# An Accelerated Test Method of Simultaneous Carbonation and Chloride Ion Ingress: Durability of Silica Fume Concrete in Severe Environments

Authors: S. A. Ghahari; A. M. Ramezanianpour; A. A. Ramezanianpour; M. Esmaeili
Journal: Advances in Materials Science and Engineering
 (2016)

---

## Abstract

The effects of simultaneous carbonation and chloride ion attack on mechanical characteristics and durability of concrete containing silica fume have been investigated through an accelerated test method. Specimens containing different amounts of silica fume were maintained in an apparatus in which carbon dioxide pressure and concentration and relative humidity were kept constant, and wetting and drying cycles in saline water were applied. Surface resistivity, sorptivity, CO2 consumption, and carbonation and chloride ion ingress depths measurements were taken. Phase change due to carbonation and chloride ion attack was monitored by XRD analysis, and microstructures and interfacial transition zones were studied by implementing SEM as well as mercury intrusion porosimetry. It was expected to have a synergistic effect in the tidal zone where simultaneous carbonation and chloride ion attack happen. However, the observed reduced surface resistivity, compared to specimens maintained in CO2 gas, could be due to the moisture that is available near the surface, hindering CO2 from penetrating into the pores of the specimens. Moreover, the porosity analysis of the specimens showed that the sample containing silica fume cured in the tidal zone had 50.1% less total porosity than the plain cement paste cured in the same condition.


---

## Body

## 1. Introduction

Deterioration of exposed structures, especially the ones made with concrete, may occur due to freezing and thawing cycles, sulfate attack, carbonation, and chloride ion attack [1]. Carbonation in such areas can take place due to pollution and chloride ion attack takes place because of sea water and/or deicing salts. In order to increase the strength and durability of concrete, blended cements or supplementary cementitious materials; that is, fly ash, limestone, silica fume, and so forth, should be used. By using such materials, reduction of carbon dioxide emissions to the atmosphere from the high energy consuming Portland cement clinker production, which affect environment, cost of production, and use of natural resources, would be achievable.Carbonation may cause corrosion in reinforced concrete structures by reducing the pH in the pore solution [1]. And it is widely known that the reduction in pH of the pore solution can cause a significant increase in the concentration of chloride ions in the pore solution [2]. By polymerizing silicate chains in C-S-H, volume decreases and shrinkage happens as well [3]. Extensive research has been performed on the deleterious effects of carbonation on durability [4, 5] and pore structure [6]. The reactions that take place in concrete microstructures are as follows [7]:(1)CaOH2+CO2⟶CaCO3+H2O(2)C-S-H+2CO2⟶SiO2+2CaCO3+H2OBy consumption of (OH)− in reaction (1), the pH of the pore solution decreases, which leads to an increase in the rate of corrosion [8] and a decrease in overall porosity [7, 9]. Reduction in pH value leads to destruction of the protective passive film around steel reinforcement [10, 11], resulting in rebar corrosion and cracking [3]. In marine environments where CO2 is available, such as the cities that are located adjacent to free waters, reaction (5) takes place through which CaCO3 is produced:(3)CO2+H2O⟶H2CO3(4)H2CO3+H2O⟶HCO3-+H3O+(5)HCO3-+H2O⟶CO32-+H3O+(6)H2CO3+CaOH2⟶CaCO3+2H2OAccording to reaction (5), H3O+ is the main cause of reduction in the pH [12].A few researchers have studied the effects of chloride ion attack on the diffusion and durability of concrete structures [13]. Kuzel’s salt (3CaO·Al2O3·0.5CaSO4·0.5CaCl2·10(11)H2O) and Friedel’s salt (3CaO·Al2O3·CaCl2·10H2O) can be formed where free chloride ions are available. The salts are considered hydrate calcium aluminate or AFm phases [14]. When chloride ions react with HC3, Friedel’s salt is formed. The chloride ion reaction with C4AF leads to the formation of Kuzel’s salt [15]. If Friedel’s salt gets carbonated, some chloride ions bound by it may dissolute into the pore solution, and an increase in chloride ions may lead to a higher chloride ion ingress rate. Such ions reach the reinforcement bars, and according to the following reaction, this causes corrosion:(7)Fe2++2Cl-⟶FeCl2(8)FeCl2+2H2O⟶FeOH2+2HClChloride-based deicing salts may harm infrastructures according to the following reactions [16] and a reduction in compressive strength and surface resistivity is caused by CaCl2 and Mg(OH)2: (9)CaOH2+MgCl2⟶MgOH2+CaCl2(10)3CaOH2+CaCl2+12H2O⟶3CaO+CaCl2+15H2OSome researchers have studied the effect of carbonation and chloride penetration separately [17]. When exposed to CO2, chloride binding is reduced [18]. If pH drops below 12, a high amount of bounded chlorides are released. Therefore, such chlorides are known as a potential risk for corrosion [19]. Carbonation, however, leads to a reduction in chloride binding [20] which then increases the rate of chloride ion ingress [21]. Aside from the recent research performed by the authors of this paper [22], few studies have been performed on the effect of combined carbonation and chloride ion attack on concrete, although it has been stated that both of these factors affect the durability of concrete structures [23]. Yoon proved that the carbonation rate while concrete is exposed to carbonation and chloride ion ingress is much slower compared with the single carbonation condition. When concrete is carbonated, free chloride content controls the total chloride content, because the concrete that is not carbonated has no binding capacity [23]. According to Yoon, when carbonation occurs, not only a decrease in pH but also a decrease in the binding capacity of chloride ions is highly possible. These changes will increase the risk of cracks due to corrosion. The effect of carbonation front progress in mortars containing fly ash in the presence of chloride ions has been studied recently [24]. In this paper, the effect of carbonation on the existence of chloride ions in specimens subjected to chloride ion ingress was investigated. Due to the refinement of the pores, it was found that specimens exposed to pure carbonation have more carbonation depth compared with the specimens subjected to chloride ion ingress and then carbonation.In this study, the effect of simultaneous carbonation and chloride ion attack on mechanical characteristics and durability of concrete containing silica fume have been investigated through an accelerated test method. Specimens containing different amounts of silica fume (0%, 7%, and 10%) and water-to-binder ratios (0.35, 0.4, and 0.45) were maintained in an apparatus in which carbon dioxide (CO2) pressure and concentration, ambient temperature, and relative humidity were kept constant, and wetting and drying cycles in saline water were applied automatically. The separate effects of carbonation and chloride ion attack were also investigated for the purpose of comparing the results. In order to evaluate the durability of silica fume concrete under simultaneous carbonation and chloride ion attack, measurements of water penetration, surface resistivity, sorptivity, CO2 consumption, carbonation, and chloride ion ingress depths were taken. In addition, phase change due to carbonation and chloride ion attack was monitored by X-ray diffraction analysis (XRD), and microstructures and interfacial transition zones were studied by implementing a scanning electron microscope (SEM) as well as mercury intrusion porosimetry (MIP). As compressive strength, TEM analysis, and CO2 consumption, as well as SEM analysis, were thoroughly discussed in the previous paper [22], this paper will mostly consider the durability aspects; however, for a comprehensive discussion of durability properties, some data from the previous paper has been used.


