# Occurrence and Assessment of Chemical Contaminants in Drinking Water in Tunceli, Turkey

Authors: Veysel Demir; Sezai Ergin
Journal: Journal of Chemistry
 (2013)

---

## Abstract

The objective of this study was to analyze drinking water samples from 21 sites in the city center and seven municipalities of Tunceli, Turkey, in order to determine the presence of nitrate, nitrite, fluoride, bromate, pesticides, polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs), trihalomethanes (THMs), and some other chemicals. In all locations, the concentrations of chemicals investigated were below the permissible limits set by local and international organizations for drinking water. Low levels of nitrate (4.79 ± 4.20 mg/L), fluoride (0.11 ± 0.08 mg/L), and THMs (6.63 ± 5.14μg/L) were detected in all locations. A low level of tetra, chloroethane, which is suspected to be a human carcinogen, was also detected in 8 locations in the range of 0.26–0.43 μg/L. These contaminants may pose adverse health effects or minimum hazard due to long-term exposure. In all locations, bromate, benzene, total PAH, 1-2 dichloroethane, vinyl chloride, acrylamide, and epichloridine levels in drinking water samples were under detection limits.


---

## Body

## 1. Introduction

Wastewater discharges, agricultural runoff, uncontrolled discharges or leakage from industrial plants or landfill sites, and chemical accidents and disasters can contaminate ground and surface water [1, 2]. These contaminations become an increasing problem for drinking water supplies [3]. The possible long-term effects of chronic exposure to substances present in drinking water, even at low concentrations, are one of the major concerns over water quality and public health [4, 5]. Lifetime exposure to chemicals such as pesticides, polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs), trihalomethanes (THMs), and trace elements in drinking water through ingestion, inhalation, and dermal contact (i.e., showering and bathing) may pose risks to human health [6]. Contaminated water can cause serious diseases, such as reproductive, cardiovascular, and neurological diseases or various cancers [6, 7].There are international and national regulations to control the quality of drinking water. Some chemical parameters including nitrate, nitrite, fluoride, undesirable organic compounds (benzene and PAHs), pesticides and pesticide residues, bromate, and THMs with specified upper limits are strictly controlled for drinking water. Nitrate is one of the most common inorganic contaminants detected in drinking water throughout the world. A high nitrate concentration in drinking water can cause methemoglobinemia in infants and in the stomachs of adults [8, 9]. Also, a high level of nitrate in drinking water is recognized as a risk factor for thyroid dysfunction in vulnerable population groups [10]. Nitrate can be reduced to nitrite, resulting in the formation of nitrosamines, which are known to be carcinogenic [11]. The World Health Organization (WHO) [12] and the Turkish Standard Institute (TSI) [13] have set the standard nitrate level in drinking water to 50 mg NO3−/L, while the US Environmental Protection Agency’s (EPA) standard is 10 mg N/L [14]. Fluoride is a necessary element for human health, and a moderate amount of fluoride intake is an effective way of reducing caries among children and adults. However, excessive fluoride intake through drinking water or food results in dental and skeletal fluorosis; furthermore, nonskeletal phase damage such as parathyroid, kidney, and liver is observed [15]. Fluorine is highly reactive and is found naturally as CaF2. It is an essential component of minerals like topaz, fluorite, fluorapatite, cryolite, phosphorite, theorapatite, and so forth. [16]. Though drinking water is the major contributor (75–90% of daily intake), other sources of fluoride poisoning are food, industrial exposure, drugs, cosmetics, and so forth [17]. The TSI [13] and EPA have set the standard fluoride level in drinking water at 1.5 mg/L, and the WHO’s safe limit is 1.0 mg/L [18].Throughout the world, pesticides including insecticides, fungicides, and herbicides, and others are used for vector control and agricultural purposes. Because of their widespread consumption, pesticides and their degradation products spread throughout the environment and contaminate the soil, water, and air [19]. Chemical classes of pesticides include organochlorine compounds, carbamates, organophosphates, and chlorophenoxy compounds. Many pesticides are persistent and bioaccumulative in the environment. Severe disorders in the reproductive, nervous, and immune systems and some chronic diseases including cancer can occur if the human body has extended exposure to pesticides [20]. Pesticides can leach into surface and ground waters; therefore, they are likely to be found in drinking water. Because of their widespread use and acute, long-term toxicity to humans, several agencies have derived drinking water guidelines for some pesticides [21]. The European Union (EU) established a list of 33 priority substances to be controlled in water