# Effect of Boron Foliar Application on Reproductive Growth of Sunflower (Helianthus annuus L.)

Authors: M. M. Al-Amery; J. H. Hamza; M. P. Fuller
Journal: International Journal of Agronomy
 (2011)

---

## Abstract

A study was carried out to determine the response of open pollinated sunflower (Helianthus annuusL. cv. Shumos) to boron fertilizer. Spring and autumn grown plots were sprayed with boron (0, 50, 100, 150, 200, and 250 mg L−1) in a randomized complete block design. The results showed that boron and green Leaf area/LAI measured at the end of seed filling were linearly related in the spring crop. In the autumn crop, the relationship between boron and dry matter yield was linear, and applications above 100 mg L−1 significantly increased dry matter compared to the control. For the autumn crop, 100, 200, and 250 mg L−1 significantly increased seed number compared to the control, but only the 150 mg L−1 treatment increased seed weight significantly. Boron tended to decrease the empty seed percentage, and for the spring crop, this was incremental and linear with applications above 150 mg L−1 leading to significant reductions in empty seed percentage. Seed yield increased linearly in the autumn crop in response to boron, and 200 and 250 mg L−1 applications gave significant increases in yield compared to the control.


---

## Body

## 1. Introduction

Sunflower is the third most important oilseed crop in the Middle East after soybean and palm oil and has diverse markets for both oilseed and nonoilseed use including both as a bird food and as a human snack food [1]. Commercial sunflower production in Iraq is currently less than expected because of a variety of reasons including, suboptimal agricultural practices especially in regard to soil management and damage caused by bird attack either at sowing, germination, or flowering stages. Two sowing seasons are commonly used in Iraq, spring (for summer harvest) and summer (for autumn harvest) with a slightly higher yield potential associated with spring sowing due to more suitable growing temperatures. High temperatures at flowering and seed formation stages leads to pollen death and decreased seed fertility, and empty seed can form a high percentage at maturity exceeding 50% in some cultivars [2, 3]. Sunflower pollination is best performed by insects and in commercial fields honeybees are reported to be the most suitable pollinating vectors [2, 3]. Even under optimal honeybee activity in nonoilseed sunflower crops relatively large proportions (15–50%) of seeds can remain empty. The same problem has also been found in oilseed sunflowers but on a smaller scale [4].Empty seeds are primarily located in the proximal (central) and distal (peripheral) regions of the capitulum [4]. It has been suggested that the empty seeds result from several unrelated factors including boron deficiency. Boron deficiency symptoms usually appear on leaves, stems, and reproductive parts [5–7] eventually manifesting as stem corkiness, deformed capitulum, poor seed set and lower seed yield. It has been reported that boron is also required for pollen germination and pollen tube growth [8], and boron deficiency at flowering can affect pollen viability and abortion of stamens and pistils [9–12] which contributes to low seed set. The boron requirement of many plants during reproductive growth is reputedly much higher than during vegetative growth [13, 14], a finding recently demonstrated in sunflower [5]. The functional boron in planta has been associated with water availability, sugar translocation, cation and anion absorption, and metabolism of N, P, carbohydrate, and fat [15]. Sunflower, has been found to be particularly sensitive to boron deficiency and is sometimes used as an indicator for assessing available boron in soils [14]. Although Boron is essential for crop growth and can be applied to meet crop demands, harmful effects can be induced by excessive applications during early phases of growth [14, 15]. Yield and the component vegetative and reproductive stages of sunflower may both be affected both positively and negatively by boron depending upon the dose used as a fertilizer. To date very few studies have addressed the effectiveness of different minerals on the pollination of sunflower and the influence of optimum boron concentration on confection sunflowers has not been reported. The major objective of the present study was to evaluate the effect of yield characters of different concentrations of foliar boron applied boron before flowering.


