# Ku Band Hemispherical Fully Electronic Antenna for Aircraft in Flight Entertainment

Authors: Alfredo Catalani; Franco Di Paolo; Marzia Migliorelli; Lino Russo; Giovanni Toso; Piero Angeletti
Journal: International Journal of Antennas and Propagation
 (2009)

---

## Abstract

The results obtained in the frame of the ESA activity “Advanced Antenna Concepts For Aircraft In Flight Entertainment” are presented. The aim of the activity consists in designing an active antenna able to guarantee the Ku band link between an aircraft and a geostationary satellite in order to provide in flight entertainment services. The transmit-receive antenna generates a single narrow beam to be steered electronically in a half sphere remaining compliant with respect to stringent requirements in terms of pattern shape, polarization alignment, EIRP, G/T, and using customized electronic devices. At the same time, the proposed solution should be competitive in terms of cost and complexity.


---

## Body

## 1. Introduction

Over the last few years the public's reliance on computer networks including, but not limited to, Internet has increased exponentially. Many people today use Internet for business and entertainment. Aeronautical broadband services provisioning  by satellites are becoming a reality moving from an experimental base to an operational condition.Aircrafts use antennas for transmitting and receiving communication signals. Key aspects to consider in the design of these antennas are the aerodynamic drag, the beam pointing capability, and the receive/transmit functionality.Concerning the aerodynamic aspects,  the antenna has to exhibit the minimum impact on the aircraft in order to reduce the extra fuel consumption due to the drag of the antenna installed on the fuselage. As a rule of thumb, the height of antennas on board large aircrafts and inclusive of the radome should not exceed30/40 cm.Concerning the beam pointing characteristics, to be operative both at equatorial routes as well as at the extreme latitudes required by polar routes, the preferred antenna solution should exhibit wide-angle beam scanning capabilities.The possible antenna architectures 0 are based on fully mechanical [1], fully electronic [2], or “hybrid” (mechanical-electronic) solutions [3, 4].Complexity and cost of the antenna are other key factors to consider together with ability to operate simultaneously in reception and in transmission.The principal target, in terms of antenna characteristics, is the operation in the complete Ku Band (10.7/12.75 GHz in receive, 14.0/14.5 GHz in transmit) and the realignment of the polarization with respect to the satellite for both receive and transmit signals, with the capability to operate also with the circular polarization in receive signals.The minimum antenna requirements in terms of operative Field of View, G/T, EIRP, and cross polar discrimination are reported in Table1.Table 1
Antenna performances requirements.
RequirementsAntennaRadiation gain pattern over RF bandIn agreement with (*)Operative antenna field of view0°<φ< 360°0°<θ< 90°G/T over RF band, in the entire field of view and for every selectable polarization>8 dBK-1EIRP over RF band, in the entire field of view>43 dBWNumber of beams1Cross polarization discrimination (including pointing error)>15 dB(*) Ref. [5]Regulatory aspects [5] are also considered: an antenna in transmission mode has to respect the applicable regulations for the EIRP antenna patterns expressed in terms of power per bandwidth as shown in Figure 1.Figure 1
ETSI regulation mask [5].


## 2. Antenna Baseline Architecture

The proposed baseline antenna architecture is an evolution of the Hemi-Spherical Antenna Array shown in Figure2.Figure 2
Hemi-spherical array.This Antenna typology, due to its particular shape, once mounted on the aircraft is able to hold-on the appropriate link whatever the position of the airborne with respect to the satellite is.In order to minimize the complexity of the antenna, the Hemi-Spherical continuous surface has been organized in flat facets. The icosahedron, a polyhedron with twenty equilateral triangles, has been selected to replace the sphere. Besides, a further division of each triangular face (obtained projecting the vertices of the triangles on the sphere) has been implemented. As a result of a dedicated optimization, the geodesic hemi-sphere with 40 facets shown in Figure3 has been considered the geometrical candidate for the presented antenna. Each triangular face exhibits the same identical subarray; therefore the same number of radiating elements disposed on a triangular lattice.Figure 3
Faceted hemi-spherical antenna.The final optimized antenna is combining on the same aperture of the receive-transmit capabilities, exhibiting a diameter of 84 cm, a height of 39 cm, and a weight in the order of 90 Kg. The number of radiating elements is 1440 with an interspacing comparable to the wavelength at the Tx higher frequency.Each triangular subarray, indicated astile, presents 36 radiating elements.For a fixed beam direction only a sector composed by 14 tiles is active while all the other elements are turned off. All the radiating elements in the active sector are excited in order to generate an equal-phase wave front perpendicular to the desired beam direction.The antenna block diagram, presented in Figure4, is representative of the antenna electrical architecture.Figure 4
Hemi-spherical antenna block diagram.The input/output ports are fed with the IF band signal, and they are converted in a Ku band signal by the up/down converter. Two dedicated beam forming networks1:40 for the receive and the transmit mode are connected to the tiles, and the CPU controls a set of switches in order to involve the selected subarrays to form the antenna beam. Each tile is composed by the radiating elements and the transmit/receive modules, directly connected behind. The CPU controls the beam steering and the polarization alignment.


