# Clinical Application of Thoracoscopic Resection of Anterior Mediastinal Tumors under the Xiphoid Process

Authors: Xingfeng Zhu; Kuanzhe Jin; Xiaobo Wu; Guiping Yu
Journal: BioMed Research International
 (2022)

---

## Abstract

Objective. To explore the feasibility and advantages of thoracoscopic resection of anterior mediastinal tumors through subxiphoid and lateral thoracic approaches. Method. 74 patients with anterior mediastinal tumors hospitalized in our hospital from January 2019 to January 2022 were retrospectively analyzed. They were divided into the lateral chest group (31 cases) and the infraxiphoid group (43 cases) according to different operation methods. The tumor size, operation time, intraoperative bleeding, postoperative pain score, postoperative complications, postoperative drainage tube removal time, and hospital stay were compared between the two groups. Result. The intraoperative bleeding and postoperative pain scores in the subxiphoid group were better than those in the lateral chest group. There was no significant difference in operation time and postoperative complications between the two groups. Conclusion. Compared with the lateral thoracic approach, the thoracoscopic subxiphoid approach can be more safe and effective in resectioning anterior mediastinal tumors.


---

## Body

## 1. Introduction

Anterior mediastinal tumors are common diseases in thoracic surgery and are often treated clinically by surgical means. The traditional open thoracotomy incision is large, which is easy to increase the pain of the patient, and it is also easy to cause postoperative complications such as sternum infection, which is not conducive to the patient’s postoperative recovery [1]. Thoracoscopic resection has been widely used in treating clinical diseases because of its advantages of minimally invasive, small incision, small intraoperative bleeding, and mild postoperative pain [2]. Early thoracoscopic resection of anterior mediastinal tumor often uses the lateral thoracic approach, but it is easy to cause damage to the intercostal nerves and muscles of patients, causing acute and chronic pain after surgery, which is not conducive to postoperative recovery [3]. Therefore, new surgical approaches must be found to reduce intercostal injuries and postoperative pain. Thoracoscopic resection of anterior mediastinal tumors under the xiphoid process was first reported by Hsu in 2002 [4]. This method has been gradually popularized with the development of video-assisted thoracoscopy in recent years [5–8]. The visual field of thoracoscopic resection of anterior mediastinal tumors via the subxiphoid process approach is obviously better than that of the lateral thoracic approach [9]. However, because most thoracic surgeons are more accustomed to lateral thoracic approaches, there is a big difference between the subxiphoid and lateral thoracic approaches [10–13]. Therefore, thoracoscopic resection of anterior mediastinal tumors under the xiphoid process has not been very popular at present. We retrospectively analyzed 74 patients with anterior mediastinal tumors who underwent surgery in our hospital from January 2019 to January 2022. They were divided into the lateral chest group (31 cases) and the subxiphoid process group (43 cases) according to different surgical methods. The advantages and disadvantages of the two surgical methods were compared.


## 2. Materials and Methods

### 2.1. General Information

A total of 74 patients with anterior mediastinal tumor who were hospitalized in our hospital from January 2019 to January 2022, including 38 males and 36 females aged 16-77 years, underwent thoracoscopic subxiphoid resection of anterior mediastinal tumor 43. For example, 31 cases of anterior mediastinal tumor resection were performed by thoracoscopic lateral thoracic surgery. All patients successfully completed the operation and were discharged from the hospital after recovery. Pulmonary infection occurred in 3 cases after the operation, and pneumothorax occurred in 2 cases after extubation. The pathological diagnosis is shown in Table1.Table 1
Statistical table of primary diseases of 74 patients with mediastinal tumors.
DiagnosisCaseThymoma41Thymocyst9Bronchogenic cyst6Hyperplasia of thymus gland5Thymic squamous cell carcinoma4Thymolipoma1Tumor-like hyperplasia of thymus adipose tissue1Ectopic parathyroid1Cavernous hemangioma1Lymphangioma1Diffuse large B cell lymphoma1Mediastinal cyst1Breast cancer metastasis1Neuroblastoma1Total74


