# Real-Time Generation Method of Oil Painting Style Brushstrokes Based on Inverse Reinforcement Learning

Authors: MingQian Zhang
Journal: Mobile Information Systems
 (2022)

---

## Abstract

A popular style in modern graphics programs like GIMP, Photoshop, and Painter is brushstroke artwork, a classic artwork that is still extensively practiced today. Regarding successive decision-making situations with ambiguity, reinforcement learning approaches can be quite helpful. In RL, a reward-enabled agent interacts with a dynamic situation to discover a strategy. To use current RL techniques, we must first offer a reward function, a concise depiction of the designer’s purpose. Hence, inverse-RL (IRL), an expansion of RL, was born. It solves this difficulty via developing the reward function from skilled demonstrations. In this article, we present a novel sundry-fidelity Bayesian optimization (SFBO) approach to boost the ability of the IRL regarding oil painting style brushstrokes. Finally, the performance of the proposed approach is examined and compared with the standard approaches to achieve the highest effectiveness in oil painting. The findings are depicted in graphical representation through Origin tool. Approaches based on RL can be quite helpful in ambiguous decision-making situations. Today’s RL approaches must include a reward function, which embodies the designer’s intent. To reduce the dimensions of the data, the proposed SFBO comprises stages of data preprocessing and feature extraction. The proposed technique was evaluated against the existing techniques in terms of accuracy, information loss, average MSE, and time consumption. Compared to the existing approaches, the proposed approach was the most effective.


---

## Body

## 1. Introduction

People can apply conventional artistic techniques like pointillism, line drawing, and brushstroke painting to their images using nonphotorealistic rendering’s artistic stylization. In terms of painting forms, brushstroke design was among the most extensively employed [1]. Computer-generated painting representation faces numerous challenges, including the difficult task of accurately placing brushstrokes in order to attain the required result.The simplest way to achieve a painterly effect is to use physics-based paintings, in which the user feels like they are drawing with such an actual brush. Several studies simulated the physical effect of ink distribution by modeling physical digital brushes, including their 3D model, motion, and connection with the paper surface. Using a digital pencil or cursor and one of the included virtual brushes, you may create a wide variety of strokes. A virtual brush, on the other hand, is extremely difficult to manipulate. Some physics-based painting systems depend on graphics processing unit (GPU) to achieve decent performance because of the significant computational costs required to generate visuals acceptable to human vision.To address the issues associated with physics-based painting, the stroke-based rendering approach was proposed to directly simulate rendering marks on a 2D canvas. This stroke-based rendering underpins many artistic rendering algorithms, especially on those emulating traditional brush-based artistic styles such as oil painting and watercolor.For nonartists, the final outcome is much more important than the way of painting, even if physics-based artwork and stroke-based rendering seem to be valuable for professionals. Several academics looked into beautifying as a way of making the painterly rendering technique better approachable for new users, allowing users to make standardized and seamless brushstrokes by using the reinforcement learning (RL) approach of artistic brushstroke creation.Figure1 shows an AI-aided art authoring (A4) technique for generating creative brushstrokes. An online synthesis stage and an offline training stage constitute the system. To help users generate artwork conceptions, [2] A4 offers an excellent graphical user interface that allows them to concentrate on drawing the location and angle of the intended strokes. Anyone, even those who are not artists, can employ an image as a guide to draw the appropriate stroke forms. The primary goal of offline training is to teach the virtual agent how to mimic the drawing style of a particular artist. A state-of-the-art methodology termed importance-weighted policy gradients using parameter-based analysis, rather than the conventional model, is used to modify and use already gathered data more effectively.Figure 1
An illustration of the AI-aided art creation (A4) platform.Experimental results show the suggested method has the potential to produce stroke placement with a unique style of its own. Thus, this study proposes a sundry-fidelity Bayesian optimization (SFBO) method to improve the IRL’s capacity to paint with oil paint style brushstrokes.


