# A Reconfigurable WiMAX Antenna for Directional and Broadside Application

Authors: M. Jusoh; M. F. Jamlos; M. R. Kamarudin; T. Sabapathy
Journal: International Journal of Antennas and Propagation
 (2013)

---

## Abstract

A novel reconfigurable compact patch array antenna for directional and broadside application is proposed. The presented antenna has successfully been able to function for directional beam at 320° or 35° and divisive broadside beam at 43° and 330°. This is realized in the unique form of aperture coupled spiral feeding technique and positioning of the radiating elements at 0°, 90,° and 180°. The switchable feature is effectively performed by the configuration of three PIN diodes. All PIN diodes are positioned at the specific location of the aperture coupled structure. It is discovered in simulation that the switches can be represented with a copper strip line or touchstone (TS) block . The proposed antenna design operates at 2.37 GHz to 2.41 GHz and has a maximum gain of 6.4 dB and efficiency of 85.97%. Such antenna produces a broadside HPBW with a wider bandwidth covering from −90° to 90° compared to the normal microstrip antenna which could only provide HPBW of −50° to 50°. Moreover, the proposed antenna has small physical dimension of 100 mm by 100 mm. The simulation and measurement results have successfully exhibited the idea of the presented antenna performance. Therefore, the antenna is sufficiently competent in the smart WiMAX antenna application.


---

## Body

## 1. Introduction

In light of the rapid growth of wireless technology, the requirement of an antenna with a higher data rate, robust to interference, and minimum bit error rate (BER) is exceptionally crucial [1]. Therefore, a special antenna design with an enhancement of the antenna performance is the main challenge. A switched beam or adaptive array antenna could be the solution. Recently switched beam has gained a huge attention among the researchers and industrial players. Owing to this, it is important to design a switchable beam antenna with the ability to direct the main beam towards the desired signal while suppressing the antenna beam in the direction of the unwanted signal.The fast-growing technology in microstrip antennas has led numerous researchers on the study of reconfigurable beam patch antenna [2–4]. Ali et al. [2] Proposed a reconfigurable planar antenna array (RPAA) by integrating with parasitic elements to achieve a beam steering capability. The reconfigurable ability is realized using a PIN diode switch to steer the beam to the desired direction angles of −3.0°, 0.0°, and 2.0°. Yusuf and Gong [3] achieved a beam steering direction angle of −20° to +20° with five different reactive loading values. In that work, a low-cost patch antenna, with center element excited by 50 Ω inset current, has driven two neighboring elements via a mutual coupling effect. This patch antenna was fabricated and measured at a frequency of 3 GHz. Antenna in [4] successfully obtained two dedicated angles of 0° and 270° with activation of probe 1 and probe 2, respectively. The hollow cylindrical dielectric pellet antenna with permittivity of six has been designed to operate at the frequency resonant of 9.53 GHz and 11.1 GHz.This paper demonstrates a novel antenna design with reconfigurable beam of directional and divisive broadside application. The proposed antenna has the capability to direct its radiation pattern to 320° and 35° at a particular predefined switches. Moreover, the divisive broadside can cater direction at 43° and 330°. Therefore, the proposed antenna with a wider HPBW which can be covered in −90° to +90° is better compared to the similar performance of antennas as discussed in [6, 7]. Furthermore, each direction has successfully achieved a maximum beam direction of 3.35 dBi, 3.21 dBi, and 2.80 dBi, respectively. To the best of our knowledge, none of reconfigurable beam antenna has achieved peak gain performance at all reconfigurable beam direction [8, 9].The reconfigurable radiation pattern is achieved by the configuration of the radio frequency switches (R-RFS). Theoretically, the switchable antenna can be realized by using radio frequency (RF) switches such as PIN diodes, varactor diodes, MEMs, and GaAs FETs. The changes of these device states, “ON” and “OFF” at the specific position, would function as a frequency tuning [10, 11] or act as a impedance-matching devices [12, 13].In terms of size, the proposed antenna with the dimensions of 100 mm× 100 mm is smaller than the conventional microstrip antenna with the similar performance [2, 14–16]. Another unique benefit of the proposed antenna lies in its design. It is discovered on the proposed antenna that the spiral feed line with various aperture slot dimensions and positions has significantly contributed to the successfulness of the directions and divisive beam performance. Moreover, the sequence radiating element placement of 90°, 180°, and 270° also leads to the achievement of reconfigurable beam capability. Besides that, the proposed aperture coupled technique has separated the radiating element and the feeding network that eventually contributed to the reduction of the spurious effect. Therefore, the efficiency of the power transfer between the radiating and feed structure is really significant [17]. The proposed antenna design in this wok applied a rectangular aperture slot that helps to couple the electromagnetic (EM) from the field of the radiating element and leads to the optimum antenna performance.The proposed antenna has successfully achieved a considerable performance at particular resonance frequency of 2.39 GHz over 2.37 to 2.41 GHz impedance bandwidth under the tolerable reflection coefficient ofS11<-10 dB. With numerous advantages, the proposed antenna is suitable for World Interoperability for Microwave Access (WiMAX) application regulated by Malaysian and Multimedia Commission (MCMC) [5]. As depicted in Figure 1, the proposed antenna operates in the range of Packet One telecommunications provider, 2.36 GHz to 2.39 GHz, for the use in Peninsular Malaysia.Figure 1
Malaysian Spectrum Allocation Chart of WiMAX 2.3 GHz [5].The remainder of this paper is organized as follows. In Section2, the antenna radiating element and the aperture coupled feed technique are explained. Besides that, the integration of the three RF PIN diode switches at the three spiral arm feeds is investigated. The antenna measurement and simulation comparison of the reconfigurable radiation pattern, reflection coefficient, and gain are presented in Section 3. Finally, conclusions are drawn in Section 4.


