# Occurrence and Distribution of Polycyclic Aromatic Hydrocarbons in Water and Sediment Collected along the Harbour Line, Mumbai, India

Authors: V. Dhananjayan; S. Muralidharan; Vinny R. Peter
Journal: International Journal of Oceanography
 (2012)

---

## Abstract

This study investigated the occurrence of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) in water and sediment samples collected along the harbour line, Mumbai, India. The∑PAHs quantified in water and sediment samples were ranged from 8.66 ng/L to 46.74 ng/L and from 2608 ng/g to 134134 ng/g dry wt., respectively. Significantly high concentration of ∑PAHs was found in water samples of Sewri and sediment samples of Mahul (P<0.05). PAH concentrations detected in the present study were several folds higher than the existing sediment quality criteria suggested by various statutory agencies. The PAH composition patterns in water and sediments suggest the dominance of high molecular weight compounds and indicate important pyrolytic and petrogenic sources. The occurrence of PAHs in the marine environment has attracted the attention of the scientific community as these compounds are frequently detected in seawater and sediments at increasing levels and can have adverse health effects on marine organisms and humans. PAH concentrations detected at Sewri-Mahul site were sufficiently high to pose a risk to marine organisms if they are exposed continuously to this concentration. Hence, continuous monitoring of the ecosystem is highly warranted.


---

## Body

## 1. Introduction

All over the world over there have been imminent problems of pollution in many of the coastal regions resulting in significant damage to marine ecosystems. Polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) are a group of over 100 different chemicals that are formed during the incomplete burning of coal, oil and gas, garbage, and other organic substances [1, 2]. These contaminants generate considerable interest because some of them are highly carcinogenic in laboratory animals and have been implicated in breast, lung, and colon cancers in humans [3–5]. Accordingly, they are included in the US EPA and the EU priority pollutants list. PAHs can reach surface waters and sediment in different ways, including atmospheric deposition, urban run-off, municipal and industrial effluents, and oil spillage or leakage [6, 7]. Owing to their low aqueous solubility and strong hydrophobic nature, these contaminants tend to associate with particulate material in the aquatic environment, with the underlying sediments as their ultimate sink [8].Recent efforts by the EPA have been aimed at establishing sediment quality criteria in an effort to further reduce human exposure to PAH, especially via ingestion of shellfish. Sediments may be a significant source of PAH to the overlying water column particularly in areas where historical PAH input to the sediments has been high. Because some of the PAHs in sediments are not readily available to partition (i.e., PAH associated with soot) and are therefore not bioavailable [9], measuring the PAH in the overlying water may provide a better indication of exposure of marine organisms to PAH than discrete sediment sampling. Also, the distribution of PAH in the sediments may be quite heterogeneous and small numbers of samples may not provide a representative distribution, while overlying water measurements can be made much more extensively in a short period of time [10].It has also been emphasized that open seas play a role as a final sink for persistent toxic contaminants and accumulate on marine organisms [11].  The coastal zone represents that part of the land affected by its proximity to the sea and the part of the sea that is affected by its proximity to the land. Papers concerning PAHs in seawater and sediment in India are scarce, due to their very low concentrations in that matrix, in comparison with the concentrations in wastes, sewage, and contaminated soils. Unprecedented increase of human activities and other sources in and around has imposed considerable stress on the surrounding marine environment, and Mumbai harbor is no exception. Mumbai is one of the fastest growing metropolitan cities. Its population is projected to increase from 18.3 million, as per 2001 census, to 22.4 million in 2011. The quality of environment is deteriorating due to release of contaminants from industries and municipal wastes. It was also estimated that 2485 MLD wastes are released in to the marine environment from both industries and domestic sewage [12]. The major objective of the present study was to determine the distribution of PAHs in water and sediment, to assess the toxicological implications of these contaminants, and to generate baseline information on the pollution status along harbour line, Mumbai, India.


## 2. Materials and Methods

### 2.1. Study Area

Mumbai is one of the major cities in India which is located along the western coast of the country. City with a human population density of 25,000 persons/km−2 generates 2.2×106 m3 d−1 of domestic sewage out of which about 2×106 m3 d−1 enters marine waters including creeks and bays, largely untreated [13]. It has great diversification of industries in metropolitan region. About 8% of industries in the country are located around Mumbai in the upstream. A variety of industries, including refineries and petrochemical complexes, from this area are releasing their effluents largely untreated into the sea. There are number of ports wherein the ship and cargo handling activities contribute to marine pollution. Sewri-Mahul and Nhava mud flats about 1000 ha have been identified as an important bird area (IBA) [14]. Sewri-Mahul mudflats (19°01′00′′N, 72°52′60′′E) (Figure 1) which extent over an area of 10 km long and 3 km wide are dominated by mangroves all along the coast. The Sewri Bay is situated just off the wide mouth of Thane Creek along the northern periphery of Mumbai’s eastern harbour.Figure 1
Study area showing water and sediment sample collection locations at Mumbai harbor line, Maharashtra, India.