## 2. Related Works

In [9], the authors train a reinforced natural media painting agent with little information. On the other hand, they generate results in a high-dimensional and continuous action space. Many strategies like education learning and E-greedy sampling are designed to minimize the policy’s search space. On different reference photos with varied styles and resolutions, they highlight performance. They show how this approach can be used for style transfer and other things. The strategy has flaws. This means that the information description is constrained in the current configuration. The policy gradient approach uses a modest patch size owing to computing expense. Another study [10] proposed an oil painting authentication mechanism based on color and texture characteristics. Based on this research, the following dataset was created and processed. To balance the photos being contrasted, the accumulating circumstances should be the same for the original versions and copies. To test the suggested approach, machine learning was employed to discriminate between originals and copies.In [11], to achieve varied visuals, the authors develop natural media painting agents that could really create artistic artworks that use media. Model-based reinforcement learning would be used to construct a natural media painting agent. Restriction formulation, a methodology for training a restricted painting agent, and several rollout strategies are proposed for introducing limits to the agents. Utilizing MyPaint’s art supplies and limitations, they implement the algorithm’s assumption. The system might recreate comparable photos in numerous artistic styles, according to the experimental outcomes. In [12], CSCW stroke-based learning and rendering (WebSBLR) system was presented. Upon that user end, the authors use WebGL and HTML5 to construct a genuine stroke rendering engine. The proposed learning strategy has worked well in user-interactive stroke artworks, as proved in the study. Unskilled users can easily learn and discover local contour-based forms regarding mid-level feature data in the form of hand drawn shapes in pictures using automatic contour extraction of photos in the future.In [13], the Artificial Fish Swarm Algorithm was used to detect brushstrokes of Van Gogh and his contemporaries. The Artificial Fish Swarm Technique can be implemented in evolutionary computational models to properly differentiate Van Gogh’s brushstrokes from those of his contemporaries. Furthermore, the two-edge recognition could be effective in discerning brushstrokes across the works of Van Gogh and his contemporaries. In [14], the authors present a deep learning-based aesthetic rating methodology for Chinese ink paintings. The suggested method estimates individual aesthetic assessment with Pearson extremely significant relationship while combining deeply learned features and hand-crafted features relying on art professional expertise. To explore Chinese traditional art assets in the age of AI, they developed a deep learning scheme enabling quantitative aesthetic assessment of Chinese artworks. Aesthetic judgment can be improved by combining handmade and learned traits, which is explored in this study.In [15], the authors employ Cross-Contrast Neural Network (CCNN) to identify artists from oil paintings. With “Selected-Wikipaintings,” the strategy using a tailored CNN pretrained using VGG-19 performed well. It demonstrates CCNN’s capability to identify dynamic system using basic statistical physics concepts. Thus, cross-contrast probability mappings transmitted through the Modified IBS portion can compare pictures. In [16], the authors addressed the topic of building interactive teaching techniques for a sequential IRL participant. They demonstrated OMNITEACHER inside an omniscient teaching environment.In [17], the authors assume that learners have preferences and restrictions. In this situation, the student not only mimics the teacher’s actions but also considers personal preferences, such as behavioral factors or physical limitations. The authors suggest and explore methods for learner-aware teaching, wherein the instructor accounts for the learner’s preferences for predictable and unpredictable choice restrictions. Both conceptually and experimentally, the learner-aware teaching techniques outperformed learner-agnostic teaching. The conceptual model and suggested techniques encourage the use of IRL throughout authentic environments where students need not uncritically copy teachers’ actions.In [18], the authors discussed how to cope with worldview conflict when a student tries to match a teacher’s feature counts. They established the teaching liability, a number which relates to the learner’s worldview as well as the actual reward function and which (1) assesses how ideal strategies for the learner could be unsatisfactory for the teacher and (2) prevents truly excellent strategies from appearing perfect to the learner. For example, employing traditional IRL-based methodologies guarantees learning a near-optimal policy via teacher examples even when worldviews are mismatched.In [19], the authors presented MFBO architecture for scalable IRL. The approach enables big organizations with variable reward functions to use several RL methods with various episode counts as numerous fidelity approximators for such a process of learning. In [20], the authors addressed the critical issue of robotic societal navigation in formerly human-occupied social environments. They proposed ReplayIRL, an IRL emphasis on social navigation that would be more sample effective, highly functional, and quicker to train Table 1.Table 1
Related works and its finding.
S. no.AuthorsFindings1Xie et al., (2018)CSCW stroke-based learning and rendering (WebSBLR) system was presented. The authors have employed WebGL and HTML5 to construct a genuine stroke rendering engine. The proposed learning strategy has worked well in user-interactive stroke artworks2Ibrahim, (2018)Artificial Fish Swarm Algorithm was used to detect brushstrokes of Van Gogh and his contemporaries. The Artificial Fish Swarm Technique can be implemented in evolutionary computational models to properly differentiate Van Gogh’s brushstrokes from those of his contemporaries. The two-edge recognition could be effective in discerning brushstrokes3Zhang et al., (2020)A deep learning-based aesthetic rating methodology for Chinese ink paintings was presented. The suggested method estimates individual aesthetic assessment with Pearson extremely significant relationship while combining deeply learned features and hand-crafted features relying on art professional expertise4Wang et al., 2020Cross-Contrast Neural Network (CCNN) was employed to identify artists from oil paintings. With “Selected-Wikipaintings,” the strategy using a tailored CNN pretrained using VGG-19 performed well. It demonstrates CCNN’s capability to identify dynamic system using basic statistical physics concepts. Thus, cross-contrast probability mappings transmitted through the Modified IBS portion can compare pictures


### 2.1. Problem Statement

Brushstroke artwork is a common style in modern graphics implementations. RL approaches can be quite useful in ambiguous decision-making circumstances. In RL, a reward-enabled agent explores a dynamic situation. For contemporary RL approaches, we need a reward function, a clear statement of the designer’s intent. Therefore, IRL was born to develop the reward function from skilled demonstrations.