## 2. Antenna Design and RF PIN Diode Configuration

Figure2 depicts the configuration of the proposed antenna design. This simulated design has been performed by Computer Simulation Technology (CST) software, as CST is competence 3D electromagnetic simulation software [18]. The proposed antenna is developed from an aperture coupled feeding technique. Technically, this technique is denoted as a multilayer method which separates the radiating element and the feeding network as shown in Figures 2(a) and 2(b). Thus, a spurious effect is minimized which eventually increasing the antenna efficiency. Figure 2(a) illustrates a simulated geometry of the three radiating elements on the upper substrate. All the rectangular radiatings have similar dimensions of 38 mm by 16 mm. It is discovered in simulation, in order to achieve a reconfigurable beam capability, that the radiating elements should be positioned in a sequent spiral manner of 90°, 180°, and 270°. Meanwhile, the lower substrate deployed on both sides consists of aperture slots and spiral feed line as indicated in Figures 2(b) and 2(c), respectively.Figure 2
Structure of the simulated antenna. (a) Radiating element surface. (b) Rectangular slot aperture coupled. (c) Spiral feed line arrangement.Working principle of the proposed antenna aperture coupled feeding shows that the optimum dimension and position of aperture slot is ultimately crucial. This determines the amount of power transferred from the antenna spiral feed line to the radiating element. Hence, the reflected power at the source is minimized. Therefore, the performances of the proposed antenna such as gain, efficiency, and radiation pattern are preserved to be optimal. Presented antenna implemented a rectangular aperture slot with dimension of 14.4 mm by 1.25 mm placed at 10 mm away from the edge of the rectangular radiating arm. The slots dimension can be obtained by resolving the following [1, 17]:
(1)Ls=0.01λo,Ws=0.115λo,λo=cf.As shown in Figure2(c), the switchable antenna is achieved by integrating the RF switches to the antenna spiral feed arm (S-Arm) instead of the radiating element. This helps to minimize power deteriorations by the introduction of the surface mount component (SMC) [10, 11, 14–16]. Switches A, B, and C are placed at the optimum location of S-Arm 1, S-Arm 2, and S-Arm 3, respectively. The R-RF switches configuration of ON state indicates that more RF current will surge to the radiating element. In contrast, the OFF state condition causes gap between the middle line and the respective S-Arm which lead to no current flow through the gap. Such circuit configuration can be considered as circuit maker or a circuit breaker. This concept is proven through simulation by representing R-RF switches with a copper strip line or a touchstone (TS) block. The presence of the copper strip shows that R-RF switches in ON state and vice versa.TS denoted as SnP file is an ASCII text file used for documenting then-port network parameter data of an active device or passive interconnect network. This SnP file of the deployed BAR50-02V PIN diode is obtained from the manufacturer’s website [19]. Based on the simulation result, the antenna performance can be predicted before the optimized antenna design is fabricated with the surface mount component (SMC).Figures3(a) and 3(b) show the schematic diagram of the TS implementation to the antenna. Firstly, the discrete port is drawn