### 2.2. Surgical Methods and Perioperative Management

The patients who underwent lateral thoracic approach took the resection of the thymic tumor through the right thoracoscope as an example. After successful anesthesia (double-lumen endotracheal intubation), the left lateral decubitus position was taken, and the 1 cm incision was made into the fifth intercostal space of the right midaxillary line as the observation hole, and the thoracic lens was placed. The 2 cm incision was made as the main operation hole at the fourth intercostal space, and the 1 cm incision was made as the auxiliary operation hole at the third interaxillary anterior line. The mediastinal pleura was opened in front of the phrenic nerve from the inferior pole of the thymus, and the pleura was opened along the lower part of the internal thoracic vessels. The ultrasonic knife was used to separate the thymic tissue from the pericardium and sternum, and the attractor pushed open the contralateral mediastinal pleura and dissociated the left inferior pole of the thymus. The isthmus of the thymus was exposed upward, and the thymic vein was severed. Dissociate to the left near the beginning of the internal thoracic vessels on the right and the surface of the adjacent superior vena cava, and then, dissociate the superior pole of the right lobe of the thymus after exposing the origin of the left innominate vein. Pull the inferior pole of the right lobe of the thymus backward and downward, continue to dissociate the space between the superior pole of the thymus and the sternum to the upper pole of the left lobe, and completely remove all the thymic tissue, including the tumor. A chest tube was retained after the operation. After the operation, the chest tube was removed and discharged according to the drainage condition.For patients with a subxiphoid approach, thoracoscopic resection of the subxiphoid thymic tumor was taken as an example. Anesthesia (single-lumen endotracheal intubation) was completed, the patient was in a horizontal position, and the legs were separated. The subxiphoid process 1 cm incision was taken as the observation hole, and the thoracoscopic lens was placed. The left and right subcostal arch clavicle midlines were used for 1 cm and 0.5 cm incisions, respectively. The ultrasonic scalpel was used to open the retrosternal space and open the mediastinal pleura on both sides. It was freed upwards from the retrosternum to the lower pole of the thyroid. According to the exposure of the retrosternal space, a sternal suspension hook was placed next to the second intercostal sternum. The mediastinal pleura was opened from the medial side of the phrenic nerves on both sides, and the lower poles of the bilateral thymus were freed to the isthmus of the thymus in front of the pericardium. Hem-o-lock was applied to disconnect the thymic vein and move upstream to the inferior pole of the thyroid on the surface of the left anonymous vein. After dissociating the superior pole of the two sides of the thymus, all the thymus tissues including tumors were completely resected. One Jackson-Pratt drainage tube was placed in the anterior mediastinum. Patients were discharged after removal of drainage tube according to postoperative drainage.


### 2.3. Statistical Method

SPSS 26.0 (IBM Inc., Chicago, IL, USA) software was used for statistical analysis, and the counting data were expressed in terms of frequency and percentage,χ2 test, mean±standard deviation, t test, and Mann–Whitney U test, respectively. The statistical significance was P<0.05.


## 2.1. General Information

A total of 74 patients with anterior mediastinal tumor who were hospitalized in our hospital from January 2019 to January 2022, including 38 males and 36 females aged 16-77 years, underwent thoracoscopic subxiphoid resection of anterior mediastinal tumor 43. For example, 31 cases of anterior mediastinal tumor resection were performed by thoracoscopic lateral thoracic surgery. All patients successfully completed the operation and were discharged from the hospital after recovery. Pulmonary infection occurred in 3 cases after the operation, and pneumothorax occurred in 2 cases after extubation. The pathological diagnosis is shown in Table1.Table 1
Statistical table of primary diseases of 74 patients with mediastinal tumors.
DiagnosisCaseThymoma41Thymocyst9Bronchogenic cyst6Hyperplasia of thymus gland5Thymic squamous cell carcinoma4Thymolipoma1Tumor-like hyperplasia of thymus adipose tissue1Ectopic parathyroid1Cavernous hemangioma1Lymphangioma1Diffuse large B cell lymphoma1Mediastinal cyst1Breast cancer metastasis1Neuroblastoma1Total74


