# Mycobiota and Natural Incidence of Aflatoxins, Ochratoxin A, and Citrinin in Indian Spices Confirmed by LC-MS/MS

Authors: Punam Jeswal; Dhiraj Kumar
Journal: International Journal of Microbiology
 (2015)

---

## Abstract

Nine different Indian spices (red chilli, black pepper, turmeric, coriander, cumin, fennel, caraway, fenugreek, and dry ginger) commonly cultivated and highly used in India were analysed for natural occurrence of toxigenic mycoflora and aflatoxins (AFs), ochratoxin A (OTA), and citrinin (CTN) contamination.Aspergillus flavus and Aspergillus niger were the most dominant species isolated from all types of spices. Red chilli samples were highly contaminated with aflatoxins (85.4%) followed by dry ginger (77.7%). 56% Aspergillus flavus from red chilli and 45% Aspergillus ochraceus from black pepper were toxigenic and produced aflatoxins and ochratoxin A, respectively. Qualitative detection and quantitative detection of mycotoxins in spices were analyzed by ELISA and further confirmed by LC-MS/MS. Penicillium citrinum produced citrinin in red chilli, black pepper, coriander, cumin, fenugreek, and dry ginger samples. The highest amount of AFs was found in red chilli (219.6 ng/g), OTA was in black pepper (154.1 ng/g), and CTN was in dry ginger samples (85.1 ng/g). The results of this study suggest that the spices are susceptible substrate for growth of mycotoxigenic fungi and further mycotoxin production. This is the first report of natural occurrence of citrinin in black pepper and dry ginger from India.


---

## Body

## 1. Introduction

Spices are cultivated worldwide but India is the largest producer and exporter country in the world [1]. Red chilli, black pepper, turmeric, coriander, cumin, fennel, caraway, fenugreek, and dry ginger are common spices used in Indian cuisine. They provide aroma, color, and flavor in food and are generally used as appetizer to enhance the appetite. They are the herbs, obtained from different parts of plants and rich in antioxidant. These spices have also some medicinal properties and are used widely in ayurvedic medicine [2] and household treatments.Mycotoxins are the toxic secondary metabolites of fungi produced on wide range of consumable substrates. The most common fungal spices that produce mycotoxins belong toAspergillus,Penicillium, andFusarium genera. Some species of these genera have potential to produce different mycotoxins such as aflatoxins, ochratoxin, and citrinin. Aflatoxins are naturally occurring secondary metabolites from some species ofAspergillus and they are carcinogenic [3]. OTA and CTN are also produced by some species ofAspergillus andPenicillium. OTA is hepatotoxic and CTN is nephrotoxic and cooccurrence of these two mycotoxins causes hepatorenal carcinogenesis [4, 5].Mycotoxin contamination especially aflatoxins contamination in cereals, pulses, oil-seeds, and agricultural products is well known but fragmentary reports are available regarding mycoflora and mycotoxins contamination in spices from India and different part of the world. However these reports are mainly confined to aflatoxins and ochratoxin A contamination [6–8]. This is the first report of CTN in black pepper, cumin, fenugreek, and dry ginger from Bihar.The present study was conducted to assess the association of toxigenic mycoflora in spices and their mycotoxin producing potentiality. The natural contamination of AFs, OTA, and CTN was also examined in these spices. It has been observed that red chilli, black pepper, coriander, fenugreek, and dry ginger samples were highly susceptible to AFs, OTA, and CTN contamination.


## 2. Material and Methods

### 2.1. Sampling

Nine different Indian spices comprise (55 samples of red chilli, 42 black pepper, 35 turmeric, 30 coriander, 28 cumin, 25 fennel, 25 caraway, 35 fenugreek, and 36 dry ginger) samples. A total 311 samples of different spices were collected from local markets of rural and urban areas of different district of Bihar (state). 100 gm of each sample was kept into sterile brown envelop and stored at 4°C to arrest any mycotoxin formation before analysis.


### 2.2. Screening of Fungi

Samples were randomly placed on the freshly prepared PDA (potato dextrose agar), standard blotter paper and incubated at28±2°C for 7 days and examined daily. All plates were examined visually and by binocular stereomicroscope and counts were recorded. Fungal colonies of different morphological type were sub-cultured in culture tube containing PDA media. Identification of fungi was carried out by morphological characteristics and followed the taxonomic schemes of Maren [9] for genusAspergillus, Pitt [10] forPenicillium, Leslie and Summerell [11] forFusarium, and Crous et al. [12] for other genera.


### 2.3. Assessment of Potentiality of Toxigenic Fungi

A. flavus,A. parasiticus,A. ochraceus,A. terreus,P. citrinum, andP. verrucosum are well known toxigenic fungi to produce aflatoxins, ochratoxin A, and citrinin [13] and they were examined for their mycotoxins producing potentiality. The suspensions of isolated fungi were prepared using 0.5 McFarland standard in normal saline that each mL of saline contains 106 spores [14]. In all cases 50 μL of each suspension was inoculated in 25 mL of freshly prepared broth media (SMKY media for aflatoxins and YES media for ochratoxin A and citrinin) and incubated at 28±2°C for 10 days. When vigorous growth of fungus occurred the medium was filtered with Whatman No. 1 paper and the cultured filtrate was extracted with 10 mL of chloroform. In case of CTN, the culture filtered was acidified with 1N HCL to bring down the pH subsequently; then it was extracted with chloroform. The chloroform extract was evaporated to dryness and residue was dissolved in 1 mL of chloroform and qualitative and quantitative estimations of mycotoxins producing potentiality of fungi were done by the method of Diener and Davis [15] for aflatoxins producing potentiality ofAspergillus species. Methods of Schwenk et al. [16] and Davis et al. [17] were followed for CTN and OTA producing potentiality of mycoflora, respectively.