### 2.2. Sample Collection

Seawater samples (1 L volume) for determination of PAH were collected during 2008 along the harbour line (Sewri, Mahul, Nhava), Mumbai, India (Figure1). A total of 27 (9 sample pooled into 3 samples from each location) water samples were collected at 1 m depth by submerging a pre-cleaned glass amber bottle by hand. Water was filtered under vacuum through a Whatman GF/F filter (previously muffled at 300°C overnight). The samples were stored in PTFE bags and frozen at −20°C until processing. Twenty seven sediment (9 samples pooled in to 3 from each location) were collected during the research period. Pre-cleaned PVC core sampler was used for sampling. Sediment surfaces were sliced to 1 cm-thick slices immediately after sampling. The sediment samples were sealed in polythene covers and transported to the laboratory at SACON, Coimbatore, in ice box and stored at −20°C in the deep freezer until analysis.


### 2.3. Sample Processing

Water samples were extracted with dichloromethane (glass distilled grade;3×100 mL). The first aliquot was used to rinse the sampling bottle and the remaining was used for solvent extraction. The two solvent extracts were combined over anhydrous sodium sulphate (also previously muffled at 300°C overnight). The collected extract was transferred to a pre-cleaned “hypovial”, capped with a PTFE septum, and stored at −20°C prior to analysis. The extract was allowed to return to room temperature, and then reduced to 2 mL by means of a rotary evaporator with a water-bath operated at <30°C so as to minimize loss of volatile components. The reduced extract was then transferred to a 10 mL test-tube and reduced to near dryness under a stream of nitrogen, before being made up to 1 mL volume by addition of Acetonitrile. Sample extracts were then filtered into an auto sampler vial.Freeze dried sediment was air dried, ground with pestle and mortar, and sieved through 0.5 mm sieve prior to further processing. Ten gram of dry sediment mixed with sodium sulfate and copper granules were extracted twice in 100 mL cyclohexane for 30 min. The extracts were concentrated to 0.5 mL under a gentle stream of nitrogen. The concentrated extracts were fractionated by a silica gel column (4 mm i.d. 90 mm). The column was then eluted first with 3.5 mL of hexane and the solution discarded. Further elution was by benzene (5 mL) to obtain PAHs [16]. All the extracts were concentrated by gentle N2 blowdown to about 100 μL.


### 2.4. Chemical Analysis

All the samples were quantified for PAHs using HPLC (Agilent 1100) consisting of programmable fluorescence detector at excited and emission wavelength of 260 nm and 500 nm, respectively. A 20μL aliquot of the extract was injected through an auto sampler into C18 column (Zorbax 4.6 × 250 mm) of 5 μm particle size. The temperature of the column was maintained at 20°C. Water/Acetonitrile (ACN) was used as mobile phase with a flow of 1 mL/min. The initial content of ACN will be 50% and then increased into 60% (0–3 min) and 95% (3–14 min). This level will be held constant for 24 minutes until the end of the analysis. Recoveries of the compounds from fortified samples (50 ng/g) ranged from 94 to 103% and the results were not corrected for per cent recovery and the results were expressed in wet weight basis. Analyses were run in batches of 10 samples plus four quality controls (QCs) including one reagent blank, one matrix blank, one QC check sample, and one random sample in duplicate. The minimum detection limit for all the compounds analyzed was 10 ng/g.Statistics
All the data were log transformed to get normal distribution. One way analysis of variance (ANOVA) was performed to assess the variation locations. Means were compared using the Bonferroni multiple comparison test. The significant level wasP<0.05. All the calculations were done using statistical software, SPSS student version 10.


## 2.1. Study Area

Mumbai is one of the major cities in India which is located along the western coast of the country. City with a human population density of 25,000 persons/km−2 generates 2.2×106 m3 d−1 of domestic sewage out of which about 2×106 m3 d−1 enters marine waters including creeks and bays, largely untreated [13]. It has great diversification of industries in metropolitan region. About 8% of industries in the country are located around Mumbai in the upstream. A variety of industries, including refineries and petrochemical complexes, from this area are releasing their effluents largely untreated into the sea. There are number of ports wherein the ship and cargo handling activities contribute to marine pollution. Sewri-Mahul and Nhava mud flats about 1000 ha have been identified as an important bird area (IBA) [14]. Sewri-Mahul mudflats (19°01′00′′N, 72°52′60′′E) (Figure 1) which extent over an area of 10 km long and 3 km wide are dominated by mangroves all along the coast. The Sewri Bay is situated just off the wide mouth of Thane Creek along the northern periphery of Mumbai’s eastern harbour.Figure 1
Study area showing water and sediment sample collection locations at Mumbai harbor line, Maharashtra, India.


