# Analysis of Intergranular Precipitation in Isothermally Aged Nitrogen-Containing Austenitic Stainless Steels by an Electrochemical Method and Its Relation to Cryogenic Toughness

Authors: Maribel L. Saucedo-Muñoz; Victor M. Lopez-Hirata; Hector J. Dorantes-Rosales; Erika O. Avila-Davila
Journal: Advances in Materials Science and Engineering
 (2011)

---

## Abstract

The precipitation process in two N-containing austenitic stainless steels, aged at temperatures between 873 and 1173 K for times from 10 to 1000 min, was analyzed by an electrochemical method based on the anodic polarization test with an electrolyte of 1 N KOH solution. The anodic polarization curves showed the following intergranular precipitation sequence: austenite→  austenite + Cr23C6→ austenite + Cr23C6 + Cr2N. Besides, the fastest precipitation kinetics was detected in the aged steel with the highest content of nitrogen and carbon due to its higher driving force for precipitation. The higher the aging temperature, the higher volume fraction of precipitates. The precipitation fraction can be associated with the current density of the dissolution peaks of each phase. The Charpy-V-Notch impact energy of the aged specimens decreased with the increase in the volume fraction of precipitates.


---

## Body

## 1. Introduction

The austenitic stainless steels are construction materials for key corrosion-resistant equipment in most of the major industries, particularly in the chemical, petroleum, and nuclear power industries [1]. These steels are iron alloys containing a minimum of approximately 12% chromium. This content of chromium allows the formation of the passive film, which is self-healing in a wide variety of environments.In the case of austenitic stainless steels, the main reason for the development of nitrogen-containing steels is due to the higher yield and tensile strengths achieved, compared with conventionally processed austenitic stainless steels without scarifying toughness [2]. High-nitrogen stainless steels have yield and tensile strengths as much as 200–350% of the AISI 300 series steels [3]. It is also important to notice that, in contrast to carbon, nitrogen-containing austenitic stainless steels retain high-fracture toughness at low temperatures. Therefore, the higher-mechanical properties of nitrogen-containing austenitic stainless steels have made very attractive its application in the power-generation industry, shipbuilding, railways, cryogenic process, chemical equipment, pressure vessels, and nuclear industries [3–5].These stainless steels are also susceptible to the precipitation of different phases because of the aging for long exposition at high temperatures or during continuous cooling after welding process. Therefore, it is important to evaluate the degree of aging-induced embrittlement due to the precipitation phenomenon which may affect the cryogenic toughness in this type of steels [6, 7].The electrochemical methods have proved to be a powerful tool for the evaluation of microstructural changes and sensitization in different steels [8–10]. In addition, these methods can also be applied nondestructively to evaluate the microstructural degradation of in-service equipments.Thus, the purpose of this work is to carry out the precipitation analysis of two isothermally aged nitrogen-containing austenitic stainless steels using an electrochemical method as well as its relation to the decrease in cryogenic toughness due to the aging-induced embrittlement.


## 2. Experimental Procedure

### 2.1. Mechanical and Microstructural Characterization

The materials used in this work were forged plates of 200 mm thick of the JN1 and JJ1 austenitic stainless steels, and their composition, in weight %, is shown in Table1. The solution treatment of JN1 and JJ1 steels was carried out at 1348 K for 30 min and then water-quenched. The aging treatments were conducted at temperatures from 873 to 1173 K for times from 10 to 1000 min. The Charpy V-Notch (CVN) test was conducted at 77 K, liquid nitrogen temperature, following the standard procedure. Specimens of about 10mm×10mm×10mm were cut from the tested CVN impact test specimens in a spark-erosion cutting machine to conduct metallographical and electrochemical analyses. The solution was treated and the aged specimens were metallographically prepared using emery-paper up to 1500 grit number, and were polished with alumina 0.05 μm. After that, polished specimens were chemically etched in a solution of Villela’s reagent (1 g of picric acid and 5 mL of hydrochloric acid in 100 mL of ethylic alcohol) for about 2 min. Finally, the etched samples were characterized with PME3 Olympus optical microscope (OM) and scanning electron microscope (SEM) equipped with an EDX microanalysis system. The precipitates were extracted by electrochemical dissolution of the austenitic matrix. The chemical solution used was an electrolyte of 5 vol. % hydrochloric acid in methylic alcohol at room temperature and 6 V (D.C.). The extracted precipitates were analyzed in an X-ray diffractometer with monochromatic Kα copper radiation. The precipitates were also extracted from the etched samples by using the replica method to carry out a chemical microanalysis in the EDX-SEM.Table 1
Chemical composition of JJ and JN steels.
Steel% C% N% Si% Mn% Ni% Cr% Mo% Al% P% SJJ10.0250.2360.4810.1311.7912.014.94—0.0210.0017JN10.0400.320.973.8815.0724.32—0.0230.0220.001


