# Isolation Improvement of a Microstrip Patch Array Antenna for WCDMA Indoor Repeater Applications

Authors: Hongmin Lee; Jinwon Park
Journal: International Journal of Antennas and Propagation
 (2012)

---

## Abstract

This paper presents the isolation improvement techniques of a microstrip patch array antenna for the indoor wideband code division multiple access (WCDMA) repeater applications. One approach is to construct the single-feed switchable feed network structure with an MS/NRI coupled-line coupler in order to reduce the mutual coupling level between antennas. Another approach is to insert the soft surface unit cells near the edges of the microstrip patch elements in order to reduce backward radiation waves. In order to further improve the isolation level, the server antenna and donor antenna are installedinorthogonal direction. The fabricated antenna exhibits a gain over 7 dBi and higher isolation level between server and donor antennas below −70 dB at WCDMA band.


---

## Body

## 1. Introduction

Microstrip patch antennas are used in modern communication systems due to their low cost, lightweight, and planar structure. However, a microstrip patch antenna has some disadvantages.In the design of a microstrip patch array antenna, the radiating patch elements have to be placed in close proximity. It produces significant mutual coupling effect that deteriorates the antenna performance. The simplest solution to improve the antenna isolation is to increase the physical separation between the antennas. Although the isolation of the antennas becomes higher as the separation length is increased, the size of the antenna will subsequently be larger. However, the size of the antenna ground plane is limited in the practical microstrip patch antenna design. Particularly when the patch antenna is printed on high dielectric substrates, its radiation pattern is considerably affected by surface waves. On a finite ground plane, surface waves propagate until they reach an edge where they are reflected back and diffracted by the edges. These cause a significant amount of wasted power in the backward hemisphere below the ground plane. Various solutions for the improvement of the radiation performance of patch antennas on a substrate are available. One approach is to construct a periodic structure, such as photonic bandgap (PBG) or electromagnetic bandgap (EBG) [1, 2], surrounding the patch antenna. Another approach is to use the concept of artificial soft and hard surfaces [3]. These surfaces have led to a wide range of applications in antennas other microwave systems [4]. Both EBG and soft surfaces can be used to suppress surface wave propagation. The main difference is that soft surfaces exhibit bandgaps in only one direction, but they offer the best performance in most applications of antennas. However, the conventional soft surfaces are made on the same ground plane of a patch antenna and the presence of via near the patch may raise the resonant frequency of the patch if the soft surface strip or cell is very close to the patch. On the other hand, it requires a considerable area to form a bandgap structure.The purpose of this paper is to present a new method for enhancing an isolation of a microstrip patch array antenna, whose Tx/Rx band is located very near. In order to reduce the mutual coupling between antennas that are located in the same plane, a passive switching feed network is used [5]. A new isolated soft surfaces structure that does not share the ground plane of a patch is also used for the reduction of the surface wave. The proposed new soft surface consists of a number of metal mushroom-type structures that is located near the edges of substrate, and it is not connected with a ground plane [6, 7]. A two-by-two microstrip patch array antenna for the indoor wideband code division multiple access(WCDMA) repeater applications is designed and tested experimentally.