### 2.4. Qualitative and Quantitative Estimation of Mycotoxins by ELISA

Natural occurrence of AFs, OTA, and CTN in spices samples was analyzed by enzyme linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA). Samples were examined by AgraQuant Total Aflatoxin (COKAQ1000) for total AFs and AgraQuant Ochratoxin (COKAQ2000) for OTA from ROMER LAB (ASTRIA) and RIDASCREEN FAST citrinin Assay (6302) for CTN. For qualitative and quantitative estimation of total AFs, OTA and CTN, 20 gm of grinded sample was mixed with 100 mL of 70% methanol and further blended for 3 minutes. The solutions were filtered and the supernatant was collected. 4 mL of extract was transferred through cleanup columns; then the amount of AFs, OTA, and CTN was detected with specific ELISA kits and the optical density was recorded by the ELISA reader using a 450 nm filter with a differential filter of 630 nm. The minimum detected amount of ELISA kit was 4 ng/g for AFs, 2 ng/g for OTA, and 15 ng/g for CTN (as mentioned by the manufacturer of Kits). Standard curve was prepared with standard solution provided with ELISA kits. The optical densities of the samples were compared to the optical density of standards and interpretative results were determined.


### 2.5. Confirmation by LC-MS/MS

Positive samples were further confirmed by LC-MS/MS using Agilent Poroshell 120 EC C18,2.1×100 mm column. 10 gm of grinded sample was mixed with 40 mL of extraction solution containing Acetonitrile : Water (40 : 10, v/v) and vortex vigorously for 5 minute and further shaken gently for another 45 minutes. The solution was filtered through 0.2 μ nylon syringe filter. 2 mL of filtrate was taken and dried under fine stream of N2 gas further 1 mL of reconstitute solution of Acetonitrile : Water (10 : 40, v/v) was added to prepare sample for LC-MS/MS analysis. 0.5 μL of sample was injected into LC-MS/MS (Agilent 6410) containing the mobile phase of 0.1% formic acid in 5 mM ammonium acetate and methanol [18].


### 2.6. Statistical Analysis

All the samples were analyzed in triplicate. Percent incidence was recorded as the mean value calculated from the number of samples analyzed from triplicate plating. ANOVA test was conducted to determine the differences in mean by one-way ANOVA using SPSS version 12.0 for MS/Windows (SPSS, Inc., Chicago, IL).


## 2.1. Sampling

Nine different Indian spices comprise (55 samples of red chilli, 42 black pepper, 35 turmeric, 30 coriander, 28 cumin, 25 fennel, 25 caraway, 35 fenugreek, and 36 dry ginger) samples. A total 311 samples of different spices were collected from local markets of rural and urban areas of different district of Bihar (state). 100 gm of each sample was kept into sterile brown envelop and stored at 4°C to arrest any mycotoxin formation before analysis.


## 2.2. Screening of Fungi

Samples were randomly placed on the freshly prepared PDA (potato dextrose agar), standard blotter paper and incubated at28±2°C for 7 days and examined daily. All plates were examined visually and by binocular stereomicroscope and counts were recorded. Fungal colonies of different morphological type were sub-cultured in culture tube containing PDA media. Identification of fungi was carried out by morphological characteristics and followed the taxonomic schemes of Maren [9] for genusAspergillus, Pitt [10] forPenicillium, Leslie and Summerell [11] forFusarium, and Crous et al. [12] for other genera.


## 2.3. Assessment of Potentiality of Toxigenic Fungi

A. flavus,A. parasiticus,A. ochraceus,A. terreus,P. citrinum, andP. verrucosum are well known toxigenic fungi to produce aflatoxins, ochratoxin A, and citrinin [13] and they were examined for their mycotoxins producing potentiality. The suspensions of isolated fungi were prepared using 0.5 McFarland standard in normal saline that each mL of saline contains 106 spores [14]. In all cases 50 μL of each suspension was inoculated in 25 mL of freshly prepared broth media (SMKY media for aflatoxins and YES media for ochratoxin A and citrinin) and incubated at 28±2°C for 10 days. When vigorous growth of fungus occurred the medium was filtered with Whatman No. 1 paper and the cultured filtrate was extracted with 10 mL of chloroform. In case of CTN, the culture filtered was acidified with 1N HCL to bring down the pH subsequently; then it was extracted with chloroform. The chloroform extract was evaporated to dryness and residue was dissolved in 1 mL of chloroform and qualitative and quantitative estimations of mycotoxins producing potentiality of fungi were done by the method of Diener and Davis [15] for aflatoxins producing potentiality ofAspergillus species. Methods of Schwenk et al. [16] and Davis et al. [17] were followed for CTN and OTA producing potentiality of mycoflora, respectively.