### 2.2. Electrochemical Characterization

In order to carry out the electrochemical analysis, the aged specimens were mounted in epoxy resin. A nickel wire was welded to these specimens to have electrical contact. The mounted specimens were metallographically prepared, using emery paper, up to 1500 grit number and then diamond paste, 15, 6, and 3μm and finally rinsed in water and then isopropyl alcohol. During the electrochemical tests, a pyrex glass cell of a capacity of 1 liter with a graphite counter electrode and a reference electrode of saturated calomel, SCE, was used. The testing electrolyte was a 1 N KOH solution prepared with pure KOH and water. The temperature of electrolyte was kept constant at 298 K. The polarization curves were determined in a potentiostat/galvanostat PAR 273-A controlled by a commercial software installed in a personal computer. The anodic curves were obtained using a swept rate of 0.2 mVs−1 in the range of −450 to 450 mV. The electrochemically tested specimens were observed with optical and scanning electron microscopes to analyze the degree of etching and dissolved phases, respectively.


## 2.1. Mechanical and Microstructural Characterization

The materials used in this work were forged plates of 200 mm thick of the JN1 and JJ1 austenitic stainless steels, and their composition, in weight %, is shown in Table1. The solution treatment of JN1 and JJ1 steels was carried out at 1348 K for 30 min and then water-quenched. The aging treatments were conducted at temperatures from 873 to 1173 K for times from 10 to 1000 min. The Charpy V-Notch (CVN) test was conducted at 77 K, liquid nitrogen temperature, following the standard procedure. Specimens of about 10mm×10mm×10mm were cut from the tested CVN impact test specimens in a spark-erosion cutting machine to conduct metallographical and electrochemical analyses. The solution was treated and the aged specimens were metallographically prepared using emery-paper up to 1500 grit number, and were polished with alumina 0.05 μm. After that, polished specimens were chemically etched in a solution of Villela’s reagent (1 g of picric acid and 5 mL of hydrochloric acid in 100 mL of ethylic alcohol) for about 2 min. Finally, the etched samples were characterized with PME3 Olympus optical microscope (OM) and scanning electron microscope (SEM) equipped with an EDX microanalysis system. The precipitates were extracted by electrochemical dissolution of the austenitic matrix. The chemical solution used was an electrolyte of 5 vol. % hydrochloric acid in methylic alcohol at room temperature and 6 V (D.C.). The extracted precipitates were analyzed in an X-ray diffractometer with monochromatic Kα copper radiation. The precipitates were also extracted from the etched samples by using the replica method to carry out a chemical microanalysis in the EDX-SEM.Table 1
Chemical composition of JJ and JN steels.
Steel% C% N% Si% Mn% Ni% Cr% Mo% Al% P% SJJ10.0250.2360.4810.1311.7912.014.94—0.0210.0017JN10.0400.320.973.8815.0724.32—0.0230.0220.001


## 2.2. Electrochemical Characterization

In order to carry out the electrochemical analysis, the aged specimens were mounted in epoxy resin. A nickel wire was welded to these specimens to have electrical contact. The mounted specimens were metallographically prepared, using emery paper, up to 1500 grit number and then diamond paste, 15, 6, and 3μm and finally rinsed in water and then isopropyl alcohol. During the electrochemical tests, a pyrex glass cell of a capacity of 1 liter with a graphite counter electrode and a reference electrode of saturated calomel, SCE, was used. The testing electrolyte was a 1 N KOH solution prepared with pure KOH and water. The temperature of electrolyte was kept constant at 298 K. The polarization curves were determined in a potentiostat/galvanostat PAR 273-A controlled by a commercial software installed in a personal computer. The anodic curves were obtained using a swept rate of 0.2 mVs−1 in the range of −450 to 450 mV. The electrochemically tested specimens were observed with optical and scanning electron microscopes to analyze the degree of etching and dissolved phases, respectively.


