued to 24 h, although the better effect was at 6 h. After a wash-out period, the ratio returns to basal value.
The OS intensifies with the increase of FFA, inferring that the ratio measures the OS.
Abramson JL. et al., 2005 [34]
Cross-sectional/USA
Adults (44±9y, both sexes)/126 subjects without CHD
Plasma/FORT
Association between OS and high sensitivity CRP (hsCRP)
The GSH/GSSG ratio showed little association with hsCRP.
The ratio was not strongly associated with CRP.
Gherghel D. et al., 2005 [35]
Cross-sectional/UK
Older adults (70±10y, both sexes)/21 POAG patients34 control subjects
Blood/none
Glutathione status in primary open-angle glaucoma (POAG)
The GSH/GSSG ratio was similar in both sexes. No differences between study group and control were observed in redox index, after correction for age and gender.
The authors did not conclude about the ratio because the results were not significant.
Yeh CC. et al., 2006 [36]
Cross-sectional/Taiwan
Adults (27-83 y, female)/112 women with BC40 control subjects
Blood, tumor tissue/none
Glutathione status in breast cancer (BC)
GSH/TGSSG ratio was decreased in the blood of the patients with breast cancer, and breast cancer tissue was increased, especially in stage II.
There was an imbalance in the glutathione redox status in the breast tumor patients.
Ashfaq S. et al., 2006 [37]
Cross-sectional/USA
Adults (30-65 y, both sexes)/114 healthy subjects
Blood/cysteine and its redox state
Thiols status and early atherosclerosis
After adjusting for traditional risk factors and hs-CRP, the GSH/GSSG ratio is an independent predictor of intima-media thickness.
Glutathione redox state is an independent predictor for the presence of early atherosclerosis.
Nikolaidis MG. et al., 2007 [38]
Experimental of isokinetic exercise/Greece
Adults (23±2y, female)/12 women in isokinetic exercise
Blood/MDA, TAC, PC
Effect of repeated muscle-damaging exercise on the time-course changes in indices of muscle damage
Exercise decreased the GSH/GSSG ratio at several time points after both exercise bouts.
The authors did not conclude directly with the ratio but shown an effect across it.
Harzallah O. et al., 2008 [39]
Cross-sectional/Tunisia
Adults (22–61 y, both sexes)/40 subjects with BD40 healthy subjects
Blood/MDA, CAT, SOD, GPx
Association between OS and Behçet’s disease (BD)
The GSH/GSSG ratio was reduced in BD patients.
Exist an OS in BD as shown by the diminution of the ratio.
Youssef H. et al., 2009 [40]
Cross-sectional postexercise effect/Lebanon
Adolescents (14-19 y, female)/29 overweight girls17 normal weight girls
Blood/F2-Iso, LOOH, ox-LDL, SOD, GPx, vit. C, vit. E,β-carot.
Effect of incremental ergocycle exercise on OS
The overweight adolescents presented the GSH/GSSG ratio lower.No changes for GSH/GSSH were observed in both groups after exercise.
Exercise exacerbates OS in the overweight adolescents; GSH/GSSG ratio is a good marker.
Tsai SM. et al., 2009 [41]
Cross-sectional/Taiwan
Adults (31-81 y, both sexes)/54 HBV-associated HCC patients57 control subjects
Blood/O2⋅−, MDA, SOD, GPx, vit. A, C, E
Changes in OS in chronic hepatitis B virus (HBV)-associated hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) patients
The ratio of GSH/GSSG of HBV-associated HCC patients was lower than that of controls.
Changes in the GSH demonstrated that HBV-associated HCC patients had undergone OS during their clinical disease progression.
Huang YS. et al., 2009 [30]
Cross-sectional/China
Adults (41-76 y, both sexes)/56 patients plaque-forming42 patients with intima-media thickening34 subjects with normal intima-media
Plasma/MDA, ox-LDL
Relationship between glutathione redox status and the atherosclerosis
GSH/GSSG redox status was positively correlated with the intima thickness.
Peroxidative glutathione redox status may be a sensitive and reliable index for monitoring OS in atherosclerosis.
Kleinsorge EC. et al., 2011 [42]
Cross-sectional/Argentina
Adults (23±2y, both sexes)/26 photocopy machine operators52 control subjects
Erythrocyte/MDA, CAT, DICA
To determinate the oxidative damage in photocopier operators
GSH/GSSG is similar between operators and controls.
The authors did not discuss or conclude about the ratio.
Patel RS. et al., 2011 [43]
Cross-sectional/USA
Adults and elderly (20-70 y, both sexes)/169 healthy subjects
Plasma/cysteine ratio, dROMs
Relationship between novel markers of OS and arterial elastic properties
The redox potential of GSH/GSSG showed modest association with carotid-femoral pulse wave velocity.
After multivariate adjustment for confounders, GSH/GSSG is not associated with impaired arterial elasticity.
Zepeda RJ. et al., 2012 [44]
Prospective randomized single blind clinical trial/Chile
Adults (30-75 y, both sexes)/23 patients with EH in carvedilol therapy21 patients with EH in nebivolol therapy30 normotensive patients
Erythrocyte/NOx, FRAP, MDA, 8-Iso
Effect of carvedilol and nebivolol on the OS and endothelial function in patients with essential hypertension (EH)
In patients with carvedilol, GSH/GSSG ratio was higher compared with patients who received nebivolol.
As part of the antihypertensive mechanism, carvedilol seems to reinforce the antioxidant system.
Llorente-Cantarero FJ. et al., 2012 [45]
Cross-sectional/Spain
Children (7-12 y, both sexes)/138 healthy subjects
Erythrocyte/MDA, 4-HNE, PC, NOx, SOD, GPx
To identify gender-based biomarkers for OS in children
Girls had a lower GSH/GSSG ratio than boys.
The authors did not conclude about the ratio directly.
Ntalapascha M. et al., 2013 [46]
Observational prospective/Greece
Adults (30-65 y, male)/18 patients with severe OSAS13 control subjects
Erythrocyte/MDA, PC, 8-Iso, CAT, SOD, TAC
Assess the OS in patients with obstructive sleep apnea syndrome (OSAS)
The overnight (morning–night) change (%) of GSH/GSSG ratio was different between OSAS and controls.
OSAS might be associated with increased OS possibly via GSH/GSSG pathway.
Shah D. et al., 2013 [47]
Cross-sectional/India
Adults (29±8y, both sexes)/40 patients with SLE40 healthy subjects
Erythrocyte/MDA, SOD, CAT, GPx, ROS production, total thiols
Association between glutathione pathway and systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) severity
Altered redox state (GSH/GSSG) was found in SLE patients.The severity of disease was allied with altered GSH/GSSG.
GSH depletion may be coupled with the severity of the disease.
Victor VM. et al., 2014 [48]
Observational prospective of testosterone (T) therapy/Spain
Adults (29±10y, transsexual)/57 female-to-male transsexuals (FtMs)
Polymorpho-nuclear cells/mitochondrial O2 consumption, membrane potential, ROS production
The effect of T treatment on the redox state of leukocytes of FtMs subjects
GSH/GSSG ratio was lower in patients post-T treatment
Treatment of FtMs with T can induce a state of OS.
Enns GM. et al., 2014 [49]
Cross-sectional/USA
All ages (0.5-50 y, both sexes)/62 subjects with mitochondrial disease (MitD)59 healthy subjects
Blood/none
To determine the redox status in mitochondrial diseases and if the redox imbalance is an indicator of clinical status
The GSH/GSSG ratio was lower in MitD patients, and redox potential was higher compared with controls.
GSH and GSSG levels may be biomarkers of mitochondrial dysfunction, and the evaluation of redox potential may be useful in monitoring of clinical status in MitD.
Schmitt B. et al., 2015 [50]
Randomized crossover trial/France
Adults (38-67 y, both sexes)/20 subjects with metabolic syndrome
Blood/reduced thiols, vit. E
To compare the effect on glutathione status of a sublingual form of GSH, compared with oral GSH and N-acetylcysteine (NAC)
A higher GSH/GSSG ratio was observed in sublingual GSH group compared with oral GSH and NAC groups.
The authors conclude about the effectivity of the treatments based in the GSH results.
Karimi R. et al., 2016 [51]
Cross-sectional/USA
Adults (48±28y, both sexes)/268 subjects
Blood/none
Seafood Hg exposure is related to a shift in redox status (low GSH/GSSG or high redox potential (Eh))
Blood Hg concentration was associated with changes in GSH/GSSG ratio and redox potential.
Hg exposure from seafood is linked to a shift in redox status toward OS.
Atkin M. et al., 2016 [52]
A double-blind, placebo-controlled crossover pilot/UK
Adults (18-70 y, both sexes)/26 subjects with T2DM
Blood/LOOH, TAS
Aged garlic extract (AGE) may improve OS in high-risk cardiovascular subjects with type 2 diabetes (T2DM)
No difference was found in GSH/GSSG ratio.
There is no clinical benefit of adding AGE, in the short term, to usual medical therapy in patients with T2DM.
Galicia-Moreno M. et al., 2016 [53]
Cross-sectional/Mexico
Adults (43±1y, both sexes)/57 subjects with ALC130 control subjects
Blood/MDA, PC
To evaluate the role of OS in alcoholic liver cirrhosis (ALC)
There were no differences in the GSH/GSSG ratio between groups.Active alcohol consumption had a tendency to produce glutathione oxidation.
ALC subjects have an increase in OS in the early stages of disease severity and abstinence from alcohol consumption favors GSH in patients with advanced disease severity.
Moreno-Solís G. et al., 2017 [54]
Observational/Spain
Infants (1-11 months, both sexes)/45 infants with RSV-AB27 healthy infants
Erythrocyte/MDA, 4-HNE, GPx
Association between OS and acute bronchiolitis caused by respiratory syncytial virus (RSV-AB) and its severity
The GSH/GSSG ratio was lower in RSV-AB infants and decrease if the infants need oxygen therapy.
The authors propose the use of GSSG and the GSH/GSSG ratio as biomarkers linked to the pathogenesis of RSV-AB.
Vacchi-Suzzi C. et al., 2018 [55]
Cross-sectional cohort/USA