## 2. Switchable Feed Network for Antenna

The schematic of a single-feed switchable feed network is shown in Figure1. It basically consists of two quarter-wavelength branch lines with characteristic impedances of Z1 and Z2 lengths of l1 and l2. Two different rectangular microstrip patch antennas of different sizes are connected to output ports 2 and 3. The resonant frequencies of these two antennas are f1 and f2, and the input impedances of each antenna are ZL1 and ZL2. Lengths of l1 and l2 are chosen as a quarter wavelength of λ1/4 and λ2/4, respectively. When a signal with a frequency of f=f1 is applied to port 1, the input impedance of the upper branch Zin1 is(1)Zin1=Z12ZL1.
If the resonant frequencies of two patches are very closely located (f1≈f2), the two quarter wavelength branch line lengths become similar (l1≈l2). Since the patch antenna connected to port 3 is off-resonant, the input impedance of the antenna is almost reactive (ZL2≈jX). Hence, the input impedance of the lower branch Zin is
(2)Zin2=Z2ZL2+jZ2tan⁡β2l2Z2+jZL2tan⁡β2l2≈-jZ22x.
When the patch antenna was off-resonant, its input reactance neared zero (x→0). Using x→0 in (2), the input impedance of port 2 neared infinity (Zin2→∞). Therefore, it acts as an open circuit. As a result, the patch at port 2 would be at resonance with the patch at the off-resonant port 3. If a signal with a frequency of f=f2 is applied to port 1, the patch at port 3 will be at resonance with the off-resonant patch at port 2. This single-feed switchable feed network combines two ports of a microstrip antenna with a quarter wavelength feed line and each resonant frequency of the antennas very closely located; it acts as an ideal single-pole double-throw (SPDT) switch. The operation of the single-feed switchable feed network when Z1=Z2=ZL1=ZL2=50 ohm is presented in Table 1. In order to further enhance the isolation between the ports, microstrip/negative-refractive-index (MS/NRI) coupled line coupler is used with the switchable feed network. An MS/NRI coupler has advantages, compared to conventional edge-coupled microstrip couplers in terms of coupled power and port isolation [8]. Figure 2 shows the geometry of the 3 dB MS/NRI coupled-line coupler for WCDMA frequency band (1.92–2.17 GHz) applications. It consists of a conventional MS right-handed transmission line edge-coupled with a NRI transmission line used in its left-handed range. A 3 dB implementation of the MS/NRI coupled-line coupler requires the equality of the magnitude at port 2 and port 3 (|S21|=|S31|). Usually the total length of the coupler and the spacing between the lines should be adjusted until a 3 dB coupling level is acquired. A 3 dB MS/NRI coupled-line coupler is designed on a Rogers RO3210 substrate (relative dielectric constant = 10.2, thickness = 2.54 mm).Table 1
The operation of the single-feed switchable feed network.
f[GHz]PortZinZLSwitch statef=f1Port 250Ω50Ω“On”Port 3≈∞Ωjx≈0Ω“Off”f=f2Port 2≈∞Ωjx≈0Ω“Off”Port 350Ω50Ω“On”Figure 1
Schematic of a single-feed switchable feed network.Figure 2
Geometry of 3 dB MS/NRI coupled-line coupler.The NRI transmission line was 15.7 mm long and the MS-line was 11.5 mm long. The spacing between MS/NRI lines is 1 mm. Figure3 presents the simulated scattering parameter results for the MS/NRI coupled-line coupler of Figure 2. Quasi-3 dB backward coupling is achieved over the range from 1.7 to 2.7 GHz. The magnitudes of the simulated S-parameter are listed in Table 2. Figure 4 shows the geometry of the feed network for two-by-two microstrip patch array antenna. It is fed by a 50Ω coaxial probe and designed on a Rogers RO3210 substrate to allow the feeding of a four-element microstrip patch antenna array. The overall dimension of the ground plane is 120 mm × 120 mm. The aimed two switching frequencies of the proposed switchable feed network are 1.95 and 2.14 GHz, respectively.Table 2
SimulatedS-parameters for the MS/NRI coupled-line coupler.
S-parameter1.95 GHz [dB]2.14 GHz [dB]S11−12.5−13.4S21−3.3−3.6S31−3.6−3.1S41−27.5−32.5Figure 3
SimulatedS-parameter results for the MS/NRI coupled-line coupler of Figure 2.Figure 4
Geometry of the feed network for two-by-two microstrip patch array antenna.These frequencies are the center of the Tx and Rx band in the WCDMA system. In Figure4, all the ends of each port of the proposed feed network for two-by-two microstrip patch antenna are made with 50Ω microstrip lines. The characteristic impedances of an NRI transmission line and the MS line were Z1=90Ω and Z2=75Ω, respectively. In order to match these impedances with 50Ω port, a single section of quarter wavelength impedance transformer was added. The proposed feed network was designed by using switched feeder network and a signal was excited at port 1 as shown in Figure 4. When the antennas connected at port 2 and port 4 were in an on state, the antennas connected at port 3 and port 5 were in an off state. However, the proposed switchable feed network shown in Figure 1 can operate when the antennas are connected at each port.For the simulation of the port isolation, all the ends of each port were terminated with microstrip patch antennas. The simulated scattering parameters of the proposed switchable feed network compared to those of the switchable feed network with/without MS/NRI coupled-line coupler are listed in Table3. The switchable feed network with MS/NRI coupled-line coupler exhibits much higher isolation than the switchable feed network without MS/NRI coupled-line coupler. When the MS/NRI coupled-line coupler was not used, the scattering parameters (S25,S34,S52,S43) between two antennas showed lower isolation. Since the patch antennas were designed to be excited at their fundamental resonant mode (TM10), strong coupling is produced between two antennas that are placed parallel to the radiating edge direction. It can be seen that the minimum isolation levels between the output ports exceed −18 dB at the aimed two switching frequencies of the proposed switchable feed network.Table 3
SimulatedS-parameters of the feed network for a four-element microstrip patch array.
Frequency [GHz]1.942.15Port isolation [dB]S-parameterWithout MS/NRI couplerWith MS/NRI couplerWithout MS/NRI couplerWith MS/NRI couplerS23−15.18−18.81−11.18−18.78S24−14.66−24.73−12.20−17.12S25−7.03−23.25−7.8−19.57S32−15.18−19.81−11.18−23.09S34−8.50−24.01−8.04−30.99S35−16.88−26.69−10.43−18.91S42−14.66−24.73−12.20−17.10S43−8.50−24.01−8.04−30.99S45−16.31−18.26−11.67−20.54S52−7.03−23.25−7.8−19.57S53−16.88−26.69−10.43−18.92S54−16.04−18.26−11.67−20.54