## 2. Materials and Methods

Field trials using a randomized complete block design with three replications were conducted during both spring and autumn seasons (2009) at the gardens of the biology department, College of Science for Women, Baghdad University, to study the effect on yield of boron foliar fertilizer on an open pollinated sunflower cultivar (Shumoss). The soil type was a sandy loam (Table1). Sowing dates were the 10th March and 7th July in plots measuring 3 × 3 m with four rows with an interrow distance of 75 cm and within row distance of 20 cm to reach an optimum population density of 71,500 plants ha−1 [16]. The amount of nutrient applied was 400 kg N ha−1as urea and 280 kg P2O5 ha−1 as superphosphate. Boron was applied at six concentrations (0, 50, 100, 150, 200, 250 mg L−1) as boric acid (H3BO3). The plants were sprayed manually at the beginning of flowering during the early morning with 15 litres per plot (1.67 L m−2). Nitrogen was applied in 2 split doses. Hoe weeding and irrigation were carried out as needed. Ten plants from each plot were covered with polyethylene bags after flowering to protect them from bird attack at full maturity and these plants were subsequently used for full destructive analysis. Plants were harvested when the periphery of the flower head was a brown colour and its back was yellow to brown and felt hard with its head bent down and the petals wilted, and dry matter was measured on three plants per plot. Seed separation from sunflower heads was performed manually and air dried. Moisture content was measured using a digital moisture meter, and seed weights were corrected for all treatments to standard 8% moisture according to the international limit for seed storage of sunflower [16].Table 1
Soil characteristics.
Spring seasonAutumn seasonSoil textureSandy loamSandy loampH8.17.93Electrical conductivity (mmhos cm−1)4.453.9N (mg kg−1)28.222.4P (mg kg−1)15.3314.2K (mg kg−1)0.7910.746B (mg kg−1)1611O.M %0.90.8


### 2.1. Measured Characters

The width (L) of each green leaf per plant was measured after flowering was complete and the leaf area (LA) per plant calculated as follows, LA= 0.56 ∑L2 [17]. LAI was calculated from LA divided by the ground area per plant. Three harvested plants from each plot were cutup, put in paper bags and dried in an oven at 70°C for 48 h, weighed [10], and then multiplied by the average population density to evaluate total dry matter (t ha−1). Head area was calculated as: radius of head *3.14 [16]. Seed separation from sunflower heads was performed manually and seed number counted. Weight of a random sample of 100 filled seed was corrected to 8% moisture after determination of seed moisture using a moisture meter. A random sample of 25 g of seed was taken from each treatment and visually examined to determine the full and empty seeds and the % empty seed calculated. Seed yield (t ha−1) was estimated by multiplying the average plant yield after correction to 8% moisture multiplied by plant population density. Harvest index was calculated by dividing grain yield by total dry matter [18].


### 2.2. Statistical Analysis

The data collected were subjected to analysis of variance (ANOVA), and differences between means were evaluated using least significant differences (LSD) [19].


## 2.1. Measured Characters

The width (L) of each green leaf per plant was measured after flowering was complete and the leaf area (LA) per plant calculated as follows, LA= 0.56 ∑L2 [17]. LAI was calculated from LA divided by the ground area per plant. Three harvested plants from each plot were cutup, put in paper bags and dried in an oven at 70°C for 48 h, weighed [10], and then multiplied by the average population density to evaluate total dry matter (t ha−1). Head area was calculated as: radius of head *3.14 [16]. Seed separation from sunflower heads was performed manually and seed number counted. Weight of a random sample of 100 filled seed was corrected to 8% moisture after determination of seed moisture using a moisture meter. A random sample of 25 g of seed was taken from each treatment and visually examined to determine the full and empty seeds and the % empty seed calculated. Seed yield (t ha−1) was estimated by multiplying the average plant yield after correction to 8% moisture multiplied by plant population density. Harvest index was calculated by dividing grain yield by total dry matter [18].


## 2.2. Statistical Analysis

The data collected were subjected to analysis of variance (ANOVA), and differences between means were evaluated using least significant differences (LSD) [19].


## 3. Results

### 3.1. Leaf Area (LA) m2 and Leaf Area Index (LAI)

LA and LAI are considered good surrogate measures of plant and crop photosynthesis which is an important factor of growth rate and eventual grain yield. There was a significant incremental effect of Boron on LA and LAI at both sowing dates (Figure1). In the spring crop Boron and LA/LAI were related linearly (LAy=0.0294x+0.4047, R2=0.78), (LAIy=0.2103x+2.8908, R2=0.78), and an increase of 1% of Boron concentration increased LA and LAI at the end of flowering by 0.4047% and 2.8908%, respectively. Applications of 150, 200, and 250 mg L−1 resulted in significant increases of LA and LAI compared to the control. In the autumn crop the relationship between boron and LA, LAI was less clear and whilst 150, 200, and 250 mg L−1 boron significantly (P<0.05) increased LA and LAI compared to the control, applications of 50 and 100 mg L−1 significantly (P<0.05) decreased LA and LAI compared to the control.Figure 1
Effect of foliar applied boron on leaf area index (LAI) in spring (filled columns) and autumn (open columns) sunflower crops. (LSD0.05 0.420 and 0.277, resp.).