## 2. Materials and Methods

### 2.1. Materials

Meeting ASTM C150 [25] specifications, the specimens were made with type I Portland cement, different amounts of silica fume, and potable water. The physical and chemical characteristics of cement and silica fume are presented in Table 1. Local natural river sand was used as fine aggregate and crushed stone as coarse aggregate, with maximum aggregate size of 4.75 mm and 19 mm, respectively. The water absorption and specific gravity of fine and coarse aggregates were 2.5% and 1.6% and 2490 and 2550 kg/m3, respectively. A liquid polycarboxylic-ether base with a solid content of 45% and a specific gravity of 1.2 was used as superplasticizer to provide suitable workability.Table 1
Characteristics of the cement and silica fume.
Oxide elements and chemical composition  (% by mass)
Cement (C)
Silica fume (S)
Silicon dioxide (SiO2)
21.10
93.2
Calcium oxide (CaO)
62.08
0.63
Ferric oxide (Fe2O3)
2.74
0.24
Aluminum oxide (Al2O3)
3.81
0.39
Sulphate oxide (SO3)
2.6
0.23
Magnesium oxide (MgO)
3.22
0.75
Potassium oxide (K2O)
0.73
0.21
Sodium oxide (Na2O)
0.12
0.23
Phosphorus oxide (P2O5)
0.22
—
Titanium oxide (TiO2)
0.24
—
C3S
51.1
—
C2S
23.1
—
C3A
5.1
—
C4AF
8.4
—
Loss on ignition (%)
2.95
1.95
Pozzolanic activity with cement (%)
—
170–190
Physical properties
Specific gravity
3.17
2.1
Blaine fineness (cm2/g)
3519
6000
Average diameter (μm)
15
1.5


### 2.2. Mixture Design and Specimens Preparation

For all mixtures, slump was kept constant at about 80 mm by adding adequate amounts of superplasticizer. All materials were batched in a 60 liter capacity vertical axis mixer with 3 different water/binder ratios: 0.35, 0.4, and 0.45, and different percentages of silica fume replacement with cement at 0%, 7%, and 10% by weight. The mixture proportion is illustrated in Table2. For both tests, mix design and curing condition, three specimens were tested. Specimens were vibrated and maintained at the temperature of 24 ± 1°C, for 24 hours and then demolded and cured in water at 24 ± 2°C. Since early carbonation can change the hydration procedure and calcium hydroxide content on the surface of concrete [5], specimens were cured for 7 days so that the test would have an impact on the normal procedure of hydration. After this period, 50% of the specimens were placed in the apparatus for simultaneous carbonation and chloride ion attack and also the pure carbonation condition. 25% of the specimens were cured in water for standard curing, and the rest were immersed in saline water. The apparatus is illustrated in Figure 1. Every 6 hours, saline water (0.3% NaOH and 3% NaCl [26]) was pumped from chamber 1 (Ch.1) to chamber 2 (Ch.2) for the tide process simulation. By using a pneumatic valve, the interior pressure was kept constant at 1.5 bar [27] (CO2 content of 7500 ± 100 ppm) in order to accelerate the carbonation rate and to be sure that CO2 content is replenished while samples absorb the gas [28]. The temperature and relative humidity were controlled and kept constant at 23 ± 2°C and 70 ± 5%, respectively. The specimens at the top of Ch.1 were not exposed to the saline water in order to provide the pure carbonation condition.Table 2
Mixture proportion of specimens.
Sample ID
Water/binder
Water
Silica fume
Cement content
Coarse aggregate
Fine aggregate
Superplasticizer dosage
kg/m3
%
kg/m3
kg/m3
kg/m3
kg/m3
% by paste volume
35-0
0.35
140
0
0
400
1018
833
1.6
35-7
7
28
372
1.75
35-10
10
40
360
2
40-0
0.4
160
0
0
400
990
810
1.3
40-7
7
28
372
1.45
40-10
10
40
360
1.7
45-0
0.45
180
0
0
400
963
788
1.2
45-7
7
28
372
1.4
45-10
10
40
360
1.5Figure 1
Apparatus for simultaneous carbonation and chloride ion attack.


## 2.1. Materials

Meeting ASTM C150 [25] specifications, the specimens were made with type I Portland cement, different amounts of silica fume, and potable water. The physical and chemical characteristics of cement and silica fume are presented in Table 1. Local natural river sand was used as fine aggregate and crushed stone as coarse aggregate, with maximum aggregate size of 4.75 mm and 19 mm, respectively. The water absorption and specific gravity of fine and coarse aggregates were 2.5% and 1.6% and 2490 and 2550 kg/m3, respectively. A liquid polycarboxylic-ether base with a solid content of 45% and a specific gravity of 1.2 was used as superplasticizer to provide suitable workability.Table 1
Characteristics of the cement and silica fume.
Oxide elements and chemical composition  (% by mass)
Cement (C)
Silica fume (S)
Silicon dioxide (SiO2)
21.10
93.2
Calcium oxide (CaO)
62.08
0.63
Ferric oxide (Fe2O3)
2.74
0.24
Aluminum oxide (Al2O3)
3.81
0.39
Sulphate oxide (SO3)
2.6
0.23
Magnesium oxide (MgO)
3.22
0.75
Potassium oxide (K2O)
0.73
0.21
Sodium oxide (Na2O)
0.12
0.23
Phosphorus oxide (P2O5)
0.22
—
Titanium oxide (TiO2)
0.24
—
C3S
51.1
—
C2S
23.1
—
C3A
5.1
—
C4AF
8.4
—
Loss on ignition (%)
2.95
1.95
Pozzolanic activity with cement (%)
—
170–190
Physical properties
Specific gravity
3.17
2.1
Blaine fineness (cm2/g)
3519
6000
Average diameter (μm)
15
1.5


## 2.2. Mixture Design and Specimens Preparation

For all mixtures, slump was kept constant at about 80 mm by adding adequate amounts of superplasticizer. All materials were batched in a 60 liter capacity vertical axis mixer with 3 different water/binder ratios: 0.35, 0.4, and 0.45, and different percentages of silica fume replacement with cement at 0%, 7%, and 10% by weight. The mixture proportion is illustrated in Table2. For both tests, mix design and curing condition, three specimens were tested. Specimens were vibrated and maintained at the temperature of 24 ± 1°C, for 24 hours and then demolded and cured in water at 24 ± 2°C. Since early carbonation can change the hydration procedure and calcium hydroxide content on the surface of concrete [5], specimens were cured for 7 days so that the test would have an impact on the normal procedure of hydration. After this period, 50% of the specimens were placed in the apparatus for simultaneous carbonation and chloride ion attack and also the pure carbonation condition. 25% of the specimens were cured in water for standard curing, and the rest were immersed in saline water. The apparatus is illustrated in Figure 1. Every 6 hours, saline water (0.3% NaOH and 3% NaCl [26]) was pumped from chamber 1 (Ch.1) to chamber 2 (Ch.2) for the tide process simulation. By using a pneumatic valve, the interior pressure was kept constant at 1.5 bar [27] (CO2 content of 7500 ± 100 ppm) in order to accelerate the carbonation rate and to be sure that CO2 content is replenished while samples absorb the gas [28]. The temperature and relative humidity were controlled and kept constant at 23 ± 2°C and 70 ± 5%, respectively. The specimens at the top of Ch.1 were not exposed to the saline water in order to provide the pure carbonation condition.Table 2
Mixture proportion of specimens.
Sample ID
Water/binder
Water
Silica fume
Cement content
Coarse aggregate
Fine aggregate
Superplasticizer dosage
kg/m3
%
kg/m3
kg/m3
kg/m3
kg/m3
% by paste volume
35-0
0.35
140
0
0
400
1018
833
1.6
35-7
7
28
372
1.75
35-10
10
40
360
2
40-0
0.4
160
0
0
400
990
810
1.3
40-7
7
28
372
1.45
40-10
10
40
360
1.7
45-0
0.45
180
0
0
400
963
788
1.2
45-7
7
28
372
1.4
45-10
10
40
360
1.5Figure 1
Apparatus for simultaneous carbonation and chloride ion attack.


## 3. Experimental Procedure

### 3.1. Physical Properties

#### 3.1.1. Phase Change Analysis

In order to quantify the phase changes, at the age of 28 days, 10 mm of the hydrated cement paste, with water-to-cement ratio of 0.35, cured in all different conditions, was powdered, and X-ray diffraction (XRD) analysis was performed by a Philips powder diffractometer. The XRD sample preparation and instrument specifications are illustrated in Table3. For phase quantification, a profile fit software (PANalytical X’Pert HighScore) was used.Table 3
XRD sample preparation and instrument specifications.
Filler
Working condition
Range
Step size
Power
Sample preparation
Radiation
Ni filler
4°–70°
2θ
0.02°
40 kV and 30 mA
Powder
Cu kα


#### 3.1.2. Scanning Electron Microscope (SEM)

At the age of 28 days, 5 × 5 × 2 mm pieces of 4 different types of specimens, including those cured in water, specimens that were maintained in the apparatus with the water-to-cement ratio of 0.35, and specimens with 10% silica fume, were coated with gold-palladium and scanned with Hitachi U8040 scanning electron microscope. Aggregates and cement paste were positioned at the center of the SEM separately for observation of carbonation and chloride ion ingress effects on microstructure and the interfacial transition zone.