Adults (≥18 y, both sexes)/282 healthy
Blood/none
Association between blood lead level (BLL) and glutathione (GSH) redox biomarkers
Increasing exposure to Pb was associated with lower levels of GSH/GSSG ratio and more positive GSH redox potential.
Blood Pb is associated with lower levels of GSH and the GSH/GSSG ratio.
β-carot.: β-carotene; CAT: catalase; CHD: coronary heart disease; dROMs: derivatives of reactive oxygen metabolites; DICA: damage index by Comet assay; F2-Iso: 15 F2α-isoprostanes; FORT: free oxygen radical test; FRAP: ferric reducing antioxidant potential; GPx: glutathione peroxidase; GR: glutathione reductase; GST: glutathione-S-transferase; 4-HNE: 4-hydroxyalkenal; hsCRP: high sensitivity C-reactive protein; 8-Iso: 8-isoprostanes; LOOH: lipid hydroperoxides; MDA: malondialdehyde; NOx: nitrite plus nitrate; O2−⋅: superoxide anion radical; OS: oxidative stress; ox-LDL: oxidized low-density lipoprotein; PC: protein carbonyls; ROS: reactive oxygen species; SOD: superoxide dismutase; TAC: total antioxidant capacity; TAS: total antioxidant status; TGSSG: total glutathione; vit. A: vitamin A; vit. C: vitamin C; vit. E: α-tocopherol.Table 4
Characteristics and findings of studies that used oxidized to reduced glutathione ratio (GSSG/GSH).
Author, year [reference]
Study design/country
Population (age, sex)/sample size
Biological sample/other markers
Main outcome
Results
Conclusion
Németh I. 1994 [31]
Prospective longitudinal/Hungary
Infants (gestational age 26-34 weeks, both sexes)/25 newborn premature infants with IRDS20 premature infants as control
Blood/none
GSSG/GSH in the blood could be an index of O2 toxicity in pathological status of premature newborns.
Premature infants with IRDS have GSSG/GSH ratio higher than control newborns. A negative correlation between the redox ratio and the arterio-alveolar oxygen ratio was found.
It is recommended the use of the blood GSSG/GSH ratio as a noninvasive measure ofin vivo OS.
Papp A. et al., 1999 [32]
Cross-sectional/Hungary
Infants who had been born prematurely (6 weeks-6 y, both sexes)/12 infants with active ROP38 patients with ROP56 control subjects
Erythrocyte/none
Glutathione status of erythrocytes in patients with retinopathy of prematurity (ROP)
Infants with active disease have the highest GSSG/GSH ratio.
The GSSG/GSH ratio may be a screen for active ROP in premature infants.
Annuk M. et al., 2001 [58]
Cross-sectional/Sweden
Adults (66±10y, both sexes)/37 subjects with CRF37 control subjects
Serum/CD, MDA, LOOH, TAA, LPF
Relationship between OS and endothelial function in chronic renal failure (CRF)
The GSSG/GSH ratio was lower in patients with CRF. Endothelium-dependent vasodilation was negatively correlatedGSSG/GSH.
The authors did not conclude directly about the ratio, but they assume that this ratio is a marker of OS.
Sáez GT. et al., 2004 [59]
Observational prospective of antihypertensive treatment/Spain
Adults (mean 46 y, both sexes)/36 subjects withβ-blockers33 subjects with telmisartan20 subjects without treatment
Blood, peripheral mononuclear cells/MDA
Impact of antihypertensive treatments on OSOS
After 3 months of antihypertensive treatment, the GSSG/GSH ratio was reduced; the beneficial effect of treatment increases over time.
The authors did not conclude directly about the ratio. Antihypertensive treatment improved the increased OS.
Skalicky J. et al., 2008 [60]
Cross-sectional/Czech Republic
Adults (51±9y, both sexes)/20 subjects obese with MetS20 subjects obese without MetS48 controls
Blood/TAS, vit. E, MDA, allantoin,α1-AP
OS in obesity with and without metabolic syndrome (MetS)
The obese patients with MetS have the highest GSSG/GSH ratio.
The authors did not conclude directly about the ratio, but they indicate that imbalance oxidative/antioxidative status is a risk in obese adults.
Lind L. et al., 2008 [61]
Prospective study/Sweden
Older adults (70 y, both sexes)/1016 subjects
Serum/CD, ox-LDL, TAC, homocysteine
Relationship between OS and brachial artery intima-media thickness (IMT) and grey scale median of the intima-media complex (IM-GSM)
The GSSG/GSH ratio was related to brachial artery IM-GSM after adjustment of traditional risk factors and inflammatory markers.
The low levels of the ratio indicate a reduced antioxidant activity.
Mercken EM. et al., 2009 [62]
Experimental/Netherlands
Adults (56±7y, both sexes)/15 COPD patients10 controls
Erythrocyte/MDA, uric acid
OS is differentially triggered by contracting peripheral muscles in COPD patients compared with controls
GSSG/GSH ratio tended to be increased in COPD patients and tended to be increased immediately after exercise.
The authors did not conclude directly about the ratio, although they discuss that the ratio slightly increased in COPD patients after exercise.
Real JT. et al., 2010 [63]
Cross-sectional/Spain
Adults (40±13y, both sexes)/30 patients with HF30 controls
Circulating mononuclear cells (CMC)/MDA, XO, SOD, CAT, GPx
Analyze the OS levels in CMC from familiar hypercholesterolemia (HF) patients and controls
GSSG/GSH ratio was significantly higher in FH patients compared with controls.
The authors did not conclude directly about the ratio, but they affirm that there is an important alteration of OS regulation in FH.
Rusanova I. et al., 2010 [64]
Cross-sectional/Panama
Children (6 months-15 y, both sexes)/95 patients with SCD40 healthy
Erythrocyte/MDA, 4-HNE, NOx, GPx, GR, SOD
To correlateβ-globin gene haplotypes with the OS in pediatric patients with sickle cell disease (SCD)
GSSG/GSH ratio was higher in patients with SCD.
Based on the ratio, the findings support the existence of oxidative damage in sickle cells.
Petrillo S. et al., 2013 [65]
Cross-sectional/Italy
All (4-64 y, does not specify sex)/14 patients with X-ALD30 healthy
LymphocyteErythrocyte/total thiols, PC, SOD, GPx
Define the role of the glutathione in X-linked adrenoleuko-dystrophy (X-ALD)
The GSSG/GSH ratio was increased in patients with adrenomyelo-neuropathy.
The balance among glutathione forms is a hallmark and a potential biomarker of the X-ALD.
De Tursi Ríspoli L. et al., 2013 [66]
Observational prospective of bariatric surgery/Spain
Adults (43±1y, both sexes)/28 patients with morbid obesity
Erythrocyte/MDA, 8-oxo-dG
Assessment of OS variations and its relationship with the weight loss after a duodenal crossing surgical
The GSSG/GSH ratio diminished across one year from 3 months after the surgery.
The authors did not conclude directly about the ratio, but they infer that weight loss improves antioxidant status.
Bagan J. et al., 2014 [56]
Observational/Spain
Adults (61±10y, sex is not specified)/24 patients treated with intravenous bisphosphonates (ivBPs) and BRONJ20 patients treated with ivBPs and without BRONJ17 controls
SerumSaliva/MDA, 8-oxo-dG
Changes of OS in patients with bisphosphonate-related osteonecrosis of the jaw (BRONJ)
The GSSG/GSH ratio was a prognostic factor for the development of BRONJ after adjusted by confounders.
The GSSG/GSH was a significant factor predicting the development of BRONJ.
Blasco H. et al., 2017 [67]
Preliminary study/France
Adults (65±14y, both sexes)/10 ALS patients 10 controls
Blood/MDA, 8-OHdG, TAS
Association of OS and amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS)
Higher GSSG/GSH ratio in ALS patients and correlations were found between the ratio and clinical markers.
The systemic alteration of the redox status in ALS patients was confirmed.
Arana C. et al., 2017 [57]
Observational/Spain
Adults (18-65 y, both sexes)/24 patients with T2DM and good metabolic control27 patients T2DM with poor metabolic control19 nondiabetic patients
Saliva/GPx, GR
Association between OS and periodontal disease in type 2 diabetes mellitus (T2DM) patients
Both diabetic groups showed higher GSSG/GSH quotients, being higher ratio in diabetic patients with poor metabolic control.
Poor metabolic control in T2DM patients is associated with higher levels of salivary OS.
Bellanti F. et al., 2018 [68]
Population-based cross-sectional study/Italy
Older adults (77±6y, both sexes)/48 sarcopenic67 nonsarcopenic
Blood/MDA, 4-HNE
Association between OS and sarcopenic obesity in terms of glutathione balance
Sarcopenic had GSSG/GSH ratio higher than nonsarcopenic patients. There is a strong association between the Framingham CVD risk and GSSG/GSH in the sarcopenic-obese patients.
Redox balance analysis would be a useful part of a multidimensional evaluation in aging.
α1-AP: α1-antiproteinase; CD: conjugate dienes; GPx: glutathione peroxidase; GR: glutathione reductase; 4-HNE: 4-hydroxyalkenal; 8-OHdG: 8-hydroxy-2′-deoxyguanosine; LOOH: lipid hydroperoxides; LPF: oxidation resistance of lipoprotein fraction; MDA: malondialdehyde; NOx: nitrite plus nitrate; 8-oxo-dG: 8-oxo-deoxiguanosina; OS: oxidative stress; ox-LDL: oxidized low-density lipoprotein; PC: protein carbonyls; SOD: superoxide dismutase; TAA: total antioxidant activity; TAC: total antioxidant capacity; TAS: total antioxidant status; vit. E: α-tocopherol; XO: xanthine oxidase.The redox potential (Eh) is a complement of the GSH/GSSG ratio to evaluate the redox status [30, 34, 37, 43, 49, 51, 55], but it can be used as an independent measurement since it provides indirect information about the redox state of all cell types, although the measurement has been performed only in erythrocytes, because the cells have similar essential functions [69].Nevertheless, the glutathione ratio seems to be a promise OS marker, it is limited because it only measures intracellular environment without considering other OS components as antioxidant enzymes and oxidized biomolecules.