through Directive no. 2008/105EC in 2008, with a third of the list being pesticides [22, 23].PAHs occur widely in the environment, and they are very slow to degrade due to the high stability and complexity of the PAHs’ molecular structure [24]. The water sources were polluted by many types of PAHs through anthropogenic and natural inputs or biological conversion of fossil fuel products. The presence of PAHs in drinking water threatens human health in the form of mutagenic, carcinogenic, and toxicological effects [25]. Therefore, many of these compounds are listed as priority pollutants by the EPA and the EU [26]. Concentrations of PAHs exceeding 10 μg/L suggested that the water was heavily contaminated [27]. The EU’s and WHO’s guidelines recommended that the total concentration of six specified PAHs should not exceed 200 ng−1 for domestic drinking water [28].During water treatment, chloride is the most widely used, cost-effective technique for disinfecting drinking water in order to protect the public from waterborne diseases and to control or prevent the regrowth of microorganisms and biofilm formation in the distribution system [29]. Nevertheless, chloride is a relatively unstable chemical, and available chlorine reacts with natural organic matters and inorganic substances in water, causing the formation of various chlorination byproducts such as THMs [30]. The frequently formed THM compounds are chloroform (trichloromethane, TCM), bromodichloromethane (BDCM), dibromochloromethane (DBCM), and bromoform (tribromomethane, TBM) [31]. These THM species and other chlorinated substances, such as 1,2-di/tri/tetra/chloroethane, are considered to be toxic, accumulative, and persistent in the environment and probable carcinogens for human health in several epidemiological studies [32, 33]. Different countries set limits for THM and other chlorinated substances in drinking water. The limits set are 40 μg/L for chloroform, 15 μg/L for bromodichloromethane, 10 μg/L for trichloroethane and tetrachloroethane, 3 μg/L for 1,2-dichloroethane, and 100 μg/L for total THMs [31, 34].Some other chemical pollutants that are also monitored in drinking water according to EU Directive 98/93 on drinking water have the following guideline values: benzene (1.0μg/L), which is widely used in products containing plastics, rubber, resins, and synthetic fabrics like nylon and polyester; epichlorohydrin (0.1 μg/L), which is used for making glycerine, plastics, and other polymers, some of which are used as coagulant aids in water treatment; vinyl chloride (0.5 μg/L), which is used in polyvinyl chloride piping in drinking water distribution systems [35]; and acrylamide, which is used in acrylamide based polymeric coagulant aids used in water treatment (0.1 μg/L)—all of which are suspected to be human carcinogens [3]. The EPA’s maximum contamination level goals in drinking water for benzene, vinyl chloride, epichlorohydrin, and acrylamide are zero [14].In Turkey, there is a national monitoring program for determining the pollutants in drinking water sources and implementing remediation recommendations based on these results. The health directorate of each city monitors drinking water quality in its area. But there are limited number of studies evaluating the results of these monitoring programs, and some results stay in the database of the local authorities without further evaluation. This study was undertaken with the Health Directorate of Tunceli in order to assess the concentration of some chemicals in drinking water samples taken from 21 different locations in the city and towns of Tunceli, Turkey. During the investigation, the contents of nitrate, nitrite, fluoride, bromate, benzene, total PAH, total pesticide, total THMs, 1,2-di/tri/tetra/chloroethane, vinyl chloride, acrylamide, and epichloridine concentrations were analyzed to determine water quality in these locations. This study will further clarify the importance of monitoring these parameters during evaluation of water quality in the city of Tunceli and benefit monitoring authorities and the city during implementation of water treatment applications in the studied areas.


## 2. Materials and Methods

### 2.1. Study Site

The city of Tunceli is located in eastern Turkey. The local terrain delimits the region and sets it apart from the surrounding area. There is no heavy industrial or agricultural activity in this region; the city center and seven municipalities of Tunceli depend on agriculture, husbandry, apiculture, and tourism. Water sources are abundant in the area due to rain and heavy snowfall in the mountains, which seeps into the ground or flows into the rivers. Most of the public waterworks consist simply of water sources, a chlorination unit, and a transport pipe. The quality of the drinking water, especially microbial contamination [36] in the rural areas of Tunceli, cannot be ensured in some cases. In this study, water samples were collected in 21 different locations in the city center and seven municipalities of Tunceli during 2011. The sampling sites were illustrated in Figure 1.Figure 1
Locations of sampling sites.