## 2.4. Qualitative and Quantitative Estimation of Mycotoxins by ELISA

Natural occurrence of AFs, OTA, and CTN in spices samples was analyzed by enzyme linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA). Samples were examined by AgraQuant Total Aflatoxin (COKAQ1000) for total AFs and AgraQuant Ochratoxin (COKAQ2000) for OTA from ROMER LAB (ASTRIA) and RIDASCREEN FAST citrinin Assay (6302) for CTN. For qualitative and quantitative estimation of total AFs, OTA and CTN, 20 gm of grinded sample was mixed with 100 mL of 70% methanol and further blended for 3 minutes. The solutions were filtered and the supernatant was collected. 4 mL of extract was transferred through cleanup columns; then the amount of AFs, OTA, and CTN was detected with specific ELISA kits and the optical density was recorded by the ELISA reader using a 450 nm filter with a differential filter of 630 nm. The minimum detected amount of ELISA kit was 4 ng/g for AFs, 2 ng/g for OTA, and 15 ng/g for CTN (as mentioned by the manufacturer of Kits). Standard curve was prepared with standard solution provided with ELISA kits. The optical densities of the samples were compared to the optical density of standards and interpretative results were determined.


## 2.5. Confirmation by LC-MS/MS

Positive samples were further confirmed by LC-MS/MS using Agilent Poroshell 120 EC C18,2.1×100 mm column. 10 gm of grinded sample was mixed with 40 mL of extraction solution containing Acetonitrile : Water (40 : 10, v/v) and vortex vigorously for 5 minute and further shaken gently for another 45 minutes. The solution was filtered through 0.2 μ nylon syringe filter. 2 mL of filtrate was taken and dried under fine stream of N2 gas further 1 mL of reconstitute solution of Acetonitrile : Water (10 : 40, v/v) was added to prepare sample for LC-MS/MS analysis. 0.5 μL of sample was injected into LC-MS/MS (Agilent 6410) containing the mobile phase of 0.1% formic acid in 5 mM ammonium acetate and methanol [18].


## 2.6. Statistical Analysis

All the samples were analyzed in triplicate. Percent incidence was recorded as the mean value calculated from the number of samples analyzed from triplicate plating. ANOVA test was conducted to determine the differences in mean by one-way ANOVA using SPSS version 12.0 for MS/Windows (SPSS, Inc., Chicago, IL).


## 3. Result and Discussion

### 3.1. Mycobiotic Association

In our study, prevalence of mycoflora was isolated from spices; total 22 species belong to 7 different fungal genera (Table1).Aspergillus was isolated from all spice samples whereasPenicillium were confined only to red chilli, black pepper, turmeric, cumin, coriander caraway fenugreek, and dry ginger samples (Figure 1).A. flavus contamination was highest in red chilli (32.3) followed by black pepper (28.3) and dry ginger (21.6) and lowest in coriander (8.0) samples. The present study revealed the wide range of fungal contamination in spices in whichA. flavus was the most dominant fungal species among all fungi (Figure 2). Recently Rawat et al. [19] have also reported some of these fungi from stored medicinal plant samples. Bokhari [20] has also reportedA. flavus andA. niger contamination from black pepper and green cardamom samples from Saudi Arabia. Moreover, the result from Table 1 also revealed that some of the fungi were only confined to specific spices.A. alternata,A. tamari, andC. globosum species were only confined to red chilli samples whereasP. citrinum andA. ochraceus were present in all spices except in fennel and coriander, respectively. It may be possible that some of the specific nutrients or essential oil present in these spices can have effect on the growth of specific fungi and further mycotoxin production. Few earlier reports are available regarding inhibitory effects of some spices on the growth of fungi and their mycotoxin production [21, 22]. It has been also observed that red chilli, black pepper, and dry ginger are susceptible substrate for growth ofA. niger,A. flavus,P. citrinum,P. verrucosum, andF. moniliforme whereas coriander, turmeric, cumin, fennel, and fenugreek are mildly resistant.Table 1
Percent incidence of fungal mycoflora isolated from different spices.
Fungal species
Name of the spices
R. chia
B. pepb
Turmc
Corid
Cumie
Fennf
Carag
Fenuh
D. gingi
Alternaria alternata
2.3
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
Aspergillus parasiticus
—
4.3
—
—
—
—
—
—
2.0
Aspergillus oryzae
—
8.3
—
—
1.6
—
3.3
—
1.3
Aspergillus tamarii
5.3
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
Aspergillus niger
15.3
19.6
8.0
10.6
9.6
5.3
4.3
2.6
9.0
Aspergillus flavus
32.3
28.3
9.6
8.0
16.6
12.3
15.3
19.6
21.6
Aspergillus ochraceus
8.6
10.0
7.6
—
3.6
5.0
1.6
2.3
4.6
Aspergillus versicolor
11.4
7.65
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
Aspergillus fumigatus
—
—
—
2.0
—
—
—
—
4.6
Aspergillus terreus
—
6.3
—
—
2.6
1.3
—
—
2.6
Aspergillus sydowii
—
—
—
2.6
—
—
4.0
2.6
—
Penicillium citrinum
12.6
19.3
4.0
7.6
3.3
—
2.3
7.6
16.3
Penicillium islandicum
—
—
—
—
—
—
1.6
—
—
Penicillium verrucosum
8.6
10.0
8.0
6.3
—
—
—
6.0
8.6
Penicillium purpurogenum
—
1.3
—
—
—
—
—
—
2.6
Penicillium cyclopium
—
—
—
—
—
—
1.6
—
—
Fusarium oxysporum
—
5.6
5.3
—
6.6
—
3.3
—
2.3
Fusarium moniliforme
6.3
9.6
4.6
—
—
3.0
—
1.6
3.0
Chaetomium globosum
1.4
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
Rhizopus nigricans
—
6.3
—
4.3
2.5
—
—
—
—
Rhizopus oryzae
4.3
6.6
—
—
2.6
2.3
—
4.0
2.6
Mucor hiemalis
7.0
3.0
—
2.6
—
1.6
—
—
—
aRed chilli, bblack pepper, c
turmeric, dcoriander, ecumin, ffennel, gcaraway, hfenugreek, and idry ginger.Figure 1
Percent incidence of toxigenic fungal contamination in spices samples.Figure 2
Fungal association of toxigenic fungi in different spices. (a) Red chilli associated withA. flavus andA. niger, (b)A. flavus,A. parasiticus,A. niger, and the other fungal contamination in black pepper, (c) fungal contamination in turmeric, (d) coriander associatedwith different fungi, and (e) association ofA. flavus andA. niger in cumin.
(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)
(e)