#### 3.1.3. Mercury Intrusion Porosimetry (MIP)

Having been crushed by hammer, 2 grams of chunks from the specimens used for SEM analysis was randomly collected for mercury intrusion porosimetry (MIP) measurement. Three samples from each mix design and curing condition were tested at the age of 28 days. Chunks were kept in the oven at 60°C until they reached a constant weight. Pore Master33, with the ability to measure 6 nm to 950µm, was used at the maximum pressure of 33000 psi. The intrusion and extrusion contact angle and surface tension of mercury were chosen to be 140° and 0.480 N/m.


#### 3.1.4. CO2 Permeance

As an indicator of permeability, the CO2 permeance is often measured, and in this research the test was performed to support the results obtained from the MIP experiment as well. For each condition, four specimens with a water-to-cement ratio of 0.35 were tested. The specimens in the dimension of 1 × 1 × 2.5 cm were placed into a tubular ceramic membrane and the holder was sealed. The experiment was performed as discussed by Xomeritakis et al. [29]. Having introduced gases one at a time into the tubular membrane, the permeation flow rate was obtained using a soap-film flowmeter. The gas pressure and stream were maintained at 15 psig and 100 cc/min, respectively. The gases used in this experiment are as follows, and their kinetic diameters are in parenthesis: He (2.6 Å), CO2 (3.3 Å), Ar (3.4 Å), N2 (3.64 Å), CH4 (3.8 Å), and SF6 (5.5 Å). Because N2 is inert and has the similar physical properties to air, it was implemented to simulate air in the experiment.


### 3.2. Durability Tests

All the durability tests were performed on the specimens cured in pure carbonation, pure chloride ion ingress, simultaneous carbonation, and chloride ion attack and the standard curing condition, shown as Carb, Chl, Sim, and PC in the figures, respectively. The following durability tests were performed on three samples for each of the curing conditions.


#### 3.2.1. Surface Resistivity

The surface resistivity of 10 × 20 cm cylinder specimens was measured at four quaternary longitudinal locations by the four-point Wenner array probe technique [30] at each test age, that is, 28 and 90 days. This nondestructive test shows the conductivity and ion penetration of the specimens.


#### 3.2.2. Water Penetration

Regarding BS EN-12390-8:2000 [31], water penetration tests were performed to identify the permeability of concrete. For 72 hours, and under 0.5 MPa pressure, 15 × 15 cm cubic specimens were exposed to water on one face. After this period, specimens were split in order to measure maximum depth of penetration at the ages of 28 and 90 days.


#### 3.2.3. Sorptivity

In order to identify the ability of moisture to penetrate into an unsaturated specimen, a sorptivity test was conducted on 10 × 10 cm cubic specimens at the ages of 28 and 90 days. Specimens, according to BS EN-480-5 [32], were placed in an oven at the temperature of 60°C for 14 days. All specimens were 5 mm above the basin, and epoxy resin was sprayed on all surfaces except for the one which was exposed so that the water would was absorbed uniaxially. Mass changes were measured at 0, 12, 24, 36, and 72 hours. The sorptivity coefficient (S) (m/s0.5) was calculated according to (11)(11)QA=C+St,where Q is obtained from the amount of water that is absorbed; A is the surface area of the sample in contact with water in square meter; t is the time of the test in seconds; C is the constant coefficient.


#### 3.2.4. Carbonation and Chloride Ion Ingress Depths

10 × 20 cm cylinder specimens at the ages of 28 and 90 days were sliced to 5 mm thickness for pH measurement in order to identify carbonation depth by spraying a pH indicator solution (0.1 g phenolphthalein in 100 mL 95% ethanol). Meanwhile, another slice 5 mm thick was used for measuring the depth of chloride ion penetration. The measuring was performed by spraying a silver nitrate (AgNO3) solution and is suitable for indicating chloride ion ingress.


## 3.1. Physical Properties

### 3.1.1. Phase Change Analysis

In order to quantify the phase changes, at the age of 28 days, 10 mm of the hydrated cement paste, with water-to-cement ratio of 0.35, cured in all different conditions, was powdered, and X-ray diffraction (XRD) analysis was performed by a Philips powder diffractometer. The XRD sample preparation and instrument specifications are illustrated in Table3. For phase quantification, a profile fit software (PANalytical X’Pert HighScore) was used.Table 3
XRD sample preparation and instrument specifications.
Filler
Working condition
Range
Step size
Power
Sample preparation
Radiation
Ni filler
4°–70°
2θ
0.02°
40 kV and 30 mA
Powder
Cu kα


### 3.1.2. Scanning Electron Microscope (SEM)

At the age of 28 days, 5 × 5 × 2 mm pieces of 4 different types of specimens, including those cured in water, specimens that were maintained in the apparatus with the water-to-cement ratio of 0.35, and specimens with 10% silica fume, were coated with gold-palladium and scanned with Hitachi U8040 scanning electron microscope. Aggregates and cement paste were positioned at the center of the SEM separately for observation of carbonation and chloride ion ingress effects on microstructure and the interfacial transition zone.


### 3.1.3. Mercury Intrusion Porosimetry (MIP)

Having been crushed by hammer, 2 grams of chunks from the specimens used for SEM analysis was randomly collected for mercury intrusion porosimetry (MIP) measurement. Three samples from each mix design and curing condition were tested at the age of 28 days. Chunks were kept in the oven at 60°C until they reached a constant weight. Pore Master33, with the ability to measure 6 nm to 950µm, was used at the maximum pressure of 33000 psi. The intrusion and extrusion contact angle and surface tension of mercury were chosen to be 140° and 0.480 N/m.


### 3.1.4. CO2 Permeance

As an indicator of permeability, the CO2 permeance is often measured, and in this research the test was performed to support the results obtained from the MIP experiment as well. For each condition, four specimens with a water-to-cement ratio of 0.35 were tested. The specimens in the dimension of 1 × 1 × 2.5 cm were placed into a tubular ceramic membrane and the holder was sealed. The experiment was performed as discussed by Xomeritakis et al. [29]. Having introduced gases one at a time into the tubular membrane, the permeation flow rate was obtained using a soap-film flowmeter. The gas pressure and stream were maintained at 15 psig and 100 cc/min, respectively. The gases used in this experiment are as follows, and their kinetic diameters are in parenthesis: He (2.6 Å), CO2 (3.3 Å), Ar (3.4 Å), N2 (3.64 Å), CH4 (3.8 Å), and SF6 (5.5 Å). Because N2 is inert and has the similar physical properties to air, it was implemented to simulate air in the experiment.


## 3.1.1. Phase Change Analysis

In order to quantify the phase changes, at the age of 28 days, 10 mm of the hydrated cement paste, with water-to-cement ratio of 0.35, cured in all different conditions, was powdered, and X-ray diffraction (XRD) analysis was performed by a Philips powder diffractometer. The XRD sample preparation and instrument specifications are illustrated in Table3. For phase quantification, a profile fit software (PANalytical X’Pert HighScore) was used.Table 3
XRD sample preparation and instrument specifications.
Filler
Working condition
Range
Step size
Power
Sample preparation
Radiation
Ni filler
4°–70°
2θ
0.02°
40 kV and 30 mA
Powder
Cu kα


## 3.1.2. Scanning Electron Microscope (SEM)

At the age of 28 days, 5 × 5 × 2 mm pieces of 4 different types of specimens, including those cured in water, specimens that were maintained in the apparatus with the water-to-cement ratio of 0.35, and specimens with 10% silica fume, were coated with gold-palladium and scanned with Hitachi U8040 scanning electron microscope. Aggregates and cement paste were positioned at the center of the SEM separately for observation of carbonation and chloride ion ingress effects on microstructure and the interfacial transition zone.


## 3.1.3. Mercury Intrusion Porosimetry (MIP)

Having been crushed by hammer, 2 grams of chunks from the specimens used for SEM analysis was randomly collected for mercury intrusion porosimetry (MIP) measurement. Three samples from each mix design and curing condition were tested at the age of 28 days. Chunks were kept in the oven at 60°C until they reached a constant weight. Pore Master33, with the ability to measure 6 nm to 950µm, was used at the maximum pressure of 33000 psi. The intrusion and extrusion contact angle and surface tension of mercury were chosen to be 140° and 0.480 N/m.