## 2.2. Sample Collection

Seawater samples (1 L volume) for determination of PAH were collected during 2008 along the harbour line (Sewri, Mahul, Nhava), Mumbai, India (Figure1). A total of 27 (9 sample pooled into 3 samples from each location) water samples were collected at 1 m depth by submerging a pre-cleaned glass amber bottle by hand. Water was filtered under vacuum through a Whatman GF/F filter (previously muffled at 300°C overnight). The samples were stored in PTFE bags and frozen at −20°C until processing. Twenty seven sediment (9 samples pooled in to 3 from each location) were collected during the research period. Pre-cleaned PVC core sampler was used for sampling. Sediment surfaces were sliced to 1 cm-thick slices immediately after sampling. The sediment samples were sealed in polythene covers and transported to the laboratory at SACON, Coimbatore, in ice box and stored at −20°C in the deep freezer until analysis.


## 2.3. Sample Processing

Water samples were extracted with dichloromethane (glass distilled grade;3×100 mL). The first aliquot was used to rinse the sampling bottle and the remaining was used for solvent extraction. The two solvent extracts were combined over anhydrous sodium sulphate (also previously muffled at 300°C overnight). The collected extract was transferred to a pre-cleaned “hypovial”, capped with a PTFE septum, and stored at −20°C prior to analysis. The extract was allowed to return to room temperature, and then reduced to 2 mL by means of a rotary evaporator with a water-bath operated at <30°C so as to minimize loss of volatile components. The reduced extract was then transferred to a 10 mL test-tube and reduced to near dryness under a stream of nitrogen, before being made up to 1 mL volume by addition of Acetonitrile. Sample extracts were then filtered into an auto sampler vial.Freeze dried sediment was air dried, ground with pestle and mortar, and sieved through 0.5 mm sieve prior to further processing. Ten gram of dry sediment mixed with sodium sulfate and copper granules were extracted twice in 100 mL cyclohexane for 30 min. The extracts were concentrated to 0.5 mL under a gentle stream of nitrogen. The concentrated extracts were fractionated by a silica gel column (4 mm i.d. 90 mm). The column was then eluted first with 3.5 mL of hexane and the solution discarded. Further elution was by benzene (5 mL) to obtain PAHs [16]. All the extracts were concentrated by gentle N2 blowdown to about 100 μL.


## 2.4. Chemical Analysis

All the samples were quantified for PAHs using HPLC (Agilent 1100) consisting of programmable fluorescence detector at excited and emission wavelength of 260 nm and 500 nm, respectively. A 20μL aliquot of the extract was injected through an auto sampler into C18 column (Zorbax 4.6 × 250 mm) of 5 μm particle size. The temperature of the column was maintained at 20°C. Water/Acetonitrile (ACN) was used as mobile phase with a flow of 1 mL/min. The initial content of ACN will be 50% and then increased into 60% (0–3 min) and 95% (3–14 min). This level will be held constant for 24 minutes until the end of the analysis. Recoveries of the compounds from fortified samples (50 ng/g) ranged from 94 to 103% and the results were not corrected for per cent recovery and the results were expressed in wet weight basis. Analyses were run in batches of 10 samples plus four quality controls (QCs) including one reagent blank, one matrix blank, one QC check sample, and one random sample in duplicate. The minimum detection limit for all the compounds analyzed was 10 ng/g.Statistics
All the data were log transformed to get normal distribution. One way analysis of variance (ANOVA) was performed to assess the variation locations. Means were compared using the Bonferroni multiple comparison test. The significant level wasP<0.05. All the calculations were done using statistical software, SPSS student version 10.


## 3. Results and Discussion

This paper presents results from analyses of PAHs in water and sediment samples collected along the harbor line, Mumbai, India. Concentration range of individuals and total PAHs are given in Tables2 and 3.


