# Bandwidth Extension of a Printed Square Monopole Antenna Loaded with Periodic Parallel-Plate Lines

Authors: Linglong Meng; Weimin Wang; Ming Su; Jinchun Gao; Yuanan Liu
Journal: International Journal of Antennas and Propagation
 (2017)

---

## Abstract

A novel wideband monopole antenna employing periodically loaded parallel-plate lines is presented in this paper. The proposed antenna consists of a main square patch, a rectangular ground plane, and a periodical structure which is printed on both sides of substrate. A strong electromagnetic coupling technique is used to design the element that enhances impedance bandwidth and decreases the side-lobe level throughout the effective bandwidth. The antenna achieves a wide impedance bandwidth of about 61.1% or ranging from 2.16 to 4.06 GHz, an omnidirectional far-field pattern, and a peak radiation gain of 2.37 dBi. Finally, the proposed antenna is analyzed and measured. The measured results show satisfactory performance and good agreement with the simulated results.


---

## Body

## 1. Introduction

Recently, the size of mobile devices has become smaller due to the development of modern wireless communication systems, and compact antennas with wide bandwidth and good omnidirectional radiation characteristics are needed [1] to satisfy the various demands for wireless services, such as simple feeding, low profile, and low manufacturing cost. The currently popular designs, which are suitable for the wireless local area network (WLAN: 2.4–2.484 GHz), mobile worldwide interoperability for microwave access (WiMAX: 2.5–2.69 GHz, and 3.4–3.69 GHz), and S-band satellite communication service (2–4 GHz), have been widely researched and used. Planar monopole antenna is a good candidate for wireless communication services because of its wide impedance bandwidth, omnidirectional radiation pattern, compact circuit structure, easy fabrication, and low cost [2]. In addition, printed monopole antennas are fabricated from a conventional monopole easily.Most previous monopole antennas suffer from the protruded structure and the bulky size [3–10]. For instance, in [6], a circular disc monopole antenna has been proposed. The antenna presents a wide impedance bandwidth (1.17–12 GHz). But this configuration is not entirely planar because of the large ground plane (30×30 cm2). It cannot be integrated to the printed circuit board of the communication device. In [8], a planar monopole antenna with two plates that results in more than 5 : 1 bandwidth ratio is reported. Besides, studies on extending the bandwidth of monopole antennas have been widely investigated [11–17]. It has been reported that, by using different ground plane sizes, bandwidth can be increased to a substantial level [11]. For the 50×50 mm2 ground plane, the measured bandwidth was 1.5 GHz, which represented a fractional impedance bandwidth of 58%. In a circularly polarized printed monopole antenna using a lumped capacitor [12], the measured return loss bandwidth is raised to 60.5% (3.75–7 GHz). The antenna presented in [13] uses a truncated optimum ground plane for achieving wide bandwidth. In [16], a meandered-microstrip fed circular shaped monopole antenna is designed. Due to meandered-microstrip structure, the impedance bandwidth is extended. However, these design solutions are generally bulky, which may be not compatible with the new generation of wireless communication systems.What is more, a novel approach to enhance the impedance bandwidth is reported by loading a trapezoid conductor-backed plane in [17]. The parasitic element is usually placed vertically under the upper radiating patch so as to improve the impedance bandwidth. According to the principle, the original broadband antenna is achieved by loading a gap and a rectangular conductor-backed plane.In this paper, a novel printed broadband monopole antenna is proposed and designed for wireless communication systems that can support the WLAN/WiMAX applications. The proposed structure consists of a main square patch, a rectangular ground plane, and a periodical structure which is printed on both sides of substrate. The wideband monopole antenna (2.16–4.06 GHz) can be achieved, and the impedance performance has been largely improved due to the strong electromagnetic coupling between the monopole and the periodical structure. Simulation and experimental results of the prototyped antenna are presented and discussed.