## 3.1.4. CO2 Permeance

As an indicator of permeability, the CO2 permeance is often measured, and in this research the test was performed to support the results obtained from the MIP experiment as well. For each condition, four specimens with a water-to-cement ratio of 0.35 were tested. The specimens in the dimension of 1 × 1 × 2.5 cm were placed into a tubular ceramic membrane and the holder was sealed. The experiment was performed as discussed by Xomeritakis et al. [29]. Having introduced gases one at a time into the tubular membrane, the permeation flow rate was obtained using a soap-film flowmeter. The gas pressure and stream were maintained at 15 psig and 100 cc/min, respectively. The gases used in this experiment are as follows, and their kinetic diameters are in parenthesis: He (2.6 Å), CO2 (3.3 Å), Ar (3.4 Å), N2 (3.64 Å), CH4 (3.8 Å), and SF6 (5.5 Å). Because N2 is inert and has the similar physical properties to air, it was implemented to simulate air in the experiment.


## 3.2. Durability Tests

All the durability tests were performed on the specimens cured in pure carbonation, pure chloride ion ingress, simultaneous carbonation, and chloride ion attack and the standard curing condition, shown as Carb, Chl, Sim, and PC in the figures, respectively. The following durability tests were performed on three samples for each of the curing conditions.


### 3.2.1. Surface Resistivity

The surface resistivity of 10 × 20 cm cylinder specimens was measured at four quaternary longitudinal locations by the four-point Wenner array probe technique [30] at each test age, that is, 28 and 90 days. This nondestructive test shows the conductivity and ion penetration of the specimens.


### 3.2.2. Water Penetration

Regarding BS EN-12390-8:2000 [31], water penetration tests were performed to identify the permeability of concrete. For 72 hours, and under 0.5 MPa pressure, 15 × 15 cm cubic specimens were exposed to water on one face. After this period, specimens were split in order to measure maximum depth of penetration at the ages of 28 and 90 days.


### 3.2.3. Sorptivity

In order to identify the ability of moisture to penetrate into an unsaturated specimen, a sorptivity test was conducted on 10 × 10 cm cubic specimens at the ages of 28 and 90 days. Specimens, according to BS EN-480-5 [32], were placed in an oven at the temperature of 60°C for 14 days. All specimens were 5 mm above the basin, and epoxy resin was sprayed on all surfaces except for the one which was exposed so that the water would was absorbed uniaxially. Mass changes were measured at 0, 12, 24, 36, and 72 hours. The sorptivity coefficient (S) (m/s0.5) was calculated according to (11)(11)QA=C+St,where Q is obtained from the amount of water that is absorbed; A is the surface area of the sample in contact with water in square meter; t is the time of the test in seconds; C is the constant coefficient.


### 3.2.4. Carbonation and Chloride Ion Ingress Depths

10 × 20 cm cylinder specimens at the ages of 28 and 90 days were sliced to 5 mm thickness for pH measurement in order to identify carbonation depth by spraying a pH indicator solution (0.1 g phenolphthalein in 100 mL 95% ethanol). Meanwhile, another slice 5 mm thick was used for measuring the depth of chloride ion penetration. The measuring was performed by spraying a silver nitrate (AgNO3) solution and is suitable for indicating chloride ion ingress.


## 3.2.1. Surface Resistivity

The surface resistivity of 10 × 20 cm cylinder specimens was measured at four quaternary longitudinal locations by the four-point Wenner array probe technique [30] at each test age, that is, 28 and 90 days. This nondestructive test shows the conductivity and ion penetration of the specimens.


## 3.2.2. Water Penetration

Regarding BS EN-12390-8:2000 [31], water penetration tests were performed to identify the permeability of concrete. For 72 hours, and under 0.5 MPa pressure, 15 × 15 cm cubic specimens were exposed to water on one face. After this period, specimens were split in order to measure maximum depth of penetration at the ages of 28 and 90 days.


## 3.2.3. Sorptivity

In order to identify the ability of moisture to penetrate into an unsaturated specimen, a sorptivity test was conducted on 10 × 10 cm cubic specimens at the ages of 28 and 90 days. Specimens, according to BS EN-480-5 [32], were placed in an oven at the temperature of 60°C for 14 days. All specimens were 5 mm above the basin, and epoxy resin was sprayed on all surfaces except for the one which was exposed so that the water would was absorbed uniaxially. Mass changes were measured at 0, 12, 24, 36, and 72 hours. The sorptivity coefficient (S) (m/s0.5) was calculated according to (11)(11)QA=C+St,where Q is obtained from the amount of water that is absorbed; A is the surface area of the sample in contact with water in square meter; t is the time of the test in seconds; C is the constant coefficient.


## 3.2.4. Carbonation and Chloride Ion Ingress Depths

10 × 20 cm cylinder specimens at the ages of 28 and 90 days were sliced to 5 mm thickness for pH measurement in order to identify carbonation depth by spraying a pH indicator solution (0.1 g phenolphthalein in 100 mL 95% ethanol). Meanwhile, another slice 5 mm thick was used for measuring the depth of chloride ion penetration. The measuring was performed by spraying a silver nitrate (AgNO3) solution and is suitable for indicating chloride ion ingress.


## 4. Results and Discussion

### 4.1. Phase Change Analysis

The effect of different conditions on phase change can be observed by means of X-ray diffractometer (XRD). The results of XRD at the age of 28 days for samples with a water-to-cement ratio of 0.35, maintained at different curing conditions, are shown in Figure2. The samples are chosen randomly from a 5 mm of the depth surface in order to consider carbonation and chloride ion ingress effect. Portlandite (Ca(OH)2), calcite (CaCO3), and silicon dioxide (SiO2), as crystalline phases, are the main peaks [33, 34]. The oxide elements and chemical compositions presented in Table 1 support the accuracy of the test.Figure 2
XRD analysis of 35-0 maintained in saline water, CO2 gas, and simultaneous CO2 gas and saline water at 28 days, from top to bottom.As stated above, Kuzel’s salt (3CaO·Al2O3·0.5CaSO4·0.5CaCl2·10(11)H2O) and Friedel’s salt (3CaO·Al2O3·CaCl2·10H2O) can be formed where free chloride ions are available. The salts are considered as hydrate calcium aluminate or AFm phases [14]. When chloride ions react with C3H, Friedel’s salt is formed. The chloride ion reaction with C4AF leads to the formation of Kuzel’s salt [15]. If Friedel’s salt gets carbonated, some chloride ions bound by Friedel’s salt may dissolute into pore solution, and an increase in chloride ions may lead to a higher chloride ion ingress rate. Sulfate is mostly found in AFt, which contains ettringite and thaumasite, and causes reactions which extenuate the sulfate concentration in the pores. In addition, sulfate and carbonate react with each other in a strong way [35]. Ettringite is formed in a crystalline hexagonal needle shape with the size of 4–10 µm early in the cement hydration process. When in contact with water, it remains stable until the temperature rises above 114°C [36], and when the humidity decreases, the temperature decreases rapidly as well [37]. Thaumasite, on the other hand, is formed when alumina is changed to silicate in ettringite. It is stable at the temperature of about 30°C. Due to the low carbonate content and also low silica activity, thaumasite is rarely formed unless carbonate is applied externally or internally from calcium carbonate. AFm phases generally contain a layer which is elementary, for example, Ca2[Al(OH)6]+. Sulfate AFm has been reported to be stable at temperatures lower than 50°C [38]. AFm phases are made up of sheets of M(OH)6 octahedral ions and are considered as a branch of hydrated calcium aluminate phases. It is noteworthy that AFm anions in Portland cement are carbonate, hydroxide, and sulfate; however, they are considered aluminosilicate particles in a blended cement [14] in which other anions are replaced with chloride. It should be noted that the AFm phase pattern obtained from XRD is similar to C4AH13 which is a type of AFm phase with hydroxide [14]. Moreover, AFt particles that have a needle shape can be seen in the SEM micrographs with a size of up to 4 µm. When carbonate replaces all the sulfate in AFm, ettringite reaches its maximum concentration [14].According to the results, Ca(OH)2 has been reduced and consequently CaCO3 has been increased in the CO2 environment which is shown in Figure 9; however, specimens maintained in the tidal zone have lesser amounts of CaCO3, perhaps due to the preventative effect of moisture available at the surface. Further, saline water can wash CO2 that may penetrate into the concrete. The reduction in Ca(OH)2 signifies that carbonation consumes Ca(OH)2 and produces CaCO3. Moreover, C2S and C3S have also been reduced; hence, the production of CaCO3 is not only due to Ca(OH)2. XRD results validate the fact that carbonation has occurred mostly in the proximity of the surface since the peaks of Ca(OH)2 are weak at points far from the surface. Furthermore, by using silica fume, more CH may be converted to C-S-H gel. Evidence for this reaction is shown in Figure 2. Specimens maintained in CO2 gas had a lower peak for Ca(OH)2 and a higher peak for C2S, C3S, and CaCO3. In the range of 2θ between 18° and 42°, because of the nonconvex shape of the XRD results, crystalline materials of carbonation products may have been available.