from the source edge to the passive edge where all antenna’s R-RF switches are positioned. TS consists of two blocks: (1) diode ON state and (2) diode OFF state. In CST schematic, the TS is imported and positioned to the desired predefined reconfigurable state. Such configuration is depicted in Figure 3 where the source port defined as port 1, switch A as port 2 (diode ON state), switch B as port 3 (diode ON state), and switch C as port 4 (diode ON state). Figure 4 illustrates the comparison of the S11 result of the antenna with TS and antenna with copper strip line. From Figure 4, the TS reflection coefficient result has shifted to the left approximately 10 MHz with reflection to the copper strip line resonant frequency of 2.39 GHz. Besides, the second harmonic of TS technique is bigger compared to the copper strip line. Moreover, the impedance matching for TS is better compared to the copper strip line. Overall, the performance of both techniques is slightly different due to some power excited has been absorbed by the PIN diode.Schematic diagram of the TSB implementation to the antenna. (a) Port creation of the antenna design. (b) TSB attached to the antenna.
(a)
(b)Figure 4
Comparison of the simulated reflection coefficient result.Figure5 shows the fabricated antenna with integration of RF switching circuit into its spiral feeding network. The R-RF switches circuit is developed from the surface mount component (SMC). It consists of one PIN diode, two DC (direct current) block capacitors, two RF choke inductors, and a DC supply. The DC source is inserted to the inductor that performed as a short circuit. However, the capacitor only allows the alternating current (AC) to pass through instead of choke the DC. Therefore, the DC flows in the other direction and ON the PIN diode. The DC supply of 5 volts is induced through the white wire and shorted to the ground via the black wire. The predefined reconfigurable direction to a desired application can be controlled via the “ON” and “OFF” switches as tabulated in Table 1.Table 1
PIN diode switches configuration of the measured and simulated antenna.
Type of switch
Number of PINdiode switch
PIN diode status
Reconfigurable RFswitches (R-RFS)
A
OFF
ON
ON
B
ON
ON
OFF
C
ON
ON
ON
Simulated peak beam angle
340°
30°
50° and 325°
Measured peak beam angle
320°
35°
43° and 330°
Simulated total antenna efficiency
83.68%
83.74%
85.97%
Measured total antenna efficiency
75.8%
76.4%
78.2%
Simulated gain (dBi)
6.281
5.542
5.154
Measured gain (dBi)
3.35
3.21
2.80
Simulated HPBW (degree)
69°
122.9°
70.3°
Type of radiation pattern
Directional beam
Divisive broadsideGeometry of the fabricatedantenna structure. (a) Radiating element surface. (b) Spiral feed network integrates with RF switches. (c) Antenna layout.
(a)
(b)
(c)Throughout the research, all measurement processes were carried out in the Antenna and Microwave Lab (AMRELLAB) of Universiti Malaysia Perlis (UniMAP) with the help of Agilent Technologies E5071C (9 kHz to 8.5 GHz) Network Analyzer, and 3D/2D Atenlab Anechoic Chamber. As depicted in Figure6, the antenna under test (AUT) performs as a transmitter, and a double ridged horn antenna functions as a receiver. The line of sight (LOS) between the antenna and the receiver is kept at 30 m.Positions of the proposed antenna in the anechoic chamber. (a) Point-to-point positioned. (b) The proposed antenna. (c) Receiver (double ridged horn) antenna.
(a)
(b)
(c)