### 3.2. Toxic Potentiality of Isolated Fungi

Aflatoxins, ochratoxin A, and citrinin producing potentiality ofA. flavus,A. parasiticus,A. ochraceus,A. terreus,P. citrinum, andP. verrucosum isolated from spices samples were examined (Table 2). ToxigenicA. flavus were isolated from all spices. 56% isolates ofA. flavus from red chilli samples were highly toxic and produce aflatoxins up to 33.6 μg/L whereas aflatoxins produced byA. parasiticus were less potential thanA. flavus.A. ochraceus andP. verrucosum produce OTA from all spices, except in cumin. CTN was only produced byP. citrinum, up to 18.5 μg/L and it was only confined to red chilli, black pepper, coriander, cumin, fenugreek, and dry ginger samples whereas none of the isolates ofA. terreus were found toxigenic.Table 2
Mycotoxin producing potentiality of toxigenic fungi from different spices.
Sn
Spice
Fungi examined
% toxa
Mycotoxin detected
Potential range (µg/L)
1
R. chi
A. flavus
56.0
AFs
4.3–33.6
A. ochraceus
41.6
OTA
2.8–18.6
P. citrinum
31.2
CTN
15.6–28.3
P. verrucosum
30.0
OTA
3.5–8.6
2
B. pep
A. flavus
45.4
AFs
6.3–26.4
A. parasiticus
26.6
AFs
4.8–9.6
A. ochraceus
45.0
OTA
5.4–22.6
A. terreus
0
—
—
P. citrinum
44.4
CTN
15.4–20.5
P. verrucosum
25.0
OTA
4.6–13.8
3
Turm
A. flavus
20.0
AFs
4.4–11.3
A. ochraceus
40.0
OTA
2.1–18.9
P. citrinum
0
—
—
P. verrucosum
16.6
OTA
3.7–6.1
4
Cori
A. flavus
38.8
AFs
5.2–13.7
P. citrinum
26.6
CTN
18.7–20.9
P. verrucosum
20.0
OTA
6.8–16.1
5
Cumi
A. flavus
46.6
AFs
5.8–18.2
A. ochraceus
0
—
—
A. terreus
0
—
—
P. citrinum
13.3
CTN
16.0–18.5
6
Fenn
A. flavus
45.0
AFs
8.7–24.3
A. ochraceus
38.8
OTA
6.5–8.4
A. terreus
0
—
—
7
Cara
A. flavus
40.9
AFs
6.4–16.7
A. ochraceus
22.2
OTA
6.1–15.4
P. citrinum
0
—
—
8
Fenu
A. flavus
35.0
AFs
6.4–19.7
A. ochraceus
40.0
OTA
3.5–20.1
P. citrinum
20.0
CTN
17.2–19.2
P. verrucosum
0
—
—
9
D. ging
A. flavus
44.0
AFs
5.8–24.2
A. parasiticus
27.7
AFs
6.4–8.1
A. ochraceus
33.3
OTA
3.1–16.7
A. terreus
0
—
—
P. citrinum
38.8
CTN
16.4–22.3
P. verrucosum
30.0
OTA
2.4–8.7
aPercentage of toxigenic isolates of  fungi.