## 3.3. Thiol Ratios

The thiols are compounds with high vulnerability to the oxidation by reactive species, mainly of oxygen, due to their -SH group, which is oxidized to their disulfide (-SS-). As this is an oxidation reaction, the imbalance between both forms in favor of the oxidized molecule is considered as OS, being a dynamic homeostasis involved in many diseases and alterations of the physiological state [70, 71]. Many proteins, nonproteins, and low molecular mass thiols have -SH group, but only cysteine and glutathione are considerate in the redox balance, where cysteine represents the extracellular environment and glutathione the intracellular. Then, the term “thiol ratio” is used to refer the measurement of these aminothiols together, both in its oxidized and reduced forms. There are some techniques to their measurement, less complex and automated what has facilitated its use in different investigations.After the proposal of an automated procedure to evaluate native thiol (-SH), total thiol (TT), and thiol-disulfide (-SS) [70], -SH/TT, -SS/-SH, and -SS/TT ratios have been calculated; where if the value of -SH/TT ratio is low and both ratios of -SS are high, the OS is present. Also, it is possible to present the result as a percentage, multiplying the total obtained by 100.Its use has spread widely to become the second most popular indicator of OS so far. In this review, we found sixty-six studies that refer them. All the studies, except one [72], were carried out in Turkey in a variety of age groups and clinical situations since 2015. The thiols can be measured in serum/plasma, but semen sample [72] and aqueous humor [73] also have been used, and they are applicable to evaluate the oxidative state in a variety of clinical events, from alterations during pregnancy, cardiovascular, psychiatric, neurological, hereditary, infectious diseases, etc. Although the information is abundant, the analysis result has not shown substantial differences among the studies, because all agree in recommending the thiol ratios to their use in clinical events; therefore, we only did a descriptive analysis of the information (Table 5) and presented references found in a supplementary file in case of any reader is interested in consulting the information.Table 5
Studies that have used the thiol ratios to measure the oxidative stress by age group and clinical event studied.
Age group
Clinical event
Number or studies
Adults (18-65 y)
Alterations in the pregnancy
8
Cardiovascular diseases
4
Respiratory diseases
4
Skin disorders
4
Psychiatric disorders
3
Metabolic disorders
3
Surgery
2
Neurologic disorders
2
Other disorders
10
Older adults (>65 y)
Ocular disorders
3
Different events
4
Children (<18 y)
Neurologic disorders
4
Genetic disorders
3
Different events
8
Adults-older adults (>18 y)
Different events
3
Children-adults (<65 y)
Neurologic disorder
1
Total
66It is important to note that, contrary to glutathione ratio, the thiol ratios generally do not need other markers to interpret the OS, although antioxidant enzymes, FRAP, TAC, total oxidant capacity (TOC), and ischemia-modified albumin (IMA), have been some of the other markers included to complement the interpretation.The thiol ratios are the OS markers used more recently, but like the glutathione ratio, to make a complete interpretation of the OS, it is necessary to include antioxidant enzymes and oxidized biomolecules.