## 2.1. Problem Statement

Brushstroke artwork is a common style in modern graphics implementations. RL approaches can be quite useful in ambiguous decision-making circumstances. In RL, a reward-enabled agent explores a dynamic situation. For contemporary RL approaches, we need a reward function, a clear statement of the designer’s intent. Therefore, IRL was born to develop the reward function from skilled demonstrations.


## 3. Proposed Work

In this section, the proposed SFBO approach is illustrated including the application of IRL. This investigation comprises data preprocessing and feature extraction stages to normalize the data and lessen the data’s dimensions, correspondingly. As per maximum-entropy approach, the IRL can be applied. Furthermore, the proposed technique is utilized regarding the optimization of IRL. Figure2 depicts the complete procedure of this research.Figure 2
Complete procedure of this research.


### 3.1. Dataset

A total of 7,500 traditional Chinese paints (TCPs) as well as 8,800 oil paintings (OPs) were used in the research. A new class is created for every painting. There will be 156 images in every class after image enhancement is complete. The statistics now have 1,175,000 and 1,375,000 subjects as samples.


### 3.2. Data Preprocessing

#### 3.2.1. Denoising Using Median Filter

In digital imaging, MF is nonlinear filtration that has been employed to eliminate distortion from datasets. MF is being used frequently since it can keep the edge when eliminating distortion under certain circumstances. Filtering a picture window-wise with MF replaces every element with the midpoint of the next closest ones. MF is a nonlinear smoothness approach that completely nullifies noise while still preserving the edge for certain noises (like random noise and salt-pepper noise). The edge of Melanoma is still the most crucial aspect because most cancerous cells have a nodular shape. For an effective diagnosis, the shape of the edge contains critical data. As a result, the MF is critical in preprocessing since it preserves the edge design. Figure3 sketches the functioning of MF (median filter).Figure 3
Function of the median filter.


#### 3.2.2. Contour-Based Image Enhancement (CIE)

CIE is an important key for outlines. By using CIE, the boundary of the skin lesion can be retrieved. The lesion portion of the digital picture is removed from the contour. Finally, the actual image and skin lesions are generated by combining the binary image of the diseased part and the actual image. This approach could follow the directions of moving spatially and temporally. It is particularly useful in the domain of medical imaging since it aids in increasing contrast, particularly whenever the ROI and surroundings have similar contrast values. The contrast augmentation index (CAI) formula is used to describe the image’s contrast as a parameter.(1)CAI=CprocssedCactual.Here,Cprocssed is the value of the contrast of the processed image and Cactual is the value of the contrast of the actual image.(2)Image area contrast=m−sm+s.Here,m is the gray-level value of the “foreground” of the image and s is the gray-level value of the “background” of the image.


### 3.3. Feature Extraction Using Gabor Filter Bank (GFB)

GFB is commonly employed to retrieve characteristics in painting pictures; it could retrieve the spatial/frequency data. Amplitude, phases, and direction are the 3 kinds of characteristics created by the GFB. A sine plane wave modulates a Gaussian envelop in such filter banks. Throughout the spatial region, the Gabor filter is stated as follows:(3)Sx,y=fc2πtnefn2/t2x2+fn2/n2y2ej2πfcx,.Here,(4)x′=xcosθd+ysinθd,y′=−xsinθd+ycosθd,fc=fmax2c/2,θd=dπ88.In addition,fc is the center frequency [fmax = 1/4] and θd is the direction.We evaluate the proportion of the center frequency to the size of such Gaussian envelope usingt as well as n. Here, t=n=2 have been the most widely used variables.Throughout this research, we employed a bank of filters with 5 scales and 8 directions to retrieve distinct information from the painting pictures,c = 1 to 4; d = 0 to 7.Consider thatI (x, y) becomes a gray-scale painting picture, and the feature extraction process is as follows:(5)Gc,dx,y=Ix,y∗Sc,dx,y.Here,Gc,dx,y is the complex filtering result.