## 2. Design and Analysis

### 2.1. Novel Broadband Monopole Antenna I

In this part, we present a miniaturized broadband monopole antenna with a gap and a parasitic planar square element. We know that planar printed monopole antennas are good candidates for use in different wireless communications because of their wide impedance bandwidth. The printed rectangular monopole has radiation pattern similar to that of a dipole antenna. Besides, it also possesses simple structure, planar configuration, and easy fabrication.The antenna design evolution process to achieve broadband operation is shown in Figure1. The proposed antenna (Ant. 4) is fabricated on the TLF-35A dielectric substrate of thickness 1.0 mm, relative permittivity of 3.5, and dielectric loss tangent of 0.0022. The overall size of the proposed antenna is only 12.0 mm × 39.5 mm or about 0.12λ0×0.39λ0, where λ0 is the free-space wavelength at the first resonant frequency 2.93 GHz.Figure 1
Antenna geometry evolution for the proposed design.The antenna design starts by a conventional rectangular monopole (Ant. 1). From Figure2(a), it can be observed that, in this case, two resonant modes seem to form at about 2.86 GHz and 6.15 GHz. However, the return loss is less than 10 dB at the first resonant frequency. More importantly, a wide operating frequency band (4.14–6.67 GHz or 46.8%) is obtained. In Figure 2(a), the antenna (Ant. 2) with a gap has a wide bandwidth from 4.46 to 6.64 GHz (39.3%) for VSWR < 2. The gap can be seen when adding a series capacitance, but impedance matching is not good and the bandwidth does not increase relatively to Ant. 1. In [18], a broadband monopole antenna with a parasitic planar square element has been proposed. By adding a planar square conducting element, the impedance performance has been largely improved due to the strong electromagnetic coupling between the monopole and the parasitic element. So, triple-band characteristics of Ant. 3 are designed. However, this is not what we expect to be broadband. Finally, we present a miniaturized broadband monopole antenna (Ant. 4) with a gap and a parasitic planar rectangular element. As shown in Figure 2(b), a simulated VSWR of less than 2 has been realized across the 2.66–5.90 GHz band (75.7%).Figure 2
Simulated reflection coefficients of the proposed antenna.
(a)
(b)Figure3 shows the simulated radiation patterns at 2.88, 3.55, and 5.43 GHz in the E-plane (XOY-plane) and the H-plane (XOZ-plane), respectively. The H-plane patterns are almost omnidirectional in this operation frequency band. Radiation pattern for E-plane gives the bidirectional pattern at 3.55 GHz frequency but appears more directional at 2.88 and 5.43 GHz.Figure 3
Simulated patterns (left:XOY-plane; right: XOZ-plane.) of the proposed Ant. 4 at (a) 2.88 GHz; (b) 3.55 GHz; (c) 5.43 GHz.
(a)
(b)
(c)


### 2.2. Novel Broadband Monopole Antenna II

From Figure3, it can be observed that the E-plane copolarization radiation patterns produce some side lobes due to current direction change. In order to obtain stable radiation patterns, a novel broadband printed square monopole antenna loaded with periodic parallel-plate lines is properly designed. The evolution of the proposed broadband antenna is shown in Figure 4, with the corresponding simulated reflection coefficients presented in Figure 5. As the number of parasitic planar square elements increases, the higher resonant frequency decreases, since the path of the antenna is increased. However, the lower resonant frequency has a little change.Figure 4
Design evolution of the proposed antenna.Figure 5
Simulated reflection coefficients of the different antenna.Furthermore, it can be seen that when two unit cells (Ant. 5) are loaded to the monopole antenna, two resonances are separated from each other, giving two narrow bands. While three unit cells were loaded, an enhanced impedance bandwidth of 61.1% ranging from 2.16 to 4.06 GHz forS11 < −10 dB is achieved, and the size is 62.5×12.0×1.0 mm3. When four unit cells were loaded, a novel printed monopole antenna (Ant. 6) with dual wideband is presented. But the size of the antenna increased to 75.0×12.0×1.0 mm3. From the comparison, the three pluralities of periodically loaded parallel-plate lines achieve both broadband operation and compact size at the same time.As a result of electromagnetic coupling, the plurality of periodically loaded aligned microstrip patches plays an important role in the broadband characteristics of this planar monopole. By adding the loading parallel-plate lines, the broadband monopole antenna is achieved.