### 3.3. Natural Occurrence of Mycotoxins in Spices

AFs (AFB1, AFB2, AFG1, and AFG2), OTA, and CTN were detected from different spices (Figures 3 and 4). All 9 types of spice samples were analyzed and it has been observed that some of the samples were only contaminated to aflatoxin B1 or B1B2 or G1 or G1G2 and some were positive to B1B2G1G2 whereas OTA and CTN were also detected from these samples (Table 3). 47 out of 55 samples of red chilli were contaminated with aflatoxins in which 31 samples were positive to AFB1. Earlier Golge et al. [23] also reported the level of aflatoxins in commercially used Turkish red chilli. CTN contamination was highly observed in dry ginger whereas none of the samples of turmeric, fennel, and caraway were CTN contaminated. OTA were detected from all different spices, except in cumin. Fazekas et al. [24] also reported AFB1, AFB2, AFG1, AFG2, and OTA contamination in spices from Hungary. It has been observed that CTN contamination is mainly confined to the dry ginger, red chilli, coriander, and black pepper samples. These samples are highly contaminated withP. citrinum orP. verrucosum or both and they were known to produce CTN on substrate. So, it may be possible that dry ginger, red chilli, coriander, and black pepper are susceptible forP. citrinum andP. verrucosum growth and further mycotoxin productions.Table 3
Number of different spice samples contaminated with aflatoxins, ochratoxin A, and citrinin.
Spices
Number of samples analyzed
Number of samples with different mycotoxins contamination
Aflatoxins
OTA
CTN
B1
G1
B1B2
G1G2
B1B2G1G2
Total
Red chilli
55
31
2
9
1
4
47
40
26
Black pepper
42
19
1
5
2
5
32
33
19
Turmeric
35
10
0
7
3
4
24
20
0
Coriander
30
15
0
4
1
2
22
09
12
Cumin
28
12
2
3
0
1
18
0
6
Fennel
25
08
0
4
1
1
14
14
0
Caraway
25
08
1
3
0
1
13
12
0
Fenugreek
35
15
0
3
2
3
23
18
13
Dry ginger
36
16
2
7
0
3
28
20
16Figure 3
LC-MS/MS chromatogram of AFs (AFB1, AFB2, AFG1, and AFG2) and OTA for red chilli sample having maximum contamination.Figure 4
LC-MS/MS chromatogram of CTN for ginger sample having maximum contamination.Natural occurrence of AFs, OTA, and CTN in spices has been shown in Table4. All spices were contaminated with AFs and detected amount is maximum compared to OTA and CTN except in fennel. Highest amount of AFs was recorded in red chilli samples (219.6 ng/g) and OTA contamination was maximum in black pepper (154.1 ng/g). Earlier Jalili and Jinap [25] have reported that 65% of chilli samples were contaminated with AFs level in the range of 0.2–79.7 ng/g and 81.25% of samples were positive to OTA in the range of 0.2–101.2 ng/g. Ozbey and Kabak [26] have also reported 30.4% AFs contamination and 17.4% of OTA contamination in black pepper powder. In present investigation, only 30% of coriander samples were positive to OTA and none of the cumin samples were positive. It may be due to essential oil (cuminaldehyde) of the cumin which inhibited the growth of OTA producing fungi (A. ochraceus andP. verrucosum) and OTA production. Earlier, Hua et al. [27] have reported that essential oil of cinnamon inhibits the growth ofA. ochraceus and ochratoxin A production. Ferreira et al. [28] have reported that turmeric has the inhibitory effect on the growth ofA. flavus and mycotoxin production but in our report 68.5% of turmeric was AFs contaminated and 57.1% was OTA contaminated with the detectable amount of 163.8 ng/g and 125 ng/g, respectively (Figure 5).Table 4
Natural occurrence and amount of aflatoxins, ochratoxin A, and citrinin detected in different ranges from the spices.
Mycotoxins
Spices
N.S.Aa
Number of samples present in between different ranges (ng/g)
Amount (ng/g)
CVd
% conte
N.Db
LDLc–100
101–200
201–300
301–400
401–500
501–≤
Mean ± S.E
AFs
R. chi
55
8
10
7
8
13
7
2
219.6 ± 21.3
0.7
85.4
B. pep
42
10
4
3
14
10
1
0
185.0 ± 22.0
0.7
76.1
Turm
35
11
4
4
6
10
0
0
163.8 ± 25.7
0.9
68.5
Cori
30
8
2
5
7
6
2
0
179.5 ± 27.2
0.8
73.3
Cumi
28
10
2
6
3
5
2
0
146.8 ± 28.7
1.0
64.2
Fenn
25
11
4
5
5
0
0
0
84.1 ± 20.2
1.2
56.0
Cara
25
12
4
2
6
1
0
0
92.7 ± 23.3
1.2
52.0
fenu
35
12
6
7
10
0
0
0
135.4 ± 24.8
1.0
65.7
D. ging
36
8
2
12
7
3
2
2
183.6 ± 25.0
0.8
77.7
OTA
R. chi
55
15
14
22
2
2
0
0
97.1 ± 12.8
0.9
72.7
B. pep
42
9
7
9
12
5
0
0
154.1 ± 19.3
0.8
78.5
Turm
35
15
3
5
7
3
2
0
125.9 ± 24.0
1.1
57.1
Cori
30
21
4
0
4
1
0
0
47.6 ± 17.2
1.9
30.0
Cumi
30
30
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Fenn
25
11
3
5
4
2
0
0
98.1 ± 22.6
1.1
56.0
Cara
25
13
6
2
4
0
0
0
63.2 ± 18.9
1.4
48.0
fenu
35
17
5
6
6
1
0
0
83.2 ± 17.6
1.2
51.4
D. ging
36
16
6
7
2
3
0
0
82.8 ± 19.0
1.3
55.5
CTN
R. chi
55
29
8
12
5
1
0
0
69.0 ± 12.5
1.3
47.2
B. pep
42
23
7
6
3
2
1
0
76.9 ± 17.8
1.5
45.2
Turm
35
35
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Cori
30
18
3
2
4
2
1
0
81.0 ± 23.0
1.5
40.0
Cumi
28
22
1
4
0
1
0
0
33.9 ± 14.7
2.3
21.4
Fenn
25
25
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Cara
25
25
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
fenu
35
22
3
5
4
1
0
0
63.1 ± 17.2
1.6
37.1
D. ging
36
20
3
7
2
4
0
0
85.1 ± 19.4
1.3
44.4
aNumber of samples analyzed, bnot detected, clowest detectable level of ELISA Kit (4 ng/g for AFs, 2 ng/g for OTA, 15 ng/g for CTN), dcoefficient of variation,  and epercent contamination.Figure 5
Amount of total aflatoxins, ochratoxin A, and citrinin in different spices.