### 2.2. Sampling

Drinking water samples were collected by the Health Directorate of Tunceli from residential drinking water according to correct sampling techniques in order to analyze their chemical contents. Five liters of each water sample was taken in polyethylene plastic containers that had been previously washed with concentrated nitric acid. All samples were transported in cooled containers to the laboratory of the Health Directorate of Erzurum and were refrigerated at 4°C until analysis, which was carried out within 48 hours of sampling.


### 2.3. Analysis

Drinking water samples were analyzed in the laboratory of the Health Directorate of Erzurum. For nitrate, nitrite, fluorite, and bromate, the Dionex ICS-5000 Ion Chromatography System with the EPA Method 300.1 was used. For pesticides including organophosphates and chlorophenoxy compounds, gas chromatography (Perkin Elmer/Clarus 500) with the EPA Methods 8141A was used. For pesticides including organochlorine compounds, gas chromatography (Agilent GC-7890A) with EPA Methods 8081B and for acrylamide and pesticides including carbamates triple quadrupole liquid chromatograph mass spectrometer (Shimadzu LC-MS-MS/8030) with EPA Methods 8361A and 531.1, respectively, were used.The levels of total PAHs including benzo[b]fluoranthene, benzo[k]fluoranthene, benzo[g,h,i]perylene, indeno[1,2,3-cd]pyrene, and benzo[a]pyrene were analyzed using high performance liquid chromatography (Thermo TSP, HPLC) with the EPA Method 550.1. THMs, benzene, 1,2-di/tri/tetra/chloroethane, and other chemical pollutants (epichloridine, vinyl chloride, and tetrachloroethane) in drinking water samples were measured by purge and trap GC/MS system including Agilent 7820A GC, Agilent 5975 MS system, and The Eclipse 4660 Purge-and-Trap Sample Concentrator using the EPA Method 524.2 and TS 9266 EN ISO 10301.


## 2.1. Study Site

The city of Tunceli is located in eastern Turkey. The local terrain delimits the region and sets it apart from the surrounding area. There is no heavy industrial or agricultural activity in this region; the city center and seven municipalities of Tunceli depend on agriculture, husbandry, apiculture, and tourism. Water sources are abundant in the area due to rain and heavy snowfall in the mountains, which seeps into the ground or flows into the rivers. Most of the public waterworks consist simply of water sources, a chlorination unit, and a transport pipe. The quality of the drinking water, especially microbial contamination [36] in the rural areas of Tunceli, cannot be ensured in some cases. In this study, water samples were collected in 21 different locations in the city center and seven municipalities of Tunceli during 2011. The sampling sites were illustrated in Figure 1.Figure 1
Locations of sampling sites.


## 2.2. Sampling

Drinking water samples were collected by the Health Directorate of Tunceli from residential drinking water according to correct sampling techniques in order to analyze their chemical contents. Five liters of each water sample was taken in polyethylene plastic containers that had been previously washed with concentrated nitric acid. All samples were transported in cooled containers to the laboratory of the Health Directorate of Erzurum and were refrigerated at 4°C until analysis, which was carried out within 48 hours of sampling.


## 2.3. Analysis

Drinking water samples were analyzed in the laboratory of the Health Directorate of Erzurum. For nitrate, nitrite, fluorite, and bromate, the Dionex ICS-5000 Ion Chromatography System with the EPA Method 300.1 was used. For pesticides including organophosphates and chlorophenoxy compounds, gas chromatography (Perkin Elmer/Clarus 500) with the EPA Methods 8141A was used. For pesticides including organochlorine compounds, gas chromatography (Agilent GC-7890A) with EPA Methods 8081B and for acrylamide and pesticides including carbamates triple quadrupole liquid chromatograph mass spectrometer (Shimadzu LC-MS-MS/8030) with EPA Methods 8361A and 531.1, respectively, were used.The levels of total PAHs including benzo[b]fluoranthene, benzo[k]fluoranthene, benzo[g,h,i]perylene, indeno[1,2,3-cd]pyrene, and benzo[a]pyrene were analyzed using high performance liquid chromatography (Thermo TSP, HPLC) with the EPA Method 550.1. THMs, benzene, 1,2-di/tri/tetra/chloroethane, and other chemical pollutants (epichloridine, vinyl chloride, and tetrachloroethane) in drinking water samples were measured by purge and trap GC/MS system including Agilent 7820A GC, Agilent 5975 MS system, and The Eclipse 4660 Purge-and-Trap Sample Concentrator using the EPA Method 524.2 and TS 9266 EN ISO 10301.