## 3. Antenna Description

The antenna works simultaneously in reception and transmission on the entire Ku band (10.7 GHz/12.75 GHz in Rx; 14.0 GHz/14.5 GHz in Tx). A deep investigation, optimization, and trade-off  have been implemented in order to identify the wide-band radiating element.


### 3.1. Passive Radiating Module

Two possible solutions are envisaged:(i)
the first one is based on a wideband or dual band radiating element; in order to separate the receive signal from the transmit signal it is mandatory the use of a circulator or a diplexer;(ii)
the second one is based on a self-diplexing radiating element; this element presents four physical ports (two for Rx, two for Tx). The self-diplexing element has the advantage to minimize the ohmic losses, therefore improving both the G/T and the EIRP.The selected solution is based on a self-diplexing radiating element. It offers better electrical performances and permits reducing the manufacturing complexity.A prototype of the realized radiating element is shown in Figure5. The measured performances of the radiating elements in terms of Return Loss are reported in Figure 6. The isolation between the ports is better than 20 dB over the operative bands.Figure 5
Radiating element prototype.Figure 6
Measured radiating element return loss.The radiation patterns of the radiating element at the center frequency in the receive and transmit band are shown in Figures7 and 8.Figure 7
Simulated radiating pattern in receive.Figure 8
Simulated radiating pattern in transmit.


### 3.2. B. Tx/Rx Active Module

Each radiating element presents an active circuitry directly connected to the output ports (Tx/Rx module). The Tx/Rx module is able to realign the linear polarization in receive and in transmit or, otherwise, it is able to generate a circular polarization [6]. The phase shifters used for the polarization control are able at the same time to form the antenna beam imposing the correct relative phase between the elements. The active modules are composed by the receive device and the transmit device (the assembled Tx/Rx device is shown in Figure 9).Figure 9
Tx/Rx active module connected to the radiating element.The manufactured modules are presented in Figure10: in particular the control board sides  are shown.Figure 10
Tx and Rx active device—control board view.Their dimensions are 20.6× 7 × 37 mm3, with a weight of 15 g.As mentioned, each Tx/Rx Active Module is directly connected to the passive radiating elements (see Figure9), and they are arranged in a triangular lattice with a number of 36 in order to compose the triangular subarray, that is, the tile of the Hemi-Spherical Antenna (Figure 11).Figure 11
Tile of the hemi-spherical antenna.Two dedicated equal-amplitude and equal-phase beam forming networks combine the transmit and the receive signals coming from the active module (Figure12).Figure 12
Receive BFN layout.Using the micro-coaxial cable, all the Rx and Tx ports behind the tiles are combined in two dedicated switching BFNs that are able to transmit and receive the signal of the selected tile. As mentioned, only a dedicated number of tiles, 14, are active instantaneously depending on the azimuth and elevation beam pointing. A micro-PC  has controled all the active components taking into account the satellite position and the aircraft attitude. The beam forming network connecting the tiles is realized using commercial microwave components.The tiles are positioned on the shell-shaped structure, shown in Figure13, which can be manufactured by a casting process or by the assembly of simple part obtained by a numerical control machine.Figure 13
Antenna structure.The result of the assembled hemi-spherical antenna is presented in Figure14. Some details of the inner part considering the cable routing between the tiles and the switching beam forming network are presented in Figure 15.Figure 14
Assembled Hemi-Spherical antenna.Figure 15
Cable routing of a part of the antenna.


## 3.1. Passive Radiating Module

Two possible solutions are envisaged:(i)
the first one is based on a wideband or dual band radiating element; in order to separate the receive signal from the transmit signal it is mandatory the use of a circulator or a diplexer;(ii)
the second one is based on a self-diplexing radiating element; this element presents four physical ports (two for Rx, two for Tx). The self-diplexing element has the advantage to minimize the ohmic losses, therefore improving both the G/T and the EIRP.The selected solution is based on a self-diplexing radiating element. It offers better electrical performances and permits reducing the manufacturing complexity.A prototype of the realized radiating element is shown in Figure5. The measured performances of the radiating elements in terms of Return Loss are reported in Figure 6. The isolation between the ports is better than 20 dB over the operative bands.Figure 5
Radiating element prototype.Figure 6
Measured radiating element return loss.The radiation patterns of the radiating element at the center frequency in the receive and transmit band are shown in Figures7 and 8.Figure 7
Simulated radiating pattern in receive.Figure 8
Simulated radiating pattern in transmit.