## 3.1. Mycobiotic Association

In our study, prevalence of mycoflora was isolated from spices; total 22 species belong to 7 different fungal genera (Table1).Aspergillus was isolated from all spice samples whereasPenicillium were confined only to red chilli, black pepper, turmeric, cumin, coriander caraway fenugreek, and dry ginger samples (Figure 1).A. flavus contamination was highest in red chilli (32.3) followed by black pepper (28.3) and dry ginger (21.6) and lowest in coriander (8.0) samples. The present study revealed the wide range of fungal contamination in spices in whichA. flavus was the most dominant fungal species among all fungi (Figure 2). Recently Rawat et al. [19] have also reported some of these fungi from stored medicinal plant samples. Bokhari [20] has also reportedA. flavus andA. niger contamination from black pepper and green cardamom samples from Saudi Arabia. Moreover, the result from Table 1 also revealed that some of the fungi were only confined to specific spices.A. alternata,A. tamari, andC. globosum species were only confined to red chilli samples whereasP. citrinum andA. ochraceus were present in all spices except in fennel and coriander, respectively. It may be possible that some of the specific nutrients or essential oil present in these spices can have effect on the growth of specific fungi and further mycotoxin production. Few earlier reports are available regarding inhibitory effects of some spices on the growth of fungi and their mycotoxin production [21, 22]. It has been also observed that red chilli, black pepper, and dry ginger are susceptible substrate for growth ofA. niger,A. flavus,P. citrinum,P. verrucosum, andF. moniliforme whereas coriander, turmeric, cumin, fennel, and fenugreek are mildly resistant.Table 1
Percent incidence of fungal mycoflora isolated from different spices.
Fungal species
Name of the spices
R. chia
B. pepb
Turmc
Corid
Cumie
Fennf
Carag
Fenuh
D. gingi
Alternaria alternata
2.3
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
Aspergillus parasiticus
—
4.3
—
—
—
—
—
—
2.0
Aspergillus oryzae
—
8.3
—
—
1.6
—
3.3
—
1.3
Aspergillus tamarii
5.3
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
Aspergillus niger
15.3
19.6
8.0
10.6
9.6
5.3
4.3
2.6
9.0
Aspergillus flavus
32.3
28.3
9.6
8.0
16.6
12.3
15.3
19.6
21.6
Aspergillus ochraceus
8.6
10.0
7.6
—
3.6
5.0
1.6
2.3
4.6
Aspergillus versicolor
11.4
7.65
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
Aspergillus fumigatus
—
—
—
2.0
—
—
—
—
4.6
Aspergillus terreus
—
6.3
—
—
2.6
1.3
—
—
2.6
Aspergillus sydowii
—
—
—
2.6
—
—
4.0
2.6
—
Penicillium citrinum
12.6
19.3
4.0
7.6
3.3
—
2.3
7.6
16.3
Penicillium islandicum
—
—
—
—
—
—
1.6
—
—
Penicillium verrucosum
8.6
10.0
8.0
6.3
—
—
—
6.0
8.6
Penicillium purpurogenum
—
1.3
—
—
—
—
—
—
2.6
Penicillium cyclopium
—
—
—
—
—
—
1.6
—
—
Fusarium oxysporum
—
5.6
5.3
—
6.6
—
3.3
—
2.3
Fusarium moniliforme
6.3
9.6
4.6
—
—
3.0
—
1.6
3.0
Chaetomium globosum
1.4
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
Rhizopus nigricans
—
6.3
—
4.3
2.5
—
—
—
—
Rhizopus oryzae
4.3
6.6
—
—
2.6
2.3
—
4.0
2.6
Mucor hiemalis
7.0
3.0
—
2.6
—
1.6
—
—
—
aRed chilli, bblack pepper, c
turmeric, dcoriander, ecumin, ffennel, gcaraway, hfenugreek, and idry ginger.Figure 1
Percent incidence of toxigenic fungal contamination in spices samples.Figure 2
Fungal association of toxigenic fungi in different spices. (a) Red chilli associated withA. flavus andA. niger, (b)A. flavus,A. parasiticus,A. niger, and the other fungal contamination in black pepper, (c) fungal contamination in turmeric, (d) coriander associatedwith different fungi, and (e) association ofA. flavus andA. niger in cumin.
(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)
(e)