## 3. Results and Discussion

The water demand in Tunceli is supplied mostly by groundwater. Abundant groundwater supplies are the most cost-effective and viable means for fulfilling the needs of the present population. There is no municipal water treatment plant for drinking water; for each location, groundwater is collected in a storage tank and disinfected by chlorination. In recent years, the city substituted most of the old sewer mains, especially old asbestos-cement pipes, with new PVC pipes. In the seven municipalities of Tunceli, the majority of people drink tap water, but in the city center, the ratio of people drinking bottled water increases with the education and income level.  City wastewater was discharged at 9 different points into Uzuncayir Dam Lake without any treatment processes. Boztug et al. (2012) [37] investigated the water quality of this lake by identifying the water’s physicchemical characteristics, and they concluded that Uzuncayir Dam Lake has good water quality and no serious pollution problem. In 2013, Tunceli’s first wastewater treatment facility for the city center was put into test operations. But the other seven municipalities of Tunceli do not have any wastewater treatment facilities, and they discharge wastewater directly into rivers or lakes.Concentrations of the studied chemicals in the drinking water sampling locations of the city center and municipalities of Tunceli, Turkey, were summarized in Table1. The mean of fluoride concentration in all water sampling sites was calculated as 0.11±0.08 mg/L. In the present study, all samples were below the permissible limit (1.5 mg/L) set by the TSI [13] in fluoride concentration. The highest level of fluoride was observed in the city center of Mazgirt at 0.28 mg/L. Considering that water is the major source of fluoride intake in humans, the recommended minimum value of fluoride in drinking water associated with the maximum level of dental caries protection and the minimum level of dental fluorosis is considered to be approximately 0.5 ppm [12, 38], and concentrations of fluoride lower than 0.5 mg/L have shown to intensify the risk of tooth decay [39]. Additionally, an extremely low level of fluoride (<0.28 mg/L) in drinking water which may cause fluoride deficiency among the inhabitants of these locations was observed in most sampling locations. Water fluoridation which is the controlled addition of fluoride to a public water supply could be advised to local authorities for preventing tooth decay.Table 1
Concentrations of the studied chemicals in the drinking water sampling locations of the city center and municipalities of Tunceli, Turkey.
No.
Locations
Municipalities
Nitrate (mg/L)
Fluoride (mg/L)
T. pesticides(μg/L)
THMs* (μg/L)
Chloroform(μg/L)
TCE** (μg/L)
1
Burmageçit
Merkez***
3.48
0.07
UDL****
3.30
3.30
UDL
2
Cumhuriyet
Merkez
4.70
0.04
UDL
5.07
5.07
0.26
3
Esentepe
Merkez
1.39
0.13
UDL
9.92
9.92
UDL
4
Kanoglu
Merkez
2.21
0.16
UDL
5.04
3.99
UDL
5
Kopuzlar
Merkez
1.65
0.10
UDL
2.34
2.34
0.30
6
Akçapinar
Çemisgezek
8.26
0.13
UDL
7.23
7.23
UDL
7
Payamdüzü
Çemisgezek
1.78
0.02
UDL
4.13
4.13
UDL
8
Tepebasi
Çemisgezek
13.11
0.26
0.027
4.09
4.09
UDL
9
Devriscemal
Hozat
1.46
0.01
UDL
13.40
11.58
UDL
10
Yenidogdu
Hozat
2.74
0.07
0.042
2.95
2.95
UDL
11
Akpazar
Mazgirt
16.22
0.16
UDL
10.05
10.05
0.37
12
Bulgurcular
Mazgirt
4.22
0.08
UDL
3.01
3.01
0.34
13
Center
Mazgirt
9.30
0.28
UDL
19.30
12.53
UDL
14
Darikent
Mazgirt
2.74
0.22
0.015
UDL
4.55
0.43
15
Center
Nazimiye
2.92
0.02
UDL
3.17
3.17
UDL
16
Çakmakli
Ovacik
0.28
0.11
UDL
12.99
12.99
UDL
17
Pasadüzü
Ovacik
8.25
0.15
UDL
6.35
6.35
0.37
18
Pulur
Ovacik
2.04
0.01
UDL
4.94
2.70
UDL
19
Camikebir
Pertek
6.06
0.04
UDL
16.46
5.61
0.30
20
Sogukpinar
Pertek
6.62
0.11
UDL
3.16
3.16
0.37
21
Center
Pülümür
1.11
0.04
UDL
2.42
2.42
UDL
*Trihalomethanes.
*
*Tetrachloroethane.
*
*
*City center.
*
*
*