## 2.1. Novel Broadband Monopole Antenna I

In this part, we present a miniaturized broadband monopole antenna with a gap and a parasitic planar square element. We know that planar printed monopole antennas are good candidates for use in different wireless communications because of their wide impedance bandwidth. The printed rectangular monopole has radiation pattern similar to that of a dipole antenna. Besides, it also possesses simple structure, planar configuration, and easy fabrication.The antenna design evolution process to achieve broadband operation is shown in Figure1. The proposed antenna (Ant. 4) is fabricated on the TLF-35A dielectric substrate of thickness 1.0 mm, relative permittivity of 3.5, and dielectric loss tangent of 0.0022. The overall size of the proposed antenna is only 12.0 mm × 39.5 mm or about 0.12λ0×0.39λ0, where λ0 is the free-space wavelength at the first resonant frequency 2.93 GHz.Figure 1
Antenna geometry evolution for the proposed design.The antenna design starts by a conventional rectangular monopole (Ant. 1). From Figure2(a), it can be observed that, in this case, two resonant modes seem to form at about 2.86 GHz and 6.15 GHz. However, the return loss is less than 10 dB at the first resonant frequency. More importantly, a wide operating frequency band (4.14–6.67 GHz or 46.8%) is obtained. In Figure 2(a), the antenna (Ant. 2) with a gap has a wide bandwidth from 4.46 to 6.64 GHz (39.3%) for VSWR < 2. The gap can be seen when adding a series capacitance, but impedance matching is not good and the bandwidth does not increase relatively to Ant. 1. In [18], a broadband monopole antenna with a parasitic planar square element has been proposed. By adding a planar square conducting element, the impedance performance has been largely improved due to the strong electromagnetic coupling between the monopole and the parasitic element. So, triple-band characteristics of Ant. 3 are designed. However, this is not what we expect to be broadband. Finally, we present a miniaturized broadband monopole antenna (Ant. 4) with a gap and a parasitic planar rectangular element. As shown in Figure 2(b), a simulated VSWR of less than 2 has been realized across the 2.66–5.90 GHz band (75.7%).Figure 2
Simulated reflection coefficients of the proposed antenna.
(a)
(b)Figure3 shows the simulated radiation patterns at 2.88, 3.55, and 5.43 GHz in the E-plane (XOY-plane) and the H-plane (XOZ-plane), respectively. The H-plane patterns are almost omnidirectional in this operation frequency band. Radiation pattern for E-plane gives the bidirectional pattern at 3.55 GHz frequency but appears more directional at 2.88 and 5.43 GHz.Figure 3
Simulated patterns (left:XOY-plane; right: XOZ-plane.) of the proposed Ant. 4 at (a) 2.88 GHz; (b) 3.55 GHz; (c) 5.43 GHz.
(a)
(b)
(c)


## 2.2. Novel Broadband Monopole Antenna II

From Figure3, it can be observed that the E-plane copolarization radiation patterns produce some side lobes due to current direction change. In order to obtain stable radiation patterns, a novel broadband printed square monopole antenna loaded with periodic parallel-plate lines is properly designed. The evolution of the proposed broadband antenna is shown in Figure 4, with the corresponding simulated reflection coefficients presented in Figure 5. As the number of parasitic planar square elements increases, the higher resonant frequency decreases, since the path of the antenna is increased. However, the lower resonant frequency has a little change.Figure 4
Design evolution of the proposed antenna.Figure 5
Simulated reflection coefficients of the different antenna.Furthermore, it can be seen that when two unit cells (Ant. 5) are loaded to the monopole antenna, two resonances are separated from each other, giving two narrow bands. While three unit cells were loaded, an enhanced impedance bandwidth of 61.1% ranging from 2.16 to 4.06 GHz forS11 < −10 dB is achieved, and the size is 62.5×12.0×1.0 mm3. When four unit cells were loaded, a novel printed monopole antenna (Ant. 6) with dual wideband is presented. But the size of the antenna increased to 75.0×12.0×1.0 mm3. From the comparison, the three pluralities of periodically loaded parallel-plate lines achieve both broadband operation and compact size at the same time.As a result of electromagnetic coupling, the plurality of periodically loaded aligned microstrip patches plays an important role in the broadband characteristics of this planar monopole. By adding the loading parallel-plate lines, the broadband monopole antenna is achieved.


## 3. Antenna Geometry

The configuration of the proposed antenna is shown in Figure6(a), which is printed on a TLF-35A substrate with a relative dielectric constant of 3.5, dielectric loss tangent of 0.0022, and thickness of 1.0 mm. The whole substrate occupies an area of 62.5×12.0×1.0 mm3, when the antenna and the ground plane are printed on different sides. The antenna can be treated as a printed square monopole with a periodical structure. It can be seen from Figure 6(b) that four square patches and microstrip feed line are printed on the top side of substrate. As shown in Figure 6(b), the feed line with a length of l1 is connected to the coaxial cable through a 50 Ω SMA connector. The square conducting plane on the top side of the substrate has a length of d, and g is the gap between the square conducting planes on the same side of the substrate. In Figure 6(c), a rectangular ground plane and four square conducting planes under the microstrip line fed monopole antenna and three square conducting planes, respectively, are printed on the bottom side of the substrate. The antenna elements are simulated in ANSYS HFSS full-wave simulator [19]. The optimized parameters of the antennas are given in Table 1.Table 1
Values of key parameters.
Parameter
Value (mm)
w
g
12
l
g
62.5
l
1
16
l
2
8
l
3
13.25
l
4
5.25
d
10
h
1
w
1
1
g
0.5Figure 6
Geometry of monopole antenna. (a) 3D view; (b) top view; (c) bottom view.
(a)
(b)
(c)