## 3.4. Oxidative Stress Index (OSI)

All the previous proposals are recognizing that OS is a dynamic process, because they consider both the oxidizing and antioxidant components in a single calculation; however, only one type of oxidant and antioxidant is related, which is a disadvantage because it is necessary to evaluate many components to establish more effective if the OS is present. Hence, other proposals have emerged that consider the measurement of oxidant and antioxidant activity whose effect is produced by the action of several components of OS measured as one.Those are based in fact that the measurement of different oxidants and antioxidant molecules separately is not practical because they are costly and time-consuming, and frequently, the procedures are complex; moreover, their oxidant or antioxidant effects are additive [74, 75]; therefore, it is possible to measure the total oxidant or antioxidant capacities of a biological sample and related them in a ratio, called index.The antioxidant capacity is measured by different procedures identified by their acronyms:(i)
Ferric reducing antioxidant potential (FRAP) or total antioxidant potential (TAOP): measurement of the ability of the sample to reduce Fe3+ to Fe2+ as a result of antioxidant activity. The formation of a complex between Fe2+ and 2,4,6-tripyridyl-1,3,5-triazine (TPTZ) is measured [20, 76]
(ii)
Oxygen radical absorbance capacity (ORAC): inhibition measurement of the peroxyl radical-induced oxidation initiated by thermal decomposition of 2,20-azobis(2-amidinopropane) dihydrochloride (AAPH) [24]
(iii)
Total antioxidant activity (TAA): it is the assessment of the ability of a sample to inhibit linolenic acid peroxidation. The results are expressed as percentage of inhibition of linolenic acid peroxidation produced by samples [58]
(iv)
Total antioxidant capacity (TAC): the method is based on the hydroxyl radical (OH⋅) produced via the Fenton reaction using a mixing ferrous ion solution and H2O2. The OH⋅ generated reacts with o-dianisidine molecule to form dianisidyl radicals [75]
(v)
Total antioxidant status (TAS): the method is based on the production of the radical cation (ABTS⋅+) by the incubation of ABTS (2,20-azino-bis[3-ethylbenzothiazoline-6-sulphonic acid]) with peroxidase (metmyoglobin) and H2O2 [17]
(vi)
Total radical-trapping antioxidant parameter (TRAP): measurement of hydrosoluble and/or liposoluble plasma antioxidants using chemiluminescence inhibition time induced by 2,2-azobis(2-amidinopropane) [21]Except in TAA, the results in all the quoted methods are expressed as Trolox equivalents (μmol/L), which is the antioxidant standard.Likewise, the measurement of the oxidant capacity can be carried out by different methods:(i)
Total oxidative capacity (TOC): assay based on the oxidation of 3,5,3′,5′-tetramethylbenzidine (TMB) to colored radical cations in the presence of peroxides by peroxidase. It used to determine total peroxides in μmol/L [77, 78]
(ii)
Total oxidant status (TOS): it is the measurement of the oxidation of Fe2+ to Fe3+ by peroxides of the sample to produce a Fe3+-xylenol orange complex. This assay quantifies total peroxides; the results are expressed as H2O2μmol Eq/L [75]Some indexes are in the literature, but the most used is called “oxidative stress index” (OSI) initially proposed in 2003 [18]. This index has had few modifications across the time, but all the studies agree in that it is a ratio between TOS and TAS expressed in arbitrary units:
(2)OSIAU=TOSTAS,where OSI is in arbitrary units (AU), TOS is in μmol H2O2 Eq/L, and TAS is in μmol Trolox Eq/L. Sometimes, the result is multiplied by 100 to represent the percentage ratio.TAC or TAOP can also be used as antioxidant component because being in the same units (μmol Trolox Eq/L), and TOS may be replaced by TOC.As we pointed above, OSI is the index most frequently reported in the literature. In this review, we found 302 studies in humans since 2003 that use this index, the majority carried out in Turkey, mainly in adult events such as cardiovascular diseases, alterations in the pregnancy, and psychiatric disorders. As the thiol ratio information, after analyzing the studies, we observe that most research recommends the use of OSI without other important contributions to this review; thus, we present only a descriptive analysis and the references in the supplementary file. However, we want to note that the measurement of oxidant and antioxidant activities for the calculation of the index has been carried out on biological samples other than blood, such as semen [79–81], urine [82, 83], cerebrospinal fluid [84], amniotic fluid [85], vaginal washing fluid [86], and gingival crevicular fluid [87–89], in addition to the saliva [90–95] and aqueous humor [96, 97] that have also been used in the measurement of thiols (Table 6).Table 6
Studies that use the oxidative stress index (OSI) as a marker of oxidative stress separated by country, age group, and clinical event.
Country
Frequency (%)
Age group
Frequency (%)
Clinical event
Frequency (%)
Turkey
257 (85.1%)
Adults (18–65 y)
190 (63.0%)
Cardiovascular diseases
38 (12.6%)
Poland
13 (4.3%)
Adults-older adults (>18 y)
40 (13.2%)
Alterations in the pregnancy
32 (10.6%)
China
11 (3.7%)
Children (2–12 y)
35 (11.6%)
Psychiatric disorders
27 (9.0%)
India
4 (1.3%)
Neonates/infants (<2 y)
19 (6.3%)
Infectious diseases
17 (5.6%)
Estonia
3 (1.0%)
Older adults (>65 y)
8 (2.6%)
Cancer
15 (5.0%)
Thailand
3 (1.0%)
Adolescents (12–17 y)
5 (1.6%)
Skin disorders
15 (5.0%)
Ethiopia
2 (0.7%)
Children-adolescent (<18 y)
2 (0.7%)
Oral diseases
15 (5.0%)
Egypt
2 (0.7%)
Children to adults (<65 y)
2 (0.7%)
Respiratory diseases
14 (4.6%)
Romania
1 (0.3%)
All age groups
1 (0.3%)
Metabolic disorders
12 (4.0%)
Mexico
1 (0.3%)
Total
302
Other disorders
117 (38.6%)
Austria
1 (0.3%)
Total
302
Korea
1 (0.3%)
Iran
1 (0.3%)
Nigeria
1 (0.3%)
Serbia
1 (0.3%)
Total
302Like the other calculations, OSI also has been accompanied of several OS markers such as MDA, DNA damage, hydroperoxides, protein carbonyls, IMA, thiols, antioxidant enzymes, prolidase, paraoxonase, and antioxidant vitamins, many times in order to show the relationship between the different markers and prove their usefulness as an independent indicator of OS. All this information makes this index a very promising way to measure the OS; however, there are still doubts regarding its interpretation. Actually, for its interpretation, the increase in the value of the index indicates a greater intensity of OS, but it has not been clearly established which is the cut-off value for the OS, necessary value to better clinical application, because in clinical practice, it is important to be able to differentiate oxidative eustress and oxidative distress, as we have pointed early in this review.