### 4.2. Surface Resistivity

Relative permeability of specimens can be evaluated by this nondestructive test. If a specimen has a higher surface resistivity (SR), it signifies more durability. Regarding the results of SR values presented in Figures3 and 4, silica fume has improved the surface resistivity. Silica fume improves surface resistivity by two reactions: (i) it produces C-S-H gel by its reaction with CH, which fills the interfacial transition zone; although silica fume has little or no cementitious feature, it chemically reacts with calcium hydroxide and forms compounds which have cementitious properties [39]; (ii) silica fume particles with an average diameter of 150 nm are significantly finer than cement particles with average diameter of 15 μm; therefore, they can fill pores which may improve surface resistivity [40]. In other words, silica fume would alter the concrete strength because of its fineness or C-S-H gel production [41] and the existence of small particles will improve the concrete properties known as “particle packing” or “microfilling.”Figure 3
Results of surface resistivity at the age of 28 days.Figure 4
Results of surface resistivity at the age of 90 days.It was expected to have a synergic effect in the tidal zone where simultaneous carbonation and chloride ion attack happen. However, the observed reduced surface resistivity, compared to specimens maintained in CO2 gas, could be due to the moisture that is available near the surface, hindering CO2 from penetrating into the pores of the specimens. In fact, saline water has washed the surface, so the process of forming carbonation products has been delayed. During carbonation, CO2 reacts with cementitious materials, an important product of which is calcium carbonate (CaCO3), which is stronger than Ca(OH)2; therefore, the specimen would become stronger at the surface [11]. One positive effect of using silica fume is providing more C-S-H gel [42], causing the ultimate hydration products to become stronger, and more surface resistivity is obtained. As silica fume fills the pores, meanwhile, less porosity is obtained by lower water/binder ratio as well. Moreover, the moisture at the surface provided less room for the carbonation products to get formed. More C-S-H gel is provided by silica fume, which makes the ultimate hydration products become stronger. The moisture that is available near the surface of the specimen hinders CO2 penetration. In other words, the formation of carbonation products has been delayed because saline water has washed the surface. In the same way, carbonated specimens have a higher SR value; however, specimens maintained in the tidal zone did not have a high value of surface resistivity which could be due to the moisture available at the surface of specimens during the simulation of four tide cycles of six hours per day. Carbonation products can fill the pores according to the following equation:(12)H2CO3+CaOH2⟶CaCO3+2H2OAlso with CaCO3 more strength can be obtained from the carbonated area. According to the results, there is a slight difference in SR values between the control and specimens maintained in saline water, because saline water cannot change any phase in the hydration products. According to Figures 3 and 4, 35-10 samples maintained in CO2 have the highest surface resistivity, which is about 60 and 80% higher than that of 35-0 samples at the ages of 28 and 90 days, respectively.


### 4.3. Water Penetration

Another way of measuring the permeability of specimens is to perform a water penetration test. Since durability is related to the permeability of concrete, a low depth of water penetration is tantamount to a low rate of chloride ion penetration and consequently higher durability. The results of water penetration tests for all specimens with different curing conditions and amounts of silica fume at the ages of 28 and 90 days are shown in Figures5 and 6, respectively. According to the results, using silica fume reduced water penetration depth. The minimum depth of water penetration was 16 mm for the specimen with 10% silica fume and water/binder ratio of 0.35 at the age of 90 days. The reduction in water penetration depth is attributed to the double action of silica fume, that is, acting as filler and producing C-S-H gel; silica fume particles with an average diameter of 150 nm are significantly finer than cement particles with an average diameter of 15 μm; therefore, they can fill pores which may improve surface resistivity [40]. On the other hand, a low water/binder ratio, which causes less porosity, is another element that has caused this imperceptible depth of water penetration. Moreover, specimens maintained in CO2 gas showed a significant reduction in the depth of water penetration due to the carbonation products such as CaCO3 that could fill the pores. Reduction in the pores can be explained through reactions (1) and (2) [7]. By consumption of (OH)− in reaction (1), the pH of the pore solution decreases which leads to a decrease in overall porosity [7, 9].Figure 5
Water penetration depth for all specimens in different conditions at the age of 28 days.Figure 6
Water penetration depth for all specimens in different conditions at the age of 90 days.There was no significant difference between the water penetration depths for the reference concrete and specimens maintained in saline water, which is due to the availability of moisture present at the surface of specimens maintained in CO2 gas and saline water, hindering the penetration of gas and chloride into the specimens. The minimum depth of water penetration was 16 mm for the sample 35-10 maintained in CO2 approximately 10% lower than that of the reference and the saline water-maintained specimen at the age of 28 days. The results support the validity of the premise that saline water can not cause any reaction in cement hydration products; hence, there is no perceptible change in porosity. Specimens in the tidal zone were observed to have a depth of water penetration more than that of specimens maintained in CO2 gas.


### 4.4. Sorptivity

Sorptivity coefficient (S) is an index of durability, and a higher sorptivity coefficient connotes more capillary porosity; however, not all capillary porosities are responsible for the durability of concrete. Capillary porosities that are connected with each other can affect durability [43]. The results of sorptivity coefficient (S) at the ages of 28 and 90 days are shown in Figures 7 and 8, respectively, which support the results obtained in the previous section from the water penetration test. As stated previously, by the consumption of (OH)− in CaOH2+CO2→CaCO3+H2O, the pH of the pore solution increases; meanwhile, a decrease in overall porosity is happening through the production of CaCO3 in C-S-H + 2CO2→SiO2 + 2CaCO3 + H2O [7, 9]. When compared to specimens maintained in saline water or the standard curing condition, specimens maintained in CO2 gas and the tidal zone have lower sorptivity coefficients. This is probably due to the filling effect of carbonation products that can block capillary porosities, although CaCO3 may fill some of those porosities as well. However, because of the moisture available in the proximity of the surface, which prohibits CO2 gas from entering into the specimens, the sorptivity coefficients for the specimens maintained at the tidal zone are higher than those of the CO2 maintained specimens. Furthermore, using silica fume has tangibly reduced the sorptivity coefficient. At the age of 90 days, the 35-10 sample maintained in CO2 gas has the minimum sorptivity coefficient of about 10−6 (m/s0.5) while the 45-0 sample has the maximum value of 3.3(10-6) (m/s0.5) when maintained in the standard curing condition. The results indicate that silica fume has reduced capillary porosity. Meanwhile, because of the finer size of silica fume than cement particles, some pores may have been filled, and the inner conductivity of pores may have been blocked. Silica fume improves surface resistivity by two reactions: it produces C-S-H gel by its reaction with CH, which fills interfacial transition zones; silica fume chemically reacts with calcium hydroxide and forms compounds which have cementitious properties [39], even though it has few cementitious features.Figure 7
Sorptivity coefficient for all specimens maintained in different conditions at the age of 28 days.Figure 8
Sorptivity coefficient for all specimens maintained in different conditions at the age of 90 days.Figure 9
35-0 maintained in CO2 gas.