### 3.4. Application of Inverse Reinforced Learning Using the Maximum-Entropy Approach

According to the concept of maximum entropy, the policy with the maximum entropy effectively depicts the observed activity, according to the restriction of reflecting the reward value of the observed behaviors. Sometimes, this requirement may be met by guaranteeing that the learned policy’s characteristic quantities reflect those of observation.This means(6)∀j∈1,…,L:∑p∈PTτ|π,PejP=e^j.Here,j is the feature and e^j is the feature’s experimental expectation.The characteristics of a strategy are identified that increases distribution entropy along limited pathways (1). When this issue is solved, the probability of the exhibited paths underneath the following distribution is enhanced.(7)Tsτ|θ,P∝cor1exp∑j=1Lθj,ejP∏p=1GPrp,bp,rp+1.Here,τ = r1b1, …, rGbG.It is worth noting that this distribution is given as a rough estimate of a more complicated one obtained using the concept of maximum entropy. However, calculating the probability function of the examples requires knowledge of the transition function (P). We present a novel strategy influenced by the sundry-fidelity Bayesian optimization (SFBO) methodology to handle this issue.


### 3.5. Sundry-Fidelity Bayesian Optimization (SFBO)

Every fidelity approximator is considered as part of the policy in this brief, which chooses good sample points throughout the parameter space along with appropriate approximators of the objective function in order to accomplish an IRL learning experience that is adaptable, precise, and quick. If the learning is at iterationm but we want to halt it, the optimal estimation of reward system parameters is a sample from the parameter space with the greatest predicted average in the posterior distribution of the Gaussian process (GP).It is possible to select the sample point:(8)θ^MT∗=argmaxθ∈Θе¯nθ.We recommend selecting the parameter and approximator pairs with the largest single-period predicted increase throughout the optimum of the surrogate design per unit cost from the parameter space as well as approximator collection when further parameter and approximator pairs are to be chosen.(9)θn+1,Mn+1=argmaxθ,M∈Θ,M1dMFn=maxθ′∈ΘFEθ′|Θn,Mn,en,θn+1=θ,Mn+1=M−maxθ′∈ΘFEθ′|Θn,Mn,en.By substituting the parameter space with a finite collection of alternatives, it is possible to produce an accurate closed-form response (9). You must choose from among a limited number of possible alternatives based on what you hope to learn. You can use a knowledge gradient policy to determine which sample from an alternate set is more desirable.Thejth alternate sample’s average and variance are equal to(10)σ¯∑nb,j,M=∑nbσM2+∑nbjj.Equation (9) can be rewritten as(11)θn+1,Nn+1=argmaxθ,M∈Θb,M1dMFnmaxj∈1,…,mμnbj+σ˜∑nb,j,MW|Θn,Mn,en,θn+1=θj,Mn+1=M−maxjε1,…,mμnbj.The provided framework’s full approach is described in Algorithm 1.Algorithm 1: Procedure of SFBO.
Step 1: Choose a preferred reward functionSθ among θ∈Θ; create a limited collection of possibilities Θb; provide a list of episode numbers M; put the price DM and variance parameterσM2 for M ϵ ℳ.Step 2: Make a MT above parameter domainΘ.Step 3:n = −1, Θ0=, M0=, E0=Step 4: While halting is not fulfilled doStep 5:n = n + 1.Step 6: Selectθn+1,Mn+1 according to (14).Step 7: Run an SK tuned toθn+1 with episode number Mn+1 to get e^θn+1.Step 8:Θn+1=Θn,θn+1,Mn+1=Mn,Mn+1,en+1=en,e^θn+1.Step 9: Update MT according to (Θn+1,Mn+1,en+1).Step 10: End whileStep 11:θ^MT∗=argmaxθ∈Θе¯nθ, where е¯nθ is the mean of the final MT.


## 3.1. Dataset

A total of 7,500 traditional Chinese paints (TCPs) as well as 8,800 oil paintings (OPs) were used in the research. A new class is created for every painting. There will be 156 images in every class after image enhancement is complete. The statistics now have 1,175,000 and 1,375,000 subjects as samples.


## 3.2. Data Preprocessing

### 3.2.1. Denoising Using Median Filter

In digital imaging, MF is nonlinear filtration that has been employed to eliminate distortion from datasets. MF is being used frequently since it can keep the edge when eliminating distortion under certain circumstances. Filtering a picture window-wise with MF replaces every element with the midpoint of the next closest ones. MF is a nonlinear smoothness approach that completely nullifies noise while still preserving the edge for certain noises (like random noise and salt-pepper noise). The edge of Melanoma is still the most crucial aspect because most cancerous cells have a nodular shape. For an effective diagnosis, the shape of the edge contains critical data. As a result, the MF is critical in preprocessing since it preserves the edge design. Figure3 sketches the functioning of MF (median filter).Figure 3
Function of the median filter.


### 3.2.2. Contour-Based Image Enhancement (CIE)

CIE is an important key for outlines. By using CIE, the boundary of the skin lesion can be retrieved. The lesion portion of the digital picture is removed from the contour. Finally, the actual image and skin lesions are generated by combining the binary image of the diseased part and the actual image. This approach could follow the directions of moving spatially and temporally. It is particularly useful in the domain of medical imaging since it aids in increasing contrast, particularly whenever the ROI and surroundings have similar contrast values. The contrast augmentation index (CAI) formula is used to describe the image’s contrast as a parameter.(1)CAI=CprocssedCactual.Here,Cprocssed is the value of the contrast of the processed image and Cactual is the value of the contrast of the actual image.(2)Image area contrast=m−sm+s.Here,m is the gray-level value of the “foreground” of the image and s is the gray-level value of the “background” of the image.