### 3.1. PAH Concentrations in Water

The mean total concentrations of 15 PAHs (∑PAHs) in water ranged from 8.66 μg/L Nhava to 46.74 μg/L at Sewri (Table 1). The highest concentration (104.07 μg/L) was observed at Sewri, where oil intrusion was clearly visible. Among the three locations, samples collected from Nhava detected lower concentration than other two places (Figure 2). Similarly, high concentration (66.74 μg/L) was also found at Mahul, which is close to sewage outlet from Mumbai. Sewri-Mahul mudflats have a surface area of about 4 sq km. The Mahul rivulet, highly polluted with wastes from Vadala, drains directly into this area. The amount of PAHs detected there is obviously related to urban runoffs, sewage discharges, and intense shipping and oil refinery activities. Ship breaking and oil seepage from industrial activities near Sewri area lead to high concentrations of total PAHs. Additionally, boats and ships transports in these regions were discharging black smokes throughout their movement, hence there are many nonpoint sources in the bay, contributing to the wide variations of PAH concentrations detected.Table 1
Concentrations of∑PAHs (μg/L) in water collected along the harbour line, Mumbai, India.
Place of collection
PAHs
SEWRI (n=3)*
MAHUL (n=3)*
NHAVA (n=3)*
Range
Mean
Range
Mean
Range
Mean
Naphthalene
<1
<1
<1
<1
<1
<1
Acenaphthene
<1–2.98
1.33
<1–2.13
1.39
<1
<1
Fluorene
<1–2.55
1.52
<1
<1
<1
<1
Phenanthrene
<1
<1
<1–3.14
1.08
<1
<1
Anthracene
<1
<1
<1
<1
<1
<1
Fluoranthene
<1–5.11
1.7
<1–1.84
1.17
<1–3.05
1.02
Pyrene
<1
<1
<1
<1
<1
<1
Benzo(a)anthracene
<1–2.93
1.78
<1–3.48
1.18
<1–3.16
1.35
Chrysene
<1
<1
<1
<1
<1
<1
Benzo(b)fluoranthene
<1–23.2
8.83
<1–17.3
5.61
<1–8.05
2.58
Benzo(k)fluoranthene
<1–2.06
1.29
<1–2.75
1.25
<1
<1
Benzo(a)pyrene
<1–1.94
1.32
<1–4.67
1.57
<1–2.03
1.34
Dibenzo(a,h)anthracene
<1–28.2
10.9
<1–12.9
4.38
<1–1.97
1.04
Benzo(g,h,i)perylene
<1–15.5
7.97
<1–5.53
2.52
<1
<1
Indeno(1,2,3-cd)pyrene
<1–19.6
10.1
<1–13
3.93
<1–2.23
1.33
Total PAHs
<1–104.07
46.74
<1–66.74
24.08
<1–20.49
8.66
<1: values below detectable concentration, *pooled from 9 water samples.Table 2
Concentrations of∑PAHs (ng/g, dry wt.) in sediment collected along the harbour     line, Mumbai, India.
Place of collection
PAHs
SEWRI (n=3)*
MAHUL (n=3)*
NHAVA (n=3)*
Range
Mean
Range
Mean
Range
Mean
Naphthalene
<1
<1
<1
<1
<1
<1
Acenaphthene
<1–245
110
<1–5265
1821
<1
<1
Fluorene
<1
<1
<1–28
9
<1
16
Phenanthrene
<1–354
120
<1–51
31
9–24
410
Anthracene
<1–331
110
<1–6.2
2
<1–1228
658
Fluoranthene
<1
<1
<1–70496
24857
527–955
17
Pyrene
<1–12
8
<1–419
271
8–23
89
Benzo(a)anthracene
<1–6
2
<1–107
54
37–143
152
Chrysene
<1–22
8
<1–344
170
13–424
193
Benzo(b)fluoranthene
<1–2796
932
<1
<1
110–470
293
Benzo(k)fluoranthene
<1–472
204
<1–40914
17486
<1–480
9
Benzo(a)pyrene
<1–265
90
<1–364
201
<1–28
739
Dibenzo(a,h)anthracene
<1–359
135
104–1450
999
316–1417
210
Benzo(g,h,i)perylene
17.3–920
337
92–13696
5153
<1–491
1251
Indeno(1,2,3-cd)pyrene
<1–1498
552
168–994
552
<1–3395
<1
Total PAHs
17–7280
2608
364–134134
51606
1020–9078
4037
<1: values below detectable concentration, *pooled from 9 sediment samples.Table 3
Comparison of total PAH concentrations (μg/L) in sub-surface water from various marine sites around the world.
Location
Year of Sampling
N
Range
References
Chesapeake Bay, USA
1995
17
0.02–0.0657
Gustafson and Dickhut  [9]
Baltic Sea
1995
14
0.300–0.594
Maldonado et al. [15]
Western Xiamen Bay, China
1998
—
0.106–0.945
Zhou et al. [16]
Alexandria coast, Egypt
—
—
0.013–0.120
El Nemr and Abd-Allah [17]
Daya Bay, China
1999
16
4.228–29.32
Zhou and Maskaoui  [18]
Northern Spanish
2002
25
0.19–28.8
González et al. [19]
Saronikos Gulf (Greece)
—
17
0.425–0.459
Valavanidis et al. [20]
Gerlache Inlet sea (Antarctica)
—
—
0.005–0.009
Stortini et al. [21]
Deep Bay, South China
2004
15
0.0247–0.069
Qiu et al. [22]
Western Taiwan Strait, China
2009
—
0.0123–0.058
Wu et al. [23]
Mumbai Harbour Line, India
2008
15
8.66–46.74
Present study
N: number of PAH compounds analysed in each study.Figure 2
Concentration and comparison of PAHs in water sample collected from different locations along harbor line, Mumbai, India. *ANOVA, P<0.05.In terms of individual PAH composition in water, almost all of the compounds (11 out of 15) analyzed were detected at all the sampling places. Many of the samples from Sewri and Mahul were present at concentrations in excess ofμg/L, suggesting that the water in the area was heavily contaminated by PAHs. Such a wide range of PAHs at different concentrations indicates that there are potentially many different sources of PAHs in the area, possibly including combustion followed by oil residues, sewage outfalls, and industrial wastewater. From the distribution of PAHs in water alone, it is difficult to differentiate these different sources of input, nevertheless, the data can act as an indication of the potential impacts of such high levels of PAHs on the local ecosystems.The total PAH concentrations found in water along the harbor line, Mumbai, are several orders of magnitude higher than those detected in various other studies around the world (Table3). Similarly, comparable high levels of PAHs were also found in seawater samples of Daya Bay, China [18], and northern Spanish [19]. Although PAHs do not show extremely high acute toxicity to aquatic organisms, the lower molecular mass compounds tend to exhibit higher lethal toxicity than the larger PAHs [33]. In addition, lethal concentration (LC50) down to less than 10 μg/L has been reported for various organisms including mysid [34, 35]. The PAH concentrations detected in water samples of Sewri and Mahul clearly show (Figure 2) that the concentrations are greater than 10 μg/L, as a result, acute toxicity may have been caused to certain exposed organisms [33]. It should be noted that different numbers of target analytes (PAH congeners) and instrument were employed in individuals studies.