## 3.2. B. Tx/Rx Active Module

Each radiating element presents an active circuitry directly connected to the output ports (Tx/Rx module). The Tx/Rx module is able to realign the linear polarization in receive and in transmit or, otherwise, it is able to generate a circular polarization [6]. The phase shifters used for the polarization control are able at the same time to form the antenna beam imposing the correct relative phase between the elements. The active modules are composed by the receive device and the transmit device (the assembled Tx/Rx device is shown in Figure 9).Figure 9
Tx/Rx active module connected to the radiating element.The manufactured modules are presented in Figure10: in particular the control board sides  are shown.Figure 10
Tx and Rx active device—control board view.Their dimensions are 20.6× 7 × 37 mm3, with a weight of 15 g.As mentioned, each Tx/Rx Active Module is directly connected to the passive radiating elements (see Figure9), and they are arranged in a triangular lattice with a number of 36 in order to compose the triangular subarray, that is, the tile of the Hemi-Spherical Antenna (Figure 11).Figure 11
Tile of the hemi-spherical antenna.Two dedicated equal-amplitude and equal-phase beam forming networks combine the transmit and the receive signals coming from the active module (Figure12).Figure 12
Receive BFN layout.Using the micro-coaxial cable, all the Rx and Tx ports behind the tiles are combined in two dedicated switching BFNs that are able to transmit and receive the signal of the selected tile. As mentioned, only a dedicated number of tiles, 14, are active instantaneously depending on the azimuth and elevation beam pointing. A micro-PC  has controled all the active components taking into account the satellite position and the aircraft attitude. The beam forming network connecting the tiles is realized using commercial microwave components.The tiles are positioned on the shell-shaped structure, shown in Figure13, which can be manufactured by a casting process or by the assembly of simple part obtained by a numerical control machine.Figure 13
Antenna structure.The result of the assembled hemi-spherical antenna is presented in Figure14. Some details of the inner part considering the cable routing between the tiles and the switching beam forming network are presented in Figure 15.Figure 14
Assembled Hemi-Spherical antenna.Figure 15
Cable routing of a part of the antenna.


## 4. Antenna Performances

The tracking capability of the antenna permits to point the beam electronically in a hemi-spherical field of view (i.e., 360 degrees in azimuth and 90 degrees in elevation) with reduced degradations of the electrical performances, guaranteeing a minimum G/T of 8 dB/K-1 and an EIRP of 43 dBW.The results are obtained using the simulated pattern of an embedded radiating element. Moreover, in the optimization of the excitation coefficients, the realistic functionality of the Rx/Tx active module (combining the amplitude and phase of the two orthogonal polarization for each radiating element) has been taken into account.The G/T is shown in Figure16: as can be seen, the performances match the required 8 dB/K in the entire field of view. The obvious decreasing of performance at the lower pointing angles is due to different orientation angles of the tiles, involved in the beam forming, with respect to the horizon. The typical azimuth receive antenna pattern is shown in Figure 17.Figure 16
G/T versus elevation angle over the horizon.Figure 17
Azimuth Rx Antenna Pattern at 11.7 GHz, considering a 30º elevation pointing over the horizon.In transmit all the active devices are able to work at the maximum power level, and the foreseen performance in term of EIRP is reported in Figure18: the minimum guaranteed performance is in the order of 43 dBW over the complete antenna field of view.Figure 18
EIRP versus elevation angle over the horizon.The antenna is also able to control the transmit antenna patterns side-lobe in order to respect the applicable regulatory recommendations such as ETSI in the European countries [5, 7] and the FCC in the United States.The typical azimuth transmit antenna pattern is presented in Figure19. The black line represents the mask that has been imposed in the optimization process (corresponding to the ETSI mask for 512 KHz bandwidth). Also the correspondent elevation transmit antenna pattern is shown in Figure 20.Figure 19
Typical Azimuth Tx Antenna Pattern at 14.25 GHz, 30º elevation pointing over the horizon.Figure 20
Typical Elevation Tx Antenna Pattern at 14.25 GHz, 30º elevation pointing over the horizon.


## 5. Conclusion

In the paper the results of the activities carried out in the frame of the ESA Contract “Advanced Antenna Concepts For Aircraft In Flight Entertainment” have been presented.The designed Ku band active antenna exhibits a compact size and the possibility of full beam pointing coverage. The antenna radiating element module is providing also polarization alignment capabilities in transmission and reception.The antenna exhibits really good technical  performances. The next activities will be focused on reducing dimension, cost, and complexity of the entire antenna in order to meet the severe expectation of a market product.



---

*Source: 230650-2009-05-24.xml*