## 3. Results and Discussion

The measurements show that the proposed antenna has successfully achieved a minimum reflection coefficient of less than −10 dB (S11<-10 dB). With certain R-RFS configuration, the return loss of 2.39 GHz is stated at −18.4 dB, −18.3 dB, and −27 dB as shown in Figures 7(a), 7(b), and 7(c), respectively. Those figures indicate that the 90% power that has been transmitted is contributed by proper alignment between the proposed antenna spiral feed line (bottom substrate) and its radiating elements (top substrate).Measured and simulated reflection coefficient of the proposed antenna. (a) R-RFS B and C are ON. (b) R-RFS A, B, and C are ON. (c) R-RFS A and C are ON. The R-RFS that was not mentioned is in OFF state.
(a)
(b)
(c)A sufficient interelement spacing (IES) of the proposed antenna for three R-RFS arrangements is proven through the surface current distribution. In Figure8(a), it is observed that more inset current has flown to the radiating elements number two and three when R-RFS B and C are ON. Less current has been attracted to the adjacent radiating element number one. Figure 8(b) depicts that all radiating elements functioned properly after receiving a number of excited currents from the SMA port. Radiating element number two has approximately null current distribution as shown in Figure 8(c). This leads to more current surge in the elements number one and three. Generally, the presented antenna has good antenna isolation and eventually enhanced the radiation efficiency and antenna efficiency to more than 85% and 83%, respectively.Surface current distributions of the antenna at 2.39 GHz (a) R-RFS B, and C are ON. (b) R-RFS A, B and C are ON. (c) R-RFS A and C are ON. The R-RFS that was not mentioned is in OFF state.
(a)
(b)
(c)Figures9 and 10 depict the simulated 3D and measured radiation pattern of the PIN diode switches configuration. It is realized in both figures that the pattern is radiated on the z-y axis at the resonant frequency of 2.39 GHz for WiMAX application. The proposed antenna achieved the reconfigurable pattern by controlling the R-RFS switches with the implementation of the spiral feed arm design. Spiralling feed with the rectangular radiating element at the position of 0°, 90° and 180° contributed to the phase shift of the EM wave. Moreover, the main lobe radiation can be tuned to the desired direction with certain R-RFS configuration as summarized in Table 1. The high gain measurements and simulations of the proposed antenna can be attributed to the good coupling from the feed line to the radiating surface through the appropriate size, position, and shape of aperture slots. The measurements show a very good agreement with simulations where the radiation patterns are formed successful with respect to the directional and divisive broadside beam characteristics.Simulated 3D radiation pattern of the proposed antenna at 2.39 GHz. (a) R-RFS B and C are ON. (b) R-RFS A, B, and C are ON. (c) R-RFS A and C are ON. The R-RFS that not was mentioned is in OFF state.
(a)
(b)
(c)Measured radiation pattern of the proposed antenna at 2.39 GHz. (a) R-RFS B, and C are ON. (b) R-RFS A, B and C are ON. (c) R-RFS A and C are ON. The R-RFS that not was mentioned is in OFF state.
(a)
(b)
(c)Figures10(a) and 10(b) show the measured polar directional radiation pattern with the normalized value. As R-RFS B and C are ON, the antenna radiation pattern is directed to 320° with a gain of 3.35 dBi and HPBW of 69° as revealed in Figure 10(a). Figure 10(b) depicts the antenna beam pointed to 35° with a gain of 3.21 dBi and HPBW of 122.9° when all R-RFSs are ON. Figure 10(c) demonstrates the divisive broadside radiation pattern headed to 43° and 330° with a gain of 2.80 dBi and HPBW of 70.3° by turning ON the R-RFS A and C. It is realized that the directional beam has a better peak gain of 3.35 dBi and 3.21 dBi compared to the broadside beam with maximum gain of 2.80 dBi. Based on the result, the proposed antenna is able to cater for the existence of the WiMAX user between 90° and −90° by directing the beam to the wanted user direction.


## 4. Conclusion

A novel patch array antenna design with directional and divisive broadside characteristic is proposed. The antenna applied an aperture coupled feed network in order to reduce the signal deterioration due to the implementation of the R-RFS. It is discovered that a spiral feed design effectively contributed to the achievement of the reconfigurable radiation pattern. Through certain R-RFS configuration of the spiral feed arm, the proposed antenna is able to direct its radiating beam to the angles of 320° or 35° and divisive broadside at directions of 43° and 330°. Therefore, the proposed antenna with a wider HPBW can cover the subscriber in the range between −90° to +90°. For all PIN diode arrangements, the antenna well performed at resonant frequency of 2.39 GHz under tolerableS11<-10 dB. On the other hand, the antenna has achieved a compact physical dimension of 100 mm by 100 mm. Moreover, the proposed antenna radiating element occupied a simple shape design yet was able to radiate at a peak gain of 3.35 dBi. The proposed antenna with numerous compensations has further confirmed its feasibility as a portable IEEE 802.16d fixed WiMAX and IEEE 802.16e mobile WiMAX application. A future research of PIN diode circuit modelling with various inductor and capacitor values for WiMAX application will be investigated.



---

*Source: 405943-2013-05-16.xml*