### 3.2. PAH Concentrations in Sediment

The∑PAH concentrations in sediment ranged from 17 ng/g at Sewri to 134134 ng/g at Mahul with mean concentrations of 2608–51606 ng/g dry wt. (Table 2). Although the higher load of PAHs was recorded in water samples of Sewri, sediment from Mahul recorded the highest concentrations of PAHs. The highest concentration was observed at Mahul, which is close to sewage intrusion to seashore and also receive water flow from Sewri, which is closer to Mahul. The total PAH concentration detected in sediment samples of Mahul is 20 times higher than the levels detected in Sewri and 13 times higher than those detected in sediment samples of Nhava (Figure 3).Figure 3
Concentration and comparison of PAHs in sediment sample collected from different locations along harbor line, Mumbai, India. *ANOVA,P<0.05.In terms of individual PAH composition in sediment, the most compounds analysed except naphthalene were detected at all the sediment samples. Many of the PAH compounds were present at low concentration range. As far as the composition pattern of PAHs in sediments is concerned, it is mostly dominated by four-ring PAHs as shown in Table2. Pereira et al. [36] also showed that four-ring PAHs dominated PAH distributions in sediments from San Francisco Bay. Pyrolysis/combustion of fossil materials yield such PAH assemblages, which are subsequently introduced into the marine environment by coastal and river runoff [37, 38]. Industrial and domestic wastes are often another important local source. The changes in the composition pattern of PAHs between sampling sites may occur due to variations in additional input sources. The coastal region of Mumbai receives industrial discharges up to 230 million liters per day (MLD) and domestic wastes of around 2200 MLD of which 1800 MLD are untreated [12]. As a result, the high concentrations of PAHs in sediment could be caused by the large amount of soil runoff and sewage discharged from this area into seawater. The results seem to suggest that PAHs in the area are derived from both the combustion of fossil fuels and petrogenic inputs.The levels of sediment contamination by PAHs in along the harbor line, Mumbai, India is fivefold lower than the levels reported in sediment of Kitimat Harbour, Canada [25]. The total concentrations of 15PAHs in sediment of present study are several folds higher than that the levels found in Victoria Harbour, Hong Kong [24], Baltic Sea [26], Masan Bay, Korea [27], and other places (Table 4). It is also worth noting that different numbers of parent PAH compounds were analysed in different studies, and that the compounds measured may be different; so the comparison of total PAH levels from different studies have to be treated with caution. Additionally, high concentrations of total and carcinogenic PAHs were also reported in fish samples collected from same location [39].Table 4
Comparision of total PAH concentrations (ng/g, dry wt.) in sediment from various marine sites around the world.
Location
Year of Sampling
N
Range
References
Victoria Harbour, Hong Kong, China
1992
8
700–26100
Hong et al. [24]
Kitimat Harbour, Canada
—
15
310–528000
Simpson et al. [25]
Baltic Sea
1996
18
3.96–22100
Baumard et al. [26]
Masan Bay, Korea
1998
16
41.5–1100
Khim et al. [27]
Western Xiamen Bay, China
1998
16
247–480
Zhou et al. [16]
East China Sea
—
—
17–157
Bouloubassi et al. [28]
Bohai Sea and Yellow Sea
—
10
20.4–5734
Ma et al. [29]
Northern Adriatic Sea
1996
22
30–600
Notar  et al. [30]
Daya Bay, China
1999
16
115–1134
Zhou and Maskaoui [18]
Deep Bay, South China
2004
15
353.8–128.1
Qiu et al. [22]
Southwestern Barents Sea
2006
22
58.8–326
Boitsov et al. [31]
Cienfuegos Bay, Cuba
—
—
180–5500
Tolosa  et al. [32]
Mumbai Harbour Line, India
2008
15
17–134134
Present studyIn order to assess whether sediments in Mumbai harbor will cause toxic effects, the PAH levels in sediments were compared against effects-based guideline values such as the effects range-low (ER-L), effects range-median (ERM), and apparent effects threshold values developed by the US National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration [40]. Among the three study locations, the maximum mean total PAH concentrations (51606 ng/g) were found in sediment samples collected from Mahul followed by Nhava (4037 ng/g). These levels were significantly higher than the ER-L value (4000 ng/g). The total PAH concentrations found in sediment samples in the present study locations exceeded the maximum values of 2000–4000 ng/g in sediment quality guidelines proposed by Ontario Ministry of the Environment [41].