## 3.2. Toxic Potentiality of Isolated Fungi

Aflatoxins, ochratoxin A, and citrinin producing potentiality ofA. flavus,A. parasiticus,A. ochraceus,A. terreus,P. citrinum, andP. verrucosum isolated from spices samples were examined (Table 2). ToxigenicA. flavus were isolated from all spices. 56% isolates ofA. flavus from red chilli samples were highly toxic and produce aflatoxins up to 33.6 μg/L whereas aflatoxins produced byA. parasiticus were less potential thanA. flavus.A. ochraceus andP. verrucosum produce OTA from all spices, except in cumin. CTN was only produced byP. citrinum, up to 18.5 μg/L and it was only confined to red chilli, black pepper, coriander, cumin, fenugreek, and dry ginger samples whereas none of the isolates ofA. terreus were found toxigenic.Table 2
Mycotoxin producing potentiality of toxigenic fungi from different spices.
Sn
Spice
Fungi examined
% toxa
Mycotoxin detected
Potential range (µg/L)
1
R. chi
A. flavus
56.0
AFs
4.3–33.6
A. ochraceus
41.6
OTA
2.8–18.6
P. citrinum
31.2
CTN
15.6–28.3
P. verrucosum
30.0
OTA
3.5–8.6
2
B. pep
A. flavus
45.4
AFs
6.3–26.4
A. parasiticus
26.6
AFs
4.8–9.6
A. ochraceus
45.0
OTA
5.4–22.6
A. terreus
0
—
—
P. citrinum
44.4
CTN
15.4–20.5
P. verrucosum
25.0
OTA
4.6–13.8
3
Turm
A. flavus
20.0
AFs
4.4–11.3
A. ochraceus
40.0
OTA
2.1–18.9
P. citrinum
0
—
—
P. verrucosum
16.6
OTA
3.7–6.1
4
Cori
A. flavus
38.8
AFs
5.2–13.7
P. citrinum
26.6
CTN
18.7–20.9
P. verrucosum
20.0
OTA
6.8–16.1
5
Cumi
A. flavus
46.6
AFs
5.8–18.2
A. ochraceus
0
—
—
A. terreus
0
—
—
P. citrinum
13.3
CTN
16.0–18.5
6
Fenn
A. flavus
45.0
AFs
8.7–24.3
A. ochraceus
38.8
OTA
6.5–8.4
A. terreus
0
—
—
7
Cara
A. flavus
40.9
AFs
6.4–16.7
A. ochraceus
22.2
OTA
6.1–15.4
P. citrinum
0
—
—
8
Fenu
A. flavus
35.0
AFs
6.4–19.7
A. ochraceus
40.0
OTA
3.5–20.1
P. citrinum
20.0
CTN
17.2–19.2
P. verrucosum
0
—
—
9
D. ging
A. flavus
44.0
AFs
5.8–24.2
A. parasiticus
27.7
AFs
6.4–8.1
A. ochraceus
33.3
OTA
3.1–16.7
A. terreus
0
—
—
P. citrinum
38.8
CTN
16.4–22.3
P. verrucosum
30.0
OTA
2.4–8.7
aPercentage of toxigenic isolates of  fungi.