## 3. Results

### 3.1. Microstructural Characterization of Precipitation

Figures1(a) and 1(b) show the SEM micrographs of the JJ1 and JN1 steels, respectively, aged at 1073 K for 300 min. Precipitation is indicated by arrows. The highest-volume fraction of intergranular precipitates corresponded to the aged JN1 steel. Some intergranular precipitates can be observed in the JN1 aged at 1073 K for 300 min, Figure 1(a). Some small transgranular precipitates in addition to the intergranular ones were also observed in the JJ1 steel aged at 1073 K for 300 min, Figure 1(b). The intergranular precipitation was slightly more uniform and abundant in the aged JN1 steel, Figure 1(a), than that corresponding to the aged JJ1 steel. The precipitation of particles was also observed to occur on twin boundaries in the aged JN1 steel. The aging at 873 K for 60 and 500 min was observed to cause a poor intergranular precipitation in JN1 and JJ1 steels, respectively.SEM micrographs the (a) JN1 and (b) JJ1 steels aged at 1073 K for 500 min.
(a)(b)The X-ray diffraction patterns of precipitates, extracted from the JN1 and JJ1 steels, aged at 973 and 1073 K for 300 min, are shown in Figure2. The extracted precipitates of the JN1 steel were identified as Cr23C6 and Cr2N. In addition to these two phases, the presence of the (Fe2Mo) η phase was also detected in the residues of the JJ1 steel aged at 1073 and 1173 K. The SEM microanalyses of the different precipitates showed that the intergranular Cr23C6 precipitates are not only composed of Cr, but also of Fe in the JN1 steel, and of Fe and Mo in the JJ1 steel. The intergranular and transgranular Cr2N precipitates are formed by Cr and Fe, while the η phase was composed of Fe and Mo and only precipitated in an intergranular mode.Figure 2
XRD patterns of the JJ1 and JN1 steels aged at 973 and 1073 K for 500 min.In summary, the above results showed that the intergranular precipitation of Cr23C6 and Cr2N preceded the transgranular precipitation of Cr2N in the JN1 steel and the transgranular precipitation of Cr2N and the η phase in the JJ1 steel. Besides, the kinetics of intergranular precipitation for JN1 steel was faster than that of JJ1 steel, because of its higher interstitial solute content and thus higher driving force for precipitation [11]. It was also observed that the higher the aging temperature, the higher volume fraction of precipitates.