## 3.5. Oxidative INDEX

This is a proposal of Vassalle et al. (2008) that also related the serum oxidative/antioxidative capacities; only that for this index, the oxidative part is the measurement of total hydroperoxides by dROMs and to the serum antioxidant activity has used a procedure called OXY Adsorbent Test [98]; both methods are automated and commercial.The dROMs or derivatives of Reactive Oxygen Metabolites, also called diacron ROM, are based on the measurement of sample alkoxyl (RO⋅) and peroxyl (ROO⋅) radicals (sample peroxides) formed by iron, according to Fenton’s reaction. These radicals are able to oxidize an alkyl-substituted aromatic amine (A-NH2), such as N,N-diethyl-para-phenylenediamine (DEPPD), transforming it into a derivative ([A-NH2⋅]+). With some modifications in the procedure, this method also is called as free oxygen radical test (FORT), which reflects levels of organic hydroperoxides. Results are expressed in arbitrary units, called Carratelli units (Carr U), where one Carr U corresponds to 0.08 mg/dL H2O2. Values greater than 300 Carr U suggest OS [99–101].The OXY Adsorbent Test evaluates the antioxidant ability of each sample to oppose the oxidant action of hypochlorous acid (HClO) added in excess. The results are expressed asμmol HClO/mL, and low values indicate a reduced antioxidant capacity [102].Two aspects that we should highlight about this index is that it has only been used in serum as a biological sample and its calculation method, which makes its daily use difficult.In this sense, due to dROMs and OXY are in different measurement units, it is necessary to have a standardization according to the following formula [101, 102]:
(3)svvar=vvar−x¯varsvar,where svvar is the standard value of each measurement which is equivalent to z, vvar is the original value of each subject, x¯var is the mean of the parameter, and svar is the standard deviation of the parameter.After this calculation, a simple subtraction between standardized dROM and standardized OXY must be calculated:(4)OxidativeINDEX=svROM−svOXY.This index has proven its usefulness in comparisons between young vs. old people [103], men vs. women [104], and in several clinical settings, such as cardiovascular diseases [98, 106, 107], oral diseases [105, 111], neurological disorders [108], hepatic diseases [109, 112], and cancer [110], showing that it has the capacity to discriminate between the groups (Table 7). It is important to note that since this index evaluates the oxidative balance, no other OS marker was included in any study.Table 7
Characteristics and findings of studies that used Oxidative INDEX (ROM/OXY ratio).
Author, year [ref]
Study design/country
Population (age, sex)/sample size
Main outcome
Results
Conclusion
Vassalle C et al., 2008 [98]
Cross-sectional/Italy
Adults (65±10y, both sexes)/100 CAD patients 70 controls
Relationship between Oxidative INDEX and cardiovascular risk factors in coronary artery disease (CAD).
The Oxidative INDEX was higher in CAD patients, correlated with aging and increased with the number of cardiovascular risk factors.
Oxidative INDEX could represent a valuable tool in clinical setting.
Vassalle C et al., 2009 [103]
Cross-sectional/Italy
Adults (16-79 y, both sexes)/179 subjects
Obesity and smoking may accelerate the increase of the OS related to advancing age.
Obesity and smoking are risk factors for elevated Oxidative INDEX. The index steadily rises at a mean rate of 5.3% (0.017 AU) per year in the overall population.
The authors did not conclude directly about the index, but they infer that OS increases due the risk factors analyzed.
Vassalle C et al., 2011 [104]
Cross-sectional/Italy
Adults (48±12y, both sexes)/116 males216 females
Gender-related difference of OS
Age, high blood pressure, and smoking habit as factors associated with the index in men. Cigarette smoking and age are risk factors for an elevated OS in women.
The authors did not conclude directly about the index, but they infer that there is a difference in OS due to sex.
Tamaki N. et al., 2011 [105]
Observational longitudinal/Japan
Adults (44±19y, both sexes)/22 with CP22 controls
To monitor OS in subjects with chronic periodontitis (CP) following nonsurgical periodontal treatment
Patients with CP have higher OS than healthy subjects. Periodontal treatment was associated with a reduction in the index.
Nonsurgical periodontal treatment was effective in decreasing the index.
Vassalle C et al., 2012 [106]
ObservationalLongitudinalRetrospective/Italy
Adults (67±11y, both sexes/97 CAD patients
Prognostic of OS on the rate of major adverse cardiovascular events (MACE) in CAD patients
High level of the index is an independent predictor of MACE.
OS (calculated by the index) may be a useful tool to predict MACE in CAD patients.
Vassalle C et al., 2012 [107]
Case-control/Italy
Adults (66±9y, both sexes)/55 post-women108 men72 CAD patients
To assess oxidative stress status in coronary artery disease (CAD) patients according to gender
There is a difference in the index between men and women without CAD. Women with CAD had the index higher than men.
The index can be a predictor of CAD in women.
Capaccio P et al., 2012 [108]
Cross-sectional/Italy
Adults (47±14y, both sexes)/39 ISSNHL patients70 healthy subjects
To evaluate role of OS in idiopathic sudden sensorineural hearing loss (ISSNHL)
The index was higher in patients than in controls.
In ISSNH, there is an imbalanced oxidative status.
Terao M et al., 2014 [109]
Cross-sectional/Japan
Adults (46-61 y, both sexes)/29 with potential POPH32 with potential non-POPH
Association between the OS and portopulmonary hypertension (POPH) in cirrhotic patients
Potential POPH patients have higher oxidative index values.
The oxidative/antioxidative balance was exacerbated in patients with potential POPH.
Uchida D et al., 2016 [110]
Translational/Japan
Adults (27-90 y, both sexes)/84 CC patients80 PC patients
OS balance in pancreatic cancer (PC) and cholangiocarcinoma (CC) patients
The index was higher in CC patients with poor outcomes and not different in PC patients.
OS balance was dysregulated in CC patients with poor outcome.
Mizuno H et al., 2017 [111]
Randomized clinical trial/Japan
Adults (61±10y, both sexes)/T2DM and CP patients.20 periodontal treatment17 control group
Effect of nonsurgical periodontal treatment on OS balance patients with type 2 diabetes mellitus (T2DM) compared to no periodontal treatment
Systemic OS balance improved in the periodontal treatment group compared to the control group at 3 months.
In T2DM patients, nonsurgical periodontal treatment improved systemic OS.
Shimomura Y et al., 2017 [112]
ObservationalLongitudinal/Japan
Adults (>40 y, both sexes)/14 patients with NAFL44 patients with NASH11 patients with NASH-related HCC15 healthy
Correlation between OS-related markers and the clinical characteristic in nonalcoholic fatty liver disease (NAFL) and to characterize the OS balance in NAFL, nonalcoholic steatohepatitis (NASH), and NASH-related hepatocellular carcinoma (NASH-HCC)
The index positively correlated with BMI and HbA1c.The index was not significantly different among the patient groups.
The authors did not conclude directly about the index, only of these components.In the interpretation, being a standardized value, there can be negative and positive values in a range of - 3 to +3, with 0 being the ideal balance between oxidants and antioxidants; therefore, positive values indicate predominant oxidized damage and negative values an imbalance towards antioxidants. Moreover, it has been shown that if the 75th percentile of the data is calculated, a cut-off value can be obtained to establish the intensity of the OS, at least by deciding whether it is low or high [102, 106], although further studies need be carried out to confirm their usefulness as a diagnostic tool [108].Another index with total hydroperoxides measured by dROMs method has been described. For this index, the measurement of the biological antioxidant potential (BAP) is used as the antioxidant component.In the BAP method, the ability of plasma antioxidant components to give reducing equivalents to reactive species is determinate using Fe3+ that are reduced to Fe2+. The values are expressed in terms of iron-reducing activity by vitamin C as standard, considering as cut-off values: >2200 μmol/L as optimum status, <1600 μmol/L as deficient status, and <1400 μmol/L as high deficiency status [99, 113].An arbitrary index is calculated as a ratio. This index has been used in two directions(i)
Oxidant to antioxidant (dROMs/BAP) ratio, if it considers that the balance is disrupted by excessive production of dROMs or by low BAP
(ii)
Antioxidant to oxidant (BAP/dROMs) ratio, when it wants to measure the relative antioxidant capacityIn addition, two modifications to the BAP/dROMs ratio have emerged. First a proposal of Yamamoto et al. (2015) called mOA that is an adjustment of the ratio by the constant 7.541 [114]:
(5)mOA=BAP/dROMs7.451.In the other modifications, each BAP/dROMs value is divided by mean BAP/dROMs ratio; in its interpretation, a cut-off value <1.0 indicates an antioxidant potential decreased [115]. This is the only study that establishes a cut-off value; others use the ratios as quantitative values. Both indexes aim to show more clearly the antioxidant potential.These indexes have been used in research mainly in Japan; seven studies calculated the ratio in the oxidant direction to the antioxidant [99, 116–121], and six in the reverse direction [113, 122–124], including the investigations that calculated the modified ratios [106, 107] (Table 8). Only in one report the follicular fluid was used as a biological sample [116]; in the others, serum or plasma was used, and neither markers of the OS were included in the studies.Table 8
Characteristics and findings of studies that used ROM/BAP or BAP/ROM ratios.
Author, year [ref]
Study design/country
Population (age, sex)/sample size
Main outcome
Results
Conclusion
Kakita H et al., 2009 [116]
Case-control study/Japan
Preterm infants(31 weeks gestational age, both sexes)/22 infants with PVL22 healthy
Association between OS and neonatal cystic periventricular leukomalacia (PVL)
ROM/BAP was higher in early cystic PVL than in late cystic PVL or controls.Postnatal duration until cyst identification displayed a negative correlation with ROM/BAP
Neonates experiencing more OS at birth show earlier onset of cystic PVL
Hussein MH et al., 2011 [99]
ObservationalLongitudinal/Japan
Children (1.2-14.4 y, both sexes)/43 patients
Relationship between OS and post-liver transplantation duration
ROM/BAP correlated positively with hepatic enzymes and negatively with post-liver transplantation duration.
The ROM/BAP can serve as an index of patients’ laboratory results and oxidative status.
Chung DH et al., 2012 [117]
Intervention study/Korea
Adults (17-68 y, both sexes)/20 AR patients 20 NAR patients
To evaluate the susceptibility of patients with allergic rhinitis (AR) to OS compared with nonallergic rhinitis (NAR) patients
The ROM/BAP ratio was higher after surgery (nasal septoplasty) in the AR group than in the NAR group.
AR patients might be vulnerable to OS, due to their ROM/BAP imbalance.
Kaneko K et al., 2012 [118]
Intervention study/Japan
Children (0.14-5.38 y, both sexes)/19 patients with KD7 patients with febrile illnesses(FI)
Association between OS and Kawasaki disease (KD) and if intravenous immunoglobulin therapy (IVIG) is a scavenger of ROS
Children with KD had low value of the ROM/BAP ratio after IVIG.
Seems that OS has a role in the pathogenesis of acute KD.
Kakita H et al., 2012 [119]
Retrospective case-control study/Japan
Newborns (37-41 wk gestational age, both sexes)/6 hypothermia16 normothermia15 control group
To evaluate OS in asphyxiated infants and to determinate if hypothermia treatment has an effect on OS
The ROM/BAP ratio values gradually increased after birth in hypothermia and normothermia cases. After 7 days, the ratio was higher in normothermia cases.
Hypothermia attenuated the OS in asphyxiated newborns.
Hussein MH et al., 2013 [120]
ObservationalLongitudinal/Japan
Children (2-15 y, both sexes)/16 IMD patients10 BA patients
Assess the differences in OS between pediatric patients undergoing living-related liver transplantation due to inherited metabolic disease (IMD) or biliary atresia (BA)
The ROM/BAP ratio was higher in the IMD group.
Patients who receive living-related liver transplantation due to IMD are prone to higher ROM/BAP ratio.
Fukuda S et al., 2016 [121]
Experimental study/Japan
Adults (37±9y and 20±0.5y, both sexes)/12 females in acute stress condition24 subjects in subacute fatigue condition121 at-rest condition
Use dROMs and BAP to discriminate patients with chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS) from healthy volunteers experiencing acute and subacute fatigue, and at rest
The ROM/BAP ratio was higher after subacute fatigue. Resting condition produced higher ratio in patients with CFS than in healthy volunteers.
The markers might be useful for discriminate acute, subacute, and resting fatigue in healthy people and CFS patients.
Faienza MF et al., 2012 [113]
Cross-sectional/Italy
Children (11±3y, both sexes)/25 obese withMetS30 obese30 controls
Alterations in the oxidant/antioxidant status in obese children with and without metabolic syndrome (MetS)
Children without MetS had lower BAP/dROMs ratio than children with MetS. The ratio BAP/dROMs was higher in controls than no-MetS and MetS children.
The authors did not conclude directly about the index, but they infer that fat accumulation is involved in the pathogenesis of systemic OS.
Fukui T et al., 2015 [122]
Intervention study/Japan
Adults (58±11y, both sexes)/Patients with hyperuricemia29 patients treated with febuxostat14 patients treated with allopurinol
Effect of febuxostat compared with allopurinol on OS measured by BAP/dROMs ratio
No significant changes were observed in the BAP/dROMs ratio.
A regulatory mechanism may be counteracted changes in the OS balance caused by febuxostat administration.
Yamamoto K et al., 2015 [114]
Experimental pilot study/Japan
Adults (17-57 y, both sexes)/42 patients with active CD in treatment with anti-TNF-α antibodies
Effect of antitumor necrosis factor (TNF)-α treatment on OS in Crohn’s disease (CD) patients.It used a modified BAP/dROMs ratio (m-BAP/dROMs ratio).
Negative correlation between m-BAP/dROMs ratio and CD activity index before and after treatment. The ratio did not differ between the patients before treatment.
Anti-TNF-α therapy decreases OS in patients with CD but does not modify the antioxidant production.
Hatanaka H et al., 2015 [123]
Cross-sectional/Japan
Older adults (81±7y, both sexes)/72 AD patients 27 with VaD24 with MD53 nondemented patients
OS differs in the pathophysiology and cognitive decline of Alzheimer’s disease (AD), vascular dementia (VaD), and mixed Alzheimer’s/vascular dementia (MD).
BAP/dROM ratios were lower in the AD and MD groups than control. The minimental state scores correlated with the ratio in the AD patients.
An imbalance in oxidant/antioxidant defenses may be involved in the pathophysiology of the AD and MD.
Nakagawa K et al., 2016 [115]
Cross-sectional/Japan
Adults (37±3y, women)/26 patients with unilateral EM29 without EM
To evaluate OS in the environment of the follicular fluid (FF) of patients with endometrioma (EM)
The patients with a m-BAP/dROMratio<1.0 in the EM group was similar to the control group.
The oxidative/antioxidant potential in the FF of EM patients is similar to the controls.
Pesce M et al., 2018 [124]
Experimental study/Italy
Older adults (60-80 y, both sexes)/29 subjects in EG23 in control group
Effect of memory training (MT) on plasma oxidant and antioxidant capacity
BAP/d-ROMs ratio improved in experimental group (EG). BAP/d-ROMs ratio was positively correlated with the measurement of memory.
MT was associated with the increase in resistance against OS at the plasma level.
ROS: reactive oxygen species.Also, it draws attention that some researchers call the dROMs/BAP ratio “oxidative stress index” (OSI) [99, 116, 119–121] as the first index that we included in this review, which is logical because this index is an oxidant/antioxidant ratio; the difference is the form of evaluation of both components. In both OSI, the oxidative part is the measurement of total peroxides or hydroperoxides, which are the oxidation products of several molecules, such as lipids, proteins, and amino acids; therefore, this is a measure of oxidative damage, what does not happen with the antioxidant capacity. The TAC and BAP have different principles, as well as their measurement units; both determinate the total nonenzymatic antioxidant capacity of biological samples, but although BAP is the most recommended procedures [125], the results of the different studies shown that this parameter almost does not change, making the index show no difference [114, 115, 122], especially when it is used to see the antioxidant potential (BAP/dROMs).In summary, seems that the Oxidative INDEX can reflex the intensity of the OS better than the dROMs/BAP ratios, but these indexes do not include antioxidant enzymes, important elements in oxidative/antioxidative balance.