## 4. Simulation and Experimental Results

Figure7 shows different views of the fabricated prototype. The physical size of the wideband monopole antenna is 62.5×12.0×1.0 mm3. Figure 8 shows the simulated and measured reflection coefficients of the proposed antenna. The simulated and measured results were obtained using ANSYS HFSS full-wave simulator [19] and Rohde & Schwarz ZVA8 vector network analyzer, respectively. Also, it is evident that the impedance matching is excellent in intermediate frequencies as the matching bandwidth with VSWR < 2 is roughly 61.1% within frequency range of 2.16–4.06 GHz. The higher resonance frequency is almost no offset. Compatible with the fabrication tolerance, the lower resonance frequency has a slight frequency shift as shown in Figure 8.Figure 7
Photograph of the fabricated antenna. (a) Top view; (b) bottom view.Figure 8
Simulated and measured reflection coefficients of the proposed antenna.The surface current distributions on the proposed antenna at 2.4 GHz and 3.5 GHz are shown in Figure9. It is clear that the currents of the proposed monopole antenna remain almost in phase in Figures 9(a) and 9(b), respectively. Thus, good radiation patterns at 2.4 GHz and 3.5 GHz are achieved.Figure 9
Simulated surface currents distribution versus frequency. (a)f=2.4 GHz; (b) f=3.5 GHz.
(a)
(b)The measured radiation patterns in theH-plane (x-y plane) and E-plane (x-z plane) at 2.4, 3.0, and 3.5 GHz are plotted in Figure 10. A good radiation pattern is obtained in the E-plane and H-plane. From an overall view of these patterns, the antenna behaves quite similarly to the typical dipole antenna in the lower and higher frequency bands. The radiation patterns are stable throughout the wideband.Figure 10
Measured copolarization and cross-polarization of proposed antenna at different frequencies: (a) 2.4 GHz; (b) 3.0 GHz; and (c) 3.5 GHz (left:XOZ-plane; right: XOY-plane).
(a)
(b)
(c)The measured peak gain of the proposed antenna is plotted in Figure11 along with measured radiation efficiency of the proposed antenna. The measured peak gain of the proposed antenna varies from −0.86 to 2.37 dBi within the effective bandwidth. The measured efficiency of the broadband antenna is above 46.5% at the operating band and about 75% peak efficiency at 3.5 GHz.Figure 11
Measured peak gain and radiation efficiency of the proposed antenna.Table2 shows the performance of proposed antenna compared with other published antenna. It can be seen that the proposed antenna occupies a small volume (62.5×12.0×1.0 mm3) and obtains wide operating bandwidth (61.1%). Finally, this table demonstrates the validity and practicability of the proposed method.Table 2
The performance of proposed antenna compared with other published antenna.
Reference
S
11
<
-
10
d
B
Relative bandwidth
Antenna size
Relative dielectric constant
[12]
3.75–7 GHz
60.5%
52 × 55 × 1.52 mm3
2.2
[14]
5.1–6.05 GHz
17%
24 × 36 × 1.6 mm3
4.4
[20]
1.85–3.40 GHz
59%
150 × 18 × 1 mm3
2.65
Proposed antenna
2.16–4.06 GHz
61.1%
62.5 × 12 × 1 mm3
3.5


## 5. Conclusion

In this paper, a novel printed square wideband monopole antenna loaded with periodic parallel-plate lines is presented. The wideband enhancement of the antenna can be obtained by coupling between the monopole and the periodical structure. The measured −10 dB impedance bandwidth is 1.90 GHz from 2.16 to 4.06 GHz (61.1%), which covers WLAN (2.4–2.484 GHz), mobile WiMAX (2.5–2.69 GHz), WiMAX (3.4–3.69 GHz), andS-band (2–4 GHz) satellite communication service. The measured efficiency is higher than 46.5% within frequency bands. Good omnidirectional radiation performances are also obtained at the effective bandwidth. The structure of the proposed antenna is simple and easy to fabricate. The proposed antenna is suitable for the modern wireless communication systems.



---

*Source: 4082780-2017-05-03.xml*