## 3.2.1. Denoising Using Median Filter

In digital imaging, MF is nonlinear filtration that has been employed to eliminate distortion from datasets. MF is being used frequently since it can keep the edge when eliminating distortion under certain circumstances. Filtering a picture window-wise with MF replaces every element with the midpoint of the next closest ones. MF is a nonlinear smoothness approach that completely nullifies noise while still preserving the edge for certain noises (like random noise and salt-pepper noise). The edge of Melanoma is still the most crucial aspect because most cancerous cells have a nodular shape. For an effective diagnosis, the shape of the edge contains critical data. As a result, the MF is critical in preprocessing since it preserves the edge design. Figure3 sketches the functioning of MF (median filter).Figure 3
Function of the median filter.


## 3.2.2. Contour-Based Image Enhancement (CIE)

CIE is an important key for outlines. By using CIE, the boundary of the skin lesion can be retrieved. The lesion portion of the digital picture is removed from the contour. Finally, the actual image and skin lesions are generated by combining the binary image of the diseased part and the actual image. This approach could follow the directions of moving spatially and temporally. It is particularly useful in the domain of medical imaging since it aids in increasing contrast, particularly whenever the ROI and surroundings have similar contrast values. The contrast augmentation index (CAI) formula is used to describe the image’s contrast as a parameter.(1)CAI=CprocssedCactual.Here,Cprocssed is the value of the contrast of the processed image and Cactual is the value of the contrast of the actual image.(2)Image area contrast=m−sm+s.Here,m is the gray-level value of the “foreground” of the image and s is the gray-level value of the “background” of the image.


## 3.3. Feature Extraction Using Gabor Filter Bank (GFB)

GFB is commonly employed to retrieve characteristics in painting pictures; it could retrieve the spatial/frequency data. Amplitude, phases, and direction are the 3 kinds of characteristics created by the GFB. A sine plane wave modulates a Gaussian envelop in such filter banks. Throughout the spatial region, the Gabor filter is stated as follows:(3)Sx,y=fc2πtnefn2/t2x2+fn2/n2y2ej2πfcx,.Here,(4)x′=xcosθd+ysinθd,y′=−xsinθd+ycosθd,fc=fmax2c/2,θd=dπ88.In addition,fc is the center frequency [fmax = 1/4] and θd is the direction.We evaluate the proportion of the center frequency to the size of such Gaussian envelope usingt as well as n. Here, t=n=2 have been the most widely used variables.Throughout this research, we employed a bank of filters with 5 scales and 8 directions to retrieve distinct information from the painting pictures,c = 1 to 4; d = 0 to 7.Consider thatI (x, y) becomes a gray-scale painting picture, and the feature extraction process is as follows:(5)Gc,dx,y=Ix,y∗Sc,dx,y.Here,Gc,dx,y is the complex filtering result.


## 3.4. Application of Inverse Reinforced Learning Using the Maximum-Entropy Approach

According to the concept of maximum entropy, the policy with the maximum entropy effectively depicts the observed activity, according to the restriction of reflecting the reward value of the observed behaviors. Sometimes, this requirement may be met by guaranteeing that the learned policy’s characteristic quantities reflect those of observation.This means(6)∀j∈1,…,L:∑p∈PTτ|π,PejP=e^j.Here,j is the feature and e^j is the feature’s experimental expectation.The characteristics of a strategy are identified that increases distribution entropy along limited pathways (1). When this issue is solved, the probability of the exhibited paths underneath the following distribution is enhanced.(7)Tsτ|θ,P∝cor1exp∑j=1Lθj,ejP∏p=1GPrp,bp,rp+1.Here,τ = r1b1, …, rGbG.It is worth noting that this distribution is given as a rough estimate of a more complicated one obtained using the concept of maximum entropy. However, calculating the probability function of the examples requires knowledge of the transition function (P). We present a novel strategy influenced by the sundry-fidelity Bayesian optimization (SFBO) methodology to handle this issue.