## 3.6. Oxidative Stress Profile

As we explained above, all the ratios and indexes proposal only measure extracellular OS components or oxidative/antioxidative capacities of the biological samples, so missing other elements that also participate in the oxidative balance.Thus, in another attempt to measure oxidative/antioxidant balance, Cutler et al. in 2005 [126, 127] proposed the so-called “oxidative stress profile,” where it considers a lot of markers of oxidative damage, such as MDA, 4-HNE, hydroperoxides, isoprostanes, oxidized nucleic acids, protein carbonyls, antioxidants (endogenous and exogenous), and plus inflammation markers, such as interleukins, measured in both blood and urine samples. In total, these were suggested more than 50 elements in a proposal to assess the oxidative/antioxidative balance [127].In the interpretation of the results, cut-off values are established for optimum health and intervals outside the reference ones, making a balance between the oxidized components through an oxidation index and an antioxidant index, obtaining an average level of antioxidant protection and other oxidative damages summarized in four categories: (1) high protection-high damage, (2) high protection-low damage, (3) low protection-low damage, and (4) low protection-high damage [126, 127]. The limitations of this proposal are the high cost due to the large number of parameters to be measured; many of which require a measurement with sophisticated equipment and techniques and also the need to establish the cut-off values to calculate the indexes, mainly of the exogenous antioxidant markers, which are dependent on the diet and lifestyle, so they cannot be generalized in the populations, and finally, the complexity in interpreting the results.


## 3.7. OXY Score

Follow-up with the same objective of creating an index to measure the OS, Veglia et al. in 2006 proposed the so-called OXY score, an index derived from the computation of different parameters of the oxidative balance. This score includes individual measurements in plasma of free and total MDA (F-MDA, T-MDA) and the GSSG and GSH levels and moreover the urinary isoprostane-PF2α-III level (iPF2α) as the combined oxidative damage. The antioxidant counterpart includes GSH, α- and γ-tocopherol, and antioxidant capacity measured by the OXY Adsorbent Test, which the authors called individual antioxidant capacity [128].For calculation, first the F-MDA, T-MDA, iPF2α, and GSSG levels are log-transformed, then each marker must be standardized according to the formula previously describe, using the raw or log-transformed value as correspond. Later, the average of the standardized oxidants (damage score) and the average of the standardized antioxidants (protection score) must be calculated. Finally, the subtraction of a damage score minus protection score is the OXY score.Same as for Oxidative INDEX, if the result is near to zero, the levels of all markers are near the average normal values or there is a balance between oxidants and antioxidants, and positive values indicate an imbalance towards the oxidants [128, 129]. It has been suggested to compute the OXY score without the urinary iPF2α as a modified OXY score, with similar results [130].Although the ability of the OXY score to discriminate between different clinical conditions, age, and sex has been reported [127, 128], it is necessary to recognize that antioxidant enzymes are not included, being a score limiting [130]. Some drawbacks of the OXY score are the difficulty in calculating it, and the methods of measurement of all the markers are included, because they are complex and expensive; thus, it is not easily applicable to clinical and epidemiological settings.Another modification to the OXY score is reported, which is a global score for the OS associated with albuminuria to their use in chronic kidney disease patients (Albumin OXY score). This index included protein carbonyl and MDA to calculate the damage score, and superoxide (O2−⋅) scavenging activity, catalase (CAT), and TAC as the protection index. For the calculating, the authors followed the procedures indicated for the Oxidative INDEX and the OXY score and proposed a new calculation that includes logarithmic transformation, standardization, and final subtraction, integrating both proposals. Being standardized values, the interpretation is equal to the two indexes previously mentioned [131]. The main clinical disadvantages of this index are the complication in the calculation, the cost, and the complexity of some measurements, although the total number of markers to be measured was reduced.