## 3. Antenna Design

Figure5 shows the geometry of the two-by-two microstrip patch array antenna using the proposed switchable feed network and proximity coupled square microstrip patch elements.Figure 5
Geometry of the proposed switchable feed network for two-by-two microstrip patch array antenna.The antenna consists of three-layer structure: an air layer having a thickness of 1 mm, a dielectric substrate layer, and a stacked microstrip patch layer. The square microstrip patches are fed by microstrip lines from perpendicular directions using the proximity coupled method. This switchable feed network was designed to achieve beam pattern reconfigurable array antenna, which generates ±45° linearly polarized slanted beam patterns at the Tx/Rx frequency bands. In order to dual slant beam, two Rx and Tx microstrip patch elements were placed orthogonally. Figure6 shows the simulated surface current distribution at the resonant frequency of 1.95 GHz (Tx) and 2.15 GHz (Rx). At the frequency of 1.95 GHz, two patch antennas for Tx band are resonant, and two patch antennas for Rx-band are off-resonant. As a result, most of the surface currents flow through the feed line for Tx-band antennas. On the other hand, at the frequency of 2.15 GHz, two patch antennas for Rx band are resonant. The perspective view of a microstrip patch array antenna system for the indoor WCDMA repeater is shown in Figure 7. The proposed repeater antenna consists of a server antenna, a donor antenna, and alumina housing. It occupies a volume of 180 mm × 180 mm × 20 mm. In order to reduce the surface waves radiation from a server antenna and a donor antenna, corner-edged via mushroom-type unit cells are formed near the edges of the upper dielectric substrate. Figure 8 shows the parallel plate waveguide model with different sizes of unit cells and the results of the simulated transmission characteristics as a function of frequency. As shown in Figure 8(b), the unit cell consists of two parallel rectangular plates with the same size (w=l) and a corner-edged via. The height of the via is 1.27 mm. Inside two rectangular plates, dielectric material (relative dielectric constant = 10.2, thickness = 1.27 mm) is placed. The transmission coefficient S21 of the parallel plate waveguide ports without cell exhibits near −43 dB, as shown in Figure 8(c). When the unit cell is inserted between two parallel plate waveguides, a stop band occurs at a certain frequency.Simulated surface current distributions.
(a)
1.95 GHz(b)
2.15 GHzGeometry of the proposed indoor WCDMA repeater antenna.
(a)
Perspective view(b)
Side viewParallel plate waveguide model with different sizes of unit cells.
(a)
Parallel plate waveguide model with a cell(b)
Geometry of unit cell(c)
The simulated transmission characteristics with different sizes of unit cellsIt depends on the physical size of the unit cell However, the bandwidth of each stop band shows very narrow characteristics due to the resonant nature of the unit cell and a high dielectric constant of the substrate. In order to cover the bandwidth within the WCDMA frequency band, three different sizes of unit cell array configuration structure (w=l=6.6mm,7.0mm,7.4mm) were used in this work. In addition, a server antenna and a donor antenna backed by the alumina housings are arranged in orthogonal direction in order to get higher isolation between two antennas.