### 3.2. Electrochemical Characterization

The anodic polarization curves of JJ1 and JN1 steels, after solution treatment are shown in Figure3. There is only one dissolution peak located at a potential of about 25 and 50 mV in the anodic polarization curve of JJ1 and JN1 steel, respectively. This anodic peak can be associated with the dissolution of the austenitic matrix. It can also be noticed that the current density peak in the JN1 steel is higher than that in the JJ1 steel. This fact suggests that the dissolution of passive film is more difficult in the former because of its higher Cr content [9].Figure 3
Anodic polarization curves of   JJ1 steel and JN1 steel solution treated.Figures4 and 5 show the anodic polarization curves corresponding to the JJ1 steel aged at 973 K for 10, 100 and 1000 min and at 900°C for 10, 100, 500, and 1000 min, respectively. In the anodic curve of sample aged at 973 K, it seems that there is only one dissolution peak, corresponding to the austenitic matrix; however, a dissolution peak corresponding to the Cr23C6 carbide could be overlapped with that of the austenitic matrix, see anodic curve corresponding to the aging time of 1000 min in Figure 4. This fact is more evident in the case the anodic curve of sample aged at 1173 K for 1000 min, Figure 5, where the presence of three dissolution peaks can be observed. These peaks correspond to the austenitic matrix at about 25 mV, Cr23C6 carbide at about 75 mV, and Cr2N nitride at about 250 mV. The M23C6 carbide dissolution peak has been reported to occur at 80 and 120 mV in the aged SUS 316H and SUS 321 austenitic stainless steels, respectively [12]. Additionally, the Cr2N nitride dissolution peak was observed to occur at about 250 mV in a Cr2N nitride specimen tested in the same solution in the present work. This fact shows a good agreement with the results of present work and it confirms that the austenitic matrix, M23C6 carbide, and Cr2N nitride have characteristic dissolution peaks.Figure 4
Anodic polarization curves of JJ1 steel aged at 973 K for 10, 100, and 1000 min.Figure 5
Anodic polarization curves of JJ1 steel aged at 1173 K for 10, 100, 500, and 1000 min.On the other hand, the anodic polarization curves for the JN1 steel samples aged at 973 K for 10, 100, and 1000 min, and at 1173 K for 10, 100, 500, and 1000 min, are shown in Figures6 and 7, respectively. Most of these anodic curves showed apparently only a dissolution peak, belonging to the austenitic matrix; however, there is a clear and small discontinuity located at a potential of about 60 mV in the matrix dissolution peak for the sample aged at 973 K for 1000 min. This fact suggests that the dissolution peak belongs to Cr23C6 carbide, and it is overlapped by the matrix. The anodic polarization curves of the JN1 steel sample aged at 1173 K, Figure 7, showed clearly the appearance of the Cr2N nitride peak located at about 250 mV as the aging time increased. In this case, there is small discontinuity in the matrix dissolution peak which also suggests that the Cr23C6 carbide dissolution peak is overlapped by that of the matrix. It is also important to mention that only one dissolution peak, corresponding to the austenite matrix, was detected for the JN1 and JJ1 steels aged at 873 K for times up to 500 and 200 min, respectively.Figure 6
Anodic polarization curves of JN1 steel aged at 973 K for 10, 100, and 1000 min.Figure 7
Anodic polarization curves of JN1 steel aged at 1173 K for 10, 100, 500, and 1000 min.To verify if each dissolution peak in the anodic curve can be attributed to the dissolution of either matrix or Cr23C6 and Cr2N precipitates, the anodic swept of aged JJ1 and JN1 steel samples was stopped and maintained for 60 min at the potential of the different dissolution peaks and then these specimens were observed with a SEM. After this, the anodic swept was restarted from the last potential. For example, Figures 8(a) and 8(b) show the SEM micrographs of the JJ1 steel aged at 1173 K for 1000 min and then electrolytically tested and stopped at 25 and 75 mV, respectively. The SEM micrograph corresponding to dissolution potential of matrix, 25 mV only revealed the microstructure, and thus both transgranular and intergranular precipitates are observed in Figure 8(a). In contrast, Figure 8(b) presents the SEM micrograph of specimen stopped at 75 mV. It can be noticed the preferential dissolution of some intergranular precipitates which seems to confirm the selectivity dissolution of the anodic polarization method. This preferential dissolution can be attributed to the fact that grain boundaries are disordered misfit regions separating grains of different crystallographic orientation. Thus, they are favored sites for the segregation of various elements or the precipitation of different phase. It is not surprising, therefore, that grain boundaries can be preferentially attacked in certain solutions [9].SEM micrographs of the electrolytically tested JJ1 steel after aging at 1123 K for 1000 min (a) at 25 mV and (b) at 75 mV in Figure5.
(a)(b)It is important to remark that the current density of dissolution peaks from Cr23C6 carbide and Cr2N nitride increases with aging time, see for instance Figures 5 and 7. This can be attributed to the increase in the volume fraction of precipitation. In general, it was observed the presence of Cr23C6 carbide and Cr2N nitride increased as the aging time and temperature increased.Besides, it is important to mention that almost no dissolution peaks corresponding to precipitation were detected for the JN1 and JJ1 steels aged at 873 K. These electrochemical results agree with the results of microstructural characterization.


### 3.3. Cryogenic Toughness

Figures9(a) and 9(b) show the plots of CVN fracture energy at 77 K versus aging time for the JJ1 and JN1 steels, respectively, aged at 973, 1073, and 1173 K. All the steels showed a monotonic decrease in the CVN fracture energy with the aging time at the three temperatures. It is also evident that the drop of fracture toughness of JN1 steel is always faster than that of JJ1 steel. The fastest drop of fracture toughness occurred in the JN1 samples aged at 1173 K. This fact may be attributed to the higher content of C and N in JN1 steel, which can lead to faster kinetics in intergranular precipitation during the aging process, as discussed in a later section.CVN fracture energy at 77 K as a function of aging time for (a) JN1 and (b) JJ1 steels aged at 973, 1073, and 1173 K.
(a)(b)The solution JN1, and JJ1 steels fractured in a ductile manner, see for example Figure10(a), while the intergranular facets were found in all the aged samples, although the area fraction of intergranular facets to ductile surface was strongly dependent on the aging conditions. The fraction of intergranular brittle fracture increased with the aging time and temperature, see for instance Figures 10(b) and 10(c), and it seemed consistent with the CVN fracture energy value.SEM fractographs of CVN impact test specimens for the JN1 steel (a) solution treated and aged at  1173 K for (b) 10 and (c) 1000 min.
(a)(b)(c)