## 2.2. Surgical Methods and Perioperative Management

The patients who underwent lateral thoracic approach took the resection of the thymic tumor through the right thoracoscope as an example. After successful anesthesia (double-lumen endotracheal intubation), the left lateral decubitus position was taken, and the 1 cm incision was made into the fifth intercostal space of the right midaxillary line as the observation hole, and the thoracic lens was placed. The 2 cm incision was made as the main operation hole at the fourth intercostal space, and the 1 cm incision was made as the auxiliary operation hole at the third interaxillary anterior line. The mediastinal pleura was opened in front of the phrenic nerve from the inferior pole of the thymus, and the pleura was opened along the lower part of the internal thoracic vessels. The ultrasonic knife was used to separate the thymic tissue from the pericardium and sternum, and the attractor pushed open the contralateral mediastinal pleura and dissociated the left inferior pole of the thymus. The isthmus of the thymus was exposed upward, and the thymic vein was severed. Dissociate to the left near the beginning of the internal thoracic vessels on the right and the surface of the adjacent superior vena cava, and then, dissociate the superior pole of the right lobe of the thymus after exposing the origin of the left innominate vein. Pull the inferior pole of the right lobe of the thymus backward and downward, continue to dissociate the space between the superior pole of the thymus and the sternum to the upper pole of the left lobe, and completely remove all the thymic tissue, including the tumor. A chest tube was retained after the operation. After the operation, the chest tube was removed and discharged according to the drainage condition.For patients with a subxiphoid approach, thoracoscopic resection of the subxiphoid thymic tumor was taken as an example. Anesthesia (single-lumen endotracheal intubation) was completed, the patient was in a horizontal position, and the legs were separated. The subxiphoid process 1 cm incision was taken as the observation hole, and the thoracoscopic lens was placed. The left and right subcostal arch clavicle midlines were used for 1 cm and 0.5 cm incisions, respectively. The ultrasonic scalpel was used to open the retrosternal space and open the mediastinal pleura on both sides. It was freed upwards from the retrosternum to the lower pole of the thyroid. According to the exposure of the retrosternal space, a sternal suspension hook was placed next to the second intercostal sternum. The mediastinal pleura was opened from the medial side of the phrenic nerves on both sides, and the lower poles of the bilateral thymus were freed to the isthmus of the thymus in front of the pericardium. Hem-o-lock was applied to disconnect the thymic vein and move upstream to the inferior pole of the thyroid on the surface of the left anonymous vein. After dissociating the superior pole of the two sides of the thymus, all the thymus tissues including tumors were completely resected. One Jackson-Pratt drainage tube was placed in the anterior mediastinum. Patients were discharged after removal of drainage tube according to postoperative drainage.


## 2.3. Statistical Method

SPSS 26.0 (IBM Inc., Chicago, IL, USA) software was used for statistical analysis, and the counting data were expressed in terms of frequency and percentage,χ2 test, mean±standard deviation, t test, and Mann–Whitney U test, respectively. The statistical significance was P<0.05.