## 3.3. Natural Occurrence of Mycotoxins in Spices

AFs (AFB1, AFB2, AFG1, and AFG2), OTA, and CTN were detected from different spices (Figures 3 and 4). All 9 types of spice samples were analyzed and it has been observed that some of the samples were only contaminated to aflatoxin B1 or B1B2 or G1 or G1G2 and some were positive to B1B2G1G2 whereas OTA and CTN were also detected from these samples (Table 3). 47 out of 55 samples of red chilli were contaminated with aflatoxins in which 31 samples were positive to AFB1. Earlier Golge et al. [23] also reported the level of aflatoxins in commercially used Turkish red chilli. CTN contamination was highly observed in dry ginger whereas none of the samples of turmeric, fennel, and caraway were CTN contaminated. OTA were detected from all different spices, except in cumin. Fazekas et al. [24] also reported AFB1, AFB2, AFG1, AFG2, and OTA contamination in spices from Hungary. It has been observed that CTN contamination is mainly confined to the dry ginger, red chilli, coriander, and black pepper samples. These samples are highly contaminated withP. citrinum orP. verrucosum or both and they were known to produce CTN on substrate. So, it may be possible that dry ginger, red chilli, coriander, and black pepper are susceptible forP. citrinum andP. verrucosum growth and further mycotoxin productions.Table 3
Number of different spice samples contaminated with aflatoxins, ochratoxin A, and citrinin.
Spices
Number of samples analyzed
Number of samples with different mycotoxins contamination
Aflatoxins
OTA
CTN
B1
G1
B1B2
G1G2
B1B2G1G2
Total
Red chilli
55
31
2
9
1
4
47
40
26
Black pepper
42
19
1
5
2
5
32
33
19
Turmeric
35
10
0
7
3
4
24
20
0
Coriander
30
15
0
4
1
2
22
09
12
Cumin
28
12
2
3
0
1
18
0
6
Fennel
25
08
0
4
1
1
14
14
0
Caraway
25
08
1
3
0
1
13
12
0
Fenugreek
35
15
0
3
2
3
23
18
13
Dry ginger
36
16
2
7
0
3
28
20
16Figure 3
LC-MS/MS chromatogram of AFs (AFB1, AFB2, AFG1, and AFG2) and OTA for red chilli sample having maximum contamination.Figure 4
LC-MS/MS chromatogram of CTN for ginger sample having maximum contamination.Natural occurrence of AFs, OTA, and CTN in spices has been shown in Table4. All spices were contaminated with AFs and detected amount is maximum compared to OTA and CTN except in fennel. Highest amount of AFs was recorded in red chilli samples (219.6 ng/g) and OTA contamination was maximum in black pepper (154.1 ng/g). Earlier Jalili and Jinap [25] have reported that 65% of chilli samples were contaminated with AFs level in the range of 0.2–79.7 ng/g and 81.25% of samples were positive to OTA in the range of 0.2–101.2 ng/g. Ozbey and Kabak [26] have also reported 30.4% AFs contamination and 17.4% of OTA contamination in black pepper powder. In present investigation, only 30% of coriander samples were positive to OTA and none of the cumin samples were positive. It may be due to essential oil (cuminaldehyde) of the cumin which inhibited the growth of OTA producing fungi (A. ochraceus andP. verrucosum) and OTA production. Earlier, Hua et al. [27] have reported that essential oil of cinnamon inhibits the growth ofA. ochraceus and ochratoxin A production. Ferreira et al. [28] have reported that turmeric has the inhibitory effect on the growth ofA. flavus and mycotoxin production but in our report 68.5% of turmeric was AFs contaminated and 57.1% was OTA contaminated with the detectable amount of 163.8 ng/g and 125 ng/g, respectively (Figure 5).Table 4
Natural occurrence and amount of aflatoxins, ochratoxin A, and citrinin detected in different ranges from the spices.
Mycotoxins
Spices
N.S.Aa
Number of samples present in between different ranges (ng/g)
Amount (ng/g)
CVd
% conte
N.Db
LDLc–100
101–200
201–300
301–400
401–500
501–≤
Mean ± S.E
AFs
R. chi
55
8
10
7
8
13
7
2
219.6 ± 21.3
0.7
85.4
B. pep
42
10
4
3
14
10
1
0
185.0 ± 22.0
0.7
76.1
Turm
35
11
4
4
6
10
0
0
163.8 ± 25.7
0.9
68.5
Cori
30
8
2
5
7
6
2
0
179.5 ± 27.2
0.8
73.3
Cumi
28
10
2
6
3
5
2
0
146.8 ± 28.7
1.0
64.2
Fenn
25
11
4
5
5
0
0
0
84.1 ± 20.2
1.2
56.0
Cara
25
12
4
2
6
1
0
0
92.7 ± 23.3
1.2
52.0
fenu
35
12
6
7
10
0
0
0
135.4 ± 24.8
1.0
65.7
D. ging
36
8
2
12
7
3
2
2
183.6 ± 25.0
0.8
77.7
OTA
R. chi
55
15
14
22
2
2
0
0
97.1 ± 12.8
0.9
72.7
B. pep
42
9
7
9
12
5
0
0
154.1 ± 19.3
0.8
78.5
Turm
35
15
3
5
7
3
2
0
125.9 ± 24.0
1.1
57.1
Cori
30
21
4
0
4
1
0
0
47.6 ± 17.2
1.9
30.0
Cumi
30
30
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Fenn
25
11
3
5
4
2
0
0
98.1 ± 22.6
1.1
56.0
Cara
25
13
6
2
4
0
0
0
63.2 ± 18.9
1.4
48.0
fenu
35
17
5
6
6
1
0
0
83.2 ± 17.6
1.2
51.4
D. ging
36
16
6
7
2
3
0
0
82.8 ± 19.0
1.3
55.5
CTN
R. chi
55
29
8
12
5
1
0
0
69.0 ± 12.5
1.3
47.2
B. pep
42
23
7
6
3
2
1
0
76.9 ± 17.8
1.5
45.2
Turm
35
35
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Cori
30
18
3
2
4
2
1
0
81.0 ± 23.0
1.5
40.0
Cumi
28
22
1
4
0
1
0
0
33.9 ± 14.7
2.3
21.4
Fenn
25
25
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Cara
25
25
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
fenu
35
22
3
5
4
1
0
0
63.1 ± 17.2
1.6
37.1
D. ging
36
20
3
7
2
4
0
0
85.1 ± 19.4
1.3
44.4
aNumber of samples analyzed, bnot detected, clowest detectable level of ELISA Kit (4 ng/g for AFs, 2 ng/g for OTA, 15 ng/g for CTN), dcoefficient of variation,  and epercent contamination.Figure 5
Amount of total aflatoxins, ochratoxin A, and citrinin in different spices.


## 4. Conclusion

On the basis of the present study, it may be concluded that the red chilli, black pepper, and dry ginger are susceptible substrate for fungal growth and subsequent mycotoxin productions. All 9 types of spices were contaminated with AFs. This is the first report of CTN contamination in black pepper, cumin, fenugreek, and dry ginger from Bihar state (India). Red chilli, black pepper, and dry ginger are the most contaminated spices in which AFs, OTA, and CTN were present in high concentration. Fennel, caraway, and cumin are the spices which can be considered a bit resistant to mycotoxigenic fungi and mycotoxin contamination. Further research is needed to isolate the active ingredient or the essential oil of these spices, which plays a vital role in the growth of toxigenic fungi and further toxin production. It is very important to care in processing, handling, transportation, and modification in storage system to reduce the production of hazardous mycotoxins in spices.



---

*Source: 242486-2015-07-02.xml*