### 4.5. SEM and MIP Results

Small gold coated portions of specimens were placed in the scanning electron microscope (SEM) stubs. The micrographs of the polished surface of the 35-0 sample for hydrated concrete specimens, maintained in different conditions, at the age of 28 days, are illustrated in Figures9–13. The samples are chosen randomly from the 5 mm of the surface in order to consider carbonation and chloride ion ingress effect. In the micrographs, C-S-H gel appears slightly brighter, and aggregates appear darker. Sands can be described by their semidark hue [44]. The 35-0 specimen micrographs maintained in CO2 gas, in the tidal zone, saline water, and standard curing conditions, are presented in Figures 9–12, respectively. According to the SEM micrographs, 35-0 maintained in CO2 gas has many cubic, crystalline particles that have been formed because of carbonation. As mentioned above, by polymerizing silicate chains in C-S-H, volume decreases and shrinkage happens as well [3]. Besides, CaCO3 is available in various forms which may increase surface resistivity. When compared to the saline water-cured sample, the sample in the tidal zone, developed cubic, crystalline particles, and CaCO3 was reduced. As a comprehensive porosity analysis will be published in another paper, the specimens used in the SEM analysis were tested using MIP in order to obtain total porosity values. A preliminary analysis of the porosity of the specimens shows that the 35-10 sample cured in the tidal zone has 50.1% less total porosity than the sample 35-0 cured in the same condition. The results are presented in Table 4. It is also visible that carbonated specimens have less porosity than specimens maintained in the tidal zone.Table 4
Mercury intrusion porosimetry results.
Label
Total intruding volume (mL/g)
Mean radius (nm)
Total porosity (%)
35-0 Carb
0.1191 ± 7.1%
15.26 ± 8.6%
10.2
35-0 Sim
0.1250 ± 5.3%
20.55 ± 7.2%
13.5
35-0 Chl
0.1507 ± 8.7%
23.92 ± 5.7%
15.7
35-0 PC
0.1459 ± 6.8%
20.71 ± 6.6%
16.2
35-10 Sim
0.0832 ± 6.5%
11.51 ± 5.1%
8.9Figure 10
35-0 maintained in tidal zone.Figure 11
35-0 maintained in saline water.Figure 12
35-0 maintained in standard curing condition.Figure 13
35-10 maintained in tidal zone.Furthermore, in both conditions, capillary porosity has been reduced leading to a lower sorptivity coefficient. The carbonated 35-0 sample has 32.4% less total porosity than the 35-0 sample cured in the tidal zone. Total porosity signifies the porosity that is responsible for capillary transportation through the concrete porous structure [45]. In Figure 9, in the 35-0 sample (Figure 10) maintained in saline water, no perceptible difference can be observed when compared to the 35-0 sample cured in the standard curing condition. It can be concluded that, by curing in saline water, no chemical or physical reaction has taken place. According to the result of gas permeation, the minimum pore size can be estimated at less than 50 Å because the ratio of He : SF6 is approximately 1000. Carbonation has led to a less permeable surface and the specimens maintained in both carbonation and chloride ion ingress show less permeability compared with plain concrete and the specimens maintained in the pure chloride ion ingress. The results support the values obtained from the durability test and MIP tests. A more detailed discussion and comprehensive porosity analysis will be presented in the forthcoming manuscript by the authors.The 35-10 specimen micrographs (at 6kx magnification), maintained in the tidal zone, are presented in Figure13. Regarding these SEM micrographs, silica fume has filled some pores, and the microstructure of the transition zone has been improved because of the production of C-S-H gel. Carbonation and silica fume have had a synergistic effect. When compared to carbonated samples without silica fume, reduced water penetration depth and sorptivity were observable, and increased surface resistivity and less porosity were noticed. According to Figure 13 and Table 4, it is evident that silica fume has filled pores although minimally, and using 10% silica fume may compensate for the effect of carbonation because of the capillary porosity blocking effect. Silica fume would alter the concrete’s strength because of its fineness or C-S-H gel production [41] and the existence of small particles will improve the concrete properties known as “particle packing” or “microfilling.”


### 4.6. Depth of Carbonation and Chloride Ion Ingress

In order to indicate carbonation depth and the depth of chloride ion ingress, phenolphthalein and silver nitrate solutions were sprayed separately on the surface of 5 mm thick slices. The results of the depth of carbonation and chloride ion ingress for specimens maintained in each environment condition, at the ages of 28 and 90 days, are presented in Figures14 and 15, respectively. The minimum depth of carbonation and chloride ion ingress for specimens maintained at the tidal zone was 5 and 10 mm for 35-10, while the maximum was 23 and 35 mm for 45-0, respectively. The results support the conclusion that silica fume fills pores so that there is less space for CO2 gas and carbonation products. Besides that, because of less capillary porosity due to the presence of silica fume and its productions, that is, C-S-H gels, less chloride ions could penetrate into the specimen. Reduction in pH, which was about 12 to 9 in this experiment, was partly due to the production of CaCO3 from Ca(OH)2. This reaction occurred in a 15 mm range at the surface, and therefore, signs of corrosion for reinforcement bars, located 50 mm from the surface, may not occur. By using 10% silica fume and a water/binder ratio of 0.35, at the tidal zone, corrosion of reinforcement bars is not likely to happen in 90 days; however, the depth of carbonation for specimens maintained in CO2 gas, which is about 50 mm from the surface, is detrimental to reinforcement bars. In fact, the pH presolution is not related merely to Ca(OH)2; rather, alkali salts such as NaOH and KOH are important since they are more likely to be carbonated. Moreover, carbonation depth for specimens maintained in CO2 gas was at least 45% higher than that of specimens maintained at the tidal zone. The minimum carbonation depth was 5 mm for 35-10 samples, which is 140% lower than that of 45-0 samples. Furthermore, chloride ion ingress for specimens maintained in saline water followed the same procedure explained above. The minimum and maximum depths of chloride ion ingress were 10 and 35 mm for 35-10 and 45-0, respectively.Figure 14
Results of the depth of carbonation.Figure 15
Results of the depth of chloride ion ingress.


## 4.1. Phase Change Analysis

The effect of different conditions on phase change can be observed by means of X-ray diffractometer (XRD). The results of XRD at the age of 28 days for samples with a water-to-cement ratio of 0.35, maintained at different curing conditions, are shown in Figure2. The samples are chosen randomly from a 5 mm of the depth surface in order to consider carbonation and chloride ion ingress effect. Portlandite (Ca(OH)2), calcite (CaCO3), and silicon dioxide (SiO2), as crystalline phases, are the main peaks [33, 34]. The oxide elements and chemical compositions presented in Table 1 support the accuracy of the test.Figure 2
XRD analysis of 35-0 maintained in saline water, CO2 gas, and simultaneous CO2 gas and saline water at 28 days, from top to bottom.As stated above, Kuzel’s salt (3CaO·Al2O3·0.5CaSO4·0.5CaCl2·10(11)H2O) and Friedel’s salt (3CaO·Al2O3·CaCl2·10H2O) can be formed where free chloride ions are available. The salts are considered as hydrate calcium aluminate or AFm phases [14]. When chloride ions react with C3H, Friedel’s salt is formed. The chloride ion reaction with C4AF leads to the formation of Kuzel’s salt [15]. If Friedel’s salt gets carbonated, some chloride ions bound by Friedel’s salt may dissolute into pore solution, and an increase in chloride ions may lead to a higher chloride ion ingress rate. Sulfate is mostly found in AFt, which contains ettringite and thaumasite, and causes reactions which extenuate the sulfate concentration in the pores. In addition, sulfate and carbonate react with each other in a strong way [35]. Ettringite is formed in a crystalline hexagonal needle shape with the size of 4–10 µm early in the cement hydration process. When in contact with water, it remains stable until the temperature rises above 114°C [36], and when the humidity decreases, the temperature decreases rapidly as well [37]. Thaumasite, on the other hand, is formed when alumina is changed to silicate in ettringite. It is stable at the temperature of about 30°C. Due to the low carbonate content and also low silica activity, thaumasite is rarely formed unless carbonate is applied externally or internally from calcium carbonate. AFm phases generally contain a layer which is elementary, for example, Ca2[Al(OH)6]+. Sulfate AFm has been reported to be stable at temperatures lower than 50°C [38]. AFm phases are made up of sheets of M(OH)6 octahedral ions and are considered as a branch of hydrated calcium aluminate phases. It is noteworthy that AFm anions in Portland cement are carbonate, hydroxide, and sulfate; however, they are considered aluminosilicate particles in a blended cement [14] in which other anions are replaced with chloride. It should be noted that the AFm phase pattern obtained from XRD is similar to C4AH13 which is a type of AFm phase with hydroxide [14]. Moreover, AFt particles that have a needle shape can be seen in the SEM micrographs with a size of up to 4 µm. When carbonate replaces all the sulfate in AFm, ettringite reaches its maximum concentration [14].According to the results, Ca(OH)2 has been reduced and consequently CaCO3 has been increased in the CO2 environment which is shown in Figure 9; however, specimens maintained in the tidal zone have lesser amounts of CaCO3, perhaps due to the preventative effect of moisture available at the surface. Further, saline water can wash CO2 that may penetrate into the concrete. The reduction in Ca(OH)2 signifies that carbonation consumes Ca(OH)2 and produces CaCO3. Moreover, C2S and C3S have also been reduced; hence, the production of CaCO3 is not only due to Ca(OH)2. XRD results validate the fact that carbonation has occurred mostly in the proximity of the surface since the peaks of Ca(OH)2 are weak at points far from the surface. Furthermore, by using silica fume, more CH may be converted to C-S-H gel. Evidence for this reaction is shown in Figure 2. Specimens maintained in CO2 gas had a lower peak for Ca(OH)2 and a higher peak for C2S, C3S, and CaCO3. In the range of 2θ between 18° and 42°, because of the nonconvex shape of the XRD results, crystalline materials of carbonation products may have been available.