## 3.1. Microstructural Characterization of Precipitation

Figures1(a) and 1(b) show the SEM micrographs of the JJ1 and JN1 steels, respectively, aged at 1073 K for 300 min. Precipitation is indicated by arrows. The highest-volume fraction of intergranular precipitates corresponded to the aged JN1 steel. Some intergranular precipitates can be observed in the JN1 aged at 1073 K for 300 min, Figure 1(a). Some small transgranular precipitates in addition to the intergranular ones were also observed in the JJ1 steel aged at 1073 K for 300 min, Figure 1(b). The intergranular precipitation was slightly more uniform and abundant in the aged JN1 steel, Figure 1(a), than that corresponding to the aged JJ1 steel. The precipitation of particles was also observed to occur on twin boundaries in the aged JN1 steel. The aging at 873 K for 60 and 500 min was observed to cause a poor intergranular precipitation in JN1 and JJ1 steels, respectively.SEM micrographs the (a) JN1 and (b) JJ1 steels aged at 1073 K for 500 min.
(a)(b)The X-ray diffraction patterns of precipitates, extracted from the JN1 and JJ1 steels, aged at 973 and 1073 K for 300 min, are shown in Figure2. The extracted precipitates of the JN1 steel were identified as Cr23C6 and Cr2N. In addition to these two phases, the presence of the (Fe2Mo) η phase was also detected in the residues of the JJ1 steel aged at 1073 and 1173 K. The SEM microanalyses of the different precipitates showed that the intergranular Cr23C6 precipitates are not only composed of Cr, but also of Fe in the JN1 steel, and of Fe and Mo in the JJ1 steel. The intergranular and transgranular Cr2N precipitates are formed by Cr and Fe, while the η phase was composed of Fe and Mo and only precipitated in an intergranular mode.Figure 2
XRD patterns of the JJ1 and JN1 steels aged at 973 and 1073 K for 500 min.In summary, the above results showed that the intergranular precipitation of Cr23C6 and Cr2N preceded the transgranular precipitation of Cr2N in the JN1 steel and the transgranular precipitation of Cr2N and the η phase in the JJ1 steel. Besides, the kinetics of intergranular precipitation for JN1 steel was faster than that of JJ1 steel, because of its higher interstitial solute content and thus higher driving force for precipitation [11]. It was also observed that the higher the aging temperature, the higher volume fraction of precipitates.