## 3. Result

The general conditions of the two groups were compared in Table2. There were significant differences in age and disease types between the subxiphoid process operation group and the lateral chest operation group (P<0.05). There was no significant difference in gender composition between the two groups (P>0.05).Table 2
Comparison of clinical data of 74 patients with mediastinal tumor resection.
CharacteristicTotal numberLateral chest groupSubxiphoid groupP valueAge (years)57.2±12.260.9±9.854.1±13.20.005Sexuality (n, %)Male38 (51.4)18 (58.1)20 (46.5)0.330Female36 (48.6)13 (41.9)23 (53.5)Disease (n, %)Thymic diseases60 (81.1)30 (96.8)30 (69.8)0.003Nonthymus diseases14 (18.9)1 (3.2)13 (30.2)The comparison of surgical data between the two groups is shown in Table3. There was a significant difference in the tumor length diameter between the two groups (P<0.05), and there was no significant difference in the operation time between the two groups (P>0.05). The intraoperative blood loss between the two groups showed that the lateral chest group was more than the subxiphoid group; there was a significant difference (P<0.05). Three days after the operation, the visual pain scores of the two groups were compared, and the subxiphoid group was lower than the lateral chest group on the first day and the third day, and there was a significant difference between the two groups (P<0.05). There was no significant difference between the two groups on the second day after the operation (P>0.05). There was no significant difference in the incidence of postoperative complications between the two groups (P>0.05). The postoperative drainage tube indwelling time and hospital stay in the two groups were longer in the subxiphoid group than in the lateral thoracic group, and there was a significant difference between the two groups (P<0.05).Table 3
Comparison of surgical data of 74 patients with mediastinal tumor.
CharacteristicLateral chest groupSubxiphoidP valueTumor length diameter (mm)55.8±25.342.5±28.00.039Operation time (min)108.5±32.7116.5±41.90.379Intraoperative bleeding (ml)60.0±52.334.2±32.70.011Postoperative pain scoreFirst day2.8±1.02.9±0.30.046Second day3.1±1.42.4±0.50.107Third day2.2±0.42.0±0.30.003Postoperative complications (n, %)2 (6.5)3 (7.0)0.653Postoperative extubation time (days)2.5±0.94.5±3.0<0.001Hospitalization days (days)9.5±3.114.7±9.30.004The curve fitting of the length of operation and the tumor length diameter in the two groups is shown in Figures1 and 2.Figure 1
Curve fitting of operation time and the tumor length diameter in the subxiphoid group.Figure 2
Curve fitting of operation time and the tumor length diameter in the lateral chest group.