## 4.2. Surface Resistivity

Relative permeability of specimens can be evaluated by this nondestructive test. If a specimen has a higher surface resistivity (SR), it signifies more durability. Regarding the results of SR values presented in Figures3 and 4, silica fume has improved the surface resistivity. Silica fume improves surface resistivity by two reactions: (i) it produces C-S-H gel by its reaction with CH, which fills the interfacial transition zone; although silica fume has little or no cementitious feature, it chemically reacts with calcium hydroxide and forms compounds which have cementitious properties [39]; (ii) silica fume particles with an average diameter of 150 nm are significantly finer than cement particles with average diameter of 15 μm; therefore, they can fill pores which may improve surface resistivity [40]. In other words, silica fume would alter the concrete strength because of its fineness or C-S-H gel production [41] and the existence of small particles will improve the concrete properties known as “particle packing” or “microfilling.”Figure 3
Results of surface resistivity at the age of 28 days.Figure 4
Results of surface resistivity at the age of 90 days.It was expected to have a synergic effect in the tidal zone where simultaneous carbonation and chloride ion attack happen. However, the observed reduced surface resistivity, compared to specimens maintained in CO2 gas, could be due to the moisture that is available near the surface, hindering CO2 from penetrating into the pores of the specimens. In fact, saline water has washed the surface, so the process of forming carbonation products has been delayed. During carbonation, CO2 reacts with cementitious materials, an important product of which is calcium carbonate (CaCO3), which is stronger than Ca(OH)2; therefore, the specimen would become stronger at the surface [11]. One positive effect of using silica fume is providing more C-S-H gel [42], causing the ultimate hydration products to become stronger, and more surface resistivity is obtained. As silica fume fills the pores, meanwhile, less porosity is obtained by lower water/binder ratio as well. Moreover, the moisture at the surface provided less room for the carbonation products to get formed. More C-S-H gel is provided by silica fume, which makes the ultimate hydration products become stronger. The moisture that is available near the surface of the specimen hinders CO2 penetration. In other words, the formation of carbonation products has been delayed because saline water has washed the surface. In the same way, carbonated specimens have a higher SR value; however, specimens maintained in the tidal zone did not have a high value of surface resistivity which could be due to the moisture available at the surface of specimens during the simulation of four tide cycles of six hours per day. Carbonation products can fill the pores according to the following equation:(12)H2CO3+CaOH2⟶CaCO3+2H2OAlso with CaCO3 more strength can be obtained from the carbonated area. According to the results, there is a slight difference in SR values between the control and specimens maintained in saline water, because saline water cannot change any phase in the hydration products. According to Figures 3 and 4, 35-10 samples maintained in CO2 have the highest surface resistivity, which is about 60 and 80% higher than that of 35-0 samples at the ages of 28 and 90 days, respectively.


## 4.3. Water Penetration

Another way of measuring the permeability of specimens is to perform a water penetration test. Since durability is related to the permeability of concrete, a low depth of water penetration is tantamount to a low rate of chloride ion penetration and consequently higher durability. The results of water penetration tests for all specimens with different curing conditions and amounts of silica fume at the ages of 28 and 90 days are shown in Figures5 and 6, respectively. According to the results, using silica fume reduced water penetration depth. The minimum depth of water penetration was 16 mm for the specimen with 10% silica fume and water/binder ratio of 0.35 at the age of 90 days. The reduction in water penetration depth is attributed to the double action of silica fume, that is, acting as filler and producing C-S-H gel; silica fume particles with an average diameter of 150 nm are significantly finer than cement particles with an average diameter of 15 μm; therefore, they can fill pores which may improve surface resistivity [40]. On the other hand, a low water/binder ratio, which causes less porosity, is another element that has caused this imperceptible depth of water penetration. Moreover, specimens maintained in CO2 gas showed a significant reduction in the depth of water penetration due to the carbonation products such as CaCO3 that could fill the pores. Reduction in the pores can be explained through reactions (1) and (2) [7]. By consumption of (OH)− in reaction (1), the pH of the pore solution decreases which leads to a decrease in overall porosity [7, 9].Figure 5
Water penetration depth for all specimens in different conditions at the age of 28 days.Figure 6
Water penetration depth for all specimens in different conditions at the age of 90 days.There was no significant difference between the water penetration depths for the reference concrete and specimens maintained in saline water, which is due to the availability of moisture present at the surface of specimens maintained in CO2 gas and saline water, hindering the penetration of gas and chloride into the specimens. The minimum depth of water penetration was 16 mm for the sample 35-10 maintained in CO2 approximately 10% lower than that of the reference and the saline water-maintained specimen at the age of 28 days. The results support the validity of the premise that saline water can not cause any reaction in cement hydration products; hence, there is no perceptible change in porosity. Specimens in the tidal zone were observed to have a depth of water penetration more than that of specimens maintained in CO2 gas.


## 4.4. Sorptivity

Sorptivity coefficient (S) is an index of durability, and a higher sorptivity coefficient connotes more capillary porosity; however, not all capillary porosities are responsible for the durability of concrete. Capillary porosities that are connected with each other can affect durability [43]. The results of sorptivity coefficient (S) at the ages of 28 and 90 days are shown in Figures 7 and 8, respectively, which support the results obtained in the previous section from the water penetration test. As stated previously, by the consumption of (OH)− in CaOH2+CO2→CaCO3+H2O, the pH of the pore solution increases; meanwhile, a decrease in overall porosity is happening through the production of CaCO3 in C-S-H + 2CO2→SiO2 + 2CaCO3 + H2O [7, 9]. When compared to specimens maintained in saline water or the standard curing condition, specimens maintained in CO2 gas and the tidal zone have lower sorptivity coefficients. This is probably due to the filling effect of carbonation products that can block capillary porosities, although CaCO3 may fill some of those porosities as well. However, because of the moisture available in the proximity of the surface, which prohibits CO2 gas from entering into the specimens, the sorptivity coefficients for the specimens maintained at the tidal zone are higher than those of the CO2 maintained specimens. Furthermore, using silica fume has tangibly reduced the sorptivity coefficient. At the age of 90 days, the 35-10 sample maintained in CO2 gas has the minimum sorptivity coefficient of about 10−6 (m/s0.5) while the 45-0 sample has the maximum value of 3.3(10-6) (m/s0.5) when maintained in the standard curing condition. The results indicate that silica fume has reduced capillary porosity. Meanwhile, because of the finer size of silica fume than cement particles, some pores may have been filled, and the inner conductivity of pores may have been blocked. Silica fume improves surface resistivity by two reactions: it produces C-S-H gel by its reaction with CH, which fills interfacial transition zones; silica fume chemically reacts with calcium hydroxide and forms compounds which have cementitious properties [39], even though it has few cementitious features.Figure 7
Sorptivity coefficient for all specimens maintained in different conditions at the age of 28 days.Figure 8
Sorptivity coefficient for all specimens maintained in different conditions at the age of 90 days.Figure 9
35-0 maintained in CO2 gas.