*Under detection limit.Nitrate and nitrite are important indicators of water pollution. In Tunceli, the main sources of nitrogen are domestic and animal wastes and nitrogen-rich fertilizers. Nitrate levels ranged from a minimum of 0.28 mg/L in Ovacik, Cakmakli, to a maximum of 16.22 mg/L in Mazgirt, Akpazar. Nitrite values were detected ≤0.08 mg/L in all locations. These values are lower than 50 mg/L of nitrate and 3 mg/L of nitrite, the acceptable values according to the TSI’s [13] and WHO’s [12] standards for drinking water quality in public water systems. The mean of nitrate concentration in all water sampling sites (4.79±4.20 mg/L) and nitrite values (≤0.08 mg/L) were measured in all sampling sites. Many studies also investigated national nitrate and nitrite levels in drinking water. Similar unpolluted groundwater in Finland with simple treatment in the water plant is used as drinking water, and its nitrate range (0.05–1.19 mg/L) is much lower than the values in this study. Finnish drinking water’s nitrite level was below the detection limit of 0.01 mg/L [40]. Therefore, even a simple treatment in the water plant can increase water quality in Tunceli. Cidu et al. (2011) [41] studied drinking water quality in Italy and determined that Italian tap water’s nitrate level ranged from <0.1 to 11 mg/L. In Italy, a limit of 10 mg/L NO3− has been recommended for the water destined to infants [41, 42]. Some drinking water samples in our study showed NO3− higher than 10 mg/L (Table 1), which may pose adverse health effects due to long-term exposure, especially in the infants of these locations.The prescribed limit set by the TSI [13] for THMs in drinking water is 150 μg/L. The mean concentration of total THMs (6.63±5.14 μg/L) in all water sampling sites mainly includes chloroform, which is the most commonly occurring THM in drinking water, and very small amounts of bromoform, dibromochloromethane, and bromodichloromethane, all of which were measured in these 21 locations. These values are below the prescribed limits of domestic [13] and international guidelines [12] for specified contamination levels of drinking water, and the results did not show an indication of pollution hazards, given the toxicity of these chemicals. Maximum concentrations were determined in Mazgirt-Merkez, Pertek-Camikebir, Hozat-Derviscemal, and Ovacık-Cakmakli as 19.3, 16.5, 13.4, and 13.0 μg/L, respectively. The concentrations of THMs found in Tunceli tap water were much less than the concentration reported for other Turkish cities such as Ankara, Izmir, and Cankırı [6, 43, 44].Pesticide contamination in drinking water samples from Tunceli was assessed also. Total pesticides in 18 locations were below the detection limit, and in 3 locations, low concentrations of total pesticides were detected in the range of 0.015–0.042μg/L. In one location, the organochlorine pesticide dieldrin, which was banned in the US in the 1980s, was detected in a low concentration of 0.015 μg/L. Also, the organochlorine insecticide alpha endosulfan, which was banned in several countries due to its acute toxicity and endocrine effects, was detected in one location with a low concentration of 0.027 μg/L. The EU sets standards for pesticides in drinking water at 0.1 μg/L for each active ingredient and 0.5 μg/L for the sum of all pesticides [21]. Although these obtained values are quite low and below the recommended values, the presence of dieldrin and endosulfan in drinking water should be monitored regularly, since these chemicals may pose adverse health effects or minimum hazard to the inhabitants of these locations due to long-term exposure.Bromate, benzene, total polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) including benzo[a]pyrene, benzo(b) fluoranthene, benzo(k) fluoranthene, benzo[ghi]perylene, indeno[1,2,3-cd]pyrene, and other chemical pollutants such as 1,2-di/trichloroethane, epichloridine, vinyl chloride, and acrylamide also were not detected in all drinking water samples. Since there is a strong correlation between an increase in urbanization, industrialization and traffic density and high levels of PAHs in the water [24], it was expected not to detect any PAHs in these sampling stations. A low level of tetrachloroethane, which is suspected to be carcinogenic, was detected in 8 locations in the range of 0.26–0.43 μg/L; these values were also lower than permissible limits of 10 μg/L set by EU Directive 98/93 for drinking water [34].


## 4. Conclusions

This study investigated the potential contamination levels of drinking water in the regions of Tunceli, Turkey, while paying special attention to pesticides, PAHs, THMs, and some other organic and inorganic chemicals. Some of these chemicals were detected in all drinking water samples, but none of the studied parameters exceeded the WHO guideline values [12] or the Turkish [13], American [14], or European [22] standards. The study results showed that the people living in Tunceli do not bear significant health risks especially due to exposure to pesticides, PAHs, THMs, and benzene in the drinking water.



---

*Source: 238374-2013-08-26.xml*