## 4. Discussion

The anterior mediastinum is also known as the prevascular space, the anterior boundary is the sternum, the posterior boundary is the hypothetical interface formed by the pericardium and large vessels, the upper boundary is the innominate artery, and the lower boundary is the septal muscle [14–16]. Traditional treatment of anterior mediastinal tumors or total thymectomy usually splits the sternum [17, 18]. If the tumor is inclined to one side of the chest, it can also be operated through the lateral thoracic intercostal incision. With the emergence of endoscopic technology, video-assisted thoracoscopy is gradually used in anterior mediastinal tumor resection [19, 20], but most of them are operated by lateral thoracic intercostal approach [21, 22]. This lateral thoracic approach to thoracoscopic surgery avoids splitting the sternum, reduces chest trauma, and is conducive to postoperative recovery. It is more suitable for resectioning anterior mediastinal tumors that protrude to one side of the thoracic cavity. For patients with tumors or who need total thymectomy, the lateral thoracic approach is not ideal for exposing the retrosternal space after the mediastinal pleura is opened. It is difficult to expose the structures above the innominate vein of the superior anterior mediastinum and the contralateral phrenic nerve, which is not ideal. The surgical approach is not a substitute for a midline incision that splits the sternum. Hsu first proposed a thoracoscopic subxiphoid approach for anterior mediastinal tumor resection in 2002 to avoid sternal splitting [4]. The advantage of this surgical method lies in its good surgical field, which can well expose the lesions and important structures of the anterior mediastinum. After the thoracoscopic subxiphoid approach opens the retrosternal space, the carbon dioxide artificial pneumothorax can be used to observe the bilateral thoracic cavity and fully expose the lesions of the anterior mediastinum. Lesions between lateral phrenic nerves, all pericardial fat pads and mediastinal adipose tissue. Its exposure is close to the median incision of the split sternum, which is significantly better than the lateral thoracic approach [23]. In addition, this operation only requires single-lumen intubation anesthesia and does not require single-lung ventilation, which has less damage to lung function and is conducive to postoperative recovery.When thoracoscopic anterior mediastinal tumor resection or thymectomy was performed via lateral thoracic approach, the posterior sternal space revealed after opening one mediastinal pleura was small, and it was difficult to expose the contralateral phrenic nerve even after opening the contralateral pleura [24]. Moreover, due to the occlusion of blood vessels in the chest, it is difficult to reveal the lesions and important structures above the level of the anonymous vein. Therefore, when removing the free suprathymoid on both sides of the whole thymus, it is necessary to pull down the thymus and remove the suprathymoid. This requires high skill for surgeons, and due to unsatisfactory exposure, there is a certain risk of bleeding. The above two problems can be avoided through the subxiphoid approach of thoracoscope.The first difficulty that thoracic surgeons encounter when performing a thoracoscopic subxiphoid approach is placing the puncture sheath and opening the retrosternal space. This procedure may be relatively easy in patients with a large substernal angle and a large retrosternal space, but in patients with a small substernal angle and a small retrosternal space, suboptimal placement of the puncture sheath and manipulation of the retrosternal space may be difficult. The surgery cannot be continued. Due to the need to travel a long distance in the soft tissue at the thoracic-abdominal junction, the puncture sheaths of the operation holes at the lower edge of the costal arch on both sides of the subxiphoid approach are limited in their mobility. This results in a reduction in the range of motion of operating instruments. Therefore, choosing the appropriate location when punching under the xiphoid process is critical. After punching and placing the puncture sheath, blunt dissection should be avoided to open the retrosternal space at the thoracoabdominal junction to avoid wound bleeding and affect the operative field of vision. It is precisely because the perforation and endoscopic operation of the subxiphoid approach is quite different from that of ordinary thoracoscopy, few doctors tried the subxiphoid surgical approach at first. At the beginning of the subxiphoid approach, we selected those patients whose tumors were not too large and whose general condition was good, which resulted in a certain difference in the comparison of age, disease type, and the tumor length diameter between the two groups.After 2014, more and more doctors began to try the thoracoscopic subxiphoid approach. They found that this method has the characteristics of good exposure to the operative field, less trauma, less complications, and less pain in patients [25–28]. And some doctors use video-assisted thoracoscopic subxiphoid approach for lobectomy [29]. The subxiphoid approach provides a minimally invasive surgical approach for anterior mediastinal tumors and expands the indications of minimally invasive thoracoscopic treatment for invasive anterior mediastinal tumors [30]. The thoracoscopic subxiphoid approach does not need to split the sternum or enter the chest on both sides. After lifting the anterior chest wall with carbon dioxide (CO2) artificial pneumothorax and sternal retractor, the subxiphoid approach has a very good field of vision and sufficient operating space, so it is effective for patients with myasthenia gravis who need anterior mediastinal tumor resection or thymectomy [31].The anterior mediastinum behind the sternum is the location where the subxiphoid approach provides better exposure and is more convenient