## 3.1. PAH Concentrations in Water

The mean total concentrations of 15 PAHs (∑PAHs) in water ranged from 8.66 μg/L Nhava to 46.74 μg/L at Sewri (Table 1). The highest concentration (104.07 μg/L) was observed at Sewri, where oil intrusion was clearly visible. Among the three locations, samples collected from Nhava detected lower concentration than other two places (Figure 2). Similarly, high concentration (66.74 μg/L) was also found at Mahul, which is close to sewage outlet from Mumbai. Sewri-Mahul mudflats have a surface area of about 4 sq km. The Mahul rivulet, highly polluted with wastes from Vadala, drains directly into this area. The amount of PAHs detected there is obviously related to urban runoffs, sewage discharges, and intense shipping and oil refinery activities. Ship breaking and oil seepage from industrial activities near Sewri area lead to high concentrations of total PAHs. Additionally, boats and ships transports in these regions were discharging black smokes throughout their movement, hence there are many nonpoint sources in the bay, contributing to the wide variations of PAH concentrations detected.Table 1
Concentrations of∑PAHs (μg/L) in water collected along the harbour line, Mumbai, India.
Place of collection
PAHs
SEWRI (n=3)*
MAHUL (n=3)*
NHAVA (n=3)*
Range
Mean
Range
Mean
Range
Mean
Naphthalene
<1
<1
<1
<1
<1
<1
Acenaphthene
<1–2.98
1.33
<1–2.13
1.39
<1
<1
Fluorene
<1–2.55
1.52
<1
<1
<1
<1
Phenanthrene
<1
<1
<1–3.14
1.08
<1
<1
Anthracene
<1
<1
<1
<1
<1
<1
Fluoranthene
<1–5.11
1.7
<1–1.84
1.17
<1–3.05
1.02
Pyrene
<1
<1
<1
<1
<1
<1
Benzo(a)anthracene
<1–2.93
1.78
<1–3.48
1.18
<1–3.16
1.35
Chrysene
<1
<1
<1
<1
<1
<1
Benzo(b)fluoranthene
<1–23.2
8.83
<1–17.3
5.61
<1–8.05
2.58
Benzo(k)fluoranthene
<1–2.06
1.29
<1–2.75
1.25
<1
<1
Benzo(a)pyrene
<1–1.94
1.32
<1–4.67
1.57
<1–2.03
1.34
Dibenzo(a,h)anthracene
<1–28.2
10.9
<1–12.9
4.38
<1–1.97
1.04
Benzo(g,h,i)perylene
<1–15.5
7.97
<1–5.53
2.52
<1
<1
Indeno(1,2,3-cd)pyrene
<1–19.6
10.1
<1–13
3.93
<1–2.23
1.33
Total PAHs
<1–104.07
46.74
<1–66.74
24.08
<1–20.49
8.66
<1: values below detectable concentration, *pooled from 9 water samples.Table 2
Concentrations of∑PAHs (ng/g, dry wt.) in sediment collected along the harbour     line, Mumbai, India.
Place of collection
PAHs
SEWRI (n=3)*
MAHUL (n=3)*
NHAVA (n=3)*
Range
Mean
Range
Mean
Range
Mean
Naphthalene
<1
<1
<1
<1
<1
<1
Acenaphthene
<1–245
110
<1–5265
1821
<1
<1
Fluorene
<1
<1
<1–28
9
<1
16
Phenanthrene
<1–354
120
<1–51
31
9–24
410
Anthracene
<1–331
110
<1–6.2
2
<1–1228
658
Fluoranthene
<1
<1
<1–70496
24857
527–955
17
Pyrene
<1–12
8
<1–419
271
8–23
89
Benzo(a)anthracene
<1–6
2
<1–107
54
37–143
152
Chrysene
<1–22
8
<1–344
170
13–424
193
Benzo(b)fluoranthene
<1–2796
932
<1
<1
110–470
293
Benzo(k)fluoranthene
<1–472
204
<1–40914
17486
<1–480
9
Benzo(a)pyrene
<1–265
90
<1–364
201
<1–28
739
Dibenzo(a,h)anthracene
<1–359
135
104–1450
999
316–1417
210
Benzo(g,h,i)perylene
17.3–920
337
92–13696
5153
<1–491
1251
Indeno(1,2,3-cd)pyrene