### 3.2. Total Dry Matter (t ha−1) at Harvest

Dry matter was increased by increased application of boron (Figure2). In the spring crop the effect of boron was a linear increase up to 150 mg L−1, but thereafter there was a linear decrease. Only the 100 and 150 mg L−1 application significantly increased dry matter compared to the control. In the autumn sowing the relationship was linear (y=1.6367x+13.367, R2=0.8531), and applications above 100 mg L−1 significantly increased dry matter compared to the control.Figure 2
Effect of foliar applied boron on total dry matter (t ha−1) in spring (filled columns) and autumn (open columns) sunflower crops. (LSD0.051.890 and 3.889, resp.).


### 3.3. Head Area Characteristics

There were no significant differences of boron treatment on head area within sowing dates, but it was noted that heads on the spring plants were larger (300 to 400 cm2) than the autumn plants (250 to 300 cm2). The number of seeds per head was not affected to any great extent by boron applications with no significant differences in the spring crop. For the autumn crop 100, 200 and 250 mg L−1 significantly increased seed number compared to the control (Figure 3). Boron did not affect seed weight to any great extent, and there were no significant differences in the spring crop, and in the autumn crop only the 150 mg L−1 treatment increased seed weight significantly compared to the control (Figure 4).Figure 3
Effect of foliar applied boron on number of seed in head in spring (filled columns) and autumn (open columns) sunflower crops. (LSD0.05  124 and 174, resp.).Figure 4
Effect of foliar applied boron on weight of 100 seed in spring (filled columns) and autumn (open columns) sunflower crops. (LSD0.05  1.075 and 1.938, resp.).


### 3.4. Empty Seed Percentage %

Boron tended to decrease the empty seed percentage, and for the spring crop this was incremental and linear (y=1.2709x+17.257, R2=0.9757) with applications above 150 mg L−1 leading to significant reductions in empty seed percentage compared to the control. For the autumn crop there was a trend for reduction in empty seed percentage above applications of 150 mg L−1, but these decreases were not statistically significant (P>0.05) (Figure 5).Figure 5
Effect of foliar applied boron on empty seed percentage % in spring (filled columns) and autumn (open columns) sunflower crops. (LSD0.05  1.6 and N.S, resp.).


### 3.5. Seed Yield (t ha−1)

Seed yield increased linearly in the autumn crop (y=0.6645x+5.8777, R2=0.8519) in response to boron, and 200 and 250 mg L−1 boron applications gave significant increases in yield compared to the control. In the spring crop the trend was not as clear, and only the 200 mg L−1 application gave any significant increase compared to the control (Figure 6).Figure 6
Effect of foliar applied boron on grain yield (t ha−1) in Spring (filled columns) and autumn (open columns) sunflower crops. (LSD0.05  0.738 and 1.507, resp.).


### 3.6. Harvest Index %

There were no consistent effects on harvest index in response to boron, and differences were not significant compared with the control.


## 3.1. Leaf Area (LA) m2 and Leaf Area Index (LAI)

LA and LAI are considered good surrogate measures of plant and crop photosynthesis which is an important factor of growth rate and eventual grain yield. There was a significant incremental effect of Boron on LA and LAI at both sowing dates (Figure1). In the spring crop Boron and LA/LAI were related linearly (LAy=0.0294x+0.4047, R2=0.78), (LAIy=0.2103x+2.8908, R2=0.78), and an increase of 1% of Boron concentration increased LA and LAI at the end of flowering by 0.4047% and 2.8908%, respectively. Applications of 150, 200, and 250 mg L−1 resulted in significant increases of LA and LAI compared to the control. In the autumn crop the relationship between boron and LA, LAI was less clear and whilst 150, 200, and 250 mg L−1 boron significantly (P<0.05) increased LA and LAI compared to the control, applications of 50 and 100 mg L−1 significantly (P<0.05) decreased LA and LAI compared to the control.Figure 1
Effect of foliar applied boron on leaf area index (LAI) in spring (filled columns) and autumn (open columns) sunflower crops. (LSD0.05 0.420 and 0.277, resp.).