## 3.5. Sundry-Fidelity Bayesian Optimization (SFBO)

Every fidelity approximator is considered as part of the policy in this brief, which chooses good sample points throughout the parameter space along with appropriate approximators of the objective function in order to accomplish an IRL learning experience that is adaptable, precise, and quick. If the learning is at iterationm but we want to halt it, the optimal estimation of reward system parameters is a sample from the parameter space with the greatest predicted average in the posterior distribution of the Gaussian process (GP).It is possible to select the sample point:(8)θ^MT∗=argmaxθ∈Θе¯nθ.We recommend selecting the parameter and approximator pairs with the largest single-period predicted increase throughout the optimum of the surrogate design per unit cost from the parameter space as well as approximator collection when further parameter and approximator pairs are to be chosen.(9)θn+1,Mn+1=argmaxθ,M∈Θ,M1dMFn=maxθ′∈ΘFEθ′|Θn,Mn,en,θn+1=θ,Mn+1=M−maxθ′∈ΘFEθ′|Θn,Mn,en.By substituting the parameter space with a finite collection of alternatives, it is possible to produce an accurate closed-form response (9). You must choose from among a limited number of possible alternatives based on what you hope to learn. You can use a knowledge gradient policy to determine which sample from an alternate set is more desirable.Thejth alternate sample’s average and variance are equal to(10)σ¯∑nb,j,M=∑nbσM2+∑nbjj.Equation (9) can be rewritten as(11)θn+1,Nn+1=argmaxθ,M∈Θb,M1dMFnmaxj∈1,…,mμnbj+σ˜∑nb,j,MW|Θn,Mn,en,θn+1=θj,Mn+1=M−maxjε1,…,mμnbj.The provided framework’s full approach is described in Algorithm 1.Algorithm 1: Procedure of SFBO.
Step 1: Choose a preferred reward functionSθ among θ∈Θ; create a limited collection of possibilities Θb; provide a list of episode numbers M; put the price DM and variance parameterσM2 for M ϵ ℳ.Step 2: Make a MT above parameter domainΘ.Step 3:n = −1, Θ0=, M0=, E0=Step 4: While halting is not fulfilled doStep 5:n = n + 1.Step 6: Selectθn+1,Mn+1 according to (14).Step 7: Run an SK tuned toθn+1 with episode number Mn+1 to get e^θn+1.Step 8:Θn+1=Θn,θn+1,Mn+1=Mn,Mn+1,en+1=en,e^θn+1.Step 9: Update MT according to (Θn+1,Mn+1,en+1).Step 10: End whileStep 11:θ^MT∗=argmaxθ∈Θе¯nθ, where е¯nθ is the mean of the final MT.


## 4. Results and Discussion

This paper’s experiment was conducted in the following settings: 64-bit operating system with 3.20 GHz Intel Core i7-9700K processor. PyTorch 1.10 is a deep learning platform for Windows 10. Regarding CNN implementation, this open-source platform is mostly developed in Python and may be employed in any environment. About 70 percent of the data generated is employed for training, 15 percent for verification, and 15 percent for test. Here, the performance metrics of the proposed technique like accuracy, information loss, average MSE, and time consumption are examined and used for comparison with the existing techniques.


### 4.1. Accuracy

The percentage of pixels inside the picture that were properly identified may be used as an additional statistic for evaluating segmentation. Including for individual classes, the pixel accuracy is often typically stated as a whole throughout all categories.


### 4.2. Rate of Information Loss

Information loss is also used to signify inability to retrieve all information accessible in statistical research regarding a specific theme.


### 4.3. Time Consumption

The total time that people spent using a particular volume of work is referred to as time consumption.