<1–1498
552
168–994
552
<1–3395
<1
Total PAHs
17–7280
2608
364–134134
51606
1020–9078
4037
<1: values below detectable concentration, *pooled from 9 sediment samples.Table 3
Comparison of total PAH concentrations (μg/L) in sub-surface water from various marine sites around the world.
Location
Year of Sampling
N
Range
References
Chesapeake Bay, USA
1995
17
0.02–0.0657
Gustafson and Dickhut  [9]
Baltic Sea
1995
14
0.300–0.594
Maldonado et al. [15]
Western Xiamen Bay, China
1998
—
0.106–0.945
Zhou et al. [16]
Alexandria coast, Egypt
—
—
0.013–0.120
El Nemr and Abd-Allah [17]
Daya Bay, China
1999
16
4.228–29.32
Zhou and Maskaoui  [18]
Northern Spanish
2002
25
0.19–28.8
González et al. [19]
Saronikos Gulf (Greece)
—
17
0.425–0.459
Valavanidis et al. [20]
Gerlache Inlet sea (Antarctica)
—
—
0.005–0.009
Stortini et al. [21]
Deep Bay, South China
2004
15
0.0247–0.069
Qiu et al. [22]
Western Taiwan Strait, China
2009
—
0.0123–0.058
Wu et al. [23]
Mumbai Harbour Line, India
2008
15
8.66–46.74
Present study
N: number of PAH compounds analysed in each study.Figure 2
Concentration and comparison of PAHs in water sample collected from different locations along harbor line, Mumbai, India. *ANOVA, P<0.05.In terms of individual PAH composition in water, almost all of the compounds (11 out of 15) analyzed were detected at all the sampling places. Many of the samples from Sewri and Mahul were present at concentrations in excess ofμg/L, suggesting that the water in the area was heavily contaminated by PAHs. Such a wide range of PAHs at different concentrations indicates that there are potentially many different sources of PAHs in the area, possibly including combustion followed by oil residues, sewage outfalls, and industrial wastewater. From the distribution of PAHs in water alone, it is difficult to differentiate these different sources of input, nevertheless, the data can act as an indication of the potential impacts of such high levels of PAHs on the local ecosystems.The total PAH concentrations found in water along the harbor line, Mumbai, are several orders of magnitude higher than those detected in various other studies around the world (Table3). Similarly, comparable high levels of PAHs were also found in seawater samples of Daya Bay, China [18], and northern Spanish [19]. Although PAHs do not show extremely high acute toxicity to aquatic organisms, the lower molecular mass compounds tend to exhibit higher lethal toxicity than the larger PAHs [33]. In addition, lethal concentration (LC50) down to less than 10 μg/L has been reported for various organisms including mysid [34, 35]. The PAH concentrations detected in water samples of Sewri and Mahul clearly show (Figure 2) that the concentrations are greater than 10 μg/L, as a result, acute toxicity may have been caused to certain exposed organisms [33]. It should be noted that different numbers of target analytes (PAH congeners) and instrument were employed in individuals studies.