## 4.5. SEM and MIP Results

Small gold coated portions of specimens were placed in the scanning electron microscope (SEM) stubs. The micrographs of the polished surface of the 35-0 sample for hydrated concrete specimens, maintained in different conditions, at the age of 28 days, are illustrated in Figures9–13. The samples are chosen randomly from the 5 mm of the surface in order to consider carbonation and chloride ion ingress effect. In the micrographs, C-S-H gel appears slightly brighter, and aggregates appear darker. Sands can be described by their semidark hue [44]. The 35-0 specimen micrographs maintained in CO2 gas, in the tidal zone, saline water, and standard curing conditions, are presented in Figures 9–12, respectively. According to the SEM micrographs, 35-0 maintained in CO2 gas has many cubic, crystalline particles that have been formed because of carbonation. As mentioned above, by polymerizing silicate chains in C-S-H, volume decreases and shrinkage happens as well [3]. Besides, CaCO3 is available in various forms which may increase surface resistivity. When compared to the saline water-cured sample, the sample in the tidal zone, developed cubic, crystalline particles, and CaCO3 was reduced. As a comprehensive porosity analysis will be published in another paper, the specimens used in the SEM analysis were tested using MIP in order to obtain total porosity values. A preliminary analysis of the porosity of the specimens shows that the 35-10 sample cured in the tidal zone has 50.1% less total porosity than the sample 35-0 cured in the same condition. The results are presented in Table 4. It is also visible that carbonated specimens have less porosity than specimens maintained in the tidal zone.Table 4
Mercury intrusion porosimetry results.
Label
Total intruding volume (mL/g)
Mean radius (nm)
Total porosity (%)
35-0 Carb
0.1191 ± 7.1%
15.26 ± 8.6%
10.2
35-0 Sim
0.1250 ± 5.3%
20.55 ± 7.2%
13.5
35-0 Chl
0.1507 ± 8.7%
23.92 ± 5.7%
15.7
35-0 PC
0.1459 ± 6.8%
20.71 ± 6.6%
16.2
35-10 Sim
0.0832 ± 6.5%
11.51 ± 5.1%
8.9Figure 10
35-0 maintained in tidal zone.Figure 11
35-0 maintained in saline water.Figure 12
35-0 maintained in standard curing condition.Figure 13
35-10 maintained in tidal zone.Furthermore, in both conditions, capillary porosity has been reduced leading to a lower sorptivity coefficient. The carbonated 35-0 sample has 32.4% less total porosity than the 35-0 sample cured in the tidal zone. Total porosity signifies the porosity that is responsible for capillary transportation through the concrete porous structure [45]. In Figure 9, in the 35-0 sample (Figure 10) maintained in saline water, no perceptible difference can be observed when compared to the 35-0 sample cured in the standard curing condition. It can be concluded that, by curing in saline water, no chemical or physical reaction has taken place. According to the result of gas permeation, the minimum pore size can be estimated at less than 50 Å because the ratio of He : SF6 is approximately 1000. Carbonation has led to a less permeable surface and the specimens maintained in both carbonation and chloride ion ingress show less permeability compared with plain concrete and the specimens maintained in the pure chloride ion ingress. The results support the values obtained from the durability test and MIP tests. A more detailed discussion and comprehensive porosity analysis will be presented in the forthcoming manuscript by the authors.The 35-10 specimen micrographs (at 6kx magnification), maintained in the tidal zone, are presented in Figure13. Regarding these SEM micrographs, silica fume has filled some pores, and the microstructure of the transition zone has been improved because of the production of C-S-H gel. Carbonation and silica fume have had a synergistic effect. When compared to carbonated samples without silica fume, reduced water penetration depth and sorptivity were observable, and increased surface resistivity and less porosity were noticed. According to Figure 13 and Table 4, it is evident that silica fume has filled pores although minimally, and using 10% silica fume may compensate for the effect of carbonation because of the capillary porosity blocking effect. Silica fume would alter the concrete’s strength because of its fineness or C-S-H gel production [41] and the existence of small particles will improve the concrete properties known as “particle packing” or “microfilling.”


## 4.6. Depth of Carbonation and Chloride Ion Ingress

In order to indicate carbonation depth and the depth of chloride ion ingress, phenolphthalein and silver nitrate solutions were sprayed separately on the surface of 5 mm thick slices. The results of the depth of carbonation and chloride ion ingress for specimens maintained in each environment condition, at the ages of 28 and 90 days, are presented in Figures14 and 15, respectively. The minimum depth of carbonation and chloride ion ingress for specimens maintained at the tidal zone was 5 and 10 mm for 35-10, while the maximum was 23 and 35 mm for 45-0, respectively. The results support the conclusion that silica fume fills pores so that there is less space for CO2 gas and carbonation products. Besides that, because of less capillary porosity due to the presence of silica fume and its productions, that is, C-S-H gels, less chloride ions could penetrate into the specimen. Reduction in pH, which was about 12 to 9 in this experiment, was partly due to the production of CaCO3 from Ca(OH)2. This reaction occurred in a 15 mm range at the surface, and therefore, signs of corrosion for reinforcement bars, located 50 mm from the surface, may not occur. By using 10% silica fume and a water/binder ratio of 0.35, at the tidal zone, corrosion of reinforcement bars is not likely to happen in 90 days; however, the depth of carbonation for specimens maintained in CO2 gas, which is about 50 mm from the surface, is detrimental to reinforcement bars. In fact, the pH presolution is not related merely to Ca(OH)2; rather, alkali salts such as NaOH and KOH are important since they are more likely to be carbonated. Moreover, carbonation depth for specimens maintained in CO2 gas was at least 45% higher than that of specimens maintained at the tidal zone. The minimum carbonation depth was 5 mm for 35-10 samples, which is 140% lower than that of 45-0 samples. Furthermore, chloride ion ingress for specimens maintained in saline water followed the same procedure explained above. The minimum and maximum depths of chloride ion ingress were 10 and 35 mm for 35-10 and 45-0, respectively.Figure 14
Results of the depth of carbonation.Figure 15
Results of the depth of chloride ion ingress.


## 5. Extension of This Work

As it is almost always the case, unsolved problems remain. One of the most important follow-up experiments is the exact chemical reactions that take place in each step, from the first day of casting to 90 days of curing. Therefore, an extensive research on the petrography of the specimens and porosity measurements as well as extracting the penetration profile of chloride ion seems useful for further discussion. Besides, a multiscale dynamic simulation is necessary to find out the precise effect of curing in different curing conditions. This work has been commenced and will also be reported in due course.


## 6. Conclusions

In this study, extensive experimentation was carried out to determine the effect of an accelerated test method of simultaneous carbonation and chloride ion attack on mechanical properties and the durability of concrete containing silica fume. The primary findings are as follows:(1)
Results of XRD tests revealed that carbonation consumed Ca(OH)2, produced CaCO3, and reduced C2S and C3S especially near the surfaces of the samples.(2)
Silica fume has filled pores, and the microstructure of the transition zone has been improved because of the production of C-S-H gel, which may lead to an increase in surface resistivity and a reduction in water penetration depth and sorptivity.(3)
Compared with the specimens maintained in CO2, specimens maintained at the tidal zone could not reach that value of surface resistivity, which could be due to the moisture available at the surface of specimens during the simulation of four tidal cycles of six hours per day.(4)
The minimum depth of water penetration was 16 mm for sample 35-10 maintained in CO2 which was about 10% lower than that of the reference and the saline water-maintained specimen at the age of 28 days.(5)
A preliminary analysis of the porosity of the specimens shows that the 35-10 sample cured in the tidal zone has 50.1% less total porosity than the sample 35-0 cured in the same condition. Furthermore, in both conditions, capillary porosity has been reduced leading to a lower sorptivity coefficient. The carbonated 35-0 sample has 32.4% less total porosity than the 35-0 sample cured in the tidal zone.(6)
Silica fume physically and chemically fills the pores of specimens and reduces carbonation depth. Similar results were obtained for chloride ion penetration.(7)
The maximum and minimum CO2 consumption for specimens maintained in CO2 gas was 14.6% and 10.6% for 45-0 and 35-10 samples, respectively, and the CO2 consumption for specimens maintained at the tidal zone was at least approximately 15% lower than that of specimens maintained in CO2 gas.(8)
The minimum depth of carbonation and chloride ion ingress for specimens maintained at the tidal zone is 5 and 10 mm for 35-10 when simultaneously maintained in CO2 gas and saline water.(9)
Reduction in pH, which is about 12 to 9 in this experiment, is partly due to the production of CaCO3 from Ca(OH)2, and this reaction is mostly occurring in 15 mm from the surface.



---

*Source: 1650979-2016-05-17.xml*