### 4.4. Average Mean Squared Error (MSE)

MSE is a metric that indicates how near a fitted line is to the sample points. Average value of MSE is referred to as average MSE.Here, both the current and presented techniques are examined in terms of performance metrics like accuracy, time consumption, average MSE, and rate of information loss. Figure4 indicates the comparative analysis of accuracy in the current and presented approaches. In this figure, the x-axis indicates the approaches and the y-axis indicates the accuracy. Similarly, the rate of information loss of the existing and proposed approaches is depicted in Figure 5. The time consumption of the existing and proposed approaches is depicted in Figure 6. The average MSE of the existing and proposed approaches is depicted in Figure 7. Figures 4–7 indicate that the SFBO model has outperformed the other models with maximum values of accuracy, reduced rate of information loss, average MSE, and reduced time consumption. The SFBO model has demonstrated high accuracy of 85% whereas the multi-agent IRL, SMIRL, MCE-IRI, and variational IRL models have obtained lower accuracy of 78%, 70%, 60%, and 47%, respectively.Figure 4
Comparative analysis of accuracy in current and presented approaches.Figure 5
Comparative analysis of rate of information loss in current and presented approaches.Figure 6
Comparative analysis of time consumption in current and presented approaches.Figure 7
Comparative analysis of average MSE in current and presented approaches.Three-dimensional (3D) virtual worlds and social networks have transitioned into a new norm known as the metaverse. Utilizing a number of pertinent technologies, the metaverse aims to provide users with immersive 3D experiences. Although the metaverse enjoys great attention and benefits, securing data and content is a natural concern for users. Blockchain presents a promising solution because of its decentralized, immutable, and transparent characteristics. An extensive survey of blockchain applications for the metaverse was provided by Gadekallu et al. to better understand the role of blockchain in the metaverse. The authors presented an overview of blockchain technology and the metaverse and explored the motivations for the use of blockchain in the metaverse. Further, they discussed blockchain-based metaverse strategies from a technical standpoint, including data collection, storage, sharing, interoperability, and privacy protection. The results of this study demonstrated promising directions for the use of blockchain technology in the future metaverse, resulting in further innovations and developments [22]. The current approaches have certain limitations. In [23], for basic tasks, the multi-agent IRL approach should not be the best option. In [2], the healthier performance measurements are not taken into account regarding the SMIRL approach. Despite the fact that the policy taught through adversarial IRL operates well, [25] shows that training a policy using the incentive system fails in the majority of beginning situations. In [26], the reward and policy are not considered in the various professional expressions. We think most cross-domain connections are complicated and should be described as many-to-many. With these problems in mind, we have developed the SFBO for IRL enhancement.Modern graphic software, such as GIMP, Photoshop, and Painter, uses brushstroke drawing among many traditional art forms. A4 is an AI-assisted system of nonphotorealistic rendering developed by Xie et al. It lets users automatically produce paintings in the style of a specific artist. The authors aimed to learn artists’ drawing styles from video-recorded stroke data by inverse reinforcement learning within reinforcement learning frameworks for brushstroke generation. A4 system, which uses AI to facilitate art authoring, is demonstrated through experiments to learn artists’ styles and render images with consistently smooth brushstrokes [2]. An algorithm for natural media painting based on reinforcement learning is presented. An objective was encoded through observations, and a reference image was reproduced using brushstrokes. This formulation of reinforcement learning takes into account the sparse distribution of rewards in the action space and the difficulty of training a reinforcement learning algorithm from scratch. The authors developed a method for converting negative samples into positive ones and changing reward distributions through a combination of reinforcement learning and self-supervised learning. Furthermore, the authors demonstrated the benefits of painting agents for reproducing brushstrokes from reference images. The approach uses a reinforcement loop with self-supervised learning and reinforcement learning. Modified rollout data was fed into the reinforcement learning framework using previously trained policy networks. In this work, the results of the proposed work have been compared with those of the self-supervised learning model and with those of the reinforcement learning model that has been trained from scratch. The results show that the proposed combination of reinforcement learning and self-supervised sampling can significantly enhance the efficiency of sampling [27].Among the major limitations of our approach is that we are highly dependent on the training data to generalize the trained policy. More specifically, the distribution of generated supervision data differs greatly from the distribution of unseen data. Our method is also limited in that it does not produce sharp results, especially when used on images with high contrast. There is still a need to define reward or loss in the problem, so we can either increase the total number of strokes or improve the resolution of the reference images. We intend to expand the runtime steps and action space of the painting environment so that the data generated can more closely reflect the distribution of the unseen data in future work. To reduce the dimensions of the data, the proposed SFBO comprises stages of data preprocessing and feature extraction. The proposed technique was evaluated against the existing techniques in terms of accuracy, information loss, average MSE, and time consumption. Compared to the existing approaches, the proposed approach was the most effective.


## 4.1. Accuracy

The percentage of pixels inside the picture that were properly identified may be used as an additional statistic for evaluating segmentation. Including for individual classes, the pixel accuracy is often typically stated as a whole throughout all categories.


## 4.2. Rate of Information Loss

Information loss is also used to signify inability to retrieve all information accessible in statistical research regarding a specific theme.


## 4.3. Time Consumption

The total time that people spent using a particular volume of work is referred to as time consumption.