## 3.2. Electrochemical Characterization

The anodic polarization curves of JJ1 and JN1 steels, after solution treatment are shown in Figure3. There is only one dissolution peak located at a potential of about 25 and 50 mV in the anodic polarization curve of JJ1 and JN1 steel, respectively. This anodic peak can be associated with the dissolution of the austenitic matrix. It can also be noticed that the current density peak in the JN1 steel is higher than that in the JJ1 steel. This fact suggests that the dissolution of passive film is more difficult in the former because of its higher Cr content [9].Figure 3
Anodic polarization curves of   JJ1 steel and JN1 steel solution treated.Figures4 and 5 show the anodic polarization curves corresponding to the JJ1 steel aged at 973 K for 10, 100 and 1000 min and at 900°C for 10, 100, 500, and 1000 min, respectively. In the anodic curve of sample aged at 973 K, it seems that there is only one dissolution peak, corresponding to the austenitic matrix; however, a dissolution peak corresponding to the Cr23C6 carbide could be overlapped with that of the austenitic matrix, see anodic curve corresponding to the aging time of 1000 min in Figure 4. This fact is more evident in the case the anodic curve of sample aged at 1173 K for 1000 min, Figure 5, where the presence of three dissolution peaks can be observed. These peaks correspond to the austenitic matrix at about 25 mV, Cr23C6 carbide at about 75 mV, and Cr2N nitride at about 250 mV. The M23C6 carbide dissolution peak has been reported to occur at 80 and 120 mV in the aged SUS 316H and SUS 321 austenitic stainless steels, respectively [12]. Additionally, the Cr2N nitride dissolution peak was observed to occur at about 250 mV in a Cr2N nitride specimen tested in the same solution in the present work. This fact shows a good agreement with the results of present work and it confirms that the austenitic matrix, M23C6 carbide, and Cr2N nitride have characteristic dissolution peaks.Figure 4
Anodic polarization curves of JJ1 steel aged at 973 K for 10, 100, and 1000 min.Figure 5
Anodic polarization curves of JJ1 steel aged at 1173 K for 10, 100, 500, and 1000 min.On the other hand, the anodic polarization curves for the JN1 steel samples aged at 973 K for 10, 100, and 1000 min, and at 1173 K for 10, 100, 500, and 1000 min, are shown in Figures6 and 7, respectively. Most of these anodic curves showed apparently only a dissolution peak, belonging to the austenitic matrix; however, there is a clear and small discontinuity located at a potential of about 60 mV in the matrix dissolution peak for the sample aged at 973 K for 1000 min. This fact suggests that the dissolution peak belongs to Cr23C6 carbide, and it is overlapped by the matrix. The anodic polarization curves of the JN1 steel sample aged at 1173 K, Figure 7, showed clearly the appearance of the Cr2N nitride peak located at about 250 mV as the aging time increased. In this case, there is small discontinuity in the matrix dissolution peak which also suggests that the Cr23C6 carbide dissolution peak is overlapped by that of the matrix. It is also important to mention that only one dissolution peak, corresponding to the austenite matrix, was detected for the JN1 and JJ1 steels aged at 873 K for times up to 500 and 200 min, respectively.Figure 6
Anodic polarization curves of JN1 steel aged at 973 K for 10, 100, and 1000 min.Figure 7
Anodic polarization curves of JN1 steel aged at 1173 K for 10, 100, 500, and 1000 min.To verify if each dissolution peak in the anodic curve can be attributed to the dissolution of either matrix or Cr23C6 and Cr2N precipitates, the anodic swept of aged JJ1 and JN1 steel samples was stopped and maintained for 60 min at the potential of the different dissolution peaks and then these specimens were observed with a SEM. After this, the anodic swept was restarted from the last potential. For example, Figures 8(a) and 8(b) show the SEM micrographs of the JJ1 steel aged at 1173 K for 1000 min and then electrolytically tested and stopped at 25 and 75 mV, respectively. The SEM micrograph corresponding to dissolution potential of matrix, 25 mV only revealed the microstructure, and thus both transgranular and intergranular precipitates are observed in Figure 8(a). In contrast, Figure 8(b) presents the SEM micrograph of specimen stopped at 75 mV. It can be noticed the preferential dissolution of some intergranular precipitates which seems to confirm the selectivity dissolution of the anodic polarization method. This preferential dissolution can be attributed to the fact that grain boundaries are disordered misfit regions separating grains of different crystallographic orientation. Thus, they are favored sites for the segregation of various elements or the precipitation of different phase. It is not surprising, therefore, that grain boundaries can be preferentially attacked in certain solutions [9].SEM micrographs of the electrolytically tested JJ1 steel after aging at 1123 K for 1000 min (a) at 25 mV and (b) at 75 mV in Figure5.
(a)(b)It is important to remark that the current density of dissolution peaks from Cr23C6 carbide and Cr2N nitride increases with aging time, see for instance Figures 5 and 7. This can be attributed to the increase in the volume fraction of precipitation. In general, it was observed the presence of Cr23C6 carbide and Cr2N nitride increased as the aging time and temperature increased.Besides, it is important to mention that almost no dissolution peaks corresponding to precipitation were detected for the JN1 and JJ1 steels aged at 873 K. These electrochemical results agree with the results of microstructural characterization.


## 3.3. Cryogenic Toughness

Figures9(a) and 9(b) show the plots of CVN fracture energy at 77 K versus aging time for the JJ1 and JN1 steels, respectively, aged at 973, 1073, and 1173 K. All the steels showed a monotonic decrease in the CVN fracture energy with the aging time at the three temperatures. It is also evident that the drop of fracture toughness of JN1 steel is always faster than that of JJ1 steel. The fastest drop of fracture toughness occurred in the JN1 samples aged at 1173 K. This fact may be attributed to the higher content of C and N in JN1 steel, which can lead to faster kinetics in intergranular precipitation during the aging process, as discussed in a later section.CVN fracture energy at 77 K as a function of aging time for (a) JN1 and (b) JJ1 steels aged at 973, 1073, and 1173 K.
(a)(b)The solution JN1, and JJ1 steels fractured in a ductile manner, see for example Figure10(a), while the intergranular facets were found in all the aged samples, although the area fraction of intergranular facets to ductile surface was strongly dependent on the aging conditions. The fraction of intergranular brittle fracture increased with the aging time and temperature, see for instance Figures 10(b) and 10(c), and it seemed consistent with the CVN fracture energy value.SEM fractographs of CVN impact test specimens for the JN1 steel (a) solution treated and aged at  1173 K for (b) 10 and (c) 1000 min.
(a)(b)(c)


