A carton enclosing a plurality of containers in at least a first row and a second row above the first row, including a first container the first row adjacent a first end and a bottom panel of the carton and a second container in the second row adjacent the first end, each container of the plurality of containers having a top and a side; the carton comprising: a first side panel connected to a top panel; the top panel connected to a second side panel; the second side panel connected to the bottom panel; the first end and the second end being substantially parallel and being disposed at opposite sides of the first side panel, the top panel, the second side panel, and the bottom panel; a tear line arrangement in the first end, the first side panel, and the second side panel, the tear line arrangement in the first end including a first tear line segment spaced a height from the bottom panel and a second tear line segment spaced a height from the bottom panel the first tear line segment being spaced a first distance from the second tear line segment the tear line arrangement including a third tear line segment in the second side panel and a fourth tear line segment in the first side panel; the first tear line segment, the second tear line segment, third tear line segment and the fourth tear line segment defining an opening flap capable of being at least partially detached from the carton to create an opening between the first tear line segment and the second tear line segment; wherein the first container and the second container are disposed on their sides and are retained from rolling out of the carton upon the at least partial detachment of the opening flap and characterized in that the heieht of the first tear line segment from the bottom panel is the diameter of the first container plus a distance between 60% and 90% of the diameter of the second container the height of the second tear line segment from the bottom panel is between 40% and 80% of the diameter of the first container so the second container can be removed from the carton through the opening prior to removal of the first container. a first side panel connected to a top panel; the top panel connected to a second side panel; the second side panel connected to the bottom panel; the first end and the second end being substantially parallel and being disposed at opposite sides of the first side panel, the top panel, the second side panel, and the bottom panel; a tear line arrangement in the first end, the first side panel, and the second side panel, the tear line arrangement in the first end including a first tear line segment spaced a height from the bottom panel and a second tear line segment spaced a height from the bottom panel the first tear line segment being spaced a first distance from the second tear line segment the tear line arrangement including a third tear line segment in the second side panel and a fourth tear line segment in the first side panel; the first tear line segment, the second tear line segment, third tear line segment and the fourth tear line segment defining an opening flap capable of being at least partially detached from the carton to create an opening between the first tear line segment and the second tear line segment; wherein the first container and the second container are disposed on their sides and are retained from rolling out of the carton upon the at least partial detachment of the opening flap and the heieht of the first tear line segment from the bottom panel is the diameter of the first container plus a distance between 60% and 90% of the diameter of the second container the height of the second tear line segment from the bottom panel is between 40% and 80% of the diameter of the first container so the second container can be removed from the carton through the opening prior to removal of the first container.