## 4.4. Average Mean Squared Error (MSE)

MSE is a metric that indicates how near a fitted line is to the sample points. Average value of MSE is referred to as average MSE.Here, both the current and presented techniques are examined in terms of performance metrics like accuracy, time consumption, average MSE, and rate of information loss. Figure4 indicates the comparative analysis of accuracy in the current and presented approaches. In this figure, the x-axis indicates the approaches and the y-axis indicates the accuracy. Similarly, the rate of information loss of the existing and proposed approaches is depicted in Figure 5. The time consumption of the existing and proposed approaches is depicted in Figure 6. The average MSE of the existing and proposed approaches is depicted in Figure 7. Figures 4–7 indicate that the SFBO model has outperformed the other models with maximum values of accuracy, reduced rate of information loss, average MSE, and reduced time consumption. The SFBO model has demonstrated high accuracy of 85% whereas the multi-agent IRL, SMIRL, MCE-IRI, and variational IRL models have obtained lower accuracy of 78%, 70%, 60%, and 47%, respectively.Figure 4
Comparative analysis of accuracy in current and presented approaches.Figure 5
Comparative analysis of rate of information loss in current and presented approaches.Figure 6
Comparative analysis of time consumption in current and presented approaches.Figure 7
Comparative analysis of average MSE in current and presented approaches.Three-dimensional (3D) virtual worlds and social networks have transitioned into a new norm known as the metaverse. Utilizing a number of pertinent technologies, the metaverse aims to provide users with immersive 3D experiences. Although the metaverse enjoys great attention and benefits, securing data and content is a natural concern for users. Blockchain presents a promising solution because of its decentralized, immutable, and transparent characteristics. An extensive survey of blockchain applications for the metaverse was provided by Gadekallu et al. to better understand the role of blockchain in the metaverse. The authors presented an overview of blockchain technology and the metaverse and explored the motivations for the use of blockchain in the metaverse. Further, they discussed blockchain-based metaverse strategies from a technical standpoint, including data collection, storage, sharing, interoperability, and privacy protection. The results of this study demonstrated promising directions for the use of blockchain technology in the future metaverse, resulting in further innovations and developments [22]. The current approaches have certain limitations. In [23], for basic tasks, the multi-agent IRL approach should not be the best option. In [2], the healthier performance measurements are not taken into account regarding the SMIRL approach. Despite the fact that the policy taught through adversarial IRL operates well, [25] shows that training a policy using the incentive system fails in the majority of beginning situations. In [26], the reward and policy are not considered in the various professional expressions. We think most cross-domain connections are complicated and should be described as many-to-many. With these problems in mind, we have developed the SFBO for IRL enhancement.Modern graphic software, such as GIMP, Photoshop, and Painter, uses brushstroke drawing among many traditional art forms. A4 is an AI-assisted system of nonphotorealistic rendering developed by Xie et al. It lets users automatically produce paintings in the style of a specific artist. The authors aimed to learn artists’ drawing styles from video-recorded stroke data by inverse reinforcement learning within reinforcement learning frameworks for brushstroke generation. A4 system, which uses AI to facilitate art authoring, is demonstrated through experiments to learn artists’ styles and render images with consistently smooth brushstrokes [2]. An algorithm for natural media painting based on reinforcement learning is presented. An objective was encoded through observations, and a reference image was reproduced using brushstrokes. This formulation of reinforcement learning takes into account the sparse distribution of rewards in the action space and the difficulty of training a reinforcement learning algorithm from scratch. The authors developed a method for converting negative samples into positive ones and changing reward distributions through a combination of reinforcement learning and self-supervised learning. Furthermore, the authors demonstrated the benefits of painting agents for reproducing brushstrokes from reference images. The approach uses a reinforcement loop with self-supervised learning and reinforcement learning. Modified rollout data was fed into the reinforcement learning framework using previously trained policy networks. In this work, the results of the proposed work have been compared with those of the self-supervised learning model and with those of the reinforcement learning model that has been trained from scratch. The results show that the proposed combination of reinforcement learning and self-supervised sampling can significantly enhance the efficiency of sampling [27].Among the major limitations of our approach is that we are highly dependent on the training data to generalize the trained policy. More specifically, the distribution of generated supervision data differs greatly from the distribution of unseen data. Our method is also limited in that it does not produce sharp results, especially when used on images with high contrast. There is still a need to define reward or loss in the problem, so we can either increase the total number of strokes or improve the resolution of the reference images. We intend to expand the runtime steps and action space of the painting environment so that the data generated can more closely reflect the distribution of the unseen data in future work. To reduce the dimensions of the data, the proposed SFBO comprises stages of data preprocessing and feature extraction. The proposed technique was evaluated against the existing techniques in terms of accuracy, information loss, average MSE, and time consumption. Compared to the existing approaches, the proposed approach was the most effective.


## 5. Conclusion

Oil painting style brushstroke artwork is a common style in modern graphics applications. RL approaches can be quite useful in ambiguous decision-making circumstances. Today’s RL approaches must include a reward function, which embodies the designer’s intent. To reduce the dimensions of the data, the proposed SFBO comprises stages of data preprocessing and feature extraction. The proposed technique was evaluated against the existing techniques in terms of accuracy, information loss, average MSE, and time consumption. Compared to the existing approaches, the proposed approach was the most effective. This article presents a novel SFBO approach for improving scalability of the IRL for oil painting brushstrokes. TCPs and OPs were used as datasets in this investigation and preprocessed with a median filter and contrast enhancement approach to normalize the raw datasets. The GFB was employed to extract features from the normalized data. The proposed approach was employed for the improvement of IRL. Additionally, the proposed technique was compared to existing techniques for accuracy, information loss, average MSE, and time consumption. The proposed approach achieved the greatest degree of effectiveness compared to existing approaches [21, 24].



---

*Source: 2996960-2022-06-18.xml*