## 3.2. Total Dry Matter (t ha−1) at Harvest

Dry matter was increased by increased application of boron (Figure2). In the spring crop the effect of boron was a linear increase up to 150 mg L−1, but thereafter there was a linear decrease. Only the 100 and 150 mg L−1 application significantly increased dry matter compared to the control. In the autumn sowing the relationship was linear (y=1.6367x+13.367, R2=0.8531), and applications above 100 mg L−1 significantly increased dry matter compared to the control.Figure 2
Effect of foliar applied boron on total dry matter (t ha−1) in spring (filled columns) and autumn (open columns) sunflower crops. (LSD0.051.890 and 3.889, resp.).


## 3.3. Head Area Characteristics

There were no significant differences of boron treatment on head area within sowing dates, but it was noted that heads on the spring plants were larger (300 to 400 cm2) than the autumn plants (250 to 300 cm2). The number of seeds per head was not affected to any great extent by boron applications with no significant differences in the spring crop. For the autumn crop 100, 200 and 250 mg L−1 significantly increased seed number compared to the control (Figure 3). Boron did not affect seed weight to any great extent, and there were no significant differences in the spring crop, and in the autumn crop only the 150 mg L−1 treatment increased seed weight significantly compared to the control (Figure 4).Figure 3
Effect of foliar applied boron on number of seed in head in spring (filled columns) and autumn (open columns) sunflower crops. (LSD0.05  124 and 174, resp.).Figure 4
Effect of foliar applied boron on weight of 100 seed in spring (filled columns) and autumn (open columns) sunflower crops. (LSD0.05  1.075 and 1.938, resp.).


## 3.4. Empty Seed Percentage %

Boron tended to decrease the empty seed percentage, and for the spring crop this was incremental and linear (y=1.2709x+17.257, R2=0.9757) with applications above 150 mg L−1 leading to significant reductions in empty seed percentage compared to the control. For the autumn crop there was a trend for reduction in empty seed percentage above applications of 150 mg L−1, but these decreases were not statistically significant (P>0.05) (Figure 5).Figure 5
Effect of foliar applied boron on empty seed percentage % in spring (filled columns) and autumn (open columns) sunflower crops. (LSD0.05  1.6 and N.S, resp.).


## 3.5. Seed Yield (t ha−1)

Seed yield increased linearly in the autumn crop (y=0.6645x+5.8777, R2=0.8519) in response to boron, and 200 and 250 mg L−1 boron applications gave significant increases in yield compared to the control. In the spring crop the trend was not as clear, and only the 200 mg L−1 application gave any significant increase compared to the control (Figure 6).Figure 6
Effect of foliar applied boron on grain yield (t ha−1) in Spring (filled columns) and autumn (open columns) sunflower crops. (LSD0.05  0.738 and 1.507, resp.).


## 3.6. Harvest Index %

There were no consistent effects on harvest index in response to boron, and differences were not significant compared with the control.


## 4. Discussion

The results of this experiment show clearly that boron fertilizer applied as a spray to sunflower plants at the beginning of flowering can have significant effects on seed set and seed yield. The boron was applied at the end of the vegetative stage, so it was not expected to have an effect on vegetative growth and development, but it clearly had a small but consistent effect on the green leaf area persistence at the end of flowering with higher levels of boron leading to greater LAI presumably through improved leaf area duration. This may be responsible for the consistent increased biomass that was measured. Seed yields also rose consistently with increases in boron application, and this may also be through a prolonged photosynthetic capacity during flowering and seed set or through improved partitioning from the increased biomass.The biggest effect of applied boron was the increase in seed yield, and this is partly due to the decrease in seed sterility, a 5% reduction in the spring crop, but also to small but incremental increases in seed size. The biggest measured effect was on biomass in the autumn crop which led to a consistent linear improvement in the seed yield. The results show that it is agronomically useful to apply boron to sunflower at the start of flowering, and more consistent effects are achieved at application levels of 1.67 L m−2 of 200 to 250 mg L−1 Boron.



---

*Source: 230712-2011-11-01.xml*