## 4. Discussion

### 4.1. Precipitation Kinetics

Figures11 and 12 show the time temperature precipitation diagrams for JJ1 and JN1 steel samples, respectively, which summarize the phases detected in the aged samples by the anodic polarization curves for these steels. It is clear from these figures that the intergranular precipitation sequence is the following:(1)austenite⟶austenite+Cr23C6⟶austenite+Cr23C6+Cr2N.Figure 11
Time-temperature precipitation diagram of JJ1 steel.Figure 12
Time-temperature precipitation diagram of JN1 steel.It can also be observed that of intergranular precipitation for the JN1 steel is faster than that of the JJ1 steel because of its higher-interstitial solute content. In general, these precipitation characteristics show a good agreement with the XRD and SEM microstructural characterization of these two steels. It is important to mention that the electrochemical test could not detect the presence of the transgranularη phase precipitates since this test dissolves preferentially the intergranular precipitates, as explained above. Additionally, same type of TTP diagrams has been reported for these steels using metallographic techniques [13].


### 4.2. Effect of Precipitation on Toughness

The highest degradation in toughness for JN1 steel is associated with the volume fraction of intergranular precipitation formed during the thermal aging, as shown by the electrochemical analysis. An abundant presence of intergranular precipitates causes the reduction of cohesive strength of grain boundaries [14]. This is also confirmed by the increase in the intergranular brittle fracture as the thermal aging progresses. According to the results of electrochemical characterization, the presence of more than one peak in the anodic polarization curve seems to be enough to cause the aging-induced embrittlement. This embrittlement becomes more severe if the current density of dissolution peaks increases since the volume fraction of intergranular precipitates also increases. That is, the aging-induced embrittlement might be evaluated by means of this electrochemical method.


## 4.1. Precipitation Kinetics

Figures11 and 12 show the time temperature precipitation diagrams for JJ1 and JN1 steel samples, respectively, which summarize the phases detected in the aged samples by the anodic polarization curves for these steels. It is clear from these figures that the intergranular precipitation sequence is the following:(1)austenite⟶austenite+Cr23C6⟶austenite+Cr23C6+Cr2N.Figure 11
Time-temperature precipitation diagram of JJ1 steel.Figure 12
Time-temperature precipitation diagram of JN1 steel.It can also be observed that of intergranular precipitation for the JN1 steel is faster than that of the JJ1 steel because of its higher-interstitial solute content. In general, these precipitation characteristics show a good agreement with the XRD and SEM microstructural characterization of these two steels. It is important to mention that the electrochemical test could not detect the presence of the transgranularη phase precipitates since this test dissolves preferentially the intergranular precipitates, as explained above. Additionally, same type of TTP diagrams has been reported for these steels using metallographic techniques [13].


## 4.2. Effect of Precipitation on Toughness

The highest degradation in toughness for JN1 steel is associated with the volume fraction of intergranular precipitation formed during the thermal aging, as shown by the electrochemical analysis. An abundant presence of intergranular precipitates causes the reduction of cohesive strength of grain boundaries [14]. This is also confirmed by the increase in the intergranular brittle fracture as the thermal aging progresses. According to the results of electrochemical characterization, the presence of more than one peak in the anodic polarization curve seems to be enough to cause the aging-induced embrittlement. This embrittlement becomes more severe if the current density of dissolution peaks increases since the volume fraction of intergranular precipitates also increases. That is, the aging-induced embrittlement might be evaluated by means of this electrochemical method.


## 5. Conclusions

The electrochemical analysis of the aged JJ and JN steels conducted to the following conclusions.(1)
The anodic polarization test in a 1 N KOH solution permitted to detect the presence of intergranular Cr23C6 carbide and Cr2N nitride precipitates in the austenitic matrix.(2)
The volume fraction of intergranular precipitation is higher as the aging temperature and time increase for both the tested JN1 and JJ1 steels.(3)
The aging-induced embrittlement may be present if the dissolution peak of intergranular Cr23C6 carbide and Cr2N nitride precipitates is detected in the anodic curve of the aged steels.



---

*Source: 210209-2011-12-06.xml*