## 3.8. Oxidative Stress Score

All the indexes mentioned until now, except that proposed by Cutler and the Albumin OXY score, include an oxidant part and the non-enzymatic antioxidant capacity and do not take into account the antioxidant enzymes as part of the calculation. Thus, it seems necessary to include at least the main enzymes in the cell antioxidant process: superoxide dismutase (SOD), glutathione peroxidase (GPx), and/or catalase (CAT).In this sense, Amstad et al. in 1991 [132] showed in transformed cell lines of mice that the balance between the activities of SOD and CAT+GPx is more important to determine the oxidative effect than the absolute activity of a single enzyme. Following this proposal, it has developed a theoretical model of biochemical interaction between these three enzymes showing an additive effect between SOD and GPx, and synergistic effects between GPx and CAT to ensure a global cell protection [133, 134]. As we know, the oxygen in aerobic organisms is part of various biochemical reactions, such as the mitochondrial respiratory chain and phagocytosis. One characteristic of these biochemical processes is the transformation of molecular oxygen into O2−⋅, which is dismuted by SOD, forming H2O2 in a first step. Although it is currently recognized that H2O2 is an important molecule in redox regulation and signaling processes, it is also known that it is a molecule harmful for its oxidizing capacity; thus, living organisms have a series of enzymes H2O2-removing to maintain balance, being glutathione peroxidases as the main second step [8, 135]. An imbalance between the first and second steps has as the potential result of increasing H2O2 levels, which is possible because the reaction constant of SOD is higher than GPx, so H2O2 is formed quickly and is not eliminated in its entirety; in addition, this disproportion in the activity between SOD and GPx in favor of the first can produce an increase in lipoperoxidation [136]; therefore, the inclusion of these enzymes as part of an integral OS measurement is important.Another point to consider in the assessment of OS is to establish which cut-off values of the oxidative/antioxidative imbalance can be considered as harmful, to refer only to the oxidative distress. In this sense, in 2004, we proposed the integral and dynamic measurement of the OS through the evaluation of the antioxidant system efficiency, establishing the categories: (a) efficient antioxidant system (EAS) when the harmful action of the oxidants is effectively counteracted, (b) antioxidant enzymatic deficiency (ANED) if there is an inefficient or insufficient action of antioxidant enzymes, (c) exogenous antioxidants deficiency (EXAD) when there is an insufficient or inefficient action of non-enzymatic antioxidants causing oxidized the molecules, and (d) antioxidant system global deficiency (ASGD) if the enzymatic and nonenzymatic antioxidant components show an imbalance in favor of oxidized molecules [137, 138]. Later, we reorganized the interpretation considering the intensity of the OS, proposing four categories: without OS (WOS), low OS (LOS), moderate OS (MOS), and severe OS (SOS). About this, Lushchak in 2014 [139] also expressed the need to classify the OS based on the intensity, suggesting three levels: low, intermediate, and high, where the high can be interpreted as severe OS, very similar to our proposal.In order to reach our classification, an index was calculated which we call the oxidative stress score (SS) [140]. The SS includes, originally, the measurement of plasma MDA and DNA damage, the activities of the SOD and GPx erythrocyte enzymes, the total antioxidant plasma status (TAS), and the calculation of the SOD/GPx ratio as a marker of oxidation, and the antioxidant gap (GAP). In this sense, GAP represents the antioxidant capacity of other nonmeasured plasma components different to albumin and uric acid, such as antioxidant vitamins, bilirubin, and hormones, can be calculated from TAS, and albumin and uric acid levels multiplied by their value of Trolox equivalent antioxidant capacity (TEAC) using the formula [10]:
(6)GAP=TAS−albumin×TEAC+uricacid×TEAC,where TAS, albumin, and uric acid are in μmol/L, TEAC for albumin is 0.69, and TEAC for uric acid is 1.00.Low-molecular-weight antioxidants such as GSH and thiols are not included in the score because both are measured in TAS, and CAT neither is considered due to its role as H2O2 removal is relative in humans, because it is a peroxisomal enzyme [8].It was defined the cut-off values of each parameter based on the 90th percentile of healthy young subjects (20-45 y and both sexes), and a score 1 was given to each value above of cut-off (MDA, DNA damage, and SOD/GPx ratio) or under the cut-off (enzymatic and non-enzymatic markers), and 0 if the values are in normal range. After, a sum of all the components was obtained as a SS ranging from 0 to 7, representing the severity of the marker modifications. Then, the SS was categorized as follows [140]:
(i)
WOS ifSS=0‐1
(ii)
LOS ifSS=2‐3
(iii)
MOS ifSS=4‐5
(iv)
SOS ifSS=6‐7Also, we have excluded DNA damage because their procedure is not easily accessible; in this case, SS is ranging from 0 to 6 [141]. This index can be dichotomous, if SS≤3, we consider as without OS or eustress, and if SS>3, the subjects have high OS or distress [142].The SS has been used in several studies since 2005. It has probed in young, mid-aged, and older subjects, both sexes and different study designs (Table9). This index has shown to be useful to differentiate rural/urban residents [140] and pre/postmenopausal women [141, 146]. Also, it has been applied in cognitive impairment [138], chronic-degenerative diseases such as diabetes mellitus and arterial hypertension [142, 145], osteoporosis [143], and metabolic syndrome [144]. In addition, it has been used in clinical experimental studies demonstrating therapeutic [148] and of nutritional supplements effects [141, 151], as well as the efficiency of controlled physical exercise [147, 150].Table 9
Characteristics and findings of studies that use the oxidative stress score (SS)∗ in Mexicans.
Author, year [ref]
Study design
Population (age, sex)/sample size
Main outcome
Results
Conclusion
Sánchez-Rodríguez MA. et al. 2005 [141]
Clinical trial
Older adults(67±7y, both sexes)/63 subjects with exercise and antioxidant diet63 subjects with vitamins E 400 UI–C 500 mg/d63 subjects with vitamins E 400 UI–C 1000 mg/d80 controls
Effect of moderate physical exercise and antioxidant diet in comparison to oral vitamins C and E vs. severe OS
All groups with treatment after 1y had SS lower compared with pretest.Only 6 elderlies in the vitamin groups have severe OS after 1 y.
Moderate physical exercise and antioxidant diet have similar effect against severe OS than antioxidant vitamins in healthy elderlies.
Sánchez-Rodríguez MA. et al., 2006 [140]
Cross-sectional
Older adults(68±7y, both sexes)/121 subjects from Mexico City85 subjects from a rural residence
To compare different OS marker vs. an integral score that considers oxidized biomolecules and the antioxidant (enzymatic and nonenzymatic) systems
Only SOD activity was similar in both groups.In urban residence, 42% of elderly had severe OS compared with 10% of the subjects of rural residence.
The proposed SS may be useful for assessing the severity of OS.
Sánchez-Rodríguez MA. et al., 2006 [138]
Cross-sectional
Older adults (68±7y, both sexes)/104 subjects from Mexico City85 subjects from a rural area
Association between OS and cognitive impairment (CI) in elderly residents from rural and urban areas
Greater proportion of subjects with OS and CI in urban than in rural areas, being a risk factor.Higher OS and CI were observed in subjects >80 y of the urban area.
Elderly from urban area have more OS and greater risk of develop CI than inhabitants of rural communities.
Beristain-Pérez AS. et al., 2006 [142]
Cross-sectional
Older adults (67±7y, both sexes)/33 subjects with DM40 subjects with AH26 subjects with OA63 healthy subjects
OS as risk factor for chronic degenerative diseases (CDD): type 2 diabetes mellitus (DM), arterial hypertension (AH), or osteoarthritis (OA) in older adults
OS was higher in DM and AH subjects.OS is a risk factor for CDD.
The OS is a risk factor for CDD, mainly for DM and AH subjects.
Sánchez-Rodríguez MA. et al., 2007 [143]
Case-control study
Older adults (68±7y, both sexes)/44 subjects with osteoporosis50 healthy subjects
OS as an independent risk factor for osteoporosis in older adults
OS was higher in subjects with osteoporosis.OS is a significant risk factor for osteoporosis.
OS is a risk factor for osteoporosis.
Sánchez-Rodríguez MA. et al., 2010 [144]
Cross-sectional
Older adults (67±1y, both sexes)/63 with MetS50 healthy
Association between the number of metabolic syndrome (MetS) components and OS.
The percentage of severe OS in subjects with MetS was higher.The risk for OS increases with the number of components.
MetS is linked to severe OxS, and the risk for OS increases with the number of MetS components.
Mendoza-Núñez VM. et al., 2011 [145]
Cross-sectional
Adults and older adults (both sexes)/56 healthy adults (47±7y)60 DM adults (52±6y)40 healthy older adults (67±7y)72 DM older adults (68±7y)
Assess the additive effect of diabetes mellitus (DM) and aging on OS
DM is a risk factor for OS and a stronger factor in older subjects.
Aging and DM exerts an additive effect over the OS.
Sánchez-Rodríguez MA. et al., 2012 [146]
Cross-sectional
Adults (women)94 premenopausal (45±4y)93 postmenopausal (53±3y)
Influence of menopause as a risk factor for OS
SS was higher in postmenopause. There is an increase in the percentage of severe OS in postmenopausal women.
The decrease of estrogens in the postmenopause can cause OS, together with the symptoms of this period.
Rosado-Pérez J. et al., 2013 [147]
Quasiexperimental study
Older adults (60-74 y, both sexes)/43 subjects walking31 subjects in tai chi23 control subjects