## 3.2. PAH Concentrations in Sediment

The∑PAH concentrations in sediment ranged from 17 ng/g at Sewri to 134134 ng/g at Mahul with mean concentrations of 2608–51606 ng/g dry wt. (Table 2). Although the higher load of PAHs was recorded in water samples of Sewri, sediment from Mahul recorded the highest concentrations of PAHs. The highest concentration was observed at Mahul, which is close to sewage intrusion to seashore and also receive water flow from Sewri, which is closer to Mahul. The total PAH concentration detected in sediment samples of Mahul is 20 times higher than the levels detected in Sewri and 13 times higher than those detected in sediment samples of Nhava (Figure 3).Figure 3
Concentration and comparison of PAHs in sediment sample collected from different locations along harbor line, Mumbai, India. *ANOVA,P<0.05.In terms of individual PAH composition in sediment, the most compounds analysed except naphthalene were detected at all the sediment samples. Many of the PAH compounds were present at low concentration range. As far as the composition pattern of PAHs in sediments is concerned, it is mostly dominated by four-ring PAHs as shown in Table2. Pereira et al. [36] also showed that four-ring PAHs dominated PAH distributions in sediments from San Francisco Bay. Pyrolysis/combustion of fossil materials yield such PAH assemblages, which are subsequently introduced into the marine environment by coastal and river runoff [37, 38]. Industrial and domestic wastes are often another important local source. The changes in the composition pattern of PAHs between sampling sites may occur due to variations in additional input sources. The coastal region of Mumbai receives industrial discharges up to 230 million liters per day (MLD) and domestic wastes of around 2200 MLD of which 1800 MLD are untreated [12]. As a result, the high concentrations of PAHs in sediment could be caused by the large amount of soil runoff and sewage discharged from this area into seawater. The results seem to suggest that PAHs in the area are derived from both the combustion of fossil fuels and petrogenic inputs.The levels of sediment contamination by PAHs in along the harbor line, Mumbai, India is fivefold lower than the levels reported in sediment of Kitimat Harbour, Canada [25]. The total concentrations of 15PAHs in sediment of present study are several folds higher than that the levels found in Victoria Harbour, Hong Kong [24], Baltic Sea [26], Masan Bay, Korea [27], and other places (Table 4). It is also worth noting that different numbers of parent PAH compounds were analysed in different studies, and that the compounds measured may be different; so the comparison of total PAH levels from different studies have to be treated with caution. Additionally, high concentrations of total and carcinogenic PAHs were also reported in fish samples collected from same location [39].Table 4
Comparision of total PAH concentrations (ng/g, dry wt.) in sediment from various marine sites around the world.
Location
Year of Sampling
N
Range
References
Victoria Harbour, Hong Kong, China
1992
8
700–26100
Hong et al. [24]
Kitimat Harbour, Canada
—
15
310–528000
Simpson et al. [25]
Baltic Sea
1996
18
3.96–22100
Baumard et al. [26]
Masan Bay, Korea
1998
16
41.5–1100
Khim et al. [27]
Western Xiamen Bay, China
1998
16
247–480
Zhou et al. [16]
East China Sea
—
—
17–157
Bouloubassi et al. [28]
Bohai Sea and Yellow Sea
—
10
20.4–5734
Ma et al. [29]
Northern Adriatic Sea
1996
22
30–600
Notar  et al. [30]
Daya Bay, China
1999
16
115–1134
Zhou and Maskaoui [18]
Deep Bay, South China
2004
15
353.8–128.1
Qiu et al. [22]
Southwestern Barents Sea
2006
22
58.8–326
Boitsov et al. [31]
Cienfuegos Bay, Cuba
—
—
180–5500
Tolosa  et al. [32]
Mumbai Harbour Line, India
2008
15
17–134134
Present studyIn order to assess whether sediments in Mumbai harbor will cause toxic effects, the PAH levels in sediments were compared against effects-based guideline values such as the effects range-low (ER-L), effects range-median (ERM), and apparent effects threshold values developed by the US National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration [40]. Among the three study locations, the maximum mean total PAH concentrations (51606 ng/g) were found in sediment samples collected from Mahul followed by Nhava (4037 ng/g). These levels were significantly higher than the ER-L value (4000 ng/g). The total PAH concentrations found in sediment samples in the present study locations exceeded the maximum values of 2000–4000 ng/g in sediment quality guidelines proposed by Ontario Ministry of the Environment [41].


## 4. Conclusion

This study provides important data set on PAH levels in the water and sediments along harbor line, Mumbai, India. The levels of PAHs in water and sediment were several folds higher than the other study reports from various countries. The PAH distribution profile indicated potential source dependence, as the levels were generally higher in the vicinity of known inputs such as oil terminals and ports. There are implications for the quality of seafood from many aquaculture areas destined for human consumption. The findings point to the urgent need to establish a monitoring programme for persistent organic pollutants such as PAHs, not only in water and sediment but also in the organisms themselves to ensure that any excess in concentrations over environmental quality standards is rapidly reported and necessary actions are taken. Their presence in marine sediments combined with other potentially toxic compounds can result in negative effects, which have yet to be investigated to any great extent.



---

*Source: 403615-2012-11-04.xml*