A method for managing synchronization between a profile store and a source of truth that is used to update the profile store via a real-time link, comprising: identifying a bulk extraction of data, from the source of truth, used to populate profiles of the profile store to the profile store; selecting, by a catch-up service executing on a processor, a profile of the populated profiles for comparison based on an access pattern associated with the profile that includes sequences of accesses that are associated with synchronization issues and indicate a series of sequential updates to the source of truth resulting in a lack of synchronization between the profile and source of truth; obtaining (404, 504, 604, 710, 802), over a first network connection with the profile store, a first set of attributes from the profile for an entity in the profile store, wherein the profile in the profile store is shared and updated by a set of remote offerings that use the profile to perform one or more tasks for the entity; obtaining (406, 506, 606, 712, 804), over a second network connection with the source of truth, a second set of attributes for the entity from the source of truth, wherein the second set of attributes from the source of truth is used by the set of remote offerings to perform one or more additional tasks for the entity; comparing (408, 508, 608, 714, 806), by the catch-up service executing on the processor, the first and second sets of attributes for mismatches between the first and second sets of attributes; tracking, by the catch-up service, execution conditions associated with the profile store and/or source of truth, wherein the execution conditions include an error rate associated with synchronizing the profile store with the source of truth; estimating, by the catch-up service, the error rate of synchronizing the profile with the source of truth based on the execution conditions, and increasing a rate of comparing the first and second sets of attributes when the estimated error rate exceeds a predetermined threshold; and when a mismatch between the first and second sets of attributes is found, correcting (412, 512, 612, 714) the mismatch by modifying, by the catch-up service, the first set of attributes in the profile store with one or more values from the second set of attributes to improve subsequent use of the profile in the profile store by the set of remote offerings. identifying a bulk extraction of data, from the source of truth, used to populate profiles of the profile store to the profile store; selecting, by a catch-up service executing on a processor, a profile of the populated profiles for comparison based on an access pattern associated with the profile that includes sequences of accesses that are associated with synchronization issues and indicate a series of sequential updates to the source of truth resulting in a lack of synchronization between the profile and source of truth; obtaining (404, 504, 604, 710, 802), over a first network connection with the profile store, a first set of attributes from the profile for an entity in the profile store, wherein the profile in the profile store is shared and updated by a set of remote offerings that use the profile to perform one or more tasks for the entity; obtaining (406, 506, 606, 712, 804), over a second network connection with the source of truth, a second set of attributes for the entity from the source of truth, wherein the second set of attributes from the source of truth is used by the set of remote offerings to perform one or more additional tasks for the entity; comparing (408, 508, 608, 714, 806), by the catch-up service executing on the processor, the first and second sets of attributes for mismatches between the first and second sets of attributes; tracking, by the catch-up service, execution conditions associated with the profile store and/or source of truth, wherein the execution conditions include an error rate associated with synchronizing the profile store with the source of truth; estimating, by the catch-up service, the error rate of synchronizing the profile with the source of truth based on the execution conditions, and increasing a rate of comparing the first and second sets of attributes when the estimated error rate exceeds a predetermined threshold; and when a mismatch between the first and second sets of attributes is found, correcting (412, 512, 612, 714) the mismatch by modifying, by the catch-up service, the first set of attributes in the profile store with one or more values from the second set of attributes to improve subsequent use of the profile in the profile store by the set of remote offerings.