Effect of the practice of tai chi and walking on OS
SS decrease in the tai chi and walking groups, but more evident in the tai chi group.
The practice of tai chi produces an antioxidant effect better than walking.
Sánchez-Rodríguez MA. et al., 2016 [148]
Randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled trial
Adults (53±1y, women)25 heathy with HT25 healthy with placebo25 MetS with HT25 MetS with placebo
Effect of oral hormone therapy (HT) (1 mg/day of estradiol valerate plus 5 mg/10 day of medroxyprogesterone) on OS in postmenopausal women with metabolic syndrome (MetS).
SS decrease after 6 mo in the two groups with HT, more evident in the women with MetS.The proportion of women with OS decreases in both groups of women with HT.
HT improves OS associated with MetS in postmenopause.
Sánchez-Rodríguez MA. et al., 2017 [149]
Cross-sectional
Adults (40-59 y, women)101 premenopausal101 postmenopausal
Relationship between OS with psychological disturbances, low self-esteem, and low quality of life in the postmenopause
Women with low self-esteem and low quality of life had higher SS.
OS is increased in women with low self-esteem and low quality of life.
Mendoza-Núñez VM. et al., 2018 [150]
Quasiexperimental study
Older adults with MetS (60-74 y, both sexes)60 subjects in TC50 control group
Effect of tai chi (TC) exercise on OS in older adults with metabolic syndrome (MetS)
Decrease in the SS after TC training.The percentage of subjects with OS in the TC group decreases after 6 mo.
The TC exercise has an antioxidative effect in the older adults with MetS.
Rosado-Pérez J., et al., 2019 [151]
Exploratory study of a single group
Older adults (71±6y, both sexes)/12 subjects
Effect of the dried fruit powder ofSechium edule (chayote) on OS in older adults with metabolic syndrome (MetS).
SS decrease after 6 weeks of treatment.
The drySechium edule has an antioxidant effect in older adults with MetS.
∗All studies defined OS using the stress score (SS).Other authors have suggested similar proposals to the SS. Initially, Goodman et al. in 2007 [152] developed an OSS with the same idea of us in the form to compute it, but they included prooxidant and antioxidant factors, mainly from diet and lifestyle, to reflect a prooxidant/antioxidant exposure balance. This score is different to our proposal, because they do not perform measurements, rather they use questionnaires to obtain the information and based on them the calculation is made. As the main intention of this index is the exposure balance, the name has been changed to oxidative balance score (OBS). The OBS is a very different index to those included in this review, so we will not discuss it, but it is important to note that it has been used mainly in cases of cancer [141, 153–155] and chronic diseases [156–158], besides it has been related to OS markers [159, 160], inflammation markers [161, 162], then too it carried out studies from its relationship with some gene expression and genetic polymorphism [163–166].On the other hand, based on the Goodman proposal [152], a study was carried out to determinate the association between adiposity measures and an OSS. The OSS was obtained from the blood measurements of GSH, GPx, vitamin C, MDA, and TAC, and some factors of lifestyle such as smoking, use of anti-inflammatory medication, nutritional supplement, and herbal product, adding a total of 9 components [167]. All the variables were categorized as 0 or 1, as we previously pointed. Although the idea is like to our SS, this index is more complex and included particular parameters such as the consumption anti-inflammatory medication and herbal product that are not necessarily useful in all the researchers.Another study used six blood oxidative stress markers: MDA, ox-LDL, total antioxidant reactivity (TAR), SOD, GPx, and CAT, and those were scored as 0, 1, and 2 according the mean and standard deviation (SD) of healthy subjects. A score of 0 was assigned if the measurement of MDA, ox-LDL, CAT, or SOD (oxidants) was rangingmean+1SD or if TAR and GPx (antioxidants) values were mean−1SD. When the values were between +1SD and +2SD of the oxidants or −1SD and −2SD of the antioxidants, a value of 1 point was assigned. A value of 2 points was scored if the oxidant values were more than +2SD or the antioxidant values were less than −2SD. In this case, OSS ranging from 0 to 12 and in a dichotomous way, 6 is the cut-off [168]. This OSS seems more accessible to clinical research than the previous, but it needs to be tested in other clinical settings, since it has only been used in phenylketonuria.In addition, in 2014, two variants of OSS have been published. The first is called OSI, because it analyzes the oxidant/antioxidant balance as the original OSI, but really is an index due to the oxidizing part which includes total lipoperoxides measured as their different forms (conjugated dienes, ketodienes, compounds with conjugated double bonds, conjugated trienes, and MDA), and in the antioxidant part, called the antioxidant defense (AOD), there is an evaluation ofα-tocopherol, retinol, and reduced and oxidized glutathione levels plus SOD activity. First is necessary to obtain the result of the division between each value and the mean value of the control group of each parameter. After that, a multiplication of the oxidized components is placed in the numerator and the multiplication of the antioxidant counterpart in the denominator. As the control value is 1, in the interpretation, values above 1 indicate OS [169]. As the calculation is complex, their use seems impractical.The last proposal includes 12 different blood OS parameters, four oxidized components (protein carbonyls, protein sulfhydryl, MDA, and 8-OHdG), and eight antioxidant components (SOD, GPx, glutathione reductase [GR], CAT, GSH, uric acid, bilirubin, and vitamin C). In the report, the calculation is not very explicit; only the authors explain that specificZ-scores of each parameter were computed, and after an OSS was calculated without explain how this is performed [170]; therefore, its application is doubtful.One common point in all those proposals is that MDA is used as oxidized marker; this is possible because this parameter is an index of lipoperoxidation involved in both recent and chronic damages, so although much has been questioned, especially its form of measurement, is the marker that best reflects the oxidative state in any health situation or disease. The other point to highlight is the use of the main antioxidant enzymes, SOD and GPx, which importance was discussed at the beginning of this section, together the measurement of the antioxidant capacity, a parameter, in which all the indexes shown here are in agreement, independently of the method by it is evaluated.Finally, all the proposals that were revised concord in an important aspect; the measurement of the involved oxidative stress markers as an indicator is more sensitive to the imbalance between oxidants and antioxidants than individual parameters.Indeed, the SS is a proposal with the advantage that it is possible to increase the number of markers (and therefore the total score), both oxidized molecules and antioxidants, being able to include oxidized proteins, DNA damage, and other enzymes or antioxidant molecules; as long as the cut-off values are taken to decide when the marker is increased or decreased, as the case may be.In this review, we analyzed the main indexes as indicators to measure oxidative stress grades linked to different clinical and health settings, highlighting the advantages and disadvantages of each of them. It should be noted that the modulating mechanisms of OS in humans are complex and interact with each other; hence, the SS can be useful to determine if an individual has a high level of OS and thus proceeds with a possible antioxidant therapy, thus improving your state of health and quality of life.It is worth mentioning as a limitation of this review that the indexes for measuring oxidative stress analyzed here are not the only ones. We find in the literature review of others, such as the prooxidant-antioxidant balance (PAB) [171] and the oxidation-reduction potential (ORP) [172], which were not included because their fundaments are outside the scope of this work.Despite the abundant information available so far, more clinical research is needed, especially on prognosis, to assess the usefulness of the different indices, and comparison studies between them, as well as an analysis of the literature of the indicators that evaluate both components, oxidant and antioxidant in a single measurement, as in the PAB, and the redox potential of a sample, such as the ORP.


## 4. Conclusion

We made a review of the state of the art of knowledge about the measurement of OS in humans, focused on different ways to integrally evaluate it.Regardless of the components for the calculation of the different indexes analyzed, all have been able to demonstrate that they can differentiate the OS in pathological or biological stress states; however, not all measure both intracellular and extracellular components involved in the OS; thus, we think they are not equivalent. We cannot say that one index is the best for measuring OS, but we can suggest that there are some proposals that, despite being different, seem to be equivalent in their interpretation since they allow differentiating the types of OS and establishing an intensity or severity, such as Oxy-score and the different proposals of oxidative stress score.Perhaps an interesting way to make this evaluation is to combine the measurement of various markers, both oxidized and antioxidant molecules (enzymatic and non-enzymatic), besides a simple way to put them together through an index whose calculation is not complicated, such as the oxidative stress index, which has demonstrated to be reliable, practical, and with clinical utility.



---

*Source: 4128152-2019-11-25.xml*