to operate. However, surgery cannot be performed if the patient’s sternum angle and posterior sternum space are small. At this time, it is necessary to lift the anterior chest wall with the help of the sternal retractor to expand the retrosternal space to facilitate the operation. Sternal retractors are also suitable for surgical patients with larger tumors. Some studies have shown that the difficulty of thoracoscopic anterior mediastinal tumor resection lies in the invasion of the tumor to the surrounding important structures and blood vessels, rather than the size of the tumor [32]. However, in the operation of this group of cases, we experienced that larger tumors will increase the difficulty of operation. Thoracoscopic resection of anterior mediastinal tumors under the xiphoid process is a one-way operation from the bottom up. Suppose the size of the tumor is large. In that case, it will sometimes lead to difficulties in the operation of the upper part of the tumor, and this effect is greater than that of thoracoscopic surgery via lateral thoracic approach. After fitting the curve between the length of operation and the tumor length diameter, we can also see that there is a significant correlation between the size of the tumor and the length of operation, while the lateral thoracic approach is not so obvious.Another advantage of the thoracoscopic subxiphoid approach compared with the lateral thoracic approach is the operation above the level of innominate vein, especially in extended thymectomy, which can completely remove the upper pole of thymus and its surrounding adipose tissue. For patients with myasthenia gravis who need extended thymectomy, extended thymectomy reported by Masaoka in 1981 has become the standard surgical treatment for patients with myasthenia gravis [33]. Most thoracic surgeons use the anterior median incision approach with sternotomy, and some thoracic surgeons use the bilateral thoracoscopic lateral thoracic approach to perform total thymectomy and extended thymectomy. The thoracoscopic subxiphoid approach can also be a good way to complete the extended thymectomy [30, 34]. Anatomical operation above the level of anonymous vein is difficult in thoracoscopic lateral thoracic approach. However, when thoracoscopic surgery via subxiphoid approach is performed, this region can have a better surgical vision and more convenient operation. Therefore, subxiphoid approach surgery is more safe and feasible than the lateral thoracic approach [35]. A meta-analysis showed that the subxiphoid approach can achieve better and safer surgical and perioperative outcomes than the thoracoscopic lateral thoracic approach [24]. We compared the video of total thymectomy with two surgical approaches, and it can be seen intuitively that subxiphoid surgery can more easily and thoroughly dissect the upper thymic pole and surrounding adipose tissue below the lower thyroid pole. Due to the good surgical field and convenient operation, the 43 patients undergoing subxiphoid approach in this group did not experience bleeding leading to conversion to split sternum surgery, and the amount of blood loss was less than that in lateral thoracic approach. And there was no significant difference in the average operation time between the subxiphoid surgery group and the lateral thoracic surgery group.Another advantage of subxiphoid approach is that the postoperative pain is mild. Thoracoscopic lateral thoracotomy avoids the huge trauma of sternotomy, and the wound is less than the thoracotomy incision. However, the intercostal approach will inevitably damage the intercostal nerve and lead to postoperative pain. The incision of subxiphoid approach did not damage the intercostal nerve, and the postoperative pain was significantly lighter than that of the intercostal approach. In this group, 74 patients were treated with intravenous analgesia pump, nerve block anesthesia, postoperative oral analgesic drugs, external analgesic drugs, and a variety of analgesic drugs for injection due to the need for rapid rehabilitation after operation. Before the patients had unbearable pain, they were given adequate analgesic treatment. Even so, the pain scores on the first day and the third day after operation in the two groups were compared, and the scores in the subxiphoid group were lower than those in the lateral chest group, and there was significant difference between the two groups.There was no significant difference in the incidence of postoperative complications between the two groups, but the complications were different. We routinely used the Jackson-Pratt drainage tube instead of chest tube after subxiphoid approach, and the patient’s tolerance was significantly better than that of silicone chest tube placed between ribs in lateral thoracic surgery. However, since the subxiphoid process approach completely opens the mediastinal pleura on both sides, it is not easy to limit the infection of patients after operation. In order to fully drain, we prolonged the time of indwelling drainage tube, so the postoperative extubation time and hospitalization days were longer than those in the lateral chest group. In this group, three patients with secondary pulmonary infection after subxiphoid surgery resulted in pleural cavity and mediastinal infection and were cured and discharged after anti-infective treatment. There was no postoperative pulmonary infection in the lateral thoracic approach group of patients. However, the method of removing chest tube for 2–3 days was generally adopted due to chest tube pain. After extubation, two patients showed pneumothorax again. Therefore, we believe that the two surgical procedures have advantages and disadvantages in postoperative complications.


## 5. Conclusion

Thoracoscopic subxiphoid approach for anterior mediastinal tumor resection is more effective than thoracoscopic lateral thoracic approach for anterior mediastinal tumor resection.



---

*Source: 2012457-2022-08-23.xml*