## 4. Experimental Result

The photographs of the fabricated two-by-two microstrip patch array antenna structure are shown in Figure9. The switchable feeder layer and a stacked microstrip patch layer are etched on a Rogers RO3210 substrate (relative dielectric constant = 10.2) having different thickness of 2.54 mm and 1.27 mm, respectively. The characteristic impedance of each of the two branch feed lines from the coaxial probe was 100Ω and the input impedance of each of the patch elements with a proximity coupled microstrip feed is 50Ω. A comparison of the measured return loss (S11) and isolation (S21) between a server antenna and a donor antenna with/without isolated soft surface unit cells is shown in Figure 10. It is noted that the resonant frequencies are barely changed.Photographs of the fabricated two-by-two microstrip patch array antenna.
(a)
Top view(b)
Switchable feed network(c)
Ground plane(d)
Antenna with housingFigure 10
Measured return loss and isolation characteristics of two-by-two microstrip patch array antenna.In the higher and lower bands, the measured −10 dB return loss bandwidths are about 84 MHz and 96 MHz, respectively. It meets the bandwidth requirement for WCDMA (1.92–2.17 GHz) applications. Compared to the fabricated antenna without isolated soft surface unit cells, the fabricated antenna with isolated soft surface unit cells exhibits higher isolation level. When the isolated soft surface unit cells are used, the maximum isolation level at the frequency of 1.94 and 2.15 GHz is −92 dB and −70 dB, respectively. The measured far-field radiation patterns in thex-y plane (θ=0°) and y-z plane (ϕ=0°) at the frequency of 1.94 and 2.15 GHz are shown, respectively, in Figure 11. It shows linear polarized radiation patterns, and the main direction of the radiated power was changed due to the placement of two patches. The main beam direction was slanted about −45° for the lower band (Tx) and +45° for the higher band (Rx). The measured peak gain/radiation efficiency for Tx/Rx band was 7.1 dBi/77% and 8.9 dBi/80%, respectively.Measured far-field radiation patterns of the fabricated antenna.
(a)
x-y plane (1.94 GHz)(b)
y-z plane (1.94 GHz)(c)
x-y plane (2.15 GHz)(d)
y-z plane (2.15 GHz)


## 5. Conclusion

The new techniques for the isolation improvement of a microstrip patch array antenna have been presented. The two main techniques presented here are (1) the single-feed switchable feed network structure with MS/NRI coupled-line coupler for higher isolation level and (2) the isolated soft surface unit cells structure for reducing the surface waves. Both structures have been discussed in the paper through proper numerical simulation. In order to improve the isolation further, the server antenna and donor antenna for an indoor repeater system were placed orthogonally. As a result, the fabricated server and donor antennas have small separation of 20 mm and exhibit higher isolation level. Experimental results shows that the maximum isolation level at the frequency of 1.94 and 2.15 GHz is −92 dB and −70 dB, respectively. The proposed techniques can be easily used for the design of the microstrip patch array antenna with higher isolation level.



---

*Source: 264618-2012-02-16.xml*